Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 12.03.2026
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
CT/GD PRAJAKTA WAKCHAURE
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Shreevardhan Dhoot and Mr.
Amrit Rathi, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Chetanya Puri, SPC, Ms. Archana
Kumari and Mr. Rishab Jain, Advs.
and Mr. Tanveer Ahmed, DC, CISF.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant civil writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India impugning the order dated 24.09.2022 passed by the
Physical Efficiency Test [‘PET’] Board1, whereby the Petitioner was
declared as “Failed in 100 mtrs. race” for recruitment to the post of Assistant
Sub Inspector (Executive) through Limited Departmental Competitive
Examination [‘LDCE’], 2020 in Central Industrial Security Force [‘CISF’].
2.
The Petitioner was appointed in CISF on 14.04.2012. She applied and
appeared for the post of Assistant Sub Inspector (Executive) in CISF
RTC Arakkonam, P.O. Suraksha Campus, Dist. Vellore, Tamil Nadu.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
through LDCE in furtherance of notification dated 31.12.2020. She duly
appeared and successfully cleared the stages (I) to (III) i.e., checking of
service records, written examination and physical standard test. The
Petitioner duly appeared for the Stage IV i.e., the PET on 24.09.2022 at
Principal-CISF RTC Arakkonam, Suraksha Campur, Dist. Vellore, Tamil
Nadu. This stage consists of four sub-stages: 800 mtrs. race in 4 minutes,
100 mtrs. race in 18 seconds, 3 feet (High Jump) in 3 chances, and 9 feet
(Long Jump) in 3 chances.
3.
The Petitioner qualified in the 800 mtrs. race, however, in the 100
mtrs. race, the Petitioner was declared unsuccessful on the ground that she
did not complete the 100 mtrs race in the stipulated time of 18 seconds.
4.
It is the case of the Petitioner that she was not informed about the
timing clocked-in at the 100 mtrs race nor was she provided any
videographic proof when she enquired for the same.
It is stated that when Petitioner ran the 100 mtrs race, she was initially
declared as ‘pass’ by the person in-charge however, for reasons not
explained to her, she was subsequently declared as ‘failed’. The Petitioner
also filed an appeal immediately on 24.09.2022 against the proceedings held
on 24.09.2022.
5.
It is the stand of the Petitioner that the selection process undertaken
on 24.09.2022 was not transparent and the Petitioner and other
participants/candidates were not disclosed the timing clocked by them at the
race.
6.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner relies upon the order passed by the
Division Bench in W.P. (C) 1617/2023 titled as ‘CT/GD Suman Yadav v.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
Union of India’, in the case of another constable, who had also participated
in the Stage IV PET on 24.09.2022 and had raised similar contentions of
lack of transparency which found favour with the Court; and the respondents
were directed to conduct a retest of the petitioner therein i.e., Suman Yadav.
6.1
He relies upon the said judgment and submits that similarly the
Petitioner herein should also be given an opportunity to have a re-test of the
100 mtrs. race and her application/candidature be proceeded with for further
assessments.
6.2
He states that the Petitioner is entitled to only three attempts to secure
a promotion through LCDE and this is her last permissible attempt or else
she will have to wait for 15 to 20 years to attain promotion in natural course
of events.
6.3
He has drawn the Court’s attention to the check-sheet for the PET
conducted on 24.09.2022, which is filed as a part of Annexure R-6 with the
Counter Affidavit.
7.
This Court has enquired from the Respondents with respect to the
timing clocked in by the Petitioner for the 100 mtrs. race on 24.09.2022.
8.
Learned counsel for Respondents state that no data has been
maintained with respect to the timing clocked in by the participants in the
race including the Petitioner and the sheet merely records (√) mark for the
candidate which qualified, and (X) mark for the candidate which did not
qualify.
8.1
He states that the race was videographed on 24.09.2022, however, he
submits that the videography of the race of 100 mtrs. has been corrupted and
is now unavailable. He states that in these circumstances Respondent is
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
unable to state before this Court the specific time clocked in by the
Petitioner.
8.2
He states that the recruitment process in pursuance to the LDCE-2020
has been completed. He states that the unfulfilled vacancies of the
recruitment year 2020 has been converted to promotion quota as per the
Recruitment Rules, 2018 and thus no vacancy remains available for the
recruitment year 2020.
9.
We have considered the submissions made by the parties.
10.
This Court notes that the impugned result declaring the Petitioner as
“Failed in 100 mtrs. race” was issued on 24.09.2022. The record shows that
the Petitioner promptly preferred an appeal on 24.09.2022 itself challenging
the said result. The filing of the appeal immediately after declaration of the
result demonstrates that the Petitioner had, at the earliest opportunity, raised
a grievance disputing the correctness and fairness of the result recorded
against her.
11.
This Court has also perused the check-sheet placed on record by the
Respondents as part of Annexure R-6. A perusal of the said document
indicates visible overwriting in the cell corresponding to the result of the
Petitioner in the 100 mtrs. race. The existence of such overwriting lends
some credence to the submission of the Petitioner that she was initially
informed that she had qualified the race and was subsequently declared as
“failed”. The Respondents have not offered any satisfactory explanation for
the said alteration.
12.
More importantly, when queried by this Court regarding the exact
time clocked by the Petitioner in the 100 mtrs. race, learned counsel for the
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
Respondents fairly submits that no contemporaneous record of the precise
timing clocked by each participant has been maintained. It is further stated
that the videography of the said 100 mtrs race is not available on account of
corruption of the recording. Consequently, the Respondents are unable to
place before this Court any objective material to substantiate the
conclusion/result that the Petitioner failed to complete the race within the
stipulated time of 18 seconds.
13.
In
the
aforesaid
circumstances,
particularly
where
(i)
the
contemporaneous record reflects overwriting, (ii) no record of the actual
timing clocked by the Petitioner at 100 mtrs race has been maintained, and
(iii) the videographic record of the race is unavailable, this Court is of the
considered view that the Respondents have been unable to satisfactorily
substantiate the declaration of the Petitioner as “failed”. In such peculiar
facts, the interest of fairness in a recruitment process warrants that the
Petitioner be afforded a limited opportunity of a re-test.
14.
At the same time, this Court takes note of the submission of the
Respondents that the recruitment process pursuant to LDCE-2020 has
already been concluded and that the vacancies of the said recruitment year
are no longer available.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner, on instructions, submits that the
Petitioner would be satisfied if she is permitted to undertake a re-test and, if
found successful in Stage- IV, be considered for the next LDCE recruitment
cycle for the post of ASI (Executive), and that she shall not claim any
seniority or other benefits with reference to LDCE-2020. The said
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
undertaking is taken on record, and the Petitioner shall remain bound by the
same.
15.
Accordingly, the Respondents are directed to conduct a re-test of the
Petitioner in the 100 mtrs. race forming part of the PET. In the event the
Petitioner successfully qualifies the said race within the prescribed time, she
shall be permitted to undertake the remaining components of the PET,
namely the High Jump and Long Jump of Stage-IV, in accordance with the
applicable standards.
In order to ensure transparency, it is directed that the re-test of the
Petitioner in the 100 mtrs. race shall be videographed, and the exact time
clocked by the Petitioner shall be recorded and preserved by the
Respondents. The video recording and relevant data shall be retained by the
Respondents for a minimum period of three months from the date of the test.
16.
The aforesaid re-test shall be conducted within a period of four weeks
from the date of this order. In the event the Petitioner qualifies the PET, i.e.,
Stage-IV, the Respondents shall proceed with her candidature further in
accordance with law and consider the Petitioner for selection to the post of
Assistant Sub Inspector (Executive) in the next LDCE recruitment cycle,
subject to fulfilment of all other eligibility requirements. It is clarified that
the Petitioner will not have to go through Stage-I, Stage-II and Stage-II tests
again.
It is also directed that the Petitioner will not be entitled to claim any
seniority or other benefits with reference to LDCE-2020.
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
17.
Needless to state that if the Petitioner is aggrieved by any subsequent
action taken by the Respondents, it shall be open to her to avail such
remedies as may be available in law.
18.
Having perused the judgment of this Court in W.P.(C) 1617/2023 and
the facts in this petition, this Court considers it appropriate to observe that
the prevalent practice of merely marking candidates as “pass” or “fail”
without maintaining any contemporaneous record of the actual time clocked
by each candidate in a timed event is liable to raise concerns regarding
transparency in the selection process. The Respondents would therefore be
well advised to consider adopting a system whereby the exact timing
clocked by each candidate is recorded and preserved, along with proper
videographic documentation of the event.
19.
Accordingly, the petition stands disposed of. Pending applications, if
any, disposed of. No costs.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MARCH 12, 2026/AM
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
11:48
W.P.(C) 16178/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review