Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: July 31, 2026
Pronounced on: August 24, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC011844232018
+
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018, CRL.M.A. 28537/2018
CHANDRA SHEKHAR SHARMA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashutosh Lohia, Ms. Shraddha
Bhargava, Mr. Mukesh Vatsa, Mr.
Pranav Kumar, Mr. Ritik Chandel
and Mr. Tarun Kaushik, Advs.
Versus
STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Satish Kumar, APP with Ms.
Upasana Bakshi, Ms. Divya Bakshi
and Mr. Ashok Kumar Shukla,
Advs. With SI-Pawan Kumar, PS:
V.K. South
Mr. Satendra Singh and Mr. Lalit
Kumar, Advs. for R-2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAURABH BANERJEE
JUDGMENT
1.
By virtue of the present petition under Section 397 read with Section
401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure1, 19731, the petitioner inter alia
seeks setting aside of the order on charge dated 11.07.20182 passed by
learned Additional Sessions Judge-03, New Delhi District, Patiala House
in SC No. 275/2017 entitled ‘State vs. Sanjay Kumar & Ors.’ arising out
Hereinafter “CrPC
Hereinafter “impugned order”
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
of FIR No.176/2017 dated 30.04.2017 insofar as it directs framing of
charges under Sections 120B read with 302 of the Indian Penal Code,
18603 against the petitioner.
2.
Briefly put, the present FIR was registered upon receipt of secret
information that an inter-State gang had allegedly taken a contract to
murder the owner of Orient Taj Hotel and Resort. On 29.04.2017, at about
09:15 PM, a police raiding team intercepted a car, a motorcycle and a
scooty. Five persons, namely Hari Ram, Chain Pal Gurjar, Sanjeev
Kumar, Sanjay Kumar and Ashok Kumar were found in the car; two
persons, namely Chaman Prakash (rider) and Bijender (pillion rider) were
on the motorcycle; Manish Khari was riding the scooty. Upon being
confronted by the police, accused Bijender allegedly fired a gunshot at SI
Krishan Kumar with an unlicensed pistol, however, he managed to duck
and narrowly escaped injury. Similarly, accused Manish Khari also fired
at Inspector Richpal with an unlicensed pistol and the bullet struck his
bullet-proof jacket.
3.
Thereafter, the accused were overpowered and apprehended by the
police team and one pistol with one live cartridge and three other live
cartridges each were recovered from accused Bijender and Manish Khari
respectively; one pistol with three live cartridges were recovered from
accused Chain Pal Gurjar; one pistol with one live cartridge and one more
live cartridge were recovered from accused Sandeep Kumar, and one
country made pistol with one live cartridge and one more live cartridge
were recovered from accused Hari Ram, Sanjay Kumar, Chaman Prakash
Hereinafter “IPC”
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
and Ashok Kumar.
4.
During investigation, in their disclosure statements, the co-accused
persons namely Sanjay Kumar, Manish Khari and Chain Pal Gurjar
revealed that co-accused Sanjay Kumar met with one Ravi Poopwas, who
further introduced them to one Vijay Nagar, who introduced them to
Shambhu Sharma and further introduced them to the present petitioner,
who is alleged to have given the contract for murdering the respondent
no.2/ victim, the petitioner’s brother. Based thereon, the present petitioner
was apprehended on 22.07.2017 from Bulandshahar, Uttar Pradesh and
was subsequently granted bail vide order dated 01.08.2017 passed by the
learned Trial Court.
5.
After filing of the chargesheet on 14.07.2017, and supplementary
chargesheet on 01.12.2017, the charges against the accused persons
including the petitioner were framed by the learned Trial Court vide
impugned order dated 11.07.2018 and formal charges were framed on
16.07.2018.
6.
Hence, the present petition seeking setting aside of the order dated
11.07.2018 and 16.07.2018 passed by the learned Trial Court.
7.
Before this Court, learned counsel for the petitioner primarily
submitted that the learned Trial Court has erred in framing charges against
the petitioner under Sections 120B read with 302 of the IPC as nothing
incriminating has been recovered at his instance, so much so, he was
neither named in the FIR nor was present at the scene of crime.
8.
Also, his involvement, as per learned counsel, in the alleged offence
is merely based on the disclosure statements of co-accused Sanjay Kumar,
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
Manish Khari and Chain Pal Gurjar and some Call Detail Records4 of the
petitioner with them. The learned counsel also submitted that the charge of
conspiracy, in the absence of any material recovery, cannot be based
merely on the disclosure statements of the co-accused persons and cannot
in itself establish complicity of the petitioner, hence such disclosure is an
inadmissible piece of evidence under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 18725.
9.
Learned counsel further submitted that, even otherwise, since co-
accused Shambhu is an old acquaintance of the petitioner, communication
over mobile phone inter se themselves cannot be the sole basis for
forming an assumption that the petitioner was a part of the alleged
conspiracy. The learned counsel also submitted that though, the disclosure
statements resulted in discovery of CDRs, but they only show the number
of times the petitioner communicated with the co-accused Shambhu
Sharma, and without their being any recorded conversation and/ or
transcript, the same accord no collaborative value to the disclosure
statements given qua the petitioner by the co-accused persons.
10.
To buttress his arguments, learned counsel placed reliance upon the
pronouncements by co-ordinate benches of this Court in Ashok Kumar
Singh vs. State of NCT of Delhi6 and Mamta Sapra vs. State Govt. of
NCT of Delhi7.
11.
Lastly, learned counsel submitted that since there is prima facie no
material either to show that the petitioner had prior knowledge of
Hereinafter “CDRs”
Hereinafter “Evidence Act”
2024 SCC OnLine Del 4203
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
commission of the offence and/ or that he shared the intention to commit
the offence and/ or that he participated in any manner whatsoever in
commission of the alleged conspiracy, charges could not have been
framed against the petitioner under Sections 120B read with 302 of the
IPC.
12.
Per contra, learned APP submitted that the impugned order is well
reasoned as there were/ are enough grounds to proceed against the
petitioner under Section 228 CrPC, as there was/ is sufficient evidence
against him to suspect commission of the alleged offence. Learned APP
further submitted that during investigation, the role of the petitioner as the
main conspirator i.e. the person having given the contract for murdering
the respondent no.2, surfaced in the disclosure statements of co-accused
Sanjay Kumar, Manish Khari and Chain Pal Gurjar, which fact has been
corroborated by way of the CDRs, analysis of the petitioner as also the coaccused persons.
13.
The learned APP submitted that the CDRs indicate a web of
frequent communication inter se them, wherein the petitioner has
communicated with co-accused Shambhu Sharma as many as 301 times
between 05.09.2016 to 14.05.2017 from his two mobile numbers and with
co-accused Vijay Nagar twice on 29.09.2016; co-accused Shambhu
Sharma has communicated with co-accused Vijay Nagar as many as 269
times between 30.09.2016 to 15.04.2017 from his three numbers; coaccused Vijay Nagar has communicated with co-accused Ravi Kumar and
co-accused Sanjay as many as 13 and 27 times respectively; co-accused
2024 SCC OnLine Del 4485
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
Ravi Kumar had communicated with co-accused Sanjay Kumar as many
as 143 times between 03.08.2016 to 16.01.2017 from his two mobile
numbers; co-accused Ravi Kumar had communicated with co-accused
Manish Khari as many as 26 times between 30.09.2016 to 15.04.2017
from his two mobile numbers; and co-accused Sanjay Kumar had
communicated with co-accused Manish Khari as many as 70 times
between 10.10.2016 to 15.04.2017 from his two mobile numbers, which
clearly indicates the active involvement of the petitioner in the
commission of the alleged offence.
14.
Lastly, learned APP submitted that at the stage of framing of
charges, the learned Trial Court is only required to sift and weigh the
evidence for the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a prima
facie case against the accused person(s) is made out as a meticulous
appreciation of evidence is impermissible.
15.
In view thereof, as per learned APP since the present revision
petition being devoid of any merit, the same is liable to be dismissed.
16.
Learned counsel for the respondent no.2/ victim in support of the
above submissions advanced by learned APP submitted that there is
sufficient incriminating material against the petitioner to show that he had
prior knowledge of the plan of the alleged offence and that the co-accused
persons were acting at his behest. In fact, the same is evident from the
disclosure statements of co-accused persons duly corroborated by the
CDRs of the petitioner and the co-accused persons, who have been
actively connected with each other and hatched the conspiracy to commit
the murder of the respondent no.2.
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
17.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, as also the learned APP and
perused the materials on record including the judgments cited at Bar.
18.
Interestingly, as per law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Union of India vs. Prafulla Kumar Samal8; Dilawar Balu vs. State of
Maharshtra9; Sajjan Kumar vs. CBI10; State of Gujarat vs. Dilipsinh
Kishorsinh Rao11 and Amit Kapoor (supra), at the stage of framing of
charges, the test is whether the allegations borne out from the record
before the learned Trial Court, taken at their highest, constitute the alleged
offence or not. As such, based on a conjoint reading of Sections 227 and
228 of the CrPC, while framing of charges, the learned Trial Court is not
required to conduct a mini trial and is only to ascertain the existence of a
prima facie case without delving into the probative value of the material(s)
available on record, the submissions advanced by the prosecution, as also
the accused for determining as to whether sufficient grounds exist for
proceeding against the accused. Thus, the statutory framework governing
discharge and framing of charges under Sections 227 and 228 of the CrPC
respectively is well-settled and needs no further deliberation.
19.
Bearing the aforesaid in mind and since the present petition
challenges the legality and propriety of the impugned order on charge
dated 11.07.2018, for ease of reference, relevant findings qua the
petitioner as recorded therein are reproduced as under:
“… …Accused Sanjay, Manish Khari and Chainpal Gurjar
further disclosed that accused Sanjay Kumar had met Ravi
(1979) 3 SCC 4
(2002) 2 SCC 135
(2010) 9 SCC 368
(2023) 17 SCC 688
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
Roopwas and further introduced them to accused Vijay who
had further introduced them to accused Shamhhu Shrama
who had further introduced them to accused Chander
Shekhar Sharma and accused Chander Shekhar Sharma,
who is the brother of victim Shri K.K. Sharma, had given
the contract for murdering the victim Shri K.K. Sharma.
Ld. Addl. PP has contended that all accused persons are
liable to be charged with conspiracy to commit murder.
Ld. Counsel for the accused persons have stated that the
disclosure statements of the accused persons cannot be taken
into account. Ld. Counsel for accused Chander Shekhar
Sharma has contended that there is no evidence against
accused Chander Shekhar Sharma and he should be
discharged.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Now as per CDRs accused Chander Shekhar Sharma had
communicated with accused Shambu Sharma from his
mobile number 8126588888 form 05.09.2016 to 14.05.2017
(206 times).
Accused Chander Shekhar Sharma had also communicated
with accused Shambu Sharma from his another mobile no.
9759022222 from 02.12.2016 to 07.04.2017 (95 calls).
Accused Chander Shekhar Sharma communicated with
accused Vijay Nagar on mobile no 7017616323 on
29.09.2016 at 10:1 AM and on 9891921515 on 29.09.2016
at 10:12 AM.
Accused Shambhu Sharma had communicated with accused
Vijay Nagar on mobile no. 9891921515 from to 15.04.2017
(73 calls) and on mobile no. 717612323 from 29.11.2016 ton
24.01.2017 (39 calls).
Accused Shambu had also communicated with the accused
Vijay Nagar on mobile no. 9891921515 from to 15.04.2017
(73 calls) and 7017612323 from 29.11.2016 to 24.01.2017
(39 calls). It is further stated that accused Shambu had
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
communicated with accused Vijay Nagar on his mobile no.
7017616323 from 30.09.2016 to 28.01.2017 (18 calls) and
9891921515 from 30.09.2016 to 20.03.2017 (139 calls).
Accused Vijay Nagar from his mobile no. 9891921515 had
communicated with accused Ravi Rupwas on 17.10.2016, 1719.02.2017 on mobile no. 9457827127 (13 calls) and accused
Vijay Nagar had also communicated with accused Sanjay on
mobile no. 9718136747 after 06.03.2017 (24 calls) and on
mobile no: 8376921484 (3 calls).
Accused Ravi Kumar @ Rupwas had communicated with
accused Sanjay Kumar from 03.08.2016 and 29.08.2016 and
after 12.10.2016 to 24.04.2017 on mobile no. 718136747
(122 calls) and mobile no. 8376921484 from 02.08.2016 to
16.01.2017 (21 calls)
Accused Ravi Kumar @ Rupwas had communicated with
accused Manish Khari on mobile no. 9599142905 from
30.09.2016 till March, 20178 (13 calls) and on mobile no.
7011459683 from 29.12.2016 to 15.04.2017 (13 calls).
Accused Sanjay Kumar from his mobile no. 9718136747 had
communicated with accused Manish Khari on mobile no.
9599142905 after 10.10.2016 to 26.04.2016 (61 calls) and
mobile no. 7011459683 from 22.11.2016 to 21.04.2017.
Accused Sanjay Kumar from mobile no. 8376921484 had
communication with accused Manish Khari on mobile no.
7011459683 on 06.03.2017 (8 calls) and on mobile no.
9599142905 on 15.04.2017 (one call).
When the police had apprehended the accused persons
namely Manish Khari, Chaman Prakash @ Dholi, Bijender
@ Khapatta, Hari Ram @ Mintu, Chain Pal Gurjar @
Chainu, Sandeep Kumar @ Dhola, Sanjay Kumar, on receipt
of secret information they were only aware that they were
going to commit murder of owner of Orient Taj Hotel and
Resort. Now Orient Taj Hotel and Resort had three owners.
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
However, after recording the disclosure statements of the
accused a new fact was discovered by the police to the effect
that the accused persons were going to commit the murder of
Shri K.K. Sharma. It was further revealed that they had
received a contract for murdering Shri K.K. Sharma which
was given by accused Chander Shekhar Sharma through
Shri Shambhu Sharma, Vijay Nagar and Ravi Roopwas to
accused Sanjay Kumar. Accused Sanjay Kumar was present
in the car along with accused Hari Ram, Chaman Prakash,
Sandeep Kumar and Ashok and all of them were possessed
illegal arms. Similarly accused Chain Pal Gurjar, Bijender
and Manish Khari were armed with illegal weapons and were
present at the same spot. As per CDRs, Sanjay had
communicated with accused Manish Khari. CDRs also show
the involvement of accused Chander Shekhar Sharma, Shri
Shambhu Sharma and Ravi Roopwas. The CDRs of the
mobile phones of the accused persons which were
subsequently recovered corroborate and confirm the
disclosure statements of the accused persons and show the
complicity of all accused persons including accused
Chander Shekahar Sharma. The chain of communication
which is established as per CDRs therefore ends at accused
Chander Shekhar Sharma and the statement of the victim
Shri K.K. Sharma recorded under section 164 Cr.P.C also
shows that accused persons used to meet accused Chander
Shekhar Sharma at the Hotel at Agra. The amount of Rs.
50,000/- towards the advance received was also recovered.
Thus prima facie the complicity of all accused persons is
established in the conspiracy.
xxx
xxx
xxx
Considering these facts and circumstances, at this stage there
is grave suspicion against the accused persons that they had
conspired to commit murder of KK. Sharma. The accused
persons had done some acts towards the execution of the
conspiracy in as much as money had passed hands, persons
had gathered with illegal arms and were proceeding to
commit the crime and when they were intercepted they
attempted to even murder the police officials. Conspiracy is
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
punishable as abetment and under section 115 IPC it is not
necessary that the act abetted should be committed.
Therefore at this stage charges are liable to be framed
against all accused persons the for offence under section
120B IPC read with section 302 IPC is made out against all
the accused persons. …”
[Emphasis supplied]
20.
As apparent from above, the learned Trial Court has proceeded to
frame the charges under Sections 120B read with 302 of the IPC against
the petitioner only on the basis of the disclosure statement(s) of the coaccused persons Sanjay Kumar, Manish Khari and Chain Pal Gurjar as
also the connection of the petitioner with the accused by way of CDRs as
also on the basis of the considering surrounding circumstances and simply
because the petitioner was in touch with one of the co-accused person for
a long stretch of time.
21.
Therefore, this Court has to judge the probative value of such
disclosure statements, and if they coupled with the CDRs connectivity are
themselves sufficient for the framing charges under Sections 120B read
with 302 of the IPC against the petitioner?
22.
It has also to be borne in mind that the said CDRs are, admittedly,
without any transcripts thereof and there is/ are no FSL Report qua them.
Merely because the petitioner was in touch with the other co-accused
persons for a long period of time, under such circumstances, is not
sufficient for framing of charges under Sections 120B read with 302 of the
IPC against the petitioner.
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
23.
In these facts, Section 27 of the IPC12 which talks about what and
how much information(s) given by any accused person, even to a “police
officer”, be it in the nature of a “confession”, may/ can be taken, is
something which forms the backbone of the present proceedings.
24.
It is relevant to note that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State (NCT
of Delhi) vs. Navjot Sandhu13 while dealing with the said provisions of
Section 27 of the IPC observed as under:“……114. The interpretation of Section 27 of the Evidence Act
has loomed large in the course of arguments. The controversy
centred round two aspects:
(i) Whether the discovery of fact referred to in Section 27
should be confined only to the discovery of a material
object and the knowledge of the accused in relation thereto
or the discovery could be in respect of his mental state or
knowledge in relation to certain things — concrete or nonconcrete.
(ii) Whether it is necessary that the discovery of fact should
be by the person making the disclosure or directly at his
instance. The subsequent event of discovery by the police
with the aid of information furnished by the accused —
whether can be put against him under Section 27.
These issues have arisen especially in the context of the
disclosure statement (Ext. PW-66/13) of Gilani to the police.
According to the prosecution, the information furnished by
Gilani on certain aspects, for instance, that the particular
cellphones belonged to the other accused, Afzal and Shaukat,
that the Christian Colony room was arranged by Shaukat in
order to accommodate the slain terrorist Mohammed, that police
uniforms and explosives “were arranged” and that the names of
the five deceased terrorists were so and so are relevant under
27. How much of information received from accused may be proved.––Provided that, when any fact is
deposed to as discovered inconsequence of information received from a person accused of any offence,
in the custody of a police-officer, so much of such information, whether it amounts to a confession or
not, as relates distinctly to the fact thereby discovered, may be proved.
(2005) 11 SCC 600
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
Section 27 of the Evidence Act as they were confirmed to be true
by subsequent investigation and they reveal the awareness and
knowledge of Gilani in regard to all these facts, even though no
material objects were recovered directly at his instance.
x
x
x
119. We have noticed above that the confessions made to a police
officer and a confession made by any person while he or she is in
police custody cannot be proved against that person accused of
an offence. Of course, a confession made in the immediate
presence of a Magistrate can be proved against him. So also
Section 162 CrPC bars the reception of any statements made to a
police officer in the course of an investigation as evidence
against the accused person at any enquiry or trial except to the
extent that such statements can be made use of by the accused to
contradict the witnesses. Such confessions are excluded for the
reason that there is a grave risk of their statements being
involuntary and false. Section 27, which unusually starts with a
proviso, lifts the ban against the admissibility of the
confession/statement made to the police to a limited extent by
allowing proof of information of a specified nature furnished by
the accused in police custody. In that sense Section 27 is
considered to be an exception to the rules embodied in Sections
25 and 26 (vide Udai Bhan v. State of U.P. [1962 Supp (2) SCR
830 : AIR 1962 SC 1116 : (1962) 2 Cri LJ 251] ). Section 27
reads as follows:
“27. How much of information received from accused may
be proved.—Provided that, when any fact is deposed to as
discovered in consequence of information received from a
person accused of any offence, in the custody of a police
officer, so much of such information, whether it amounts to
a confession or not, as relates distinctly to the fact thereby
discovered, may be proved.”
x
x
x
125. We are of the view that Kottaya case [AIR 1947 PC 67 : 48
Cri LJ 533 : 74 IA 65] is an authority for the proposition that
“discovery of fact” cannot be equated to the object produced or
found. It is more than that. The discovery of fact arises by
reason of the fact that the information given by the accused
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
exhibited the knowledge or the mental awareness of the
informant as to its existence at a particular place. ……”
[Emphasis supplied]
25.
In the present proceedings, and as apparent from the impugned
order, framing charge against the petitioner under Sections 120B read with
302 of the IPC, everything is based on the disclosure statements of the coaccused persons qua him, and that too, to the effect that the petitioner was/
is a co-conspirator in the alleged conspiracy and that since he gave the
contract for murdering the respondent no.2 herein, he is said to be the
main conspirator. Barring this, admittedly, there is no physical recovery of
any kind in pursuance thereto from any of the co-accused persons and/ or
the petitioner. This, thence, per se is not sufficient for establishing any
kind of nexus and/ or relationship inter se them.
26.
Even otherwise, since the said CDRs are, admittedly, without any
transcripts, there is no clarity about the details of conversations inter se the
co-accused persons and the petitioner. In view thereof, though the
petitioner was in touch with the other co-accused persons for a long period
of time, the same itself without any concrete proof and/ or FSL Report qua
them, can hardly form the basis of framing of charge against the petitioner
under Sections 120B read with 302 of the IPC.
27.
In view of the dicta in Prafulla Kumar Samal (supra); Dilawar
Balu (supra); Sajjan Kumar (supra); Dilipsinh Kishorsinh Rao (supra)
and Amit Kapoor (supra), this Court finds reason for interfering with the
findings rendered by the learned Trial Court in the impugned order
whereby charges have been framed under Sections 120B read with 302 of
the IPC against the petitioner.
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
28.
This Court also finds that co-ordinate benches of this Court, while
dealing with similar circumstances in Ashok Kumar (supra) and Mamta
Sapra (supra), have also discharges the accused(s) therein.
29.
In view of the aforesaid analysis, as also the legal position discussed
hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion that there are no
sufficient material(s) on record qua the petitioner for framing of charges
against him under Sections 120B read with 302 of the IPC and proceed
with trial.
30.
Accordingly, the present petition is allowed and the impugned order
on charge dated 11.07.2018 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge03, New Delhi District, Patiala House in SC No. 275/2017 entitled ‘State
vs. Sanjay Kumar & Ors.’ arising out of FIR No.176/2017 dated
30.04.2017 is set aside. As such, the formal order on charge dated
16.07.2018 is also set aside.
31.
As such, the present petition along with the pending application is
disposed of in the above terms.
32.
A copy of the judgment be sent to the learned Trial Court for
necessary information and compliance.
SAURABH BANERJEE, J.
AUGUST 24, 2026/Ab/DA
CRL.REV.P. 623/2018
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:40:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review