The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. A suit can be permitted to be withdrawn with liberty to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of action only when the defect pointed out in the plaint is a formal defect and not a -8NC: 2026:KHC-D:851 WP No. 106044 of 2018 HC-KAR substantial one. Such permission cannot be granted to enable the plaintiff to fill up the gap and cover up the laches.
11. In the instant case, the suit was been filed for declaration and injunction, and the cause of action pleaded in the plaint pertains to the said relief. Now it is the case of the plaintiff / respondent No.1 herein that he never had a cause of action to file a suit for declaration and injunction, but had a cause of action to file a suit for redemption of mortgage. The liberty granted by the trial Court has the effect of permitting the plaintiff / respondent No.1 herein to once again file a suit for declaration and injunction, which is impermissible. Hence, the following: (i) The writ petition is hereby allowed. (ii) The suit in O.S. No.330 of 2009 on the file of the Prl. Senior Civil Judge & JMFC, Hospet stands dismissed reserving the as liberty withdrawn, to the without plaintiff / respondent No.1 herein to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of action. (iii) However, it is clarified that the liberty is always available to the plaintiff / respondent No.1 to institute a fresh suit in respect of the same suit -9NC: 2026:KHC-D:851 WP No. 106044 of 2018 HC-KAR schedule property on some other cause of action, in accordance with law. (iv) The liberty granted to the appellant / respondent No.1 herein in I.A. No.III in R.A. No. 5022 of 2015 to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of action is hereby set aside. (v) R.A. No.5022 of 2015 on the file of III Addl. District & Session…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 23RD DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
WRIT PETITION NO. 106044 OF 2018 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
BYALALU SANNAPPA
S/O. BYALAL ROKKAPPA,
AGED: 59 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: 16/32 WARD,
TALWARKERI AREA,
HOSAPETE, DIST: BALLARI.
… PETITIONER
(BY SRI. VISHWANATH HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
VISHAL
NINGAPPA
PATTIHAL
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench,
Dharwad
1.
B. ABDUL GAFFUR SAB
S/O. ABDUL NABI SAB,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR’S
1A.
SMT. SHEKANABI
W/O. B. ABDUL GAFFUR SAB,
AGED 73 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: HOUSE NO. 583,
BANAKAR ONI MASZID,
I.S.R. ROAD, CHITTAWATGI, HOSAPETE,
DIST: BALLARI – 583 273.
1B.
ABDUL LATIF
S/O. B. ABDUL GAFFUR SAB,
AGED 45 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: HOUSE NO.583,
BANAKAR ONI MASZID,
I.S.R. ROAD, CHITTAWATGI,
HOSAPETE, DIST: BALLARI – 583 273.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
1C.
SHAKEEL AHAMAD
S/O B. ABDUL GAFFUR SAB,
AGED 40 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
I.S.R. ROAD, CHITTWADGI HOSAPETE,
DIST: BALLARI – 583 273.
1D. SHABREEN B W/O. MOHAMMAD RAFIQ,
AGED 46 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: HOUSE NO.583,
BANAKAR ONI MASZID,
I.S.R. ROAD, CHITTAWADGI,
HOSAPETE, DIST: BALLARI – 583 273.
2.
DAVANAGERE MABU SAB
S/O. LATE HUSSAIN SAB,
AGED: 55 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURIST,
C/O: DAVANEGERE HUSSIN SAB,
NEAR PINJAR MASJID,
1ST WARD, CHITTAWADIGI,
HOSAPETE, DIST: BALLARI.
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. K.S. PATIL, ADV. FOR R1 (A TO D);
NOTICE ISSUED TO R2 IS SERVED
BUT UNREPRESENTED)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE WRIT OF
CERTIORARI QUASHING THE ORDER DATED 27.08.2018 ON IA NO.III
IN R.A.NO.5022/2015 ON THE FILE OF III ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE BALLARI, SITTING AT HOSAPETE MARKED AT
ANNEXURE-A. CONSEQUENTLY, THE INTERIM APPLICATION NO. III
FILED UNDER ORDER XXIII RULE 1 (3) OF C.P.C. FILED BY
PLAINTIFF/1ST RESPONDENT IN R.A.NO.5022/2015 ON THE FILE OF III
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE BALLARI, SITTING AT
HOSAPETE BE REJECTED AND ETC.,
THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
B GROUP THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN)
1.
Respondent No.1 / plaintiff filed a suit in O.S. No.330
of 2009 with the following reliefs:
“XII. It is, therefore, prayed that the Honorable
Court be pleased to pass the Decree in favour of the
plaintiff and against the Defendants:(a)
declaring he title of plaintiff to the Land
described in the schedule hereunder:
(b)
Consequently granting permanent Injunction
restraining the Defendants, their agents, relations or
anybody through them from trespassing or dispossessing
the plaintiff from the suit schedule land:
(c)
for costs of the suit;
-and-
(d)
for such other relief or reliefs as
honorable Court deems fit and proper in
circumstances of the case.”
2.
the
the
The petitioner / defendant No.2 and respondent No.2
/ defendant No.1 filed written statements denying the title of the
plaintiff to the suit schedule property. Defendant No.1 claimed to
be the owner of the suit schedule property and contented that he
had subsequently sold the suit schedule property in favour of
defendant No.2.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
3.
The trial Court based on the pleadings, framed the
following issues:
“1.
Does plaintiff proves that, suit schedule property is
ancestral property?
2.
Does plaintiff proves that, he has succeeded the
suit schedule property through the ancestors/or
partition?
3.
Does the plaintiff proves that he is the absolute
owner of the suit schedule property?
4.
Does the plaintiff proves that he is in the peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule
property as on the date of the suit?
5.
Does the plaintiff proves that, the defendant No.1
colluding with the revenue authority got mutated
the suit schedule property in his name without
passing of the title as per law?
6.
Does the defendant No.1 proves that, the change of
khata in his name was legal one?
7.
Does defendants prove that, suit of the plaintiff is
time barred one?
8.
Does the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
declaration of his title over the suit schedule
properly?
9.
Does plaintiff is entitled for the relief of Permanent
Injunction?
10.
What order or decree?”
and issues were answered as follows:
“Issue No.1: In the Negative.
Issue No.2: In the Negative.
Issue No.3: In the Negative.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
Issue No.4: In the Negative.
Issue No.5: In the Negative.
Issue No.6: In the Negative.
Issue No.7: In the Affirmative.
Issue No.8: in the Negative.
Issue No.9: in the Negative.
Issue No.10: As per final order”
4.
The trial Court held that both the plaintiff and
defendant No.1 failed to prove their ownership over the suit
schedule property concerned. However, the suit was dismissed
on the ground that it was barred by limitation.
5.
Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff preferred R.A.
No.5022 of 2015. In the course of the proceedings, the plaintiff /
appellant filed an application under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) before
the First Appellate Court, praying that the original suit be
dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to institute a fresh suit on
the same cause of action. The grounds urged in support of the
said contentions are that the plaintiff, being the owner of the suit
schedule property, had mortgaged the same in favour of
defendant No.1. However, due to ignorance of law, instead of
filing a suit for redemption of mortgage, he filed a suit for
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
declaration and injunction. It was contended that it was not
possible to carry out the necessary amendments in the plaint
and that it is advisable to institute a fresh suit for redemption of
mortgage.
6.
The First Appellate Court agreed with the contentions
of the plaintiff / appellant, allowed the application, and passed
the following order:
“I.A.No. III is allowed.
The plaintiff-appellant is permitted to withdraw the
suit in O.S.No.330/2009 with a liberty to file a fresh suit
on same cause of action.
Regular Appeal in R.A.No.5022/2015 is disposed off
accordingly.
Under the facts and circumstances of the case,
parties are directed to bear their own cost.
Return the lower Court records to the trial Court
along with copy of this order.”
7.
Aggrieved by the same, the present writ petition is
8.
The case of the petitioner is that the original plaintiff
filed.
has admitted that the suit for declaration and injunction was a
mistake and ought not have been filed. However, the impugned
order has the effect of permitting the original plaintiff /
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
respondent No.1 to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of
action for declaration and injunction, which is impermissible. It is
further submitted that
the petitioner
has no
objection if
respondent No.1 is permitted to file a suit for redemption of
mortgage in accordance with law. However, respondent No.1 is
not agreeable for the same. He justifies the impugned order and
prays for dismissal of the writ petition. It is contented that the
defect in the original suit is a formal defect and, therefore, the
impugned order is just and fair. It is further submitted that the
impugned order is in line to make a real inquiry as to the
ownership and secure the interest of justice.
9.
The question that arises for consideration in the
instant writ petition is whether the trial Court was correct in
permitting the plaintiff / appellant to withdraw the original suit
while reserving liberty to institute a fresh suit on the same cause
of action?
10.
A suit can be permitted to be withdrawn with liberty
to institute a fresh suit on the same cause of action only when
the defect pointed out in the plaint is a formal defect and not a
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
substantial one. Such permission cannot be granted to enable
the plaintiff to fill up the gap and cover up the laches.
11.
In the instant case, the suit was been filed for
declaration and injunction, and the cause of action pleaded in the
plaint pertains to the said relief. Now it is the case of the plaintiff
/ respondent No.1 herein that he never had a cause of action to
file a suit for declaration and injunction, but had a cause of
action to file a suit for redemption of mortgage. The liberty
granted by the trial Court has the effect of permitting the plaintiff
/ respondent No.1 herein to once again file a suit for declaration
and injunction, which is impermissible. Hence, the following:
ORDER
(i)
The writ petition is hereby allowed.
(ii)
The suit in O.S. No.330 of 2009 on the file of
the Prl. Senior Civil Judge & JMFC, Hospet
stands
dismissed
reserving
the
as
liberty
withdrawn,
to
the
without
plaintiff
/
respondent No.1 herein to institute a fresh suit
on the same cause of action.
(iii)
However, it is clarified that the liberty is always
available to the plaintiff / respondent No.1 to
institute a fresh suit in respect of the same suit
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:851
WP No. 106044 of 2018
HC-KAR
schedule property on some other cause of
action, in accordance with law.
(iv)
The
liberty
granted
to
the
appellant
/
respondent No.1 herein in I.A. No.III in R.A.
No. 5022 of 2015 to institute a fresh suit on
the same cause of action is hereby set aside.
(v)
R.A. No.5022 of 2015 on the file of III Addl.
District & Sessions Judge, Ballari (Sitting at
Hosapete) also stands dismissed.
Sd/(M.I.ARUN)
JUDGE
VNP / CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review