Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition (CRL) No. 758 of 2025
Chandra Lekha.
………………… Petitioner.
Versus
State of Uttarakhand
and others.
……………Respondents.
Present:
Mr. Rahul Consul, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. Sandeep Sharma, learned A.G.A. with Mrs. Rangoli Purohit, learned Brief Holder for
the State.
Mr. Piyush Garg, learned counsel for CBI.
Mr. Lalit Sharma and Mr. S.R.S. Gill, learned counsel for the co-accused.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
By the instant petition the petitioner herein Ms. Chandra
Lekha the victim and the wife of the deceased Ram Shankar
praying for transfer of investigation of First Information Report
dated 13.12.2024 bearing FIR No. 0307 of 2024 P.S. Khanpur,
District Haridwar to the respondent no. 4 – the Central Bureau of
Investigation.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that a missing report no. 13 of
2024 was lodged by the father-in-law of the petitioner for missing
of his son Ram Shankar and on the basis of the missing report a
dead body was recovered on pointing out of one namely Robin on
13.12.2024 and thereafter a First Information Report was
registered on 13.12.2024 as FIR No. 0307 of 2024 at P.S. Khanpur,
District Haridwar, wherein, three persons namely Robin, Akshay
and one Ankit were implicated for the offences punishable under
sections 103(1), 238, 3(5) and 311 of BNS, 2023.
3.
It is contended in the petition that the investigation was
conducted by the local police in a very causal manner, which is
evident from the fact that the car which was used in the
commission of crime belongs to one Anil Kumar was neither
taken into custody nor any forensic examination was done
though just before the incident the car was in the custody of one
person namely Sonu Fauji. In paragraph-6 reference has been
made of an order dated 26.06.2025 passed in bail application
moved by one of the accused Robin bearing Bail Application No.
551 of 2025 and by referring the said order Mr. Rahul Consul,
learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the aforesaid
order reveals that the investigation was carried out in a very
casual manner. The relevant extract of the order dated 26.06.2025
is extracted herein as under:
“5. What this Court observed that the investigation was
carried out in a very casual manner and keeping in mind
that the statutory period for filing the charge sheet is 90
days, in a hurried manner the charge sheet was filed before
the expiry of statutory period.
6. So many lacunas have been pointed out by Mr. Aditya
Singh learned counsel for the applicant in respect of the
investigation and in reference to this he brings to the notice
the statements of two prosecution witnesses, namely, Anil
Kumar and one Sultan Singh, father of Sonu Fauji. Anil
Kumar is a person who owned vehicle UP12AN 8378, which
according to the prosecution was used in commission of the
crime and Sultan Singh is the father of Sonu Fauji who took
car from Anil Kumar on 06.12.2024.
7. In this case, missing report was filed on 09.12.2024 with
the complaint that from 08.12.2024 Ramshankar (deceased)
was missing. On this missing report the investigation was
commenced and during investigation it was found that there
was a transaction of Rs. 30,000/- with two persons, namely,
Praveen and Vinay servingin a petrol pump who paid Rs.
30000/- in cash to the applicant Robbin and in turn the
applicant refund the amount by way of UPI transaction. In
furtherance of the investigation one Anil Kumar was also
interrogated (who owned the car used in the crime) who
informed that the vehicle was took over by Sonu Fauji on
06.12.2024. On further investigation it was found by the I.O.
that Sonu Fauji left to join fauj. Since, Sonu Fauji left to join
Fauj, consequently his father was interrogated by the I.O.
who informed that the car took by the present applicant on
08.12.2024.
8. The statement of Anil Kumar and the statement of father
of Sonu Fauji are placed on record along with the case diary
and by showing the statements of these two prosecution
witnesses the counsel for the applicant argued that it is
absolutely incorrect that Sonu Fauji left for Fauj, since, as per
the statement of Anil Kumar and his father Sonu Fauji was
in the village on the date when the incident was happened.
9. On perusal of the case diary it reveals that charge sheet
was filed against the applicant, since, as per the prosecution
Sonu Fauji left to join the Fauj. The case diary further reveals
that Anil Kumar is close relative of Sonu Fauji. Case diary
further reveals that as per the prosecution the dead body of
the deceased was kept in the car of Anil Kumar but no
forensic examination of the car was carried out.
10. Apart from this, Mr. Aditya Singh submits that the
recovery of car also appears to be doubtful since as per the
prosecution, car used in the crime was recovered on
14.12.2024 on the instance of the present applicant from the
place behind D.S. Rolling Company. The recovery memo is
placed on record at page 45 and by referring the recovery
memo Mr. Aditya Singh bring to the notice the statement of
Anil Kumar, the copy of which is enclosed as Annexure 14
to the counter affidavit, on perusal of which it reveals that
Anil Kumar has stated in his statement that Robbin returned
the car on 10.12.2024. The question is if the car was returned
to Anil Kumar by Robbin on 10.12.2024, then how the car
was recovered on the instance of present applicant. Prima
facie, on perusal of the statements of Anil Kumar and father
of Sonu Fauji including recovery memo and case diary
reveals that the investigation to somehow is faulty.
11. Since, the investigating officer is present in Court, let he
may file his personal affidavit to explain whether there is
any fault in his investigation and if not then he has to give
answer in the affidavit with regard to the observations as
made above.”
4.
Mr. Consul further argued that despite sufficient material
the Investigating Officer gives a clean chit to other suspect
persons namely Anil Kumar and Sonu Fauji and filed the chargesheet.
5.
I gone through with the order rejecting bail application of
Robin and it reveals that certain crucial aspects have not been
included in the investigation by the local police. Photographs of
the dead body are also enclosed along with the CCTV footages.
6.
In this petition the counter affidavit has been filed by the
Investigating Officer and certain relevant extracts of the counter
affidavit are also being extracted herein as under:
“5. That in reply to the contents of Para 02, 03 and 04 of the
affidavit it is submitted that at Police Station Khanpur, District
Haridwar, a missing person report No. 13/2024 Missing
Ramshankar son of Nixa Ram resident of village Kudkawala,
Police Station Daiwala, District Dehradun, was registered
regarding his son Ram Shankar coming from his house to
Khanpur and not returning home. After the investigation it
came to light that Robin and Minor (X) had told that we along
with our friend Ankit son of Amarpal had caught Ramshankar
to rob him but Ramshankar had only Rs. 400, Ramshankar was
threatening to send us to jail. Then we got angry with
Ramshankar and we took Ramshankar's mobile phone and
threatened him and asked for his phone password and Phone
Pay PIN. Then we were afraid that Ramshankar might send us
to jail and he was shouting. Then Ankit put tape on
Ramshankar's mouth and shut his mouth. After some time
Ramshankar died. Then we got scared and Robin went home
and asked for Sonu Fauji's car from home. Then we put
Ramshankar's dead body in Sonu Fauji's car no. UP12 AN 8378
KUV 100 and took it to the banks of Banganga river at
Chandpuri Ghat. Then we put Ramshankar's dead body in a
sack and a bag and dug a pit in the sand. They pressed the chest
and also put salt on it and returned home rand on the
information of the accused Robin, Minor X, the dead body of
Ramshankar was recovered from the bank of the river
Wanganga, ahead of the ghat of Chandpuri Khurva (Khadar)
and was buried in the sand. Ramshankar's family members
identified it on the spot. With the help of the field unit, a plastic
piece recovered from the place of recovery on which MAIZE
STARCH is written in English was kept in a polybag, a jute sack
in a polling bag and the Khaki tape tied on the mouth of the
deceased was kept in a polybag, 03 packets of salt Tara Salt were
kept in polybag, blood soaked sand and plain sand recovered
from the spot sand was packed in different plastic containers,
one pen colour wagon on which FLAIR was written in English,
separate seals and survey stamps were made and sample stamps
were prepared which have been sent to the Forensic Science
Laboratory Dehradun for testing, the test report of which is
awaited. On the other hand Robin Sonu went to Mangalore
Petrol Pump to withdraw money by taking Fauji's car and
Ramshankar's phone and withdrew a total of 30000 (thirty
thousand
rupees)
separately.
True/correct
typed
version/photocopy of the statements of witnesses recorded
under section 180 of BNSS namely Ramesh Chandra
(complainant/alongwith subsequent statement), S.I. Sameep
Pandey, Karan Singh, Rohit Rana, Anil Kumar, Sultan Singh,
Praveen Kumar, Sanjay Pal, Dr. Sarfarz Ahmad alongwith Post
Mortem as well as Inquest Report, Receipt dated 11.11.2023,
Recovery Memo and CDR are being filed herewith and marked
as Annexure No. 02 (colly), 03, 04, 05, 06, 07, 08, 09, 10 (colly), 11,
12 and 13 respectively, to this affidavit.”
7.
Para-8 of the counter affidavit is also being reproduced
herein as under:
“8.
That the contents of Para 07 to 09 of the affidavit the
statement is wrong, whereas in the investigation, on the
indication of the accused, the body of deceased Ramshankar
was recovered buried in the sand on the banks of Wanganga on
the indication of Robin and Minor X of Wanganga river and on
the indication of the accused, the mobile phone, cheque book of
deceased Ramshankar and the four-wheeler used in the
incident, registration number UP 12 AN 8378 KUV 100 were
recovered. During the investigation of the above incident, the
registered owner of the car no. UP12 AN 8378 KUV 100, Anil
Kumar alias Sunil and the currents occupant of this vehicle,
Sultan Singh, were questioned and thei statements were
recorded. Sultan's son Sonu is a soldier. Sultan Singh ha
mentioned in his statement that on the day of the above inciden
(08.12.2024), my son Sonu Fauji had gone to Jalalpur Neela
village which has been confirmed by the CDR of Sonu Fauji's
mobile and t register owner of the vehicle used in commission of
crime was not found any evidence to be involved.”
8.
Mr. Lalit Sharma and Mr. S.R.S. Gill, learned counsel who
are appearing for the accused Robin in connected second bail
application, also submits that a specific plea has been taken in the
bail application that the investigation is faulty and the chargesheet has been filed in a very mechanical manner without
collecting scientific evidence and now trial is going on without
FSL report which is still awaited.
9.
When a specific query is asked from the learned A.G.A.
why in absence of the FSL report charge-sheet has been filed he
failed to give any satisfactory response.
10.
Mr. Rahul Consul, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submits that even after observation of this court in the bail
application of co-accused Robin that investigation is faulty no
attempt was made to proceed for further investigation by the
investigating agency.
11.
Mr. Rahul Consul, learned counsel for the petitioner, placed
reliance to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
State of West Bengal and Others vs. Committee for Protection of
Democratic Rights, (2010) 3 SCC 571 and submits that this is a fit
case in which the investigation should be transferred to the CBI.
12.
I peruse the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case
of West Bengal and Others (supra), wherein, it has been held that
the High courts are authorized under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India to issue direction, orders or writs to any
person or authority including any government to enforce
fundamental rights and for any other purposes.
13.
In the aforesaid judgment the Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed that the words “life” and “personal liberty” are used
under Article 21 as compendious terms to include within
themselves all the varieties of life which go to make up the
personal liberties of a man and not merely the right to the
continuance of person’s animal existence. All those aspects of life
which make a person life with human dignity are including
within the meaning of word “life” and the State has a duty to
enforce the human rights of a citizen providing for fair and
impartial investigation against any person accused of commission
of a cognizable offence, which may include its own officers.
Article 21 in its broad application not only takes within its scope
enforcement of rights of an accused but also rights of the victim.
In certain situation even witness of crime may seek for and shall
granted protection by the State. The right to life and personal
liberty is paramount likewise if Article 14 and 19 are put out of
operation. Being the protectors of civil liberties of the citizens, the
Supreme Court and the High Courts have not only the power and
jurisdiction but also an obligation to protect the fundamental
rights, guaranteed by Part III in general and under Article 21 of
the Constitution in particular, zealously and vigilantly. Therefore,
a direction by the High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution, to CBI to investigate a cognizable
offence alleged to have been committed within the territory of a
State without the consent of that State will neither impinge upon
the federal structure of the Constitution nor violate the doctrine of
separation of power and shall be valid in law.
14.
It has also been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that the
order directing an enquiry by CBI should be passed only when
the High Court after considering the material on record comes to
the conclusion that such material does disclose a prima-facie case
calling for investigation by the CBI or any other similar agency.
The conclusion as drawn by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
aforesaid case is in paragraph 68, 69 and 70, which are being
reproduced herein as under:
“ 68. Thus, having examined the rival contentions in the
context of the Constitutional Scheme, we conclude as follows:
(i) The fundamental rights, enshrined in Part III of the
Constitution, are inherent and cannot be extinguished by any
Constitutional or Statutory provision. Any law that abrogates or
abridges such rights would be violative of the basic structure
doctrine. The actual effect and impact of the law on the rights
guaranteed under Part III has to be taken into account in
determining whether or not it destroys the basic structure.
(ii) Article 21 of the Constitution in its broad perspective seeks
to protect the persons of their lives and personal liberties except
according to the procedure established by law. The said Article
in its broad application not only takes within its fold
enforcement of the rights of an accused but also the rights of the
victim. The State has a duty to enforce the human rights of a
citizen providing for fair and impartial investigation against any
person accused of commission of a cognizable offence, which
may include its own officers. In certain situations even a witness
to the crime may seek for and shall be granted protection by the
State.
(iii) In view of the constitutional scheme and the jurisdiction
conferred on this Court under Article 32 and on the High Courts
under Article 226 of the Constitution the power of judicial
review being an integral part of the basic structure of the
Constitution, no Act of Parliament can exclude or curtail the
powers of the Constitutional Courts with regard to the
enforcement of fundamental rights. As a matter of fact, such a
power is essential to give practicable content to the objectives of
the Constitution embodied in Part III and other parts of the
Constitution. Moreover, in a federal constitution, the
distribution of legislative powers between the Parliament and
the State Legislature involves limitation on legislative powers
and, therefore, this requires an authority other than the
Parliament to ascertain whether such limitations are
transgressed. Judicial review acts as the final arbiter not only to
give effect to the distribution of legislative powers between the
Parliament and the State Legislatures, it is also necessary to
show any transgression by each entity.
Therefore, to borrow the words of Lord Steyn, judicial review is
justified by combination of "the principles of separation of
powers, rule of law, the principle of constitutionality and the
reach of judicial review".
(iv) If the federal structure is violated by any legislative action,
the Constitution takes care to protect the federal structure by
ensuring that Courts act as guardians and interpreters of the
Constitution and provide remedy under Articles 32 and 226,
whenever there is an attempted violation. In the circumstances,
any direction by the Supreme Court or the High Court in
exercise of power under Article 32 or 226 to uphold the
Constitution and maintain the rule of law cannot be termed as
violating the federal structure.
(v) Restriction on Parliament by the Constitution and restriction
on the executive by Parliament under an enactment, do not
amount to restriction on the power of the Judiciary under
Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution.
(vi) If in terms of Entry 2 of List II of the Seventh Schedule on
the one hand and Entry 2-A and Entry 80 of List I on the other,
an investigation by another agency is permissible subject to
grant of consent by the State concerned, there is no reason as to
why, in an exceptional situation, court would be precluded from
exercising the same power which the Union could exercise in
terms of the provisions of the Statute. In our opinion, exercise of
such power by the constitutional courts would not violate the
doctrine of separation of powers. In fact, if in such a situation
the court fails to grant relief, it would be failing in its
constitutional duty.
(vii) When the Special Police Act itself provides that subject to
the consent by the State, the CBI can take up investigation in
relation to the crime which
was otherwise within the
jurisdiction of the State Police, the court can also exercise its
constitutional power of judicial review and direct the CBI to
take up the investigation within the jurisdiction of the State.
The power of the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution cannot be taken away, curtailed or diluted by
Section 6 of the Special Police Act. Irrespective of there being
any statutory provision acting as a restriction on the powers of
the Courts, the
restriction imposed by Section 6 of the Special
Police Act on the powers of the Union, cannot be read as
restriction on the powers of the Constitutional
Courts.
Therefore, exercise of power of judicial review by the High
Court, in our opinion, would not amount to infringement of
either the doctrine of
separation of power or the federal
structure.
69.In the final analysis, our answer to the question referred is
that a direction by the High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution, to the CBI to investigate a
cognizable offence alleged to have been committed within the
territory of a State without the consent of that State will neither
impinge upon the federal structure of the Constitution nor
violate the doctrine of separation of power and shall be valid in
law. Being the protectors of civil liberties of the citizens, this
Court and the High Courts have not only the power and
jurisdiction but also an obligation to protect the fundamental
rights, guaranteed by Part III in general and under Article 21 of
the Constitution in particular, zealously and vigilantly.
70.Before parting with the case, we deem it necessary to
emphasise that despite wide powers conferred by Articles
32 and 226 of the Constitution, while passing any order, the
Courts must bear in mind certain self-imposed limitations on the
exercise of these Constitutional powers. The very plenitude of
the power under the said Articles requires great caution in its
exercise. In so far as the question of issuing a direction to the
CBI to conduct investigation in a case is concerned, although no
inflexible guidelines can be laid down to decide whether or not
such power should be exercised but time and again it has been
reiterated that such an order is not to be passed as a matter of
routine or merely because a party has levelled some allegations
against the local police. This extra-ordinary power must be
exercised sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations
where it becomes necessary to provide credibility and instil
confidence in investigations or where the incident may have
national and international ramifications or where such an order
may be necessary for doing complete justice and enforcing the
fundamental rights. Otherwise the CBI would be flooded with a
large number of cases and with limited resources, may find it
difficult to properly investigate even serious cases and in the
process lose its credibility and purpose with unsatisfactory
investigations.”
15.
So far as the present case is concerned admittedly there are
so many flaws in the investigation carried out by the local police.
There is no scientific evidence and even the conduct of two
persons namely Anil Kumar and Sonu Fauji have not been
properly investigated, therefore, this court is of the firm opinion
that the investigation was carried out by the local police is
completely faulty, therefore, the matter deserves to be transferred
to the CBI for further investigation.
16.
At this juncture Mr. Sandeep Sharma, learned A.G.A.
argued that trial has already been commenced, therefore, at this
stage investigation cannot be transferred.
The submissions as advanced by the learned A.G.A. cannot
be accepted simply for the reason that the charge-sheet has been
filed without FSL report, which is still awaited though the trial
has been commenced. Even otherwise, if this court comes to the
conclusion that there is some lapse on the part of the local police
while conducting the investigation then even if the trial has been
commenced, this court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India can refer the matter to the CBI for the purpose of further
investigation.
17.
In view of the observation and discussion as above the
instant writ petition is allowed and the matter is transferred to the
CBI forthwith for further investigation of the First Information
Report dated 13.12.2024 bearing FIR No. 0307 of 2024 P.S.
Khanpur, District Haridwar. The local Investigating Agency is
directed to handover the entire record including the charge-sheet
during investigation to the CBI forthwith.
18.
In addition to this, since now the trial has already been
commenced the CBI is given liberty to move an appropriate
application before the concerned court as per law.
19.
No order as to costs.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
08.04.2026
PR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review