Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
--------Death Reference No.03 of 2025
[Against the Judgment of conviction dated 23.09.2025 and order of
sentence dated 25.09.2025 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Chandil in Sessions Trial No.196/2019, arising out of Chandil P.S. Case
No. 23 of 2019 corresponding to G.R. Case No.244 of 2019]
-------The State of Jharkhand (through Shidhu Soren) … …
Prosecution
Versus
Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru, son of late Mangal Manjhi, resident of Purisili,
Kapali, PO: Kapali, PS Chandil/Kapali, District Seraikella-Kharsawan,
Jharkhand.
…
… Respondent
With
Criminal Appeal (DB) No.1343 of 2025
-----Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru, aged about 32 years, son of late Mangal Manjhi,
resident of Purisili, Kapali, PO: Kapali, PS Chandil (Kapali OP), District
Seraikella-Kharsawan, Jharkhand.
…
…
Appellant
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
… … Respondent
PRESENT
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PRASAD
…..
For the Convict
: Mr. Atanu Banerjee, Advocate;
Mr. Suman Kumar Ghosh, Advocate
For the State
: Mr. Pankaj Kumar, Public Prosecutor
…..
C.A.V. on: 01.05.2026
Pronounced on:18/06/2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
1.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant, facing the death sentence,
and learned counsel for the State, in the death reference.
2.
As this death reference and the instant appeal arise out of the
common judgment of conviction and order of sentence, they were heard
together and are being disposed of by this common Judgment.
3.
This death reference and the connected Criminal Appeal arise out of
the impugned judgment of conviction dated 23.09.2025 and order of
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
sentence dated 25.09.2025 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Chandil in Sessions Trial Case No. 196 of 2019, arising out of Chandil PS
case No. 23 of 2019, G.R. No. 244 of 2019, whereby, the sole appellant
Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru has been found guilty and convicted for the
offences under Sections 302 and 427 of the Indian Penal Code.
4.
Upon hearing on the point of sentence, the appellant Chunnu Manjhi
@ Putru has been sentenced to the capital punishment along with fine of Rs.
20,000/- (Twenty Thousand), for the offence under Section 302 of the Indian
Penal Code, directing him death sentence by hanging and further in default
of fine R.I. for 6 months. He has further been sentenced to undergo two
years for the offence u/s 427 of the Indian Penal Code.
5.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment of Conviction and order of
sentence, the appellant has preferred the present appeal, whereas the death
reference is made by the learned Trial Court for confirmation of the death
sentence imposed upon the sole appellant, namely, Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru.
Factual Matrix
6.
The prosecution case was instituted on the fardbayan of the
informant Sidhu Soren Soren (P.W.-6) recorded on 23.02.2019 at 14:30 hrs.,
at M.G.M., Hospital, Jamshedpur.
7.
Informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6), in his fardbeyan, has stated that
while he and his mother were sleeping in their house on the night of
23.02.2019, at about 04:00 a.m., the accused Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru
(appellant herein), armed with an axe, came and began striking the door. At
that time, the accused was stating that he had killed Ravi Manjhi, Kalpana
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
@ Parwati, Jiten @ Jitendra Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi, and Puresh Manjhi, and
further threatened that he would kill the informant also. Saying so, the
accused forcefully struck the door with the axe.
8.
Informant further stated that when he opened the door, then accused
Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru attacked him with an axe to which, informant
caught his hand, then, axe slipped from his hand.
9.
Thereafter, accused Chunnu Manjhi @ Putr, took dabli, but in the
meantime informant fled away and entered into the house of his neighbour
namely Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9) and closed the door. Then, accused
restrained informant’s mother Guruwari Majhian and assaulted her.
Informant further stated that on hearing halla, neighbours came and
informed the police. Police came there and apprehended the accused Chunnu
Manjhi @ Putru. Accused Chunnu Manjhi was telling that he has set the
entire house on fire and committed murder of Ravi Manjhi and his family
members and he was also telling that the informant and others family
members were asking Rs. 20,000/- back, which was given to him.
10.
Informant further stated that accused Chunnu Manjhi had assaulted
his mother Guruwari Majhian, with an axe and injured her. It has further
been alleged that the accused has set house on fire, and also set ablaze his
motorcycle, cycle and other articles. It has further been alleged that the
accused, apart from setting fire to his own house, also burnt the room of
Ravi Manjhi (deceased) and one room belonging to Rai Muni Manjhiyan
(P.W.-5). The accused is further stated to have broken the asbestos roofing
and caused its destruction.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
11.
On the fardbeyan of informant, Chandil P.S. Case No. 23/2019 dated
23.02.2019 was registered for the offences u/s 325, 307, 436, 302 and 427 of
I.P.C. After investigation Police submitted charge-sheet against the accused
/appellant for the offences U/Ss. 302, 307, 326, 427, 440 and 506 of IPC.
12.
On 14.05.2019, cognizance was taken against accused/appellant for
the offences U/Ss. 302, 307, 326, 427, 440 and 506 IPC and case was
committed to the Court of Sessions.
13.
Thereafter, charges U/Ss. 302, 307, 326, 427, 440 and 506 of IPC
were framed against the appellant which were read over and explained to
him to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
14.
In order to establish charges levelled against accused person,
prosecution had examined altogether 11 witnesses which are as follows:
PW-1
Shambhu Soren
PW-2
Chaita Soren
PW-3
Harendra Singh
PW-4
Uttam Singh
PW-5
Rai Muni Manjhiyan
PW-6
Sidhu Soren (informant)
PW-7
Dr. Vishnudeo Prasad Sah
PW-8
Ropna Ram Kanshi(investigating
Officer)
PW-9
Bhagan Tudu
PW-10
Bablu Tudu
PW-11
Hiralal Mundu
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
15.
Further the prosecution in order to prove the charges has exhibited
the following documents:
Sr. No.
Exhibit Number
Description
1.
Ext. P-1/P.W.6
Signature of informant P.W.6 on
fardbeyan
2.
Ext. P-2/P.W.7
Signature of P.W.7 on postmortem
report
3.
Ext. P-2/1/P.W.7
Signature of P.W.7 on postmortem
report of Ravi Manjhi
4.
Ext. P-2/2/P.W.7
Signature of P.W.7 on postmortem
report of Kalpana Devi
5.
Ext. P-2/3/P.W.7
Signature of P.W.7 on postmortem
report of Jiten Manjhi
6.
Ext. P-2/4/P.W.7
Signature of P.W.7 on postmortem
report of Suresh Manjhi
7.
Ext. P-1/1/P.W.8
Whole fardbeyan
8.
Ext. P-1/2//P.W.8
Forwarding report in fardbeyan
9.
Ext. P-1/3/P.W.8
Identified
the
signature
on
endorsement on written report
10.
Ext. P-3/P.W.8
The formal F.I.R.
11.
Ext. P-4/P.W.8
The inquest report of Ravi
Manjhi
12.
Ext. P-4/1/P.W.8
The inquest report of Kalpana
Manjhi
Ext. P-4/2/P.W.8
The inquest report of Jiten
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Manjhi
14.
Ext. P-4/3/P.W.8
The inquest report of Suresh
Manjhi
15.
Ext. P-4/4/P.W.8
The inquest report of Paresh
Manjhi
16.
Ext. P-5/P.W.8
The carbon copy of challan of
Ravi Manjhi
17.
Ext. P-5/1/P.W.8
The carbon copy of challan of
Kalpana Devi
18.
Ext. P-5/2/P.W.8
The carbon copy of challan of
Jiten Manjhi
19.
Ext. P-5/3/P.W.8
The carbon copy of challan of
Suresh Manjhi
20.
Ext. P-5/4/P.W.8
The carbon copy of challan of
Paresh Manjhi
21.
Ext. P-6/P.W.8
Identified the memo of arrest of
Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru
22.
Ext. P-7/P.W.8
Signature on seizure list
23.
Ext. P-8/P.W.8
Identified
the
signature
on
inspection report
24.
Ext. P-9/P.W.8
The confessional statement of
Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
25.
Ext. P-10/P.W.8
Identified the acknowledgment
report
26.
Ext. P-11/P.W.8
Identified the letter no. 127/2019
dt. 28.02.2019 (Total 3 pages)
27.
Ext. P-12
The SFSL report no. 444/2019
dt. 23.04.2025
28.
Ext. P-7/1/P.W.9
Signature of PW-9 on seizure list
29.
Ext. P-6/1/P.W.7
Signature of PW-9 on memo of
arrest of Chhunu Manjhi
30.
Ext. P-7/2/P.W.10
Signature of PW10 on seizure
list
31.
Ext. P-6/2/P.W.10
Signature of PW10 on memo of
arrest of Chhunu Manjhi @
Putru
32.
Ext. M.O.-1
A wooden box
33.
Ext. M.O.-II
Yellow colour half sleeve T-shirt
34.
Ext. M.O.-III
Maroon colour half pant
35.
Ext. M.O.-IV
Torn pink with yellow and black
coloured stripped Saree piece
36.
Ext. M.O.-V
Yellow colour torn blouse
37.
Ext. M.O.-II/I
Black and Maroon colour torned
and burnt T-shirt
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
38.
Ext. M.O.-VI
White colour torned half shirts
with stains
39.
Ext. M.O.-II/2
Black and white checked torned
T-shirt
40.
Ext. M.O.-VII
Black colour track suite pant
41.
Ext. M.O.-II/3
Ganji brown colour T-shirt
42.
Ext. M.O.-VIII
Tangi 7a
43.
Ext. M.O.-VIII/1
Tangi 7b
44.
Ext. M.O.-VIII/2
Tangi 7c
45.
Ext. M.O.-IX
Blue colour cloth piece
46.
Ext. M.O.-IX/1
Green and red colour cloth piece
47.
Ext. M.O.-IX/2
Yellow colour cloth piece
48.
Ext. M.O.-IX/3
Yellow and black colour cloth
piece
49.
Ext. M.O.-IX/4
Yellow colour cloth piece
50.
Ext. M.O.-IX/5
Brown yellow cloth piece
51.
Ext. M.O.-IX/6
Yellow green colour cloth piece
52.
Ext. M.O.-IX/7
Maroon grey colour cloth piece
53.
Ext. M.O.-X
Plastic Dibba containing semi
solid reddish brown material
54.
Ext. M.O.-XI
Stained Gauge
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
16.
55.
Ext. M.O.-IX/8
Stained cotton piece-10
56.
Ext. M.O.-IX/9
Stained cloth piece-11(a)
57.
Ext. M.O.-IX/10
Stained cotton piece-11(b)
The trial Court, after recording the evidence of witnesses,
examination-in-chief and cross-examination, recorded the statement of the
accused/appellant found the charges proved against the appellant under
Sections 302 and 427 of the IPC.
17.
Accordingly, the appellant had been convicted under Sections 302
and 427 of the IPC and sentenced as aforesaid.
18.
The aforesaid order of conviction and sentence is subject matter of
instant appeal.
Submission of the learned counsel for the appellant:
19.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the impugned
Judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned trial
court cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.
20.
The following grounds have been taken by the learned counsel for
the appellant in assailing the impugned judgment of conviction: (i)
It is submitted that there is no eyewitness to the alleged
occurrence. The informant is also not an eye witness to the
alleged occurrence of murder.
(ii)
It is further submitted that PW-2 has deposed to have
heard that the appellant is mentally unfit.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
(iii)
It is also submitted that motive behind the occurrence is
also not clear though there is allegation in the oral evidence of
land dispute.
(iv)
The prosecution has not proved the chain of
circumstances and the circumstances are not linked and
complete.
(v)
The learned trial court has erred in observing- “the act
of the accused going to the house of the informant and
concealing himself in the house after the incident shows his
conduct immediately after the incident.”
(vi)
It is submitted that the Investigating Officer has not
taken the finger print of the accused on the seized axes.
(vii) There is no injury report of the informant or his mother
on record.
(viii) There is no seizure of remains of burnt motorcycle on
record.
(ix)
The learned trial court has erred in observing- “the
statement as well as the conduct forms the part of same
relevant fact and is admissible under section 6 of the Evidence
Act.”
(x)
It is submitted that the evidences on record are not
sufficient so as to construed that the same is relevant fact
forming part of same transaction as there is no consistent
trustworthy evidence that appellant was seen present at the
alleged place of occurrence with axe in his hand.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
(xi)
The learned trial court has erred in placing reliance
upon Section 106 of the Evidence Act though the prosecution
has failed in its primary burden of proving the alleged offence.
(xii) The learned trial court has erred in relying upon SFSL
report, which is not conclusive or definite.
(xiii) The benefit of exception of Section 84 of the Indian
Penal code has not been properly appreciated.
(xiv) It is submitted that the finding of land dispute being the
motive behind the alleged occurrence is also not supported by
consistent evidence.
(xv)
The statement of appellant under section 313 Cr.P.C.
has not been properly appreciated
(xvi) The sentence awarding capital punishment is not
justified even otherwise the case would not fall within the
purview of rarest of rare case.
(xvii) It is further submitted that while awarding the sentence,
there is no consideration of the mitigating factors and, thus,
the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence is
bad in law and contrary to the materials on record and is liable
to be set aside.
Submission of the learned P.P for the State:
21.
Per contra, Mr. Pankaj Kumar, learned Public Prosecutor appearing
for the State, has submitted by taking the following grounds in defending the
impugned judgment:
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
(i)
Learned counsel for the State submitted that the case in hand
relates to brutal murder of five persons by axe and the case
comes within the category of rarest of rare cases, and as such
it is a fit case in which the death sentence awarded to the
accused by the Trial Court be confirmed.
(ii)
Learned State counsel has submitted that it is a case of
circumstantial evidence and the incident took place in the late
night and the accused was only person who was present at the
place of the occurrence. The accused has himself confessed
that he had committed murder of five persons and after
committing the murder he concealed himself in the house
from where the accused was apprehended.
(iii)
It is further stated that the prosecution has been able to
complete the chain of circumstances in the case of
circumstantial evidence. The accused after committing the
murder of the deceased went to the house of other victims of
the case and has stated about the murder. He has also injured
the informant and his mother. So, in all circumstances the
prosecution has ably proved that the accused is the only
person who had committed murders. Hence, the prosecution
has proved the charges leveled against the appellant beyond
all shadow of reasonable doubt and the accused is fit to be
convicted.
22.
Learned counsel for the State, based upon the aforesaid grounds has
submitted that the impugned judgement needs no interference.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Analysis
23.
Heard the learned Counsel for the parties.
24.
In course of trial, the prosecution had examined altogether 11
witnesses. The depositions of prosecution witnesses are being referred
herein25.
P.W.-1 Shambhu Soren is the brother of the accused Chunnu
Manjhi. He has deposed that on 23.02.2019 at around 4:00 am accused
Chunnu Manjhi had killed his brother Ravi Manjhi and his three sons by an
axe. He had also lit on fire a motorcycle, house and some articles and he had
pushed his mother. The police had arrested the accused Chunnu Manjhi and
he was telling that he will kill all the remaining persons, when he will return
back.
26.
In his cross-examination, P.W.-1 stated that on the day of the
incident his leg was fractured and he was sleeping in the house. He had not
seen Chunnu Manjhi burning bike, house and other articles but had seen the
articles burning. He cannot say who had taken Chunnu Manjhi to Mental
Hospital. After the accused had committed murder, then they heard halla
that accused Chunnu Manjhi had committed the incident. He has stated that
they are five brothers and eldest among them is Budhrai Soren, who is dead,
second is Ravi Soren(deceased), then he himself, fourth brother is Som
Manjhi and fifth one is accused Chunnu Manjhi (appellant herein). P.W.-1
further stated that Ravi Soren (deceased), had sold one katha of land for one
lakh rupees and money was distributed among the five brothers amounting
to Rs.20,000/- each. All the brothers reside separately but their lands are
common. His mother stays in the house of Budhrai and adjacent to the
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
house, there is house of Bhogen Tudu and Rabindra Pramanik. He had not
given any statement earlier and for the first time he was deposing in the
court.
27.
P.W.- 2 Chaita Soren has also deposed that on 23.02.2019 at
around 4:00 p.m., when they were sleeping Chunnu Manjhi had killed Ravi
Manjhi, his three children and wife by an axe. Chunnu Manjhi had assaulted
his grandmother as a result her waist was fractured. Accused had also
pushed his grandmother. When he woke up at 4:00 a.m., and entered the
room where Chunnu Manjhi had committed murder, there he saw axe in the
hand of Chunnu Manjhi. Chunnu Manjhi had chased him but he fled away.
Chunnu Manjhi was telling that when he will return, he will kill others.
Chunnu Manjhi had also burnt the motorcycle, house and household articles.
28.
In his cross-examination P.W.-2 stated that at the time of the
incident he was sleeping so he had not witnessed the incident. When he
woke up on halla of fire, he found the house of Ravi Uncle burning. Prior to
the incident they were having good relationship with Chunnu Manjhi. Two
weeks before the incident, his all uncle had sold a land to someone for way,
and all had received their share of money. He had heard that Chunnu Manjhi
was mentally unfit and was taken to Ranchi but cannot say who took him.
He had not given any statement before the police.
29.
P.W.-3 Harendra Singh had stated in his evidence that on
23.02.2019, he was in his house at Purisili. In the morning, he came to know
from villagers that Chunnu Manjhi had killed his brother Ravi Manjhi, his
wife Kalpana Majhian and their three children Jiten Manjhi, Puresh Manjhi
and Suresh Manjhi by an axe and he had burnt their houses. When he went
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
there, he saw Ravi Manjhi and his whole family were lying dead. Then, they
informed about the incident to the police. Later, he came to know that there
was dispute regarding land among the brothers.
30.
In his cross-examination P.W.-3 stated that he cannot say as to who
told him about the incident and he has no personal knowledge of it. He had
gone to the place of occurrence at 6 am in the morning and at that time
Bhagan Tudu, Badal Tudu and 8 to 10 females were present at the place of
occurrence. The police had recorded his statement on 23.02.2019 at 11 am.
The accused was mentally fit and he had no knowledge that brother of the
accused had taken the accused to Ranch for treatment. He has no personal
knowledge about the land dispute of the accused. Accused is a co-villager
so, he knew the accused.
31.
P.W.-4 Uttam Singh has stated in his evidence that the incident
took place in the night of 22-23.02.2019. He was sleeping in the house in the
same village and on the next day he came to know that there was murder of
five persons in the Pudisili Sadar Tola. He went to the house of Ravi Manjhi
(deceased) and saw five dead bodies and the person who had committed the
incident was hiding inside. The murder was committed by an axe. Ravi
Manjhi, his wife Kalpana Devi and their three children Jiten Manjhi, Puresh
Manjhi and Suresh Manjhi were murdered. Chunnu Manjhi was arrested by
the police.
32.
In the cross-examination P.W.4 stated that Sardar Tola is 1½
kilometer North of his house. He had reached the house of accused Chunnu
Manjhi at 5:00 am. The dead bodies were in the room of Ravi Manjhi. When
he reached there, then after 15-20 minutes, administration came there.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Harendra Singh Sardar, who is the mukhiya, had told him that the accused is
hiding inside. The house of the accused Chunnu Manjhi is 10 steps from the
place from where the dead bodies were recovered. He does not know
whether Chunnu Manjhi is mentally unfit. The police had taken his
statement. He does not know whether there was a land dispute between the
accused and their brothers.
33.
P.W.-5 Rai Muni Majhiyan, is the sister-in-law (babhi) of the
informant. She had stated in her evidence that 4 years ago accused Chunnu
Manjhi had cut Ravi Majhi, Parvati Majhian, Suresh Manjhi, Paresh Manjhi
and Jiten Manjhi, with an axe. Her mother-in-law Guruwari Majhian was
also assaulted as a result her waist was fractured. Chunnu Manjhi had burnt
three houses. Accused Chunnu Manjhi had burnt her two houses and
motorcycle of Sidhu Soren (informant) was also burnt. She was locked in a
room and accused Chunnu Manjhi had also broke the Asbestos sheet.
34.
In her cross-examination P.W.-5 stated that her parental home is at
Deoghar and it took one hour to go from her parental home to her
matrimonial home. In her matrimonial home in village Purisili, she resides
with her mother-in-law, brother-in-law Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6) and son and
they reside in one house. The incident is of 4-4.30 am and at that time all
were sleeping. Accused Chunnu Manjhi is not insane and he had not gone to
Ranchi. They were having good relationship with the family of Chunnu
Manjhi.
35.
P.W.-6 Sidhu Soren, is the informant of the case. Informant has
stated in his evidence that on 23.02.2019, he was sleeping with his mother in
his house at Purisili and in the morning at around 4:00 am, accused Chunnu
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Manjhi came to his house and started hitting the door and was telling that he
has killed Ravi Manjhi, Parvati Manjhi and their children Jiten Manjhi,
Suresh Manjhi and Paresh Manjhi by an axe and he threatened to kill him.
When he opened the door, then, Chunnu Manjhi gave blow of axe to which
he caught his hand. He received the injury on his head and was treated in
M.G.M. hospital. Thereafter, Chunnu Manjhi came with dawli, then he ran
away and entered in the house of his neighbor Bhagan Tudu and locked the
door. Accused Chunnu Manjhi finding his mother Guruwari Majhian alone
surrounded her and assaulted her as a result there was fracture on her waist
and leg and she was also treated in M.G.M. Hospital. The police came and
apprehended Chunnu Manjhi. Chunnu Manjhi was saying that he had lit the
house on fire and had killed Ravi Manjhi and family of Ravi Manjhi and
will kill them also. Informant had identified his signature on the fardbeyan,
which was marked as Ext.P-1/P.W.6.
36.
In his cross-examination informant stated that accused Chunnu
Manjhi is his own elder brother. He is immediate neighbour of Chunnu
Manjhi. Chunnu Manjhi was saying that he had killed Ravi Manji and his
family members but he (informant) had not witnessed the incident of killing
them. He had concealed himself in the house of Bhagan Tadu and came out
at 7:00 a.m., when the police came. The police had read over him, the
content of the fardbeyan, after which he had signed on it.
37.
P.W. 7 Dr. Vishnudeo Prasad Sah deposed that on 23.02.2019, he
was posted as Medical Officer at Sadar Hospital, Seraikella. On that day at
01:00 p.m., he conducted post-mortem examination over the dead body of
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Puresh Manjhi, Male aged about 11 yeas S/O Ravi Manjhi. On examination,
he found following ante-mortem injuries present over body: A. External finding:
1. These is deep cut injury over the front of neck measuring 8 x 6 x 2 cm in
diameter with tracheal bone fracture.
2. There is also another cut injury over the back of left ear measuring 4 x 2x 1
cm in diameter.
B. Internal finding:
1. Brain and meninges intact pale, and congested;
2. Lungs- both lungs is intact and pale;
3. Heart- is intact and chamber empty;
4. Stomach-intact and contain undigested food particle;
5. Small intestine- is intact and contain semi digested food;
6. Large intestine- is intact and contain faecal matter and gases;
7. Livers- is intact and pale;
8. Spleen-is intact and pale;
9. Kidney- Both kidneys are intact and pale;
Time since death-within 5 to 12 hours
Object used-hard, heavy and sharp object,
Cause of death- Cardio-respiratory failure due to haemorrhagic and
traumatic shock.
The post-mortem report of the deceased Puresh Manjhi was marked
as P-2/PW-7.
38.
On the same day Doctor conducted the post-mortem of Ravi Manjhi
and found following injuries: External Examination:
There is deep cut injury over the right perital region with fracture
corresponding bone measuring 13 x 4 x 2 cm in diameter, otherwise
there is no external injuries seen in whole body.
Internal Examination: 1) Brain and meaningeses- intact and pale.
ii) Lungs- Both lungs intact and pale,
iii) Heart- is intact and chamber empty,
iv) Stomach -is intact and contain undigested food particles,
v) Small intestine intact and contain semi digested food,
vi) Large intestine- intact and contain faecal matter and gases,
vii) Liver-intact and pale,
viii) Spleen-intact and pale,
ix) Kidney-both kidney intact and pale,
Time since death 5 to 12 hours.
Object used-hard heavy and sharp object,
Cause of death-cardio-respiratory arrest due to hemorrhagic and neurogenic
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
shock
The post-mortem report of the deceased Ravi Manjhi was marked
as P-2/1PW-7.
39.
On the same day Doctor conducted the post-mortem of Kalpana
Devi, 40 years old W/o Ravi Manjhi, and found following injuries External Examination: 1) There is deep cut injury over the right side of nose measuring 12 x
4 x 5 cm in diameter, with fracture meaxillary bone;
ii) There is another cut injury just below the right ear measuring 2 x 2
x1 cm in diameter,
iii) There is 3rd cut injury over the occipital region measuring 3 x 2 x 1
cm in diameter,
Internal Examination: i) Brain and meaningeses- intact and pale and congested,
ii) Lungs- Both lungs intact and pale,
iii) Heart is intact and chamber empty,
iv) Stomach is intact and contain undigested food particles,
v) Small intestine- intact and contain semi digested food,
vi) Large intestine intact and contain faecal matter and gases,
vii) Liver intact and pale,
viii) Spleen-intact and pale,
ix) Kidney-both kidney intact and pale,
Time since death 5 to 12 hours.
Object used-hard heavy and sharp object,
Cause of death-cardio-respiratory arrest due to hemorrhagic and neurogenic
shock.
The post-mortem report of the deceased of Kalpana Devi was marked
as P-2/2/PW-7.
40.
On the same day Doctor conducted the post-mortem of Jiten Manjhi,
15 years old S/o Ravi Manjhi and found injuries as followsExternal Examination:1) There is deep cut injury over the front of neck with trachean bone
fracture measuring 8 x 6 x 2 cm in diameter,
ii) There is burn injury over the both hand abdomen and left leg.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
iii) There is also cut injury over the left ear measuring 3 x 2 x 1 cm in
diameter,
Internal Examination:i) Brain and meaningeses- intact and pale and congested.
ii) Lungs-Both lungs intact and pale,
iii) Heart- is intact and chamber empty.
iv) Stomach is intact and contain undigested food particles,
v) Small intestine- intact and contain semi digested food,
vi) Large intestine-intact and contain faecal matter and gases,
vii) Liver intact and pale,
viii) Spleen-intact and pale,
ix) Kidney-both kidney intact and pole,
Time since death 5 to 12 hours
Object used-hard heavy and sharp object,
Cause of death-cardio-respiratory arrest due to hemorrhagic and
neurogenic shock
The post-mortem report of the deceased of Jiten Manjhi was
marked as P-2/3/PW-7.
41.
On the same day Doctor had conducted the post-mortem of Suresh
Manjhi, 13 years old, S/0 Ravi Manjhi, and found injuries External Examination:1) There is deep cut injury over the occipito perital region measuring
5 x 4 x 2 cm
in diameter with bulging out of brain material,
ii) There is another incised injury over the occipital region measuring
3 x 2 x 1 cm diameter two in number adjacent to each other of same
size,
iii) There is also fracture of right shoulder.
Internal Examination:i) Brain and meaningeses intact and pale and congested,
ii) Lungs- Both lungs intact and pale,
iii) Heart- is intact and chamber empty,
iv) Stomach is intact and contain undigested food particles,
v) Small intestine-intact and contain semi digested food,
vi) Large intestine intact and contain faecal matter and gases,
vii) Liver- intact and pale,
viii) Spleen-intact and pale,
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
ix) Kidney-both kidney intact and pale,
Time since death 5 to 12 hours
Object used- hard heavy and sharp object
Cause of death-cardio-respiratory arrest due to haemorrhagic and
neurogenic shock.
The post-mortem report of the deceased of Suresh Manjhi was
marked as P-2/4/PW-7.
42.
P.W.-8 Ropna Ram Kanshi, is the Investigating Officer of the
case. Investigating Officer has stated in his evidence that on 23.02.2019, he
was posted as ASI in Chandil (Kapali) Police Station. ASI Shiv Shankar
Prasad had recorded the fardbeyan of Sidhu Soren which is in his
handwriting and bears his signature to which he identifies and the fardbeyan
was marked as Ext. P-1/1 P.W.8. This fardbeyan was forwarded to Chandil
Police Station by Shiv Shankar Prasad and the endorsement on the
fardbeyan was marked as Ext.P-1/2 PW8 and the endorsement in the
fardbeyan was written by officer-in-charge Ranbijay Singh and bears his
signature to which identifies and is marked as Ext.P-1/3/PW.8. The formal
F.L.R. is in the pen and bears the signature of officer-in-charge Ranbijay
Singh which he identifies and is marked as Ext.P-3/P.W.8.
43.
Investigating Officer further stated that after taking over the charge
of investigation he perused the inquest report of Ravi Manjhi, Kalpana
Majhian, Jiten Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi, Puresh Manjhi which was prepared
by ASI Sanjay Kumar Singh and is in his pen and bears his signature to
which he identifies and the inquest reports are marked as Ext.P-4/P.W.8, P4/1/PW.8, P-4/2/PW.8, P-4/3/P.W.8 and P-4/4P.W.8. The challan of the
dead bodies was prepared by ASI Sanjay Kumar Singh and bears his
signature to which he identifies and is marked as Ext. P-5/PW.8, P-5/1/
P.W.8, P-5/2/P.W.8, P-5/3/P.W.8, P-5/4/ PW.8. The arrest memo of accused
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Chunnu Manjhi was prepared by ASI Shiv Shankar Prasad and bears his
signature to which he identifies and is marked as Ext.P-6/PW.8. In the
presence of independent witnesses Bhagan Tudu and Bablu Tudu he had
seized three axes with wooden handle, blood stained bed and blood stained
clothes of accused Chunnu Manjhi and accordingly prepared the seizure list
to which he identifies and is marked as Ext.P-7/P.W.8.
44.
Investigating Officer further stated that he visited the place of the
occurrence which is 5 in numbers. The first place of occurrence is the house
of deceased Ravi Manjhi in Sardar Tola Pudisili. To the north of the
courtyard, there is two rooms and in the eastern room the dead bodies of
Kalpana Majhian, Jiten Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and Paresh Manjhi were
recovered. In this room bed was found and, on the bed, and on the wall of
the room, blood was found. The second place of occurrence is room of Ravi
Manjhi and he was sleeping in a cot from where his dead body was
recovered. The third place of occurrence is the mud straw house of accused
Chunnu Manjhi in which accused had himself set the house on fire. The
fourth places of occurrence are the room of Guruwari Manjhi adjacent to it
is veranda and in the veranda a motorcycle and bicycle was kept and the
accused had lit the same on fire. The fifth place of occurrence is the house of
the informant Sidhu Soren, which is house of mud built by wood and straw
and here informant’s motorcycle and other articles were also lit on fire by
the accused.
45.
Investigating Officer further stated that during the investigation he
recorded the statement of Shambhu Soren, Chaitan Soren, Guruwari
Majhian, Uttam Singh and Harendra Singh and all have supported the case.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
In course of investigation, SFSL Team, Ranchi, had seized material and the
seized materials were sent to SFSL, Ranchi for examination. The inspection
application contained the signature of Dr. Ajay Kumar, the Deputy Director
SFSL Ranchi and Dr. Amit Kumar and ASI Shiv Shankar Prasad to which
he identifies is marked as Ext.P-8/PW.8. The confessional statement of the
accused Chhunu Manjhi was recorded by him and bears his signature to
which he identifies and is marked as Ext.P-9/P.W.8. He took the restatement of informant and the statement of Rai Mani Majhian. The seized
articles were sent to SFSL and its receipt is marked as Ext.P-10/P.W.8 and
vide Letter No.127/2019 dated 28.02.2019, the seized articles were sent to
SFSL which also bears the signature of S.D.J.M. which is in three sheets to
which he identifies and is marked as Ext.P-11/P.W.8. On the basis of
supervision note and finding the case true he submitted charge sheet against
the accused Chhunu Manjhi @ Putru u/s 302,307, 326, 427, 440, 506 and
436 of 1.P.C. Investigating Officer had identified the accused.
46.
In his cross-examination Investigating Officer stated that on
23.02.2019 five persons were murdered. After the incident accused Chunnu
Manjhi burnt his house and hide himself in the house of his neighbour
Bhagan Tudu. The accused was having an axe in his hand which was stained
with blood. During the investigation the neighbours of the accused Bhagan
Tudu, Sidhu Soren, Rai Mani Soren and Guruwari Soren had stated that
accused Chunnu Manjhi had committed the murder by means of axe.
47.
P.W.-9 Bhagan Tudu has deposed that on 23.02.2019 at 8:00 am,
the police had seized three axes which had wooden handles, blood stained
bed of the deceased, blood stained clothes of accused from the house of
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
deceased and prepared its seizure list and he had signed on it as seizure list
witness to which he identified and is marked as Ext. P-7/1/P.W.-9. On that
day the police had arrested accused Chunnu Manjhi and he had signed arrest
memo as witness to which he identified and is marked as Ext.P-6/1/P.W.-9.
In his cross-examination he stated that he had signed the seizure list at the
police station.
48.
P.W.-10 Bablu Tudu had deposed that on 23.2.2019 at around
08:00 am, the police had seized three axes which had wooden handles, blood
stained bed, blood stained clothes of accused from the house of deceased
and prepared its seizure list and he had signed on it as seizure list witness to
which he identifies and is marked as Ext. P-7/2/PW10. On that day the
police had arrested accused Chunnu Manjhi and he had signed on the arrest
memo as witness to which he identifies and is marked as Ext. P-6/2/PW10.
In the cross-examination he stated that he has signed the seizure list in the
police station. He has no personal knowledge of the incident.
49.
P.W.-11 ASI Hira Lal Mundu had produced the materials Exhibits
of this case in the court which was received from SFSL Ranchi.
The
material Exhibits were sealed in white markin cloths in which FSL444/2019 was written with black pen.
50.
Before proceeding further, it would be fruitful to discuss the
admitted facts which has come in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
and documentary evidence. The admitted facts are as follows –
i.
Five persons of the same family namely Ravi Manjhi (age-50
years) and Kalpana@ Parwati (age-40 years), both spouse and
their three sons Jiten Manjhi (age-15 years), Suresh Manjhi
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
(age-13years) and Puresh Manjhi (age-11 years), were
murdered in the night of 23.02.2019, in their house.
ii.
51.
There is no eyewitness, to the said occurrence .
This Court, on the basis of the aforesaid factual aspect vis-à-vis
argument advanced on behalf of parties, is now proceeding to examine the
legality and propriety of the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence by formulating following issues to be answered by this Court:
i.
Whether there is vital contradiction in the evidence as to
discovery of bodies from the first and second place of occurrence i.e.
rooms of the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi vis-à-vis inquest reports
wherein bodies were shown found in the courtyard of the house?
ii.
Whether seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, pertaining to the alleged
recovery of three axes and blood stain clothes wore by the accused,
said to be recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi),
was prepared before the information received in the concerned police
station?
iii.
Whether the alleged recovery of three axes vide seizure list Ext.P7/PW8, said to be recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi
Manjhi), can be treated as cogent evidence to prove the culpability of
the appellant in the alleged commission of crime.
iv.
Whether the alleged recovery of the blood stain clothes (Ext.P-
7/PW8) wore by the accused, said to be recovered from the house of
the deceased (Ravi Manjhi), can be treated as cogent evidence to
prove the culpability of the appellant in the alleged commission of
crime.
v.
Whether acquittal of the appellant for the charges under section
307 and section 326 of IPC for giving axe blow and causing grievous
hurt to Guruwari Majhiyan (informant’s mother), has adversely
affected the prosecution case?
vi.
Whether the material as has come in course of trial is sufficient
to prove the charge under section 427 of the Indian Penal Code?
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
vii.
Whether the testimony of P.W.-6 (informant) and P.W.-2 Chaita
Soren, is cogent, reliable and trustworthy to convict the appellant?
viii.
Whether the trial Court, while convicting the appellant, has
committed any illegality or not?
ix.
Whether on the basis of the testimony of oral as well as
documentary evidence, can it be said to be a case based on
circumstantial evidence or if it based upon the circumstantial
evidence the chain is being completed or not?
Re: Issue No. (i)
52.
Regarding the issue i.e. whether there is vital contradiction in the
evidence as to discovery of bodies from the first and second place of
occurrence i.e. rooms of the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi vis-à-vis inquest
reports wherein bodies were shown found in the courtyard of the house?
53.
In this regard this Court has firstly gone into the fardbeyan and
testimony of the informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6), who is the brother of the
Ravi Manjhi (deceased). But, surprisingly informant neither in his fardbeyan
nor in his testimony had stated that when he had seen the dead bodies of five
persons, where the dead bodies were laying.
54.
Further, P.W.-1 Shambhu Soren, P.W.-2 Chaita Soren and P.W.-5
Rai Muni Manjhiyan, who are brother, nephew and sister-in-law(bhabhi)
respectively of the Ravi Manjhi (deceased) had also not stated in their
evidence that where they had firstly seen the dead bodies of the five
deceased persons.
55.
Further, P.W.-3 Harendra Singh and P.W.-4 Uttam Singh, appears to
be independent witness.
56.
P.W.-3 Harendra Singh had also not stated in his evidence that
where the five dead bodies were lying, when he had witnessed the five dead
bodies at first instance.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
57.
But, the other independent witness P.W.-4 Uttam Singh, had
specifically stated in his cross-examination that body of the five deceased
persons were in the room of Ravi Manjhi (deceased). For ready reference the
aforesaid part of testimony of P.W.-4, is being quoted as under:
“9. रिव मां झी के
म म पाँ चों लाश था। मृत
िकस रं ग का कपड़ा
पहने थे नहीं बता सकते ह।“
58.
Hence, fact remains that none of the witnesses i.e. P.W.-1, P.W.-2,
P.W.-3, P.W.-5 including the seizure list witnesses P.W.-9 and P.W.-10, had
stated in their evidence that where they had witnessed the dead bodies
except P.W.-4 Uttam Singh, who had stated in his cross-examination that
body of the five deceased persons were in the room of Ravi Manjhi
(deceased).
59.
Now, coming to the evidence of the investigating officer Ropna Ram
Kanshi (P.W.-8), regarding the place of recovery of the dead bodies of the
five deceased persons.
60.
The investigating officer had stated in his evidence that in the
present case there are five places of occurrence and at first and second place
of occurrence dead bodies of five deceased persons were recovered.
61.
The investigating officer had deposed that the first place of
occurrence is the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi in Sardar Tola at village
Pudisili. To the north of the courtyard, there is two room and in the eastern
room the dead bodies of Kalpana Majhian, Jiten Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and
Puresh Manjhi were found. The second place of occurrence is room of Ravi
Manjhi (deceased) and he was sleeping in a cot and here dead body of Ravi
Manjhi (deceased) was found. For ready reference the aforesaid part of
testimony of the investigating officer, is being quoted as under:
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
“6.अनुसंधान के
म म सभी मृतकों के शव को पो माटम हे तु सदर
अ ताल सरायकेला भेजा गया। अनुसंधान के
म म घटना ल का
अवलोकन िकया। इस कां ड म पाँ च घटना ल है । पहला घटना ल कपाली,
चां िडल थाना से करीब 8 िकमी० पि म-दि ण कोण पर ाम पुडीिसली म
सरदार टू ला मृतक रिव मां झी का घर
त है । घर के आगे ऑगन के उ र म
दो कमरा है । पि म वाले कमरा म पुआल रखा है । पूरब वाले कमरे म मृितका
क ना मझयाइन, िजतेन मां झी, सुरेश मां झी एवं पुरेश मां झी का शव पाया
गया। इसी कमरे म ाथिमकी अिभयु
चु मां झी के ारा उपरो
चारों
यों को मारकर ह ा करने की बात बतायी गयी है । कमरा म िबछावन
लगा आ पाया है । िबछावन एवं कमरा म खून लगा आ पाया गया है । उ र
वाले दीवार म करीब 3 फीट तक खून का िछ ् टा और दाग, दि ण वाले
दीवार म करीब 1 फीट तक खून का दाग का िछट् ा पाया गया है । कमरे का
दरवाजा सटा आ पाया गया। ाथिमकी अिभयु
सोये ए अव
के ारा दरवाजा खोलकर
म टां गी (कु ाड़ी) से मारकर ह ा करने की बात बतायी
जाती है । इस घटना ल के पूरव म मृतक रिव मां झी का ही एक कमरा जो
एलवे र से है ।
घटना ल का चौह ी जो िन
कार से है - पूरव म मृतक रिव मां झी का
एलबे र से बना एक कमरा, उसके बाद नीज जमीन, पि म म पी०सी०सी०
रोड, दि ण म वादी एवं मृतक का नीज जमीन है ।
इस कां ड का दू सरा घटना ल कपाली ओपी से 8 िकमी ० ाम पुडीिसली
त मृतक रिव मां झी का कमरा है जो 30/14 फीट का बना है जो एलवे र
से छाया है । इस कमरा म दरवाजा लगा आ नही या। कमरा म खॉट िबछा
आ था। इसी खॉट म मृतक रिव मां झी सोया आ था। खॉट पर ही मृतक
रिव मां झी का शव पड़ा आ पाया गया है । मृतक का िसर उ र तथा पैर
दि ण िदशा की ओर पाया गया है । मृतक के नाक एवं मुँह से खून िनकला
आ पाया गया है । खॉट के नीचे भी खून का ध ा पाया गया है । ाथिमकी
अिभयु
चु ु मां झी के ारा रिवा मां झी को टां गी से काटकर ह ा की बात
बताई जाती है ।“
62.
Hence, it is the specific testimony of the investigating officer that all
the five dead bodies were found in two rooms of the house of Ravi
Manjhi(deceased) and investigating officer had also given specific location
of the rooms from where dead bodies were found i.e. bodies of Kalpana
Majhian, Jiten Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and Puresh Manjhi were found in the
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
eastern room and this room is to the north of the courtyard and the dead
body of Ravi Manjhi was found in the another room.
63.
But, in the inquest reports of the five deceased persons, the dead
bodies were shown to be found in the courtyard and at the door of the house
instead of bodies being found in the two rooms of the house of Ravi
Manjhi(deceased), situated in the north of the courtyard as stated by the
investigating officer (P.W.-8) and also by P.W.-4 (Uttam Singh).
64.
On perusal of inquest reports of the deceased persons Kalpana
Majhian, Jiten Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and Puresh Manjhi marked as Ext.4/1/PW8, Ext.-4/2/PW8, Ext.-4/3/PW8 and Ext.-4/4/PW8 respectively, this
Court finds that in these inquest reports bodies of Kalpana Majhian, Jiten
Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and Puresh Manjhi were mentioned to be found in
the courtyard and in the inquest report Ext.-4/PW8 of Ravi Manjhi, body of
Ravi Manjhi, was mentioned to be found at his door.
65.
Hence, there is material contradiction in the evidence of the
investigating officer (P.W.-8) and Uttam Singh (P.W.-4) vis-à-vis inquest
reports of the deceased persons, wherein both the investigating officer and
Uttam Singh(P.W.-4), in their testimony, had specifically stated that they
had witnessed the five dead body in the two rooms of the house of Ravi
Manjhi(deceased) ,but, contrary to that in the inquest reports of the five
deceased persons, the four bodies i.e bodies of Kalpana Majhian, Jiten
Manjhi, Suresh Manjhi and Puresh Manjhi were mentioned to be found in
the courtyard and the body of Ravi Manjhi (deceased) is said to be found at
the door of his house.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
66.
At this juncture, it needs to refer herein the settled position of law
that not every discrepancy or contradiction matters for assessing the
reliability and credibility of a witness, unless the discrepancies and
contradictions are so material that it destroys the substratum of the
prosecution case.
67.
Reference in this regard be made to the judgment rendered by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in case of Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta (Dr.) v.
State of Maharashtra, (2010) 13 SCC 657, wherein Apex court has dealt
material contradiction, which is quoted for ready reference“30. While appreciating the evidence, the court has to take into
consideration whether the contradictions/omissions had been of such
magnitude that they may materially affect the trial. Minor
contradictions, inconsistencies, embellishments or improvements on
trivial matters without effecting the core of the prosecution case
should not be made a ground to reject the evidence in its entirety. The
trial court, after going through the entire evidence, must form an
opinion about the credibility of the witnesses and the appellate court
in normal course would not be justified in reviewing the same again
without justifiable reasons. (Vide State v. Saravanan1.)
31. Where the omission(s) amount to a contradiction, creating a
serious doubt about the truthfulness of a witness and the other witness
also makes material improvements before the court in order to make
the evidence acceptable, it cannot be safe to rely upon such evidence.
(Vide State of Rajasthan v. Rajendra Singh2.)
32. The discrepancies in the evidence of eyewitnesses, if found to be
not minor in nature, may be a ground for disbelieving and
discrediting their evidence. In such circumstances, witnesses may not
inspire confidence and if their evidence is found to be in conflict and
contradiction with other evidence or with the statement already
recorded, in such a case it cannot be held that the prosecution proved
its case beyond reasonable doubt. (Vide Mahendra Pratap Singh v.
State of U.P.3)
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
33. In case, the complainant in the FIR or the witness in his statement
under Section 161 CrPC, has not disclosed certain facts but meets the
prosecution case first time before the court, such version lacks
credence and is liable to be discarded. (Vide State v. Sait4.)
34. In State of Rajasthan v. Kalki5, while dealing with this issue, this
Court observed as under : (SCC p. 754, para 8)
“8. … In the depositions of witnesses there are always normal
discrepancies however honest and truthful they may be. These
discrepancies are due to normal errors of observation, normal errors
of memory due to lapse of time, due to mental disposition such as
shock and horror at the time of the occurrence, and the like. Material
discrepancies are those which are not normal, and not expected of a
normal person.”
35. The courts have to label the category to which a discrepancy
belongs. While normal discrepancies do not corrode the credibility of
a party’s case, material discrepancies do so. (See Syed Ibrahim v.
State of A.P.6 and Arumugam v. State7.)
36. In Bihari Nath Goswami v. Shiv Kumar Singh8 this Court
examined the issue and held: (SCC p. 192, para 9)
“9. Exaggerations per se do not render the evidence brittle. But it can
be one of the factors to test the credibility of the prosecution version,
when the entire evidence is put in a crucible for being tested on the
touchstone of credibility.”
37. While deciding such a case, the court has to apply the aforesaid
tests. Mere marginal variations in the statements cannot be dubbed as
improvements as the same may be elaborations of the statement made
by the witness earlier. The omissions which amount to contradictions
in material particulars i.e. go to the root of the case/materially affect
the trial or core of the prosecution case, render the testimony of the
witness liable to be discredited.”
68.
Likewise, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Shyamal Ghosh v.
State of West Bengal, reported in (2012) 7 SCC 646, wherein, paragraphs46, it has been held as under:
“46. Then, it was argued that there are certain discrepancies and
contradictions in the statement of the prosecution witnesses inasmuch
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
as these witnesses have given different timing as to when they had
seen the scuffling and strangulation of the deceased by the accused. It
is true that there is some variation in the timing given by PW 8, PW 17
and PW 19. Similarly, there is some variation in the statement of PW
7, PW 9 and PW 11. Certain variations are also pointed out in the
statements of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 6 as to the motive of the accused
for commission of the crime. Undoubtedly, some minor discrepancies
or variations are traceable in the statements of these witnesses. But
what the Court has to see is whether these variations are material and
affect the case of the prosecution substantially. Every variation may
not be enough to adversely affect the case of the prosecution.
69.
Thus, from the aforesaid proposition of law it is evident that minor
discrepancies, embellishments and contradictions in the evidence of the
eyewitness do not destroy the essential fabric of the prosecution case, the
core of which remains unaffected. But at the same time, it is equally settled
that the discrepancies which go to the root of the matter and shake the basic
version of the witnesses that can be annexed with due importance.
70.
Now, reverting back to the fact of the present case, this court finds
that vital contradiction has cropped up in the prosecution case as to place
recovery of five dead bodies as the investigating officer had specifically
stated in his evidence that he found all the five dead bodies in the rooms,
situated to the north of the courtyard of the house of Ravi
Manjhi(deceased),but, contrary to this in the inquest reports Ext.-4/1/PW8,
Ext.-4/2/PW8, Ext.-4/3/PW8 and Ext.-4/4/PW8, of the five deceased
persons, bodies were mentioned to be found in the courtyard of the house,
which are self-contradictory.
71.
Hence, from the forgoing discussion, this court comes to the
conclusion that there is vital contradiction in the evidence as to discovery of
bodies from the first and second place of occurrence i.e. rooms of the house
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
of deceased Ravi Manjhi vis-à-vis inquest reports wherein bodies were
shown found in the courtyard of the house.
72.
So, this court is of the view that prosecution evidence is self-
contradictory as to the place of recovery of the bodies of the deceased
persons.
73.
Accordingly, issue no.(i) is hereby answered.
Re: issue no.(ii)
74.
Regarding this issue whether seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, pertaining to
the alleged recovery of three axes and blood stained clothes worn by the
accused, said to be recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi),
was prepared before the information received in the concerned police
station?
75.
On going through Ext. P-7/PW8, which is the seizure list of alleged
recovery of three axes and blood stained clothes worn by the accused, which
was said to be recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi), this
court finds that in this seizure list it is mentioned that seizure list was
prepared on 23.02.2019 at 8.00 am in the morning.
76.
Informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6) had also specifically stated in his
cross-examination that police had arrived at the place of occurrence at 7 am
in the morning. Relevant part of the cross-examination of informant Sidhu
Soren, is being quoted herein:
12. म अपने पड़ोस भोगेन टु डू के घर म िछपा रहा और पुिलस के आने पर
वहाँ से िनकाला था। पुिलस लगभग 7 बजे सुबह म आयी थी। तब तक हम
वहीं िछपा रहा ।
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
77.
Hence, as per the prosecution case immediately after the murder of
five persons, at about 4 am in the morning, police had reached at the place of
occurrence and had prepared the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8.
78.
Further, in the testimony of the seizure list witnesses Bhagan
Tudu(P.W.-9) and Bablu Tudu(P.W.-10), who had stated in their evidence
that on 23.02.2019 at 8 am in the morning the police had seized three axes
which had wooden handles, blood stained bed of the deceased, blood stained
clothes worn by the accused, which were recovered from the house of
deceased and seizure list of it was prepared on which they had signed on it.
The relevant part of the testimony of seizure list witness Bhagan Tudu(P.W.9), is quoted herein below“1 िदनाक 23/2/2019 को सुबह 8 बजे ाम पुडीिसली मृतक के घर से पुिलस
ारा तीन टागी, लकड़ी का बेट लगा आ एवं मृतक का सोने वाला िब र
िजसम खून लगा कपड़◌ा तथा अिभयु
ज
का पहना
आ खून लगा कपड़ा,
कर ज ी-सुिच बनाई गई थी िजसपर गवाह के
प म मेरा ह ा र है
पहचाना ँ । ज ी-सुिच पर गवाह का ह ा र को दश P-7/1/PW9 अंिकत
िकया जाता है ।“
79.
Further, the relevant part of the testimony of seizure list witness
Bablu Tudu (P.W.-10), is quoted herein below“1.िदनां क 23/2/2019 को सुबह 8 बजे पुिलस ारा ाम पुडीिसली
मृ क के घर से तीन टागी िजसमे लकड़ी को बेट लगा लगा आ, मृतक
का सोने वाला िब र िजसमे खून लगा कपड़ा तथा अिभयु
आ कपड़ा िजसमे खून लगा आ ज
िजसपर गवाह के
का पहना
कर ज ी-सूिच बनाई गई थी
प म मेरा ह ा र है पहचानता ं िजसे दश P-
7/2/PW10 अंिकत िकया जाता है ।”
80.
Hence, from the testimony of both the seizure list witnesses, it is
obvious that on 23.02.2019 at 8 am in the morning the police had seized the
alleged three axes and blood stained clothes worn by the accused, which
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
were recovered from the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi and police had
prepared the seizure list on which both the seizure list witnesses had signed
on the seizure list at 8 am itself.
81.
But, later on, in their testimony, both these seizure list witnesses had
resiled from their earlier statement that they had signed on the seizure list at
the place of occurrence itself on 23.02.2019 at 8 am and contrary to that
stated that they had signed on the seizure list at the police station. The
relevant part of the cross-examination of seizure list witness Bablu Tudu
(P.W.-10), is quoted herein below“4. मने दोनों ह
82.
ा र थाना म िकया था।“
Hence, to test the veracity of the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8 vis-à-vis
contradictory statement of both the seizure list witnesses, this Court has
gone through the FIR.
83.
But, surprisingly, in the FIR, time of receiving information at the
police station is entered as 17.30 hours i.e. 5.30 pm in the evening on
23.02.2019 and station diary entry time is also shown as 17.30 hours and the
column of station diary entry is left blank.
84.
Hence, this leads to the conclusion that prosecution had supressed
and withheld the document containing the information regarding murder of
five deceased persons because on the one hand in the seizure list Ext.P7/PW8, date and time of preparation of seizure list is shown as 23.02.2019
at 8.00 am in the morning, but, on the other hand in the FIR, time of
receiving information at the police station is entered as 17.30 hours i.e. 5.30
pm in the evening on 23.02.2019.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
85.
This Court is of the considered view that the seizure list, Ext.
P-7/PW-8, relating to the alleged recovery of three axes and blood-stained
clothes said to have been worn by the accused and recovered from the house
of the deceased Ravi Manjhi, was prepared even prior to the receipt of
information at the concerned police station. Accordingly, the said seizure list
cannot be regarded as reliable, as it has not been prepared in a proper or
lawful manner.
86.
Accordingly, issue no. (ii), is hereby answered.
Re: issue no.(iii)
87.
Regarding this issue i.e. whether the alleged recovery of three axes
vide seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, said to be recovered from the house of the
deceased (Ravi Manjhi), can be treated as cogent evidence to prove the
culpability of the appellant in the alleged commission of crime.
88.
In this regard ongoing through Ext. P-7/PW8, which is inter alia the
seizure list of alleged recovery of three axes, this court finds that in this
seizure list it is mentioned about the seizure of ‘three axes fitted with
wooden stick’ recovered from the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi.
89.
In his cross-examination, the Investigating Officer had stated that
accused had tangi(axe) in his hand which was soaked in blood. Relevant
para of the cross-examination of the Investigating Offer is quoted for ready
reference“21. घटना के बाद अिभयु
चु ु मां झी ने
यं अपने घर पर आग लगाकर
बगल म पड़ोसी भगान टु डू के घर म छु प गया था। अिभयु
के हाथ म टां गी
था जो खून से लथपथ था।“
90.
But, surprisingly in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8 pertaining inter alia
to the recovery of ‘three axes fitted with wooden stick’, nothing is
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
mentioned that any of these axes were blood stained, though, the
Investigating Officer had stated in his cross-examination that accused had
tangi(axe) in his hand which was soaked with blood.
91.
Hence, there is vital contradiction in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8,
pertaining to the seizure of the three axes wherein only recovery of three
axes are shown and it was not mentioned in the seizure list that any of the
axes had blood stain though Investigating Officer had stated in his crossexamination that accused had tangi(axe) in his hand which was soaked with
blood.
92.
Now this court is proceeding to examine the SFL Report Ext.-12.
Here, it is pertinent note that in the SFL Report Ext.-12 under the caption
titled ‘Description of Article(s) contained in the Parcel(s)’, it mentioned at
serial no. 10 that iron rusted tangi(axe) marked as Ext.-7a, bore reddish
brown stains at places and at serial no. 11 and 12 it is mentioned that iron
rusted tangi(axe) bearing Ext.-7b and Ext.-7c respectively bore no any
distinct stains.
93.
Hence, facts remain that in the FSL report it is specifically noted that
one of the axe (tangi) i.e. Ext.-7a, which was sent to the FSL vide letter no.
127/2019 dated 28.02.2019 (Ext.P-11/PW8), bore blood stain.
94.
Then, question arises, why in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8, which is
inter alia the seizure list of alleged recovery of three axe said to be recovered
from the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi, in any of the axe, no recovery of
any blood stain axe was shown in the seizure list and it raises doubt in the
prosecution case.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
95.
Hence, this Court is of view that in the present case there was
manipulation, in the preparation of seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8, which is also
evident from the fact that when the three seized axes were sent to the FSL
vide Ext.-7 under letter no. 127/2019 dated 28.02.2019 (Ext.P-11/PW8),
FSL had noted that in one of the iron rusted tangi(axe) marked as Ext.-7a, it
bore reddish brown stains at places though in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8
no any recovery of blood stain axe was shown.
96.
Now this court is proceeding to examine the DNA report. At this
juncture, it would be pertinent to see the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court
on the issue of reliability of DNA evidence in criminal trial. Hon’ble Apex
court in case of Dharam Deo Yadav v. State of U.P., (2014) 5 SCC 509 had
laid down that question as to whether DNA tests are virtually infallible may
be a moot question, but the fact remains that such test has come to stay and
is being used extensively in the investigation of crimes and the court often
accepts the views of the experts, especially when cases rest on
circumstantial evidence. Paragraph-36 of this judgment is quoted herein
below“36. The DNA stands for deoxyribonucleic acid, which is the
biological blueprint of every life. DNA is made up of a double
stranded structure consisting of a deoxyribose sugar and phosphate
backbone, cross-linked with two types of nucleic acids referred to as
adenine and guanine, purines and thymine and cytosine pyrimidines.
The most important role of DNA profile is in the identification, such
as an individual and his blood relations such as mother, father,
brother, and so on. Successful identification of skeleton remains can
also be performed by DNA profiling. DNA usually can be obtained
from any biological material such as blood, semen, saliva, hair, skin,
bones, etc. The question as to whether DNA tests are virtually
infallible may be a moot question, but the fact remains that such test
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
has come to stay and is being used extensively in the investigation of
crimes and the court often accepts the views of the experts, especially
when cases rest on circumstantial evidence. More than half a century,
samples of human DNA began to be used in the criminal justice
system. Of course, debate lingers over the safeguards that should be
required in testing samples and in presenting the evidence in court.
DNA profile, however, is consistently held to be valid and reliable, but
of course, it depends on the quality control and quality assurance
procedures in the laboratory…”
97.
Further, in case of Anil v. State of Maharashtra, (2014) 4 SCC 69,
Apex court has laid down that DNA genotype can be obtained from any
biological material such as bone, blood, semen, saliva, hair, skin, etc. Now,
for several years, DNA profile has also shown a tremendous impact on
forensic investigation. Generally, when DNA profile of a sample found at
the scene of crime matches with the DNA profile of the suspect, it can
generally be concluded that both the samples have the same biological
origin. Paragraph-18 of this judgment is quoted herein below“18. Deoxyribonucleic acid, or DNA, is a molecule that encodes the
genetic information in all living organisms. DNA genotype can be
obtained from any biological material such as bone, blood, semen,
saliva, hair, skin, etc. Now, for several years, DNA profile has also
shown a tremendous impact on forensic investigation. Generally, when
DNA profile of a sample found at the scene of crime matches with the
DNA profile of the suspect, it can generally be concluded that both the
samples have the same biological origin. DNA profile is valid and
reliable, but variance in a particular result depends on the quality
control and quality procedure in the laboratory.”
98.
Again, in case of Pattu Rajan v. State of T.N., (2019) 4 SCC 771,
Hon’ble Apex Court had laid down that like all other opinion evidence, the
probative value accorded to DNA evidence also varies from case to case,
depending on the facts and circumstances and the weight accorded to other
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
evidence on record, whether contrary or corroborative. Relevant paragraph
of this Judgment is quoted herein below“49. One cannot lose sight of the fact that DNA evidence is also in the
nature of opinion evidence as envisaged in Section 45 of the Evidence
Act. Undoubtedly, an expert giving evidence before the court plays a
crucial role, especially since the entire purpose and object of opinion
evidence is to aid the court in forming its opinion on questions
concerning foreign law, science, art, etc., on which the court might not
have the technical expertise to form an opinion on its own. In criminal
cases, such questions may pertain to aspects such as ballistics,
fingerprint matching, handwriting comparison, and even DNA testing or
superimposition techniques, as seen in the instant case.
50. The role of an expert witness rendering opinion evidence before the
Court may be explained by referring to the following observations of this
Court in Ramesh Chandra Agrawal v. Regency Hospital Ltd. [Ramesh
Chandra Agrawal v. Regency Hospital Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC 709 : (2009) 3
SCC (Civ) 840] : (SCC p. 714, para 16)
“16. The law of evidence is designed to ensure that the court considers
only that evidence which will enable it to reach a reliable conclusion.
The first and foremost requirement for an expert evidence to be
admissible is that it is necessary to hear the expert evidence. The test is
that the matter is outside the knowledge and experience of the lay
person. Thus, there is a need to hear an expert opinion where there is a
medical issue to be settled. The scientific question involved is assumed to
be not within the court's knowledge. Thus cases where the science
involved is highly specialised and perhaps even esoteric, the central role
of an expert cannot be disputed.”
(emphasis supplied)
51. Undoubtedly, it is the duty of an expert witness to assist the Court
effectively by furnishing it with the relevant report based on his expertise
along with his reasons, so that the Court may form its independent
judgment by assessing such materials and reasons furnished by the
expert for coming to an appropriate conclusion. Be that as it may, it
cannot be forgotten that opinion evidence is advisory in nature, and the
Court is not bound by the evidence of the experts. [See State (UT of
Delhi) v. Pali Ram [State (UT of Delhi) v. Pali Ram, (1979) 2 SCC 158 :
1979 SCC (Cri) 389] ; State of H.P. v. Jai Lal [State of H.P. v. Jai Lal,
(1999) 7 SCC 280 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1184] ; Baso Prasad v. State of
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Bihar [Baso Prasad v. State of Bihar, (2006) 13 SCC 65 : (2007) 2 SCC
(Cri)
567]
; Ramesh
Chandra
Agrawal v. Regency
Hospital
Ltd. [Ramesh Chandra Agrawal v. Regency Hospital Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC
709 : (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 840] and Malay Kumar Ganguly v. Sukumar
Mukherjee [Malay Kumar Ganguly v. Sukumar Mukherjee, (2009) 9
SCC 221 : (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 663 : (2010) 2 SCC (Cri) 299] .]
52. Like all other opinion evidence, the probative value accorded to DNA
evidence also varies from case to case, depending on the facts and
circumstances and the weight accorded to other evidence on record,
whether contrary or corroborative. This is all the more important to
remember, given that even though the accuracy of DNA evidence may be
increasing with the advancement of science and technology with every
passing day, thereby making it more and more reliable, we have not yet
reached a juncture where it may be said to be infallible. Thus, it cannot
be said that the absence of DNA evidence would lead to an adverse
inference against a party, especially in the presence of other cogent and
reliable evidence on record in favour of such party.”
99.
Further, in case of Manoj v. State of M.P., (2023) 2 SCC 353,
Hon’ble Apex Court had held that reliance, on the DNA report
is corroborate and being an opinion, the probative value of such evidence
has to vary from case to case. Paragraph-158 of this judgment is quoted
herein below“158. This Court, therefore, has relied on DNA reports, in the past,
where the guilt of an accused was sought to be established. Notably,
the reliance, was to corroborate. This Court highlighted the need to
ensure quality in the testing and eliminate the possibility of
contamination of evidence; it also held that being an opinion,
the probative value of such evidence has to vary from case to case.”
100.
Hence, DNA evidence is also in the nature of opinion evidence as
envisaged in Section 45 of the Evidence Act and like all other opinion
evidence, the probative value accorded to DNA evidence also varies from
case to case, depending on the facts and circumstances.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
101.
Now, before proceeding further it would be pertinent to narrate
certain facts related to FSL Report.
102.
On perusal of record, this Court finds that apart from other articles
recovered, the three alleged recovered axes were marked as Ext.-7 and were
sent to Forensic Science Laboratory vide letter no. 127/2019 dated
28.02.2019 vide Ext.P-11/PW.8 for examination.
103.
The Conclusion of SFL Report is DFSL Report No: 444/2019
Ranchi dated 23.04.2025, which was marked as Ext.-12.
104.
From the SFL Report Ext.-12, it appears that the aforesaid three
recovered axes which were sent to the SFL vide Ext.-7, were further marked
as Ext.-7a, Ext.-7b and Ext.-7c in the laboratory, which is mentioned under
the caption ‘Description of Article(s)contained in the Parcel(s)’ Here, it is
also mentioned that iron rusted tangi(axe) marked as Ext.-7a, bore reddish
brown stains at places and rusted tangi(axe) bearing Ext.-7b and Ext.-7c
bore no any distinct stains.
105.
Further, under the caption ‘Result of examination(s)’ it is mentioned
that as a result of chemical test, blood was detected in Exhibits marked-7a at
places. It was also mentioned that as a result of chemical test blood could
not be detected in the exhibit marked 7b and 7c.
106.
Thereafter, under the caption ‘Description of source of exhibits for
DNA Profiling’, at Serial no. 10 it is mentioned blood positive Swab from
iron rusted tangi on gauze piece cuttings marked-7a and at the Serial no. 11
and 12, there is mention of blood negative Swab from iron rusted tangi on
gauze piece cuttings marked-7b and 7c.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
107.
The Conclusion of the DNA report is quoted herein below for the
ready reference“Conclusions
1. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-1a
(Source: Blood positive T-Shirt piece cuttings said to be ganji of
deceased Ravi Manjhi), Exhibit marked-10 (Source: Blood positive
cotton piece cuttings), Exhibit marked-3 (Source: Blood positive TShirt piece cuttings said to be deceased Jiten Manjhi), Exhibit
marked-8g (Source: Blood positive cloth piece cuttings), Exhibit
marked-6a (Source: Blood positive track pant piece cuttings said to be
of accused Chunun Manjhi), Exhibit marked-8a (Source: Blood
positive cloth piece cuttings), Exhibit marked-8d (Source: Blood
positive cloth piece cuttings), Exhibit marked-11h (Source: Blood
positive cotton piece cuttings), Exhibit marked-4 (Source: Blood
positive half Shirt piece cuttings said to be of deceased Suresh
Manjhi), Exhibit marked-8b (Source: Blood positive cloth piece
cuttings), Exhibit marked-81 (Source: Blood positive cloth piece
cuttings), Exhibit marked-1b (Source: Blood positive half pant piece
cuttings said to be deceased Ravi Manjhi), Exhibit marked-65
(Source: Blood positive half sleeve T-Shirt piece cuttings said to be of
Accused Chunnu Manjhi) and Elhibit marked-9b (Source: Blood
positive gauze piece cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi) is
from six different human male source of origin.
2. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-2a
(Source: Blood positive sari piece cuttings said to be deceased Kalpna
Manjhiyain), Exhibit marked-2b (Source: Blood positive blouse piece
cuttings said to be deceased Kalpna Manjhiyain), Exhibit marked-8c
(Source: Blood positive cloth piece cuttings), and Exhibit marked-8h
(Source: Blood positive cloth piece cuttings) is from one and the same
human female source of origin.
3. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-9a
(Source: Blood positive swab from plastic dibba on gauze piece
cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi) and Exhibit marked-7h
(Source: Blood negative swab from iron rusted tangi on gauze piece
cuttings) is mixed and partial DNA profile from more than one human
source of origin.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
4. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-8c
(Source: Blood positive cloth piece cuttings) is partial DNA profile
are from one and the same human source of origin.
5. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-7a
(Source: Blood positive swab from iron rusted tangi on gauze piece
cuttings) and Exhibit marked-11a (Source: Blood positive cotton piece
cuttings) is mixed DNA profile from more than one human source of
origin.
6. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-7a
(Source: Blood positive swab from iron rusted tangi on gauze piece
cuttings) is mixed DNA profile from more than one human source of
origin which is found to be present/The DNA profile generated from
the source of Exhibit marked-la (Source: Blood positive T-Shirt piece
cuttings suid to be ganji of deceased Ravi Manjhi), Exhibit marked-3
(Source: Blood positive T-Shirt piece cuttings said to be deceased
Jiten Manjhi) except three allele and Exhibit marked-6a (Source:
Blood positive track pant piece cuttings said to be of Accused Chunnu
Manjhi).
7. The DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit marked-11a
(Source: Blood positive cotton piece cuttings) is mixed DNA profile
from more than one human source of origin which is found to be
present in the DNA profile generated from the source of Exhibit
marked-la (Source: Blood positive T-Shirt piece cuttings said to be
ganji of deceased Ravi Manjhi) and Exhibit marked-4 (Source: Blood
positive half Shirt piece cuttings said to be of deceased Suresh
Manjhi).
8. The DNA profile could not be generated from the source of exhibit
marked 7c (Source: Blood negative swab from iron rusted tangi on
gauze piece cuttings amplifiable DNA could not be extracted.
Therefore, no further opinion could be furnished.”
108.
Now, out of the three alleged tangi(axe) seized, in the FSL Report
under the caption ‘Result of examination(s)’ it is mentioned that as a result
of chemical test, blood could not be detected in the exhibit marked 7b and
7c. Accordingly, regarding axe marked exhibit 7c, in the conclusion report
of DNA, it is rightly mentioned that DNA Profile could not be generated
from the source exhibit marked 7c.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
109.
Again, regarding the axe marked exhibits marked-7b, under the
caption ‘Description of source of exhibits for DNA Profiling’, at Serial no.
11, it is noted that blood negative Swab from iron rusted tangi on gauze
piece cuttings marked-7b.
110.
But, in the conclusion of the DNA Report, at serial no. 3, regarding
the axe marked exhibits marked-7b, it is noted that the DNA profile was
generated from exhibits marked-7b and its source is shown blood negative
swab from iron rusted tangi on gauge piece cutting.
111.
Hence, this Court is of view that it will not be safe to place reliance
on DNA profile generated from axe exhibits marked-7b, for two reasons firstly that no blood stain axe was seized as it is evident from the seizure list
of Ext. P-7/PW8 of the seizure of axe and also for the reason that under
‘Description of source of exhibits for DNA Profiling’ regarding axe marked
Exibit-7b, in its source it is noted blood negative Swab from iron rusted
tangi on gauze piece cuttings.
112.
Hence, now only one axe marked exhibits marked-7a remains and
DNA profile generated from axe marked exhibits marked-7a cannot be
accepted because in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8 pertaining to the three
axes, no blood stain on any of these three axes were shown in the seizure
list Ext. P-7/PW8, but, when, the three axes were sent to FSL
examination, FSL had noted under
for
the caption ‘Description of
Article(s)contained in the Parcel(s)’ that iron rusted tangi(axe) marked as
Ext.-7a, bore reddish brown stains at places.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
113.
This Court has already come to the conclusion while dealing issue
no.(ii) that seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, inter-alia pertaining to alleged recovery
of three axes, was not reliable.
114.
Hence, from the forgoing discussion this Court is of view that
alleged recovery of three axes vide seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, said to be
recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi), cannot be treated
as cogent evidence to prove the culpability of the appellant in the alleged
commission of crime and that too in present case where the prosecution case
is solely based on circumstantial evidence.
115.
Accordingly, issue no (iii) has been answered.
Re: issue no. (iv)
116.
Regarding this issue i.e. whether the alleged recovery of the blood
stain clothes vide Ext.P-7/PW8, wore by the accused, said to be recovered
from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi), can be treated as cogent
evidence to prove the culpability of the appellant in the alleged commission
of crime.
117.
In this regard ongoing through the Ext. P-7/PW8, this court finds
that in this seizure list it is mentioned about the seizure of ‘blood stain
clothes wore by the accused’ from the house of deceased Ravi Manjhi.
118.
Hence, in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8, no specific description of
clothes wore by the accused/appellant is mentioned.
119.
But, when blood stain clothes were sent to Forensic Science
Laboratory vide letter no. 127/2019 dated 28.02.2019 vide Ext.P-11/PW8
for examination, surprisingly at Serial No.6, specific description of dress
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
recovered by the Investigating Officer was shown as ‘black colour track
suit’ and ‘brown vest’, stained with blood, marked as Ext.-6.
120.
Hence, question arises why the investigating officer in the seizure
list Ext. P-7/PW8, did not specifically mentioned that accused was wearing
‘black colour track suit’ and ‘brown vest’ instead investigating officer had
only ambiguously mentioned recovery of ‘blood stain clothes wore by the
accused’.
121.
Hence, this omission by the investigating officer in preparing the
seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8 to the recovery of ‘blood stain clothes wore by the
accused’ was not normal omission, but it was manipulated to suit the
prosecution case.
122.
Now, coming to the FSL Report. On perusal of record, this Court
finds that blood stain clothes wore by the accused
was marked as Ext.-6
and was sent to Forensic Science Laboratory vide letter no. 127/2019 dated
28.02.2019 vide Ext.P-11/PW8 for examination.
123.
The Conclusion of SFL Report is DFSL Report No: 444/2019
Ranchi dated 23.04.2025, which is Ext.-12.
124.
From the SFL Report Ext.-12, it appears that track suit and vest
which was sent to the SFL vide Ext.-6, was further marked as 6a and 6b
respectively in the SFL. It was also mentioned that black colour track suit
pant marked as 6a, bore reddish brown stains over small area and the brown
colour, half sleeve t-shirt marked-6b, bore no stains.
125.
In the result of examination, blood was detected in Exhibit marked-
6a over small area.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
126.
In the SFL Report Ext.-12, it was also mentioned that as a result of
chemical test blood could not be detected in the exhibit marked -6b.
127.
In its observation at Serial No.1, it is mentioned that DNA profile
generated from Exhibit marked-6a (Source: Blood positive track pant piece
cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi) is from six different human
male source of origin.
128.
Further, in its conclusion at Serial No.1, it is mentioned that DNA
profile generated from source Exhibit marked-6a (Source: Blood positive
track pant piece cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi) and Exhibit
marked-6b (Source: Blood positive half sleeve T-Shirt cuttings said to be of
accused Chunnu Manjhi) is from six different human male source of origin.
129.
But, the SFL Report Ext.-12, pertaining to DNA profile generated
from Exhibit marked-6a (Source: Blood positive track pant piece cuttings
said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi) and Exhibit marked-6b (Source:
Blood positive half sleeve T-Shirt cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu
Manjhi), cannot be relied upon, as in the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8
pertaining to the recovery of ‘blood stain clothes wore by the accused’, it
was not mentioned that cloth which accused/ appellant was wearing during
the time of murder of the deceased persons was ‘track pant’ and ‘half sleeve
T-Shirt’. Hence, subsequently DNA profile generated from Exhibit marked6a (Source: Blood positive track pant piece cuttings said to be of accused
Chunnu Manjhi) and Exhibit marked-6b (Source: Blood positive half sleeve
T-Shirt cuttings said to be of accused Chunnu Manjhi), cannot be relied.
130.
Accordingly, on the basis of forgoing discussion, this court is of
view that alleged recovery of the blood stain clothes (Ext.P-7/PW8) wore by
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
the accused, said to be recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi
Manjhi), cannot be treated as cogent evidence to prove the culpability of the
appellant in the alleged commission of crime.
131.
Accordingly, issue no. (iv) has been herby answered.
Re: issue no.(v)
132.
Regarding this issue i.e. whether acquittal of the appellant for the
charges under section 307 and section 326 of IPC for giving axe blow and
causing grievous hurt to Guruwari Majhiyan (informant’s mother), has
adversely affected the prosecution case?
133.
This court finds that charges were framed against the appellant
under sections 307 and 326 of IPC for giving axe blow and causing grievous
hurt respectively to Guruwari Majhiyan (informant’s mother).
134.
But the learned trial court had acquitted the appellant for the charges
under sections 307 and 326 of IPC.
135.
At this juncture, this court think it apposite to refer to certain
authorities pertaining to evidentiary value of the injured eye witness.
136.
The law is well settled that the judgment of conviction can be passed
on the basis of the evidence of injured witnesses which has greater
evidentiary value and unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are
not to be discarded lightly, as per the judgment rendered by Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of State of M.P. v. Mansingh, (2003) 10 SCC 414.
Relevant paragraph of the said judgment is being referred hereunder as :- .
“The evidence of injured witnesses has greater evidentiary value and
unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are not to be
discarded lightly. Merely because there was no mention of a knife in
the first information report, that does not wash away the effect of the
evidence tendered by the injured witnesses PWs 4 and 7. Minor
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
discrepancies do not corrode the credibility of otherwise acceptable
evidence. The circumstances highlighted by the High Court to attach
vulnerability to the evidence of the injured witnesses are clearly
inconsequential. It is fairly conceded by the learned counsel for the
accused that though mere non-mention of the assailants’ names in the
requisition memo of injury is not sufficient to discard the prosecution
version in entirety, according to him it is a doubtful circumstance and
forms a vital link to determine whether the prosecution version is
credible. It is a settled position in law that omission to mention the
name of the assailants in the requisition memo perforce does not
render the prosecution version brittle.”
137.
Likewise, in case of Neeraj Sharma v. State of Chhattisgarh,
(2024) 3 SCC 125, at paragraph-22 of the judgment Hon’ble Apex Court
held as follow“22.The importance of injured witness in a criminal trial cannot be
overstated. Unless there are compelling circumstances or evidence
placed by the defence to doubt such a witness, this has to be accepted
as extremely valuable evidence in a criminal trial.”
138.
Further, in case of Birbal Nath v. State of Rajasthan, (2024) 15
SCC 190, Hon'ble Apex Court reiterated that the statement of an injured
eyewitness is an important piece of evidence which cannot be easily
discarded by a court. Minor discrepancies do not matter. Paragraph-31 of the
said judgment is quoted herein below“31. The High Court has gone wrong in its appreciation of the case,
both on facts as well as on law. The statement of an injured eyewitness
is an important piece of evidence which cannot be easily discarded by
a court. Minor discrepancies do not matter. In State of M.P. v.
Mansingh5 where conviction of the accused by the trial court, inter
alia, under Section 302, was set aside by the High Court on the socalled discrepancies of an injured witness this Court while allowing
the State’s appeal against the acquittal said this: (SCC p. 419, para 9)
“9. The evidence of injured witnesses has greater evidentiary value
and unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are not to be
discarded lightly. Merely because there was no mention of a knife in
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
the first information report, that does not wash away the effect of the
evidence tendered by the injured witnesses, PWs 4 and 7. Minor
discrepancies do not corrode the credibility of otherwise acceptable
evidence. The circumstances highlighted by the High Court to attach
vulnerability to the evidence of the injured witnesses are clearly
inconsequential.”
139.
Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Balu Sudam Khalde
v. State of Maharashtra, (2023) 13 SCC 365, has laid down certain legal
principles, which the Courts are required to keep in mind while appreciating
the evidence of an injured eyewitness. Paragraphs 26 to 27 of the said
judgment are being referred hereunder as“26. When the evidence of an injured eyewitness is to be appreciated,
the undernoted legal principles enunciated by the courts are required
to be kept in mind:
26.1. The presence of an injured eyewitness at the time and place of
the occurrence cannot be doubted unless there are material
contradictions in his deposition.
26.2. Unless, it is otherwise established by the evidence, it must be
believed that an injured witness would not allow the real culprits to
escape and falsely implicate the accused.
26.3. The evidence of injured witness has greater evidentiary value
and unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are not to be
discarded lightly.
26.4. The evidence of injured witness cannot be doubted on account of
some embellishment in natural conduct or minor contradictions.
26.5. If there be any exaggeration or immaterial embellishments in the
evidence of an injured witness, then such contradiction, exaggeration
or embellishment should be discarded from the evidence of injured,
but not the whole evidence.
26.6. The broad substratum of the prosecution version must be taken
into consideration and discrepancies which normally creep due to loss
of memory with passage of time should be discarded.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
27. In assessing the value of the evidence of the eyewitnesses, two
principal considerations are whether, in the circumstances of the
case, it is possible to believe their presence at the scene of occurrence
or in such situations as would make it possible for them to witness the
facts deposed to by them and secondly, whether there is anything
inherently improbable or unreliable in their evidence. In respect of
both these considerations, circumstances either elicited from those
witnesses themselves or established by other evidence tending to
improbabilise their presence or to discredit the veracity of their
statements, will have a bearing upon the value which a court would
attach to their evidence. Although in cases where the plea of the
accused is a mere denial, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
has to be examined on its own merits, where the accused raise a
definite plea or put forward a positive case which is inconsistent with
that of the prosecution, the nature of such plea or case and the
probabilities in respect of it will also have to be taken into account
while assessing the value of the prosecution evidence.”
140.
Thus, from the aforesaid mentioned judgments, it is evident that the
evidence of injured witness has greater evidentiary value and has to be
accepted as extremely valuable evidence in a criminal trial. The evidence of
injured witness cannot be doubted on account of some embellishment in
natural conduct or minor contradictions.
141.
In the present case, informant in his fardbeyan had stated that
appellant had assaulted his mother Guruwari Majhian.
142.
Further in his examination-in-chief also informant Sidhu Soren
(P.W.-6) had deposed that appellant had assaulted his mother Guruwari
Majhian, and broke her waist and legs and his mother was treated in
M.G.M., Hospital. Relevant part of testimony of informant the is quoted
herein below for ready reference“3. मेरे घर पर मेरी माँ गु वारी मंिझयाईन को अकेली पाकर छे ककर रखा
और बाद म उसके साथ भी मार-पीट िकया। मेरी माँ को उसने मारकर कमर
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
तथा पैर तोड़ िदया मेरी माँ का ईलाज भी एम० जी० एम० अ ताल म आ
था।“
143.
But, surprisingly alleged injured Guruwari Majhian (informant’s
mother), whose name also finds place in the charge sheet under the column
‘witnesses to be examined’, was neither examined by the prosecution nor
her injury requisition and injury report, is on record.
144.
Hence, the informant’s testimony that after the murder of Ravi
Manjhi and members of Ravi’s family, appellant had come to his house and
assaulted his mother with tangi, has no leg to stand.
145.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Balu Sudam Khalde v. State of
Maharashtra(supra), had laid down the legal principles, which the courts
are required to keep in mind while appreciating the evidence of an injured
eyewitness and at paragraph-26.2 had laid down that it must be believed that
an injured witness would not allow the real culprits to escape and falsely
implicate the accused.
146.
Prosecution, ought to have examined the alleged injured Guruwari
Majhian (informant’s mother) and that too in a case which rest entirely on
circumstantial evidence. But, in present case prosecution did not examine
the alleged injured Guruwari Majhian (informant’s mother) and hence,
prosecution case becomes doubtful.
147.
Therefore, this court is of view that acquittal of the appellant for the
charges under section 307 and section 326 of IPC for giving axe blow and
causing grievous hurt to Guruwari Majhiyan (informant’s mother), has
adversely affected the prosecution case.
148.
Accordingly, issue no.(v) is hereby answered.
Issue no.(vi)
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
149.
Regarding the issue i.e. whether the material as has come in course
of trial is sufficient to prove the charge under section 427 of the Indian Penal
Code?
150.
This Court finds that charge under Section 427 of IPC was framed
by the learned trial court against the appellant for committing mischief by
causing lose to the motorcycle, cycle and other goods of the house of the
informant Shidhu Soren (P.W.-6).
151.
The learned trial court had convicted the appellant for charge under
section 427 of the Indian Penal Code relying on the oral testimony of P.W.1, P.W.-2 P.W.-3, P.W.-5 and P.W.-6, holding that appellant had burnt the
motorcycle of the informant.
152.
On going through the evidence of Investigating Officer(P.W-8), this
Court finds that Investigating Officer had stated that out of the five place of
occurrence, the fifth places of occurrence, is the house of the informant
Shidhu Soren (P.W.-6), which is made of mud and straw and here motorcycle, important document and house hold articles were said to be destroyed
due to burning. Relevant portion of testimony of the Investigating Officer
(P.W-8), is quoted below for ready reference“10. इस कां ड का पाँ चवा घटना
ल पुडीिसली
त वादी िस
सोरे न का
लकड़ी एवं फूस से बना िम ी का मकान है जो 15/10 फीट का है जहाँ पर
वादी का मोटर साईिकल एवं अ
मह पूण कागजात तया घरे लू सामान
जलकर न होने की बात बताई जाती है । इसकी चौह ी िन
म कटहल का पेड़, उसके बाद रिव
कार है - पूरब
मािणक का िम ी का मकान, पि म
म वादी का नीज जमीन, उ र म पी०सी०सी० रोड तथा दि ण म जामुन का
पेड़ और खाली मैदान
त है । मेरे ारा सभी घटना ल का मानिच भी
बनाया गया है ।“
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
153.
But, ongoing through the testimony of informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-
6), surprisingly informant had nowhere in his testimony had stated that due
to fire his motorcycle and other house hold articles were burnt though
specific charge was framed against the appellant that appellant had
committed mischief by causing lose to the motorcycle, cycle and other
goods of the house of the informant Shidhu Soren.
154.
Further, this court finds that no seizure list of remains of burnt
motorcycle, cycle and other house hold articles, are on record, which could
have conclusively proved the guilt of the appellant for burning the
motorcycle, cycle and house hold articles of the informant Shidhu Soren
(P.W.-6).
155.
Hence, when informant Shidhu Soren (P.W.-6) had himself not
supported the prosecution case of burning his motorcycle, cycle and other
house hold articles, by the appellant, then prosecution case becomes
doubtful for the charge under section 427 of IPC against the appellant.
156.
Hence, this Court is of the view that no material as has come in
course of trial, which is sufficient to prove the charge under section 427 of
the Indian Penal Code against the appellant.
157.
Accordingly, issue no.(vi) has been herby answered.
Issue no.(vii)
158.
This issue is whether the testimony of P.W.-6 (informant) and P.W.-
2 Chaita Soren, is cogent, reliable and trustworthy to convict the appellant?
159.
To test the reliability and trustworthiness of the informant Sidhu
Soren (P.W.-6), this Court finds that informant in his examination-in-chief
had stated that when he opened the door, then, accused/appellant gave the
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
blow of axe on him, but he caught the hand of the accused/appellant. He
received the injury on his head for which he was treated in M.G.M. Hospital.
Paragraph-2 of the examination-in-chief of the informant Sidhu Soren
(P.W.-6), is quoted for ready reference“2. जब म दरवाजा खोला तो मुझ पर भी हमला िकया और मेरे उपर भी
कु ाड़ी चलाया म बचते ए उसके हाथ को पकड़ िलया। मुझे सर पर चोट
लगी थी िजसका मने ईलाज एम० जी० एम० अ ताल म आ था। उसके
बाद वह दाउली लेकर आया तब तक म वहाँ से भागर अपने पड़ोसी भेगेन
टु डू के घर घुसा और दरवाजा बंद कर िलया ।“
160.
Hence, as per the testimony of the informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6),
informant was injured by the accused/appellant for which he was treated in
M.G.M. Hospital. But, ongoing through the record, this Court finds that
neither the injury requisition nor injury report of the doctor is on record to
prove that informant was injured by the accused/appellant and hence, raises
doubt in the reliability and trustworthiness in the evidence of the informant.
161.
Again, informant in paragrap-2 of his examination-in-chief, had
deposed that when, accused/appellant came with dawli, then he ran away
and entered in the house of his neighbor Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9) and locked
the door. Paragraph-2 of the examination-in-chief of the informant Sidhu
Soren (P.W.-6), has already been quoted above.
162.
But, ongoing to the evidence of Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9), this Court
finds that Bhagan Tudu had nowhere in his evidence had stated that
informant Shidhu Soren (P.W.-6), had entered into his house and had locked
the door.
163.
Further, informant in his fardbeyan had specifically stated that his
motorcycle, cycle and other articles were burnt due to setting of his house on
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
fire. But, in his evidence informant Shidhu Soren (P.W.-6), had not stated
that his motorcycle, cycle and house hold articles were burnt in fire.
164.
Hence, informant has failed to support the prosecution case on vital
fact of burning his motorcycle, cycle and house hold articles and the oral
evidence of the informant that he was assaulted by the appellant with an axe
has also not been proved by the injury requisition and injury report.
165.
Therefore, the summary of the foregoing discussion is that allegation
of the informant in his oral evidence that he was assaulted by an axe by the
accused/appellant, as a result he was injured, which is not supported by any
injury report, renders informant’s evidence unreliable and doubtful.
166.
Further, the informant had remained silent in his examination-in-
chief on the fact of burning his motorcycle, cycle and house hold articles,
though specific charge was framed in this regard against the appellant.
Further, finding no support from Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9), about the fact that
when accused/appellant came with dawli, then he ran away and entered in
the house of his neighbor Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9), puts the informant in class
of unreliable and untrustworthy witness.
167.
Now, coming to the testimony of P.W.-2 Chaita Soren. P.W.-2
Chaita Soren, is the nephew of the deceased Ravi Manjhi and
accused/appellant Chunnu Manjhi. In his examination-in-chief, P.W.-2 had
stated that when he woke up at 4:00 a.m., then, he entered the room where
Chunnu Manjhi had committed murder and there, he saw axe in the hand of
accused Chunnu Manjhi and Chunnu Manjhi had also chased him. Relevant
part of the deposition of P.W.-2 Chaita Soren, is quoted for ready reference“ 2. जब म 4.00 बजे उठा तो जहाँ चु ु माझी मडर िकया था उस कमरा म
घुस गया तो दे खा िक चु ु माझी के हाथ म कु ाडी था। चु ु माझी मुझे भी
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
दौडाया था लेिकन म भाग गया। चु ु माझी बोल रहा था िक जब हम वापस
आयेगे तो सब को मार दगे।“
168.
But, ongoing through paragraph-7 of his cross-examination, this
court finds that evidence of P.W.-2 Chaita Soren, is self-contradictory as in
paragraph-7 P.W.-2 had stated that when he woke up on halla of fire, he
found the house of Ravi Uncle(deceased) burning and smoke was coming
out. Hence, question arises when as per the testimony of P.W.-2, the house
of Ravi Manjhi (deceased) was burning, then, why the accused/appellant
will allow himself to remain present in the burning house of the Ravi Manjhi
(deceased) and will allow to ablaze himself in fire, more so when accused/
appellant was free to move and also that why P.W.-2 Chaita Soren will enter
in the burning house. Relevant part of the cross-examination, of P.W.-2
Chaita Soren, is quoted for ready reference“7 घटना के समय म सोया आ था इसिलए म नहीं दे खा घटना कौन िकया
है । म आग लगा का ह
ा सुना तो उठा था तो दे खा िक रिब चाचा के घर म
अंदर आग लगा था और धुंआ उठ रहा था।“
169.
Here, it is pertinent to note that the Investigating Officer Ropna Ram
Kanshi (P.W-8) had not stated in his evidence that there was fire in the
house Ravi Manji(deceased).
170.
Hence, the statement of P.W.-2 Chaita Soren, that when he entered
the room where Chunnu Manjhi had committed murder i.e room of Ravi
Manjhi (deceased) and there, he saw axe in the hand of Chunnu Manjhi and
that Chunnu Manjhi had also chased him, is self-contradictory and cannot be
accepted and hence, raises doubt in the credibility and trustworthiness of
P.W.-2.
171.
Accordingly issue no. (vii) has been hereby answered.
Re: Issue no. (viii)
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
172.
The issue is whether the trial Court, while convicting the appellant,
has committed any illegality or not?
173.
From the impugned judgment, this Court finds that the learned Trial
Court had noted that this case was based on circumstantial evidence and
motive behind the murder was land dispute. The learned Trial Court had also
noted that the appellant was found at the place of occurrence with the
murder weapon and had chased a witness in order to kill him. The learned
Trial Court had also noted that DNA profile generated from the seized
articles which was sent to SFSL is mixed and partial DNA profile from more
than one human source of origin reveals that it was used in the commission
of offence as there were five deceased persons.
174.
Regarding motive of the present case, this Court finds that Shambhu
Soren (P.W.-1), who is the brother of the deceased Ravi Manjhi and
accused/ appellant Chunnu Manjhi, had stated in his cross-examination that
Ravi Soren (deceased), had sold one katha of land for one lakh rupees and
money was distributed among the five brothers amounting to Rs.20,000/each. Further, P.W.-2 Chaita Soren, who is the nephew of the deceased, had
also stated in his cross-examination that two weeks before the incident, his
all uncle had sold a land to someone for way, and all had received their
share of money. Informant Sidhu Soren (P.W.-6), had also denied the
suggestion
that
there
was
land
dispute
between
him
and
the
accused/appellant.
175.
Hence, in their evidence Shambhu Soren (P.W.-1) and Sidhu Soren
(P.W.-6), who are the brothers of the accused/appellant Chunnu Manjhi and
Chaita Soren (P.W.-2), who is the nephew of accused/appellant Chunnu
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
Manjhi, they have not deposed that there was land dispute between the
brothers or with accused/appellant Chunnu Manjhi and the deceased Ravi
Manjhi.
176.
Moreover, Ravi Manjhi(deceased), his wife Parvati Majhian and all
the three sons of Ravi Manjhi(deceased) namely Suresh Manjhi, Paresh
Manjhi and Jiten Manjhi, were killed. Hence, not a single member in the
family of Ravi Manjhi(deceased), is left to state about the enmity for which
Ravi Manjhi(deceased) and Ravi Manjhi’s entire family members were
killed.
177.
Hence, motive behind the murder of Ravi Majhi, Parvati Majhian,
Suresh Manjhi, Paresh Manjhi and Jiten Manjhi, is uncertain.
178.
The learned Trial Court had also noted that the appellant was found
at the place of occurrence with the murder weapon.
179.
But this Court while dealing the issue no.(iii) had answered that
alleged recovery of three axes vide seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8, said to be
recovered from the house of the deceased (Ravi Manjhi), cannot be treated
as cogent evidence to prove the culpability of the appellant in the alleged
commission of crime.
180.
The learned Trial Court had also noted that the appellant had chased
a witness in order to kill him. Though, learned Trial Court had not
specifically named the witness who was chased by the accused/appellant.
But, Chaita Soren (P.W.-2), in his evidence had stated that accused/appellant
had chased him.
181.
But, while dealing issue no. (vii), this Court had already noted that
evidence of Chaita Soren (P.W.-2), was self-contradictory and cannot be
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
accepted and hence, this Court has raised doubt in the credibility and
trustworthiness in the evidence of Chaita Soren (P.W.-2).
182.
The learned Trial Court had relied on the DNA profile generated
from the seized articles which was sent to SFSL, is mixed and partial DNA
profile from more than one human source of origin reveals that it was used
in the commission of offence as there were five deceased persons.
183.
In this regard, this Court is of the view that learned Trial Court failed
to observe that in the present case seizure list Ext. P-7/PW.8 which pertains
to the alleged recovery of three axes and blood stain clothes worn by the
accused, which was said to be recovered from the house of the deceased
Ravi Manjhi, was prepared on 23.02.2019 at 8.00 am in the morning
whereas in the FIR it is mentioned that information was received in the
police station at 5.30 pm on 23.02.2019.
184.
Hence, while dealing the issue no.(ii), this Court had come to the
conclusion that prosecution had supressed and withheld the document
containing the first information regarding murder of five deceased persons
and hence, Seizure list Ext.P-7/PW8 is not reliable, but the leaned Trial
Court had overlooked such vital issue.
185.
So, the learned Trial Court erred in relying on the DNA profile
generated from the seized articles vide seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8.
186.
Further, the learned trial court had convicted the appellant for the
charge under section 427 of IPC for committing mischief by causing loss to
the motorcycle, cycle and other goods of the house of the informant Shidhu
Soren (P.W.-6). But, while dealing issue no.(vi), this court has come to the
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
conclusion that there was no material before the trial court to prove the
charge under section 427 of the Indian Penal Code.
187.
Accordingly issue no. (viii) has been hereby answered.
Re: Issue No. (ix)
188.
This issue is whether on the basis of the testimony of oral as well as
documentary evidence, can it be said to be a case based on circumstantial
evidence or if it based upon the circumstantial evidence the chain is being
completed or not?
189.
In the present case it is admitted fact that five persons of the same
family were murdered and no one had witnessed the murder of the five
persons. Leaned Trial Cort had found the chain of chain of circumstances
were complete and hence, had convicted the accused/appellant.
190.
Before we analyze and appreciate the circumstances that have
weighed with the trial court, we think it apposite to refer to certain
authorities pertaining to delineation of cases that hinge on circumstantial
evidence.
191.
There is no quarrel with the settled position of law that in the case of
circumstantial evidence, the chain should be complete then only there will
be conviction of the concerned accused person, as has been laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hanumant son of Govind Nargundlar
vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1952 SC 343 wherein it has been held
that "It is well to remember that in cases where the evidence is of a
circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt
is to be drawn should in the first instance be fully established, and all the
facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
of the accused. Again, the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency and they should be such as to exclude every hypothesis but the
one proposed to be proved. In other words, there must be a chain of
evidence so far complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for a
conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and it must be such
as to show that within all human probability the act must have been done by
the accused."
192.
The same view has been taken by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Bakhshish Singh vs. State of Punjab, (1971) 3 SCC 182 wherein the
Hon'ble Apex Court has observed that the principle in a case resting on
circumstantial evidence is well settled that the circumstances put forward
must be satisfactorily proved and those circumstances should be consistent
only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. These circumstances
should be of a conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to
exclude every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words,
there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of the
accused and it must be such as to show that within all human probability the
act must have been done by the accused.
193.
The Hon'ble Apex Court while laying down such proposition in the
said case has considered the factual aspect revolving around therein and
while considering the fact has only found the incriminating evidence against
the appellant was his pointing the place where the dead body of the deceased
had been thrown which the Hon'ble Apex Court has not considered to be
circumstantial evidence though undoubtedly it raises a strong suspicion
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
against the appellant. The Hon'ble Apex Court while coming to such
conclusion has observed that even if he was not a party to the murder, the
appellant could have come to know the place where the dead body of the
deceased had been thrown. Hence anyone who saw those parts could have
inferred that the dead body must have been thrown into the river near about
that place. In that pretext, the law has been laid down at paragraph-9 thereof,
which reads as under:
"9. The law relating to circumstantial evidence has been stated by this
Court in numerous decisions. It is needless to refer to them as the law
on the point is well-settled. In a case resting on circumstantial
evidence, the circumstances put forward must be satisfactorily proved
and those circumstances should be consistent only with the hypothesis
of the guilt of the accused. Again, those circumstances should be of a
conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to exclude
every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words,
there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and it must be such as to show that within all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused."
194.
It is, thus, evident from the close analysis of the aforesaid
judgments, the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against
an accused can be said to be fully established:
(i) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be
drawn should be fully established.
(ii) the facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not
be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is
guilty,
(iii) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
(iv) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to
be proved, and
(v) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence
of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act
must have been done by the accused.
195.
The Hon'ble Apex Court has reiterated the said principle again in the
case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC
116 holding all the above five principles to be the golden principles which
constitute the panchsheel of the proof of a case based on circumstantial
evidence. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the said case as under paragraph-155,
156, 157, 158 and 159 has been pleased to hold that if these conditions are
fulfilled only then a Court can use a false explanation or a false defence as
an additional link to lend an assurance to the court and not otherwise.
Paragraphs-155, 156, 157, 158 and 159 of the said judgment read as under:
"155. It may be interesting to note that as regards the mode of proof in
a criminal case depending on circumstantial evidence, in the absence
of a corpus delicti, the statement of law as to proof of the same was
laid down by Gresson, J. (and concurred by 3 more Judges) in King v.
Horry [1952 NZLR 111] thus: "Before he can be convicted, the fact of
death should be proved by such circumstances as render the
commission of the crime morally certain and leave no ground for
reasonable doubt: the circumstantial evidence should be so cogent
and compelling as to convince a jury that upon no rational hypothesis
other than murder can the facts be accounted for."
156. Lord Goddard slightly modified the expression "morally certain"
by "such circumstances as render the commission of the crime
certain".
157. This indicates the cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence
that a case can be said to be proved only when there is certain and
explicit evidence and no person can be convicted on pure moral
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
conviction. Horry case [1952 NZLR 111] was approved by this Court
in Anant Chintaman Lagu v. State of Bombay [AIR 1960 SC 500]
Lagu case [AIR 1960 SC 500] as also the principles enunciated by
this Court in Hanumant case [(1952) 2 SCC 71] have been uniformly
and consistently followed in all later decisions of this Court without
any single exception. To quote a few cases -- Tufail case [(1969) 3
SCC 198] , Ramgopal case [(1972) 4 SCC 625] , Chandrakant
Nyalchand Seth v. State of Bombay [ Criminal Appeal No 120 of
1957,], Dharambir Singh v. State of Punjab [ Criminal Appeal No 98
of 1958,]. There are a number of other cases where although
Hanumant case [(1952) 2 SCC] has not been expressly noticed but the
same principles have been expounded and reiterated, as in Naseem
Ahmed v. Delhi Administration [(1974) 3 SCC 668, 670] , Mohan Lal
Pangasa v. State of U.P. [(1974) 4 SCC 607,] , Shankarlal Gyarasilal
Dixit v. State of Maharashtra [(1981) 2 SCC 35, 39] and M.G.
Agarwal v. State of Maharashtra [AIR 1963 SC 200 : (1963) 2 SCR
405,] -- a five-Judge Bench decision.
158. It may be necessary here to notice a very forceful argument
submitted by the Additional Solicitor General relying on a decision of
this Court in Deonandan Mishra v. State of Bihar [AIR 1955 SC 801]
to supplement his argument that if the defence case is false it would
constitute an additional link so as to fortify the prosecution case. With
due respect to the learned Additional Solicitor-General we are unable
to agree with the interpretation given by him of the aforesaid case, the
relevant portion of which may be extracted thus: "But in a case like
this where the various links as stated above have been satisfactorily
made out and the circumstances point to the appellant as the probable
assailant, with reasonable definiteness and in proximity to the
deceased as regards time and situation. such absence of explanation
or false explanation would itself be an additional link which completes
the chain."
159. It will be seen that this Court while taking into account the
absence of explanation or a false explanation did hold that it will
amount to be an additional link to complete the chain but these
observations must be read in the light of what this Court said earlier
viz. before a false explanation can be used as additional link, the
following essential conditions must be satisfied: (1) various links in
the chain of evidence led by the prosecution have been satisfactorily
proved, (2) the said circumstance points to the guilt of the accused
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
with reasonable definiteness, and (3) the circumstance is in proximity
to the time and situation."
196.
The foremost requirement in the case of circumstantial evidence is
that the chain is to be completed. In Padala Veera Reddy v. State of A.P.
[1989 Supp (2) SCC 706 the Hon'ble Apex Court held that when a case rests
upon circumstantial evidence, the following tests must be satisfied:
"10. ... (1) the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is
sought to be drawn, must be cogently and firmly established; (2) those
circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing
towards guilt of the accused; (3) the circumstances, taken
cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape
from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was
committed by the accused and none else; and (4) the circumstantial
evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and
incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt
of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with
the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence."
197.
In Ram Singh v. Sonia (2007) 3 SCC 1, while referring to the
settled proof pertaining to circumstantial evidence, the Hon’ble Apex Court
reiterated the principles about the caution to be kept in mind by court. It has
been stated therein as follows:
"39. ... in a case depending largely upon circumstantial evidence,
there is always a danger that conjecture or suspicion may take the
place of legal proof. The court must satisfy itself that various
circumstances in the chain of events have been established clearly and
such completed chain of events must be such as to rule out a
reasonable likelihood of the innocence of the accused. It has also been
indicated that when the important link goes, the chain of
circumstances gets snapped and the other circumstances cannot in
any manner, establish the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable
doubts."
198.
Thus, it is evident that for proving the charge on the basis of
circumstantial evidence, it would be necessary that evidence so available
must induce a reasonable man to come to a definite conclusion of proving of
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
guilt; meaning thereby there must be a chain of evidence so far it is
complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent
with the innocence of the accused and it must be such as to show that within
all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.
199.
This Court, after referring the impugned judgment and adverting to
the testimony as recorded in course of the trial of the witnesses produced on
behalf of the prosecution as well as documentary evidence has found that in
the present case prosecution has failed to prove the chain of circumstances
due to the following reasons:
I.
A material inconsistency emerges in the prosecution
evidence regarding the place of recovery of the deceased
persons’ bodies. While investigating officer deposed that the
bodies were discovered inside the rooms of the house of the
deceased Ravi Manjhi, the inquest reports record the recovery
as having been made from the courtyard of the said house.
This divergence on a fundamental aspect renders the
prosecution version self-contradictory as to the precise place
of occurrence and recovery of the bodies.
II.
There is vital contradiction in the seizure list Ext. P-
7/PW8, pertaining to the seizure of the three axes wherein
recovery of three axes are shown, but, it was not mentioned in
the seizure list that any of the axes had blood stain though
Investigating Officer had stated in his cross-examination that
accused had tangi(axe) in his hand which was soaked with
blood.
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
III.
In the seizure list Ext. P-7/PW8 only seizure of ‘blood
stain clothes wore by the accused’, was mentioned and no
specific
description
about
clothes
wore
by
the
accused/appellant is mentioned. But, when clothes were sent to
Forensic Science Laboratory vide letter no. 127/2019 dated
28.02.2019 vide Ext.P-11/PW8 for examination, surprisingly
at Serial No.6 specific description of dress recovered by the
Investigating Officer was shown as ‘black colour track suit’
and ‘brown vest’, stained with blood, which was not
mentioned in the Seizure list.
IV.
Thus, the seizure list, Ext. P-7/PW-8, which purports to
record the recovery of three axes and blood-stained clothes
allegedly worn by the accused from the house of the deceased
Ravi Manjhi, suffers from serious infirmities. It has not been
prepared in a proper and lawful manner, and the circumstances
surrounding its preparation disclose conspicuous manipulation.
V.
According to the prosecution, following the murder of five
persons, the accused/appellant proceeded to the house of the
informant, Sidhu Soren, where he assaulted the informant’s
mother, Guruwari Majhian, with an axe. The informant claims
to be an eyewitness to this assault, in which Guruwari Majhian
sustained grievous injuries to her waist and legs, necessitating
treatment at M.G.M. Hospital. However, it is noteworthy that
the alleged injured witness, Guruwari Majhian, was neither
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
examined by the prosecution nor is any injury requisition or
medical report available on record.
VI.
It is further significant to note that the learned trial court
has acquitted the appellant of the charges under Sections 307
and 326 of the Indian Penal Code, relating to the alleged
axe-blow and grievous injuries inflicted upon Guruwari
Majhian. Consequently, the prosecution has failed to establish
a vital link in the chain of circumstances necessary to prove
that, subsequent to the murder of five persons, the
accused/appellant proceeded to the house of the informant and
assaulted Guruwari Majhian with an axe, thereby causing
injuries to her.
VII.
The chain of circumstances subsequent to the murder of
the five deceased persons also remains incomplete. The
informant,
in
his
testimony,
stated
that
upon
the
accused/appellant approaching with a dawli, he fled and took
shelter in the house of his neighbour, Bhagan Tudu (P.W.-9),
by closing the door from within. However, P.W.-9 has not
corroborated this assertion in his evidence, as he did not
depose that the informant had entered his house and secured
the door. This absence of corroboration creates a significant
gap in the prosecution narrative and further weakens the
continuity of the chain of circumstances.
VIII.
The informant has deposed that subsequent to the incident
he sustained an injury on his head, for which he was treated at
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
M.G.M. Hospital. However, neither the injury requisition nor
any injury report has been brought on record to substantiate
that the informant was in fact injured by the accused/appellant
after the occurrence.
IX.
In his fardbeyan, the informant stated that after
committing the murders, the accused/appellant set fire to his
motorcycle, cycle, and other household articles. However, as
already discussed while dealing with Issue No. (VI), the
prosecution has failed to substantiate this vital allegation. The
absence of credible evidence on this point further weakens the
prosecution’s attempt to establish a continuous chain of
circumstances against the accused/appellant.
200.
Hence, in the present case, this Court is of the considered view that
the chain of circumstances remains incomplete, and therefore no conclusive
inference of guilt can be drawn against the accused/appellant.
201.
Accordingly issue no. (ix) has been hereby answered.
202.
It needs to refer herein that the Hon'ble Apex Court in catena of
decision has propounded the proposition that in the criminal trial, there
cannot be any conviction if the charge is not being proved beyond all
reasonable doubts, as has been held in the case of Rang Bahadur Singh &
Ors. Vrs. State of U.P., reported in (2000) 3 SCC 454, wherein, at
paragraph-22, it has been held as under:"22. The amount of doubt which the Court would entertain regarding
the complicity of the appellants in this case is much more than the
level of reasonable doubt. We are aware that acquitting the accused in
a case of this nature is not a matter of satisfaction for all concerned.
At the same time we remind ourselves of the time-tested rule that
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
acquittal of a guilty person should be preferred to conviction of an
innocent person. Unless the prosecution establishes the guilt of the
accused beyond reasonable doubt a conviction cannot be passed on
the accused. A criminal court cannot afford to deprive liberty of the
appellants, lifelong liberty, without having at least a reasonable level
of certainty that the appellants were the real culprits. We really
entertain doubt about the involvement of the appellants in the crime."
203.
Likewise, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Krishnegowda &
Ors. Vrs. State of Karnataka, 2017 (13) SCC 98, has held at paragraph-26
as under:
"26. Having gone through the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
and the findings recorded by the High Court we feel that the High
Court has failed to understand the fact that the guilt of the accused
has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt and this is a classic case
where at each and every stage of the trial, there were lapses on the
part of the investigating agency and the evidence of the witnesses is
not trustworthy which can never be a basis for conviction. The basic
principle of criminal jurisprudence is that the accused is presumed to
be innocent until his guilt is proved beyond reasonable doubt."
212.
Further, it needs to refer herein the principle of 'benefit of doubt'
belongs exclusively to criminal jurisprudence. The pristine doctrine of
'benefit of doubt' can be invoked when there is reasonable doubt regarding
the guilt of the accused, reference in this regard may be made to the
judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State of
Haryana Vrs. Bhagirath & Ors., reported in (1999) 5 SCC 96, wherein, it
has been held at paragraph-7 as under: "7. The High Court had failed to consider the implication of the evidence of
the two eyewitnesses on the complicity of Bhagirath particularly when the
High Court found their evidence reliable. The benefit of doubt was given to
Bhagirath "as a matter of abundant caution". Unfortunately, the High Court
did not point out the area where there is such a doubt. Any restraint by way
of abundant caution need not be entangled with the concept of the benefit of
doubt. Abundant caution is always desirable in all spheres of human activity.
But the principle of benefit of doubt belongs exclusively to criminal
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
jurisprudence. The pristine doctrine of benefit of doubt can be invoked when
there is reasonable doubt regarding the guilt of the accused. It is the
reasonable doubt which a conscientious judicial mind entertains on a
conspectus of the entire evidence that the accused might not have committed
the offence, which affords the benefit to the accused at the end of the
criminal trial. Benefit of doubt is not a legal dosage to be administered at
every segment of the evidence, but an advantage to be afforded to the
accused at the final end after consideration of the entire evidence, if the
Judge conscientiously and reasonably entertains doubt regarding the guilt of
the accused."
It needs to refer herein that the Hon'ble Apex Court, in the case of
Allarakha K. Mansuri v. State of Gujarat reported in (2002) 3 SCC 57 has
laid down the principle that the golden thread which runs through the web of
administration of justice in criminal case is that if two views are possible on
the evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the guilt of the accused
and the other to his innocence, the view which is favourable to the accused
should be adopted, for ready reference, paragraph 6 thereof requires to be
referred herein which reads hereunder as :“6. ------The golden thread which runs through the web of
administration of justice in criminal case is that if two views are
possible on the evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the guilt
of the accused and the other to his innocence, the view which is
favourable to the accused should be adopted. —"
214.
It needs to refer herein before laying down the aforesaid view, the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra reported in (1984) 4 SCC 116 has already laid down the
same view at paragraph 163 which is required to be referred which read
hereunder as“163. We then pass on to another important point which seems to
have been completely missed by the High Court. It is well settled that
where on the evidence two possibilities are available or open, one
which goes in favour of the prosecution and the other which benefits
2026:JHHC:17828-DB
an accused, the accused is undoubtedly entitled to the benefit of
doubt.---"
215.
This Court, after having discussed the factual aspect and legal
position as discussed hereinabove is of the view that the prosecution has
failed to prove the charges against the appellant Chunnu Manjhi @ Putru,
beyond all reasonable doubt as such the impugned judgment of conviction
and order of sentence requires interference by this Court.
216.
Accordingly,
the
impugned
judgment
of
conviction
dated
23.09.2025 and order of sentence dated 25.09.2025 passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Chandil in Sessions Trial Case No. 196 of 2019,
arising out of Chandil PS case No. 23 of 2019, G.R. No. 244 of 2019, is
hereby quashed and set-aside.
217.
Consequently, the reference is answered in negative. Accordingly,
we set aside the conviction and sentence as proposed by the learned trial
Court which has been sent for affirmation of this Court.
218.
Consequently, the appeal preferred by the appellant is allowed.
219.
The accused be released forthwith if not wanted in any other case.
220.
Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
221.
Let the Lower Court Records be sent back to the Court concerned
forthwith, along with a copy of this Judgment.
I Agree
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
Date: 18.06.2026
Nibha /A.F.R.
Uploaded on: 19/06 /2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review