The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. With the above findings, this Writ Petition is allowed by setting aside the impugned orders bearing No.1O6l3/Engg.(ll/2O2O dated 30.05.2023 issued by the respondent No.1 and also the consequential proceedings in Memo No.2259/Cl/2023 12524 dated 21.06.2023 issued by the respondent No.2 and further directing the respondents to reconsider the case of the petitioner for appointment on compassionate grounds as per her eligibility and qualification to a suitable post within a I t2 period of eight (08) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and communicate the same to the petitioner. Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this writ petition, shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to costs Sd/.C.DEEPIKA ,,, //TRUE COPY/i One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH (For His Lordships kind perusal) To, 1 1 LR Copies Th-e Under S_ecretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company .) Affairs, New Delhi. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association, Library, High Court Buildings, Hyderabad. The Principal Secretary, MA & UD (ENGG,) Department, The State of Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 5 The Managing Director, HMWS I SB, Hyderabad. The Chief General Manager (Engg), O&M Circle No.lll, HMWS&SB, Goshamahal, Hyderabad. 1 2. 7 The General Manager (Engg), Operation and Maintance Division.lll, HMWS&S Board, Navodaya Colony, Gudimalkapur, Hyd…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
IVONDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF I!{ARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION NO: 30921 OF 2023
Between:
D. Vimala, S/o. Late D- Balram, aged about 41 years, unemployee, R/o
lbrahim Village, Golconda Mandal, Hyderabad District.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, rep., by its Principal Secretary, MA & UD (ENGG')
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The Managing Director, HMWS & SB, Hyderabad.
J
The Chief General Manager (Engg), O&M Circle No.lll, HMWS&SB'
Goshamahal, Hydeabad. 12.
4 The General Manager (Engg), Operation & Maintance Division.lll, HMWS&S
Board, Navodaya Colony, Gudimalkapur, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ more in the nature of Writ of Mandamus or any other wril
order or direction, to declare the impugned proceedings of the 1st Respondent
bearing Memo.No.1 0613/Engg.( 1)12020, dated 3O10512023, rejecting the claim of
the petitioner for appointment on compassionate grounds and consequential
proceedings of the 2nd Respondent bearing Memo. No.22591C11202312524'
dated 21tO612O23 rejecting the claim of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate grounds is contrary to Law laid down by the Hon'ble Court in
WP.No.1624212013, dated 2OtOOt2023 and set aside the same and consequently
to declare the petitioner is entitled for appointment on compassionate grounds
with all consequential benefits.
(As per Court dated 23.01.2024 vide lA No.2 of 2023 prayer is amended)
IANO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate grounds by suspending the operation of the impugned order of
the 1 st Respondent bearing Memo.No.1061 3lEngg.()12020, dated 3OlO5l2O23
fothwith pending disposal of the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI R. RAJASEKHARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI BODDU SRAVAN KUMAR,
ASST. GP FOR SERVICES I
Counsel forthe Respondent No.2 to 4: SRI A. VEERESH KUMAR
(SC FOR HMWS & SB)
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT TIYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION No.3O92L of 2o23
THE 2"d DAY OF MARCH 2026
Between:
D.Vimala.
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Secretary,
MA & UD (ENGG) Department and others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Mr. R.Rajasekhar Rao, learned counsel for the
petitioner; learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Services-I appearing for the respondent No.1 and learned
Standing Counsel for HMWS & SB appearing for the
respondent Nos.2 to 4. Perused the material available on
record.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
mother of the petitioner worked as GPE (WS) in the
respondent-Sewerage Board and while in service, died in
harness on 14.02.2016. The parents of the petitioner have
three daughters and no male issue. All the three daughters
are married and the petitioner is a divorced daughter. The
petitioner stayed with her mother due to family disputes with
her husband at the time of her mother's death. In view of the
same, the petitioner made an application for providing
compassionate appointment within one (O1) year as per the
relevant GOs' and circular Memos and the same was rejected
by the respondent No.1 on the ground that the petitioner was
a married daughter at the time of death of the deceased
employee. Subsequent to the death of the deceased employee,
the petitioner hled divorce petition and obtained divorce
orders from the family Court after death of the deceased
employee i.e., 01. lO.2016.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
Memo bearing No.1O613/Engg.(l)/2O2O dated 30.05.2023
issued by the respondent No.1 and the consequential
proceedings issued by the respondent No.2 in Memo
No.2259 lCll2O23/2524 dated 21.06.2023, are contrary to
G.O.Ms.No.350, General Administration Departrnent dated
30.O7 .1999 and also firrther orders issued in Memo
No.116417 /Ser.A/2003-1 dated 08.10.2003. The married
daughter, whether divorced or not, is eligible for the
compassionate appointment if there is no male child. The
impugned orders issued by the respondent No.1 are contrary
to the orders passed by the Division Bench of this Court
4. In support of his arguments, learned counsel for the
petitioner has relied upon the Judgment passed by this Court
in Commissioner of Police, Ilgderabad Citg and. others a.
K. Padrnajar. In view of the same, learned counsel requested
this Court to set aside the impugned proceedings of the
respondent
No.1
uide
Memo
bearing
No.10613/Engg.0)/2020 dated 30.05.2023 and the
consequentia-l proceedings of the respondent No.2 uide Memo
No.2259/C[1202312524 dated 21.06.2023 and also to direct
the respondents to consider the request of the petitioner for
appointment under compassionate grounds.
5. On the other hand, Iearned Standing Counsel for the
respondent Nos.2 to 4 basing on the counter submits that
the Respondent-Board has considered the petitioner's
application and examined it based on the Government Rules
and Orders issued from time to time under the
compassionate appointment scheme. It was noticed that the
petitioner was a married daughter at the time of her mother's
' zort 1l; el,t sor
death i.e., on 14.02.2016 and she had applied for divorce on
28.O3.2016 i.e., after the death of her mother and obtained
divorce orders from the family Court on 01.10.2016, which
clearly proves that the petitioner was not dependant at the
time of her mother's death. As per the clarification on
appointment of married daughters on cornpassionate
grounds in
Memo No.4O6l10/A.1/Admn.ll/2024,
Fin.(Admn.II), dated 20.O3.2024, Once the marriage is
performed,
a
daughter is not dependant on her
father/mother even if she is un-employee or her husband is
un-employee. The petitioner has not fulfilled any of the above
conditions. Further, the Government issued clarification on
providing compassionate appointment to a married daughter
tn
Memo
No.80863/Ser-G/A1 l2OO5-1, General
Administration (Ser-G) Department, dated O6.08.20O5,
stating that when the spouse of the deceased Government
employee is not alive, the purpose of providing employment to
the married daughter will not be served. In view of the same,
the respondents rejected the case of the petitioner by issuing
the impugned proceedings and there is no illegality 1n
passing the said orders and therefore, requested this Court to
dismiss the writ petition as the petitioner is not dependant on
her deceased mother
6. After hearing both sides and pemsing the material
available on record, this Court is of the considered view that
admittedly, there is no dispute with regard to the death of the
petitioner's mother while in service irr the respondentSewerage Board as GPE (WS) on 14.02.2016. Subsequent to
the death of her mother, the petitioner made an application
for compassionate appointment as a married daughter with
consent of her two (O2l sisters. The compassionate
appointment scheme is governed by G.O.Ms.No.687, GAD,
dated O3.1O.I977, which was later clarified extending the
benefit even to a married daughter by issuing
G.O.Ms.No.35O, GAD, dated 30.07.1999 and was turther
clarified in
Memo No.ll64l7 / Ser.A/2003-1 dated
08.10.2003.
7.
The respondents rejected the case of the petitioner for
providing compassionate appointment only on the ground
that the petitioner was a married daughter and was not
dependant on her mother at the time of her mother's death
and also stating that the petitioner has obtained divorce
orders after death of her mother. In the counter, the
respondents are relied on the Memo issued by the Finance
Dcpartment uide No.4O6/ 1OlA. 1/Admn.ll l2OO4 dated
2O.O3.2OO4 stating that once the marriage is performed, a
daughter is not dependant on her father/mother even if she
is un-empioyed or her husband is un-employed.
8. The Memo No.4O6l 10/A. 1/Admn.|ll2OO4 dated
2O.O3.2OO4 was considered by the Division Bench of this
Court in Cornmissioner of Police, Hyderabad Citg and.
other (supro/ and the relevant portion at Paragraph Nos.4
and 1O reads as follows
4.
Challenging tle
said
memo,
the
respondent/ applicant approached the Tibunal. Before
the Tribunal, the case of the petitioners herein is that as
per the inslructions ssued bg the Finance Department
uicle Menrn No.406/ 1O/A.1/Admn.11/2OO4, dated
20.03.2004, unless the married daughter ts d"ependent
on her mother/father, she is not entitled for
appointmenl on compassionate grounds.
10. Basing on the additional mateial placed bg the
Leorned counsel for the petitioners, before this Court to
dag, it is submitted bg the leamed counsel for
petitioners that the applicant and her husband uere
staAing separatelg Luith their outn income. A perusal of
I
:
report dated 15.06.2O 13 makes it clear that th-e
husband o.f the applicant is an unemplogee. Euen uLith
reqard- to income of the applicant, it is clearlg stated
that she is slaging in the out house of house beaing
No.2'2-12/ 6, D.D.CoIong, Amberpet, Hgderabad and is
eking liuelihood by sewing clotltes. There is no other
mateial to reject the claim of the appliconf as she is not
hauing de.fLnite income of her oun and she utas
dependant on her late father. Euen if the applicant is
residing in a separate house, that bg itself, is not a
ground to rejcct the claim of appointment. So far as the
income of the opplicant is concerned, it is proued that
she is not hauing ang ind-ependent income to liue on her
ou)n ond she is also toking care oJ her mother (uidoul of
the deceased emplogee). No ualid reasons uere
recorded bg the authoities, to reject the claim of the
applicont for compassionate appointment. Euen bg wag
of counter, no reasons u.tere added to support tLrc order
passed bg the authoities. Except the contention of the
petitioners that the respondent is getting some income
bg seu,ting clothes and residing separatelg in an outhouse, and, a uague report placed on record to-day,
there is no other mateial to shou.t that sh,e i.s Lnuing
definite income on her outn. Euen as per th-e said
applicant's report, husband is stated to be unemploged.
Yet another defence is taken by the leamed counsel that
as the uife of the deceased k getting familg pension,
the applicant is not entitled for compassionate
appointment. But tle same cannot be accepted. Merelg
because familg pension is beirLg paid to the uife of the
deceased, the same is not a ground to depriue the
benefit of compassionate appointment under this
scheme notified bg the Gouernm.ent for the children of
the deceased uho died in harness.
9.
The above frndings would squarely apply to the
instant case. Moreover, the respondents failed to show that
the petitioner is working and having independent income
to earn her livelihood. In view of the same, the respondents
cannot rely on the said Memo of Finance Depafiment uide
No.aO6l10/A.1/Admn.1l /2OO4 dated 2O.O3.2004, which
was considered by this Court in the above judgment and
the contention was rejected, directing appointment of the
respondent therein. The said order became final and was
implemented.
lO.
In view of the same, the respondents have to follow
t0
the orders of the Division Bench passed by this Court for
providing compassionate appointment to the petitioner
The respondents, in their counter, relying on the Finance
Department Memo uide No.4O6/lOl A.1/Admn.ll/2OO4
dated 20.03 .2004 and Memo No.808631Ser-G / Al /2005-1,
General Administration (Ser-G) Department, dated
06.08.2005 cannot be taken into account. The impugned
orders passed by the respondents are without basing on
the said Memos. The respondents mentioning the said
Memos to substantiate their case in the counters calnot
be acceptable. It amounts to improving their case by
mentioning the said Memos in the counters and the same
is contrary to the orders passed by the Hon'ble Suprerne
Court in Mohinder Singh Gilt and Another a. Chief
Election Commissioner, Neut Delhi and. Others2.
1.
Moreover,
the
Memo
uide
No.406/10/A 1/Admn.Ll/2004 dated 20.03.2OO4 has
already been considered by the Division Bench in
Cornmissioner of Police, Hgderabad. Citg and other
(supra). The Memo uide No.80863/Ser-G/Al/2OO5-1,
General
' toza scc 1t1ros
Administration (Ser-G)
Department,
ll
dated 06.08.2005, is not in consonance with the G.O.'s
issued by the Government in G.O.Ms.No.687, GAD, dated
03.1O.1977 and G.O.Ms.No.350, cAD, dated 30.07 .1999.
It is settled law that the Memos/ Executive instructions
cannot be override the Government Orders. In view of the
same, the said Memo has no relevance in the instant case.
L2,
The respondents have to consider the case of the
petitioner for appointment on compassionate grounds as
per G.O.Ms.No.350, GAD, dated 30.07.1999 and the Memo
No.116417lSer.A/2OO3-l dated 08.10.2003 without
taking into account whether the petitioner is divorced or
not, for considering her entitlement as on the date of the
death of her mother.
13.
With the above findings, this Writ Petition is
allowed by setting aside the impugned orders bearing
No.1O6l3/Engg.(ll/2O2O dated 30.05.2023 issued by the
respondent No.1 and also the consequential proceedings in
Memo No.2259/Cl/2023 12524 dated 21.06.2023 issued
by the respondent No.2 and further directing the
respondents to reconsider the case of the petitioner for
appointment
on compassionate grounds as per her
eligibility and qualification to a suitable post within a
I
t2
period of eight (08) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order and communicate the same to the petitioner.
Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this writ
petition, shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to
costs
Sd/.C.DEEPIKA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
,,,
//TRUE COPY/i
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
To,
1 1 LR Copies
Th-e Under S_ecretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
.)
Affairs, New Delhi.
The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association, Library, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
The Principal Secretary, MA & UD (ENGG,) Department, The State of
Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
5 The Managing Director, HMWS I SB, Hyderabad.
The Chief General Manager (Engg), O&M Circle No.lll, HMWS&SB,
Goshamahal, Hyderabad. 1 2.
7 The General Manager (Engg), Operation and Maintance Division.lll,
HMWS&S Board, Navodaya Colony, Gudimalkapur, Hyderabad.
8. One CC to SRI R. RAJASEKHARA RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
o ONE CC tO SRI A VEERESH KUMAR (SC FOR HMWS & SB)
IOPUC]
10 Two CCs to cP FOR SERVICES l, High Court for the State of Telangdna.
I
tourl
PMK
Two CD Copies
BN
HIGH COURT
DATED:0210312026
t
u
t
k:
()
?3, :
*.-r
ORDER
WP.No.30921 of 2023
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
K5
*lsl$
,)J,
r..u
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review