Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 19th August, 2026
%
#
+
CNR No. DLHC012935382016
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
UNION BANK OF INDIA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rajat Arora, Mr. Niraj
Kumar & Mr. Sourabh Mahla,
Advs.
versus
MAHIR HUSSAIN
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Binisa Mohanty, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The petitioner challenges the Award dated 29.10.2015
(hereafter ‘the impugned award’) passed by the learned Presiding
Officer, Labour Court, holding the Respondent entitled for
reinstatement with immediate effect and payment of salary with
consequential benefits.
2.
Succinctly stated, the Respondent was working as a Peon at the
Gujranwalan Town Branch of the Petitioner Bank, and was suspended
on 10.08.2009. The Chargesheet dated 01.07.2009 was initially issued
to the Petitioner which was withdrawn and, thereafter, another
chargesheet dated 21.10.2009 was issued, alleging gross “misconduct”
on the part of the Respondent.
3.
It was alleged that he had introduced two persons for opening of
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
savings bank account and the bank accounts were opened by using
fabricated documents. One allegation was also in regard to the stolen
demand draft being used by the persons who had opened the bank
accounts.
4.
Pursuant to issuance of the chargesheet, Departmental Inquiry
was held and the Enquiry Officer by the Report dated 26.05.2010 held
that the charges against the Respondent are proved.
5.
By order dated 27.07.2010, the Disciplinary Authority imposed
the punishment of “Discharge from service”, against which the appeal
is stated to have been preferred by the Respondent on 25.08.2010.
While no decision was taken in the appeal and the same remained
undecided, the Respondent filed a claim under Section 2A of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 regarding the punishment imposed.
6.
The learned Tribunal vide order dated 31.03.2014, decided the
preliminary issue with respect to the validity and fairness of the
enquiry proceedings and held that though the Enquiry Officer had
considered the material and there was no reason to reach a conclusion
that the finding was perverse, the enquiry was tainted on the ground
that the appeal filed by the Respondent against the order of
punishment was not decided by the Appellate authority.
7.
The said Order passed by the Tribunal was challenged before
this Court in W.P.(C) 4264/2014. The said petition was, however,
dismissed vide Order dated 31.10.2014, with observations that the
appeal filed by the Respondent ought to have been decided on merits
by the appropriate authority. This Order dated 31.10.2014, upholding
the Order dated 31.03.2014, has also attained finality as the same was
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
admittedly not challenged by the Petitioners.
8.
The matter, thereafter, proceeded before the learned Labour
Court and it remains undisputed that multiple opportunities were
given to the Petitioner to lead additional evidence in support of his
allegations.
9.
However, the learned Tribunal, thereafter, noting that no
evidence has been adduced by the Petitioner, set aside the order of
Discharge dated 27.07.2010 and directed reinstatement of the
respondent with immediate effect along with payment of salary and
consequential benefits.
10.
Aggrieved the present petition has been filed.
11.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that once the learned
Tribunal, by its order dated 31.03.2014 categorically upheld the
conclusions reached by the Enquiry Officer, a contrary view ought not
to have been taken in the impugned order. He submits that only
because the appeal filed by the Respondent against the order of
discharge was not decided, this could not have been the ground for
setting aside the enquiry and the order of discharge.
12.
He submits that the enquiry was validly held and the order of
discharge was passed after considering the evidence on record and in
the absence of any contrary appreciation of the evidence, the
impugned order cannot be sustained.
13.
He lastly contends that once the employee has lost confidence,
no order of reinstatement can be granted.
14.
Per Contra, the Learned counsel for the respondent submits that
the order dated 31.10.2014 passed by the High Court on an earlier
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
round has attained finality and in the absence of any challenge to the
same, the Petitioner cannot be allowed to take support of the enquiry
proceedings.
15.
He submits that the learned Tribunal gave ample opportunities
to lead evidence and in the absence of the same, it had no option but to
pass an order in favour of the Respondent.
16.
Submissions heard and record perused.
17.
The record reveals that, the Issue No. 1 with respect to the
enquiry conducted against the Respondent being fair and proper, was
decided in favour of the Respondent by the learned Tribunal, vide
Order dated 31.03.2014. It was categorically held therein that though
the evidence adduced before the Enquiry Officer was thoroughly
considered and findings arrived at cannot be held to be perverse,
admittedly the Appeal preferred by the Respondent was never decided
on merits and it was merely discarded because the Appeal was not
filed by the Respondent within the stipulated period of 45 days. Thus,
the Respondent could never avail his statutory right of appeal which
was denied to him on mere technicalities. Hence, the enquiry was
found to be tainted as the Petitioner failed to follow the principles of
Natural Justice.
18.
This Order was assailed before this Court in W.P.(C)
4264/2014.
The said petition was dismissed vide Order dated
31.10.2014 and it was held that the appeal filed by the Respondent
ought to have been decided on merits by the appropriate authority.
19.
Admittedly, this Order dated 31.10.2014, upholding the Order
dated 31.03.2014, has attained finality and has never been challenged
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
by the Petitioners. Though this Court is mindful of the fact that the
charges against the Respondent are serious, however, judicial
propriety demands that once the issue with respect to the fairness of
the enquiry proceedings stands settled and decided, this Court ought
not to consider any re-agitated arguments on the same issue. It does
not lie in the mouth of the Petitioner to raise these issues when they
consciously chose not to challenge the above order.
20.
Once it was decided that the enquiry stood tainted, the evidence
therein could not have been considered. Thus, the Respondents, as per
settled law, were required to lead evidence in support of their
allegations/ the merits of the case to prove validity of the charges. It
stands admitted that no such evidence has been produced despite
several opportunities being granted to the Petitioner.
21.
Hence, in the peculiar facts of the case, this Court finds no
reason to interfere with the approach adopted by the learned Tribunal
in setting aside the Order of Punishment issued by the Disciplinary
authority.
22.
As regards the aspect of relief, it would be apposite to
reproduce the charges and allegations against the employee which
were held to be proved during the enquiry proceedings. The same read
as under: i) "Whereas in terms of letter No.PAD:DISC:42:09:1052:2009
dated 10.08.2009, you were placed under suspension. And whereas
as per the above letter dated 10.08.2009, you were further
informed that the earlier charge sheet bearing No.
PAD:DISC:42:09:775:2009 dated 01.07.2009 issued to you stood
withdrawn and that a fresh charge sheet would be issued for
reasons stated therein. Accordingly, the revised charge sheet is
hereby issued for the allegation reported against you as under:
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
ii) That on 22.01.2009, one Shri Kapil, whose SB Account No.7112
was introduced by you, approached you, alongwith one person
named Shri Jay Chand Malik and requested you to open one SB
account in the name of the latter. That you provided the Account
Opening form to them and then Shri Kapil, after putting his
signature as introducer returned the said Account Opening Form
to you and requested to fill up the remaining column. That the
party also handed over to you an amount of Rs.200.00 as initial
deposit for opening the account alongwith supporting documents
like one photograph, photocopies of driving licence, and PAN card
in a single sheet of paper and left the branch. That you filled up
the, remaining details in the Account Opening Form, affixed the
photograph and handed over the set of documents to Shri Suraj
Mani officiating clerk for opening the new SB account. That
accordingly on 22.01.2009, the SB account bearing No.7471 in the
name of Shri Jay Chand Malik with residential address 'A-340,
Madipur, New Delhi 110026' and office address 'C-4/194,
Shakurpuri, New Delhi 110035' was opened at the branch. That the
said account was opened with zero balance, without obtaining
initial cash deposit of Rs.500.00 as stipulated for new account.
That you had informed Shri Suraj Mani and other connected staff
members that as the case was closed for the day, you would deposit
cash on the next day. That accordingly, on 23.01.2009, you
deposited a sum of Rs.200.00 towards initial cash deposit in
respect of the aforesaid SB account. That you affixed the date seal
on the Account Opening Form of SB account No.7471 without
date, which is also used by you while preparing the slip bundle
dated 22.01.2009. that the above circumstances indicate that the
SB Account No.7471 was opened at your instance.
iii) That on 24.01.2009, a Demand Draft (DD) bearing
No.6904370 dated 17.01.2009 for Rs.1,41,000.00 issued in favour
of Jay Chand Mallick' drawn on State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur,
Kolkata, Brabourne Road branch was sent for collection under
OCCF No. 17/2009 for credit of SB account :No.7471. That on
05.02.2009, a cheque book containing 10 leaves bearing cheque
leaves No.420011 to 420020 was issued in the SB Account
No.7471. That though an entry was made to this effect in the
cheque book issued Register of the branch by you, the cheque book
in question was delivered without obtaining signature of the
account holder towards acknowledgement.
iv) That on 06.02.2009, an amount of Rs.5000..00 came to be
withdrawn from the aforesaid SB account through cheque leaf
No.420011, leaving a balance of Rs.1.36 lakh. That on 09.02.2009,
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
Kolkata service Branch informed Delhi Gujranwala Town branch
that the purchaser of the aforesaid DD had lodged a complaint
with State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur, Ghantol branch informing
loss of the said DD and requested to exercise caution. That the
purchaser of the DD also filed a police complaint in this regard.
That on the basis of the said information, the aforesaid SB account
was freezed by the branch. That, on 10.02.2009 the branch
Manager discussed the matter with the officials of the branch and
also perused the account Opening Form pertaining to SB Account
No.7471, which was in tact alongwith the photograph of the
account holder. That on the same day, evening the Branch
Manager informed all the staff members of the branch about the
DD incident and at that time, he found the Account Opening Form
tampered with someone replacing the photograph of the account
holder with certain other photograph and also by removing
photocopy of the PAC card and driving licence held with the
Account Opening Form.
v) That on 14.02.2009, at about 9.00 p.m., you telephonically
requested Shri Jai Pal, Officer of the branch to receive on closed
cover containing certain documents from one Madan, a tea vendor,
whose shop is located close to Delhi Gujranwala Town branch
premises. That to collect the cover, when Shri Jai Pal, Officer
approached Shri Madan on 15.02.2009, he refused to hand over
the same to him. That, however, after getting confirmation from
you over telephone, Shri Madan delivered the cover to Shri Jai
Pal. That the said cover bears a single sheet of paper containing
photocopies of both driving licence and PAN card in the name of
Shri Jay Chand Malik. That verification of the said paper disclosed
that the photograph, date of birth, PAN number and address as
appearing on the said two documents are different from the details
on record in the Account Opening Form of SB Account No.7471.
that these circumstances go to show your involvement in opening
SB account No.7471.
vi) That on verification of records, it came to light that the SB
account No.7471 was opened with fictitious address and the
account was opened fraudulently. That the proof of address of Shri
Kapil, the introducer and furnished to the bank was also fictitious.
That the account opening form bear an unidentifiable initial of
someone alongwith the seal of the Branch for having permitted the
opening of the said account. That the purchaser of the aforesaid
DD demanded refund of the amount as the amount was wrongly
credited to some other account than that of the payee. That in the
circumstances. Bank was compelled to settle the claim of the
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
purchaser of the DD by making payment of Rs.1,41,000.00 by
incurring a financial loss of Rs.5000.00 in the matter.
vii) that on 09.02.2009, another cheque pertaining to the said SB
account No.7471 i.e. cheque no.420012 dated 06.02.2009 for
Rs.1,35,500 favouring one Shri 'Suresh Prasad, was presented
through clearing by Central Bank of India, Madpur, New Delhi
branch. That however the said cheque was returned unpaid, as the
operations in the said SB account NO.7471 was freezed. That it
was later revealed that the payee of the said cheque, Shri Suresh
Prasad was earlier staying at Madipur and was your neighbor
before he shifted to MIE Lines in ;Bahadurgarh. That Shri Suresh
Prasad used to take your help in conducting his bank transactions
with Central Bank of India, Madipur branch. That you were
knowing Shri Suresh Prasad's Bank account number, with Central
Bank of India, Madipur branch. That sometimes back you
telephoned Shri Suresh Prasad and informed him that you will be
depositing a cheque in the name of Suresh Prasad in his account
with Central Bank of India and that once the amount is collected,
the same should be paid back to him. That you told Shri Suresh
Prasad that obtaining the cheque in your name would result in lot
of hue and cry and hence such an arrangement was resorted to.
That about a week thereafter, you again telephoned Shri Suresh
Prasad and advised him not to go to the bank as some one had
deposited a stolen cheque in his account and that police would
arrest him. That you also requested Shri Suresh Prasad not to
reveal to anybody that he know you and said to him that you would
sort out the issue. That later when Shri Suresh Prasad wanted to
do his banking transactions and hence contacted you, you gave
him copies of three letters addressed to Corporation Bank,
Gujranwala Town branch by Zonal Office, Delhi and Anti Frauds
Section, HO and told him that he could go to his bank and
withdraw money as his name was not figuring in any of those
letters. That however when Shri Suresh Prasad went to Central
Bank of India, Madipur branch, he came to know that operation in
his bank account was freezed. That the Branch Manager of Central
Bank of India also informed Shri Suresh Prasad to meet Manager
of Corporation Bank, Gujranwala Town branch. That on
22.07.2009 Shri Suresh Prasad met the Branch Manager of
Corporation Bank, Gujrawalan Town branch. That the above
circumstances showed your intention to defraud the bank. That
Corporation Bank, Gujranwala Town branch had not received the
above referred three letters, but you provided copies of the said
letters to Shri Suresh Prasad which showed that you intercepted
them and deliberately, removed the above letters with a view to
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
keep the branch in the dark on eh directions made in the matter.
viii) That by your aforesaid acts and omissions, you facilitated
opening of a fictitious SB account No.7471 , fraudulent collection
of the Demand Drat for Rs.1.41 lakh, and fraudulent withdrawal of
Rs..5000.00 and dishonestly caused a financial loss of of
Rs.5000.00 to the bank. That further, you also resorted to
manipulation of bank records by clandestinely removing the
photograph and photocopies of driving licence and PAN card from
the account opening form and attempted to replace the same with
certain other documents as stated earlier so as to prevent the
identity of the impersonator. That you also attempted to
fraudulently encash Rs. 1,35,500.00 from SB account No.7417 by
arranging to present cheque no.420012 in clearing through
Central Bank of India, Madipur branch for the credit of SB
account of Shri Suresh Prasad. That you intercepted the above
referred three letters addressed to the branch with a view to keep
the branch in the dark. That you also made available copies of
such correspondence to Shri Suresh Prasad, resulting in
unauthorized disclosure of information regarding affairs of the
bank.
ix) That your aforesaid acts and omissions are serious in nature
and if proved, would be grossly detrimental to the interest of the
bank and tantamount to:
(a) unauthorized disclosure of information regarding the affairs of
the bank or any of its customers or any other person connected
with the business of the bank which is confidential o
(b) willful damage or attempt to cause damage to the property of
the bank or any of its customers;
(c) doing any act prejudicial to the interest of the bank
gross misconduct under clauses 5(b), 5(d) and 5(j) respectively of
the Memorandum of Settlement on Disciplinary Procedure dated
10.04.2002 applicable to you."
23.
Since the findings with respect to such serious charges of
financial fraud were not held to be perverse and arrived at on the basis
of the evidence led before the competent authority, this court finds
merit in the argument raised by the Petitioner that once confidence in
the employee has been lost by the department, no relief of
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
reinstatement ought to have been granted. Thus, in lieu of the totality
of circumstances, and the need to bring finality to a dispute which has
remained alive for almost 2 decades, this Court deems it just and
proper to modify the relief awarded and grant a lump-compensation of
Rs. 4,00,000/-, to be paid by the Petitioner to the Respondent, within 4
weeks from date, towards full and final settlement of all the claims
arising out of the Award.
24.
Accordingly, the impugned award is modified and the petition
along with pending application(s), if any, is disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
AUGUST 19, 2026
“SS”
Signed By:DEEPANSHU
19:16:08
W.P.(C) 11213/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review