The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The only question was, as to whether the gift deed dated 23.02.2016, executed by the appellants in favour of the respondent is null and void or not? And related to it, the question was, whether in fact, the gift deed dated 23.02.2016 was executed in favour of the respondent by playing fraud with the appellants or by misrepresentation made by the respondent. That was a factual issue. The trial court has extensively dealt with the evidence. The attending circumstances while appreciating evidences the trial court has taken into consideration the status of the parties and took note of the fact that, in fact, appellant no.1 also runs a school, who is post graduate. The appellant no.2 is also an educated woman. There were stamps of Rs.56,000/- that were also purchased, on which, the gift deed was recorded. Taking into consideration all these relevant materials, the finding has been recorded. It is not the case that the court below has ignored the material evidence or acted on no evidence. It is also not the case that the court has drawn wrong inferences from the proved facts by applying the law erroneously. It is a case of the concurrent finding of the fact by both the courts below. In fact, there is no substantial question of law involved in this case. Therefore, there is no reason to admit the appeal and it deserves to be dismissed at the admission stage itself.
17. The appeal is dismissed in limine. (Ravindra Maithani, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Second Appeal No. 55 of 2026
Chandra Shekhar Kargeti and another
........Appellants
Vs.
Rameshwar Prasad
……..... Respondent
Present : Mr. A.D. Tripathi, Advocate for the appellants.
JUDGMENT
Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J. (Oral)
The appellants propose to challenge the following
judgments and orders in the instant second appeal:(i)
Judgment and Order dated 12.04.2022, passed
in Civil Suit No.20 of 2016, Chandra Shekhar
and another Vs. Rameshwar Prasad, by the court
of Civil Judge (Jr. Div.)/Judicial Magistrate,
Ramnagar, District Nainital (“the suit”); and
(ii)
Judgment and order 11.03.2026, passed in Civil
Appeal No.22 of 2022, Chandra Shekhar Kargeti
and another Vs. Rameshwar Prasad, by the court
of District Judge, Nainital (“the appeal”).
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
3.
The suit was filed by the appellants for cancellation of
registered gift deed dated 23.02.2016. It has been the case of the
appellants that Khasra No.700, admeasuring 0.035, Khasra
No.702, admeasuring 0.275, Khasra No.703, admeasuring 0.044,
Total Area 0.354 Hectare (“the land”) were recorded in the name of
the appellants and the respondent. The respondent is uncle of the
appellant no.1 and brother-in-law of appellant no.2.
4.
It has been the case of the appellants that on
23.02.2016, the respondent called
the appellants at
Tehsil
Ramnagar, so that, the land may be declared as non-agricultural.
Believing the respondent, according to the appellants, they reached
Tehsil Ramnagar on stipulated date, where trusting the respondent,
the appellants signed and put their thumb impressions on various
documents. On 14.03.2016, the appellants came to know that
under the garb of declaring the land as non-agricultural land, the
respondent had got gift deed executed in his favour of 0.118
Hectare land that belonged to the appellants.
5.
It has been the case of the appellants that the gift deed
was executed by playing fraud and by misrepresentation by the
respondent. The appellants approached the authorities and the
police was also directed to look into the matter. Based on these
allegations, the suit has been filed for cancellation of the gift deed
dated 23.02.2016.
6.
The respondent did file his Written Statement in the
suit. According to him, the land was purchased by him for running
a school, which the respondent had been running in a rented
accommodation. Since, the relations between the brothers of the
respondent were cordial at that time; he got the land purchased
in the name of his brothers as well. One of whom, is father
of
appellant
no.1
and
husband
of respondent no.2. It has
further been the case of the respondent that the appellants knew
that the land belongs to the respondent, which he had purchased
by the self acquired assets. Therefore, under a moral obligation the
appellants as well as another brother of the respondent jointly
reached Tehsil Ramnagar in the Sub Registrar Office and executed
gift deed dated 23.02.2016 in favour of the respondent, but it is the
case of the respondent that subsequently, the appellants tried to
put pressure on the respondent. The land has already been
mutated in the name of the respondent. The appellant no.1 is post
graduate, who also runs a school. The appellant no.2 is also an
educated woman. They both, with their full knowledge, executed
the gift deed dated 23.02.2016. Based on the pleadings of the
parties on 13.01.2017, the following issues were framed in the
suit:(i)
Whether the gift deed dated 23.02.2016 is liable to
be declared null and void? If yes, its effect?
(ii)
Whether the plaintiff has any cause of action?
(iii) Whether the plaintiffs have properly valued the
suit?
(iv) Whether the plaintiffs have paid the sufficient
court’s fee?
(v)
7.
Any other relief?
The parties adduced evidences in the suit. On issue
no.1, the trial court made extensive discussion of the evidence and
held that the gift deed dated 23.02.2016 is not liable to be declared
as null and void.
8.
On issue no.2, the court held that the appellants have
no cause of action to institute the suit.
9.
On issue no.3, the court held that the suit has been
properly valued.
10.
Issue no.5 had already been decided on 09.02.2016.
Accordingly, the relief clause was discussed and suit was
dismissed. It was challenged in the appeal, which as stated, has
already been dismissed.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the
land was in the name of the father of the appellant no.1 and
husband of the appellant no.2. The appellants were co-sharers of
the land. In the garb of declaring the land as non-agricultural land
under Section 143 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land
Reforms Act, 1950 (“the U.P.Z.A. & L.R. Act”) the respondent called
the appellants in Tehsil Ramnagar and by misrepresenting and
playing fraud got their signatures and thump impressions on
certain documents on 23.02.2016. It is argued that the appellants
did sign and put their thumb impressions under the impression
that they are preparing documents for declaring their land as nonagricultural. But subsequently, it was revealed that under the garb
of declaration under Section 143 of the U.P.Z.A. & L.R. Act the
respondent has got a gift deed executed, which is null and void.
12.
Learned
counsel
also
argued
that,
in
fact,
the
respondent in his evidence had admitted that he had contacted the
appellants for seeking declaration under Section 143 of the U.P.Z.A.
& L.R. Act. He has referred to the statement of DW1 Ram Prashad
Kargeti particularly, page 2, top paragraph. Learned counsel would
submit that the legal provisions have not been considered; the
evidences have not been rightly appreciated. Merely, the courts
below assumed that since the appellant no.1 is post graduate, he
could not be cheated, which it is argued, is not a lawful
presumption. It is also argued that the respondent did not produce
any sale deed to reveal that the land was purchased by the
respondent.
13.
Second appeal under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(“the Code”) cannot be filed as a matter of right. Second appeal from
decree can only be entertained if, the Court is satisfied that the
case involved a substantial question of law.
14.
In the case of Hero Vinoth (Minor) Vs. Seshammal,
(2006)5 SCC 545, the Hon’ble Supreme Court summarized the
principle made to Section 100 and observed as follows:“24. The principles relating to Section 100 CPC relevant for this case may
be summarised thus:
(i)
An inference of fact from the recitals or contents of a document is
a question of fact. But the legal effect of the terms of a document
is a question of law. Construction of a document involving the
application of any principle of law, is also a question of law.
Therefore, when there is misconstruction of a document or wrong
application of a principle of law in construing a document, it gives
rise to a question of law.
(ii)
The High Court should be satisfied that the case involves a
substantial question of law, and not a mere question of law. A
question of law having a material bearing on the decision of the
case (that is, a question, answer to which affects the rights of
parties to the suit) will be a substantial question of law, if it is not
covered by any specific provisions of law or settled legal principle
emerging from binding precedents, and, involves a debatable legal
issue. A substantial question of law will also arise in a contrary
situation, where the legal position is clear, either on account of
express provisions of law or binding precedents, but the court
below has decided the matter, either ignoring or acting contrary to
such legal principle. In the second type of cases, the substantial
question of law arises not because the law is still debatable, but
because the decision rendered on a material question, violates the
settled position of law.
(iii)
The general rule is that High Court will not interfere with the
concurrent findings of the courts below. But it is not an absolute
rule. Some of the well-recognised exceptions are where (i) the
courts below have ignored material evidence or acted on no
evidence; (ii) the courts have drawn wrong inferences from proved
facts by applying the law erroneously; or (iii) the courts have
wrongly cast the burden of proof. When we refer to “decision based
on no evidence”, it not only refers to cases where there is a total
dearth of evidence, but also refers to any case, where the evidence,
taken as a whole, is not reasonably capable of supporting the
finding.”
15.
It is not disputed that the land was recorded in the
name of the appellants, respondent and brother of the respondent
Leela Dhar Kargeti. What has been stated by the respondent in his
Written Statement was that he had purchased the land in his own
name, in the names of his brothers as well. Sale deed of the land is
not in question. Therefore, there was no need of production of the
sale deed. It was not required at all. It was not related to any issue
that was framed in the suit.
16.
The only question was, as to whether the gift deed
dated 23.02.2016, executed by the appellants in favour of the
respondent is null and void or not? And related to it, the question
was, whether in fact, the gift deed dated 23.02.2016 was executed
in favour of the respondent by playing fraud with the appellants or
by misrepresentation made by the respondent. That was a factual
issue. The trial court has extensively dealt with the evidence. The
attending circumstances while appreciating evidences the trial
court has taken into consideration the status of the parties and
took note of the fact that, in fact, appellant no.1 also runs a school,
who is post graduate. The appellant no.2 is also an educated
woman. There were stamps of Rs.56,000/- that were also
purchased, on which, the gift deed was recorded. Taking into
consideration all these relevant materials, the finding has been
recorded. It is not the case that the court below has ignored the
material evidence or acted on no evidence. It is also not the case
that the court has drawn wrong inferences from the proved facts by
applying the law erroneously. It is a case of the concurrent finding
of the fact by both the courts below. In fact, there is no substantial
question of law involved in this case. Therefore, there is no reason
to admit the appeal and it deserves to be dismissed at the
admission stage itself.
17.
The appeal is dismissed in limine.
(Ravindra Maithani, J.)
11.06.2026
Sanjay
SANJAY
KANOJIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH
COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=e50e50b49596520698eff87e0a08bbd504686d
f4d1afc60f54a287831dec46fe, postalCode=263001,
st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=26EEB7122ED0DD23233A255DD8EC450
A84B515A087CAEFD1B3179A7DEAE40699, cn=SANJAY
KANOJIA
Date: 2026.06.15 16:39:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review