Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010658362022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3558]
FRIDAY,THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHEEKATI MANAVENDRANATH ROY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
WRIT PETITION NO: 39363/2022
Between:
1. CONVENTION OF BAPTIST CHURCHES OF NORTHERN CIRCARS,,
REG. NO.16/48-49, REP. BY ITS SECRETARY K. CHANDRA KUMAR,
OFFICE AT PLOT NO.19, BHARATHI NAGAR,
VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
2. K. CHANDRA KUMAR,, S/O. KAMESWARA RAO, AGED 55 YEARS,
OCC. SOCIAL SERVICE, SECRETARY OF CONVENTION OF
BAPTIST CHURCHES OF NORTHERN CIRCARS, R/O. D.NO.6-1,
BHAGYA NAGAR, KANURU, VIJAYAWADA - 520 007, KRISHNA
DISTRICT
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION
AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT, SECRETARIAT BUILDINGS,
VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
VISAKHAPATNAM
DISTRICT,
3. GREATER VISAKHAPATNAM MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, REP.
BY ITS COMMISSIONER,
GREATER VISAKHAPATNAM
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, VISAKHAPATNAM.
4. M/S H R R CONSTRUCTION PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
5. M/S RAMASHIL CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
6. M/S SHIMANI CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
7. FINE SHINE DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
8. M/S ANIRAGH CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
9. M/S H R S CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
10. M/S JAISHIL CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
11. M/S H N P CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
12. M/S H B J CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
13. M/S SOWDAMINI CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY
ITS DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
14. M/S SEEMA CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. SEEMA REDDY THYAGARAJ, W/O. THYAGARAJ
CHRISTOPHER KARUNAKAR, AGED 49 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.59A-73/2, 2ND LANE, NEAR SAI BABA TEMPLE ROAD, RTC COLONY,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
15. M/S JENET PROPERTY DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY
ITS DIRECTOR SMT. JENET MALINI THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN
RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, AGED 75 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, NEAR D.V. MANOR, VENKATESWARAPURAM,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT
16. M/S JYOSTNA ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR HEMAN RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU,
S/O. HEMAN
JESUDAS THYAGARAJ, AGED 82 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, CHANDRAMOULI PURAM,
VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
17. M/S TYAGARAJ CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR HEMAN RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, S/O. HEMAN
JESUDAS THYAGARAJ, AGED 82 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, CHANDRAMOULI PURAM, VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
18. M/S CHRISTINA CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY
ITS DIRECTOR HEMAN RATNAKAR THYAGARAJU, S/O. HEMAN
JESUDAS THYAGARAJ, AGED 82 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.40-3-3,
KRISHNA NAGAR, CHANDRAMOULI PURAM, VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
19. M/S CHINTAKUNTA CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED REP BY
ITS DIRECTOR SMT SEEMA REDDY THYAGARAJ, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR SMT. SEEMA REDDY THYAGARAJ, W/O. THYAGARAJ
CHRISTOPHER KARUNAKAR, AGED 49 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.59A-73/2, 2ND LANE, NEAR SAI BABA TEMPLE ROAD, RTC COLONY,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
20. M/S DINAKAR CONSTRUCTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
DIRECTOR DINAKAR THYAGARAJ, W/O. HEMAN RATNAKAR
THYAGARAJU, AGED 49 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.7-237, PLOT NO.39,
KCP COLONY, KANURU, PENAMALURU MANDAL, NEAR
SIDHARATHA ENGINEERING COLLEGE, VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
21. M/S SUNITHA ESTATES PVT LTD, REP. BY ITS DIRECTOR
CHRISTOPHER KARUNAKAR THYAGARAJ, THYAGARAJ HEMAN
RATNKAR, AGED 53 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.59A-7-3/2, 2ND LANE,
NEAR SAI BABA TEMPLE ROAD, RTC COLONY, VIJAYAWADA,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
22. MR
DINAKAR
THYAGARAJ,
W/O.
HEMAN
RATNAKAR
THYAGARAJU, AGED 49 YEARS, R/O. D.NO.7-237, PLOT NO.39,
KCP COLONY, KANURU, PENAMALURU MANDAL, NEAR
SIDHARATHA ENGINEERING COLLEGE, VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased topleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in
the nature of 'Writ of Mandamus' declaring the impugned 'Award of
Transferable Development Right' vide TDR.No.1086/00061/TDR/WTW/2022
dated 29-10-2022, issued by the 3rd respondent herein, in favour of the
respondent No.22, as illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction and a 'fraud' against
the 1st petitioner interest and title and possession, violative of Articles 14, 21
and 300-A of the Constitution of India, apart from being violative of principles
of natural justice, consequently set aside the same, and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the impugned 'Award of Transferable Development Right'
vide TDR.No.1086/00061/TDR/WTW/2022 dated 29-10-2022, issued by the
3rd respondent herein, in favour of the respondent No.22 pending final
disposal of the main writ petition, and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. T LAKSHMI NARAYANA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. K.MADHAVA REDDY (SC FOR GVMC)
2. GP FOR REVENUE
3. V V RAVI PRASAD
4. PILLIX LAW FIRM
5. GP FOR IRRIGATION COMM AREA DEV
The Court made the following:
ORDER:- (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Cheekati Manavendranath Roy)
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for a
Mandamus is filed to declare the award of Transferable Development Right
(TDR) dated 29.10.2022 issued by respondent No.3 in favour of respondent
No.22 as illegal and without jurisdiction and that they are issued by way of
playing fraud against the 1st petitioner.
2.
Heard Sri T.Lakshmi Narayana, learned counsel for the petitioners,
Ms.S.Pranathi, learned Special Government Pleader attached to the office of
learned Advocate General for official respondents 1 to 3 and Sri V.V.Ravi
Prasad, learned counsel for the unofficial respondents 4 to 22.
3.
The 3rd respondent-Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation,
represented by its Commissioner (hereinafter referred to as „GVMC‟) acquired
a private land for the public purpose of widening the road in Visakhapatnam
city. As the 3rd respondent-GVMC found respondents 4 to 21 as owners of
the said land that was acquired for the aforesaid public purpose, a registered
gift deed was obtained from them represented by their GPA holder, who is
respondent No.22 of all the said registered companies. The registered gift
deed is dated 27.07.2021.
Subsequently, a rectification deed dated
11.10.2022 was also executed which was also registered. After acquiring the
said land for the aforesaid public purpose under the aforesaid registered gift
deed, TDR dated 29.10.2022 was issued in favour of the owners of the said
land, who are the unofficial respondents herein, represented by their GPA
holder.
4.
Questioning the legal validity of the said TDR that was issued by the 3rd
respondent-GVMC in favour of the unofficial respondents, the instant writ
petition has been filed by the writ petitioners.
5.
The writ petitioner is a Convention of Baptist Churches of Northern
Circars, represented by its Secretary by name K.Chandra Kumar (hereinafter
referred to as „CBCNC‟). According to the writ petitioner, the land that was
acquired by the 3rd respondent-GVMC is owned by CBCNC and it is the
original and absolute owner of the said property. As CBCNC is represented
by a trust association bearing Registration No.12 of 1960, the same is being
represented by the board members. The 2nd writ petitioner K.Chandra Kumar
claims to be the Secretary of the said association. Therefore, it is the case of
the writ petitioners that as CBCNC is the absolute owner of the property that
was acquired, the unofficial respondents herein are not entitled to any
compensation or the TDR and it is the CBCNC, which is entitled for the TDR.
6.
The 3rd respondent-GVMC and also the unofficial respondents have
filed their counters opposing the writ petition. According to the case pleaded
by the 3rd respondent-GVMC, the unofficial respondents, who are 18 in
number, are the absolute owners of the land that was acquired by the GVMC
and as such, the TDR was issued in their favour. As per the case pleaded by
the unofficial respondents, it is stated that they have purchased the said land
along with the remaining part of the land from the erstwhile representatives of
the CBCNC under various registered sale deeds, which are 18 in number in
the year 1993 and they have taken possession of the property and exercising
their right of ownership of the said property and as on the date of acquiring the
said property by the 3rd respondent-GVMC, they are the absolute owners of
the said property and as such, they alone are entitled for TDR. It is denied
that the second writ petitioner is the office bearer of the trust association of the
1st petitioner CBCNC.
7.
The fact that CBCNC is the original owner of the property in question, is
not in dispute. But the erstwhile representatives and office bearers of the said
CBCNC, which is represented by the trust association registered under the
Andhra Pradesh Societies Registration Act, 2001, sold away the said property
to the unofficial respondents herein under various registered sale deeds long
back in the year 1993. Subsequently, as it is found that the CBCNC is holding
a surplus land, proceedings are initiated and in the said proceedings, the
possession of the unofficial respondents was regularized by the Government.
Therefore, after the unofficial respondents purchased the said property under
registered sale deeds from the erstwhile representatives of the CBCNC, as on
date of acquiring the land in the year 2021, the unofficial respondents claim to
be the owners of the property.
8.
The 2nd writ petitioner K.Chandra Kumar is claiming to be the Secretary
of the association. His status as the Secretary of the said trust association is
very much in dispute in this writ petition as the unofficial respondents
categorically denied that he is the Secretary of the trust association. In fact,
the material on record discloses that various people are claiming to be the
representatives of the said trust association of the CBCNC. Therefore, the
Division Bench of this Court in W.A.No.631 of 2021 relating to a batch of writ
petitions as per order dated 01.04.2025, having found that various persons
are claiming to be the representatives of the said trust association of the
CBCNC, has disposed of the writ appeal with the following directions:“1. The Registrar of Public Societies shall receive all lists
submitted by the parties to these litigations.
2. These lists are to be submitted to the Registrar within two
weeks from today.
3. At the expiry of the period of two weeks, the Registrar shall
collate all the lists and verify whether there is any overlap in the
periods claimed for each Governing Body.
4. The Registrar shall also verify whether more than one list has
been filed in relation to any period.
5. In the event of any such overlap or dispute relating to the
identity of the members of Governing Body for any period, the
Registrar shall not decide the said dispute and shall leave it open
to the parties to approach the appropriate forum for resolution of
these disputes.
6. In the event of the Registrar being able to reconcile the lists,
without going into any disputes, the same shall be taken on
record.
7. If the Registrar is unable to reconcile these lists and he is
required to leave it open to the parties to approach the appropriate
forum, the Registrar shall keep all the lists submitted to him in the
record. However, no copy of such lists will be released nor shall it
be taken to as a certification of election of any of the members
mentioned in that list. Though an interim direction for protecting
the property of the Society had been issued by this Court, it would
not be possible for this Court to extend the same as any such
extension would amount to an open ended extension effectively
barring the Society from alienating its property for all times to
come.”
9.
As can be seen from the direction No.5, the Coordinate Bench of this
Court has directed the parties to submit their lists before the Registrar of the
Societies within two weeks from the date of the order to verify whether more
than one list has been filed in relation to any period and then further held that
in the event of any such overlap or dispute relating to the identity of the
members of Governing Body for any period, the Registrar shall not decide the
said dispute and shall leave it open to the parties to approach the appropriate
forum for resolution of the said disputes.
10.
Therefore, it is evident that there are rival claims made by various
persons claiming to be the representatives of the said trust association of
CBCNC. As the dispute pertains to internal dispute among the members of
the Society, the same has to be decided under Section 23 of the Andhra
Pradesh Societies Registration Act, 2001. At this stage, it cannot be decided
as to who is the lawful representative of the said trust association in this writ
petition. Further, the ownership rights of the property also cannot be decided
by a Writ Court. The fraud alleged by the writ petitioners cannot also be
decided in this writ petition. It is well settled that in order to establish the fraud
alleged, there must be a specific plea relating to the details of the fraud played
and proof of the same to decide whether there is any fraud in obtaining TDR
or not. The same also cannot be decided in this writ petition as it is the
disputed question of fact which requires evidence to adjudicate the same.
Therefore, if at all, the writ petitioner claims to be the lawful representative of
the trust association of CBCNC during the relevant period and if at all, the
CBCNC challenges the legal validity of the registered sale deeds executed by
its erstwhile representatives in favour of the unofficial respondents, they have
to challenge the same before the competent civil Courts and then claim for
TDR. They cannot question the same in this writ petition.
11.
Therefore, we do not find any valid legal ground emanating from the
record to entertain this writ petition as per the relief claimed by the petitioners
in this writ petition.
12.
So, the writ petition is devoid of merit and it is liable to be dismissed.
13.
Resultantly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand closed.
________________________________________
JUSTICE CHEEKATI MANAVENDRANATH ROY
_____________________________
JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
Date: 13.03.2026
ARR
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHEEKATI MANAVENDRANATH ROY
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
WRIT PETITION NO: 39363/2022
Date: 13.03.2026
ARR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review