Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on
:
Pronounced on :
Uploaded on
:
%
+
13th January 2026
10th March 2026
11th March 2026
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
CHOLAMANDALAM MS GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Suman Bagga and Ms. Mouli
Sharma, Advs.
versus
PALAK SHARMA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Bhupesh Narula, Mr. Yogesh
Narula and Mr. Abhin Narula, Advs.
for R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal assails the impugned award dated 09 th September 2014
passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, North-West District (MACT),
in Case No.330/2010.
The incident
2.
On 12th March 2010 at about 6.30 a.m., Sh. Palak Sharma along with
his friend Sh. Sanjay Bansal was going to Maharishi Dayanand Park,
Keshavpuram, Delhi, for yoga on a two-wheeler bearing registration No.
DL-8SV-3616 driven by Sh. Sanjay Bansal and the petitioner was riding on
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 1/18
the pillion. When they reached the T-point in front of Maharishi Dayanand
Park, it is alleged that an Innova bearing registration no. HR-55HT-3382,
driven by Mr. Amit Kumar in a rash and negligent manner and at a high
speed, came from the side of Hathora Ram Park, and hit the scooter.
3.
It was noted by the MACT that at the time of the filing of the petition
the injured/Sh. Palak Sharma was still in coma since the day he sustained
injuries, and later on came out of the coma, but has remained in a vegetative
state.
4.
The owner of the offending vehicle was M/s Top Wheels Tours and
Travels, and the vehicle was insured with Cholamandalam MS General
Insurance Company, the appellant herein.
5.
FIR No. 97/2010 under Sections 279/337 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 was registered at PS Keshav Puram, Delhi.
The impugned award
6.
Driver, owner and the insurance company filed their written
statements, and denied their liabilities.
7.
Sh. Ajay Sharma, father of the petitioner, was examined as PW1; Sh.
Chandan Kumar, the attendant, was examined as PW2; Dr. Nimit Gupta,
neurosurgeon from Dr. BSA hospital, Delhi, was examined as PW3; Sh.
Praveen Kumar, physiotherapist, was examined as PW4; and Sh. Lakshmi
Narayan Gupta, an eyewitness, was examined as PW5.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 2/18
8.
MACT after assessing the evidence was of the opinion that Sh. Amit
Kumar was driving the offending vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and
had caused the accident and, therefore, the respondent no.1/claimant had
sustained injuries.
Compensation
9.
Considering that Sh. Palak Sharma had suffered from permanent
disability to the extent of 100% and clearly was not able to work, the loss of
earning capacity was assessed at 100% with addition of 50% towards future
prospects.
10.
Reliance was, therefore, placed on Income Tax Return (‘ITR’) of
respondent no.1 for the year 2009-2010, taken as duly proved on record by
PW1. The said ITR showed that the gross income was Rs.3,24,811/- and
Rs.17,539/- had been paid towards tax. Therefore, the income was taken as
Rs.3,07,272/- per annum.
11.
Applying the multiplier of 18 with 50% future prospects (respondent
no.1 being 22 years on date of accident), the amount arrived at was
Rs.82,96,344/-.
12.
Towards attendant charges, considering the condition of the injured
and the testimony of PW2/attendant, that he was being paid Rs.20,000/- per
month by way of a cheque and that claimant’s condition would require an
attendant throughout life, an amount of Rs.20,000/- per month calculated
over a period of a year and using a multiplier of 18 was taken, amounting to
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 3/18
Rs.43,20,000/-. However, MACT recorded the submission of counsel of
petitioner that even if 50% of the said amount is awarded as attendant
charges and would be kept in FDR, then it may fetch an amount equivalent to
approximately Rs. 20,000/- per month and would serve the purpose towards
the payment to attendant. Accordingly, an amount of Rs. 22,00,000/- was
awarded towards attendant charges which would also include future
attendant charges.
13.
As regards the compensation towards physiotherapy, taking the
testimony of PW4, the physiotherapist, that he used to charge Rs.400/- per
day, an amount of Rs.3,80,000/- was granted for expenses already incurred
and the physiotherapy which would be required in the future.
14.
Further, an amount at Rs.6,000/- per month was awarded towards
special diet. Multiplier of 18 was applied and was calculated amounting to
Rs.12,96,000/-. However, an amount of Rs.7 Lakhs was granted to the
claimant towards special diet which also includes expenses of future diet.
15.
Towards the equipment an amount of Rs.2,30,000/- was awarded.
Towards conveyance and ambulance charges an amount of Rs.8,64,000/was awarded and towards medical bills an amount of Rs.23,23,000/- was
granted.
16.
Other non-pecuniary damages were awarded. The tabulation of
compensation awarded is given as under:
S. No.
Compensation under various heads
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Amount awarded
Page 4/18
1.
Loss of Income/Earning Capacity
Rs. 82,96,344/-
2.
Attendant Charges
Rs. 22,00,000/-
3.
Physiotherapy
Rs. 3,80,000/-
4.
Special Diet
Rs. 7,00,000/-
5.
Purchase of equipments
Rs. 2,30,000/-
6.
Conveyance
Rs. 8,64,000/-
7.
Medical Bills
Rs. 23,23,000/-
8.
Pain, agony and suffering
Rs. 3,00,000/-
9.
Loss of education
Rs. 2,00,000/-
10.
Loss of Amenities in Life
Rs. 3,00,000/-
11.
Loss
of
marriage
matrimonial discomfort
prospects/ Rs. 3,00,000/-
12.
Disfigurement
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Total
Rs. 1,62,93,344/-
Analysis
17.
Ms. Suman Bagga, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company,
contended that the Tribunal did not appreciate that the injured/respondent
no.1 was a student of BBA final year and the business which he professed to
be earning out of, was actually being carried out by the father and the
grandfather of the injured. Moreover, the ITR of respondent no.1 was being
filed in order to create capital of respondent no.1. No books of accounts were
produced. The injured, the father and the grandfather were allegedly carrying
out business from the same premises and the injured had joint bank account
with the grandfather.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 5/18
18.
Ms. Suman Bagga further contended that since it was a family
business, there was no loss of income after the accident. The Tribunal,
therefore, erred in awarding huge amounts towards loss of income.
19.
In this regard, it would be apposite to examine the testimony which
was assessed by the Tribunal. Ajay Sharma, the father of the injured, testified
as PW1. Regarding the educational status of the injured, he stated that Sh.
Palak Sharma was a student of final year of BBA, had qualified the entrance
examination for the MBA course and was a meritorious student. Further, he
was working and earning Rs.3,50,000/- per annum and was an Income Tax
payee and had a PAN card in his name. The ITRs filed forms part of the
record as Ex.PW1/F.
20.
The Tribunal notes that the driver and the owner of the offending
vehicle (Amit Kumar and M/s Top Wheels Tours and Travels, respectively)
had not disputed the educational qualifications of the injured, nor disputed
that he was earning while studying, or that the ITRs were not genuine.
21.
The Insurance Company could not produce any evidence to show that
the injured was not in the final year of the BBA course or was not earning the
amount as testified by PW1, or that the ITRs were fake, fabricated or
manipulated in any manner. The only contention, which has subsisted, since
the proceedings before the Tribunal, is that the injured was doing the same
business as done by PW1, from the premises of PW1 and, therefore, could
not have a separate income.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 6/18
22.
To this, the MACT opined that this plea was not convincing, as it
cannot be presumed that the son cannot carry on the same business or must
be compelled to do something else merely because the business was being
run from the same premises. Testimony of PW1 cannot be considered
unreliable, as it was entirely plausible that the father and the son were doing
business independently from the same premises as it is natural for a father to
help the son to start and sustain a business using the same infrastructure that
they had.
23.
The Tribunal further noted that although PW1 was subjected to
lengthy cross-examination by the Insurance Company, there was nothing on
record to show that PW1 had deposed falsely regarding the qualifications or
income of the injured, or that the ITRs did not reflect the correct income, or
that they were false or fabricated. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the
ITR of the injured for the year 2009-2010 was duly proved on record by
PW1 and ought to be taken into consideration. Reliance was placed on the
judgment in Amrit Bhanushali & Ors. v. National Insurance Company &
Ors. in Civil Appeal no. 3397/2012.
24.
Having perused the testimony of PW1 and having heard the
arguments of appellant, this Court does not see any reason to displace the
conclusion drawn out by the Tribunal. The ITRs for three years were placed
on record as Ex.PW1/F and have been examined by this Court. In the
cross-examination, PW1 stated that his son (the injured) used to sell metal
scrap on commission basis from the same premises, from which he
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 7/18
operates/works. He further stated that he joined him in year 2007 and
initially worked with him and filed his ITRs for the year 2007-2008.
25.
PW1 further stated that initially the injured was maintaining his bank
account jointly with the grandfather; however, thereafter, the grandfather
had retired. PW1 denied the suggestion that the injured was not carrying on
independent work and that the returns were filed merely to show income or
to make his capital. He stated that the grandfather was an income tax payee
as well and was declaring his income from the same business.
26.
Suggestions from the Insurance Company that the income reflected in
the ITRs was that of grandfather and that the affidavit was false and
fabricated were denied. There is nothing suggested by the Insurance
Company that the income tax records produced by PW-1 was false or
fabricated. Nothing had been placed on record by the Insurance Company as
well to controvert what was being stated PW1.
27.
Counsel for the respondents stated that the injured had gone into a
coma and remained in a vegetative state and continues to be under treatment
suffering from fits at regular intervals. He has been certified with 100%
permanent total disability. It is quite evident that family was engaged in the
business of scrap dealing, where earnings were made on a commission basis.
It is also quite clear that from the evidence on record that the grandfather and
the father were both in the same business and that the injured had started his
business under the guidance and support of his father.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 8/18
28.
It does seem clear that in order to facilitate the professional education
of the injured, the route taken was of doing the Bachelors in Business
Administration followed by Masters in Business Administration. It is not
uncommon in a business family to encourage a progeny to get a professional
degree in business management and subsequently join the family business.
Once having joined the family business, it is also not uncommon that a
portion of the income is allocated to the progeny in order to ensure financial
independence for that person. Even though the source of income might be a
connected business or a joint business, it does not mean that the progeny
would be considered as without any income.
29.
The Insurance Company seems to suggest that anybody who is part of
a joint family business, but files his ITRs, paying tax on the income that is
declared, ought to be considered as a non-earning member of the family.
This argument advanced by the Insurance Company is fallacious and
completely oblivious of reality of the society and the circumstances which
surround us. As the Supreme Court states repeatedly assessments of
compensation cannot be divorced from realities. The very fact that the son
had started to file his returns, declaring his own income, and paying tax on
the same, to delve into the details of how the income was being allocated
between the family members, would be unnecessary.
30.
The core issue is whether the accident had occurred or not and had the
injured not lapsed into a vegetative state, he would have enjoyed financial
independence and would have earned income, albeit from the same family
business. The answer is crystal clear.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 9/18
31.
The injured was 22 years old, major in age, pursuing a professional
qualification and working in the family business. He was entitled to be
assessed on his own income. Besides, there was no contradictory evidence
which had been placed by the Insurance Company, which could have
enabled the Tribunal to discard the plea of loss of income for the injured.
This assessment of the Tribunal is, therefore, upheld in this regard.
32.
The second issue, which has been raised is that 50% future prospects
were awarded, whereas the injured was self-employed, therefore, 40% future
prospect ought to have been awarded. In this regard, it would be apposite to
align with the principles enunciated in National Insurance Company
v. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC, wherein in case of self-employment,
(which is admittedly the case here, considering that he was part of the family
business), the future prospect would be taken at 40%.
33.
The third issue, which has been raised by the Insurance Company, is
that the injured/respondent no.1 did not examine the doctor who treated him
for the injuries sustained by him regarding future medical treatment if
required. No medical prescription had been filed to show that any
physiotherapy in the future would be required.
34.
To this, counsel for respondent no.1 stated that this argument has no
merit as Dr. Namit Gupta was thoroughly examined before the Tribunal to
prove the disability certificate. Dr. Gupta was a member of the Medical
Board which consisted of 5 doctors who had examined the injured for a
period of 2 years before issuing the disability certificate. The Board stated
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 10/18
that after lapse of 3 years from the date of injury, there are very little chances
of the condition improving. There was no reason why all treating doctors
would have to be examined since the injured was treated by a number of
doctors for many years at various hospitals and continues to be under
treatment.
35.
Moreover, the Insurance Company had appointed a doctor from their
panel to examine the injured and who visited the injured home 3 times, but
the doctor has not provided his report.
36.
In this regard, it is an admitted position that the injured is in a
vegetative state even 14 years after the accident. The contention of the
Insurance Company on the medical issue is completely unmerited and, in
fact, frivolous. The Insurance Company after having appointed the panel
doctor could have easily produced their report if they wish to controvert that
he was not in a vegetative state. Even the Tribunal noted in detail the
testimony of the father of the injured regarding the treatment which the
injured had undergone throughout 2010 and 2011. In fact, it was also
recorded there was no way it could have been assessed how much time and
expense it would take to cure the injured and that he could have to be
medicated for all his life. It was also noted that the injured was completely
bedridden and was surviving through external support with the catheter, food
pipe, special air bed, pillows, special mattresses, urine-toilet pots, oxygen
cylinder etc. for which huge amounts of money had been spent. The details
need not be replicated and are available in the Tribunal’s award at paragraph
18.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 11/18
37.
Further, the Tribunal in paragraph 23 notes the examination of Dr.
Namit Gupta, who was a neurosurgeon at Baba Saheb Ambedkar Hospital.
38.
The final disability certificate was issued on 11th June 2012, showing
that the injured suffered 100% permanent disability. He stated that the
injured was neither mentally nor physically fit and needed special
semi-liquid diet to be given through the mouth, and the chances of recovery
were very less, and he required regular attendant and physiotherapy. There is
nothing on record to suggest that the disability certificate was falsely
procured or manipulated.
39.
The other issue, which has been taken up by respondent no.1, is that
the attendant charges should be twice but have been reduced to half.
40.
Even the Insurance Company has taken up in the appeal, a ground
relating to the attendant charges, stating that the payments made to the
alleged attendant did not appear to be genuine since it was stated to be an
engagement on a monthly basis and the cheques issued were infrequent, only
sometimes for two or three months only.
41.
As regards the attendant charges, the Tribunal notes in paragraph 29
of the impugned award that since the injured was 100% permanently
disabled and bedridden one person was required around the clock to look
after him. The testimony of PW2, Chandan Kumar, was considered who
was the attendant at that point of time. Chandan Kumar stated that he was
being paid Rs.20,000/- per month by way of cheque and had provided the
proof of his payment in the passbook, exhibited as Ex.PW2/1.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 12/18
42.
It was noted that the Insurance Company could not produce any
evidence on record to show that PW2 was not engaged to look after the
injured and was not charging Rs.20,000/- per month.
43.
Before MACT, PW2 had explained that he was working in
Sanjeevani Hospital as a ward boy since 2006, where he used to work for 8
hours per day and used to get Rs.7,000/- per month and gave up his job and is
working as an attendant for the injured.
44.
Certain cross-objections were taken up in the written submissions and
the arguments of the following:
i. Attendant charges ought to be Rs. 64,80,000/- ([Rs.20,000 + 50%]
x12 x18). Counsel for respondent no. 1 contends that future prospect
of 50% ought to be added to the attendant charges and a multiplier of
18 ought to have been applied by the Tribunal to calculate while
computing the attendant charges. In support of this contention, he
relied upon the decision of Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish
Chandra & Ors. (2020) 4 SCC 413.
ii. Physiotherapy charges ought to have been awarded at Rs. 39,42,000/([Rs. 400 + 50%] x 365 x 18), as allegedly an amount of Rs. 400/- per
visit is being spent on physiotherapy and the injured requires
physiotherapy each day for 2 hours in the morning and 2 hours in the
evening.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 13/18
iii. Compensation towards Special Diet ought to have been awarded at Rs.
19,44,000/- ([Rs. 6,000 + 50%] x 12 x 18).
iv. Compensation towards future requirements of special equipment
ought to have been award at Rs. 16,20,000/- [(Rs. 5,000 + 50%) x 12x
18], considering that the special equipment's require regular changing.
v. Compensation towards Conveyance charges ought to have been
awarded after adding future prospects of 50% and applying the
multiplier system.
vi. Future Medicine and charges for doctors ought to have been awarded
at Rs. 32,40,000/- [(Rs. 10,000/- + 50%) x 12x 13]. Counsel for
respondent no. 1 alleges that an amount of Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 15,000/per month is being spent on medicines.
vii.Pain and suffering ought to have been awarded at Rs. 15,00,000/- as
awarded in Kajal (supra).
45.
The appeal filed by Insurance Company has been pending since 2014,
and no cross-appeal has been filed so far. The Court is, therefore, not
inclined to assess such large extensive claims for enhancement.
46.
However, considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case, particularly that the injured was a young man aged 22 years with a
bright future ahead of him, which has been irreversibly affected due to
accident, this Court is mindful of the pain and suffering endured by him and
the lifelong assistance and hardships he is likely to face.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 14/18
47.
In the case of R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P) Ltd. (1995)
1 SCC 551
9. Broadly speaking while fixing an amount of
compensation payable to a victim of an accident, the
damages have to be assessed separately as pecuniary
damages and special damages. Pecuniary damages are
those which the victim has actually incurred and which
are capable of being calculated in terms of money;
whereas non-pecuniary damages are those which are
incapable of being assessed by arithmetical
calculations. In order to appreciate two concepts
pecuniary damages may include expenses incurred by
the claimant: (i) medical attendance; (ii) loss of earning
of profit up to the date of trial; (iii) other material loss.
So far non-pecuniary damages are concerned, they may
include (i) damages for mental and physical shock, pain
and suffering, already suffered or likely to be suffered in
future; (ii) damages to compensate for the loss of
amenities of life which may include a variety of matters
i.e. on account of injury the claimant may not be able to
walk, run or sit; (iii) damages for the loss of expectation
of life, i.e., on account of injury the normal longevity of
the person concerned is shortened; (iv) inconvenience,
hardship, discomfort, disappointment, frustration and
mental stress in life.
10. It cannot be disputed that because of the accident
the appellant who was an active practising lawyer has
become paraplegic on account of the injuries sustained
by him. It is really difficult in this background to assess
the exact amount of compensation for the pain and
agony suffered by the appellant and for having become
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 15/18
a lifelong handicapped. No amount of compensation
can restore the physical frame of the appellant. That is
why it has been said by courts that whenever any
amount is determined as the compensation payable for
any injury suffered during an accident, the object is to
compensate such injury “so far as money can
compensate” because it is impossible to equate the
money with the human sufferings or personal
deprivations. Money cannot renew a broken and
shattered physical frame.”
(emphasis added)
48.
Therefore, in the context of settled principles of just and reasonable
compensation, this Court recognizes the tremendous suffering undergone by
the injured, depriving him of opportunity to complete his professional
education, of the vast incalculable loss of amenities of life including of
marriage prospects. What would have been a regular prosperous life has
been rendered meaningless for the injured/victim. Therefore, all
non-pecuniary amounts are increased to Rs.5,00,000/- each.
49.
The revised computation is as under:
S.
No.
1.
Re-computed
amount
Rs.3,07,272/-
2.
Compensation under various Amount awarded
heads
Income of Injured (A) (less Income Rs.3,07,272/Tax)
Add Future Prospects (B)
50%
3.
Multiplier (C)
4.
Loss of Income/Earning Capacity Rs. 82,96,344/[(A+B) x C]
Attendant Charges
Rs. 22,00,000/-
5.
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
40%
Rs. 77,43,254.40/Rs. 22,00,000/-
Page 16/18
6.
Physiotherapy
Rs. 3,80,000/-
Rs. 3,80,000/-
7.
Special Diet
Rs. 7,00,000/-
Rs. 7,00,000/-
8.
Purchase of equipments
Rs. 2,30,000/-
Rs. 2,30,000/-
9.
Conveyance
Rs. 8,64,000/-
Rs. 8,64,000/-
10.
Medical Bills
Rs. 23,23,000/-
Rs. 23,23,000/-
11.
Pain, agony and suffering
Rs. 3,00,000/-
Rs. 5,00,000/-
12.
Loss of education
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Rs. 5,00,000/-
13.
Loss of Amenities in Life
Rs. 3,00,000/-
Rs. 5,00,000/-
14.
Loss of marriage
matrimonial discomfort
prospects/ Rs. 3,00,000/-
Rs. 5,00,000/-
15.
Disfigurement
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Total
Rs. 1,62,93,344/-
Rs. 1,66,40,254.40/-
Rate of Interest Awarded
7.5% per annum
7.5% per annum
50.
Vide
order
dated
03.12.2014,
this
Court
directed
the
appellant/Insurance Company to deposit 50% of the entire awarded amount
with proportionate up to date interest within six weeks with the Registrar
General of this Court, subject to which stay was granted. Further, the Court
directed release of 80% of the said deposited amount in favour of claimant
proportionately as per the directions in the Award through UCO Bank, Delhi
High Court Branch and the balance deposited amount was directed to be kept
in fixed deposit.
51.
Accordingly, the balance amount along with interest @7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of the petition be deposited by the Insurance
company within a period of 6 weeks with the Registrar General of this Court
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 17/18
and be disbursed as per the scheme of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the appeal
stands disposed of.
52.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of as being rendered
infructuous.
53.
The statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to appellant.
54.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
MARCH 10, 2026/mk/bp
MAC.APP. 1095/2014
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
13:39:27
Page 18/18
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review