The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In order to amount an offence under Section 13(1) (d) of the PC Act, a public servant should have acted in illegal means with dishonest intention so as to obtain valuable things or pecuniary advantage for himself or to any other person. 2025:KER:10600 Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022 Here, the allegation is that on account of the illegal acts of the petitioners and the other officials in the bank, accused No.6 obtained a pecuniary advantage. The conspiracy hatched between the accused persons in order to enable accused No. 6 to get such a pecuniary advantage is the allegation. But when all the accused were tried in C.C. No.122 of 2013 by a competent court and were acquitted, there cannot be another trial of them for the offence of same conspiracy again. On account of that bar, a charge in this case against the petitioners would only be groundless.
16. Special In the above circumstances, the order of the Court directing framing of charge against the petitioners is not able to be sustained. The impugned order is therefore set aside. I make it clear that these findings would not fetter the Manjeri Co-operative Urban Bank Limited, Kondotty, to proceed against the erred employees or its customers for realisation of any loss occasioned to the bank. It is also made clear that the authorities, such as the Reserve Bank of India and Cooperative Department will also have 2025:KER:10600 Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022 every right to take appropriate action in the matter and this order shall not be a bar. Accordingly this Crl.M.C. is allowed. Further proceedings against the petitioners in C.C. No.20 of 2016 on the files of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kozhikode are quashed. Sd/- P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE dkr 2025:KER:10600 Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022 ANNEXURE-1 DATED 9-9-2006 ANNEXURE-2 CRL.M.C.5286 OF 2018 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT DATED 1-9-2021 ANNEXURE-3 6-5-2022 HON'BLE
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:10600
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
MONDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 21ST MAGHA, 1946
CRL.MC NO. 3702 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 06.05.2022 IN CC NO.20 OF 2016 OF
THE ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE, KOZHIKODE.
CRIME NO.10/2003 OF SPECIAL INVESTIGATION UNIT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
PETITIONERS/ACCUSED NOS.3 & 8:
C.M.SHABEER
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O.MOHAMMED KUTTY, CHITTANGATTU HOUSE,
CHUNGAM, KONDOTTY.P.O, MALAPPURAM (FORMERLY
JUNIOR CLERK, MANJERI CO-OPERATIVE URBAN BANK
LIMITED, EVENING BRANCH, KONDOTTY),
PIN – 673638.
R.V.SUNIL KUMAR
AGED 50 YEARS
S/O.GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR, UMA NIVAS,
AYIKKARAPPADY.P.O, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT
(FORMERLY JUNIOR CLERK, MCUB LTD, KONDOTTY
EVENING BRANCH), PIN - 673637
BY ADVS.
B.RAMAN PILLAI (SR.)
R.ANIL
M.SUNILKUMAR
SUJESH MENON V.B.
THOMAS ABRAHAM (NILACKAPPILLIL)
THOMAS SABU VADAKEKUT
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
MAHESH BHANU S.
S.LAKSHMI SANKAR
RESSIL LONAN
SWETHA P. DILEEP
RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH
COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682031.
BY SMT REKHA S., SR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING COME UP FOR FINAL
HEARING ON 10.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED
THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, J.
----------------------------------------------------------Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
----------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 10th day of February, 2025
ORDER
Accused Nos.3 and 8 in C.C.No.20 of 2016 pending before
the
Court
of
Enquiry
Commissioner
and
Special
Judge,
Kozhikode have filed this Crl.M.C. under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Code). The offences alleged
against them and their co-accused totalling eight are punishable
under Sections 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act) and under Section
120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
2.
The case of the prosecution is the following:
During the period between 09.11.2000 and 01.06.2002, a
huge amount of money was collected from the Centurian Bank
through the accounts opened in the Manjeri Co-operative Urban
Bank Limited in the name of accused No.6 fictitious persons. The
transfer of money was effected using the Instant Money Transfer
Scheme (IMTS). There occurred a short collection of commission
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
to a tune of Rs.3,56,165/-. Such transfers were in violation of the
Reserve Bank of India guidelines. Hence the Reserve Bank of
India took action and imposed a penalty of Rs.5,00,000/-. Thus,
the Manjeri Co-operative Urban Bank sustained a total loss of
Rs.8,56,165/-. The said loss was caused due to the illegal acts of
accused Nos.1 to 5, 7 and 8, and it was pursuant to a conspiracy
hatched by them with accused No.6 with a view to enure him
undue pecuniary advantage.
3.
Based on the said allegations, the Special Court
framed a charge against the accused persons. Challenging the
order framing charge, accused Nos.1 and 7 filed a revision
petitions and accused Nos.3 and 8 (present petitioners) filed a
Crl.M.C. before this Court. The said petitions were disposed of
by
this
Court by a common order
dated
01.09.2021.
Annexure-2 is a copy of that order. While revision petitions
were dismissed, the Crl.M.C. filed by the petitioners was
allowed in part. On quashing the charge framed against them,
the Special Court was directed to consider afresh the question
of framing charges against them.
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
4.
In obedience to the said direction, the Special
Court considered the matter afresh and held as per the order
dated 06.05.2022, Annexure-3, that there were sufficient
materials to presume that the petitioners committed the
offences. Accordingly, a charge was ordered to be framed
against them. The said order is under challenge in this
Crl.M.C.
5.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and
the learned Senior Public Prosecutor.
6.
A statement of the investigating officer was placed
on record by the learned Senior Public Prosecutor. The
petitioners filed Crl.M.A. No.2 of 2024 producing therewith a
copy of the judgment in C.C. No.122 of 2013 on the files of
the Court of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class,
Malappuram.
7.
submit
The learned counsel for the petitioners would
that
alleging
the
same
set
of
facts,
another
prosecution was initiated against the petitioners and their coaccused in C.C. No.20 of 2016 before the Judicial Magistrate
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
of the First Class, Malappuram. In that case, apart from the
accused herein, five more persons were arraigned. The
offences alleged in that case are punishable under Sections
409, 465, 467, 468, 471, 477A, 120B read with Section 34 of
the IPC.
8.
The judgment in C.C.No.122 of 2013 is Annexure-4.
It is submitted that the trial in Annexure-4 case was held
based on the same set of facts and when there is commonality
of allegations in both cases, the acquittal of the petitioners as
per Annexure-4 creates a bar for the trial in C.C.No.122 of
2013. This is a petition for revising an order framing charge.
The materials require consideration, ordinarily, are those which
were produced by the prosecution alone. Annexure-4 judgment
being an unimpeachable document and the question arises in
the light of that document being one of law, I proceed to
consider that document also.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioners would
submit that the conspiracy aspects alleged in both cases are
in regard to the same criminal acts and therefore the
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
prosecution in C.C. No.20 of 2016 would not come within the
exclusion clause contained in sub-section (4) of Section 300 of
the Code. What is relevant is not the identity of the
allegations on facts but the identity of the ingredients of the
offence for the purpose of deciding whether or not the second
trial is barred under Section 300 of the Code. In the view of
the learned counsel for the petitioners, the prosecution in C.C.
No.20 of 2016 is based on the same ingredients which
constituted the foundation for the prosecution in C.C.No.122
of 2013. In that view of the matter, there is absolutely no
justification to try the petitioners in C.C.No.20 of 2016, it is
urged. In this regard, the learned counsel for the petitioners
places reliance on Sangeetaben Mahendrabhai Patel v.
State of Gujarat and Another [AIR 2012 SC 2844] and
also Vedhasingh J v. R.M.Govindan [AIR 2022 SC 3772].
10.
The learned Senior Public Prosecutor, on the other
hand, would submit that the offences on which the trial was
held before the learned Judicial Magistrate of the First Class,
Malappuram, were unconnected with the allegations in the
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
present case. Misconduct of the public servant, including the
petitioners, who were the Junior Clerks in the Manjeri Cooperative Urban Bank Limited by acting illegally and enabling
accused No.6 to obtain pecuniary advantage is the core of
allegations. When those offences were not at trial in the case
before the learned Magistrate, this is a case which comes
within the excluded category under sub-section (4) of Section
of
the
Code.
The
learned
Prosecutor
accordingly
submitted that Annexure-4 judgment would not stand in the
way of a trial in C.C. No.20 of 2016. It is further submitted
that the conspiracy aspect is essentially the subject matter in
C.C. No.20 of 2016 and there is sufficient materials to frame a
charge against the petitioners.
11.
The material facts which constitute the charges
against the petitioners are narrated in paragraph No.7 in the
statement filed by the investigating officer. Paragraph No.7 is
extracted below:
“7. The brief of the Vigilance Case is that Senior
Clerk(A1), Sri.M Hassan, Manager(A2), Sri.C.M.Shabeer,
Senior
Clerk(A3),
Sri.M.C.Sainul
Abideen,
Junior
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
Clerk(A4).
K.P.Abdul
Rasheed,
Junior
Clerk(A5),
Sri.K.K.Mohammed Faizal (A7), Asst. Secretary and
Sri.R.V.Sunil
Kumar,
Junior
Clerk(A8)
of
Manjeri
Cooperative Urban Bank Ltd Kondotty evening branch
entered into a criminal conspiracy among themselves
and
with
Shri.P.Mohammed
Asharaf(A6)
and
in
pursuance of the said conspiracy, the said Mohammed
Asharaf was allowed to open as many accounts at the
Kondotty evening branch of the said bank in his name
and several other fictitious names to collect huge
amounts transferred from Centurion Bank Ltd, Mumbai
branch as per Instant Money Transfer facility scheme and
allowed the said Mohammed Asharaf (A6) to collect an
amount of Rs.62,39,71,000/-(Sixty two crore thirty nine
lakh seventy one thousand) during the period from 0811-2000 to 01- 06-2002 through 13 accounts without
monitoring the funds in accordance with the instructions
of the Reserve Bank of India and also without realizing
the bank commission prescribed as per the Bank
circulars and thereby caused pecuniary loss to the tune
of Rs.8,56,165/-(Eight lakh fifty six thousand one
hundred and sixty five) to the Bank by way of short
collection of Bank commission for Rs.3,56,165/-(Three
lakh fifty six thousand one hundred and sixty five) and
liability occurred to the Bank for remittance of fine of
Rs.5 lakhs imposed by the RBI for having violated their
instructions.”
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
12.
Two essential elements are the basis for the
prosecution. The first is that false documents were received in
regard to the transactions in question and accounts were
allowed to be opened in the name of fictitious persons. The
second is that there occurred a short collection in the
commission due to the bank concerning instant money
transfers through the Manjeri Co-operative Urban Bank
Limited. On account of such unauthorised transactions, which
were against the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India, the
bank allegedly sustained a loss of Rs.3,56,165/-. The further
allegation is that by allowing such unauthorised and illegal
transactions, directions of the RBI were violated and that
invited
a
penalty
of
Rs.5,00,000/-.
Thus,
a
loss
of
Rs.8,56,165/- was occasioned to the Bank.
13.
The offence under Section 13(1)(d) of the PC Act is
said to be constituted since there was a conspiracy between
the accused persons in order to enable accused No.6 to
transact huge sums by instant money transfer facility in the
name of various persons without ensuring payment of the
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
commission due to the bank. The same were the allegations in
C.C. No.122 of 2013 as well. Of course, misuse of the official
position by the officials of the Bank that enabled accused No.
6 to obtain pecuniary advantage and corresponding loss to the
bank were not specifically alleged in that case. However, when
the same were part of the allegations in that case and the
offence of criminal breach of trust was part of allegations,
there is commonality of ingredients of the offences in both
cases.
14.
Viewed so, it has to be said that the ingredients of
the offences for which trial was held in C.C. No.122 of 2013
are also the ingredients of the offences in the present case.
The law laid down in Sangeetaben (supra) is that where an
issue on facts has been tried by a competent court on an
earlier occasion and a finding has been recorded in favour of
the accused, such a finding would constitute an estoppel or
res judicata against the prosecution, not as a bar to the trial
and conviction of the accused for a different or distinct
offence,
but
as
precluding
the
acceptance/reception
of
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
evidence to disturb the findings of the fact when the accused
is tried subsequently for a different offence. The principle of
bar of issue of estoppel is therefore not connected to the
commonality of the offence, but concerning the admissibility
of the evidence which would come to upset the finding of facts
recorded by a competent court in a previous trial. Of course,
in the said case, the Apex Court, based on the findings on
facts, held that there was no bar for a second trial. But the
aforementioned principle of law laid down in that case is
applicable to the instant case inasmuch as the ingredients of
the offence alleged in both cases are the same, except
concerning misuse of official position by the bank officials
including the petitioners who are accused Nos.3 and 8.
Therefore, the said principle applies and a second trial
becomes illegal.
15.
In order to amount an offence under Section 13(1)
(d) of the PC Act, a public servant should have acted in illegal
means with dishonest intention so as to obtain valuable things
or pecuniary advantage for himself or to any other person.
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
Here, the allegation is that on account of the illegal acts of the
petitioners and the other officials in the bank, accused No.6
obtained a pecuniary advantage. The conspiracy hatched
between the accused persons in order to enable accused No. 6
to get such a pecuniary advantage is the allegation. But when
all the accused were tried in C.C. No.122 of 2013 by a
competent court and were acquitted, there cannot be another
trial of them for the offence of same conspiracy again. On
account of that bar, a charge in this case against the
petitioners would only be groundless.
16.
Special
In the above circumstances, the order of the
Court
directing
framing
of
charge
against
the
petitioners is not able to be sustained. The impugned order is
therefore set aside. I make it clear that these findings would
not fetter the Manjeri Co-operative Urban Bank Limited,
Kondotty, to proceed against the erred employees or its
customers for realisation of any loss occasioned to the bank.
It is also made clear that the authorities, such as the Reserve
Bank of India and Cooperative Department will also have
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
every right to take appropriate action in the matter and this
order shall not be a bar.
Accordingly this Crl.M.C. is allowed. Further proceedings
against the petitioners in C.C. No.20 of 2016 on the files of
the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kozhikode are
quashed.
Sd/-
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
dkr
2025:KER:10600
Crl.M.C.No.3702 of 2022
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 3702/2022
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE-1
THE TRUE COPY
DATED 9-9-2006
OF
THE
FINAL
REPORT
ANNEXURE-2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER IN
CRL.M.C.5286 OF 2018 OF THIS HON'BLE
COURT DATED 1-9-2021
ANNEXURE-3
THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
6-5-2022
OF
THE
HON'BLE
ENQUIRY
COMMISSIONER
AND
SPECIAL
JUDGE,
KOZHIKODE
ANNEXURE 4
THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE JUDGMENT
DATED 4-4- 2023 IN C.C. NO. 122 OF
2013 IN THE COURT OF THE JUDICIAL
FIRST CLASS MAGISTRATE, MALAPPURAM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review