The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. However, with regard to the rule of pay and recovery, as the learned Trial Judge has observed that there is the violation of policy condition and the appellant Insurance Company will be entitled to recover, such recovery should be made as per the decision of this Court in the case of National Insurance Company Limited v. Lirasa Bibi & Anr. reported in FMA 1003 of 2025. In the said case it was observed as follows: “Now with regard to the submission of pay and recovery it is well settled that in case of violation of Insurance Policy Condition, the Insurance Company is entitled to recover from the insured the compensation amount awarded after making payment to the claimant/victim. However before proceeding to recover from the insured, the compensation amount the insurer upon making necessary enquiry and upon giving the vehicle owner an opportunity of being heard shall ascertain as to whether the violation of policy condition was bona fide unintentional or deliberate. Thereafter the Insurance Company may decide whether to proceed against the insured or to condone such breach. In the case of Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd. VS Niyati Kumar and ors FMA- 1326 of 2025 reported in 2025 SCC Online Cal 8886 it was observed as follows: „Thus it is well settled that in order to absolve from liability of paying compensation and to obtain an order of pay and recovery it is mandatory fo…
22. Hence, this appeal FMA 83 of 2026 with COT 36 of 2025 along with all connected applications stand disposed. The judgment and award dated 18th June, 2025 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Fast Track, 3rd Court, Tamluk, Purba Mednipur in M.A.C Case No.9 of 2019 stands modified to the extent that the claimant, respondents Rs.5,50,000/- claimants from are entitled the to appellant Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Ltd. along with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing claim case i.e. 29th January, 2019 till today.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 1
09.09.2026
Court No.9
Swd
IN THE High COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
FMA 83 of 2026
With
CAN 3 of 2026
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company
Limited
Vs.
Astami Jana Maiti & Ors.
With
COT 36 of 2025
Astami Jana Maiti & Ors.
Vs.
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company
Limited & Anr.
Mr. Soumalya Ganguli.
… for the Appellant/Insurance Co.
Mr. Amit Ranjan Roy.
… for the Respondent/Claimant.
1. Learned Advocates for the parties are present.
2. Heard learned Advocates.
3. The appellant before this Court was an opposite
party in a case under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the
judgment and award dated 18th June, 2025
passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Fast Track, 3rd Court, Tamluk, Purba Mednipur
in M.A.C Case No.9 of 2019.
4. The case of the claimant before the learned Trial
Court may be summed up thus:
On 19.12.18 at about 5.30 P.M. the victim was
standing near Bakhrabad Bus Stoppage keeping
his extreme left side morum portion of NH-41.
Suddenly the offending vehicle bearing no.-WB11D/7561
(Bus)
which
was
coming
from
Mecheda side towards Haldia side with extreme
high speed, endangering the human life and
safety with zig-zag manner without blowing any
horn dashed the victim with great force from
behind. As a result the victim sustained grievous
bleeding injury all over the body, specially on
head. After the accident the victim was taken to
Purba Medinipur District Hospital at Tamluk,
where the attending doctor examined him and
declared him dead.
The accident was caused due to rash and
negligent driving on the part of the driver of the
offending
vehicle
bearing
No.WB-11D/7561
(Bus).
5. Pursuant to filing of this case, notice was issued
upon the opposite parties. The opposite party
vehicle owner did not appear to contest the case.
However, the opposite party Insurance Company
contested by filing written statement. Issues were
framed and evidence was adduced.
6. By judgment and award dated 18.06.2026 the
learned Trial Judge was pleased to dispose the
claim case by observing and directing as follows:
“Hence, It Is,
ORDERED
that the instant claim petition u/s 166 of the M.V
Act be and the same is allowed on contest against
the O.P / Insurer/ Cholamandalam M.S General
Ins. Co. Ltd. and exparte against O.P/Owner,
however, without any cost.
The claimants/petitioners are entitled to an award
of compensation amounting to Rs.4,42,640 /-with
interest at a rate of Rs.7% per annum from the
date of filing of the case (w.e.f. 29.01.2019) till the
realization of the amount of compensation.
O.P / Insurer/ Cholamandalam M.S General Ins.
Co. Ltd is directed to pay Rs.4,42,640 /-(Four
Lakh Forty Two Thousand Six Hundred and Forty
only) with accrued interest at a rate of Rs.7% per
annum from the date of filing of the case (w.e.f.
15.09.2017) till the date of payment to the four
(04)claimants / petitioners i.e. petitioner no. 1)
Astami Jana Maiti, 2) Debasish Maiti, 3) Pushpita
Kuilya Ray and 4) Papiya Jana equal share by
issuing separate A/C payee cheques to be drawn
in their favour or through NEFT/RTGS directly to
their bank accounts, if any, furnished by the
claimants / petitioners to the insurers within 60
days from the date of this order, in default, the
claimants / petitioners shall be at liberty to realise
the
compensation
along
with
interest
in
accordance with law.
O.P/Insurance Company is not responsible to pay
the aforesaid interest from the date of order till the
date of deposit of the deficit court fees by the
claimants / petitioners, if any.
The claimants / petitioners are directed to pay the
deficit court fees within 30 days from the date of
this order, if any.
Let a copy of this order/judgement be handed over
to the parties free of to the claimants / costs in
terms of Section 168 (2) of the M.V.Act.
The copy of the order/judgement shall not be
supplied petitioners until payment of deficit court
fees.”
7. The
appellant
Cholamandalam
MS
General
Insurance Company Limited being aggrieved by
the judgment and award passed by the learned
Trial Court has come up with the instant appeal.
8. The claimant respondent being also aggrieved by
the quantum of compensation awarded has filed
cross objection.
9. Heard learned Advocate for the appellant and
learned Advocate for the claimant respondent.
Perused the evidence adduced and the materials
on record.
10. Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that
the learned Trial Judge although was pleased
to observe that the insurance company opposite
party
was
entitled
to
recover
the
compensation from the vehicle owner, but has
not observed the same in the ordering portion of
the award.
11. Learned
Advocate
further
submits
that
the
compensation awarded is excessive as the widow
of the victim being one of the claimant is
receiving family pension pursuant to the death of
the victim. It is also submitted by the learned
Advocate that the interest awarded is excessive.
12. Learned advocate for the claimant's respondent
disputes
the
submission
made
by
the
learned Advocate for the insurance company.
Learned advocate submits that the claimant
under
law
is
entitled
to
receive
the
compensation without the family pension being
adjusted.
13. Learned
learned
advocate
trial
further
judge
erred
submits
in
that
the
considering the
personal deduction as one-third instead of onefourth. It is also submitted that the learned Trial
Judge
ought
to
have
awarded
consortium
of Rs.40,000/14. The following decisions are relied upon by the
learned Advocate for the parties:-
a) Vishavjit Singh Vs. Cholamandalam MS
General
Insurance
reported
in
SLP
Ors.
Vs.
No.13442 of 2020,
b) Mrs.
Helen
C.
Maharashtra
Rebello
State
&
Road
Transport
Corporation & Anr. reported in AIR 1998
SC 3191,
c) Binapani Ghosh & Ors. Vs. The New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. reported in
2013 SCC OnLine Cal 6441.
15. Upon
hearing
the
learned
Advocate
and
considering the judicial decision relied upon, this
Court is of the view that before proceeding to
decide the issue as to whether the family pension
is to be adjusted at the time of computing the
compensation, necessarily the relevant judicial
decision should be considered.
16. In the case of Mrs. Helen C. Rebello & Ors.
(Supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court was pleased
to observe:
“36.Broadly, we may examine the receipt of the
provident fund which is a deferred payment out of
the contribution made by an employee during the
tenure of his service. Such employee or his heirs
are entitled to receive this amount irrespective of
the accidental death. This amount is secured, is
certain to be received, while the amount under the
Motor Vehicles Act is uncertain and is receivable
only on the happening of the event, viz., accident,
which may not take place at all. Similarly, family
pension is also earned by an employee for the
benefit of his family in the form of his contribution
in the service in terms of the service conditions
receivable by the heirs after his death. The heirs
receive family pension even otherwise than the
accidental death. No corelation between the two.
Similarly, life insurance policy is received either by
the insured or the heirs of the insured on account
of the contract with the insurer, for which the
insured contributes in the form of premium. It is
receivable even by the insured if he lives till
maturity after paying all the premiums. In the case
of death, the insurer indemnifies to pay the sum to
the heirs, again in terms of the contract for the
premium paid. Again, this amount is receivable by
the claimant not on account of any accidental
death but otherwise on the insured's death. Death
is only a step or contingency in terms of the
contract, to receive the amount. Similarly any
cash, bank balance, shares, fixed deposits, etc.
though are all a pecuniary advantage receivable
by the heirs on account of one's death but all these
have no corelation with the amount receivable
under a statute occasioned only on account of
accidental death. How could such an amount come
within the periphery of the Motor Vehicles Act to be
termed
as
“pecuniary
advantage”
liable
for
deduction. When we seek the principle of loss and
gain, it has to be on a similar and same plane
having nexus, inter se, between them and not to
which there is no semblance of any corelation. The
insured (deceased) contributes his own money for
which he receives the amount which has no
corelation
to
the
compensation computed
as
against the tortfeasor for his negligence on account
of
the
accident.
As
aforesaid,
the
amount
receivable as compensation under the Act is on
account of the injury or death without making any
contribution towards it, then how can the fruits of
an amount received through contributions of the
insured be deducted out of the amount receivable
under the Motor Vehicles Act. The amount under
this Act he receives without any contribution. As
we have said, the compensation payable under
the Motor Vehicles Act is statutory while the
amount receivable under the life insurance policy
is contractual.”
17. This Hon’ble Court in the case of Binapani
Ghosh & Ors. (supra),
upon considering the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Mrs. Helen C. Rebello & Ors. (supra),
was pleased to observe that since the family
pension was not receivable by the widow as a
benefit arising out of accidental death of her
husband, the amount of family pension which
the widow is receiving cannot be taken into
consideration for ascertaining the actual loss of
dependency of the claimants on the death of the
deceased.
18. Thus, considering the judicial decision, the Court
is of the view that there is no scope to adjust the
family pension at the time of computing the
compensation. Now, with regard to the personal
deduction, considering the number of dependents
of the deceased, this Court is of the view that
personal deduction should be one-fourth and not
one-third. As the consortium is not awarded by
the learned Trial Judge, consortium is also to be
awarded
at
the
time
of
ascertaining
the
compensation.
19. In the event, the monthly income of the victim is
considered as Rs.10,828/-,
one-fourth being
deducted, which is Rs.2,707/-, the net monthly
income comes to Rs.8,121/-. The yearly income
comes to Rs.97,452/-. The multiplier of 5 being
applied, the total dependency loss comes to
Rs.4,87,260/-.
Further,
the
claimants
respondents are entitled to general damages on
account of loss of consortium
Rs.80,000/-,
funeral expenses Rs.15,000/- and loss of estate
Rs.15,000/-, total amounting to Rs.1,10,000/-.
Thus Rs.5,97,260/- is the total compensation
which comes by arithmetical calculation.
20. However, in the view of this Court, Rs.5,50,000/is just and reasonable.
Thus, the claimants
respondents are entitled to Rs.5,50,000/- from
the Appellant Insurance Company.
21. However, with regard to the rule of pay and
recovery,
as
the
learned
Trial
Judge
has
observed that there is the violation of policy
condition and the appellant Insurance Company
will be entitled to recover, such recovery should
be made as per the decision of this Court in the
case of National Insurance Company Limited v.
Lirasa Bibi & Anr. reported in FMA 1003 of
2025. In the said case it was observed as follows:
“Now with regard to the submission of pay and
recovery it is well settled that in case of violation
of Insurance Policy Condition, the Insurance
Company is entitled to recover from the insured
the compensation amount awarded after making
payment to the claimant/victim. However before
proceeding to recover from the insured, the
compensation amount the insurer upon making
necessary enquiry and upon giving the vehicle
owner
an
opportunity
of
being
heard
shall
ascertain as to whether the violation of policy
condition
was
bona
fide
unintentional
or
deliberate. Thereafter the Insurance Company
may decide whether to proceed against the
insured or to condone such breach.
In the case of Reliance General Insurance
Company Ltd. VS Niyati Kumar and ors FMA-
1326 of 2025 reported in 2025 SCC Online Cal
8886 it was observed as follows:
„Thus it is well settled that in order to absolve from
liability of paying compensation and to obtain an
order of pay and recovery it is mandatory for the
Insurer to prove breach of the condition of
Insurance Policy.
Although all Insurance Companies are not „State‟
within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution
of India but the fact that third party Motor
Insurance Law is a beneficial Legislation and it
has a public aspect and its object is to protect the
public (third parties) from financial losses due to
accidents caused by a motorist by ensuring that
victims are compensated. On one hand, and also
to protect the vehicle owners from bearing huge
burden of compensation in case of accidents
where the insurance policy condition is complied
with on the other hand. Thus considering the
public aspect of Motor Insurance Claims Insurance
Companies have responsibilities to ensure that
genuine accident claims are settled without delay
and the vehicle owner who has not violated the
terms of policy is not unnecessarily harassed.
In the event the Insurance Company has reasons
to believe that policy conditions were violated it
should conduct an enquiry issue notice upon the
vehicle owner and give him an opportunity of
being heard. Where the Insurance Company is
satisfied after enquiry that conditions of policy
were not violated the allegations of violation of
policy, namely the vehicle was driven without
permit or without valid driving license should not
be raised in Court.
However upon Enquiry if the Insurance Company
finds that there was violation of terms of policy
such findings should be recorded by Insurance
Company and necessary evidence should be
adduced in Court. In such a case the Enquiry
Report should also be filed in Court, apart from
adducing evidence.
A vehicle owner after getting his vehicle insured
proceeds with the assumption that Insurance
Company will settle the compensation claim in
case
of
accidents
thus
the
vehicle
owners
ordinarily do not appear in Court to contest claim
cases. Thus in the event there is allegation of
violation of condition of Policy the vehicle owners
should be given an opportunity of being heard
before such allegation being made in Court and
before being examined in Court as witness. Upon
such enquiry being made the Insurance Company
can decide as to whether policy violation was
minor or major and whether to condone such
violation or recover the amount of compensation
paid.
In the instant case the Appellant Insurance
Company has merely alleged that the vehicle was
driven without permit on the ground permit was
not seized by Police Authority but no steps were
taken to conduct an enquiry and to examine
officers of Regional Transport Authority as witness
with regard to permit of the vehicle.‟
In the event the violation of policy condition
appears at the time of argument when the case is
at the verge of disposal and there was no scope
for the Insurance Company to make preliminary
enquiry and give the vehicle owner an opportunity
of being heard the Learned Tribunal after it arrives
at a finding that there was breach of policy
condition shall after directing payment by the
Insurance Company to the claimant issue show
cause upon the Insured/vehicle owner as to „why
the compensation amount directed to be paid shall
not be recovered.‟ Copy of the Award shall also be
enclosed with the notice.
Upon hearing the vehicle owner/insured with
regard to violation of policy condition if the
tribunal/Court comes to the conclusion that there
was violation of policy condition which was not
bona fide and without sufficient explanation, the
Court/Tribunal will order recovery of amount
directed to be Paid by Insurance Company.
In the normal course where vehicle owners
receives notice of claim case they ordinarily do not
appear in Court on the ground that Insurance
Company
will
settle
the
claim.
However
if
subsequent allegation is made in the written
statement about violation of policy condition and
additional issue in this regard is framed, and
evidence adduced by the Insurance Company
further notice in this regard should be issued upon
vehicle owner to meet the allegation. In the event
the Court/Tribunal is of the view that notice to be
issued after considering the evidence adduced in
this regard Learned Tribunal may issue notice
after evidence. In any event prior to directing
recovery after payment notice in this regard must
be issued specifically and the vehicle owner
should be given an opportunity of being heard.
In the instant case the vehicle owner/insured was
not put to notice with regard to violation of policy
condition for the purpose of pay and recovery.
Thus no order with regard to recovery can be
directed
without
the
Appellant
Insurance
Company causing enquiry and giving the vehicle
owner/insured an opportunity of being heard.
Thus the Appellant National Insurance Company
Limited is granted liberty to cause service of notice
upon the vehicle owner/insured annexing copy of
the order of trial Court and this order and upon
hearing him with regard to violation of policy
condition and recovery of compensation amount
awarded. Upon hearing the insured respondent
no-2
Subrata
Nath
the
Appellant
National
Insurance Company Limited will decide whether to
proceed against the said respondent for recovery.
In the event recovery proceedings is instituted
parties will be entitled to take relevant points
involved to enable the Court/Tribunal to arrive at
a just decision.”
22. Hence, this appeal FMA 83 of 2026 with COT
36 of 2025 along with all connected applications
stand disposed. The judgment and award dated
18th June, 2025 passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, Fast Track, 3rd Court, Tamluk,
Purba Mednipur in M.A.C Case No.9 of 2019
stands modified to the extent that the claimant,
respondents
Rs.5,50,000/-
claimants
from
are
entitled
the
to
appellant
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company
Ltd. along with interest @ 6% per annum from
the date of filing claim case i.e. 29th January,
2019 till today.
23. The appellant insurance company shall deposit
Rs.5,50,000/- along with interest @
6% per
annum. Such deposit shall be made within a
period of 8 weeks to the Registrar General, High
Court, Calcutta from the date of communication
of this order.
24. In the event, compensation awarded by the
learned Trial Court is already deposited, the
balance
deposit
be
made.
The
claimant
respondent will be entitled to withdraw the
compensation
upon
compliance of
necessary
formalities. Upon payment of the compensation
the insurance company will be entitled to proceed
for recovery as per the procedure laid down in the
case of National Insurance Company Limited v.
Lirasa Bibi & Anr. (Supra). All relevant points of
law will be kept open.
25. FMA 83 of 2026 and COT 36 of 2025 be treated
as days list.
26. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance of all necessary formalities.
(BISWAROOP CHOWDHURY, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review