Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:6883-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
First Appeal No.187 of 2017
Chiranjeev Kumar Jha, son of Shri Jagannath Jha, resident of
Shastri Nagar, Banderjori, P.O. Dumka, P.S. Dumka (T), District
Dumka.
----- Appellant
Versus
Smt. Rekha Kumari Jha, wife of Shri Chiranjeev Kumar Jha,
daughter of Shri Santosh Kumar Jha, resident of Q.No.MG/9A,
Ranchi Colony, P.O. and P.S. Maithan, District Dhanbad.
----- Respondent
-----CORAM:HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
------For the Appellant
: Mr. Rajeeva Sharma, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondent : Mrs. Swati Shalini, Advocate
------34/11.03.2026
Heard Mr. Rajeeva Sharma, learned senior counsel
for the appellant and Mrs. Swati Shalini, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent.
2.
This appeal is directed against the judgment and
decree dated 31.05.2017 (decree signed on 09.06.2017) passed
by Shri Niraj Kumar Srivastav, learned Additional Principal
Judge, Additional Family Court, Dhanbad in T (M) S No. 542 of
2013 whereby and whereunder the suit preferred by the
appellant for dissolution of his marriage with the respondent has
been dismissed.
3.
For the sake of convenience, both the parties are
referred to in this judgment as per their status before the learned
trial court.
4.
The plaintiff (appellant herein) had preferred a suit for
dissolution of his marriage with the defendant (respondent
herein) under Section 13(1)(1a) of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955
in which it has been stated that the marriage of the plaintiff was
solemnized with the defendant on 24.06.2005 at Maithan
according to Hindu rites and customs. After marriage both the
plaintiff and the defendant started residing at Dumka and out of
the said wedlock two daughters were born to them. There was
peace in the marital life of the plaintiff and the defendant for
about 1-1.5 years. The plaintiff had encouraged the defendant to
obtain a law degree and in pursuance of which the defendant got
herself enrolled in Law College, Dhanbad for which the plaintiff
helped her in various manners with the support of his parents.
In the meantime, the defendant was pressurizing the plaintiff to
sell the house at Dumka, send his parents to their native village
and start staying with the defendant at Maithan. Since the
plaintiff did not accede to such demands of the defendant, he
was subjected to ill-treatment at the hands of the defendant and
her family members. It has been stated that after obtaining law
degree the defendant had started her practice without any
consent or consultation with the plaintiff and his family
members. The defendant was not willing to reside with the
plaintiff who is unemployed as his wife. The plaintiff could not
attend the birthday celebration of his second daughter on
10.07.2009 at Maithan due to sudden illness and when he
reached Maithan on the following day he was abused and
tortured. It has been stated that on a request made by the
plaintiff in writing the parents of the defendant had come and a
detailed discussion had taken place. The matter was amicably
settled and the plaintiff went to Maithan on the next day and
brought back the defendant to Dumka. On 12.07.2011 the
plaintiff had met with an accident causing fracture of his right
arm and for better treatment the plaintiff was sent to Dhanbad
by his father in consultation with the father of the defendant on
13.07.2011. On 15.07.2011 the plaintiff underwent an operation
and the entire expenses were borne by the father of the plaintiff.
Since the plaintiff had to undergo a final checkup after a week,
he stayed at Maithan. The plaintiff after conversation with his
father had informed the defendant and her family members that
he will go back to Dumka on 29.07.2011, but on 27.07.2011 a
quarrel had taken place between the plaintiff and his brother-inlaw and the plaintiff was abused and was on the verge of being
assaulted. When the plaintiff was leaving for Dumka the
defendant had refused to accompany him and the plaintiff
returned to Dumka with Suraj Mishra and his wife. The
defendant and her family members did not enquire about the
health condition of the plaintiff from 27.07.2011 to 06.09.2011.
There was an exchange of letters and the defendant had
specifically stated that she is not willing to live as the wife of the
plaintiff. Due to such dispute a meeting was held in the
residence of the father of the defendant at Maithan in which
others were also present and despite some proposal given by the
father of the plaintiff to iron out the differences, the defendant
did not accept such proposal and refused to enter into an
agreement. The plaintiff had filed a suit for restitution of
conjugal rights bearing Case No. 103/2011 and on 10.09.2012
an application was filed by the plaintiff for withdrawal of the suit.
5.
On being noticed, the defendant had appeared and
filed a written statement in which the allegations levelled against
the defendant in the plaint has been denied. It has been stated
that the defendant had always tried to maintain a cordial
relationship with the plaintiff and her parents-in-law. After the
operation of the plaintiff at Maithan when the defendant went to
stay at her matrimonial house at Dumka, the plaintiff had
expressed his desire to oust her and solemnize another marriage.
The suit itself is not maintainable since the suit for restitution of
conjugal rights is already pending. The defendant has also
expressed her desire to reside with the plaintiff and her parents
without any condition.
6.
Based on the pleadings of the parties, the following
issues have been framed for adjudication:1.
Whether the suit as framed is maintainable?
2.
Whether the plaintiff has got a valid cause of action
for the suit?
3.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of
dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty?
4.
7.
What are the relief or reliefs the plaintiff is entitled?
The plaintiff has examined three witnesses in support
of his case.
8.
P.W.1 Jagannath Jha is the father of the plaintiff who
has stated that the marriage of the plaintiff was solemnized in
the year 2005 with the defendant as per Hindu rites and
customs and after two years of marriage disputes cropped up
between them. The defendant did not want to stay at Dumka and
put pressure upon the plaintiff to stay with her on a permanent
basis at Maithan. The defendant had expressed a desire to study
law which was encouraged by him and the plaintiff and in the
year 2011 the defendant had obtained her law degree. He has
stated that the plaintiff had gone to Maithan for his treatment
and on 15.07.2011 he was operated upon and a plate was
inserted in his fractured arm. At the time of treatment the
defendant, Subhash Kumar Jha and his son as well as
Kameshwar Mandal were present along with him. He had asked
the plaintiff to return to Dumka along with his wife and children
on 29.07.2011 but on 27.07.2011 the plaintiff had called him
over phone and informed him that he is being abused and
assaulted. He had offered to come to Maithan with a car but after
sometime the defendant called him and asked him not to come
as she will not rent a car and come back to Dumka. On the same
day at about 4.30-5.00 p.m the plaintiff came back to Dumka
along with the brother-in-law of the plaintiff but the defendant
and her child had not come. He has stated that his wife has
several ailments but in spite of the same the defendant did not
return and the health condition of his wife and the plaintiff made
him miserable. The defendant and her family members for the
next two months did not even come to know about the condition
of the plaintiff and his parents. In order to restore normalcy in
the marital life of the plaintiff and defendant he had gone to
Maithan
on
18.10.2011
along
with
Kashinath
Mishra,
Basukinath Pandey and Raghunath Jha and they had a
discussion with the family members of the defendant but the
defendant refused to go back to Dumka. On 18.11.2011 he had
once again gone to Maithan accompanied by the persons who
had earlier come on 18.10.2011 as also with the plaintiff when
the situation was found to be tense and he had asked the
defendant to come to Dumka on Sunday and the plaintiff will
take her back. When he was going back to Dumka, the younger
sister of the defendant spat at the car and started muttering
something. The plaintiff had filed a suit for restitution of conjugal
rights which was not taken seriously by the defendant and
instead she had filed an application in the High Court for
transfer of the suit. He had come to know a year back that the
defendant has started practice in Civil Court, Dhanbad. The
defendant is a selfish woman and has a rude behavior.
In cross-examination he has deposed that the plaintiff
is not capable to bear the expenses of the family. Sometimes the
plaintiff asks him for money for his own personal need. He had
not given permission to the defendant to practice law. He has
deposed that it is true that at the time of fracture of the arm of
the plaintiff, the father of the defendant stood beside him at the
time of distress. It is also true that the defendant and her family
members had looked after the plaintiff and gave him proper
treatment. After the checkup of the plaintiff it was the father of
the defendant who had sent his son-in-law to accompany the
plaintiff in coming back to Dumka. The relationship deteriorated
after the plaintiff came back to Dumka.
9.
P.W.2 Kashinath Mishra has stated that he had
attended the Barat of the plaintiff. In the year 2008-09 the
defendant had created so much of trouble that he had to
accompany the father of the plaintiff to Maithan to leave the
defendant at her parents' house. He had gone to Maithan on
18.10.2011 and 18.11.2011 along with Satish Jha to resolve the
dispute. The defendant despite repeated efforts refused to come
back to Dumka. On both the dates the defendant had behaved
very rudely and she did not even extend the basic courtesy. In
July 2011 the defendant had taken the plaintiff to Maithan for
treatment and she had never come back to Dumka thereafter.
In cross-examination he has deposed that he does not
have a family relation with the plaintiff. He does not know as to
whether the plaintiff has filed any suit for restitution of conjugal
rights or not. The plaintiff will take the Bidai of the defendant
and her children.
10.
P.W.3 Chiranjeev Kumar Jha is the plaintiff who has
reiterated what has been stated by P.W.1 in his sworn statement.
He has also referred to the exchange of letters through which the
defendant had threatened him. Several times counseling had
been done but the defendant was not ready to accept any
condition. He has lost confidence on the defendant and it is too
late in the day to restore normalcy in his marital life.
In cross-examination he has deposed that in the legal
notice dated 16.09.2011 the defendant had expressed her
intention to stay with him. He has instituted the suit for
dissolution of marriage after filing a withdrawal application in
the suit for restitution of conjugal rights. The suit for restitution
of conjugal rights was disposed of in the year 2014-15. He has
an income of Rs. 2000-4000/- per month. He is not financially
capable to take care of his wife and children. The defendant
during her stay at her matrimonial house used to cook only and
his parents were looked after by a maid servant.
11.
The defendant has examined herself as a witness.
12.
D.W.1 Rekha Kumari Jha is the defendant who has
stated about solemnization of her marriage with the plaintiff on
24.06.2025 at Maithan as per Hindu rites and customs and out
of the said wedlock two daughters were born to the couple. In
T(M)S No.542 of 2013 she had filed a reply in which she has
expressed her willingness to stay with the plaintiff at her
matrimonial house. When T(M)S No.542 of 2013 was dismissed,
she had filed a suit for restitution of conjugal rights being T(M)S
No.398/2015.
In cross-examination she has deposed that in her
legal practice she has only one brief at present. In her
application dated 03.03.2015 she had mentioned the income of
the plaintiff as Rs. 65,000/- per month which is correct.
13.
It has been submitted by Mr. Rajeeva Sharma,
learned senior counsel for the petitioner/appellant that the
petitioner has been able to show the manner by which he was
subjected to cruelty and several instances have been given by
him to highlight such assertion. Despite the best efforts made by
the plaintiff, he was subjected to humiliation and was ousted
from his in-laws place at Maithan. There has been no conjugal
relationship since 27.07.2011 and the marriage has, for all
practical purposes, become dead. The defendant, in fact, during
her marital journey with the plaintiff, had herself stayed for a
year at her matrimonial house. Mr. Sharma, learned senior
counsel has submitted that it is to be borne in mind that the
defendant had never alleged any atrocity or torture committed
upon her by the plaintiff. The defendant could obtain a law
degree only on account of the active support of the plaintiff and
his father.
14.
Mrs. Swati Shalini, learned counsel appearing for the
defendant/respondent has submitted that the learned trial court
has correctly appreciated the nuances of the case while
dismissing the suit. It was the defendant and his family
members who had looked after the plaintiff when he had suffered
a fractured arm, but the plaintiff had never cared to lead a
peaceful marital life with the defendant. The defendant has
always expressed her desire to reside with the plaintiff at her
matrimonial house.
15.
We have heard the learned counsel for the respective
parties and have also perused the trial court records.
16.
The only issue of substance is whether the plaintiff
was treated with cruelty by the defendant or not. The learned
trial court has answered the said issue in the negative and
therefore the plaintiff has assailed the impugned judgment in
this appeal. As per the plaintiff, after his marriage with the
defendant,
the
defendant
had
resided
peacefully
at
her
matrimonial house for 1-1.5 years after which the relationship
deteriorated and the plaintiff has sought to give various
instances which, according to him, are the focal points in his
endeavor to seek dissolution of marriage on the ground of
cruelty. The evidence of the plaintiff and his witnesses do not
suggest of even a solitary incident which can be construed to be
a compelling situation for the plaintiff not to stay with the
defendant. Even the plaintiff and his witnesses have admitted
that when the plaintiff met with an accident and fractured his
arm, it was the defendant and his family members who got him
treated and took care of him. Even after an operation was
conducted and a plate inserted in his arm, the plaintiff
recuperated at Maithan and during this period the operating
Surgeon had also reviewed the progress of the plaintiff.
17.
On consideration of the pleadings and the evidence
there apparently does not seem to be any justifiable reasons
which could have implored the plaintiff leading to his instituting
a suit for divorce. Earlier the plaintiff had filed a suit for
restitution of conjugal rights in which he had also filed an
application for withdrawal followed by the present suit. This
sequence of events does not lend any credibility to the claim of
the plaintiff that he was subjected to cruelty. Nothing of
substance has emanated either from the plaintiff or from the
evidence of the witnesses of the plaintiff which would even show
a semblance of truthfulness to the effect that the acts of the
defendant had made it an impossibility for the plaintiff to reside
with the defendant. The learned trial court, on consideration of
the entire factual matrix of the case, has rightly decided Issue
No. 3 in favour of the defendant and against the plaintiff.
18.
Mr. Rajeeva Sharma, learned senior counsel has
strenuously pointed out the long separation of the plaintiff and
the defendant which would indicate that the marriage has
broken down irretrievably and no fruitful purpose will be served
in prolonging the marital ties. This, in our considered opinion,
cannot be answered by us for the simple reason that the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955 does not contain “irretrievable breakdown of
marriage” as one of the conditions by which dissolution of
marriage can be sought. The said contention of Mr. Rajeeva
Sharma, learned senior counsel for the appellant is beyond the
domain of this Court.
19.
Thus, on consideration of the entire aspects of the
case, we affirm the judgment and decree dated 31.05.2017
(decree signed on 09.06.2017) passed by Shri Niraj Kumar
Srivastav, learned Additional Principal Judge, Additional Family
Court, Dhanbad in T (M) S No. 542 of 2013 and consequently we
dismiss this appeal.
20.
Pending Interlocutory application(s), if any, stand(s)
closed.
(Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.)
Dated: 11.03.2026
Shamim/Uploaded on: 16/03/2026
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review