Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 548 of 2022
Central Bank of India, a body corporate and constituted
under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of
Undertaking) Act V of 1970 having its head office at
Chandramukhi, Nariman Point, Mumbai- 400 021 in the
State of Mahrastra and having branches at several other
places and also at Arrah, P.O. and P.S. Arrah, District Arrah
represented through its Manager, Mr. Sujeet Kumar, S/o
Sri Arbind Kumar, having office at Central Bank of India,
Regional Office, Maurya Lok Complex, Dak Bunglow Road,
District- Patna, Bihar.
...
Appellant
Versus
1. Union of India, through its Secretary, Ministry of Labour
and Employment, Shram Shakti Bhawan, Rafi Marg, P.O. &
P.S. & District- New Delhi - 110 001.
2. Krishna Kumar, S/o Chandra Shekhar Ram, R/o Qtr. No.
16/D, Railway Colony, Mal Godam, P.O. & P.S.- Arrah,
Dist.- Bhojpur- 802301.
…
Respondents
---PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
For the Appellant
For the Resp.
CAV on: 17/01/2025
---: Mr. P.A.S. Pati, Adv.
: Mrs. Swati Shalini, Amicus Curiae
---Pronounced on : 15/06/2026
Per Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J. :
1.
Heard Mr. P.A.S. Pati, learned counsel for the appellant and
Mrs. Swati Shalini, learned amicus curiae appearing for the
respondents.
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
2.
This appeal is directed against that part of the order dated
11-11-2020 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(L) No.
4668 of 2012, whereby and whereunder, the impugned order has
been modified from regularization of services to reinstatement in
service as part-time sweeper with effect from 01-04-1999 with
50% back wages.
3.
The factual aspects of the case reveal that the writ petitioner
had engaged the respondent no. 2 intermittently for cleaning and
sweeping of the Bank premises by the In-charge of the Bank on
some occasions in the year 1998-99 on payment of Rs. 5/- on
each occasion. He was never appointed on daily wages either
against a leave vacancy or temporary vacancy. It has been stated
that the respondent no. 2 had lastly worked on 31-03-1999 and
thereafter he was not engaged for any work of cleaning and
sweeping in the bank. The respondent no. 2 had approached the
Patna High Court for regularization of his services in a Class IV
post, but the said writ application being C.W.J.C. No. 3023/2000
was dismissed on 03-09-2004. The respondent no. 2 had
thereafter raised a dispute before the Assistant Labour
Commissioner at Patna which ended in failure and the Central
Government had referred the dispute for adjudication before the
Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Dhanbad. The terms of
reference was as follows:
“Whether the claim of Sri Krishna Kumar that he was
engaged on daily wage basis by the Management of
Central
Bank
of
India during
the
period
from
02.08.1997 to 31.03.1999 is correct? If so, what relief
is he entitled to? Whether the action of the management
in terminating the service of Sri Krishna Kumar is
justified and legal? If not what relief is he entitled?
4.
An Award was passed in Reference Case No. 102 of 2003 by
the learned Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad on 05-01-2012 in which the reference
was answered in favour of the respondent no. 2 and it was held
that the concerned workman is entitled to be reinstated in service
as part-time sweeper with effect from 01-04-1999 with 50% back
wages and be regularized. Being aggrieved with the Award dated
05-01-2012, the petitioner had preferred a writ application being
W.P.(L) No. 4668 of 2012 which was disposed of on 11-11-2020
by modifying the Award in the following manner:
“the concerned workman is entitled to be reinstated in
service as part-time sweeper with effect from 01-041999 with 50% back wages”
5.
Assailing the impugned order dated 11-11-2020, Mr. P.A.S.
Pati, learned counsel for the petitioner/appellant has submitted
that the learned Single Judge has not taken into consideration
the fact as to whether the retrenchment was unlawful or not and
in absence of there being any such finding, the respondent no. 2
could not have been directed to be reinstated in service even as
part-time sweeper. The learned Single Judge has not taken into
consideration that the respondent no. 2 was neither a permanent
worker nor did he work on daily wage basis against a leave
vacancy or temporary vacancy. Mr. P.A.S. Pati has submitted
that the reinstatement cannot be automatic and transgression of
Section 25(F) of the Industrial Disputes Act being established,
suitable compensation would be the appropriate remedy. It has
also been submitted that once the learned Single Judge had
come to a conclusion that the Tribunal had exceeded its
jurisdiction, the impugned order ought to have been set aside in
its entirety. Mr. Pati has relied upon the case of Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited v. Bhurumal reported in (2014) 7 SCC 177.
6.
Mrs. Swati Shalini, learned Amicus Curiae appearing on
behalf of the respondent no. 2 has submitted that the respondent
no. 2 was working in the petitioner Bank as a part-time sweeper
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
and the learned Single Judge has simply modified the Award of
the Tribunal and the present Letters Patent Appeal, therefore,
does not have any legs to stand. The issue of regularization has
been left open though it has not been denied by the petitioner
that the respondent no. 2 has continued working in the Bank on
a part-time basis.
7.
We have heard the learned counsel for the respective sides
and have perused the affidavits on record.
8.
On a perusal of the Award dated 05-01-2012, it transpires
that the respondent no. 2 was terminated from service after
working continuously from 02-08-1997 to 31-03-1999. As per
the case of the respondent no. 2, such termination was without
notice, notice pay or providing retrenchment compensation and
finding such assertion to be true, the learned Tribunal has held
that the respondent no. 2 is entitled to be reinstated in service
as part-time sweeper with effect from 01-04-1999 along with 50%
back wages and be regularized. This Award was modified by the
learned Single Judge by omitting the word regularization in view
of the observation made by the Patna High Court in C.W.J.C. No.
3023 of 2000. The order of the learned Single Judge has been
assailed by the learned counsel for the petitioner/appellant by
asserting that the respondent no. 2 at best can be extended
monetary compensation. In the context of the above submission,
we may refer to the case of BSNL v. Bhurumal (supra) wherein
it has been held as follows:
“33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid
judgments that the ordinary principle of grant of
reinstatement
with
full
back
wages,
when
the
termination is found to be illegal is not applied
mechanically in all cases. While that may be a position
where services of a regular/permanent workman are
terminated illegally and/or mala fide and/or by way of
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
victimisation, unfair labour practice, etc. However,
when it comes to the case of termination of a daily-wage
worker and where the termination is found illegal
because of a procedural defect, namely, in violation of
Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, this Court is
consistent in taking the view that in such cases
reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and
instead the workman should be given monetary
compensation which will meet the ends of justice.
Rationale for shifting in this direction is obvious.
34. The reasons for denying the relief of reinstatement
in such cases are obvious. It is trite law that when the
termination is found to be illegal because of nonpayment of retrenchment compensation and notice pay
as mandatorily required under Section 25-F of the
Industrial Disputes Act, even after reinstatement, it is
always open to the management to terminate the
services
of
that
employee
by
paying
him
the
retrenchment compensation. Since such a workman
was working on daily-wage basis and even after he is
reinstated, he has no right to seek regularisation [see
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3)17]. Thus when he
cannot claim regularisation and he has no right to
continue even as a daily-wage worker, no useful
purpose is going to be served in reinstating such a
workman and he can be given monetary compensation
by the Court itself inasmuch as if he is terminated again
after
reinstatement,
he
would
receive
monetary
compensation only in the form of retrenchment
compensation and notice pay. In such a situation,
giving the relief of reinstatement, that too after a long
gap, would not serve any purpose.
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
35. We would, however, like to add a caveat here.
There may be cases where termination of a daily-wage
worker is found to be illegal on the ground that it was
resorted to as unfair labour practice or in violation of the
principle of last come first go viz. while retrenching such
a worker daily wage juniors to him were retained.
There may also be a situation that persons junior to him
were regularised under some policy but the workman
concerned terminated. In such circumstances, the
terminated worker should not be denied reinstatement
unless there are some other weighty reasons for
adopting the course of grant of compensation instead of
reinstatement. In such cases, reinstatement should be
the rule and only in exceptional cases for the reasons
stated to be in writing, such a relief can be denied.”
9.
There is no denial of the fact that the mandatory
requirements enshrined in Section 25(A) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 has not been followed by the petitioner and
the respondent no. 2 who was a daily wage worker, all of a
sudden, found himself out of service. As has been held in the
judgment under reference, the workmen should be given
monetary compensation as reinstatement with back wages is not
automatic. Various classifications have been made with respect
to the category of terminated employees and the respondent
no. 2 falling in the category of a daily wage terminated employee
would deserve monetary compensation. The learned Single Judge
has not explored the issue of monetary compensation which is
the only avenue available to the respondent no. 2 as a solace.
10. During the hearing of this appeal, Mr. P.A.S. Pati, learned
counsel for the petitioner/appellant had offered an amount of
Rs. 2 lakhs as monetary compensation to finally lay the dispute
to rest, but no response appears to have been forthcoming from
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
2026:JHHC:18222-DB
the respondent no. 2. Nonetheless, since the respondent no. 2 is
only entitled to monetary compensation in view of the case of
BSNL v. Bhurumal (supra), instead of remanding the matter, we
fix the monetary compensation at Rs. 3 lakhs payable by the
petitioner to the respondent no. 2 within a period of 08 weeks
from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order. This
amount of monetary compensation has been arrived at by us
taking into consideration the prolonged duration of the dispute
between the petitioner and the respondent no. 2.
11. As a consequence, to the conclusions arrived at by us, the
Award dated 05-01-2012 in Reference Case No. 102/2003
passed by the learned Presiding Officer, Central Government
Industrial Tribunal, Dhanbad and the order dated 11-11-2020
passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(L) No. 4668 of 2012
is modified to the extent that the respondent no. 2 is entitled only
to an amount of Rs. 3 lakhs as monetary compensation which is
to be paid by the petitioner/appellant within the time specified
by us above.
12. This appeal stands disposed of.
13. Pending I.A.(s), if any, stands closed.
(RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY, J.)
(ARUN KUMAR RAI, J.)
Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi
Dated the 15th Day of June, 2026
Preet/N.A.F.R.
Uploaded on: 24 /06/2026.
L.P.A. NO. 548 OF 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review