Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
'
$ !
&
#
$
#%
!
#
( '
)
!
#$
$ $
&
VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$
$
$
$
'
!
&
$
(
&
$
"
%
-2-
&
)
!
$
&
$
"
#$
$
%
*
&
!!
*
&
!!'
&
&
+
*
*
((
#
' !
%
,
'
!
'
$
&
-$.
*
/$
)
012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674= 244>17? 56
@AB20
6C:<
6(
;< =42367:475
!
4?1254=4:
6C:< !
' :B54:
774GA=4
F1:4
'!
=:4= :1=4D5167
' EB175B174:
5 12 504 DB24 68 504 345151674= 50B5 04 12 B7
B:F6DB54 =421:17? 17 504
B1D0A=
04=4 CB2 B 34=267B9
-3-
47E15< ;45C447 504 345151674= B7: 674
6504=2
01EEB1B0 B7:
7 8A=504=B7D4 68 504 B;6F4 47E15< 504=4 4=A354:
B 81?05 ;45C447 5C6 ?=6A32 68 346394
DD6=:17?9< ;B24:
67 504 D6E39B175 B7 &
DBE4 56 ;4 =4?1254=4: B?B1725
345151674= 17
!
=1E4
HA=12:1D5167 68
6!
45BH17B?B=
' B7: !' !
691D4
' C15017 504
5B5167
B1D0A=
D0B=?4 20445 DBE4 56 ;4 8194: B?B1725 5012 345151674= 17
=1E4
6!
!
' # 39
::15167B9
(
B7:
B2542 B7: 504
5=6D15142%
D5
6A=5 (
4D51672
(
4D5167
!
% 67 504 8194
B1D0A= 86= 504 68847D42
(!(
(
B7: 17
=1;42 # =4F475167 68
=1E4
6 !' !
::15167B9
' #
1F19 )A:?4 B7:
B1D0A= 86= 504 68847D4 3A7120B;94 A7:4=
((!
(('
( (
=4B: C150
$B24: 67 504 =4?125=B5167 68 504 D=1E4
B7: 81917? 68 504 D0B=?4 20445 =42367:475
% 68 504
4D5167 ( # % #
D04:A94:
! !(% 67 504 8194 68
) &
6!
4D51672 (!
D04:A94:
%
4221672 )A:?4
3A7120B;94 A7:4=
'
#
7234D56=
691D4 =4D6EE47:4: 56 6347 B =6C:< 20445 B?B1725 504
-4-
345151674=
43A5<
04=417
$B24:
A34=17547:475 68
C01D0
691D4
=42367:475
6(
B1D0A= 6=:4=4: 86=
634717? A3 68 504 =6C:< 20445 C1506A5 122A17? 504 7651D4
=6C:< 20445 DBE4 56 ;4 63474: 17 504 7BE4 68
345151674= :B54:
'!
' ;< 4754=17? 012 7BE4 17 504
=4?1254=
(
5 12 D67547:4: ;< 94B=74: D6A7249 86= 504
345151674= 50B5 504 DB24 26 EB:4 6A5 ;< 504 =42367:4752 17
=1E4
6!
!
' B7: !' !
DBE4 56 ;4 BD@A1554: 67 !
B854= 5=1B9
04=486=4
'
!
504 345151674= 04=417
B7: 67 (
! !
15 12 D67547:4: 50B5 504=4 12 76
D=1E17B9 DB24 347:17? B2 B?B1725 504 345151674= 6= B7<
D6E39B175 =4?1254=4: B?B1725 504 345151674= ;486=4 504
3691D4 25B5167
6C:<
5 12 8A=504= D67547:4: 50B5 67 504 ;B212 68
3691D4 =42367:475
4?1254= EB175B174: ;< 504 =42367:475
0B2 ;447 8=4@A4759< 2AEE6717?
504 345151674= 56 504 3691D4 25B5167 B7: 6=:4=17? 01E 56 215
504 4751=4 :B< 17 504 3691D4 25B5167 C1506A5 504=4 ;417? B7<
D6E39B175 &
6= 4F47 B7 B994?B5167 B?B1725 504 345151674=
-5-
:423154 504 8BD5 50B5 04 12 765 =4@A1=4: 17 B7< DB24 86= B7<
17F4251?B5167 C0B5264F4=
04=486=4 345151674= 2A;E1554:
B =43=42475B5167 67
(
! !
56 =4F14C B7: =4E6F4 012
6C:<
4?1254=
7BE4 8=6E 504
$A5 =42367:475
6 ! 0B2 765 D6EEA71DB54: 6= 3B224: B7< 6=:4= 17 =4234D5
68 504 =43=42475B5167 26 2A;E1554:
5 12 D67547:4: 50B5 C047 504 345151674= EB:4
B7
B3391DB5167
6=
=43=42475B5167
=42367:475
BA506=15142 6A?05 56 0BF4 BDD4354: 504 =43=42475B5167 B7:
3=6F1:4: B7 6336=5A715< 56 504 345151674= 56 3A586=50 012
DB24 68 504=4 ;417? 76 B994?B5167 68 D=1E17B9 DB242 347:17?
B?B1725 01E B7: 50B5 17D9A2167 68 012 7BE4 B7: D67517A17?
012 7BE4 17 504
6C:<
4?1254= 12 F169B51F4 68 504
3=17D13942 68 7B5A=B9 HA251D4 17D9A:17? 012 34=267B9 91;4=5<
5 12 B926 D67547:4: 50B5 17 23154 68 504
345151674= ;417? BD@A1554: 17 504 5C6 DB242 50B5 C4=4 8194:
B?B1725 01E :A4 56 34=267B9 47E15< B7: :423154 504
=43=42475B5167 ;417? EB:4 504 345151674=/2 7BE4 12 765
25=AD> 688 8=6E 504 =4?1254= 68 =6C:142 504=4;< DBA217?
-6-
A7569: 0B=:2013 B7: F169B5167 68 012 8A7:BE475B9 =1?05 68
8=44 E6F4E475 B7: 012 91;4=5<
'
5 12 B926 D67547:4: ;< 504 94B=74: D6A7249 50B5
=42367:4752 0BF4 765 86996C4: 504 74D422B=< ?A1:491742
9B1: :6C7 ;< 5012
6A=5 17 504 DB24 68
=436=54: 17
04=486=4 04 D67547:2 50B5 1E391DB517? 504
345151674= B7: =4?1254=17? 012 7BE4 17 504 =6C:< 20445 12
1994?B9 B7: F169B51F4 68 3=17D13942 68 7B5A=B9 HA251D4 B7: 504
?A1:491742 122A4: 17 504 DB24 68
#2A3=B%
47D4 504 2BE4 =4@A1=42 56 ;4 =4E6F4: B7: D6724@A4759<
@AB204:
47D4 504 345151674= 12 34=86=D4: 56 B33=6BD0
6A=5 17F6>17? 504 C=15 HA=12:1D5167
94B=74:
:F6DB54 =43=4247517? =42367:475
:6A;5
345151674=
0B2
::15167B9
6F4=7E475
5B54 D67547:2 50B5 76
;447
BD@A1554:
B86=4E4751674: DB242 ;A5 504 7BE4 68 504 345151674= CB2
17D9A:4: 17 504
6C:<
4?1254= 3=16= 56 BD@A155B9 B7:
B926 @A425167 68 86996C17? 504 ?A1:491742 9B1: :6C7 ;< 504
-7-
6 6=:17B54 $47D0 68 5012
6A=5 17 504 DB24 68
#2A3=B% C6A9: 765 B=124 86= 504 =4B267 50B5
17D9A2167 68 504 7BE4 68 504 345151674= 17 504
4?1254= 12 3=16= 56 504 2B1: HA:?E475
C199 765 47A=4 56 012 ;474815
6C:<
47D4 504 2BE4
DD6=:17?9<
04 244>2 56
:12E122 504 34515167
0BF4 04B=: 94B=74: D6A7249 86= 504 345151674=
B7: 94B=74:
::15167B9
6F4=7E475
:F6DB54 86= 504
5B54
5 12 B 8A7:BE475B9 =A94 68 9BC 50B5 C047 B
34=267 12 1E391DB54: B2 B =6C:< 204454= ;< 17D9A:17? 012
7BE4 17 504 9125 68 =6C:< 20445 504 67A2 12 A367 504
5B54
56 86996C 504 :A4 3=6D4:A=4 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 504
=494FB75 =A942 B7: =4?A9B51672
B=7B5B>B
691D4
7 504 3=42475 DB24 504
B7AB9 E6=4 234D181DB99< 504
6C:142 EB175B174: 17 6=:4=
4?1254= 68
C01D0 :4B92 C150
01256=< 204452 B7: =6C:< 204452 B7: 47=699E475 6=
=4?125=B5167 68 34=2672 17 504 2B1: 20445 86= =4?1254= 86=
D67517A6A2 E67156=17? ;< 504 3691D4 BA506=15142
86996C4:
5B7:17?
=:4=
12 765
:4B92 C150 =4?125=B5167
-8-
68 =6C:142
04 :481715167 3=6F1:4: 12 50B5 B =6C:< EB< ;4
:48174: B2 B ?A7:B B7: 17D9A:42 B 06691?B7
56A?0
FB?B;67: 6= B7< 34=267 C06 12 :B7?4=6A2 56 3A;91D 34BD4
B7: 5=B7@A1915<
04=4 B=4 EB7< 86=E2 68 =6C:12E C01D0
B=4 :42D=1;4: 504=417 B7: 504 3=6D422 B7: 3=6D4:A=4
D6754E39B54: 56 ;4 EB175B174: 17 :1884=475 3B=52 7BE49<
B=5
B=5 $ B7:
B=5
C01D0 ?6F4=7 504 EB17547B7D4
68 B =4?1254= B7: 504 7BE42 68 504 =6C:142 17 5041=
=4234D51F4 3B=52
5 12 504 :A5< B7: 6;91?B5167 DB25 A367
504 =42367:4752 C01D0 12 765 635167B9 56 86996C 504 :A4
3=6D4:A=4 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 504 25B7:17? 6=:4=2 68 504
B=7B5B>B
34=267
691D4
B7AB9
=6C:<
C0194 4754=17? 504 7BE4 68 B
20445
B7:
504=4
B=4
D4=5B17
3=6D4:A=42 56 ;4 EB7:B56=19< 86996C4: ;486=4 4754=17? 504
7BE42
2 D67547:4: ;< 94B=74: D6A7249 86= 504 345151674=
504 3=6D422 B7: 3=6D4:A=4 B2 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 504
25B7:17?
=:4=
68 504
B=7B5B>B
691D4
B7AB9
0B2 765 ;447 86996C4: B7: 76 6336=5A715< CB2 ?1F47 56 504
345151674= 56 8194 012 =439< 6= 4G39B7B5167 86= =4E6F17? 012
-9-
7BE4 17 504
6C:<
4?1254= B7: E4=49< ;4DBA24 04
CB2 17F69F4: 17 D=1E17B9 DB242 17 C01D0 B926 504 345151674=
0B2 ;447 BD@A1554: 17 504 <4B= !
D67547:4:
50B5
506A?0
B7: ! !
345151674=
0B2
5 12 B926
EB:4
B
=43=42475B5167 56 504 =42367:475 BA506=15142 B854= 504
BD@A155B9 67
(
! !
504 =43=42475B5167 0B2 765 ;447
D6721:4=4: B7: 4F47 B854= 504 BD@A155B9
2AEE674:
HA=12:1D5167B9
04 0B2 ;447
3691D4
25B5167
86=
A774D422B=< 1754==6?B5167 C047 504=4 12 76 DB24 347:17?
B?B1725 01E
5 C6A9: ;4 =494FB75 56 4G5=BD5 3B=B?=B30
68 504 HA:?E475 68
1F12167 $47D0 68 5012
!"
=436=54: 17 #$
%&&
6A=5 17 504 DB24
"
'
(
C04=417 504
1F12167
$47D0 :4B95 C150 21E19B= 2A;H4D5 EB554= C01D0 =4B:2 B2
A7:4=
- 10 -
!
"
#
#
%
&'(
$
#
)
$
%
)
#
* )
$
&'(
#
+
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
#
)
)
)
)
,
)
#
-
I
5B7:17?
B7AB9
=:4=
B=7B5B>B
691D4
12 4G5=BD54: ;496C
&'( . / 0
#
)
)
.2/
3+
/
!
,
/ 6
#
)
)
#
/
)
,
- 11 -
/
!
)
)
+
)
+
)
))
/*
,
,
/
,
/
.7/ 6
#
#9
)
;
%
:
.</ . / %
&&
)
#
)
)
)
. / %
)
8"
)
=
:
)
#
. / %
)
>% #
)
>
+
.'/
$
+* #
)
$
#
.?/ %
)
!
)
:
)
. / @
)
#
- 12 -
)
#
)
$
.A/
#
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
*
)
)
.(/ $
"
*
#
)
#
#
:
)
)
"
)
*
* $
#
#
. &/
)
#
)
#
#
.
)
/ @
)
#
+
$
!
8:8
)
)
$
!
- 13 -
. 2/ @
+
8:8
@
)
!
$
. 7/ %
8:8
)
!
)
)
)
+* #
. </
$
)
+
)
)
)
. '/ B
!
)
C
./
)
!
#
. /
))
)
2(<
4 .
/,
. /
#
!
(2 . / .)/ .1/
(?7
. /
#
D
C
!
) #
- 14 -
. #/ 0
&A . /
,
.#/ 0
& 4
.# / 0
&4
.# / 0
,
)
# / EC
'?
#
#
)
''
D
!
. C/ 0
(?7,
'&( 6
# +
. ?/ E#
)
E
"
:
)
)
#
+
)
+ +
#
)
)
!
)
+
.
/ @
#
$
)
)
"
#
#
. A/
)
&?
)
3+
/
%
2/ %
7/ 5
)
)
)
- 15 -
</ %
)
'/
?/ $
F
/%
A/
!
. (/ 6
)
)
#
)
)
#
!
!
)
-
6 6=:17B54 $47D0 68 5012
6A=5 17 504 DB24
#2A3=B% 0B2 9B1: :6C7 ?A1:491742
C01D0 B=4 56 ;4 86996C4: C0194 =4?1254=17? 504 7BE4 68 B
34=267 17 504
6C:<
4?1254= C01D0 4F47 3=16= 56
504 2B1: HA:?E475 CB2 B EB7:B54 86= 504 =42367:4752 56
0BF4 86996C4: 25=1D59< 17 BDD6=:B7D4 56 504 25B7:17? 6=:4=
68 504
B=7B5B>B
691D4
B7AB9
C01D0 17 E<
6317167 D6721:4=17? 504 8BD52 B7: D1=DAE25B7D4 68 504
3=42475 DB24 0B2 765 ;447 86996C4: B7: 4F47 B854= 504
BD@A155B9 68 504 345151674= 17 504 5C6 DB242
C01D0
DA9E17B54: 17 BD@A155B9 B854= :45B194: 5=1B9 B7: 4F47 B854=
- 16 -
504 =43=42475B5167 ?1F47 ;< 504 345151674= 86= =4E6F17? 012
7BE4 8=6E 504
6C:<
4?1254=
504=4 12 76
=4236724 6= =439< 6= BD5167 ;< 504 =42367:4752 17
=4E6F17? 012 7BE4
(
7 F14C 68 767 D6E391B7D4 68 504 3=6D4:A=4
D6754E39B54:
B=7B5B>B
A7:4=
691D4
25B7:17?
6=:4=
B7AB9 B7: 767 D6721:4=B5167 68 504
=43=42475B5167 ?1F47 ;< 504 345151674= 3A=2AB75 56 012
BD@A155B9 5012
6A=5 12 68 504 6317167 50B5 504 345151674=
0B2 EB:4 6A5 B FB91: DB24 56 D6721:4= 8BF6A=B;9<
DD6=:17?9<
3B22 504 86996C17?
04 C=15 34515167 12
04 1E3A?74: 6=:4= 68 634717?
6C:<
4?1254= 17 504 7BE4 68 504 345151674=
;4B=17?
'!
))
6(
'
EB175B174:
12 04=4;< @AB204:
*
!
' :B54:
;<
=42367:475
- 17 -
04 =42367:4752 B=4 04=4;< :1=4D54: 56
=4E6F4 504 7BE4 68 504 345151674= 8=6E 504
6C:<
4?1254= EB175B174: ;< 504E
C15017 B 34=16: 68 86A= C44>2 8=6E 504 :B54
68 =4D4135 68 D4=51814: D63< 68 504 6=:4=
1F
1;4=5<
06C4F4=
=42367:475
=424=F4:
5B54 56 3=6D44: 17 BDD6=:B7D4
C150 9BC B?B1725 504 345151674= 18 B5 B99 B7<
DB24 12 EB:4 6A5 B7: C0194 :617? 26 504<
20B99 25=1D59< 86996C 504 ?A1:491742 9B1: :6C7
;< 5012
6A=5 17 504 DB24 68
=436=54: 17
(
J
!*+
!
$
#
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review