Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3304 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 34440 OF 2017
Between:
D.Srinivas Reddy, S/o.D.Yadireddy Aged 43 years, Occ Police Constable No.2439
Of Alweil P.S., Cyberabad, R/o.H.No 2-1 -23 Cherlapally, Cyberabad, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Home (Ser.ll)
Department Telangana State Secretariat, Hyderabad
2. The Addl. Director General of Police, State of Telangana, Hyderabad
3. The Commissioner of Police, Cyberabad, H.yderabad, T.S.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of the t dt Respondent in passing orders
vide G.O.Rt.No.973, dt.18.11.2015 to an extent that the period of suspension
and out of employment is however treated as Not on Duty as illegal, arbitrary,
unconstitutional and contrary to the Judgment of the Apex Court in Union of lndia
Vs. Jaipal Singh (Civil Appeal No.8565/2003, dt.03.11.2003) and consequently
set aside to that extent.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI R. GlRl KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES - |
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE H]IGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE ItrON'BILE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO
\.)_ -o > - 2-o>- G
UIRIT PETITION No. 34440 of 2OL7
Betweer:t :
D.Srinivra.s Reddy.
. Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana and others.
Respondents
ORDER:.
This writ petition is filed, aggrieved by the
proceedings of the lst respondent in G.o.Rt.No.973, dated
18. 1 1 .2O 15, to
the extent of treating the period of
suspension and out of ernployment as 'not on duty''
2.
Brief facts of the case are as follou's :-
(a) The petitioner rffas appointed as a constable in
the Police Department, and he has been discharging his
duties without any complaint- While So, a case in
Cr.No.3,5O of 2OO4'v\ras registered against the petitioner and
two others for offences punishable under Sections 364, 3O2
and 2Ol of the IPC at Kushaiguda Police Station. The
petitioner was acquitted in Cr.No.36O of 2OO4 (S.C.No.20 of
2006l by the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge
(FTC), Ranga Reddy District.
(b) Another case in Cr.No.418 of 2OO3 was
registered against the petitioner in the year 2oll for the
offences punishable under Sections 364,302 and 2OL read
with 34 IPC. Based on the said crimes, an enquiry was
conducted, and the 3.a respondent passed an order dated
14.O9.2OO9 dismissing t-he petitioner from service and
treating the period of suspension from 01.05.2009 to
14.O9.2009 as 'Not on duty'. Aggrieved thereby, the
petitioner preferred an appeal before the 2"d respondent,
which was rejected on 24.O5.2OL3. Questioning the said
order, the petitioner filed a revision petition, and the l"t
respondent vide proceedings dated 18.11 .2OI5, while
setting aside the order of dismissal, treated the period of
suspension and out of employment as 'not on duty'.
(c) Aggrieved by the order dated 18. 11.2O 15,
J
insofar a.s treating the period of suspension and out of
,not on duty" the present 'uvrit petition is
employment as
filed.
3.
Lee.rned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that by r.irtue of the order dated 18.11.2015 passed by the
1"t respondent, the petitioner joined the service on
14.01 .2Crl6. The 1.t respond.ent ought to have considered
the acqtrittal judgment and ought not to have t.reated the
period cf suspension and out of employment as 'not on
d.uty'.'Ihelstrespondentoughttohavereinstatedthe
petitionr:r into service with all consequential benefits'
Therefore, appropriate orders be passed in the '*'rit
petition
by settirr.g aside the impugned order of the 1'r respondent
to the extent of treating the period of suspension and out
of empl<lyment as
.not on duty,and allow the '*,rit petition.
Ttre 3..1 respondent filed a counter affidavit stating as
follo'*,s :-
(al The petitioner, who was appointed as a police
constalrle was involved in a case in cr.No.350 0f 2004 at
Kushaiguda Police Station for the offences punishable
under Sections 364 and 302 tPC, and he was acquitted by
the tV Additional District ancl Sessions Judge, Fast Track
Court, Ranga Reddy District on 27 .O2.2OO7 .
(b) Another case in Cr.No.418 of 2OO3 was
registered against the petitioner for the offences punishable
under Sections 302 and 2O 1 read vvith 34 IPC, and he was
arrested on 01.O5.2009 and remanded to judicial custody,
and he was placed under suspension vide proceedings
dated 12.O5.2OO9 .
(c) The disciplinary authority, after conducting an
enquiry, dismissed the petitioner from service vide
proceedings datecl 14.O9.2OO9 and treated the period of
suspension from 0i.05.2009 to 1,4.O9.2OO9 as "Not on
duty". Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred. art
appeal before the 2"d respondent, which was rejected on
24.O5.2O13. Further aggrieved thereby, the petitioner
preferred a revision petition before the 1't respondent.
(d) The lst respondent under the impugned orJ.er,
while setting aside the order of dismissal, treated the
f
)
period of suspension and out of employment as
"not on
duty". T,t the extent of treating the suspension period and
outofenrploymentas.notonduty,,thepetitionerfiledthe
present r,vrit Petition.
5.
Leerned Government Pleader appearing for the
respondr:nts submits that the petitioner is not entitled
back wages in view of the acquittal in the criminal
for
case'
Crimina]chargesanddepartmentalchargesarenotone
andtheSame.Thedisciplinaryauthority,afterconducting
an enquiry, dismissed' the petitioner from service and
treatedtheperiodofsuspensionfrom0l.05.2009to
l4.og.2oogas.notond.uty,.Afteracquittalbythecriminal
court,t,hel"trespondent,whilesettingasidetheorderof
of
dismissal from service, rightly treated the period
suspenl;ion and out of employment as 'not on duty'
as per
thcpro'risionsofFR-54andaspertheprincipleof.nowork
no pay, Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled
to the relief
soughtinthepresentwritpetition.Hence,thewritpetition
lacks rrterit and is liable to be dismissed'
r*1
6.
Heard Sri R.Giri Kumar, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner and the learned Government Pleader for
Services-l appearing for the respondents'
7.
tn the present case, the Government vide impugned
G.O.RI.No.973, dated 18.11.2015, while setting aside the
punishment of dismissal from service, treated the period of
suspension and out of employment as 'not on duty'.
Aggrieved by the said ord.er, the present writ petition is
filed
B.
The main contention of the petitioner is that in both
the criminal cases, i.e., s.c.No.20 0f 2006 and S.c.No.328
of 2o11, the trial court itself acquitted him vide judgments
dated 27.O2.2OO7 and 30.1 l.2ol2, respectively and against
the said. acquittal judgments, the respondent authorities
did not prefer anY aPPeal.
g.
The main grievance of the petitioner is that once the
trial Court acquitted him in both the criminal cases, the
Govt., while setting aside the punishment of dismissal from
service, ought to have granted all consequential benefits'
in
was illegatly implicated
he
that
The petitioner contends
his part and that he
on
fault
any
criminal cases without
$,as trnemployed
for nearly ten years'
contentions' learned
his
support
To
10.
appearingi
Apex
counsel
upon the judgment
relied
petitioner
the
for
AND O?I{ERS
Court in UNION OF INOIL
of the
Vs' JAIPAL
SINGHI
the
11. [n the above said case'
appeal was filed against
theorderoftheDivisionBenchoftheHighCourtofPunjab
CWP
dated 30' 10'2001 in
Chandigarh
at
and Haryana
Division Bench has
the
whereunder
lggg'
No.129119 of
allo'uved
by the respondents
the writ petition filed
for' directing
grantecl relief, as prayed'
reinstatement of the
back wages
responCent with full
and consequential
said judgment' the
the
Against
benefits.
Appeal' and
preferred the above
authorities
the Apex Court observed
as follrrvs :-
-.....ifasacitizerttheemploaeeorapublic
a cnminal
seruant got inuolued in
' (UOO+) I SuPreme
Court Cases l2l
and
case and if after a
Initial conuiction by the trial court, lrc gets acquittal
on appeal subsequentlg, the department cannot in
anA manner be found fault with for hauing kept him
out of seruice, since the law obliges a person
conuicted of an offence to be so kept out and not to
be retained in seruice. Consequently, the reasons
giuen in the decision relied upon, for the appellants
are not onlg conuincing but are in corusonance with
reasonableness as uell. Though exception taken to
that part of the order directing reinstatement cannot
be sustained and the .respondent has to be
reinstated in seruice, for the reason that the earlier
disclmrge u)as on account of those ciminal
proceedings and conuictioru only, the appellants are
uell within their rights to deny back wages to the
respondent for the period he uas not irt seruice. The
appellants cannot be made liable to pay for the
peiod for which theg could not auail of tlrc seruices
of the respondent. The High Court, in our uiew,
committed a graue error, in allouing-back-wages
also, uithout aduerting to all such releuant aspects
and considerations. Consequently, the order of the
High Court insofar as it directed payment of back
wages is liable to be and is hereby set aside.
The respondent will be entitled to back uages
from the date of acquittal and except for the purpose
of denying the respondent actual payment of back
wageq that peiod also will be counted as period of
seruice, uithout any break.....".
/
12. In
petitioner was acquitted
the
hand'
at
tlr.e case
and
of 2O06 on 27 'O2'2OOT
S.C.No.2C'
S'C'No'328 of 2011
appellate authority'
30- 1 1 '2012' The
on
Government,
18. 1
1.2015,
i'"''
the
o'973
issued impugned G'O'Rt'N
on
punishment
white setting aside the
treated the
service'
from
dismissa.l
and out
in
of
period of suspenslon
on d'uty"'
of employment as "not
above observation
and i11e5',al as Per the
which is incorrect
of the APex Court
Government
contentions' learned
13. In support of his
upon the
the respondents relied
Pleader appearing for
in
judgme'nt of the Apex Court
STATE Of I'[/ES T
KUIIIAR JANA2
ANDO'ffIERS Vs' MITUL
appeal
BENGAL
In the said case' the
judgment of the
arises out of the
High Court of
JudiczttureatCalcutta,dated|6.|2.2010,passedin..WPST
Mitul Kumar Jana'
respondent
by
filed
2o10,,
of
No.6o,J
said judgment
The Fiigh Court by the
allowed the writ and
23'11'2010 passed
set ar;ide, the order dated
Bengal
and directed
Administrative Tribunal
'2023 (14) scc 719
by the West
appellant No'2
l0
i.e., Superintendent of Police, to appoint the respondent as
a constable in the West Bengal Police Force.
14. [n the above case, the applicant, at the time of
submission of the application for the post of constable,
suppressed the material information regarding his
involvement in a pending criminal case. During police
verification, the authorities came to know that the
applicant was involved in a criminal case, and he had
suppressed the material information. Moreover, the
applicant has not mentioned in his application that he was
acquitted in the criminal case. In the said circumstances,
the Apex Court disposed of the above case.
15. In the case at hand, the issue is completely different
and in both criminal cases, the petitioner was acquitted,
and no appeal was preferred by the respondent authorities
against the acquittal judgments. Hence, the above case is
not applicable to the present case.
16. Learned Government Pleader appearing for the
respondents also relied upon the judgment of the Apex
/
ll
Court in BALDEV
In the
OF INDIA
SIAIGI{ Vs' UMON
appellant was convicted
sai<l case' the
court- However'
Court,
AND OTI{ERS3'
by
his appeal was accepted
vid'e
anC he was acquitted
The appellant
day along
that he
his
that he reported to
judgment'
with a copy of the
the strength
was reinstated on
and continued'
not fixei
the High
order dated 26'O3'L992'
was released
alleged that he
O4.O4-lg92and
by the trial
from jail on
unit on the next
He further stated
of such acquittal
pay and allowances
in service' but his
30'O g'lgg3' he
or released' On
from the service'
were
was discharged
completed
He claimed to have
the
requisil-eperiodofservicefromthedateofenrolmenttothe,
the release of
to
entitled
be
and' to
date of d'ischarge'
3O'O3' 1987 to
from
period
the
for
arrear:; of salary
periods'
as pension
30.09'1993' as well
17.
[t rn'as
not rt:ported
for the subsequent
when the appellant
that
observed
further
issue
for duty despite the
letters and' also
of as many as nlne
to his
after sending a person
t (zoos) 8 SuPreme Court Cases 747
had
home, it is felt
l2
t"\
that the case does not warrant consideration for
r egularizati on by ob tain in g government sanction.
18. It was further observed that inspite of several
attempts the writ petitioner refused to join duty, and his
conduct established a clear motive for only getting arrears
of salary and pension. It was held that he r*'as to be entitled
to salary for the period for which the writ petitioner
actuall-v rendered service and not for earlier periods.
19. In the said. circumstances, the Apex Court held that
the order of the High court does not suffer from any
infirmity and accordingly dismissed the appeal. Ho'ut ever,
the present case is altogether different, as the petitioner
herein had already joined service, and he contends that he
\ ras illegally implicated in the criminal cases. The trial
court itself acquittecl the petitioner in both cases. In the
present case, no letters were issued to the petitioner calling
upon him to join duty, nor did the authorities visit the
petitioner's house. Hence, the said case is not applicable to
the case on hand.
'i
l3
-
20. [n view of the foregoing discussion and as per the
dictum laid by the Hon',ble Apex court in JAIPAL SIMI{',s
case (1 supra), this Court is of the considered view that the
Governrnent, while setting aside the punishment of
dismissal from service, ought to have granted back wages
to the lletitioner, at least to some extent, from the date of
passing of the acquittal judgments till the date of passing
of the impugned order. Therefore, this court is inclined to
grant 25o/o of back wages from 27.O2.2OO7 to 29.11.2012
and 50(/o of back wages from 30.1 1.2012 to 18.11.2015 i.e.,
from th e dates of passing the judgments in s.c.No.2o of
2006 aed S.C.No.328 of 2O1 1 till the date of passing the
impugned order.
2l . Hence, the respondent authorities are directed to pay
250r1t of back wages from 27.02.2007
500/o berck wages from 30.11.20t2
to 29.11.2012 and
to 18.11.2015, within a
period of six months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this orcter.
I
I
t4
t\
22.. With the above direction, the writ petition is disposed
of. No order as to costs.
. ', Pending,itiscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed
SD/- C.DEEPIKA
ISTANT REGISTRAR
\
/TRUE COPY//
OFFICER
To
One fair coPY to the HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAV
(For His LordshiP's Kind Perusal)
RAJESHWAR RAO
1. 11 L.R. CoPies.
and company
2. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice
Affairs, New Delhi.
3. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library,
High court
Buildings, HYderabad.
of Telangana'
Principal Secretary, HgT". (ser.ll) Department, State
4.
' The
i"6ngini'state Secretiriat, Hyderabad'
5. The Addl. Director General of Police, State of Telangana, Hyderabad'
6.TheCommissionerofPolice,Cyberabad,Hyderabad,T.S.
g. Two ccs to GP for services-1, High court for the state of Telangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
9. Two CD CoPies
tVIP
1c
HIGH COURT
DATED 11210212026
THE S
1 9 F[8 20/8
*
*
o
-;t
f!
WP.No.34440 ot 2017
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
b
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review