Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 20th April, 2026
Pronounced on: 9th July, 2026
%
+
RFA No. 960/2023
D. K. SAXENA
S/o Shri G.P. Saxena,
R/o Q-603, Anupam Apartments,
East Arjun Nagar
New Delhi- 110032
Also at:
Sector-121, Noida, U.P.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Radhakrishna S Hegde, Ms.
Farhat Jahan Rehmani, Mr. Prakash
Chandra Sharma, Advocates
versus
G. P. SAXENA
S/o Late Shri B. B. L. Saxena
R/o Q-603, Anupam Apartments,
East Arjun Nagar
New Delhi- 110032
Through:
.....Respondent
Counsel for Respondent (appearance
not given)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been filed
against the Judgment and Decree dated 30.05.2023 whereby the Suit of the
Plaintiff / Respondent, Sh. G.P. Saxena for recovery of possession,
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
permanent injunction and recovery of mesne profits has been decreed, by
the learned Additional District Judge.
2.
The Plaintiff had filed a Suit bearing C.S. No. 1328/2009
(renumbered as C.S. No. 1935/2016) for Possession, Permanent
Injunction and recovery of mesne profits in respect of Flat no. Q-603,
Anupam Apartments, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi- 110032 consisting of four
bed rooms.
3.
The facts as narrated in the Plaint, are that the Plaintiff, Sh. G.P.
Saxena has two sons, namely the Defendant, Sh. D.K. Saxena and Sh. V.K.
Saxena, and two daughters, Smt. Prem Lata Saxena and Smt. Madhu Lata
Saxena. The Plaintiff got his son Sh. D.K. Saxena, defendant No.1 married
to Smt. Bindu Saxena in the year 1989, and the marriage expenses were
borne by him.
4.
The Plaintiff was employed as an Assistant Manager with the Food
Corporation of India and retired in the year 1990.Thereafter, initially he
shifted to the rented accommodation at P-303, Anupam Apartments, East
Arjun Nagar, Delhi-110032, where he resided along with his family and the
defendant, for about two and a half years. During this period, Defendant got
employed with N.I.C.D., as a Lab Assistant, in December 1984.
5.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff arranged sufficient funds from various
sources and purchased the property in question, from his own funds, with no
contribution from the defendant. The plaintiff, thereafter, requested the
defendant to arrange separate accommodation for himself and his family.
However, the defendant continued to reside in rented premises at P-303,
Anupam Apartments for about two years, after which he requested the
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Plaintiff and other family members to allow him and his family to reside in
the suit property.
6.
The plaintiff, on the request of the defendant and due to intervention
of family members, on humanitarian grounds, permitted the defendant and
his family to occupy a portion of the suit property comprising of two rooms,
W.C. Bathroom and one-third portion of the balcony, (hereinafter referred
to as the „Suit Property‟), as a licensee. The plaintiff along with his younger
son and his family, continued to reside in the remaining portion of the flat.
7.
The plaintiff alleged that the defendant and his family did not
contribute towards payment of house tax, electricity charges, water charges,
or other expenses relating to the property. Subsequently, the defendant
started interfering with the peaceful enjoyment and possession of the suit
property by the plaintiff and his family. In March 2009, defendant demanded
transfer of the portion occupied by him in the suit property exclusively in his
name and threatened to forcibly dispossess the plaintiff in case of noncompliance.
8.
Consequently, the plaintiff issued a Legal Notice dated 08.05.2009,
terminating the license of the defendant and sought the vacant possession,
on or before 30.06.2009. The defendant gave a reply dated 27.05.2009, but
he failed to vacate and handover the peaceful possession of the premises, to
the plaintiff.
9.
The plaintiff, thus filed the Suit seeking recovery of possession of the
suit property, mesne profit for wrongful use and occupation @ 200/- per day
since 30.06.2009 till date and Permanent Injunction.
10.
The Defendant, in his Written Statement, took a preliminary
objection that the present Suit was not maintainable, as the plaintiff had
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
suppressed the material facts. It was further alleged that the Plaintiff was
attempting to dispossess the Defendant from the suit property without any
legal justification and deprive him of his legitimate rights therein, despite
the Defendant having been residing in the suit property jointly with the
Plaintiff and other family members, for more than 19 years.
11.
The Defendant explained that the funds for purchase of the suit
property were arranged by him. He had got Rs.1,00,000/- from the sale of
plot bearing No.64, Prabhat Sahakari Awas Samiti Ltd., Prabhat Nagar,
Bareilly, owned by him. He had taken a personal loan of Rs.1,00,000/- from
his paternal aunt, Smt. Indu Verma w/o Late Sh. Umesh Verma. He also
obtained a loan of Rs.10,700/- against LIC policy and contributed the
remaining amount from his personal savings. It was contended that out of
the total consideration amount of Rs.4,00,000/- for purchase of the flat,
Defendant had contributed more than Rs.2,50,000/-, i.e., approximately 62%
of the total cost, from his own funds and borrowed sources.
12.
The Defendant further stated that he had contributed an additional
sum of Rs.50,000/-, through cheque No.239045 dated 08.01.2003 drawn on
Punjab National Bank, Radhey Puri, Delhi, towards renovation of the suit
property. The cheque was issued in the name of his mother, Smt. Shail
Kumari, at the instance of the Plaintiff.
13.
It was stated by the Defendant that the Plaintiff was involved in a
corruption case, initiated by the Food Corporation of India and was
dismissed from service after allegedly being caught while accepting a bribe,
and had not received any retirement benefits, such as pension or gratuity
from FCI. Due to such circumstances, Plaintiff was not financially capable
of purchasing the suit property and that the property was acquired from joint
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
family funds, though the title documents were executed in the name of the
Plaintiff as Karta of the alleged HUF. Thus, the Plaintiff had no exclusive
right over the suit property.
14.
The Defendant further asserted that the Plaintiff and his wife had been
residing with him since 1990 and had enjoyed various benefits arising out of
his employment, including medical facilities and LTC benefits, as the
Defendant was employed as a Research Assistant with N.I.C.D under the
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India.
15.
The Plaintiff and his wife were dependent upon the Defendant for the
purpose of availing medical benefits, under the C.G.H.S. facility. They had
been included as a dependent under C.G.H.S. Dispensary No.67, Laxmi
Nagar, Delhi, bearing Card No.0006010, issued in the name of the
Defendant, and they had been availing medical benefits thereunder.
However, subsequently, vide Application dated 08.01.2008 submitted before
N.I.C.D., the Plaintiff sought deletion of his and his wife’s names from the
list of dependents maintained under the said C.G.H.S. card.
16.
On merits, the defendant denied the plaintiff’s claim of ownership
over the suit property and contended that the property was not purchased
solely from the Plaintiff’s funds or income. It was reiterated that the Plaintiff
was dismissed from service. The Defendant claimed that he had contributed
more than 62% of the total cost of the suit property from his own funds and
resources.
17.
The Defendant further contended that the family had always
remained joint and maintained a common ration card Mark D-1. It was
alleged that merely because the property documents stood in the name of the
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Plaintiff, the Plaintiff could not claim exclusive ownership over the same, as
the property was purchased for the benefit of the Hindu Undivided Family.
18.
The Defendant denied the Plaintiff’s claim that his marriage with Smt.
Bindu Saxena, was arranged and financed by the Plaintiff. It was stated that
the Defendant was already employed with N.I.C.D since 1984 and had
contributed towards his own marriage expenses.
19.
The Defendant further denied that the Plaintiff had taken the rented
premises bearing No. P-303, Anupam Apartments, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi
after leaving his employment. The Defendant claimed that the said premises
were taken on rent by him, and he had paid the rent.
20.
The defendant categorically mentioned that he started working with
N.I.C.D as a technician since November, 1984 and not December, 1984. His
wife was also employed with Indian Council for Research on International
Economic Relation, New Delhi and that they were the primary earning
members of the family whose income was utilised towards household
expenses.
21.
All the averments made in the Plaint were denied and it was claimed
that the Suit was liable to be dismissed.
22.
The Plaintiff in his Replication, denied the preliminary objections
and averments contained in the Written Statement of Defendant and
reiterated and reaffirmed the case set up in the plaint.
23.
Upon consideration of the pleadings of the parties, the Issues were
framed on 21.11.2011, as under:
i. Whether plaintiff is entitled to a decree of possession
as prayed for? OPP.
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
ii. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of
permanent injunction? OPP.
iii. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of mesne
profit? If so, at what rate? OPP
iv. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable?
OPD
v. Whether the suit property is a joint Hindu family
property? OPD
vi. Relief.
24.
The Plaintiff, Sh. G.P. Saxena in support of his case, examined
himself as PW-1 and tendered in evidence his affidavit on the same lines of
his plaint and the same is Ex. PW1/A. In support of his case, the Plaintiff
relied upon various documentary evidences. The Plaintiff placed reliance
upon the original conveyance deed dated 20.01.2005 pertaining to the suit
property, which was Ex.PW1/1, along with the original site plan Ex.PW1/2.
He further relied upon the original letter dated 19.08.2009 issued by Sir
Ganga Ram Hospital to the Plaintiff, Ex.PW1/3. The Plaintiff also relied
upon the original share certificates dated 05.05.1984 issued in the names of
Devinder Kumar Saxena and Virender Kumar Saxena, Ex.PW1/4 and
Ex.PW1/5, respectively, along with receipts relating to booking of plots in
Bareilly in the names of Devinder Kumar Saxena and Virender Kumar
Saxena, Ex.PW1/6 and Ex.PW1/7. Further, the Plaintiff relied upon the
instalment receipts pertaining to the said plots, Ex.PW1/8 and Ex.PW1/9,
and the documents relating to payment of development charges, which were
marked as Mark A and Mark B (Ex.PW1/10 and Ex.PW1/11 having been
de-exhibited and marked). The Plaintiff further relied upon the original
allotment certificates issued in the names of Devinder Kumar Saxena and
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Virender Kumar Saxena, Ex.PW1/12 and Ex.PW1/13. The Plaintiff also
placed reliance upon the photocopies of sale deeds dated 24.03.1992 and
07.03.1992, which were marked as Mark C and Mark D (Ex.PW1/14 and
Ex.PW1/15 having been de-exhibited and marked). Additionally, the
Plaintiff relied upon the original LIC instalment receipts Ex.PW1/16 to
Ex.PW1/26 and the photocopies of demand drafts marked as Mark A1 to
Mark A7. These documents were relied upon by the Plaintiff to substantiate
his claim regarding the ownership of the suit property and the financial
transactions relied upon by him.
25.
PW-2, Sh. Vijay Kumar Bitta, husband of the sister of Plaintiff’s
wife, tendered his evidence by way of affidavit as Ex. PW2/A. He supported
the case set up in the plaint and stated that he arranged an accommodation
on rent i.e. Flat P-303, Anupam Apartment, in the year 1991, @ Rs. 1800/per month which was paid by the plaintiff to Sh. Sanjay, owner of the flat
through cheque.
26.
PW-3, Smt. Anu Saxena, younger daughter-in-law of the plaintiff,
tendered her evidence by way of affidavit as Ex. PW3/A. She supported the
case of the Plaintiff that he allowed the defendant to reside in the suit
property in the month of December, 1992. He was allowed only to occupy
the portion shown in red colour in the site plan Ex. PW1/2.
27.
PW-4, Smt. Lata Saxena, younger daughter of the plaintiff, in her
affidavit of evidence Ex. PW4/A, supported the case of the Plaintiff that he
arranged entire funds from his own resources and purchased the suit
property.
28.
In defence, Defendant Sh. D.K. Saxena examined himself as DW-1
and tendered his evidence by way of affidavit, Ex.DW1/A, reiterating the
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
averments made in the Written Statement. In support of his defence, the
Defendant relied upon various documents, including the letter dated
08.09.2009 Ex.DW1/1. He further relied upon the copy of the certificate
dated 20.10.2009 issued by Punjab National Bank, Radhey Puri Branch,
which was marked as Mark D-1. Additionally, the Defendant placed reliance
upon the copy of the LTC advance form dated 13.10.1994 and the copy of
the LTC bill dated 05.01.2004, which were marked as Mark D-2 and Mark
D-3, respectively.
29.
DW-2, Sh. Jagdish Chandra, UDC from the office of NCDC,
Shammath Marg, New Delhi proved the LTC advance from Mark D-2 and
the same was exhibited as Ex.DW2/1. He also proved the LTC bills as Ex.
DW2/2 (Mark D-3).
30.
DW-3, Ms. Manju Gupta, Senior Manager, Punjab National Bank
deposed that Sh. Ashok Kapoor was the Manager in Punjab National Bank,
Radhey Puri Branch in the year 2009 and he expired on 28.05.2017. She
further deposed that the reply by Punjab National Bank dated 20.10.2009
bears his signature at point A and the same is exhibited as Ex. DW3/1. In
her cross-examination, she tendered email date 29.11.2017 as Ex. DW3/P1
and attested copies of the Housing Loan documents as Ex. DW3/P2.
31.
DW-4, Ms. Indu Verma, paternal aunt of the defendant, tendered
her evidence by way of affidavit Ex.DW4/A. She supported the defendant
and stated that she had given a personal loan of Rs. 1,00,000/- to the
defendant towards the purchase of the suit flat, and had issued the demand
draft No. 063344/17 dated 08.07.1992 drawn on Allahabad Bank Bareilly,
payable at Allahabad, directly in favour of Sh. B.C. Gupta, seller of the suit
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
flat. Moreover, the amount was repaid by the defendant in cash in several
instalments, for which she relied upon the document Ex. PW1/D-1.
32.
The
learned
ADJ,
while
deciding
the
claim
of
the
Appellant/Defendant that the property in question was purchased from the
funds of HUF in the name of the Plaintiff, who was acting as the Karta of
the HUF and as to whether the suit property was a joint Hindu family
property, placed reliance upon the Conveyance Deed dated 20.01.2005
Ex.PW1/1 to observe that the Plaintiff was the recorded owner of the suit
property. No material was placed on record to establish that the Plaintiff had
acquired the suit property, in the capacity of Karta of the HUF. The
Defendant had also claimed that the suit property was a joint family
property. The stand taken by the Defendant was held to be contradictory, as
he claimed the property to be both HUF property as well as a joint family
property.
33.
The learned ADJ further observed that merely because a Hindu joint
family existed, it would not automatically create a presumption that every
property standing in the name of a family member, was joint family
property. The defendant was required to establish that the suit property was
purchased from the nucleus of any ancestral or joint family property.
However, the defendant failed to produce any evidence to establish the
existence of any such joint family nucleus or that the suit property was
purchased from joint family funds.
34.
It was held by learned ADJ that even if the defendant had contributed
financially towards the purchase of the property, such contribution would
not create any right, title or interest in the suit property, as explained in the
case of Srinivas Krishnarao Kango v. Narayan Devji Kango, AIR 1954 SC
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
379, wherein Apex Court held that the existence of a joint family by itself,
does not lead to a presumption that the property held by any member is joint
family property. The burden lies upon the person asserting such claim to
establish that the property was acquired from the joint family nucleus.
35.
The ld. ADJ also placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Delhi High Court in Santosh Vishweshwarnath Wadhwa v. Gulshan
Chhabra & Ors., 2016 (3) CLJ 415 Del., to hold that a mere assertion
regarding existence of HUF is insufficient, unless specific facts are pleaded
and established regarding the creation and nature of HUF property.
Accordingly, it was held that the defendant failed to prove that the suit
property was a joint family property.
36.
Consequently, the ld. Trial Court vide Judgment and Decree dated
30.05.2023, decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff, for possession and permanent
injunction in respect of the suit property. The ld. Trial Court further
awarded mesne profits/use and occupation charges @ Rs. 3,000/- per
month w.e.f. 01.07.2009 with 10% annual escalation until handing over of
vacant possession by the defendant.
37.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment and Decree dated 30.05.2023, the
present
Regular
First
Appeal
has
been
preferred
by
the
Appellant/Defendant.
38.
The grounds of challenge are that the Ld. Trial Court has failed to
appreciate the material evidence and facts on record and has erroneously
held that the suit property was the exclusive property of the
Respondent/Plaintiff. It has been contended that the suit property was
purchased when the parties were residing as a joint family with a common
residence and mess, and that the property was acquired from joint family
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
funds, including substantial contribution made by the Appellant. Merely
because the property was purchased in the name of the Respondent, who
was the father and Karta of the family, it could not be presumed to be his
self-acquired property.
39.
It has been contended that the Ld. ADJ failed to appreciate that the
Appellant had contributed more than 62% towards the purchase of the suit
property and that the said contribution was admitted by the Respondent in
his evidence. It has been further asserted that the ld. Trial court failed to
consider the circumstances surrounding the purchase of the property,
including the sale of the plot in the name of the Appellant and utilisation of
the sale proceeds as well as availing loan against the LIC policy of the
Appellant, which established that the property was purchased from joint
family funds.
40.
It has also been asserted that the findings of the Ld. Trial Court
wrongly held that even if the Appellant had contributed towards the
purchase of the property, he could only seek recovery of the amount and
such contribution would not create any right or interest in the property.
According to the Appellant, the Court has wrongly created a new case in
favour of the Respondent, which was neither pleaded nor supported by
evidence. Hence, the Ld. ADJ has failed to appreciate that the Appellant had
proved the existence of a joint family and that the suit property was
purchased from the nucleus of joint family funds.
41.
The Ld. ADJ also failed to consider the evidence regarding the joint
nature of the family and the fact that the Appellant was earning prior to the
purchase of the suit property and had paid instalments of the plot and LIC
premiums, from his own income. The Appellant further relied upon the
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
testimony of DW-4 Smt. Indu Verma to contend that he had taken a loan of
Rs.1,00,000/- for purchase of the suit property, which was subsequently
repaid from his own income.
42.
It is further claimed that the Mesne Profits have been awarded at an
arbitrary rate of Rs. 3,000/- per month, as no evidence was led by the
Respondent/Plaintiff to establish entitlement to mesne profits at the awarded
rate. The Ld. ADJ ignored the fact that the Appellant was already
contributing towards maintenance expenses of the property and therefore,
was not liable to pay mesne profits.
43.
It is therefore, submitted that the impugned Judgment dated
30.05.2023, is liable to be set aside.
44.
Written submission has been filed on behalf of the Appellant in
support of and to substantiate the grounds raised in the present Appeal. The
submissions contained therein reiterate the averments and contentions urged
in the present Appeal.
45.
The reliance has been placed on Adiveppa & Ors. v. Bhimappa &
Anr., in Civil Appeal No. 11220 of 2017, wherein the Apex Court held that
all assets pertaining to Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) are to be treated as
joint property of the HUF, unless the contrary is proved as self-acquisition
of property through valid documents.
46.
Similarly, in Nanak Chand and Ors. v. Chander Kishore and Ors.,
AIR 1982 Delhi 520 it was held that there is a presumption that family is
joint, but there is no presumption that any property whether movable or
immovable, held by a member of a joint Hindu is joint family property. The
burden lies upon the person who asserts that a particular property is joint
family property to establish that fact. But if he proves that there was
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
sufficient joint family nucleus from and out of which, the said property
could have been acquired, the burden shifts to the member of the family
setting up the claim that it is his personal property to establish that the said
property has been acquired without any assistance from the joint family
property. The mere fact that it was purchased in his name, does not render
the property his separate property for all that is perfectly consistent with the
notion of its being joint.
47.
Written submission has also been filed on behalf of the Respondent,
wherein the averments made in the Plaint have been reiterated. It has stated
that the impugned Judgment is well-reasoned, detailed and free from any
infirmity and that the learned Trial Court has rightly appreciated the
evidence and material placed on record. Hence, there is no merit in the
present Appeal.
Submissions heard and record perused.
48.
The case of the Plaintiff is that he was employed as an Assistant
manager with Food Corporation of India from where he retired in the year
1990. Earlier, he was residing in a rented accommodation at P-303, Anupam
Apartment, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi, along with his family as well as
Defendant, Sh. D.K. Saxena, where they all resided for 2.5 years.
49.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff arranged funds and purchased the Suit
Property by virtue of Agreement to Sell, etc. dated 16.07.1992. He thereafter
shifted to the Suit Premises along with his younger son. After about 2 years
of their shifting into the Suit Premises, D.K. Saxena, his son, who had been
residing in a rented accommodation, shifted along with his family and
requested the Plaintiff to allow him to reside in the Suit Property.
Consequently, the Plaintiff being the father on humanitarian grounds as well
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
as on the intervention of family members, permitted Defendant and his
family to occupy two rooms, WC bathroom, kitchen and one-third portion of
the balcony in the Suit Flat as a Licensee.
50.
These facts have essentially not been denied by the Defendant except
that he claimed that his father did not retire in 1990, but his services were
terminated. Before that, he had faced corruption charges and a departmental
inquiry had been initiated against him.
51.
The Defendant claimed that since he got appointed with N.I.C.D. as
Lab Assistant in December 1984 and his wife was employed in Indian
Council for Research on International Economic Relations in Delhi. They
both were the primary earning members of the family, whose income was
being utilized for household expenses. The Defendant claimed that it was
not he who was dependent on the Plaintiff, but it was other way around and
the Plaintiff and his wife in fact, were dependent upon the Defendant.
52.
To support his assertions, he had deposed that the Plaintiff, i.e., his
father as well as mother, were shown as dependents in his office records.
53.
The Plaintiff in his cross-examination admitted that D.K. Saxena,
Appellant was holding C.G.H.S Card wherein, the plaintiff and his wife
were shown as dependents of the Defendant. He explained that since the
termination of his service in the year 1990, he was not having any medical
facility, which explains why his name was added in the CGHS Card of the
Defendant, D.K. Saxena.
54.
The Plaintiff also admitted that he and his wife had been availing
medical facility on this C.G.H.S. Card upto 2008. He however, moved an
Application before Administrative Officer, N.I.C.D for deletion of the name
of himself and his wife from the aforesaid CGHS Card on 08.10.2008, copy
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
of which is Ex.PW1/D4 and PW1/D5. The Plaintiff sought to explain by
volunteering that he had asked the Defendant several times for deletion of
his and his wife’s name from the CGHS Card, but he did not do so which
compelled him to file the Application.
55.
It was explained by DW1 Defendant, Sh. D.K. Saxena in his
testimony that thereafter, the Plaintiff has started availing the CGHS Card
facilities of Smt. Anu Saxena, wife of V.K. Saxena, younger son of the
Plaintiff by getting their names added on their card.
56.
The Defendant had further stated in his affidavit of evidence that the
Plaintiff and his wife had also availed LTC facility for Delhi to Jagannath
Puri from 14.11.1994 to 17.11.1994 and they also went to Delhi-Goa from
22.12.2003 to 02.01.2004 along with the Defendant, in support of which he
filed documents Ex.DW1/3 and DW1/4.
57.
The Plaintiff had further admitted that he had shifted to L-202,
Anupam Apartments, had been taken on rent by his younger son, V.K.
Saxena, which was vacated on 15.04.2014. The renovations were going on
in the Suit Flat which got completed in March, 2014, after which the
Plaintiff along with his wife, younger son and his family had shifted on
around 15.04.2014 to the suit Flat.
58.
The core question which arises is whether the circumstances are
sufficient to establish that there existed a joint family or there were any
HUF funds.
59.
It is quite evident that the Plaintiff was in service and he and his wife
shifted to Delhi only in 1990. They shifted into the rented premises which
according to them, had been taken on rent by the younger son V.K. Saxena.
The Plaintiff and his wife thereafter, on acquiring the suit property, along
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
with their younger son, shifted to suit property wherein the Defendant along
with his family joined them, after about two years.
60.
It has emerged from the evidence of the parties that both the sons and
the Plaintiff were in Government jobs and they all have been working
independently. They may have decided to reside as a family for a certain
period as has emerged from the testimony above, but these circumstances do
not establish any joint family as is understood under the traditional Hindu
Law. For their convenience, they may have lived together for a certain
period of time, and the Plaintiff along with his wife on retirement, may have
started residing with one son or both the son, but that in itself does not
constitute a joint family.
61.
It would be pertinent to first understand that the two concepts of Joint
Hindu family and Hindu Undivided family (HUF) are absolutely different. In
Gowli Buddana v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Mysore AIR 1966 SC
1523, it was held that a Hindu Joint Family consists of all persons lineally
descended from a common ancestor and includes their wives and unmarried
daughters. However, a Joint Family is a larger body consisting of a group of
persons who are united by a tie of sapindaship arising by birth, marriage or
adoption as was observed in Surjit Lal Chhabra v. Commissioner of Income
Tax, Bombay 1976 SCR (2) 164. The fundamental principle of Hindu Joint
Family is the sapindaship. A Joint Family is not limited to three generations
or only to male members but is a larger body which includes all the family
members from a common ancestor.
62.
In Sunny (Minor) & Anr. v. Raj Singh & Ors. (2015) 225 DLT 211
this Court considered the judgments of the Apex Court in Yudhishter v.
Ashok Kumar, 1987 (1) SCC 204, and Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
v. Chander Sen,(1986) 3 SCC 567 and succinctly enumerated the principles
relating to HUF property and its inheritance as under:
“(i) If a person dies after passing of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956 and there is no HUF existing at the time of the
death of such a person, inheritance of an immovable
property of such a person by his successors-in-interest is no
doubt inheritance of an “ancestral” property but the
inheritance is as a self-acquired property in the hands of the
successor and not as an HUF property although the
successor(s) indeed inherits “ancestral” property i.e a
property belonging to his paternal ancestor.
(ii) The only way in which a Hindu Undivided Family/joint
Hindu family can come into existence after 1956 (and when
a joint Hindu family did not exist prior to 1956) is if an
individual's property is thrown into a common hotchpotch.
Also, once a property is thrown into a common hotchpotch,
it is necessary that the exact details of the specific
date/month/year etc. of creation of an HUF for the first time
by throwing a property into a common hotchpotch have to
be clearly pleaded and mentioned and which requirement is
a legal requirement because of Order VI Rule 4 CPC which
provides that all necessary factual details of the cause of
action must be clearly stated. Thus, if an HUF property
exists because of its such creation by throwing of selfacquired property by a person in the common hotchpotch,
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
consequently there is entitlement in coparceners etc. to a
share in such HUF property.
(iii) An HUF can also exist if paternal ancestral properties
are inherited prior to 1956, and such status of parties qua
the properties has continued after 1956 with respect to
properties inherited prior to 1956 from paternal ancestors.
Once that status and position continues even after 1956; of
the HUF and of its properties existing; a coparcener etc.
will have a right to seek partition of the properties.
(iv) Even before 1956, an HUF can come into existence
even without inheritance of ancestral property from
paternal ancestors, as HUF could have been created prior
to 1956 by throwing of individual property into a common
hotchpotch. If such an HUF continues even after 1956, then
in such a case a coparcener etc. of an HUF was entitled to
partition of the HUF property”
63.
Therefore, in such a post 1956 scenario, a mere ipse dixit statement in
the plaint that an HUF and its properties exist is not a sufficient compliance
of the legal requirement of creation or existence of HUF properties in as
much as it is necessary for existence of an HUF and its properties, It must
be specifically stated that as to whether the HUF came into existence before
1956 or after 1956 and if so how and in what manner giving all requisite
factual details. It is only in such circumstances where specific facts are
mentioned to clearly plead a cause of action of existence of an HUF and its
properties, can a suit then be filed and maintained by a person claiming to be
a coparcener for partition of the HUF properties.
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
64.
The next question which arises is whether there was any HUF existing
inter se the Plaintiff and his two sons. Merely because the father and the
sons at certain times, started residing together, it does not lead to any ipso
facto creation of an HUF.
65.
For an HUF to be created especially after 1955, it has to be a
conscious creation of HUF. However, in the present case there is not an
iota of evidence from where the inference of existence of any HUF can be
drawn. There is neither any HUF account nor any details of any nucleus
being created on the HUF; rather what has emerged is that after the
retirement, Plaintiff had been residing with the two sons with some
contribution for the day to day expenditure, by the two sons and their wives.
There is not an iota or any evidence of there being any HUF in existence
or of any HUF corpus, from where money was paid for the purchase of
suit property.
66.
The Plaintiff had asserted that he had purchased the Suit Property in
the name of his deceased wife Smt. Shail Kumari Saxena, on payment of the
sale consideration of Rs.4 lakhs. It may now be considered whether the
explanations given by the Plaintiff, about the manner of payment of Rs.4
lakhs, for purchase of the suit property.
67.
He had explained the sources for payment of Rs.4 lakhs which he
deposed, to have been arranged by him. He deposed that he had made the
payment through 7 Demand Drafts, the details of which are as under:
“i.
Demand Draft No. 063344/17 dated 08.07.1992,
for Rs.1,00,000/- of Allahabad Bank, Bareilly.
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
ii.
Demand
Draft
No.
91/1/
859602
dated
08.07.1992, for Rs.50,000/- of Bank of Baroda, Civil lines,
Bareilly.
iii.
Demand Draft No. 196209 dated 10.07.1992, for
Rs.50,000/- New Bank of India, Radhey Puri, Delhi.
iv.
Demand
Draft
No.
QVA
578516
dated
11.07.1992, for Rs.1,00,000/- Punjab National Bank,
Laxmi Nagar, Delhi.
v. Demand Draft No. 196217 dated 11.07.1992, for
Rs.50,000/- New Bank of India, Radhey Puri, Delhi.
vi.
Demand Draft No. 297744 dated 13.07.1992, for
Rs.25,000/- State Bank India, Indra Nagar, Bareilly.
vii.
Demand Draft No. 297745 dated 13.07.1992, for
Rs.25,000/- State Bank of India, Indra Nagar, Bareilly.”
68.
These aforesaid Demand Drafts were marked as Mark A to G. The
Plaintiff explained in his testimony that he had purchased two plots bearing
No. 62 and 63 in Prabhat Sahakari Awas Samiti, Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh, in
the names of his sons, namely D.K. Saxena and V.K. Saxena. The original
Share Certificates relating to these plots, are Ex.PW1/4 and Ex.PW1/5. The
booking receipts dated 01.09.1983 were Ex.PW1/6 and Ex.PW1/7,
respectively. The Instalment Receipts dated 16.01.1985 are Ex.PW1/8 and
Ex.PW1/9. The Development charge receipts Ex.PW1/10 and Ex.PW1/11.
The Allotment Letters dated 20.01.1985 are Ex.PW1/12 and Ex.PW1/13.
69.
The Plaintiff as PW1 had further deposed that he had sold the plot in
the name of his elder son, D.K. Saxena on 24.03.1992, to Smt. Rita
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Srivastava for a consideration of Rs.1,00,000/- through demand drafts
Ex.PW1/14. Likewise, the plot in the name of his younger son, V.K. Saxena
was sold on 07.03.1992 to Smt. Aanchal Aggarwal, for a sale consideration
of Rs.1,20,000/- through Ex.PW1/15. Accordingly, the Plaintiff deposed that
he had arranged Rs.2,20,000/- by the sale of these two plots from which he
had got the drafts prepared and given them for the purchase of the Suit
Property.
70.
The Defendant D.K. Saxena in his testimony, claimed that these two
Plots were in his name and in the name of his brother and the Plaintiff could
not have claimed these two properties as owned by him and he could not
claim the sale proceeds from the sale of these two plots, as his own income.
71.
From the documents placed on record, the bookings had been made in
the year 1983. The Defendant, D.K. Saxena in order to show his earning
capacity to be able to book the flat, had deposed that he had passed his class
Xth in 1975. He asserted that he was taking tuitions of the students of class
VI to VIII since the year 1980. He further tried to explain that he was getting
tuition fee in cash and was earning about Rs.2,000-2,500/- p.m., but was
unable to produce any documents in proof thereof. He claimed that he used
to save about Rs.1,500 to 1,600/-, but again it is not corroborated by any
evidence.
72.
However, it is difficult to believe that a student who has himself
studied till class X, would be in a position to take the tuition for the students
of class VI to VIII. Moreover, he admittedly was unable to produce any
documents, registers to show that he was taking the tuitions of the students
or to prove the fee that he had been receiving from these tuitions.
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Admittedly, he has not filed any income tax returns prior to 1984, when he
got his appointment in NICD.
73.
He, when specifically asked, was unable to give details of the
payments made in the year 1983 for purchase of these two plots, was unable
to give any details. In fact, he himself admitted that these amounts
pertaining to the plots in Bareilly purchased in his name, was from the
unaccounted wealth of the father. It all clearly reflects and supports that
testimony of the Plaintiff that the booking of the two plots had been done by
him, though in the name of his two sons.
74.
Another significant aspect which has emerged from the cross-
examination of DW1 D.K. Saxena, is that from the sale of the plot booked
in his name, on 24.03.1992, a sale consideration of Rs.1,00,000/- was
received through two demand drafts of Rs.50,000/-, each. He got prepared
two demand drafts of Rs.50,000/- each from his bank account and directly
gave it to Sh. B.C. Gupta, seller of the Suit Property.
75.
It is quite evident that the money on sale of the plots came to the two
sons since the plots were in their respective names, but it was the investment
made by the Plaintiff, who sold them for the purpose of raising the part sale
consideration for the purchase of land.
76.
The Plaintiff had further asserted that he had taken two LIC Policies
in the names of his sons, respectively on 28.03.1979 for a sum assured of
Rs.25,000/-, each. He deposed that the entire premiums/payments were paid
by the Plaintiff in respect of these two Policies, which were for a period of
10 years. He had further deposed that during this period of 10 years, and no
payment towards the premium, was made by the two sons. When the Suit
Property was purchased, on his request, the LIC policies were encashed and
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
Rs.10,700/- was received D.K. Saxena and Rs.10,000/- by V.K. Saxena. The
two sons returned him Rs.20,700/- realised on the encashment of LIC policy,
which were utilised for payment of sale consideration. The Defendant in his
testimony as DW-1, has not furnished any proof of having paid the premium
of LIC policy.
77.
As already discussed above, it has emerged from his testimony that
till about 1984, when he got into the service, he did not have sufficient funds
for making any investments. The testimony of the parties thus, establishes
that all the investments had been made by the Plaintiff in the name of his
two sons, which he liquidated to arrange for the sale consideration of the
Suit Property
78.
The Plaintiff had further claimed that his sister, Indu Verma had given
him a Bank Draft of Rs.1,00,000/-, which also was paid to the seller B.C.
Gupta. He explained that Indu Verma had repaid the amount that was spent
by him on the treatment of her husband Umesh Chand Verma in Ganga Ram
Hospital, during the period March-April, 1991, where he was treated for
Kidney failure. The Certificate issued by the hospital, is Ex.PW1/3.
79.
The Defendant, D.K.Saxena, however, asserted that he had used his
goodwill with Indu Verma, his Bua and had taken Rs.1,00,000/- as loan. The
Draft was admittedly given by Indu Verma directly in the name of seller
B.C. Gupta, on his request.
80.
In order to corroborate his defense, he had examined DW4 Indu
Verma, who deposed that she had given the draft of Rs.1,00,000/- in the
name of the seller on the request of D.K. Saxena and it was a loan given to
D.K. Saxena.
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
81.
DW4 Indu Verma, however, in her cross-examination, admitted that
she was a Clerk in Government Department, i.e., Hydral Department,
wherein she had got the job on compassionate ground in place of her
husband, in the year 1991. She admitted that no loan document in regard to
this alleged loan transaction, was executed. She further explained that this
amount was refunded by D.K. Saxena in 3 to 4 years, in the instalment of
Rs.5,000/- to Rs.10,000/-. However, she admitted that she had not shown the
repayment of these amount in her Income Tax Returns, as she was getting it
in cash. She thereafter, volunteered that she was not an Income Tax
Assessee at that time.
82.
Pertinently, DW4 Indu Verma admitted that in the year 1991, her
husband was ill and admitted to Sir Ganga Ram Hospital and about
Rs.70,000-80,000/- were spent o his treatment. These admissions support the
assertions of the Plaintiff that he had spend from his pocket, on the treatment
of husband of Indu Verma and the draft of Rs.1,00,000/- was in lieu thereof.
83.
Another significant admission made by DW4 is that their relations
were cordial, but they ceased to be so after the filing of the Suit.
84.
From this evidence as well, it is established that it is the Plaintiff, who
had arranged Rs.1,00,000/- from his sister.
85.
From the entire evidence as discussed above, it is established that the
sum of Rs.4,00,000/- for payment of sale consideration, had been arranged
by the Plaintiff from his various resources. Those investments may have
been made in the name of his two sons, but that in itself, cannot be a ground
to claim that the property so purchased, was an HUF property.
86.
Learned ADJ had rightly observed that even if it is accepted that some
contributions were made by the two Defendants, this is not sufficient to
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
conclude that the Suit Property is HUF. To be so, it has to be established that
it is purchased from HUF funds, which the Defendants have miserably failed
to establish.
87.
The property has been purchased by the Plaintiff initially in the name
of his wife, by arranging the funds himself and thus, it is shown that the wife
Smt. Shail Kumari was the owner in whose name the sale documents were
executed. Thereafter, the Conveyance Deed dated 20.01.2005 was executed
by Smt. Shail Kumari Saxena, in the name of the Plaintiff.
88.
The Defendant had asserted that on the instructions of the Plaintiff, he
had also paid a sum of Rs.50,000/-vide cheque dated 08.01.2003, Ex.DW1/1
and Ex. DW1/2 respectively, issued in the name of the mother of the
Defendant, to the Plaintiff as a contribution for carrying out renovation
work in the Suit Flat.
89.
The Plaintiff, however, had explained that he had made investment in
Kishan Vikas Patra, which he had purchased on 23.06.1997, jointly in the
name of his wife, Smt. Shail Kumari Saxena and Smt. Bindu Saxena, wife of
the Defendant, for a sum of Rs.25,000/-. The Plaintiff deposed that he had
made this investment with the intent of extending financial assistance for the
education of the children of the Defendant. The Kishan Vikas Patra matured
on 23.12.2002 and was encashed on 30.12.2002 and an amount of
Rs.50,000/- so received on maturity, was returned by Smt. Bindu Saxena
vide the cheque bearing No. 239045 dated 08.01.2003. The Plaintiff denied
that such amount was towards renovation or maintenance of the Suit
Property.
90.
The first thing, which emerges, is that admittedly, a sum of
Rs.50,000/- had been given to the Plaintiff vide Cheque dated 08.01.2003 by
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
the wife of the Defendant. The suit property was purchased in the year 1992,
since when the Plaintiff and the Defendant had been residing together.
Though, subsequently differences arose, but there is nothing on record to
show that this Rs.50,000/- were actually utilized for renovation. But even if
it is accepted, then merely because the Defendant contributed Rs.50,000/for repairs, would not be a fact indicating his ownership rights in the Suit
Property.
91.
The Defendant had also asserted that he was paying 50% of
maintenance charges of the Suit Property. However, being in occupation and
using the Property, merely payment of maintenance charges, would not
create any title in the Defendant.
92.
It is pertinent to observe that the Plaintiff’s father had been driven to
file a Petition before the Maintenance Tribunal, for seeking the maintenance
in which an Order dated 04.05.2012 Ex.PW1/D11, was made directing the
Defendant, to pay the maintenance w.e.f. 2011.
93.
The aforesaid evidence as led by the parties, do not establish either
that there was any Joint Hindu Family or an HUF constituted between the
Plaintiff and the Defendant. There is also no evidence of any HUF being
constituted or the sale proceeds from the nucleus of HUF. The Plaintiff was,
therefore, rightly held entitled to recovery of possession.
94.
The only question which remains, is the determination of the Mesne
Profits and at what should be the rate at which the Mesne Profits must be
calculated.
95.
The Mesne Profits are defined under Section 2 (12) of CPC as under:
“2(12) "mesne profits" of property means those profits
which the person in wrongful possession of such property
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
actually received or might with ordinary diligence have
received therefrom, together with interest on such profits,
but shall not include profits due to improvements made by
the person in wrongful possession;”
96.
The very definition of Mesne Profits means the profits that the person
has derived from the wrongful possession of the property. It is, therefore,
evident that the calculation of Mesne Profits is not of the profits that the
Plaintiff may have derived from sale or otherwise of the property, but it is
the wrongful benefit derived by the Tenant who has continued in unlawful
possession.
97.
In the case of Bureau of Indian Standards vs. Goodwill Threatres Pvt.
Ltd. 2018(1) RCR (Civil) 400, while referring to the definition of Mesne
Profits under Section 2(12) CPC, it was observed that the Mesne Profits do
not include profits due to improvements made by the person in wrongful
possession. It is the value of the usage of the land to the person in wrongful
possession.
98.
In the light of this definition, the mesne profits may be considered.
Even if no evidence was led by the Plaintiff to prove the Mesne Profits i.e.
the charges, he could have realized by letting out the suit property to the
third person, but the learned District Judge rightly took judicial notice of the
location, nature of the premises and the long possession of the Defendant, to
grant Mesne Profits @Rs.3,000/- per month towards user and occupation
charges w.e.f. 01.07.2009. Furthermore, the annual escalation @10% p.a.,
has also been rightly granted to the Plaintiff.
CONCLUSION
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
99.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, there is no merit in the
present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed. The pending Applications, if
any, are also disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JULY 09, 2026
N/RS
RFA 960/2023
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:50:16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review