The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. The writ application stands disposed of.
20. Connected application, if any, stands disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
29.09.2026
Item No.26
Ct. No. 30
Aloke
WPA 27372 of 2026
CESC Power Sthyaee Karmachari Sangh & Anr.
Vs
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Joydip Kar, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Debdut Mukehrjee
Mr. S.N. Upadhyay
Mr. Anurag Modi
Mr. Utkarsh Singh
… for the petitioners
Mr. Balaram Patra
Mr. Anuj Kr. Mishra
Mr. Pradip Kumar
… for the respondent no.4
Mr. Suvodip Bhattachrjee
… for the respondent no. 5
Mr. Soumya Majumder, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Debanjan Mukherjee
…for CESC/respondent
no.6
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee, ld.Sr. Adv.
Ms. Aparna Banerjee
Mr. Debasish Basu
Mr. Atanu Basu
Mr. Abhilash Chatterjee
Mr. Jitendra Kr. Sharma
… for the State
1.
The
writ
application
has
been
preferred
challenging an order dated 8th September, 2026,
passed by the respondent no. 2/The Registrar of
Trade Unions.
2.
Vide the impugned order the Registrar of
Trade Unions has held as follows :
“On perusal of the documents and
office records, it is observed that Sri
Sumanta Kumar Nayak at one point of
time remained the General Secretary of the
union and the original records including
the original certificate of registration had
been kept in his custody. He did not return
the same to his successor when he left the
union. Afterwards, an application for
having a duplicate copy of the registration
certificate was submitted by Sri Pijush
Banerjee being in the capacity of General
Secretary of the said union. After
Inspection of the records including the
Annual Returns submitted by the said
trade union it was found satisfactory to
issue
the
duplicate
certificate
of
registration to the applicant. Sri Pijush
Banerjee indeed established that the union
was affiliated to Bharatiya Mardoor Sangh
(BMS) at that point of time and this fact of
affiliation under BMS has also been
confirmed by the BMS authorities.
It is also observed that Sri Sumanta
Kumar Nayak had submitted a set of
Annual Return for the year 2025.
However, holding the original certificate of
registration in one's possession cannot be
the regarded the only ground of being the
real office bearers of the union. The
breakaway group headed by Sri Sumanta
Kumar Nayak/Sri Rakash Kumar Singh
could not produce any order from the
appropriate Civil Court to establish their
locus standi to get registration of the
proposed change of address from the
registered head office of the union from
one place to the other. Because of the fact
as above, notices in Form-Cl and F1 given
by Sri Rakesh Kumar Singh and his men,
amongst others, Sri Sumanta Kumar
Nayak cannot stand in the eye of law and
hence, rejected.
The same is applicable to the
notice/application submitted by Sri Amar
Bahadur Singh and the same is also
rejected.
In that view of the matter, the
applications in Form-‘I’ made by Sri
Sarmana Kumar Nayak and Sri Amar
Bahadur Singh for the purpose of
recognition of C.E.S.C. Power Sthayee
Karmachari Sangh (Regn. No. 28048) in
the establishment of M/s C.E.S.C. Ltd.,
3.
CESC
House,
Chowringhee
Square,
Kolkata-700 001 stand rejected.
Therefore, the application in Form‘I’ submitted by Sri Pijush Banerjee,
General Secretary of C.E.S.C. Power
Sthayee Karmachari Sangh (Reg. No.
28048) remains sustained for the purpose
of recognition in the establishment of M/s
CESC Ltd., CESC House, Chowringhee
Square, Kolkata-700 001.
With the orders as above, the
notices for the change of address and
applications for recognition in respect of
the
said
C.E.S.C.
Power
Sthayee
Karmachari Sangh (Regn. No. 28048)
stand disposed of.”
The respondent no. 5 herein has raised the
issue of maintainability which has been countered
by Mr. Kar, learned senior counsel appearing for t he
petitioner stating that the nature of order challenged
herein is not covered under Section 11 of the Trade
Unions Act, 1926.
4.
On hearing the parties, this Court finds that
the order passed is not covered under the provisions
of Section 11 of the Act and as such the writ in it’s
present form is maintainable.
5.
Mr. Kar submits that the impugned order is
bad in law as the petitioner no. 2’s documents have
been totally ignored by the respondent no. 2,
whereas the respondent no. 5’s documents have
been duly considered and his prayers have also been
allowed, whereas the petitioner no.2’s prayer and
applications have been rejected, leading to the
petitioner being seriously prejudiced.
6.
Mr.
Majumder,
learned
senior
counsel
appearing for the CESC has placed petitioners’
Advocate’s letter at page 323 to the writ application
being annexure-P-10 wherein it is stated that the
matter for consideration of the Registrar of Trade
Unions in the impugned order was a request by the
petitioner for change of the registered address of the
Trade Union and for cancellation and withdrawal of
the duplicate registration certificate issued to the
respondent no. 5.
7.
Mr.
Majumder
further
submits
that
the
Registrar of Trade Unions was only required to
decide the said issues which he was authorized to
decide and has thus decided the same.
8.
Mr. Kar submits that by rejecting the Form-I
submitted by the petitioner no. 2 which was a prayer
for recognition of the petitioner no. 1 Trade Union,
the respondent no. 2, in view of his observation
therein has prima facie gone into the issue of Intra
Trade Union rivalry between the petitioner no. 2 and
the respondent no. 5.
9.
Mr. Kar thus prays for setting aside of the
said order.
10.
On the other hand, Mr. Majumder appearing
for the CESC submits that a dispute relating to and
between the officer bearers of the a Trade Union is
an Intra Trade Union rivalry and in view of the
judgments in R.N. Singh & Anr. vs. State of Bihar
& Ors. reported in 1998 SCC OnLine Pat 100 and
O.N.G.C. Workmen’s Association vs. The State of
West Bengal & Ors. reported in 1987 SCC OnLine
Cal 255 is subject to adjudication by a Civil
Court.
11.
Mr. Majumder further submits that the office
bearers of the trade union may be having a dispute
as to the positions held by the parties, but there is
no challenge to the said registered Trade Union,
which is free to participate in the elections for
recognition, to be conducted by the respondent no.
2, as the dispute between the office bearers is not an
embargo or an obstacle for the Elections to proceed,
in view of the fact that a recognized Trade Union is
an important body for collective bargaining in an
establishment/company.
12.
Learned counsel for the respondent no. 5
submits that the parent Union of the petitioner no.
1/Trade Union is Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh (BMS)
and it is Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh (BMS) to which
the petitioner no. 1 Trade Union being Sthyaee
Karmachari Sangh is affiliated to and the said
affiliation
has
been
confirmed
by
the
BMS
authorities.
13.
The
Registrar
of
Trade
Unions
in
the
impugned order has observed that the respondent
no. 5 has established the said fact and the BMS
Authorities have confirmed the same and on being
satisfied, the Registrar of Trade Unions issued the
duplicate certificate of registration to the respondent
no. 5.
14.
In view of the said observations and findings
of the respondent no. 2, the Registrar of Trade
Unions, this Court prima facie finds no illegality or
infirmity in the impugned order. The Registrar of
Trade Unions on considering the documents before
it, was of the view that it is the respondent no. 5
who was authorized by the parent body to apply for
recognition and contest the Election and accepted
the same by a reasoned order.
15.
The application of the petitioner no. 2 herein
was thus rejected by the Registrar of Trade Unions
on the ground that it was the respondent no. 5
whose application was in accordance with law, even
though he was issued a duplicate certificate. More
so, in view of the fact that the respondent no. 5 had
the support of the parent body of the Union being
BMS.
16.
Regarding the rejection of Form-I, this Court
finds that the dispute lies between the office bearers
of the petitioner no. 1, Trade Union and as the
respondent no. 2 has accepted the application of the
respondent no. 5 on the grounds therein, the
petitioner no. 2’s Form-I has been rejected giving
reasons. As such, any dispute between the officer
bearers of the petitioner no. 1/ Trade Unions is an
Intra Trade Union rivalry subject to adjudication by
a Civil Court in view of the judgments in R.N. Singh
(supra)
and
O.N.G.C.
Workmen’s
Association
(supra) and the officer bearers are at liberty to
approach the proper forum (Civil Court).
17.
Considering the said facts, this Court finds no
reason to interfere with the impugned order.
18.
The respondent no. 2 is at liberty to proceed
with the Election for recognition of the Trade Unions
in accordance with law.
19.
The writ application stands disposed of.
20.
Connected application, if any, stands disposed
of.
21.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied
for,
be
supplied
to
the
parties
upon
compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review