Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
LPA 816/2013, CM APPL. 17317/2013,
47074/2024, 7131/2025, 7218/2025
17319/2013,
CORPORATION BANK
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Rajat Arora, Mr. Niraj
Kumar and Mr. Sourabh Mahela, Advs.
versus
RADHEY SHYAM & ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. A.P. Verma, Adv. for R-1
Ms. Manisha Agrawal Narain, CGSC for
UOI
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
04.02.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
On 18 August 2009, an advertisement was issued by the
Corporation Bank1 for recruitment against 575 clerical vacancies. The
respondent applied against the said advertisement. An appointment
letter was issued to him on 23 March 2010, whereby he was appointed
as a probationary clerk in the Bank with effect from 5 April 2010.
2.
The appointment letter specifically stated, in Clause 5(c) thereof
thus:
“5(c) You will be governed by the “Defined Contributory
Retirement Benefit Scheme”2 introduced at the industry level,
1 “the Bank” hereinafter
2 “the CPF Scheme” hereinafter
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
following the Memorandum of Understanding dated 27.11.2009,
entered into between the Indian Banks’ Association and United
Forum of Bank Unions.”
3.
Mr. Rajat Arora, learned Counsel for the Bank, points out that,
prior to the aforenoted appointment of the respondent, a Memorandum
of Understanding3 had been executed between the Indian Banks
Association4 and the workmen’ Union of the Banks on 27 November
2009. Clauses 3 and 4 of the MoU read thus:
“3.
The Bank Employees’ Pension Regulations, 19955 will be
effective upto 31.03.2010 and cease to apply to any person
appointed in the services of banks on or after 1.4.2010.
4.
A defined contributory retirement benefit scheme as
governed by the “contributory pension scheme introduced for
employees of Central Government with effect from 1.1.2004” will
be introduced for workmen/officers joining the services of banks
on or after 1.4.2010. There shall be no separate contributory
provident fund in respect of these workmen/officers.”
4.
Though the respondent was informed of the fact that he was
selected for appointment as probationary clerk in the Bank on 23
March 2010, the said letter specifically stipulated in para 2, that the
date of joining of the respondent as a probationary clerk in the Bank
had been fixed as 5 April 2010. The respondent expressed no
objection thereto.
5.
Even more significantly, as we have already noted, Clause 5(c)
of the appointment order specifically informed the respondent that he
would be governed by the defined Contributory Retirement Benefit
3 “MoU” hereinafter
4 “IBA” hereafter
5 “the 1995 Pension Regulations” hereinafter
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
Scheme6 following the MoU dated 27 November 2009 (supra).
6.
Clause 9 of the aforenoted letter of appointment read thus:
“9.
If you are agreeable to the aforesaid terms and conditions of
your appointment in the Bank, you have to communicate to us,
your acceptance of the above offer by duly affixing your signature
with date, on the duplicate copy of the offer of appointment
(enclosed) in token of your acceptance of the offer of appointment
and mail the same within 7 days from the date of receipt thereof to
the undersigned at the aforesaid address. In the event of your non
acceptance for failure to report for training as stated above, it will
be deemed that you are not interested in the offer of appointment
and accordingly the offer made in terms of this letter, would stand
automatically cancelled, without further reference to you.”
7.
The respondent joined the services of the Bank on 5 April 2010.
8.
Two years after joining the Bank, the respondent petitioned this
Court by way of WP (C) 6003/20127. The writ petition contained only
one prayer, which we reproduce thus:
“In the facts and circumstances as mentioned above, it is most
respectfully prayed the Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
a)
Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus thereby
directing the respondent bank to give pensions benefits to
the petitioner as available under the “Corporation Bank
(Employees) pensions Regulation, 1995" in place of
“Defined Contributory Retirement Benefit Scheme.”
9.
Thus, the respondent did not elect to challenge either the MoU,
or any provision thereof or Clause 5(c) of his appointment order.
10.
The aforenoted writ petition came to be allowed by the learned
6 “CPF Scheme” hereafter
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
Single Judge of this Court. The Bank had raised, before the learned
Single Judge, the contention that the respondent, having joined in full
consciousness of the CPF Scheme by which he would be governed,
was estopped from contending to the contrary. The learned Single
Judge rejected the appellant’s submissions and allowed the
respondent’s writ petition on the ground that estoppel would not stand
in the way of enforcement of fundamental rights and that the
respondent had been discriminated vis-à-vis one Sumit Panchal who
had been granted pension in accordance with the 1995 Pension
Regulations.
11.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment of the learned Single
Judge, the Bank is in LPA before us.
12.
On 1 November 2013, a Coordinate Division Bench of this
Court had issued notice in the present LPA limited to the aspect of
whether the respondent was estopped from claiming the benefit of the
1995 Pension Regulations. This order was, however, challenged by
the Bank before the Supreme Court by way of Civil Appeal
5161/20178. By order dated 9 November 2023 the Supreme Court
disposed of the said Civil Appeal by requiring this Court to consider
all aspects raised by the appellant and not the limited aspect on which
notice had been issued.
13.
We have heard Mr. Rajat Arora, learned Counsel for the Bank
and Mr. A.P. Verma, learned Counsel for the respondent, at some
7 Radhey Shyam v. Union of India
8 Corporation Bank v. Radhey Shyam & Anr.
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
length.
14.
Mr. Arora submits that the learned Single Judge was patently in
error as the case of Sumit Panchal could not be likened to that of the
respondent. He submits that Sumit Panchal joined the services of the
Bank on 29 March 2010 following an offer of appointment dated 15
March 2010. As such, having joined the services of the Bank prior to
1 April 2010, Sumit Panchal was correctly given the benefit of the
1995 Pension Regulations. The respondent, having joined the services
of the Bank after 1 April 2010, could not be given the benefit of the
1995 Scheme.
15.
Mr. Verma has assiduously sought to contend that it was
completely unfair on the part of the Bank to discriminate the
respondent vis-à-vis Sumit Panchal and that the respondent had no
option at the time of joining but to accept the terms on which the
appointment order was issued. Mr. Verma also sought to contest the
legality of the MoU dated 27 November 2009 and the terms thereof.
16.
We regret our inability to address these arguments of Mr.
Verma, for the simple reason that there was no challenge, in the writ
petition, to any conditions of the MoU or to Clause 5(c) of the
appointment letter dated 23 March 2010.
17.
The appointment letter made it perfectly clear that the
respondent would be governed by the benefits of the CPF Scheme.
Even if we were to ignore, for a minute, the MoU, the appointment
letter would bind the respondent.
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
18.
It is settled law, enunciated in Vidyavardaka Sangha v Y.D.
Deshpande9, that an employee is governed by the terms and
conditions of his offer of appointment.
19.
That apart, the appointment letter was in consonance with the
MoU which, as we have noted, is not under challenge.
20.
The respondent joined the services of the Bank on 5 April 2010.
The MoU was clear that any person appointed to the services of the
bank after 1 April 2010 would be entitled to the benefit of the CPF
scheme.
21.
Though Mr. Verma has emphasised the fact that the letter of
appointment was dated 23 March 2010, which was prior to 1 April
2010, we are of the opinion that this factor cannot seriously weigh in
his favour. The letter dated 23 March 2010 was only a communication
informing the respondent of the fact that he had been selected as
probationary clerk. Para 2 of the letter made it clear that the date of
joining of the respondent as probationary clerk had been fixed as 5
April 2010.
22.
Moreover, at the cost of repetition, we may note that Clause
5(c) of the appointment letter left no room for doubt, as it clearly
stated that the respondent would be governed by the terms of CPF
scheme. The respondent accepted the said stipulation without demur.
9 (2006) 12 SCC 482
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
23.
Having not chosen to challenge the provisions of the MOU or
the appointment letter issued to him, we are of the opinion that the
respondent could not even have maintained WP (C) 6003/2012 before
this Court, as the prayer in the writ petition was in the teeth of Clause
5(c) of the appointment letter as well as the terms of MOU.
24.
The view adopted by the learned Single Judge cannot be
sustained as Mr. Sumit Panchal, vis-à-vis whom the learned Single
Judge has found the respondent to have been discriminated, was
differentially situated. Mr. Panchal had joined the services of the Bank
prior to 5 April 2010 and was, therefore, entitled to the benefit of the
1995 Pension Regulations.
25.
The learned Single Judge, therefore, clearly erred in proceeding
on the ground that there was discrimination between the respondent
and Mr. Sumit Panchal.
26.
Mr. Verma has sought to rely on the judgment of a Division
Bench of this Court in Inspector Rajendra Singh v. UOI10.
27.
We have seen the said decision.
28.
That case is clearly distinguishable. The Division Bench, in that
case, was seized with a situation in which the advertisement,
consequent on which the appellants had joined, specifically stated that
they would be entitled to benefit of the Old Pension Scheme. That
Clause was subsequently modified and the appellants were sought to
10 2017 SCC OnLine Del 7879
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
be brought under the New Pension Scheme. Apart from this fact, the
Division Bench has also noted that the appellants were not in a
position to opt for one scheme or the other. Further, that case dealt
with recruitment to the post in the Central Reserve Police Force and
even on that ground cannot be analogised to the present case.
29.
In the present case, para 9 of the offer of appointment
specifically called upon the respondent to accept the terms of
appointment. The respondent did so and thereafter have served the
Bank as per the said terms of appointment for over two years before
petitioning this Court. This case is not, therefore, in any way similar
to the case of Insp. Rajendra Singh.
30.
We, therefore, are of the opinion that the impugned judgment of
the learned Single Judge cannot sustain on facts or in law. It is
accordingly quashed and set aside.
31.
WP (C) 6003/2012 filed by the respondent before this Court
shall accordingly stand dismissed.
32.
The appeal is accordingly allowed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
FEBRUARY 4, 2026
pa/dsn
LPA 816/2013
KUMAR
12:55:22
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review