Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 17.11.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 23.01.2026
+
CO.APP. 9/2025, CM APPLs.56690/2025, 56691/2025 &
68197/2025
S.K. TANDON & ANR.
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Nidhesh Gupta, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Aman
Leekha, Mr. Ankur Chibber &
Mr. Jaymut, Advocates for A-1
& 2.
versus
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA &
ANR.
.....Respondents
Through:
+
Mr. Pratap Venugopal, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Abhishek
Baid and Mr. Praneet Das,
Advocates for R-1
Mr. Avneesh Garg, Mr. Utkarsh
Sharma, Ms. Iptisha, Ms. Sneha
Sharma, Ms. Saloni Kapoor and
Mr. Ayush Pundir, Advocates
for R2
CO.APP. 10/2025, CM APPLs. 56810/2025 & 56811/2025
C R BHANSALI & ORS.
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Pinaki Misra, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Rahul
Sharma, Mr. Shubham Shekhar
and Mr. Himanshu Singh,
Advocates for A-1
versus
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA &
ANR.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Pratap Venugopal, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Abhishek
Baid and Mr. Praneet Das,
Advocates for R-1
Mr. Avneesh Garg, Mr. Utkarsh
Sharma, Ms. Iptisha, Ms. Sneha
Sharma, Ms. Saloni Kapoor and
Mr. Ayush Pundir, Advocates
for R-2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
1.
With the consent of the parties, both Appeals were taken up for
hearing together. As they arise out of the same proceedings and assail
the same Judgment, we propose to adjudicate them by way of the
present consolidated Judgment.
PROLOGUE:
2.
The present Appeals have been filed under Section 483 of the
Companies Act, 19561, assailing Judgement dated 01.09.20252
passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in CO. APP. Nos.
420/2022,
351/2023,
546/2023,
37/2024,
39/2024,
203/2024,
204/2024, 506/2024, 403/2025, and 404/2025, arising out of CO. PET.
Companies Act
Impugned Judgement
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
No. 379/2009 titled ‗Securities Exchange Board of India (Trust
Petition No. 3/1997) v. CRB Capital Markets Ltd.’. By the Impugned
Judgment, the learned Single Judge adjudicated the aforesaid
applications and issued various directions to the parties.
3.
The Appellants in CO. APP. No. 9/2025, namely, Mr. S.K.
Tandon and Mr. S.C. Das, are former members of the Special
Committee constituted pursuant to an order dated 29.05.2013 passed
by the learned Single Judge, which was subsequently reconstituted
vide Order dated 12.09.2023. Appellant No. 1 was the erstwhile
Chairman of the Special Committee, while Appellant No. 2 was one
of its members and is an Ex-Executive Director of SEBI. It is relevant
to note that another member of the Special Committee, namely Mr.
A.A. Sisodia, representing the Ex-Management of CRB Capital
Markets Ltd.3, was also part of the said Committee but was removed
pursuant to the order dated 12.09.2023 passed by the learned Single
Judge.
4.
CO.APP. No.9/2025 has been preferred by Mr. S.K. Tandon
and Mr. S.C. Das, the former members of the Special Committee,
challenging the Impugned Judgment and seeking to set aside the same.
The Appellants also initially prayed for restoration of the status quo
ante, namely, the status of the Special Committee as constituted vide
Order dated 29.05.2013, along with permission to complete the
process of winding up of the mutual fund. However, during the course
of arguments, learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants clarified that
the challenge in the present Appeal is confined to those portions of the
Impugned Judgment which record adverse findings against the
CCML
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Appellants‘ conduct, attribute impropriety to the functioning of the
Special Committee, and issue consequential directions having civil
and reputational ramifications against the court-appointed officials
such as the members of the Special Committee.
5.
The Appellants in CO. APP. No. 10/2025 are Mr. C.R.
Bhansali, CRB Trustees Ltd., and CRB Asset Management Co. Ltd.
Appellant No. 1 is the ex-Director of CCML and a settlor of CRB
Trustees Ltd. (Appellant No. 2). Appellant No. 1 is also a Director of
CRB Asset Management Company Ltd. (Appellant No. 3).
6.
CO. APP. No. 10/2025 has been filed challenging the
Impugned Judgment primarily on the ground that it purportedly reopens and modifies the Order dated 29.05.2013, imposes an embargo
upon the Special Committee from disbursing funds to the CRB Group
Companies flowing from the Interim Order dated 25.01.1999, and
issues further directions, particularly with respect to recovery
proceedings, forensic audit, and transfer of control to SEBI through
the Special Cell.
7.
The Respondents in both Appeals are (i) SEBI and (ii) Rommel
Investment Pvt. Ltd4.
8.
Since the grounds urged in both Appeals, as well as the defence
raised by the Respondents therein, are substantially similar, the
Appeals are being considered together for the sake of convenience,
clarity, and uniformity. Accordingly, unless the context otherwise
requires, the Appellants in both Appeals shall hereinafter be
collectively referred to as ―the Appellants‖, and the Respondents in
both Appeals shall be collectively referred to as ―the Respondents‖.
Rommel
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
BRIEF FACTS:
9.
The present proceedings arise out of a long and chequered
history. However, eschewing unnecessary detail, the facts material to
the institution of the present Appeals may be succinctly set out as
follows:
a) CRB Mutual Fund was established in 1993 by CCML for
undertaking mutual fund activities. For managing the said
mutual fund, CCML proposed to set up:
(i)
an Asset Management Company under the name CRB
Asset Management Company Limited; and
(ii)
a Trust under the name CRB Trustees Limited.
b) Accordingly, a Trust Deed dated 15.12.1993 was duly executed
between CCML, as the Settlor, and CRB Trustees Limited, as
the Trustee. CRB Asset Management Company Limited was
also incorporated in 1994 in terms of Regulation 19 of the SEBI
(Mutual Fund) Regulations, 1993, which were subsequently
replaced by the SEBI (Mutual Fund) Regulations, 19965.
c) In August 1994, CRB Mutual Fund launched a close-ended
scheme titled Arihant Mangal Growth Scheme6, scheduled to
mature in September 1999.
d) In the meantime, upon inspection of the records of CRB Mutual
Fund, Securities and Exchange Board of India7 detected
multiple regulatory violations. Consequently, a Show Cause
Notice dated 12.12.1995 was issued, culminating in an Order
1996 Regulations
the Scheme
SEBI
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
dated 24.04.1996 whereby CRB companies and the Trust were
prohibited from launching new schemes until June 1997.
Thereafter, on 20.05.1997, when SEBI summoned the
Trustees/Directors to ascertain the steps taken to safeguard the
interests of unit holders, it was informed that the entire Board
had resigned.
e) In the backdrop of the aforesaid developments, the Reserve
Bank of India8 instituted a winding-up petition against CCML,
being CO. PET. No. 191/1997. By order dated 22.05.1997, the
learned Single Judge of this Court appointed a Provisional
Liquidator to take custody of the assets and properties of
CCML.
f) Parallelly, SEBI instituted Trust Petition No. 3/1997 before the
Bombay High Court against the CRB Group Companies and
connected persons.
g) In the Trust Petition, the Bombay High Court, apprehending
mismanagement by the CRB Group Companies, vide order
dated 09.10.1997, appointed Mr. M.L.T. Fernandes as the
Provisional Administrator9 to take charge of all assets of CRB
Trustees Limited and CRB Asset Management Company
Limited and to carry out the winding up of the Scheme.
h) By an Order dated 25.01.1999, the Bombay High Court
approved a premature repayment scheme proposed by the PA
for small investors holding between 300 and 10,000 units. It
was specifically directed that entities belonging to the CRB
RBI
PA
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Group Companies and persons associated with CRB Bhansali
would be excluded from such payments. In this regard, a list of
133 companies identified as being related to CCML or CRB
Bhansali was recorded.
i) On 04.08.2000, CCML was deleted from Trust Petition No.
3/1997 on the grounds that it did not hold any units in the
mutual fund.
j) Since CO. PET. No. 191/1997 seeking winding up of CCML
was already pending before this Court, and pursuant to the order
passed by the Hon‘ble Supreme Court in Transfer Petition
(Civil) No. 756/2004, Trust Petition No. 3/1997 was transferred
to this Court vide order dated 13.08.2007 and renumbered as
Com. Pet. No. 379/2009.
k) Thereafter, the PA filed Company Application No. 1143/2009
in Company Petition No. 379/2009 seeking directions regarding
the distribution of funds to unit holders holding up to one lakh
units under the second scheme of repayment. Although
pleadings were completed, the PA unfortunately expired on
24.02.2012.
l) On 29.05.2013, the learned Single Judge disposed of the main
petition along with several connected applications. By the said
Order, a Special Committee with a tenure of one year was
constituted, comprising:
(i)
Mr. S.K. Tandon, retired Additional District Judge, as
Chairperson,
(ii)
Mr. S.C. Das, former Executive Director of SEBI, and
(iii)
Mr. M.D. Kanther, nominee of the Ex-Management.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Upon the demise of Mr. Kanther on 29.05.2014, he was
replaced by Mr. A.A. Sisodia.
The Special Committee was entrusted with the task of winding
up the Scheme in accordance with the 1996 Regulations, and
for this purpose, several directions were issued by the learned
Single Judge.
m) The Committee was authorised to dematerialise and liquidate
the securities of the Scheme, engage intermediaries, compute
the Net Asset Value10, and disburse amounts to unit holders,
subject to statutory liabilities and expenses. Over the years, the
Special
Committee
realised
certain
assets
and
made
disbursements from time to time. Nearly three dozen interim
reports and statements of accounts were filed before the learned
Single Judge. However, later, these reports were found to be
deficient as they did not disclose specific details of the
recipients of payments. From the reports, it emerged that
disbursements commenced from the third interim report
onwards. Up to the 34th interim report, a total of 15,70,16,100
units were redeemed for an aggregate sum of approximately Rs.
211,65,47,028/-.
n) In the interregnum, several applications continued to be filed by
various parties in the said Company Petition.
o) One such application, Company Application No. 1132/2017,
was filed by the Special Committee against the National Stock
Exchange and Rommel. By Order dated 05.12.2019, the learned
Single Judge allowed the application against Rommel, holding
NAV
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
that Rommel had failed to furnish particulars such as folio
numbers and share numbers of the Reliance Industries
Limited11, shares allegedly pledged by CCML. Consequently,
the defence of Rommel based on alleged agreements dated
22.11.1995 and 24.04.1996 was rejected as untenable and
illusory.
p) The said Order dated 05.12.2019 was assailed by Rommel
before the Division Bench in Company Appeal No. 1/2020,
which remains pending. An interim application therein was
rejected, whereafter Rommel approached the Hon‘ble Supreme
Court, which directed maintenance of the status quo with
respect to the RIL shares pending adjudication of the appeal.
q) In 2021, Rommel filed Company Application No. 737/2021
alleging serious irregularities in the functioning of the Special
Committee, including disbursements made to the
Management.
Pursuant
thereto,
SEBI
filed
Ex-
Company
Application No. 420/2022 seeking a final extension of one year
for completion of the winding-up process, followed by
dissolution of the Special Committee. SEBI contended that
although the Special Committee was envisaged to complete its
task within one year, it had continued to seek extensions from
2013 to 2022 without fully discharging its mandate.
r) The Special Committee filed Company Application No.
351/2023 seeking a further extension of its tenure for 12 months
from 28.05.2023, was kept pending and not allowed by the
RIL
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
learned Single Judge and eventually came to be disposed of vide
the Impugned Judgement.
s) Upon consideration of the rival submissions and allegations, the
learned Single Judge, by Order dated 17.08.2023, directed the
Special Committee to transfer the entire fund lying with it,
approximately Rs. 120 crores, to the Registrar General of this
Court within two weeks. The Special Committee was permitted
to retain Rs. 1 crore for day-to-day expenses. The Chairperson
was further directed to file a detailed report before the Court.
t) By Order dated 12.09.2023, the learned Single Judge
reconstituted the Special Committee by retaining only Mr. S.K.
Tandon and Mr. S.C. Das, and removed Mr. A.A. Sisodia. The
learned counsel for Rommel and SEBI were permitted to
inspect the data submitted by the Special Committee, with a
restriction on sharing their findings. It is noteworthy that this
order was challenged by Mr. C.R. Bhansali in CO.APP. No.
25/2023, which was dismissed by Order dated 05.10.2023,
observing that no direction prejudicial to Mr. Bhansali had been
passed.
u) Upon inspection of the data, Rommel submitted a preliminary
report dated 30.10.2023 alleging serious irregularities, including
that approximately Rs. 131.90 crores had been disbursed to Mr.
C.R. Bhansali, his family members, relatives, group companies,
and sister concerns. In view of allegations of collusion, notices
were issued to Mr. C.R. Bhansali and Mr. A.A. Sisodia. The
Special Committee, however, contested these allegations.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
v) Mr. C.R. Bhansali and Mr. A.A. Sisodia appeared before the
learned Single Judge on 18.01.2024, whereupon their
statements were recorded by the learned Single Judge.
w) Additional applications, including Company Application No.
403/2025 filed by Rommel and Company Application No.
506/2024 filed by SEBI, sought directions, inter alia, for a
forensic audit, freezing of accounts, and scrutiny of payments
made to CRB Group entities.
x) By the Impugned Judgment dated 01.09.2025, after hearing the
parties at length, the learned Single Judge addressed issues of
maintainability and, on merits, held that the doctrine of merger
was inapplicable to the interim order dated 25.01.1999 vis-à-vis
the final order dated 29.05.2013. It was concluded that the
exclusion of CRB Group entities from payments continued to
operate. The learned Single Judge also examined the propriety
of the functioning of the Special Committee and objections
relating to unclaimed redemption amounts.
y) Accordingly, directions were issued by the learned Single Judge
for a forensic audit to be conducted within three months under
Sections 11 and 11B of the Securities and Exchange Board of
India Act, 199212. A Special Cell of SEBI was constituted to
take over the functions of the Special Committee as Trustee,
with a mandate to complete the winding up of the Scheme
under Regulations 41 and 42 of the 1996 Regulations within
one year. Further, payments to Mr. C.R. Bhansali and related
SEBI Act
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
entities were restrained pending completion of the forensic
audit.
z) It was further directed by the learned Single Judge that
unclaimed
redemption
amounts
of
approximately
Rs.
95,40,51,044/- corresponding to 7,22,34,100 units held by 9,860
unitholders be transferred to the Investor Protection and
Education Fund after one year, subject to SEBI‘s decision on
extending the claim period.
aa) Aggrieved by the said Judgment, the present Appeals have
been preferred before us:
(i)
By the Special Committee constituted by the order dated
29.05.2013 (which was reconstituted vide order dated
12.09.2023), assailing the findings and directions
concerning its functioning; and
(ii)
By Mr. CR Bhansali and the CRB Group Companies,
challenging, inter alia, the observations and directions
relating to disbursements made to CRB Group unit
holders and the consequential directions for further
scrutiny and recovery.
CONTENTIONS OF THE APPELLANTS:
10.
On behalf of the Appellants, the submissions advanced may be
summarised as follows:
I.
The core mandate under the Order dated 29.05.2013 was the
realisation of the assets of the Scheme and distribution of the
proceeds
to
“all
the
unit
holders”.
Consequently,
disbursements made to the entities that were lawful unitholders
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
of the Scheme, even if affiliated with the CRB Group, were in
strict compliance with the express judicial directions. There
was no embargo in the said order excluding CRB Group
entities from receiving payments.
II.
The inclusion of a nominee of the Ex-Management in the
Special Committee was neither clandestine nor irregular. It
was expressly authorised by the learned Single Judge in the
Order dated 29.05.2013. Further, the composition of the
Special Committee fully conformed to Regulation 16(5) of the
1996 Regulations, which requires that two-thirds of the
trustees be independent. The nominee of the Ex-Management
constituted a permissible minority within the statutory
framework.
III.
The learned Single Judge, in effect, undertook a review of the
Order dated 29.05.2013, after a lapse of more than a decade,
without any formal review proceedings and in the absence of
grounds recognised in law for exercising such power.
IV.
The Order dated 29.05.2013 was a consent order passed with
the concurrence of all the parties. The said Order, not having
been challenged on the grounds of fraud, misrepresentation, or
mistake, has attained finality and operates as an estoppel
against any unilateral modification. SEBI, being a consenting
party to the said Order, could not subsequently seek directions
contrary thereto by filing Company Application No. 506/2024,
which amounts to an abuse of the process of the Court.
Further, SEBI was always aware of the earlier Orders dated
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
25.01.1999 and 29.05.2013, yet remained silent for several
years and has now taken a complete volte-face.
V.
The learned Single Judge erred in holding that the Order dated
25.01.1999 did not merge with the final order dated
29.05.2013. The Order dated 25.01.1999 squarely falls within
the four corners of the doctrine of merger and therefore stood
absorbed into the final order. The learned Single Judge failed
to appreciate that an interlocutory order, insofar as it finally
determines an issue in controversy, stands merged with the
final judgment. The Order dated 25.01.1999 passed by the
Bombay High Court was final qua the premature repayment
scheme, and in any event, all interim directions contained
therein stood merged into and superseded by the final order
dated 29.05.2013 governing the winding up of the Scheme.
VI.
The Order dated 29.05.2013 expressly contemplated the sale of
all assets and distribution of proceeds to “all unit holders”,
and was passed with full knowledge of the earlier orders of the
Bombay High Court. Accordingly, none of the recognised
exceptions to the applicability of the doctrine of merger were
attracted qua Orders dated 25.01.1999 and 29.05.2013.
VII. The interim reports submitted by the Special Committee before
the learned Single Judge were concise and contained all
material particulars. The detailed transactional data relating to
disbursements made to unitholders could not be annexed with
the reports owing to their voluminous nature. It has been
emphasised that neither the Court nor SEBI had ever called
upon the Special Committee to furnish such granular details.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
In any event, SEBI was never precluded from seeking these
particulars.
VIII. The direction to conduct a forensic audit was assailed as
wholly unwarranted and disproportionate. No material was
placed on record to indicate that disbursements were made to
persons other than those disclosed by the Committee, or that
there existed any irregularity, misstatement, or suppression in
the accounts. The accounts of the Special Committee were
periodically audited by independent statutory auditors, and the
reports placed before the Court were accepted and acted upon
for several years without objection. Further, during the
hearings culminating in the Impugned Judgment, no specific
instance of financial impropriety, misappropriation, or
falsification of records was either pleaded or demonstrated.
IX.
The learned Single Judge erred in drawing adverse inferences
from the fact that the Special Committee functioned from
premises associated with the CRB Group. Such an
arrangement was expressly contemplated and permitted vide
Order dated 29.05.2013, considering the location of records,
existing infrastructure, and logistical requirements. The
Committee functioned independently, bore its own expenses,
and paid rent and other charges for the use of the premises.
X.
In the event of any failure to wind up the Scheme in
accordance with Regulations 41 and 42 of the 1996
Regulations, the statutory remedy lies under Regulation 68
thereof. Invocation of Rule 9 of the Companies (Court)
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Rules, 195913, was therefore impermissible. This jurisdictional
objection was neither adequately considered nor adjudicated in
the Impugned Judgment.
XI.
There has never been any allegation of diversion or siphoning
of public funds by the Ex-Management, either by SEBI in
Company Petition No. 379/2009 or by the RBI in Company
Petition No. 191/1997. In the absence of any such foundational
allegation, the directions for a forensic audit and refund were
contended to be unsustainable.
XII. The reliance placed by the learned Single Judge on the
pleadings in Company Application No. 1143/2009 was
misconceived, as the said application, along with the main
petition, stood disposed of by the Order dated 29.05.2013.
XIII. The learned Single Judge failed to conclusively determine the
locus standi of Rommel and nevertheless entertained its
applications, overlooking the fundamental requirement of
establishing locus.
XIV. By Order dated 12.09.2023, the Special Committee was
reconstituted and the nominee of the Ex-Management was
expressly removed. The order categorically provided that,
“until further orders”, the Committee would consist only of
Mr. S.K. Tandon and Mr. S.C. Das. The order on NCM
International‘s claim was passed on 29.11.2023, prior to the
sealing of the Committee‘s office on 07.12.2023. It has
therefore been urged that the Special Committee was fully
competent and authorised to pass the said order.
Companies (Court) Rules
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
XV. Further, the learned Single Judge erred in upholding SEBI‘s
submissions regarding NCM International‘s claim, as the said
application already stood released for listing before the roster
bench in terms of the order dated 17.05.2025, and could not
have been dealt with by the learned Single Judge.
XVI. The constitution of the Special Cell of SEBI has been assailed
as being contrary to the 1996 Regulations, and therefore,
illegal. Further, there is no provision in the said Regulations
permitting SEBI employees to assume the role or functions of
trustees.
XVII. The learned Single Judge misread and misunderstood the
purport of the SEBI Circulars dated 24.11.2000 and
25.02.2016 concerning the transfer of unclaimed redemption
amounts to the ‗Investor Protection and Education Fund‘.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS:
11.
Per contra, on behalf of the Respondents, the submissions
advanced may be summarised as follows:
I.
The Special Committee lacks locus standi to maintain the
present Appeals. The Special Committee was constituted by
the Court for a limited, specific, and time-bound purpose.
Upon its dissolution by the Impugned Judgment, it ceased to
exist in the eyes of the law. Further, no adverse directions have
been issued against the members of the Special Committee in
their personal capacities. A direction for conducting a forensic
audit of records, by itself, does not give rise to any personal or
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
enforceable cause of action so as to confer a right of appeal
upon the erstwhile Committee or its members.
II.
The Special Committee, being a creature of judicial order,
possessed no independent or vested right to seek continuation
or revival of its mandate. Once the learned Single Judge, in
exercise of supervisory jurisdiction, entrusted the winding up
of the Scheme to SEBI, the role and authority of the Special
Committee stood extinguished ipso facto. Thus, former
members of the Committee cannot seek to undo or sit in
appeal over such judicial directions.
III.
The functioning of the Special Committee was marred by a
lack of transparency and accountability. Despite functioning
for nearly a decade, the thirty-four interim reports filed
between 2013 and 2023 failed to disclose critical particulars
such as the identity of individual beneficiaries, the quantum of
payments made, and the supporting vouchers. Such omissions
were in clear derogation of fiduciary obligations and the
disclosure requirements mandated under the 1996 Regulations.
IV.
The very object of the Trust Petition and the orders passed
therein, particularly the Order dated 25.01.1999 of the
Bombay High Court, was to safeguard the interests of genuine
investors by excluding Mr. C.R. Bhansali, his relatives, and
CRB Group entities from receiving any payments under the
Scheme. These protective directions continued to bind all
subsequent administrators and authorities overseeing the
Scheme and could not have been ignored or diluted by the
Special Committee.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
V.
Despite the subsistence of the aforesaid judicial embargo, the
Special Committee proceeded to disburse substantial funds to
entities linked with the CRB Group without obtaining prior
leave of the Court and without disclosing such disbursements
in its reports. These conducts itself warranted judicial
intervention and justified the direction by the learned Single
Judge for a comprehensive forensic audit.
VI.
The directions contained in the Impugned Judgment are firmly
rooted in SEBI‘s statutory powers under Section 11B of the
SEBI Act. As the statutory market regulator, SEBI is best
equipped to undertake a forensic audit, trace fund flows,
investigate irregularities, and ensure effective protection of
investor interests.
VII. Out of the total recovered corpus of approximately Rs.
211,65,47,028/-, a sum of about Rs. 131.90 crores, constituting
nearly 62.32%, had been disbursed by the Special Committee
to Mr. C.R. Bhansali, his family members, and entities
forming part of the CRB Group. Such disbursements were in
direct violation of the embargo imposed by the Bombay High
Court‘s Order dated 25.01.1999 and are therefore liable to be
recovered. In view of the gravity of the allegations and the
magnitude of the disbursements, a forensic audit of the records
and actions of the Special Committee was stated to be
imperative.
VIII. Several attendant circumstances demonstrate the impermissible
influence of Mr. C.R. Bhansali over the functioning of the
Special Committee. These include the operation of the Special
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Committee from premises associated with the CRB Group, use
of staff connected with the said Group, appointment of counsel
who had previously represented CRB Group entities, induction
of nominees associated with the CRB Group into the Special
Committee, and the persistent failure to disclose beneficiarywise details in the interim reports.
IX.
Paragraph 18(xxii) of the Order dated 29.05.2013 expressly
mandated that upon completion of the winding up, the Special
Committee shall submit to SEBI and the unit holders a
comprehensive report containing particulars such as the
circumstances leading to winding up, steps taken for disposal
of assets, expenses incurred, net assets available for
distribution, and a certificate from the auditors of the fund.
These judicial mandates were admittedly not complied with,
and even after the lapse of more than a decade, the winding up
of the Scheme remained incomplete, thereby justifying the
intervention ordered by the learned Single Judge.
ANALYSIS:
12.
We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties at
length and, with their able assistance, have carefully perused the
Impugned Judgment, the material placed on record, and the written
submissions advanced on their behalf.
13.
At the outset, before adverting to the merits of the rival
submissions, it is necessary to delineate the true nature of the
controversy which arises for our consideration. The dispute essentially
hinges upon the scope, ambit, and legal character of the Order dated
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
29.05.2013 passed by the learned Single Judge, the interpretation and
effect of which has a direct bearing on the correctness of the
Impugned Judgment. For this purpose, it would be apposite to first
advert to the settled principles governing the construction and
interpretation of judicial pronouncements. The Hon‘ble Supreme
Court, in P.S. Sathappan v. Andhra Bank Ltd.14, made the following
pertinent observations:
“Precedent
144. While analysing different decisions rendered by this Court, an
attempt has been made to read the judgments as should be read
under the rule of precedents. A decision, it is trite, should not be
read as a statute.
145. A decision is an authority for the questions of law determined
by it. While applying the ratio, the court may not pick out a word
or a sentence from the judgment divorced from the context in
which the said question arose for consideration. A judgment, as is
well known, must be read in its entirety and the observations made
therein should receive consideration in the light of the questions
raised before it. [See Haryana Financial Corpn. v. Jagdamba Oil
Mills [(2002) 3 SCC 496 : JT (2002) 1 SC 482] , Union of
India v. Dhanwanti Devi [(1996) 6 SCC 44] , Nalini Mahajan
(Dr.) v. Director of Income Tax (Investigation) [(2002) 257 ITR
123 (Del)] , State of U.P. v. Synthetics and Chemicals
Ltd. [(1991) 4 SCC 139] , A-One Granites v. State of U.P. [(2001)
3 SCC 537 : 2001 AIR SCW 848] and Bhavnagar
University v. Palitana Sugar Mill (P) Ltd. [(2003) 2 SCC 111] ]
146. Although decisions are galore on this point, we may refer to a
recent one in State of Gujarat v. Akhil Gujarat Pravasi V.S.
Mahamandal [(2004) 5 SCC 155: AIR 2004 SC 3894] wherein
this Court held: (SCC p. 172, para 19)
―It is trite that any observation made during the course of
reasoning in a judgment should not be read divorced from
the context in which it was used.‖
147. It is further well settled that a decision is not an authority for
the proposition which did not fall for its consideration.‖
(2004) 11 SCC 672
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
14.
Similarly, in Goan Real Estate & Construction Ltd. v. Union
of India15, the Hon‘ble Supreme Court reiterated and elaborated upon
the principles governing the interpretation of judicial orders,
observing as under:
―31. It is well settled that an order of a court must be construed
having regard to the text and context in which the same was
passed. For the said purpose, the judgment of this Court is required
to be read in its entirety. A judgment, it is well settled, cannot be
read as a statute. Construction of a judgment should be made in the
light of the factual matrix involved therein. What is more important
is to see the issues involved therein and the context wherein the
observations were made. Observation made in a judgment, it is
trite, should not be read in isolation and out of context….‖
15.
Guided by the aforesaid authoritative pronouncements, we now
proceed to examine the Order dated 29.05.2013 passed by the learned
Single Judge, which lies at the very core of the present controversy
and ultimately culminated in the passing of the Impugned Judgment
which us under challenge before us. In the said order, after noticing
the essential factual background, including the conduct of the
concerned officials of the Companies and the Trustees which led to
the filing of the Trust Petition, the appointment of the PA, and the
relevant provisions of the 1996 Regulations, the learned Single Judge
proceeded to issue various directions. The relevant portion of the said
Order reads as follows:
―14. Therefore, looking to the special circumstances in this case,
and keeping in mind the fact that a Provisional Administrator
appointed by the Court has been looking after the management and
administration of the Scheme ever since the year 1997; the fact that
the last Provisional Administrator, Sh. M.L.T. Fernandes, has
passed away in February 2012; and there also is no trustee
available to administer the scheme; and with a view to doing
(2010) 5 SCC 388
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
complete justice in the matter which has been pending in the courts
for the last 16 years; and as prayed for by counsel for both parties;
it would be in the fitness of thing if matters are now brought to a
close with this Court constituting a special committee to carry out
the functions of the Trustee and to proceed to wind up the Scheme
in terms of the aforesaid Regulations 41 and 42 of the Securities
Exchange Board of India (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996, with
full power to act in this behalf in a manner similar to that of
regularly constituted trustees, as contemplated under the said
Regulations. This would include the power, inter alia, to dispose
off all the securities of Arihant Mangal Scheme, presently lying
with respondent No.4, IIT Corporate Services Ltd., and all other
securities, wherever they may be; and to distribute the sale
proceeds thereof to all the unitholders at the Net Asset Value
(NAV), which is to be ascertained by the committee after
following the prescribed procedure in terms of provisions of the
aforesaid SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996.
15. Consequently, a Committee is now constituted, consisting of
Sh. S.C. Das, Ex Executive Director, SEBI (suggested by counsel
for the petitioner); Sh. M.D. Kanther, (suggested by counsel for the
respondent No.1); and Sh. S.K. Tandon, retired Additional District
Judge, Delhi, who shall be the Chairman of the Committee. Since
this Committee is being put in place to carry out the work of the
trustees, it is noteworthy that its composition also meets the
requirements of Regulation 16(5) of the SEBI Regulations
prescribing the composition of the Trustees. Regulation 16(5)
states as follows:
―Two-thirds of the trustees shall be independent persons
and shall not be associated with the sponsors or be
associated with them in manner whatsoever‖
16. During the course of hearing, and after examining the question
of premises for the Committee at length, all parties agreed that the
Committee would require some premises measuring about 10001500 sq. ft. The ex management of respondent No. 1 has agreed to
provide the services of a minimum of three dealing assistants; one
peon and one stenographer to the Committee, to begin with. It
would, of course, be open to the Chairman of the Committee to
request the respondent/ex-management for the staff to be either
increased or decreased, as he deems fit. All other necessary
equipment in the form of computers, printers, stationery etc. shall
also be made available by the ex-management. In this context,
Counsel for the ex management informed the Court that they have
obtained premises at 201, II Floor, Priyadarshini Vihar, Delhi110092 measuring 1300 sq. feet at a rent of Rs. 45,000/- per
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
month. Counsel for SEBI states that since the premises are stated
to be commercial premises, he does not have any objection to this.
17. To enable the aforesaid Committee to carry out its functions,
the complete records lying at the office of the erstwhile Provisional
Administrator, Late Sh. M.L.T. Fernandes, be transferred from
Mumbai to Delhi at a place and time convenient to the Chairman
of the Committee. The other modalities of the transfer may be
finalized by the Chairman himself in consultation with the parties
and members of the Committee.
18. Under the circumstances, therefore, and for the removal of any
doubts, the Committee is empowered to take all or any of the
following steps:
(i) Transfer the records from Mumbai office of the erstwhile
Provisional Administrator to its own office at Delhi.
(ii) Reconstitute the Board of CRB Asset Management Co. Ltd.
and CRB Trustees Ltd.
(iii) Appoint a Custodian to carry out the custodial services of the
assets of Arihant Mangal Scheme of CRB Mutual Fund
(hereinafter called the Scheme) and for de-materialization of
the securities held by CRB Mutual Fund.
(iv) Appoint a SEBI registered Registrar and Share Transfer Agent
for maintaining the records of the unit holders and for
dematerialisation of securities in place of M/s. Sharex
Dynamic India Pvt. Ltd.
(v) Appoint SEBI registered Stock Broking Firm.
(vi) To open Demat account with a SEBI registered Depository
Participant.
(vii) To open one or more Bank accounts, as required, with two
signatories.
(viii) Dispose of the assets of the scheme at the best available
market price and in the best interest of the unit holders of the
Arihant Mangal Scheme.
(ix) Appoint Statutory Auditors of M/s CRB Asset Management
Company Limited and M/s CRB Trustee Limited as required
under Section 224 of the Companies Act, 1956.
(x) The proceeds realized from the sale of assets of the scheme be
first utilized towards discharge of such liabilities as are due
and payable under the scheme including the making of
appropriate provision for meeting the expenses connected with
its winding up. The balance shall thereafter be paid to the unit
holders in proportion to their respective interest in the assets of
the scheme. In this context, counsel for SEBI submits that his
client‘s decision to move the Court was, inter alia, predicated
on the abandonment of their duties by all the trustees of the
trust company, namely, CRB Trustees Ltd., respondent No. 2
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
herein, which ultimately led to the appointment of the
Provisional Administrator; and which also obliged his clients,
i.e. SEBI, to provide funds to the tune of Rs. 10 Lacs for
establishment and administrative expenses. Under the
circumstances, the sum of Rs. 10 Lacs, which is stated by
counsel for SEBI to have been paid by SEBI to the Provisional
Administrator appointed by the Bombay High Court, for
meeting the establishment and administrative expenses be
reimbursed to SEBI in the first instance from the proceeds
realised by the Committee after the sale of the securities.
Counsel for the ex-management also has no objection to this.
(xi) The balance remaining in the hands of the Committee after
deducting all other expenses shall be paid to the unit holders in
proportion to their respective share to the units held by them
under the scheme.
(xii) As agreed by all counsel, including counsel for SEBI, the
Committee shall also compute the Net asset value of Arihant
Mangal Scheme, according to the relevant rules and
regulations, and publish the same in at least two daily
newspapers at intervals of not exceeding one week.
(xiii) Compute and carry out valuation of investments made in
Arihant Mangal Scheme.
(xiv) Wind up the ―Arihant Mangal Scheme‖ of CRB Mutual
Fund as per SEBI Mutual Fund Regulations.
(xv) File Audited Annual Accounts as required under Section 220
of the Companies Act, 1956, Annual Returns as required under
Section 159 read with Section 161 of the Companies Act, 1956
of M/s CRB Asset Management Company Ltd. and M/s CRB
Trustee Ltd. before the Registrar of Companies.
(xvi) Maintain statutory records, Registers, Forms, Returns etc. as
are required to be maintained under the following Sections of
the Companies Act, 1956.
(i)
Register of Investment under Section 49.
(ii)
Register of Members under Section 150.
(iii) Index of Members under Section 151.
(iv)
Annual Returns under Section 159.
(v)
Books of Accounts under Section 209.
(vi)
Register of Contracts under Section 301.
(xvii) File Income Tax or any other Returns, Forms etc. of CRB
Asset Management Company Limited and CRB Trustee
Limited as required under Section 139 and other applicable
Provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
(xviii) File appeal, revisions against ex-parte orders passed by
Income Tax, SEBI and/ or any other statutory authority in
relation to CRB Trustee Ltd. and CRB Asset Management Co.
Ltd.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
(xix) Obtain internal audit reports at regular intervals from
independent auditors appointed by the Committee.
(xx) Hold meeting of Committee as may be deemed fit and proper.
(xxi) Maintain records of the decisions of the Committee at their
meetings and of the minutes of the meetings.
(xxii) On the completion of the winding up, it shall forward to the
SEBI and the unit holders a report on the winding up
containing particulars such as circumstances leading to the
winding up, the steps taken for disposal of assets of the fund
before winding up, expenses of the fund for winding up, net
assets available for distribution to the unit holders and a
certificate from the auditors of the fund.
19. As regards CRB Asset Management Company Ltd., which was
arrayed as respondent No. 3 in the petition moved by SEBI before
the Bombay High Court, the said respondent was appointed as an
Asset Management Company in terms regulations 20, 21 and 22 of
the SEBI (Mutual Fund) Regulations, 1996. As required under
regulation 20(2) thereof, SEBI had granted approval to the said
company in terms of regulation 21(2) which was subject to the
terms and conditions mentioned in Regulation 22 thereof.
Regulations 20(2) and 20(3) provide that the appointment of an
Asset Management Company, such as respondent No. 3, can be
terminated either by majority of the trustees or by 75% of the
unitholders of the scheme and further, that any change to the
appointment of the Asset Management Company shall be subject
to prior approval of SEBI as well as unitholders. Admittedly, the
trustees of the trust company have expressed their disinclination to
discharge their duties as such more than 17 years ago. At the same
time, there is no gainsaying the fact that the petitioner, Securities
Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has been constituted with the
object of protecting the interest of investors and to regulate the
securities market and/or matters connected therewith or incidental
thereto, and to that extent, is interested in safeguarding the interest
of the unitholders of the scheme. In these circumstances, counsel
for SEBI as well as counsel for the ex-management of respondent
No. 1 company i.e., the sponsor, are agreed that the interest of all
stakeholders is best served by termination of the appointment of
the aforesaid CRB Asset Management Company, i.e. respondent
No. 3 herein. This Court also feels that upon consideration of all
the facts and surrounding circumstances, and since a special
committee has been appointed to wind up the scheme, the
appointment of the aforesaid CRB Asset Management Company be
terminated. However, as regards the liabilities of that company, its
directors and officers, the provisions of Regulation 25(6) are
relevant. It states as follows:
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
―Notwithstanding anything contained in any contract or
agreement or termination, the asset management company
or its directors or other officers shall not be absolved of
liability to the mutual fund for their acts of commission or
commission, while holding such position or office.‖
It is, therefore, made clear that the termination of appointment of
respondent No. 3 by this Court does not absolve the company, its
directors or other officers of liability to the mutual fund for their
acts of commission or omission, if any, that may come to light. It is
ordered accordingly.
20. Furthermore, keeping in mind the special circumstances, and
the fact that the matter has remained sub judice; as well as the
administration by successive Provisional Administrators appointed
by the court, which had effectively divested the management over
the control of the affairs of the respondent companies as well as of
the mutual fund, it would be manifestly unjust to visit the exmanagement of the respondent companies with any penalties or
sanctions for non compliance with any statutory obligations during
the period the matter has been sub judice and the affairs of mutual
fund have been under the control and supervision of the
Administrator and the court exclusively.
Under the circumstances, therefore, a general direction is issued to
the Income Tax Authority, Registrar of Companies; or any other
statutory authority to the effect that all the sanctions or adverse
orders passed against any of these respondent companies or their
employees, directors etc. shall stand withdrawn.
21. It is, however, made clear that as regards any claim in respect
of respondent No.2 and 3, of any statutory authority, or any
liabilities with regard to the period before the appointment of the
Provisional Administrator; it would be open to the authorities to
proceed as per law, whilst at the same time, it would be open to the
respondent Nos.2 and 3, their directors and officials to take the
defence on facts that they were either unable or prevented from
compliance due to intervening orders of the court. Such a plea, if
taken, will be duly considered.
22. Securities pertaining to the Arihant Mangal Scheme are stated
to be lying with respondent No. 4, IIT Corporate Services Ltd. The
said respondent has also moved Co. Appl. No. 710/2010. In this
application, IIT Corporate Services Ltd. has sought discharge from
acting as the custodian of the securities pertaining to the Arihant
Mangal Scheme held in the name of CRB Trustees Ltd. account
CRB Mutual Fund and to move all records and share certificates
etc. pertaining to that scheme from its office; and to surrender the
same to the ―Provisional Administrator/Official Liquidator‖.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
23. Looking to the circumstances and the fact that by this order, a
separate committee for winding up the affairs of the Arihant
Mangal Scheme has been appointed, it would be in the fitness of
things to direct the Committee acting through its Chairman to also
take charge of the aforesaid securities pertaining to the scheme
which are lying with the custodian, IIT Corporate Services Ltd.,
i.e. respondent No. 4 herein, after proper verification and
inventorisation to be carried out at the premises of respondent No.
4 with the requisite cooperation of the said respondent. For this
purpose, considering the importance of the matter, the Chairman
shall depute both the members of the Committee to go to Bombay.
After the proper inventorisation, the said records may be shifted by
the committee to its own premises at Delhi from where it shall be
functioning in terms of this order.
24. Counsel for the aforesaid IIT Corporate Services Ltd. states
that her client‟s only desire is that these records be removed from
their office as early as possible so that valuable space does not
remain tied down, and that they do not have any further claims in
this regard. It is, therefore, made clear that nothing further is to be
paid by either the Committee or the ex-management or anyone else
for that matter, to respondent No. 4 on any account.
Prior intimation shall be given to respondent No. 4, IIT Corporate
Services Ltd. as well as to counsel Mrs. Francesca Kapur
(Chamber No. 131, Delhi High Court, New Delhi), for all further
steps proposed to be taken in this regard by the Committee.
25. In addition to the above, the Committee is also authorized to
carry out certification of securities transacted during the period
22.05.1996 to 22.05.1997 after laying down the certification
procedure and giving due publicity in two newspapers. While
laying down a certification procedure, the Committee shall also
keep in mind the procedure laid down by the Bombay High Court.
The Committee is fully empowered in this behalf to seek
information, summon records and seek verification of facts, on
affidavits or otherwise, as it may think fit, from any person or
Authority. Keeping in mind the relevant circumstances, the
Committee is at liberty to seek transfer of all funds that were
deposited by Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. which have been
mentioned in the separate orders passed by this Court disposing off
Co. Appl. No. 1145/2009 and 1941/2010; which funds are now
lying with the Registrar of this Court along with all accrued
interest; to a Bank Account to be opened by the Committee for this
purpose. It would be open to the Committee to direct disbursement
of the same to the party found entitled to the same after completion
of the certification process, along with any further amounts that
may have been deposited or accrued by way of interest thereon.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Since the committee is being empowered to carry out the aforesaid
certification procedure with a view to satisfying the object of the
interim orders passed by the Bombay High Court instituting such a
procedure on 22.01.1999, which was amended on 4.5.1999, the
Committee is requested to proceed with this work along with the
process of winding up at the outset itself, in parallel with its other
work and make every endeavour to complete this process within
six months.
26. It would also be open to the Committee to appoint any
Advocate or any other expert, if it considers it necessary for more
effectively carrying out its functions; and for also approaching the
court from time to time, if it is so advised, for any clarification/
modification/ directions that may be necessary for effective
winding up of the scheme.
It is expected that the Committee shall move with sufficient
despatch since the matter is very old and a large amount of money
of small investors is also involved. Both counsel feel that with the
Committee members meeting about 3-4 times a week, the work of
the Committee is likely to be completed within a year. The
Chairman of the Committee shall be paid a fee of Rs. 1,00,000/per month and each member shall be paid Rs. 75,000/- per month.
It shall be open to the Chairman to recruit administrative staff and
fix a reasonable compensation in this regard commensurate to the
work to be done. The term of the Committee is fixed at 12 months
from today. It is also expected that the staff made available to the
Committee by the respondents or recruited by it, shall render
service at least eight hours a day and 5 days a week. Reliable
records in this regard be also kept. The Committee shall also file
quarterly interim reports before this Court.‖
16.
From a bare reading of the extracted portion of the Order dated
29.05.2013, the following, among others, undisputed and relevant
facets emerge:
(i)
The interest of the unitholders was held to be paramount, and
the learned Single Judge emphasised that all decisions and
actions must be guided solely by the objective of safeguarding
their best interests.
(ii) In view of the prolonged and chequered litigation, the complete
absence of functioning trustees at the relevant times, and later
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
the demise of the PA, the learned Single Judge found it
necessary to bring finality to the matter. Accordingly, a threemember Special Committee was constituted to function as
trustees, with a specific mandate to wind up the Scheme in
accordance with Regulations 41 and 42 of the 1996
Regulations. The Committee was vested with full trustee-like
powers, including the authority to sell all securities of the
Scheme and to distribute the sale proceeds to the unitholders at
the NAV determined in accordance with law.
(iii) The learned Single Judge observed that the composition of the
Special Committee satisfies the requirement of Regulation
16(5) of the SEBI Regulations, inasmuch as two-thirds of its
members are independent persons and not associated with the
sponsor.
(iv) Recognising
the
practical
requirements
for
effective
functioning, the learned Single Judge put in place a complete
mechanism for infrastructure, staffing, premises, and transfer of
records. Adequate office space, supporting staff, equipment,
and logistical support were directed to be made available, and
all records of the erstwhile PA were ordered to be transferred to
the Special Committee to enable it to discharge its functions
efficiently and without impediment.
(v) The Special Committee was conferred extensive and wideranging powers to ensure an effective winding up of the
Scheme. These powers include the authority to transfer and take
custody of all records and assets of the Scheme; to reconstitute
the Boards of CRB Asset Management Co. Ltd. and CRB
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Trustees Ltd.; to appoint custodians, SEBI-registered Registrars
and Share Transfer Agents, stock brokers, statutory and internal
auditors; and to open demat and bank accounts as required.
(vi) The Special Committee was also authorised to dispose of the
assets of the Scheme at the best available market value in the
interest of unitholders, to compute and publish the NAV in at
least two daily newspapers at regular intervals, to value
investments, to maintain statutory records and books of
account, and to file all corporate, tax, and regulatory returns.
(vii) The Special Committee was further empowered to file appeals
or revisions against ex parte orders passed by statutory
authorities, to conduct internal audits, to convene and record
meetings, and to submit a comprehensive final winding-up
report to SEBI and the unitholders.
(viii) With respect to the utilisation of sale proceeds, the learned
Single Judge laid down a clear order of priority. The proceeds
were to be utilised for discharging all Scheme liabilities and
meeting winding-up expenses. Also, an amount of Rs. 10 Lacs
advanced by SEBI towards establishment and administrative
expenses was directed to be reimbursed to SEBI. Thereafter, the
remaining balance was to be distributed proportionately among
the unitholders in accordance with their respective holdings.
(ix) It is noteworthy that the learned Single Judge also directed the
termination of the appointment of CRB Asset Management
Company Ltd., as the Asset Management Company, with the
consent of all concerned parties. However, it was expressly
clarified that such termination does not absolve the Asset
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Management Company, its directors, or officers from any
liability arising out of their acts of commission or omission
during their tenure, in terms of Regulation 25(6) of the 1996
Regulations.
(x) Considering that the matter had remained sub judice for a
prolonged period and that the affairs of the mutual fund were
under the exclusive control of court-appointed administrators,
the learned Single Judge granted limited relief to the ExManagement. It was directed that no penalties or sanctions shall
be imposed on the Ex-Management for statutory noncompliance during this period, and that all adverse orders or
sanctions passed by statutory authorities for the said duration
shall stand withdrawn.
(xi) At the same time, the learned Single Judge clarified that
liabilities pertaining to the period prior to the appointment of
the PA were not wiped out, and statutory authorities were at
liberty to proceed in accordance with law in respect of such
prior liabilities.
(xii) To ensure effective discharge of its mandate, the Special
Committee was authorised to engage advocates, auditors, and
other experts as may be necessary.
(xiii) It was further provided that the Special Committee would have
the liberty to approach the learned Single Judge from time to
time for clarification, modification, or further directions.
(xiv) Finally, the learned Single Judge expressed the expectation that
the entire exercise would be completed within a period of one
year, provided a clear mechanism for remuneration of the
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Chairman and members of the Committee, and directed that
quarterly interim reports shall be filed before the learned Single
Judge to monitor progress.
17.
Thus, from the entire Order dated 29.05.2013, it emerges that
the matter had been pending before the Court for nearly 16–17 years,
even though the Scheme had matured as far back as in the year 1999.
Considering that numerous applications were pending on various
aspects and that continued delay would not benefit the unitholders,
who had been awaiting resolution for decades, the learned Single
Judge considered it appropriate to chart a way forward with the
dominant objective of protecting the best interests of the unitholders.
18.
Considering the scheme of the 1996 Regulations and the fact
that the appointed PA was no longer alive, the Court constituted a
three-member Special Committee to function as ―trustees‖. This
appointment was of considerable significance. While the learned
Single Judge took note of the relevant provisions of the 1996
Regulations, the extraordinary situation, where statutory functions had
not been performed by the originally designated entities and where
SEBI had been compelled to approach the Court to safeguard the
interests of unitholders, necessitated such an arrangement.
19.
Accordingly, the learned Single Judge appointed a three-
member Committee comprising an expert member from SEBI, a
representative from the Ex-Management, and a neutral individual in
the form of a retired Judge of the District Court, and vested it with full
trustee-like powers. It is noteworthy that, by the same order, the role
of CRB Asset Management Company Ltd. was terminated, and
therefore, the inclusion of a member from the Ex-Management was
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
considered necessary for the smooth discharge of the Committee‘s
functions.
20.
The three-member Committee was thus constituted to complete
the task earlier entrusted to the sole PA. In place of a single PA, a
collective body came into existence. The learned Single Judge noted
in the said Order that the earlier PA was an extension of the Court.
Consequently, the appointment of the three-member Committee as
trustees was intended to safeguard the interests of the unitholders and,
in effect, constituted an extension of the Court‘s own function to wind
up the Scheme in terms of the 1996 Regulations. The ultimate
objective remained a fair and lawful winding up of the Scheme,
keeping the best interests of the unitholders at the forefront.
21.
To enable the Special Committee to effectively discharge the
tasks entrusted to it, trustee-like powers were conferred upon it,
accompanied by specific directions. These included a mandate to
complete the entire exercise within a period of one year and to submit
quarterly interim reports before the learned Single Judge, thereby
facilitating continuous judicial monitoring. In order to maintain
fairness and ensure independence, the learned Single Judge further
directed that two-thirds of the members of the Committee shall be
independent persons having no association with the sponsor.
22.
However, instead of completing the assigned task within one
year, the Committee took more than a decade, repeatedly seeking
extensions of time, thereby clearly frustrating the intent and spirit of
the Order dated 29.05.2013.
23.
In the said Order, the learned Single Judge issued several
directions and clarifications, inter alia, that the termination of CRB
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Asset Management Company Ltd., as the Asset Management
Company does not absolve it, or its directors or officers, from any
liability arising out of acts of commission or omission during their
tenure, in terms of Regulation 25(6) of the 1996 Regulations. The
learned Single Judge further clarified that although no penalties or
sanctions were to be imposed on the Ex-Management for statutory
non-compliance during the pendency of the proceedings, liabilities
pertaining to the period prior to the appointment of the PA were not
extinguished, and statutory authorities were at liberty to proceed in
accordance with law.
24.
This demonstrates that the learned Single Judge remained
conscious of the prior conduct of the management and trustees and
ensured that no party could take advantage of its own wrongs, which
had culminated in a complete breakdown necessitating SEBI‘s
intervention to protect bona fide unitholders.
25.
Turning now to the crucial aspect of the controversy, namely,
the Order dated 25.01.1999, it is evident that the Order dated
29.05.2013 does not advert to, or even whisper about, the stand of the
PA in relation thereto, nor about the mandate and implications of the
interim Order dated 25.01.1999. It is not discernible from the Order
dated 29.05.2013 whether the learned Single Judge kept in mind the
existence, purport, and ramifications of the said Order, which directly
concerned the acts and conduct of the CRB Group companies and
persons associated with CRB Bhansali. The said Order had expressly
mandated that entities belonging to the CRB Group companies and
persons associated with CRB Bhansali would be excluded from
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
payments, and recorded a list of 133 companies identified as being
related to CCML or CRB Bhansali.
26.
Among other things, it is apparent that the learned Single Judge,
while passing the Order dated 29.05.2013, was conscious that the
Order might not be perfect and that there could be errors, omissions,
or oversights requiring clarification, modification, or further
directions. It was for this reason that express liberty was granted to the
Special Committee to approach the Court in such eventualities.
27.
Ex facie, in view of the apparent oversight, or at least an
apparent contradiction, between the purport of the Order dated
25.01.1999 and the Order dated 29.05.2013, it would, in our
considered opinion, have been prudent for the Special Committee to
seek clarification from the Court. The Committee was not permitted to
proceed on assumptions, particularly in the complex factual backdrop
of the present case.
28.
In the event of ambiguity, the Special Committee ought to have
sought clarification, especially when its mandate was to protect the
best interests of the honest unitholders. From inception, including
during the tenure of the PA, the underlying premise was that errant
persons must not be allowed to benefit, while the interests of honest
and bona fide unitholders must not be compromised at any cost.
29.
In our considered opinion, once the Court consciously vested
the Special Committee with the role of a trustee, the Special
Committee stood placed in a fiduciary position and was required to
strictly adhere to that role. In terms of the empowerment granted by
the Order dated 29.05.2013, clarifications or modifications were
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
required to be sought from the Court rather than proceeding on
presumptions or assumptions, if there was any.
30.
What further emerges is that although the Order dated
29.05.2013 formally disposed of the main petition along with the
pending applications, it was never intended to close the matter once
and for all. The express liberty for clarification and modification
clearly indicates this. Further, since the Special Committee was
constituted by the Court and functioned as an extension of the Court‘s
mandate, it could never be concluded that mere disposal of the petition
marked the end of judicial oversight.
31.
The directions to submit periodic reports to the Court and a
comprehensive final winding-up report to SEBI and the unitholders,
which admittedly never happened, also demonstrate that the Order
dated 29.05.2013 was neither final nor co-terminus. Had it been so,
the only remedies available would have been those under law, such as
review or appeal, rather than the continuing supervisory directions and
repeated extensions granted by the Court.
32.
It is no longer res integra that such an appointment carries a
fiduciary character and imposes a corresponding obligation to act with
good faith, fairness, loyalty, and scrupulous integrity. The Hon‘ble
Supreme Court, in Marcel Martins v. M. Printer16, has elaborately
contemplated and explained these aspects. The Court examined the
concept of ―fiduciary‖ by referring to authoritative legal dictionaries
and precedents, emphasising that the essence of a fiduciary
relationship lies in trust, confidence, integrity, and the obligation to
(2012) 5 SCC 342
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
act primarily for the benefit of another. The relevant portion of the
said judgement reads as under:
―32. The term ―fiduciary‖ has been explained by Corpus Juris
Secundum as under:
―A general definition of the word which is sufficiently
comprehensive to embrace all cases cannot well be given.
The term is derived from the civil or Roman law. It
connotes the idea of trust or confidence, contemplates
good faith, rather than legal obligation, as the basis of the
transaction, refers to the integrity, the fidelity, of the party
trusted, rather than his credit or ability, and has been held
to apply to all persons who occupy a position of peculiar
confidence toward others, and to include those informal
relations which exist whenever one party trusts and relies
on another, as well as technical fiduciary relations.
The word ‗fiduciary‘, as a noun, means one who holds a
thing in trust for another, a trustee, a person holding the
character of a trustee, or a character analogous to that of a
trustee with respect to the trust and confidence involved in
it and the scrupulous good faith and condor which it
requires; a person having the duty, created by his
undertaking, to act primarily for another's benefit in
matters connected with such undertaking. Also more
specifically, in a statute, a guardian, trustee, executor,
administrator, receiver, conservator or any person acting
in any fiduciary capacity for any person, trust or estate.‖
33. Words and Phrases, Permanent Edn. (Vol. 16-A, p. 41) defines
―fiducial relation‖ as under:
―There is a technical distinction between a ‗fiducial
relation‘ which is more correctly applicable to legal
relationships between parties, such as guardian and ward,
administrator and heirs, and other similar relationships,
and ‗confidential relation‘ which includes the legal
relationships, and also every other relationship wherein
confidence is rightly reposed and is exercised.
Generally, the term ‗fiduciary‘ applies to any person who
occupies a position of peculiar confidence towards
another. It refers to integrity and fidelity. It contemplates
fair dealing and good faith, rather than legal obligation, as
the basis of the transaction. The term includes those
informal relations which exist whenever one party trusts
and relies upon another, as well as technical fiduciary
relations.‖
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
34. Black's Law Dictionary (7th Edn., p. 640) defines ―fiduciary
relationship‖ thus:
―Fiduciary relationship. — A relationship in which one
person is under a duty to act for the benefit of the other on
matters within the scope of the relationship. Fiduciary
relationships—such as trustee-beneficiary, guardian-ward,
agent-principal, and attorney-client—require the highest
duty of care. Fiduciary relationships usually arise in one of
four situations : (1) when one person places trust in the
faithful integrity of another, who as a result gains
superiority or influence over the first, (2) when one person
assumes control and responsibility over another, (3) when
one person has a duty to act for or give advice to another
on matters falling within the scope of the relationship, or
(4) when there is a specific relationship that has
traditionally been recognised as involving fiduciary duties,
as with a lawyer and a client or a stockbroker and a
customer.‖
35. Stroud's Judicial Dictionary explains the expression ―fiduciary
capacity‖ as under:
―Fiduciary capacity.—An administrator who [had]
received money under letters of administration and who is
ordered to pay it over in a suit for the recall of the grant,
holds it ‗in a fiduciary capacity‘ within the Debtors Act,
1869 so, of the debt due from an executor who is indebted
to his testator's estate which he is able to pay but will not,
so of moneys in the hands of a receiver, or agent, or
manager, or moneys due on an account from the London
agent of a country solicitor, or proceeds of sale in the
hands of an auctioneer, or moneys which in the
compromise of an action have been ordered to be held on
certain trusts or partnership moneys received by a
partner.‖
36. Bouvier's Law Dictionary defines ―fiduciary capacity‖ as
under:
―What constitutes a fiduciary relationship is often a
subject of controversy. It has been held to apply to all
persons who occupy a position of peculiar confidence
towards others, such as a trustee, executor, or
administrator, director of a corporation or society, medical
or religious adviser, husband and wife, an agent who
appropriates money put into his hands for a specific
purpose of investment, collector of city taxes who retains
money officially collected, one who receives a note or
other security for collection. In the following cases debt
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
has been held to be not a fiduciary one: a factor who
retains the money of his principal, an agent under an
agreement to account and pay over monthly, one with
whom a general deposit of money is made.‖
37. We may at this stage refer to a recent decision of this Court
in CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay [(2011) 8 SCC 497], wherein
Raveendran, J. speaking for the Court in that case explained the
terms ―fiduciary‖ and ―fiduciary relationship‖ in the following
words: (SCC pp. 524-25, para 39)
―39. The term ‗fiduciary‘ refers to a person having a duty
to act for the benefit of another, showing good faith and
candour, where such other person reposes trust and special
confidence in the person owing or discharging the duty.
The term ‗fiduciary relationship‘ is used to describe a
situation or transaction where one person (beneficiary)
places complete confidence in another person (fiduciary)
in regard to his affairs, business or transaction(s). The
term also refers to a person who holds a thing in trust for
another (beneficiary). The fiduciary is expected to act in
confidence and for the benefit and advantage of the
beneficiary, and use good faith and fairness in dealing
with the beneficiary or the things belonging to the
beneficiary. If the beneficiary has entrusted anything to
the fiduciary, to hold the thing in trust or to execute certain
acts in regard to or with reference to the entrusted thing,
the fiduciary has to act in confidence and is expected not
to disclose the thing or information to any third party.‖
It is manifest that while the expression ―fiduciary capacity‖ may
not be capable of a precise definition, it implies a relationship that
is analogous to the relationship between a trustee and the
beneficiaries of the trust. The expression is in fact wider in its
import for it extends to all such situations as place the parties in
positions that are founded on confidence and trust on the one part
and good faith on the other.
38. In determining whether a relationship is based on trust or
confidence, relevant to determining whether they stand in a
fiduciary capacity, the court shall have to take into consideration
the factual context in which the question arises for it is only in the
factual backdrop that the existence or otherwise of a fiduciary
relationship can be deduced in a given case. Having said that, let us
turn to the facts of the present case once more to determine
whether the appellant stood in a fiduciary capacity vis-à-vis the
respondent-plaintiffs.‖
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
33.
The Special Committee appointed by the learned Single Judge
stood in the position of a Trustee of the unitholders under the Scheme.
After the failure of the Company and the erstwhile Trustees to
discharge their statutory and fiduciary obligations, the Court itself
assumed this role and discharged the same through the PA for more
than one and a half decades. Thereafter, by Order dated 29.05.2013,
the learned Single Judge expressly extended this fiduciary role to the
Special Committee, directing it to act as Trustee for the unitholders.
34.
As noted earlier, the Special Committee was initially assigned
the task of completing the winding-up exercise within a period of one
year. However, the said task remained incomplete even after the
passage of more than a decade. Extension after extension was sought
by the Committee. When it became evident that these extensions were
not leading to completion, SEBI raised objections, initially in the year
2022, by filing an application seeking dissolution of the Committee.
Subsequently, several other applications were filed seeking various
directions by different stakeholders, including the Committee,
Rommel, and SEBI.
35.
Considering these developments, and upon further inquiries
conducted over a period of time, the Impugned Judgment came to be
passed by the learned Single Judge, as is evident from its perusal.
While doing so, the learned Single Judge examined various aspects in
detail and thereafter issued multiple directions. Among the others,
directions were issued for a forensic audit to be conducted within
three months under Sections 11 and 11B of the SEBI Act. A Special
Cell of SEBI was also constituted to take over the functions of the
Committee as Trustee, with a mandate to complete the winding up of
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
the Scheme under Regulations 41 and 42 of the 1996 Regulations
within one year. Further, payments to Mr. C.R. Bhansali and related
entities were restrained pending completion of the forensic audit. It
was also directed that unclaimed redemption amounts aggregating to
approximately Rs. 95,40,51,044/-, corresponding to 7,22,34,100 units
held by 9,860 unitholders, be transferred to the Investor Protection
and Education Fund after one year, subject to SEBI‘s decision on
extension of the claim period.
36.
Before issuing these directions, the learned Single Judge also
examined the propriety of the functioning of the Special Committee
and objections relating to unclaimed redemption amounts. In doing so,
the learned Single Judge examined the entire historical background,
pleadings, and materials placed on record in the main petitions as well
as the applications filed from time to time. The learned Single Judge
also recorded the statements of Mr. C.R. Bhansali and Mr. A.A.
Sisodia, who appeared before the learned Single Judge on 18.01.2024.
On the basis of these materials and statements, the learned Single
Judge drew certain inferences which ultimately led to the issuance of
directions, including the direction for a forensic audit.
37.
A perusal of the ―Conclusions and Reliefs‖ portion of the
Impugned Judgment makes it clear that, upon consideration of the
overall factual matrix, the learned Single Judge found it reasonable
and necessary to direct a forensic audit by SEBI. Further, since the
Special Committee had failed to complete its task in entirety, the
learned Single Judge constituted a Special Cell of SEBI for a period of
one year to complete the winding up of the Scheme in terms of the
1996 Regulations, while also providing a broad mechanism for its
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
functioning. As regards the unclaimed portion of the redemption
amounts, specific directions were issued which, in our considered
opinion, are justified and are in consonance with Section 11 of the
SEBI Act, the SEBI (Investor Protection and Education Fund)
Regulations, 2009, and the SEBI Circulars dated 24.11.2000 and
25.02.2016.
38.
Turning now to the most crucial aspect of the ―Conclusions and
Reliefs‖ of the Impugned Judgment, namely, the issue concerning
―Refund by CRB Group‖, it is apposite to reproduce the relevant
portion, which reads as under:
―140. ………
*****
REFUND BY CRB GROUP
(g) In as much as the prayer to recover the disbursements made by
the Special Committee to the CRB group is concerned, upon
conducting the forensic audit, if any violations are identified, SEBI
is given liberty to proceed in accordance with law.‖
39.
A bare reading of the aforesaid portion makes it clear that
although the learned Single Judge examined the factual background in
detail, including the essence of the Order dated 25.01.1999, the
pleadings in Company Application No. 1143/2009, the applicability of
the doctrine of merger between the Orders dated 25.01.1999 and
29.05.2013, and the propriety of the functioning of the Special
Committee, no conclusive finding was recorded either against the
members of the Special Committee or against the CRB Group
companies and sister concerns. In particular, the learned Single Judge
did not conclusively oust the CRB Group entities from their claims,
pursuant to which the Special Committee is alleged to have made
payments in disregard of the Order dated 25.01.1999.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
40.
This direction itself makes it clear that had there been a
conclusive finding on this issue, the learned Single Judge would not
have deferred the matter to be examined upon the completion of a
forensic audit, nor would liberty have been granted to SEBI to proceed
in accordance with law only if violations were identified.
41.
Therefore, in our considered opinion, there is no substance in
the apprehension of the Appellants, whether members of the Special
Committee or the CRB Group, that the learned Single Judge has
rendered any conclusive finding imputing manipulation or mala fide
conduct in the entire winding-up mechanism.
42.
In view thereof, we find no reason to examine the allegations
and counter-allegations raised by the parties at this stage. We concur
with the directions of the learned Single Judge, inter alia, directing the
conduct of a forensic audit and granting liberty to SEBI to take action
in accordance with law in relation to the recovery of disbursements
made by the Special Committee to the CRB Group, if violations are
established upon such audit.
43.
As regards the submissions of the Appellants that there existed
no grounds for directing a forensic audit, we are unable to accept the
same. The very objective of a forensic audit is to ascertain the truth,
and not to presume wrongdoing in advance. The existence of material
raising legitimate questions itself justifies such an exercise.
44.
The record reflects multiple reasons that necessitated the
direction for a forensic audit by SEBI, and the learned Single Judge
rightly exercised such discretion. By way of illustration, as pointed
out by the Respondents during the hearing before us, the reply filed by
the Special Committee to Company Application No. 737/2021, which
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
was filed by Rommel before the learned Single Judge, stated, in
response to paragraph 6, that “the Special Committee has carefully
compiled the list of unit holders and has not found either CRB Capital
Markets Ltd. or any other company connected with the same to be a
unit holder of the Mutual Fund Scheme”.
45.
This statement, ex facie, does not appear to be in consonance
with the submissions advanced by the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the Appellants, particularly those made while handing
over a chart across the Bar.
46.
Similarly, there appears to be numerous other inconsistencies,
and many of them have been taken note of by the learned Single Judge
in the Impugned Judgement itself. In view of these inconsistencies in
the record, the direction issued by the learned Single Judge for
conducting a forensic audit was both necessary and justified, as it was
essential to ascertain the true and correct factual position.
47.
At this stage, we express our deep dismay at the conduct of the
concerned parties, who have failed to wind up, in accordance with the
law, a Scheme that had matured as far back as in the year 1999. The
entire object and intent of the Order dated 29.05.2013, which was
passed with a view to expediting the winding-up process, has been
completely frustrated, as the winding up could not be concluded even
after the lapse of more than a decade thereafter. Despite the regulatory
body being the Petitioner in the proceedings, the winding up has
continued to linger for over two and a half decades, thereby defeating
the very purpose of judicial intervention.
48.
It is undisputed that the Order dated 29.05.2013 was passed
with the consent of the parties present before the Court. The Trust
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Petition filed by SEBI was intended to safeguard the interests of the
unitholders; however, the situation might have been better addressed
had SEBI not allowed the earlier Order dated 25.01.1999 to go
unnoticed while the Order dated 29.05.2013 was being passed by the
learned Single Judge, and had SEBI sought appropriate clarification at
that stage or at least soon thereafter. SEBI, being the regulator as well
as the Petitioner, was further expected to act with greater promptitude
and vigilance, particularly when extensions were being granted
repeatedly from 2014 till 2022 without any objection.
49.
So far as the applicability of the doctrine of merger is
concerned, as discussed hereinabove, having regard to the nature of
the Order dated 29.05.2013, it cannot be said that the said order was
final or co-terminus in nature. The order was clearly open-ended and
itself contemplated multiple contingencies and further proceedings,
thereby leaving the matter alive for continuation. Consequently, the
doctrine of merger, in stricto sensu, could not be attracted in the
present case.
50.
Similarly, with respect to the submissions regarding review by
the learned Single Judge in the Impugned Judgment qua the Order
dated 29.05.2013, we reiterate that, considering the nature of the
original order and the scope and ambit of the Impugned Judgment, the
latter, having been passed in the context of subsequent developments,
cannot be characterised as a review of the Order dated 29.05.2013.
51.
Moreover, the proceedings, since their inception, were not
strictly adversarial in nature, but were primarily directed towards
safeguarding the interests of the unitholders, under the supervision of
the Court. In this backdrop, the contention of the Appellants that the
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
Order dated 29.05.2013 was a consent order and that SEBI is,
therefore, precluded from raising any objection in any manner, is
wholly misconceived. The learned Single Judge was not adjudicating
inter se disputes between the parties; rather, the focus of the Court
was to ensure that the winding-up proceedings were carried out in
accordance with law and brought to their logical conclusion at the
earliest possible point in time. Consequently, any conduct or omission
on the part of SEBI cannot prejudice, dilute, or defeat the true intent
and purpose of the Order dated 29.05.2013.
52.
We now turn to the other arguments raised by the Appellants in
the present Appeals.
53.
The Appellants have assailed the constitution of the Special
Cell of SEBI as being contrary to the 1996 Regulations, contending
that there is no provision therein permitting SEBI employees to
assume the role or functions of trustees. We find no merit in this
argument.
54.
It is pertinent to note that when the PA was functioning for
more than one and a half decades, he acted as a sole member. Having
regard to the nature and object of the petition and the extraordinary
situation prevailing, namely, the protection of the interests of the
unitholders, and considering that the Special Committee envisaged by
the Order dated 29.05.2013 was unable to complete the task assigned,
we find no error in the learned Single Judge proceeding to constitute a
Special Cell of SEBI to bring the long-pending winding-up process of
the scheme to its logical conclusion. In any event, all actions of the
Special Cell remain under the supervision of the Court and are always
open to judicial scrutiny.
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
55.
With respect to the argument relating to the failure of the
learned Single Judge to conclusively determine the locus standi of
Rommel, we find no merit in the same as well, as such a
determination was not necessary for the adjudication of the present
proceedings. The Impugned Order has been passed after considering
various facets and is not founded solely on the actions of Rommel.
Consequently, a definitive determination of locus standi was not
required at this stage, and the prima facie satisfaction recorded by the
learned Single Judge is sufficient, with which we are in agreement.
56.
Coming to the order passed by the Special Committee on
29.11.2023 in relation to NCM International‘s claim, we find that
during the pendency of the application seeking extension of the
Committee‘s mandate, the passing of any such order by the
Committee was clearly beyond its jurisdiction. The Committee was
constituted pursuant to an order of the Court and was, therefore,
bound to act strictly within the confines of the mandate granted by the
Court. In the absence of any express authorization or subsisting
mandate, any action taken by the Committee, particularly one
affecting the substantive rights of a party, cannot be recognised or
sustained in law.
57.
The Appellants have contended that by virtue of the Order
dated 12.09.2023, the Special Committee stood reconstituted, the
nominee of the ex-management was expressly removed, and the order
categorically provided that ―until further orders‖ the Committee
would consist only of Mr. S.K. Tandon and Mr. S.C. Das. On this
basis, it has been argued by the Appellant that, in the absence of any
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
further order, the Committee was well within its powers to pass the
order rejecting NCM International‘s claim.
58.
In our considered opinion, the expression ―until further orders‖
used in the Order dated 12.09.2023 was limited to the reconstitution of
the Committee from three members to two members and did not
operate as an express extension of the mandate of the Committee. This
assumes significance in view of the fact that Company Application
No. 351/2023, seeking extension of the mandate of the Committee,
was kept pending by the learned Single Judge. The relevant portion of
the Order dated 12.09.2023 reads as under:
―CO.APPL.351/2023 (seeking extension of mandate)
10. The Court has heard the submissions of ld. Counsel for the
Applicant in CO.APPL.737/2021 as also heard ld. Senior Counsel
appearing for the Special Committee in part.
*****
14. Considering this position as also considering the fact that a
substantial amount disbursement has already been made by the
Special Committee, it is deemed appropriate that until further
orders, the Special Committee shall now consist only of the
following members:
i. Mr. S.K. Tandon, retired ADJ (Chairperson)
ii. Mr. S.C. Das, Ex-Executive Director of SEBI (Member).
15. Mr. A.A. Sisodia shall no longer function as a member of the
Special Committee. Mr. Tandon is free to engage his own staff for
the purpose of conducting affairs of the Special Committee and
shall not allow any interference by Mr. Bhansali or any of his
family members or officials.
*****
24. Insofar as the remaining contentions are concerned, the same
shall be considered on the next date of hearing. 25. List on 31st
October, 2023.‖
59.
The Appellants have further argued that NCM‘s application,
being Company Application No. 504/2024, had already been released
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
by the learned Single Judge on 17.05.2025 and, therefore, the
direction issued in the Impugned Judgment on the said issue is
erroneous.
60.
We again find no merit in this submission. By the Impugned
Judgment, the learned Single Judge decided numerous applications,
including Company Application No. 351/2023 filed by the Committee
seeking extension of its mandate. The direction pertaining to NCM‘s
claim was mere consequential to the rejection of the application
seeking extension of the mandate. Moreover, the learned Single Judge
merely relegated the issue to the appropriate authority for
reconsideration and did not adjudicate upon the merits of NCM‘s
claim either way. Accordingly, this argument of the Appellants does
not necessitate any interference by this Court.
61.
We now turn to the last major argument advanced by the
Appellants, namely, that in the event of any failure to wind up the
scheme in accordance with Regulations 41 and 42 of the 1996
Regulations, the statutory remedy lies under Regulation 68 thereof
and that invocation of Rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules was
impermissible.
62.
We find no merit in this contention either. The Company Court
is vested with ample authority to exercise its inherent powers, having
regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. The comparison
sought to be drawn between Regulation 68 of the 1996 Regulations
and Rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules is misconceived.
Regulation 68 of the 1996 Regulations empowers SEBI to initiate
action upon satisfaction of the conditions stipulated therein, whereas
Rule 9 of the Companies (Court) Rules preserves the inherent powers
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
of the Court to pass such orders as may be necessary to meet the ends
of justice. The two provisions operate in distinct and independent
spheres and are not in conflict with each other. Accordingly, this
argument of the Appellants also stands rejected.
DECISION:
63.
In view of the foregoing discussion and analysis, we find no
merit in the present appeals. Accordingly, both appeals are dismissed.
64.
The present Appeals, along with pending application(s), if any,
stand disposed of in the above terms.
65.
No order as to costs.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 23, 2026/sm/her
CO.APP. 9/2025 & CO.APP. 10/2025
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review