The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Therefore, the proposed amendment to claim 1 is allowed being within the scope of Section 59 of 1970 Act and amended claim is taken on record. Appellant shall file the complete amended specification including amended claim before the Patent Office and as and when the needful is done, Patent Office shall proceed to examine the matter afresh taking into account the amended claim.
12. Accordingly, this appeal is partially allowed setting aside the impugned order dated 10.04.2024 and remanding the matter back to the Respondent for taking a fresh decision after giving a fresh hearing notice to the Appellant. It is expected that the Respondent shall endeavour to take the decision as expeditiously as possible and in any event not later than two months from the date the amended specification and claim are filed.
13. The appeal stands disposed of, making it clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
DAIKIN INDUSTRIES LTD
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Tanveer Malhotra and Mr. Vineet
Rohilla, Advocates.
versus
ASSISTANT CONTROLLER OF PATENTS
AND DESIGNS
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ankur Mittal, CGSC with Ms.
Rabaica Jaiswal
and
Mr. Hrithik Saxena,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
ORDER
26.02.2026
%
1.
This appeal is filed on behalf of the Appellant under Section 117A(2)
of the Patents Act, 1970 (‘1970 Act’) laying a challenge to order dated
10.04.2024 passed by the Respondent refusing grant of Indian Patent
Application filed on 23.06.2022 with priority date from JP Patent
Application No. 2020-003842 dated 14.01.2020.
2.
As pleaded in the appeal, the subject application is a national phase
application of PCT Application No. PCT/JP2020/043546 dated 24.11.2020
with 11 claims. Appellant filed a formal request on Form-13 dated
24.06.2022 for amending the claims along with amended claims 1-5
followed by a request on 08.07.2022 for examination of the application. On
10.11.2022, Patent Office examined the application and issued the First
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
Examination Report (‘FER’) inter alia raising objection of lack of inventive
step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the 1970 Act qua claims 1-5 in light of prior
art documents D1-D4.
3.
Detailed response was filed by the Appellant to the objections raised
in the FER along with amended claims and supporting documents on
09.02.2023. The application was further examined looking into the response.
In the hearing notice dated 26.02.2024, Respondent cited new prior art
document D1: US3840070A and raised an objection that the invention
lacked novelty. In the hearing on 20.03.2024, arguments were addressed on
behalf of the Appellant on the objections raised and subsequently written
submissions were filed. However, vide order dated 10.04.2024, Respondent
refused the subject application on the ground that the claimed invention
lacks novelty in view of the disclosures in cited prior art D1: US3840070A.
4.
At the outset, without entering into the merits of the case that D1:
US3840070A is an old patent filed in 1972 and does not disclose the
features of claimed invention, learned counsel for the Appellant submits that
Appellant has filed proposed amended claim as an Auxiliary Request along
with the appeal before this Court, which is based on incorporation of claim 2
into the main claim and the amendment is well supported by original
description and claims. Appellant has also filed an additional Auxiliary
Request along with the written note of submissions, where proposed
amended claims is identical to the claim granted by the United States Patent
and Trademark Office (‘USPTO’). Prior art D1: US3840070A was also
considered by USPTO before grant of US Application. In light of this, it is
urged that the proposed amendment be allowed as it falls within the scope of
Section 59 of 1970 Act and permission be granted to the Appellant to file
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
complete amended specifications including amended claim before the Patent
Office for fresh examination.
5.
Learned counsel for the Respondent, fairly and candidly, does not
dispute the position of law that amendments to the claims can be carried out
at the appellate stage, if warranted.
6.
Heard.
7.
The subject invention relates to a Shell-And-Plate Heat Exchanger
and the object of invention is to improve the heat exchange efficiency of a
shell-and-plate heat exchanger. Claim 1 of the subject application as rejected
by the Respondent on ground of lack of novelty in view of cited prior art
document D1: US3840070A is as follows:“1.
A shell-and-plate heat exchanger comprising:
a shell (10) forming an internal space (15); and
a plate stack (20) housed in the internal space (15) of the shell (10)
and including a plurality of heat transfer plates (21) stacked and
joined together,
the shell-and-plate heat exchanger allowing a refrigerant that has
flowed into the internal space (15) of the shell (10) to be condensed,
wherein
a refrigerant channel (24) that communicates with the internal
space (15) of the shell (10) and allows the refrigerant to flow through
and a heating medium channel (25) that is blocked from the internal
space (15) of the shell (10) and allows a heating medium to flow
through are alternately arranged between adjacent plates (21) of the
plurality of heat transfer plates (21), a meandering portion (28, 29,
31) configured to meander the refrigerant condensed on a surface of
each of the plurality of heat transfer plates (21) is provided in at least
a lower portion of the plate stack (20), and
the meandering portion (28, 29, 31) is provided by processing the
plurality of heat transfer plates (21).”
8.
During the pendency of this appeal, Appellant has filed an additional
Auxiliary Request and seeks to amend claim 1 and it is urged that proposed
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
amended claim 1 is identical to claim granted by USPTO, wherein D1:
US3840070A was also considered before grant of the US Application.
Proposed amended claim 1 is as follows:“1.
A shell-and-plate heat exchanger comprising:
a shell (10) forming an internal space (15); and
a plate stack (20) housed in the internal space (15) of the shell
(10), the plate stack (20) and including a plurality of heat transfer plates
(21) stacked and joined together,
the shell-and-plate heat exchanger being configured to allow
allowing a refrigerant that has flowed into the internal space (15) of the
shell (10) to be condensed, wherein
a refrigerant channel (24) that communicates communicating with
the internal space (15) of the shell (10) and being configured to allow
allows the refrigerant to flow through, and a heating medium channel (25)
that is blocked from the internal space (15) of the shell (10) and being
configured to allow allows a heating medium to flow through, and the
refrigerant channel (24) and the heating medium (25) being are
alternately arranged between adjacent plates (21) of the plurality of heat
transfer plates (21), and
a meandering portion (28, 29, 31) being provided in a lower
portion of the plate stack (20) but no meandering portion being provided
in an upper portion of the plate stack, the
a meandering portion (28, 29, 31) being configured to meander the
refrigerant condensed on a surface of each of the plurality of heat transfer
plates (21), is provided in at least a lower portion of the plate stack (20),
and
the meandering portion (28, 29, 31) is being provided by
processing the plurality of heat transfer plates (21).”
9.
Parties are ad idem that amendments can be carried out even at the
appellate stage. In this context, I may refer to the decision of this Court in
Fresenius Medical Care Deutschland Gmbh v. Controller General of
Patents, Designs and Trademarks and Another, 2025 SCC OnLine Del
2721, wherein the Court allowed the amendment relying on two earlier
decisions of this Court. Relevant passages are as follows:-
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
“11. In Societe Des Produits Nestle SA v. Controller of Patents and
Designs, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 582, I have held that the High Court,
while hearing an appeal against a refusal order passed by the Controller,
would have the same powers as given to a Controller under Section 15 of
the Act, which includes the powers to require amendment. Therefore, the
Court is within its power to direct the Appellant to amend the complete
specification of the patent application including claims at this stage.
12. The aforesaid observations made in Nestle SA v. Controller of
Patents (supra) were also relied on by another Coordinate Bench of this
Court in Opentv Inc. v. Controller of Patents, 2023 SCC OnLine Del
2771 wherein it was noted that irrespective of the amendments to the
claims or complete specification of a patent application being made at the
behest of the applicant or the Court, amendments are allowed at the
appellate stage before Court. The relevant paragraph of the said judgment
is given below:
“54. Thus, amendments having been held to be permissible at the
appellate stage, this Court is of the opinion that irrespective of
whether the amendment is directed by the Court or is at the instance
of Patent Applicant, so long as the requirements as laid down under
Section 59 of the Act are fulfilled such that the amended claims are
within the scope of original claims, is not breached, the amendment
is permissible.”
***
“61. Therefore, though there is no embargo on permitting a Patent
Applicant to amend claims even at the appellate stage, the amendment
sought in this particular case intends to widen the scope of the
original claims as filed. It is due to this reason that the same cannot
be allowed.”
[Emphasis supplied]”
10.
Section 59 of 1970 Act deals with amendment of patent applications
and provides that: (a) an amendment to a patent application, including the
complete specification, can be made only be way of ‘disclaimer’,
‘correction’ or ‘explanation’; (b) amendment has to be for the purpose of
incorporation of actual facts; and (c) amendment cannot be in respect of
matters not disclosed in the specification prior to the amendment and the
amended claims have to fall within the scope of claims as originally filed.
Having considered the proposed amendment to claim 1, I am of the view
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
that the amendment sought does not broaden the scope of unamended claim
in any manner and its subject matter is disclosed in the specification.
11.
Therefore, the proposed amendment to claim 1 is allowed being
within the scope of Section 59 of 1970 Act and amended claim is taken on
record. Appellant shall file the complete amended specification including
amended claim before the Patent Office and as and when the needful is
done, Patent Office shall proceed to examine the matter afresh taking into
account the amended claim.
12.
Accordingly, this appeal is partially allowed setting aside the
impugned order dated 10.04.2024 and remanding the matter back to the
Respondent for taking a fresh decision after giving a fresh hearing notice to
the Appellant. It is expected that the Respondent shall endeavour to take the
decision as expeditiously as possible and in any event not later than two
months from the date the amended specification and claim are filed.
13.
The appeal stands disposed of, making it clear that this Court has not
expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.
JYOTI SINGH, J
FEBRUARY 26, 2026/YA
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 56/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 12:58:31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review