Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (PIL) No. 5065 of 2025
Court on its Own Motion
Versus
1. State of Jharkhand through its Chief Secretary, Govt. of Jharkhand,
Ranchi
2. Principal Secretary, Department of Road Construction, Ranchi
3. The Union of India through its General Manager, South Eastern
Railway, Kolkata
4. DRM, Ranchi Division, South Eastern Railway, Ranchi
...
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the State:
Mr Vibhor Mayank, A.C. to A.G.
For the UOI:
Mr Prashant Pallav, ASGI
--------12/Dated: 09.07.2026
1.
Heard Mr Vibhor Mayank, learned A.C. to A.G. appearing for the
State, and Mr Prashant Pallav, learned Senior Advocate and the
learned A.S.G.I. appearing for the Union of India (Railways).
2.
This matter was registered as a suo motu Public Interest Litigation,
consequent upon a receipt of a letter from Dr Devendra Mahato on
4th September 2025, which reads as follows:“To,
Date: 04-Sept-25
The Chief Justice of High Court
Ranchi, Jharkhand.
Sub: Regarding the road condition in your recent visit to Jonha
Water Fall
Respected Sir,
While returning from Jonha Water Fall to Ranchi, the
condition of connecting road from water fall located in Village
Koynardih to Jonha Fall Road is very miserable.
This is the only approaching road which connects villagers to
Jonha Bazar, School, Hospital and Ranchi Town. Almost more
than 15 villages and 20 thousand people getting affected due to
poor condition of road. Tourism also getting affected due to
such poor road condition.
This road has to start from Jonha Fall Road (near Gautam
Dhara Station underpass) and approx.. 1 KM area comes
under railway authority and they also not allowing
construction the road whereas on other side railway has made
underpass and road at his own land for public.
Villagers met with MP/MLA and our MP/MLA further
forwarded letter to REO, PWD and also sent letters to Forest
and Railway department but no action taken for more than 15
years. Because of such frustration few Villagers has boycotted
the last parliament election.
Considering the situation of poor villagers and struggling in
their day-to-day activities without the road, we are requesting
you to take suo motu cognizance for the development of this
area.
We would be highly obliged, if you could help us.
Thanking you,
Sincerely Yours
Dr. Devendra Mahato”
3.
During the hearing, it transpired that the State authorities were
willing to undertake the work of widening of the existing kutcha
road from 5 meters to 8 meters and further, to convert this kutcha
road into a metal paved road.
4.
However, the learned Advocate General and other Advocates who
appeared on behalf of the State stated that no objection certificate
from the Railways would be necessary to undertake the above
works. Accordingly, Mr Prashant Pallav, learned A.S.G.I., who
appears in this matter on behalf of the Union of India (Railway
authorities), stated that the Railway authorities would consider
issuing a no-objection certificate for road-strengthening works
from Masrijara to Heslabeda, which was the subject matter of this
suo motu public interest litigation.
5.
From time to time, several orders were issued regarding joint
inspection, layout preparation, surveys, etc.
6.
Finally, we were informed that the proposal for the grant of NOC
by the Railways was at an advanced stage and that a decision
would be taken in the matter shortly.
7.
Today, we are happy to note that Mr Prashant Pallav, learned
A.S.G.I., has handed over the communication dated 01.07.2026
addressed
to
him
by
the
Divisional
Railway
Manager
(Engineering) / RNC, South Eastern Railways. A copy of this
communication is taken on record and marked as “X” for
identification.
8.
The above communication reads as follows:“South Eastern Railway
Office of the
Divl. Railway Manager (Engg.)/RNC
Dtd. 01.07.2026
No.L/12/Court case/2026
To,
Shri Prashant Pallav
Assistant Solicitor General of India
Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi
Mob. No.-9470307609
Sub:- Issuance of No Objection Certificate (NOC)
for road strengthening works from Masrijara
to Heslabeda W.P.(PIL) No. 5065/2025 before
the Hon'ble High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi.
Sir,
With reference to the subject cited above, it is submitted that
the proposal for issuance of a No Objection Certificate (NOC)
for road strengthening works from Masrijara to Heslabeda
over 1.887 Km of Railway Land under Ranchi Division has
been approved by the Competent Authority in compliance with
the directions of Hon'ble High Court of Jharkhand in its order
dated 26.02.2026 and 09.04.2026, while duly safeguarding the
operational, safety and ownership interests of the Railways.
As stipulated under point no.5 of the order dated 26.02.2026,
"it is agreed that the road shall, as far as possible, be adjacent
to the Railway land boundary (within the Railway property)",
the proposal has accordingly been processed and approved by
the competent authority in conformity with the aforesaid
direction. It is further submitted that the State Government
shall be required to provide the remaining 3.0 meters of
additional land so that the road width may be increased to the
minimum required width of 8.0 meters.
The proposal was approved by the Principal Financial Advisor
(PFA) vide Note# 79 and subsequently by the Principal Chief
Engineer(PCE) vide Note# 80 on 24.06.2026 with the following
remarks: "Approved in the light of Hon'ble High Court RNC
directions. Please take necessary action protecting all rights of
Railways". The approval has been accorded subject to the
following conditions:
1.
The provisions
of
Railway
Board's letter No.
2012/LM(PA)/03/08/Policy dated 21.10.2015 and other
extant instructions/guidelines issued by the competent
authority may be complied with.
2.
The work to be executed at the cost of the State
Government/Local Authority without any financial
liability to Railways.
3.
Issuance of NOC may not confer any right, title,
ownership, easement or permanent claim over Railway
land and shall remain subject to Railway requirements.
4.
The executing agency may obtain all requisite statutory
clearances/permissions
and
execute
necessary
safeguard before commencement of the work.
5.
It may be ensured that the proposed work does not
affect Railway land, assets, drainage, utility services,
signaling and telecommunication installations, or
safety of train operations.
6.
Compliance
with
all
stipulated
conditions
and
applicable Railway guidelines may be ensured by the
concerned Railway authorities before commencement
of the work.
In view of the above, you are requested to kindly place the
enclosed approval of the competent authority before the
Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi, in connection with
W.P.(PIL) No. 5065 of 2025. The matter is presently listed for
hearing on 09.07.2026
This is submitted for your kind information and necessary
action.
Encl: Copy of approval/note sheet of the competent authority
and sketch plan referred to in the proposal.
Sd/Div. Engineer ( East)/Ranchi
Copy to :-1. PS to DRM/RNC for kind information to DRM/RNC
please.
2. Sr. DEN(Co)/RNC for kind information please
Law Officer/SER/RNC for kind information and necessary
action please
Sd/Div. Engineer ( East)/Ranchi”
9.
A copy of the communication dated 01.07.2026 has been handed
over to Mr Vibhor Mayank, the learned A.C. to A.G.
10. The learned A.S.G.I. and Mr Vibhor Mayank agree that this
communication now constitutes the N.O.C. on behalf of the South
Eastern Railways, authorising the State Government to proceed
with the works of road strengthening, widening and metal paving
of the road in question. We also direct that the above
communication constitutes the requisite N.O.C. for the State
Government to proceed with the works of road strengthening,
widening and metal paving of the road in question.
11. In our order dated 09.04.2026, we had recorded the statement of
the learned Advocate General that no sooner the Railways
authorities give their N.O.C., the State will undertake the work of
road widening the existing kutcha road from 5 meters to 8 meters,
and further this kutcha road would be converted into a metal paved
road. This statement was accepted and is hereby accepted. By the
same order dated 09.04.2026, we also directed the State
Government to indicate a timeline for the completion of the above
road works.
12. Though no affidavit has been filed and Mr Mayank states that
instructions would be obtained from the Secretary, we think that
more than ample time has been spent on this project, and the State
Government, to date, has not provided a timeline for the
completion of the construction/strengthening works.
13. Earlier, the State Government had indicated that it is more than
willing to undertake these works, but it was unable to proceed for
want of an N.O.C. from the Railways. Now that the N.O.C. from
the Railways is in place, we direct the State to forthwith undertake
the above works and to complete them as expeditiously as
possible, and in any event within six months from today, without
giving any usual excuses or seeking extensions. This timeline is
more than sufficient for completing the works, as they pertain only
to a stretch of approximately 1.887 kms.
14. None of the parties disputed the necessity of the above works. The
miserable state of the road as at present was not disputed. The fact
that such a road serves almost 15 villages and a population of
about 20,000 was also not seriously disputed. In addition, locals
and tourists visiting the Johna waterfalls have difficulty accessing
this road.
15. The villagers who addressed a letter to this Court complained that
their day-to-day activities are adversely affected by the miserable
condition of this road, which is a lifeline to their villages. The
letter also refers to the villagers' efforts to persuade the Authorities
to look into and redress their genuine grievance.
16. The only difficulty expressed by the State Government was the
lack of an N.O.C. from the Railway authorities. That difficulty no
longer exists, and therefore there is no reason to delay the
commencement and completion of the works any further.
Accordingly, we direct the State Government to commence and
conclude the works within six months from today.
17.Since the learned Advocate General has made a statement on behalf
of the State of Jharkhand, we do not think that it is necessary to
remind the State Government that such statement binds the State
Government. All this while, the only difficulty expressed by the
State Government was the want of N.O.C. from the Railway
authorities. As noted earlier, this difficulty no longer survives and
therefore, there should be no further delay on the part of the State
Government in undertaking the works consistent with the statement
made on their behalf.
18.The Secretary, Rural Works Department, Government of Jharkhand
will be personally responsible for ensuring that these works are
commenced and concluded within six months from today. The
Secretary, Rural Works Department, Government of Jharkhand can
assign this work to the Executive Engineer or any other Officer
whom he deems fit and competent. However, the ultimate
responsibility would be that of the Secretary, Rural Works
Department, Government of Jharkhand.
19. We dispose of this petition with the above directions. But before
we do so, we record our appreciation for the fair approach of Mr
Prashant Pallav, the learned A.S.G.I., and the then learned
Advocate General for the State of Jharkhand, Mr Rajiv Ranjan, in
finding a solution to this much-vexed issue that has been bothering
the residents of that region.
20. The suo motu public interest litigation is disposed of in the above
terms, without any order for costs. Pending interim applications, if
any, will not survive and are disposed of.
21. The Secretary, Rural Works Department, Government of
Jharkhand must file a compliance report in this Court by giving an
advance copy to Ms Niki Sinha, the learned C.G.C., who appears
along with Mr Prashant Pallav, the learned A.S.G.I., by
18.01.2027.
22. Though the petition is disposed of, we direct the Registry to list
this matter on 21.01.2027 for considering the compliance report.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
July 09, 2026
N.A.F.R.
Manoj/Sharda/Cp.2
Uploaded on 11.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review