The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. The ordinary rule of civil law is that the rights of the parties stand crystallised on the date of the institution of the suit and, therefore, the decree in a suit should accord with the rights of the parties as they stood at the commencement of the lis. However, the Court has power to take note of subsequent events and mould the relief accordingly subject to the following conditions being satisfied: (i) that the relief, as claimed originally has, by reason of subsequent events, become inappropriate or cannot be granted; (ii) that taking note of such subsequent event or changed circumstances would shorten litigation and enable complete justice being done to the parties; and (iii) that such subsequent event is brought to the notice of the court promptly and in accordance with the rules of procedural law so that the opposite party is not taken by surprise. In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. Motor & General Traders [(1975) 1 SCC 770: AIR 1975 SC 1409] this Court held that a fact arising after the lis, coming to the notice of the court and having a fundamental impact on the right to relief or the manner of moulding it and brought diligently to the notice of the court cannot be blinked at. The court may, in such cases, bend the rules of procedure if no specific provision of law or rule of fair play is violated, for it would promote substantial justice provided that there is absence of o…
12. Such subsequent event may be one purely of law or founded on facts. In the former case, the court may take judicial notice of the event and, before acting thereon, put the parties on notice of how the change in law is going to affect the rights and obligations of the parties and modify or mould the course of litigation or the relief so as to bring it in conformity with the law. In the latter case, the party relying on the subsequent event, which consists of facts not beyond the pale of controversy either as to their existence or in their impact, is expected to have resort to amendment of pleadings under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Such subsequent event, the Court may permit being introduced into the pleadings by way of amendment, as it would be necessary to do so for the purpose of determining real questions in controversy between the parties. In Trojan & Co. v. RM. N.N. Nagappa Chettiar [(1953) 1 SCC 456: AIR 1953 SC 235] this Court has held that the decision of a case cannot be based on grounds outside the pleadings of the parties and it is the case pleaded that has to be found; without the amendment of the pleadings the Court would not be entitled to modify or alter the relief. In Sri Mahant Govind Rao v. Sita Ram Kesho [(1898) 25 IA 195 (PC)], Their Lordships observed that, as a rule, relief not founded on the pleadings should not be granted.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Chet Ram (deceased) through LRs Vs. Ami
Chand and others
RSA No. 326 of 2016
Reserved on: 22.7.2026
28.7.2026 Present:
Mr. Sahil Dixit, Advocate, for the appellants.
Mr Mohinder
respondents.
Verma,
Advocate,
for
the
filed
the
CMP No. 26774 of 2025
The
applicants/defendants
have
present application under Section 151 CPC for bringing the
subsequent events on record. It has been asserted that late
Sh. Chet Ram had filed a civil suit against the defendants
for permanent prohibitory injunction who had purchased
the property out of his share. He had sold the land
measuring 0-02-51 hectares out of Khasra No. 1354 and
1355 to Smt. Mridula through a registered sale deed on
16.12.2004. There was an old structure which was
demolished and a three-storied building was constructed
during the pendency of the litigation. Chet Ram is not
entitled to the injunction as prayed for by him. Therefore,
it was prayed that the present application be allowed and
the subsequent events be taken on record.
The application is opposed by filing a reply
taking
preliminary
objection
regarding
lack
of
maintainability and suppression of material facts. It was
asserted that the application has been filed to mislead the
Court and prolong the disposal of the main Appeal. The
facts sought to be brought on record are neither
subsequent nor newly discovered. The existence and
execution of the Sale Deed dated 16.12.2004 was fully
disclosed before the learned Trial Court by all the
contesting parties, and this fact was incorporated in the
statement of original plaintiff-Chet Ram, Dhani Ram
(DW1) and Om Prakash (DW2). The execution of the sale
deed was duly admitted by all the parties. The applicants
want to reintroduce the facts which were part of the record
of the learned Trial Court. The respondents No.1 and 3 have
alienated the suit property by way of registered sale deeds
dated 22.12.2015 and 12.07.2024, respectively. Hence, it was
prayed that the present application be dismissed.
I have heard learned counsel of the parties and
have gone through the records carefully.
The applicants are seeking to bring on record
the factum of execution of a Sale Deed dated 16.12.2004.
The record shows that the civil suit was filed before the
learned Trial Court on 02.12.2003 and was decided on
10.12.2012. The facts sought to be brought on record had
transpired during the pendency of the civil suit before the
learned Trial Court and cannot be said to be a subsequent
event which had taken place during the pendency of the
appeal before this Court. Moreover, the record shows that
Chet Ram (PW1) had admitted in his cross-examination
that Guddi Devi had constructed a house and he had not
filed any suit against her. Dhani Ram (DW1) stated that the
plaintiff sold the land to Guddi Devi, who had started the
construction of the wall. Similarly, his witness Om Prakash
(DW2) stated that the plaintiff had also sold the land to
Guddi Devi, who was carrying out the construction.
Therefore, the evidence on record clearly
shows that the sale made in favour of Guddi Devi was
disclosed to the Court in the statements on oath.
It was laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Om Prakash Gupta v. Ranbir B. Goyal, (2002) 2 SCC 256:
2002 SCC OnLine SC 96 that the rights and liabilities are
crystallised on the date of filing of the suit, but the Court
can take note of subsequent events if they are brought on
record by following the proper procedure by way of
amendment of the pleadings. It was observed at page 262:
11. The ordinary rule of civil law is that the rights of
the parties stand crystallised on the date of the
institution of the suit and, therefore, the decree in a
suit should accord with the rights of the parties as
they stood at the commencement of the lis.
However, the Court has power to take note of
subsequent events and mould the relief accordingly
subject to the following conditions being satisfied:
(i) that the relief, as claimed originally has, by
reason of subsequent events, become inappropriate
or cannot be granted; (ii) that taking note of such
subsequent event or changed circumstances would
shorten litigation and enable complete justice
being done to the parties; and (iii) that such
subsequent event is brought to the notice of the
court promptly and in accordance with the rules of
procedural law so that the opposite party is not
taken by surprise. In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v.
Motor & General Traders [(1975) 1 SCC 770: AIR 1975
SC 1409] this Court held that a fact arising after the
lis, coming to the notice of the court and having a
fundamental impact on the right to relief or the
manner of moulding it and brought diligently to
the notice of the court cannot be blinked at. The
court may, in such cases, bend the rules of
procedure if no specific provision of law or rule of
fair play is violated, for it would promote
substantial justice provided that there is absence of
other disentitling factors or just circumstances.
The Court, speaking through Krishna Iyer, J.,
affirmed the proposition that the court can, so long
as the litigation pends, take note of updated facts to
promote substantial justice. However, the Court
cautioned: (i) the event should be one as would
stultify or render inept the decretal remedy, (ii)
rules of procedure may be bent if no specific
provision or fair play is violated and there is no
other special circumstance repelling resort to that
course in law or justice, (iii) such cognizance of
subsequent events and developments should be
cautious, and (iv) the rules of fairness to both sides
should be scrupulously obeyed.
12. Such subsequent event may be one purely of law
or founded on facts. In the former case, the court
may take judicial notice of the event and, before
acting thereon, put the parties on notice of how the
change in law is going to affect the rights and
obligations of the parties and modify or mould the
course of litigation or the relief so as to bring it in
conformity with the law. In the latter case, the
party relying on the subsequent event, which
consists of facts not beyond the pale of controversy
either as to their existence or in their impact, is
expected to have resort to amendment of pleadings
under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Such subsequent event,
the Court may permit being introduced into the
pleadings by way of amendment, as it would be
necessary to do so for the purpose of determining
real questions in controversy between the parties.
In Trojan & Co. v. RM. N.N. Nagappa Chettiar [(1953)
1 SCC 456: AIR 1953 SC 235] this Court has held that
the decision of a case cannot be based on grounds
outside the pleadings of the parties and it is the
case pleaded that has to be found; without the
amendment of the pleadings the Court would not
be entitled to modify or alter the relief. In Sri
Mahant Govind Rao v. Sita Ram Kesho [(1898) 25 IA
195 (PC)], Their Lordships observed that, as a rule,
relief not founded on the pleadings should not be
granted.
13. Power of the court to take note of subsequent
events, especially at the appellate stage, came up
for the consideration of a Full Bench of the Nagpur
High Court presided over by Justice Sinha (as His
Lordship then was) in Chhote Khan v. Mohd.
Obedulla Khan [AIR 1953 Nag 361]. Hidayatullah, J.
(as His Lordship then was) held, on a review of
judicial opinion, that an action must be tried in all
its stages on the cause of action as it existed at the
commencement of the action. No doubt, courts
“can” and sometimes “must” take notice of
subsequent events, but that is done merely “inter
partes” to shorten litigation, but not to give to a
defendant an advantage because a third party has
acquired the right and title of the plaintiff. The
doctrine itself is of an exceptional character only to
be used in very special circumstances. It is all the
more strictly applied in those cases where there is a
judgment under appeal. His Lordship quoted the
statement of law made by Sir Ashutosh Mookerjee,
J. in a series of cases that merely because the
plaintiff loses his title pendente lite is no reason for
allowing his adversary to win if the corresponding
right has not vested in the adversary but in a third
party. In the case at hand, the defendant-appellant
has simply stated the factum of proceedings
initiated by HUDA against the plaintiff-respondent
in an affidavit very casually filed by him. He has not
even made a prayer to the court to take notice of
such subsequent event and mould the relief
accordingly, or to deny the relief to the plaintiffrespondent as allowed to him by the judgment
under appeal, much less sought for an amendment
of the pleadings. The subsequent event urged by
the defendant-appellant is basically a factual event
and cannot be taken cognisance of unless brought
to the notice of the court in accordance with the
established rules of procedure, which, if done,
would have afforded the plaintiff-respondent an
opportunity of meeting the case now sought to be
set up by the appellant. We do not think this Court
would be justified in taking notice of a fact sought
to be projected by the appellant in a very cavalier
manner. The fact remains that the present one is a
landlord-tenant dispute and we cannot upset the
relief granted by the courts below and the High
Court to the plaintiff-respondent by relying on the
doctrine of eviction by title paramount as it cannot
be said that the proceedings initiated by HUDA
against the plaintiff-respondent have achieved a
finality or are such proceedings wherein the
plaintiff-respondent cannot possibly have any
sustainable defence.
Therefore, it is impermissible to act upon the
applications filed under Section 151 of CPC for taking note
of the subsequent events, and the present application
cannot be allowed on this ground as well.
In view of the above, the present application
fails, and it is dismissed.
The observations made hereinbefore shall
remain confined to the disposal of the present application
and will have no bearing whatsoever on the merits of the
case.
CMP No. 17771 of 2026
The present application has been filed for filing
the English translation of relevant documents. The
documents are in Hindi. Therefore, a prayer has been made
to get the documents translated by the official translator
on payment of the expenses.
Since the documents are admittedly in Hindi,
the present application is allowed, and the official
Translator of the Court is directed to translate the
documents on deposit of the expenses by the applicant.
The present application stands disposed of.
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Judge
28th July, 2026
(Chander)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review