Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010648972025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3562]
MONDAY, THE 22nd DAY OF JUNE 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
WRIT PETITION NO: 33545/2025
Between:
BUDDIGA DHANA LAKSHMI, W/O DEVEDU, AGED ABOUT
50 YEARS, R/O. D.NO58-17-11 SANJIVAYYA NAGAR VTC
RAJAHMUNDRY (URBAN) EAST GODAWARI
...PETITIONER
2.
AND
1.THE STATE OF AP, REP. BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY,
AP
SECRETARIYAT
BUILDING
VELAGAPUDI
AMARAVATHI. GUNTUR DISTRICT
.
2. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY GENERAL ADMINISTRATION
DEPARTMENT(SC-L)
AP SECRTARIAT VELAGAPUDI
GUNTUR DISTRICT
. 3. THE DISTRICT COLLECTTOR AND
MAGISTRATE, EAST GODAWARI DISTRICT
DISTRICT
4. THE DISTRICT PROHIBITION AND EXCISE OFFICER,
RAJAHMUNDRY, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT.
5. THE
SUPERINTENDENT,
CENTRAL
PRISION
RAJAMAHENDRAVARAM EAST GODAWARI DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. V SRINIVASULA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. THE ADVOCATE GENERAL
The Court made the following:
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
+ WRIT PETITION No.33545 of 2025
% Dated: 22.06.2026
Between:
3.
# Buddiga Dhana lakshmi
..…Petitioner
And
The State of Andhra Pradesh and four others….Respondents
! Counsel for the petitioner
: Sri V.Srinivasulu Reddy
5.
I
^ Counsel for the Respondents : Sri Akula Venkata Sai Jagdeesh,
N THE HIGH COUR
Assistant Government Pleader
< GIST :
> HEAD NOTE :
? Cases referred:
W.P.No.15808 of 2025 dated 03.11.2025
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
WRIT PETITION NO.33545 OF 2025
Between:
4.
……Petitioner
# Buddiga Dhana lakshmi
And
The State of Andhra Pradesh and four others
DATE OF JUDGMENT RESERVED
…….Respondents
: -----
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED:
22.06.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT UPLOADED
03.07.2026
:
Submitted for approval:
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
Yes/No
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Yes/No
Marked to Law Reporters/Journals.
3. Whether Their Lordship wishes
Yes/No
to see the fair copy of the Judgment?
____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
______________________
SUBHENDU SAMANTA, J
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
WRIT PETITION No.33545 of 2025
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari)
Heard Sri V.Srinivasulu Reddy, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Sri Akula Venkata Sai Jagadeesh, learned Assistant
Government Pleader attached to the office of the learned Additional
Advocate General, appearing for the respondents.
2.
This writ petition has been filed for a Writ of Habeas Corpus,
for release of the petitioner, also challenging the order of detention
dated 31.07.2025 passed by the District Collector & District
Magistrate, East Godavari District, Rajamahendravaram, as
affirmed by the State vide G.O.Rt.No.1914, General Administration
(SC-I) Department, dated 17.10.2025.
3.
The order of detention was passed considering seven criminal
cases against the petitioner.
4.
In the said order, the District Collector considered the bail
granted in Crime No.141 of 2024 of Prohibition and Excise Station,
Rajamahendravaram, registered under Section 7B r/w 8(B) of the
A.P.Prohibition Amendment Act, 2020. The order of detention is
also for the maximum period of twelve months.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in all the seven
cases bail was granted to the detenu but this vital information
relating to grant of bails was not placed before the respondent
authorities. Such non-consideration vitiates the order of detention
as also the order of confirmation. He placed reliance in the case of
Ponnada Geetha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh and others
(W.P.No.15808 of 2025 dated 03.11.2025), to contend that if all
the bail orders, in the criminal cases based on which the detention
order has been passed have not been considered that vitiates the
order of detention which becomes illegal and the detenu deserves
to be released from detention.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner referred to para No.10 of the
writ affidavit, which reads as under:
“10.The detention order passed basing on 7
grounds 7 different cases that were registered
against the detenue out of 7 cases the detenue
was granted bails in all cases but this vital
information relating to grant of bail is not placed
before the respondent authority.”
7.
The learned Assistant Government Pleader, referring to the
counter-affidavit filed by respondent No.3, District Collector &
District Magistrate, at para No.10, submits that out of seven cases,
only in one case (Crl.P.No.139 of 2025), the detenu was granted
bail on 27.03.2025 and that was placed before respondent No.2.
He submits that in no other case, the bail was granted prior to
passing of the order of detention. So, the detention order is valid.
8.
Para No.10 of the counter-affidavit of respondent No.3, District
Collector & District Magistrate, reads as under:
“In reply to the allegations contained in Ground No.3&10 of
the affidavit that the 2nd respondent passed the order of
preventive detention against the detenue basing on 7 grounds
and that in all the cases detenue was granted bail and that the
respondents deliberately suppressed the said vital fact of bail
orders and did not place the same before the respondents 1 &
3 are not true and cannot be accepted. It is submitted that
copy of bail order dated 27.03.2025 passed by this
Hon'ble Court in CRLP.No. 139 of 2025 was placed before
the 2nd respondent. Further, out of 7 cases, only in one
case the detenue was granted bail before passing the
order of detention. In all other cases, the detenue was in
judicial as he was produced through PT Warrant in 5 out
of the 7 cases. Therefore, the said contention that bail
orders were not placed before the respondents is not true
and is herewith denied. Further, it is submitted that the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Tamil Nadu and another
Vs. Abdullah Khader Batcha and another reported in 2009 (1)
SCC 333 held that it is the duty of the Court to see whether
non supply of any document is in any way prejudicial to the
case of the detenu. It was further held that merely because
copies of some documents have not been supplied, they
cannot by any stretch of imagination be called as relied upon
documents. While examining whether the non-supply of
documents to the detenu, the court has to examine whether
the detenue would be deprived of making an effective
representation in the absence of a documents.”
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, in the writ
petition itself, the petitioner has given the details of all the seven
criminal cases and the date(s) of the bail granted in para No.3(a) to
(G).
10. Para No.3 (a) to (G) of the grounds of the writ affidavit reads
as follows:
“a. CR.NO.183/2025 registered (S.H.O Rajamahendravaram)
under section 7(B) R/W 8(B) of APP Act in this crime detenue
is A2 in this crime, police personal seized 12.05 liters of ID
liquor from the possession of the accused. in this crime police
arrested the petitioner on pt WARRANT ON 29-07-2025 Bail is
granted ON04-08-2025.
b.
CR.NO.273/2025
registered
(S.H.O
P&E
Rajamahendravaram South) under section 7(B) R/W 8(A) OF
APP Act in this crime detenue is A2, police personal seized
250 Kgs of jaggary and 1600 liters of FJ wash from the
possession of the accused.IN this crime police arrested the
petitioner on PT WARRANT ON 18-07-2025 Bail is granted
ON 24-07-2025.
C.
CR.NO.121 /2025 registered (S.H.O Rajanagaram)
under section 7(B) R/W 8(A) OF APP Act in this crime detenue
is Al, police personal seized 125 liters of id liquor from the
possession of the accused.IN this crime police arrested the
petitioner on PT warrant ON 19-07-2025 Bail is granted ON
23-07-2025.
D.
CR.NO.489 /2025 registered (S.H.O rajanagaram)
under section 7(B) R/W 8(A) OF APP Act in this crime detenue
is Al, police personal seized 10 liters of id liquor from the
possession of the accused.IN this crime police arrested the
petitioner on PT warrant ON 19-07-2025 Bail is granted ON
23-07-2025.
E.
CR.NO.135
/2025
registered
(S.H.O
P&E
Rajamahendravaram) under section 7(B) R/W 8(B) OF APP
Act in this crime detenue is Al, police personal seized 1800
liters of f.j WASH AND 250 kgs of jiggery from the possession
of the accused.IN this crime police arrested the petitioner on
PT warrant ON 29-07-2025 Bail is granted ON 04-08-2025.
F.
CR.NO.194/2025
registered
(S.H.O
P&E
Rajamahendravaram) under section 7(B) R/W 8(B) OF APP
Act in this crime detenue is Al, police personal seized 1800
liters of F.J wash and 250 kgs of jiggery from the possession
of the accused.IN this crime police arrested the petitioner ON
15-07-2025 Bail is granted ON 30-07-2025.
G.
CR.NO.141/2024
registered
(S.H.O
P&E
Rajamahendravaram North) under section 7(B) R/W 8(B) OF
APP Act in this crime detenue is A2,.selling illicit distilled
arrack to public. In this crime this Hon'ble High court granted
anticipatory bail granted but the Respondent authority
deliberately suppressed the said vital fact of bail orders and
that they did not placed before the first and third respondents,”
11. In support of the aforesaid, the petitioner has placed copy of
the bail order of all seven cases along with the memo dated
08.05.2026.
12. A perusal of para No.3 of the writ petition with the memo dated
08.05.2026 shows that 1) in Crime No.273 of 2025 of the Station
House Officer, Prohibition and Excise Station, Rajamahendravaram
South, registered under Section 7(B) r/w 8(A) of the A.P.Prohibition
(Amendment) Act, 2020, the bail was granted on 24.07.2025; 2)
in Crime No.121 of 2025 of Station House Officer, Rajanagaram
also
under
Section
7(B)
r/w
8(A)
of
the
A.P.Prohibition
(Amendment) Act, bail was granted on 23.07.2025; 3) in Crime
No.489 of 2024 of Rajanagaram Police Station, registered under
Section 7(B) r/w 8(A) of the A.P.Prohibition (Amendment) Act, the
bail was granted on 23.07.2025; 4) in Crime No.194 of 2025 of
Prohibition and Excise Police Station, Rajamahendravaram North,
bail was granted on 30.07.2025; 5) in Crime No.183 of 2025 of
Prohibition and Excise Police Station, Rajamahendravaram,
registered under Section 7(B) r/w 8(A) of the A.P.Prohibition
(Amendment) Act, the petitioner was granted bail on 04.08.2025;
and in Crime No.135 of 2025 of Prohibition and Excise Police
Station, Rajamahendravaram, bail was granted on 04.08.2025;
whereas 7) in Crime No.141 of 2024 of Prohibition and Excise
Police Station, Rajamahendravaram North, registered under
Section 7(B) r/w 8(A) of the A.P.Prohibition (Amendment) Act,
anticipatory bail was granted by the High Court on 27.03.2025
in Crl.P.No.139 of 2025.
13. A perusal of the aforesaid further shows that in five cases at
Sl.Nos.B, C, D, F and G bails had been granted prior to passing of
the detention order dated 31.07.2025.
In case at D, bail was
granted on 30.07.2025, so even if that be excluded, in all other four
cases in which bail was granted, deserved consideration by the
District Collector while passing the detention order. Further, in any
case bails were granted in all seven cases before G.O.Rt.No.1481
dated 07.08.2025 and
G.O.Rt.No.1914 dated 17.10.2025 were
issued but there also, there is no consideration of the bails granted
in all seven cases.
14. In Ponnada Geetha (supra), a Coordinate Bench of this Court
has held that when the detenu was already released on bail in a
crime and when it was made basis for passing the order of
preventive detention and when such order of bail was not placed
before the detention authority, it vitiates the order of preventive
detention. Paragraph Nos.(9) to (12) of Ponnada Geetha (supra)
read as under:
“However, as per the settled law, the very fact that the
order of bail granted to the detenu in Crime No.219 of 2024 of
Gopalapatnam Police Station for the offence under NDPS Act,
was not placed before the detaining authority, while passing the
impugned order of detention, by itself, is sufficient to hold that it
vitiates the impugned order of detention. The legal position in
this regard is fairly well settled.
10.
The Division Bench of the common High Court for the
State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh had an
occasion to elaborately deal with the said legal position in the
case of Vasanthu Sumalatha v. State of Andhra
Pradesh(2016) 1 ALT 738 (DB). At paragraph 44 of the said
judgment, it is held as follows:
“44. When a person is enlarged on bail by a competent criminal
court, great caution should be exercised in scrutinizing the validity
of an order of preventive detention, which is based on the very
same charge which is to be tried by the criminal court. (Vijay
Narain Singh v. State of Bihar [(1984) 3 SCC 14]; Jotha
Viswanadh v. Chief Secretary, Govt. of A.P. [Judgment in
W.P.No.10018 of 2012, dated 29.06.2012 (APHC) (DB)]. Where
the detenu is released on bail, and is enjoying his freedom under
the order of the court, the order of bail must be placed before the
detaining authority, when the order of detention is passed, to
enable him to reach a proper satisfaction. (Rushikesh Tanaji
Bhoite v. State of Maharashtra [(2012) 2 SCC 72]. If the detaining
authority was unaware of the order of bail, the detention order is
rendered invalid as the Court cannot attempt to assess in what
manner, and to what extent, consideration of the order granting
bail to the detenu would have effected the satisfaction of the
detaining authority in passing the order of preventive detention
(Rushikesh Tanaji Bhoite (42 supra); Rekha (5 supra); Jotha
Viswanadh (44 supra).”
11.
At paragraph 42 of the said judgment, it is also held by
the Division Bench of the common High Court that it is incumbent
that all vital materials are placed before the detaining authority to
enable him to arrive at the subjective satisfaction as to the
necessity for passing an order of detention, as decided in M.
Ahamedkutty v. Union of India ((1990) 2 SCC 1 and State of
U.P. v. Kamal Kishore Saini(1988 (1) SCC 287). Therefore, it is
held that the bail order is a vital material for consideration and if it
is not considered, the satisfaction of the detaining authority would
be impaired.
12.
Thus, it is obvious from the analogy and the legal
position decided in the aforesaid judgment of the Division Bench
of the common High Court, which is binding on this Court, that
when the detenu was already released on bail in a crime and
when it was made basis for passing the order of preventive
detention and when the said order of bail was not placed before
the detaining authority, it vitiates the impugned order of
preventive detention. Therefore, in view of the law enunciated in
the above judgment, as the order of bail is admittedly not placed
before the 2nd respondent when he has passed the impugned
order of preventive detention, the impugned order of preventive
detention is vitiated and, therefore, cannot be sustained.”
15. The aforesaid is the settled position in law. The bail order and
the conditions of bail are relevant material to be considered to
arrive at the satisfaction if the order of detention is yet to be
passed.
16. Admittedly, there is no consideration of all the bail orders in the
order of detention though in five cases the bail was granted prior to
passing of the order of detention and even in the order of approval
and confirmation by the State there is no consideration whereas by
that time in all seven cases bail (s) had been granted.
17. All the impugned orders deserve to be set aside and the
detenu deserves to be released/set free.
18. The writ petition is allowed, setting aside the impugned order
of preventive detention dated 31.07.2025 passed against the
detenu,
and the
order
of
confirmation by the State
by
G.O.Rt.No.1914, General Administration (SC-I) Department, dated
17.10.2025. The detenu by name Buddiga Devudu shall be
released/set free forthwith on receipt of copy of this order.
19. However, it shall be open for the respondents to reconsider the
matter keeping in view all the bail orders. Since the detenu has
already served detention under the impugned orders for almost
eleven months, in case fresh order is passed on reconsideration,
the detention period shall not exceed twelve(12) months inclusive
of the period of detention already served under the impugned
orders.
20. The District Collector & District Magistrate, East Godavari
District, Rajamahendravaram shall submit his explanation on
affidavit, with respect to para No.10 of the counter-affidavit filed by
him as to why it was so mentioned that there was only one bail
order prior to passing of the order of detention out of seven cases,
though the position with respect to the bail orders granted to the
petitioner was clearly stated in para No.3 of the writ petition, which
clearly showed that in five cases, the petitioner was granted bail
prior to passing of the detention order.
21. Post the matter on 13.07.2026 only for perusal of the
explanation of the District Collector & District Magistrate, East
Godavari District, Rajamahendravaram and if required to pass
necessary orders by this Court on such explanation.
22. As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending if any, shall
stand closed.
____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
______________________
SUBHENDU SAMANTA, J
Date: 22.06.2026
Note:
L.R.Copy to be marked
B/o.
Pab
Whether the order is:
Speaking
Reportable
Reasoned
☑
Non-reportable
☑
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
WRIT PETITION No.33545 of 2025
DATE: 22.06.2026
Pab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review