The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Since the involvement of the State Governments and the Union Territories is critical to child rights and the effective implementation of the JJ Act, it would be appropriate if each High Court and the Juvenile Justice Committee of each High Court continues its proactive role in the welfare of children in their State. To make the involvement and process more meaningful, we request the Chief Justice of every High Court to register proceedings on its own motion for the effective implementation of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 so that road-blocks if any, encountered by statutory authorities and the juvenile Justice Committee of the High Court are meaningfully addressed after hearing the concerned governmental authorities. A copy of this judgment and order should be sent by the Secretary General of this Court to the Registrar General of each High Court for being placed before the Chief Justice of every High Court for initiating suo motu proceedings.” PIL No.7 of 2018. Page 4 Pursuance to the said order, notice has been served to the respondent department and according to the respondent department, under Rule 83(4) of the Care and Protection of Children Model Rules, 2016 where the State Government shall create a fund for delivering Juvenile Justice fund for every child and the Juvenile Justice fund may utilize by the State Government under Rule 83(4)…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
JOHN TELEN Digitally
JOHN TELEN KOM
Date: 2024.12.09
KOM
08:43:10 +05'30'
Item No.33(DB)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
PIL No. 7 of 2018
Court on its own motion
.…Petitioner
– Versus –
The State of Manipur through the Chief Secretary & 7 Ors.
…. Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. A. Romenkumar, Amicus Curiae.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl.AG assisted
by Ms. Jyotsana Devi & Adv KH. Tarunkumar, Sr. Adv.
JUDGEMENT&ORDER
(ORAL)
04.12.2024
D. Krishnakumar, C.J. :
This Suo Moto PIL has been taken up by this Court and during the
course of arguments, the Amicus Curiae, appointed by this Court, has clearly
stated before this Court that the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 1
09.02.2018 passed in WP(C)No.473 of 2005 have been complied with except for
the direction No. 13 and the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme is incorporated
as under:
“1. The Ministry of Women and Child Development in the Government of India
and the State Governments should ensure that all positions in the NCPCR and
the SCPRs are filled up well in time and adequate staff is provided to these
statutory bodies so that they can function effectively and meaningfully for the
benefit of the children.
2. The NCPCR and the SCPCRs should take their duties, functions and
responsibilities with great earnestness keeping in mind the faith reposed in
them by Parliament. A position in these statutory institutions is not a sinecure.
These bodies have a very significant and proactive role to play in improving
the lives of children across the country.
3. The State level Child Protection Societies and the District level Child
Protection Units have an enormous responsibility in ensuring that the JJ Act is
effectively implemented and Child Care Institutions are managed and
maintained in a manner that is conducive to the well-being of children in all
respects including nutrition, education, medical benefits, skill development
and general living conditions. These two bodies would be well advised to take
the assistance of NGOs and civil society to ensure that the JJ Act serves the
purpose for which it is enacted by Parliament.
4. The State Governments must ensure that all positions in the JJBs and CWCs
are filled up expeditiously and in accordance with the Model Rules or the Rules
framed by the State Government. Any delay in filling up the positions might
adversely impact on children and this should be avoided.
5. The JJBs and CWCs must appreciate that it is necessary to have sittings on
a regular basis so that a minimal number of inquiries are pending at any given
point of time and justice is given to all juveniles in conflict with law and social
justice to children in need of care and protection. This is a constitutional
obligation.
6. The NCPCR and the SCPCRs must carry out time-bound studies on various
issues, as deemed appropriate, under the JJ Act, Based on these studies, the
State Governments and the Union Territories must take remedial steps.
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 2
7. In particular the NCPCR and the SCPCRs must carry out a study for
estimating the number of Probation Officers required for the effective
implementation of the JJ Act. Based on this study, the State Government must
appoint the necessary number of Probation Officers. It must be emphasized
that the role of a Probation Officer is critical for the rehabilitation and social
reintegration of a juvenile in conflict with law and due importance must be
given to their duties as postulated in the Model Rules and Rules, if any, framed
by the State Governments and the Union Territories.
8. The MWCD must continue to make creative use of information and
communication technology not only for the purpose of collecting data and
information but also for other issues connected with the JJ Act such as having
a database of missing children, trafficked children and for follow up of adoption
cases etc. With the utilization of technology to the fullest extent, administrative
efficiency will improve considerably, which in turn will have a positive impact
on the lives of children.
9. It is important for the police to appreciate their role as the first responder
on issues pertaining to offences allegedly committed by children as well as
offences committed against children. There is therefore a need to set up
meaningful Special Juvenile Police Units and appoint Child Welfare Police
Officers in terms of the JJ Act at the earliest and not only on paper. In this
context, it is necessary to clearly identify the duties and responsibilities of such
Units and Officers and wherever necessary, guidance from the available
expertise, either the National Police Academy or the Bureau of Police Research
and Development or NGOs must be taken for the benefit of children.
10. The National Police Academy and State Police Academies must consider
including child rights as a part of their curriculum on a regular basis and not
as an isolated or sporadic event.
11. The management of Child Care Institutions is extremely important and
State Governments and Union Territories would be well advised to ensure that
all such institutions are registered so that children can live a dignified life in
these Institutions and issues of missing children and trafficking are also
addressed.
12. State Governments and Union Territories would be well advised to appoint
eminent persons from civil society as Visitors to monitor and supervise the
Child Care Institutions in all the districts. This will ensure that the management
and maintenance of these Institutions are addressed. We have no doubt that
the State Legal Service Authorities and the District Legal Service Authorities
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 3
will extend full assistance and cooperation to the government authorities in
this venture as well as to the Visitors.
13. The JJ Fund is a bit of an embarrassment with an absence of an effective
response from the State Governments and the Union Territories. If financial
resources are not made available for the welfare of the children we shudder
to think what could be better utilization of the funds.
14. NALSA has done a remarkable job in collecting data and information
relating to the JJ Act, as evidenced by the three part Report prepared by it.
We request NALSA to carry forward the exercise and complete a similar Report
preferably before 30th April, 2018 to assist all the policy making and decision
taking authorities to plan out their affairs.
15. The importance of training cannot be over-emphasized. It is vital for
understanding and appreciating child rights and for the effective
implementation of the JJ Act. All authorities such as JJBs and CWCs, Probation
Officers, members of the Child Protection Societies and District Child
Protection Units, Special Juvenile Police Units, Child Welfare Police Officers
and managerial staff of Child Care Institutions must be sensitized and given
adequate training relating to their position. A very positive step has been taken
in this regard by NALSA and we expect the NCPCR with the assistance of the
SCPCRs to carry forward this initiative so that there is meaningful
implementation of the JJ Act.
16. Since the involvement of the State Governments and the Union Territories
is critical to child rights and the effective implementation of the JJ Act, it would
be appropriate if each High Court and the Juvenile Justice Committee of each
High Court continues its proactive role in the welfare of children in their State.
To make the involvement and process more meaningful, we request the Chief
Justice of every High Court to register proceedings on its own motion for the
effective implementation of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of
Children) Act, 2015 so that road-blocks if any, encountered by statutory
authorities and the juvenile Justice Committee of the High Court are
meaningfully addressed after hearing the concerned governmental authorities.
A copy of this judgment and order should be sent by the Secretary General of
this Court to the Registrar General of each High Court for being placed before
the Chief Justice of every High Court for initiating suo motu proceedings.”
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 4
Pursuance to the said order, notice has been served to the
respondent department and according to the respondent department, under
Rule 83(4) of the Care and Protection of Children Model Rules, 2016 where the
State Government shall create a fund for delivering Juvenile Justice fund for
every child and the Juvenile Justice fund may utilize by the State Government
under Rule 83(4) of the Care and Protection of Children Model Rules, 2016.
Learned Amicus Curiae, Mr. A. Romenkumar has pointed out to this
Court that the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in respect of utilization of
the fund allocated under the category of Juvenile Justice’s fund can be utilized
for the particular category as allocated by the Government and it cannot be
diverted to any other departments.
Further, the Amicus Curiae also suggested before this Court that this
Court may passed appropriate order for utilizing the fund only for the purpose
of sanction required under the said category and the amount allocated thereof
shall be utilized under Rule 83(4) Juvenile Justice Rules, 2016 and this would
help proper control and transparent utilization of the fund and prevent any
diversion of the said fund.
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 5
The respondent No.2 has filed additional affidavit dated 01.07.2024 and
in the para 3, it is stated as follows:
“3. That, the answering deponent beg to submit that as per the Directorate
letter dated 7th March, 2024, the Department had already earmarked budget
for the FY 2024-25 and a sum of Rs. 30 lakh has been allocated under the
following Head of Account:
Major Head - 2235- Social Security & Welfare
Sub-Major – 02-Social Welfare
Minor – 106-Correction Services
Sub-Head – 04-Juvenile Justice Fund
Detailed – 00
Object – 49-Other Revenue Expenditure
As such, the aforementioned allocated amount can and shall be used solely
for implementation of all the 17 purposes elaborated in Rule 83(4) of the Model
JJ Rule, 2016 in letter and spirit and nothing else. This is done by sending
financial proposal citing reason [any one or more purposes amongst the 17
purposes under Rule 83(4) of the Model JJ Rule, 2016] for the need of
encashment of fund in the Sub-Head (04- Juvenile justice Fund) to the Finance
Department and thereafter, only when it is approved, the requested amount
is sanctioned. Hence, there is no possibility of the aforementioned allocated
amount to be used for some other provision other than for the purposes
elaborated under Rule 83 (4) of the Model Juvenile Justice Rule, 2016.
Further, the answering deponent humbly beg to submit that with regard to
mapping up to different object heads separately as suggested by the learned
Amicus Curiae vide Hon’ble High Court order dated 13th February, 2024, after
careful deliberation and discussion with the Finance Department, it is found
that mapping up of different object heads separately may prove to be
detrimental as opposed to it being beneficial. Once the Sub-Head 04 Juvenile
Justice Fund is sub divided into different object heads, the fund allocated in
each object head becomes non-transferrable (amongst various object heads
i.e. purposes). Such fund may go un-utilized in a particular Financial Year and
may lapse while on the other hand, there might arise a need to allocate
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 6
additional fund for a purpose mentioned in some other object head, thereby
causing non-availability of resources/fund to meet contingencies. It is not
possible to asses which of the seventeen purposes listed under Rule 83(4) will
require more fund during a financial year as it is not possible to predict the
number of children to be assisted. For instance, if we create a separate object
head under “Domestic Travel expenses” and earmark a budgetary provision
of Rs.1.00 lakh, we might require much more than Rs.1.00 lakh if some
children are to be transported from some other state during a particular
financial year. On the other hand, we may utilize even less than Rs.10,000/in a year if there are very few cases of children requiring travel/transportation.
Thus, keeping the Juvenile Justice Fund in the common pool (one Sub-Head
with the same Object Head-49) has more advantage over creating various
object-heads. However, the Department may earmark certain fund internally
to each of the 17 purposes, except for those which have already been taken
care of by other schemes. An indicative allocation submitted by the Director
(Social Welfare), Manipur is shown at Annexure M/1 for better appreciation of
the Hon’ble Court.”
In view of the above additional affidavit, Mr. M. Devananda, learned
Addl. AG stated that the apprehension of the learned Amicus Curiae may not be
appreciated and the said affidavit clearly stated that the said fund will be utilized
only for the purpose of the particular category which has been sanctioned by the
State Government and if any excess amount are available, the said amount will
be utilized to the other category as per Rule 83(4) of Model JJ Rules, 2016.
In view of the aforesaid statements made by respondent No.2 by
way of filing additional affidavit as well as the submissions made by the
Additional Advocate General, this Suo Moto PIL stands closed.
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 7
We are also appreciating the learned Amicus Curiae, Mr. A.
Romenkumar who has been rendering his valuable assistance to the Court in
disposing the aforesaid PIL and has given various suggestions to this Court by
supplying the provisions of the JJ Act and the directions passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
John Kom
PIL No.7 of 2018.
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review