Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:16592-DB
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.04.13
10:22:44
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 12 of 2024
Chalan Baghel S/o Sadhu Baghel Aged About 51 Years R/o VillageTangiyajodi, Police Station- Kodenar, Tehsil And District- Bastar,
Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through- Station House Officer, Police of Police
Station- Kodenar, Tehsil And District- Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
For State/Respondent
: Mr. Ashutosh Shukla, Advocate
: Mr. Priyank Rathi, Government Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
10.04.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Ashutosh Shukla, learned counsel for the appellant.
Also heard Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government Advocate,
appearing for the State/respondent.
2.
Today, though the criminal appeal has been listed for hearing on
I.A. No.01, application for suspension of sentence and grant of
bail to the appellant, however, with the consent of learned counsel
for the parties, the appeal is heard finally as the appellant is in jail
since 01.08.2022.
3.
Accordingly, I.A. No.01, application for suspension of sentence
and grant of bail to the appellant, stands disposed of.
4.
This criminal appeal is filed by the appellants/accused under
Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short,
‘Cr.P.C.’) is directed against the impugned judgment of conviction
and order of sentence dated 24.11.2023 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Bastar at Jagdalpur (C.G.) in Sessions Trial
No.71/2022, whereby the appellant/accused has been convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (for short, ‘IPC’) and sentenced to undergo
imprisonment for life and fine of Rs.100/-, in default of payment of
fine amount, additional rigorous imprisonment for one month.
5.
The prosecution case, as unfolded during trial, originates from the
Merg Intimation (Ex.P/01) lodged by the complainant PW-04
Vishwanath Baghel on 01.08.2022 at about 08:30 AM at Police
Station Kodenar. In the said intimation, it was reported that there
existed a long-standing land dispute between the accused
Chankalan Baghel and his younger brother PW-03 Dashrath
Baghel. It was further alleged that the deceased Sonasher Baghel
used to support Dashrath in the said dispute, on account of which
the accused bore animosity towards the deceased.
6.
On the intervening night of 31.07.2022, after having dinner, the
complainant and his family members went to sleep inside the
house, whereas the deceased Sonasher Baghel was sleeping
outside the house on a cemented platform (parchi). At about 11:00
PM, PW-01 Smt. Milky Baghel, upon hearing cries from the
courtyard, came out and witnessed that the accused was
assaulting the deceased with an iron rod (tangiya/iron weapon).
Upon her raising alarm, the complainant and other family
members rushed to the spot, where they saw the accused fleeing
with the weapon. He was chased and apprehended by PW-08
Bhagat Baghel and PW-06 Vishnu Baghel. By that time, the
deceased had succumbed to the injuries. On enquiry, the accused
allegedly disclosed that due to the ongoing land dispute and the
deceased siding with Dashrath, he assaulted the deceased and
thereafter intended to kill Dashrath as well.
7.
On the basis of the merg intimation, FIR (Ex.P/02) was registered
on the same day against the accused for the offence punishable
under Section 302 of the IPC. The investigation was conducted by
PW-11 Ram Pyara Patel (Sub-Inspector) and PW-12 Vikas
Chandra Roy (Investigating Officer). The Investigating Officer
proceeded to the spot and prepared the Naksha Panchayatnama
(Ex.P/04) in the presence of witnesses after issuing notice under
Section 175 CrPC (Ex.P/03). The dead body was sent for postmortem examination through PW-10 Rakesh Kumar Ekka,
constable, along with requisition (Ex.P/13), and duty certificates
(Ex.P/16
&
Ex.P/17).
The
post-mortem
examination
was
conducted by PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel, who proved the PostMortem Report (Ex.P/14). As per his findings: (i) The death was
caused due to coma and shock resulting from excessive bleeding
and head injury, (ii) The injuries were sufficient in the ordinary
course of nature to cause death, (iii) The death was homicidal in
nature, and (iv) The time since death was approximately 24–25
hours prior to the post-mortem. Further, a Query Report (Ex.P/15)
was also submitted after examination of seized articles, and the
doctor opined that the injuries could be caused by the seized
weapon.
8.
During investigation, blood-stained and plain soil were seized
from the spot vide Seizure Memo (Ex.P/09). The spot map
(Ex.P/05) was prepared based on the complainant’s version. The
accused gave a memorandum statement (Ex.P/06) under Section
27 of the Evidence Act, pursuant to which: the weapon of offence
(iron rod/tangiya) was recovered and the clothes worn by the
accused at the time of incident were seized vide Seizure Memo
(Ex.P/07). The seized articles were sent for chemical examination
to the Forensic Science Laboratory, and FSL Report (Ex.P/22)
confirmed the presence of blood on the seized articles. The
forwarding memo and receipts are Ex.P/19, Ex.P/20, and Ex.P/21.
The accused was arrested on 01.08.2022, and the arrest memo is
Ex.P/23, while information of arrest to relatives is Ex.P/24.
9.
In order to prove the case, the prosecution examined as many as
12 witnesses, whose testimonies are summarized as follows:
•
PW-01 Smt. Milky Baghel: An eyewitness who categorically
deposed that she saw the accused assaulting the deceased
with an iron rod. Her testimony is direct, natural, and forms the
backbone of the prosecution case.
•
PW-02 Gangadhar: A witness to the circumstances and part of
the surrounding events.
•
PW-03 Dashrath Baghel: Brother of the accused; he proved the
existence of the land dispute and motive behind the incident.
•
PW-04 Vishwanath Baghel (Complainant): Supported the
prosecution case and proved the merg intimation and FIR.
•
PW-05
Sonsai
Baghel: A
witness
to
the
surrounding
circumstances.
•
PW-06 Vishnu Baghel: A material witness who chased and
helped in apprehending the accused.
•
PW-07 Ku. Sundarvati Vendra: Witness to the incident or
surrounding facts.
•
PW-08 Bhagat Baghel: Supported the prosecution version and
deposed regarding apprehension of the accused.
•
PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel: Proved the post-mortem report and
nature of injuries.
•
PW-10 Rakesh Kumar Ekka: Carried the dead body for postmortem and proved procedural aspects.
•
PW-11 Ram Pyara Patel (SI): Conducted initial investigation
and proved seizures and procedural steps.
•
PW-12 Vikas Chandra Roy (IO): Completed the investigation
and proved the entire chain of investigation.
10.
The prosecution, in support of its case, exhibited 24 documents
as Ex.P/1 to Ex.P/24, in turn, in order to defence, accusedappellant neither examined any witness nor exhibited any
document.
11.
After completion of investigation, a charge-sheet (Ex.P/Final
Report) was filed against the accused under Section 302 IPC
before the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Jagdalpur,
which committed the case to the Court of Session. The charge
under Section 302 IPC was framed against the accused. He
abjured guilt and claimed to be tried. His statement under Section
313 CrPC was recorded, wherein he denied all allegations and
pleaded false implication. However, he did not adduce any
defence evidence.
12.
After completion of the prosecution evidence, the statements of
the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 of the
Code
of
Criminal
Procedure,
wherein
they
denied
the
incriminating circumstances appearing against them and pleaded
innocence. No evidence was adduced by the accused in defence.
13.
The trial Court after completion of trial and after appreciating oral
and documentary evidences available on record, by the impugned
judgment dated 24.11.2023 convicted and sentenced the
appellant in the manner mentioned in the fourth paragraph of this
judgment, against which this appeal under Section 374(2) of the
Cr.P.C. has been preferred by them calling in question the
impugned judgment.
14.
Mr. Ashutosh Shukla, learned counsel appearing for the appellant,
has assiduously taken this Court through the entire evidence on
record and contended that the conviction recorded by the learned
trial Court is unsustainable in the eyes of law and deserves to be
set aside. Elaborating his submissions, he would contend as
follows:
•
Firstly, it is submitted that the entire prosecution case rests
heavily upon the testimony of PW-01 Smt. Milky Bai, who has
been projected as an eyewitness to the incident. Learned
counsel submits that though the prosecution has termed her
testimony as unimpeachable, a careful scrutiny would reveal
that her presence at the spot and her ability to clearly witness
the incident in the late hours of the night is highly doubtful. It is
urged that the incident is alleged to have occurred at about
11:00 PM, and there is no convincing evidence regarding the
availability of sufficient light enabling proper identification. It is
further contended that her testimony, being that of an
interested witness closely related to the deceased, requires
strict corroboration, which is conspicuously absent. Even
otherwise, according to learned counsel, certain omissions
and improvements in her deposition render her evidence
unreliable, and thus it would be unsafe to base conviction
solely on her testimony.
•
Secondly, learned counsel submits that the prosecution has
attempted to build a case of immediate apprehension of the
accused by relying upon the testimonies of PW-06 Vishnu
Baghel and PW-08 Bhagat Baghel, alleging that the accused
was chased and caught while fleeing from the spot. It is
contended that this so-called chain of events is not free from
doubt, as there are inconsistencies in the statements of these
witnesses regarding the manner of apprehension and the
exact sequence of events. It is further argued that both these
witnesses are interested witnesses belonging to the same
family or village faction as the deceased, and therefore their
testimonies ought to have been scrutinized with greater
caution. The possibility of false implication due to prior enmity
cannot be ruled out.
•
Thirdly, with regard to the alleged extra-judicial confession,
learned counsel submits that the same is a weak piece of
evidence and cannot be relied upon as the sole basis of
conviction. It is argued that the alleged confession made
before PW-06 and PW-08 is neither voluntary nor reliable, and
appears to be a concocted version introduced to strengthen
the prosecution case. It is further contended that no
independent witness has been examined to corroborate the
alleged confession, and the circumstances under which it was
made are not clearly established. Therefore, the learned trial
Court erred in placing undue reliance on such a doubtful piece
of evidence.
•
Fourthly, learned counsel submits that though the prosecution
has relied upon medical and scientific evidence, the same
does not conclusively connect the appellant with the crime.
While PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel has opined that the death
was homicidal and caused by injuries inflicted by a sharpedged weapon, it is argued that such opinion is general in
nature and does not specifically link the injuries to the alleged
weapon recovered from the accused. It is further contended
that the FSL Report (Ex. P-22) merely indicates the presence
of blood on the clothes of the accused, but the prosecution
has failed to establish the blood group or conclusively prove
that the same belonged to the deceased. In absence of such
conclusive linkage, the scientific evidence loses much of its
evidentiary value. It is also pointed out that mere nonexplanation by the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. cannot
be treated as substantive evidence against him.
•
Fifthly, assailing the recovery, learned counsel submits that
the alleged recovery of the weapon and clothes at the
instance of the accused under Section 27 of the Evidence Act
is highly doubtful and suffers from procedural irregularities. It
is contended that the memorandum statement (Ex. P-06) and
seizure memo (Ex. P-07) have not been proved in accordance
with law, and the witnesses to the recovery are not
independent. The possibility of planting of the alleged weapon
and clothes cannot be ruled out, particularly when the
recovery is from an open and accessible place. Therefore, the
evidentiary value of such recovery is seriously diminished.
•
Lastly, with regard to motive, learned counsel submits that
though the prosecution has alleged a land dispute between
the accused and his brother Dashrath (PW-03), the same has
not been proved with cogent and reliable evidence. It is
argued that the alleged motive is weak and insufficient to
sustain a conviction, especially in a case based on doubtful
evidence. It is further contended that mere existence of some
dispute does not necessarily lead to the conclusion that the
accused would commit such a grave offence. In absence of a
strong and clearly established motive, the prosecution case
becomes further doubtful.
15.
On the strength of these submissions, learned counsel for the
appellant prays that the impugned judgment of conviction and
sentence be set aside and the appellant be acquitted of the
charge.
16.
Per contra, Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the State, has supported the impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence and submitted that the learned
trial Court has meticulously appreciated both the oral and
documentary evidence available on record and has not committed
any illegality or perversity in holding the appellant guilty for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of the IPC. It is contended
that the prosecution has succeeded in establishing the guilt of the
appellant beyond reasonable doubt by leading cogent, consistent,
and reliable evidence, which inspires full confidence of the Court.
17.
Elaborating further, learned State counsel submits that the
conviction is primarily based on the clear, natural, and trustworthy
testimony of PW-01 Smt. Milky Bai, who is an eyewitness to the
occurrence. Her presence at the scene is most natural, being a
member of the household, and her testimony has remained
unshaken in cross-examination. It is argued that there is no
reason to disbelieve her version merely on the ground of
relationship with the deceased, particularly when her evidence is
consistent and inspires confidence. The prompt disclosure of the
incident and immediate naming of the accused further lends
assurance to the prosecution case.
18.
It is further contended that the prosecution has established a
complete and unbroken chain of events, inasmuch as the
appellant was apprehended immediately after the incident by PW-
06 Vishnu Baghel and PW-08 Bhagat Baghel while fleeing from
the spot. The conduct of the accused, coupled with the extrajudicial confession made before these witnesses, clearly points
towards his guilt. Learned counsel submits that the said
confession is voluntary and has been consistently proved by the
prosecution witnesses, and there is no material contradiction or
omission to discard the same.
19.
Lastly, learned State counsel submits that the ocular version
stands fully corroborated by the medical and scientific evidence.
The testimony of PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel, along with the postmortem report, clearly establishes that the death was homicidal
and caused by injuries inflicted by a sharp-edged weapon. The
recovery of the weapon and blood-stained clothes at the instance
of the appellant pursuant to his memorandum statement, coupled
with the FSL report (Ex. P-22) confirming the presence of blood,
further strengthens the prosecution case. It is thus contended that
the prosecution has proved motive, recovery, and the manner of
occurrence beyond doubt, and the appeal deserves to be
dismissed.
20.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered
their rival submissions made herein-above and also went through
the original records of the trial Court with utmost circumspection.
21.
In light of the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties and upon perusal of the record of the trial Court, the
following points arise for determination in the present appeal:(i) Whether the death of the deceased Sonadhar Baghel was
homicidal in nature ?
(ii) Whether the appellant is the author of the crime and has
committed the murder of deceased Sonasher Baghel ?
Point for Determination
(i) Whether the death of the deceased Sonadhar Baghel was
homicidal in nature ?
22.
The prosecution witnesses, particularly PW-04 Vishwanath
Baghel (complainant) and PW-01 Smt. Milky Baghel, have
categorically deposed that Sonasher Baghel had died on the night
of the incident and his body was found lying outside the house on
the cemented platform (parchi). Their testimonies clearly indicate
that the deceased was assaulted at the said place, which
ultimately resulted in his death.
23.
PW-01 Smt. Milky Baghel, who is an eyewitness to the
occurrence, has stated that upon hearing cries at about 11:00 PM,
she came out of the house and saw the accused assaulting the
deceased with a weapon. Her testimony further establishes that
the deceased was lying injured at the spot and had succumbed to
the injuries. Presence of dead body at the place of occurrence is
supported by other witnesses PW-06 Vishnu Baghel & PW-08
Bhagat Baghel, who reached spot immediately thereafter.
24.
The procedural aspects relating to the dead body have been duly
proved by PW-10 Rakesh Kumar Ekka, who has deposed that on
01.08.2022, under the instructions of the Station House Officer, he
carried the शव of the deceased Sonasher Baghel along with the
requisition for post-mortem (Ex.P/13) to Community Health
Centre, Badekilepal. He has further stated that after post-mortem
examination, the body was handed over to the relatives of the
deceased for last rites, and the execution report of the duty
certificate has been proved as Ex.P/16.
25.
The registration of merg intimation and FIR has been proved by
PW-12 Vikas Chandra Roy, who has stated that upon receiving
information from the complainant regarding the death of Sonasher
Baghel, he recorded the merg intimation (Ex.P/01) and thereafter,
on the basis of oral report, registered the FIR (Ex.P/02) at Police
Station Kodenar. The dead body was thereafter sent for postmortem examination through PW-10 Rakesh Kumar Ekka, as
proved by requisition (Ex.P/13).
26.
The medical evidence assumes great significance in determining
the nature of death. PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel, who conducted
the post-mortem examination on 01.08.2022, has proved the postmortem report (Ex.P/14). He has deposed that on external
examination, the deceased was found lying in a supine position
with multiple incised wounds on vital parts of the body, particularly
on the head and face. The injuries noted by him include:
• An incised wound on the left side of the neck/jaw region
measuring approximately 3×3×3 cm with fracture of the
lower jaw;
• An incised wound near the left eye measuring 3×3×3 cm;
• An incised wound above the left eye on the frontal region
measuring 3×3×2 cm;
• An incised wound on the right parietal region measuring
2×2×2 cm;
• An incised wound on the posterior part of the skull measuring
3×3×3 cm.
27.
The doctor has clearly opined that all the injuries were grievous in
nature and caused by a hard and sharp-edged weapon. According
to him, the cause of death was coma and shock due to excessive
bleeding and head injuries, and the nature of death was
homicidal. He has further stated that the death had occurred
approximately 24–25 hours prior to the post-mortem examination.
Despite cross-examination, nothing substantial has been elicited
to discredit his testimony or to suggest any alternative cause of
death. The nature, number, and location of injuries, particularly on
the vital parts such as the skull and face, clearly rule out the
possibility of accidental or natural death. The injuries are
consistent with repeated assault by a sharp-edged weapon and
are sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.
28.
Furthermore, the spot inspection, preparation of inquest (Naksha
Panchayatnama Ex.P/04), and seizure of blood-stained soil from
the place of occurrence also lend support to the prosecution case
that the deceased was assaulted at the spot where his body was
found.
29.
In view of the consistent ocular testimony of the witnesses who
saw the deceased immediately after the incident, the duly proved
procedural evidence relating to handling of the dead body, and the
unimpeachable medical evidence of PW-09 Dr. Pradeep Baghel
supported by the post-mortem report (Ex.P/14), this Court is of the
considered opinion that the death of Sonasher Baghel was clearly
homicidal in nature.
30.
The learned trial Court has rightly recorded the said finding after
proper appreciation of the entire evidence on record, and this
Court finds no reason to take a different view. Accordingly, the
finding recorded by the learned trial Court on this point is hereby
affirmed.
31.
Consequently, Point for Determination No. (i) is answered in the
affirmative and held to be duly proved.
(ii) Whether the appellant is the author of the crime and has
committed the murder of deceased Sonasher Baghel?
32.
The learned trial Court, upon meticulous appreciation of the entire
evidence on record, has recorded a finding that the present
appellant is the author of the crime. This Court now proceeds to
examine whether such finding is borne out from the evidence,
particularly the testimony of the eyewitnesses and other
corroborative circumstances.
33.
The prosecution case primarily rests upon the direct ocular
testimony of PW-01 Smt. Milky Bai, who is an eyewitness to the
occurrence. She has categorically deposed that on the fateful
night at about 11:00 PM, upon hearing commotion, she came out
of the house and witnessed the appellant assaulting the deceased
Sonasher Baghel with a tangiya (axe). Her presence at the spot is
natural and cannot be doubted, as the incident took place just
outside her house. Despite lengthy cross-examination, her
testimony has remained unshaken and no material contradiction
or omission has been brought on record so as to discredit her
version. There is also no suggestion of any enmity or motive for
false implication against the appellant. Her evidence, thus,
inspires confidence and has rightly been relied upon by the
learned trial Court.
34.
The testimony of PW-06 Vishnu Baghel assumes considerable
significance. He has deposed that immediately after the incident,
he saw the appellant fleeing from the spot, and along with PW-08
Bhagat Baghel, he chased and apprehended him. Upon being
caught and questioned by them as well as other villagers, the
appellant confessed that he had assaulted and killed the
deceased. This witness has further stated that the appellant
disclosed the motive behind the crime, namely a land dispute.
Importantly, this part of the testimony has remained intact during
cross-examination, and no material contradiction has been
elicited.
His
presence
at
the
spot
and
participation
in
apprehending the accused lend strong assurance to the
prosecution case.
35.
Similarly, PW-08 Bhagat Baghel has corroborated the version of
PW-06 in material particulars. He has stated that he, along with
Vishnu Baghel, apprehended the appellant while he was
attempting to flee after the incident. He has also supported the
prosecution case regarding the extra-judicial confession made by
the appellant before them and other villagers. The defence has
failed to impeach his credibility, and his testimony also remains
unchallenged on the core aspects of apprehension and
confession.
36.
The contention raised on behalf of the defence regarding alleged
irregularities in the memorandum (Ex.P/06) and seizure (Ex.P/07)
proceedings, on the ground that signatures were obtained on
blank papers, has been rightly discarded by the learned trial
Court. A careful perusal of the cross-examination of the witnesses
does not reveal any specific suggestion that the memorandum
and seizure documents were fabricated in the police station after
obtaining signatures on blank papers. The Investigating Officer
(PW-11) has categorically denied such suggestion and has proved
the due execution of these documents. In absence of any cogent
evidence, the said defence plea does not create any dent in the
prosecution case.
37.
The recovery of the weapon of offence and other articles further
strengthens the prosecution case. The Investigating Officer (PW11) has proved that blood-stained soil and plain soil were seized
from the spot (Ex.P/09). The clothes of the deceased, duly sealed,
were handed over by the doctor after post-mortem and were
seized vide Ex.P/08. The seizure of the clothes worn by the
appellant at the time of the incident has also been duly proved,
and no serious challenge has been made to the same.
38.
The medical evidence, as discussed while answering Point No. (i),
clearly establishes that the injuries sustained by the deceased
were caused by a sharp-edged weapon and were sufficient in the
ordinary course of nature to cause death. PW-09 Dr. Pradeep
Baghel has also opined that the injuries could be caused by the
seized tangiya. His opinion has remained unshaken in crossexamination.
39.
The forensic evidence also lends corroboration to the prosecution
case. As per the FSL report (Ex.P/22), human blood has been
detected on the clothes of the deceased as well as on the shirt of
the appellant. Though no blood was detected on the tangiya, the
evidence on record, particularly the testimony of the doctor and
the Investigating Officer, indicates that the weapon was stained
with blood at the time of seizure, and the possibility of the stains
being disintegrated or wiped off before chemical examination
cannot be ruled out. Moreover, the presence of human blood on
the clothes of the appellant is a highly incriminating circumstance,
for which no explanation has been offered by him in his statement
under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
40.
The conduct of the appellant in fleeing from the spot immediately
after the incident and his subsequent apprehension by PW-06 and
PW-08 is another circumstance which goes against him. Such
conduct is relevant under Section 8 of the Evidence Act and
strengthens the prosecution case.
41.
Further, the extra-judicial confession made by the appellant before
PW-06 Vishnu Baghel and PW-08 Bhagat Baghel, in the presence
of villagers, has not been challenged in cross-examination. It is
well settled that if an extra-judicial confession is voluntary and
inspires confidence, it can be relied upon. In the present case, the
said confession finds corroboration from the ocular testimony of
PW-01 and the medical as well as forensic evidence.
42.
The nature of injuries inflicted on the deceased, particularly on
vital parts such as the head, face, and neck, clearly indicates the
intention of the appellant to cause death. The repeated blows with
a sharp-edged weapon on such vital parts rule out any possibility
of accidental or unintentional act. The opinion of the doctor that
death was caused due to coma and shock resulting from
excessive bleeding and head injuries further supports the
prosecution case. Thus, the intention to commit murder is clearly
established.
43.
In view of the consistent and reliable testimony of the eyewitness
PW-01 Smt. Milky Bai, duly corroborated by PW-06 Vishnu
Baghel and PW-08 Bhagat Baghel regarding apprehension and
confession, coupled with medical and forensic evidence, and the
conduct of the appellant, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the prosecution has successfully proved, beyond reasonable
doubt, that it is the appellant who committed the murder of
deceased Sonasher Baghel.
44.
The defence has failed to bring on record any material to
probabilise an alternative hypothesis or to create a reasonable
doubt in the prosecution case. There is no evidence to suggest
that the deceased died due to any cause other than the assault
made by the appellant.
45.
Accordingly, the finding recorded by the learned trial Court holding
the appellant guilty for the offence punishable under Section 302
IPC is well-founded and does not call for any interference by this
Court.
46.
Consequently, Point for Determination No. (ii) is answered in the
affirmative, holding that the appellant is the author of the crime
and has committed the murder of deceased Sonasher Baghel.
47.
Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the prosecution has
successfully established the guilt of the appellant beyond all
reasonable doubt by leading cogent, consistent, and reliable
evidence. The case at hand is not one resting on weak or
circumstantial evidence, but is firmly anchored in direct ocular
testimony, which has been duly corroborated by medical and
scientific evidence. The testimony of the eyewitness stands
unimpeached and inspires full confidence, having remained
steadfast
during
cross-examination
without
any
material
contradiction or embellishment. Such credible and trustworthy
evidence forms a strong foundation for sustaining the conviction.
48.
Further, the chain of events brought on record by the prosecution
is complete and unbroken. The immediate apprehension of the
appellant while fleeing from the scene of occurrence lends
significant assurance to the prosecution story and rules out any
possibility of false implication. The extra-judicial confession made
by the appellant before independent witnesses, which remained
unshaken, further strengthens the prosecution case and clearly
reflects the culpability of the appellant. The recovery of the
weapon of offence and blood-stained clothes at the instance of
the appellant constitutes an additional incriminating circumstance,
duly proved in accordance with law, which corroborates the
prosecution narrative.
49.
The medical evidence adduced by the prosecution fully supports
the ocular version and conclusively establishes that the death of
the deceased was homicidal in nature and caused by a sharpedged weapon. The forensic report detecting human blood on the
clothes of the appellant, coupled with the absence of any
plausible explanation in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
constitutes a strong adverse circumstance against him. The
motive behind the crime, arising out of a longstanding land
dispute, has also been satisfactorily proved and provides a clear
backdrop for the commission of the offence.
50.
In view of the aforesaid analysis, this Court finds no infirmity,
perversity, or illegality in the findings recorded by the learned Trial
Court. The appreciation of evidence has been carried out in a
proper and judicious manner, and the conclusion arrived at is fully
supported by the material available on record. The conviction of
the appellant under Section 302 IPC and the sentence imposed
are found to be just and appropriate, warranting no interference
by this Court.
51.
Accordingly,
the
criminal
appeal
preferred
by
the
appellant/accused- Chalan Baghel being devoid of merit is liable
to be dismissed. The conviction and sentence imposed upon the
appellant by the learned Sessions Judge, Bastar at Jagdalpur in
Sessions Trial No.71/2022 vide judgment dated 24.11.2023 are
hereby affirmed.
52.
It is stated at the Bar that the appellant is reported to be in
custody since 01.08.2022, he shall serve out the sentence as
ordered by the learned trial Court.
53.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the
concerned Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is
undergoing his jail sentence to serve the same on the appellant
informing him that he is at liberty to assail the present judgment
passed by this Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court with the assistance of High Court Legal Services
Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
54.
Let a certified copy of this judgment along with the original record
be transmitted to the trial court concerned forthwith for necessary
information and compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review