Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF
DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 02nd December, 2025
%
Pronounced on: 09th February, 2026
CRL.A.1662/2025
+
BSES RAJDHANI POWER LTD.
Having its Registered Office At:
BSES Bhawan, Nehru Place, New Delhi-110019,
and
Its Corporate, Legal and Enforcement Cell,
at Near Andrews Gunj Market, New Delhi-110049
through its Authorised Representative
Mr. Pradeep Baisoya
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Sharique Hussain, Mr. Vikasdeep
Sharma and Ms. Anjani Suri,
Advocates.
Mr. Vijay Yadav, Mr. Rohit Kashyap
and Mr. Shubham Gupta, Advocates.
versus
DEEPAK THAKUR
S/o Vinod Thakur,
C/o Mazdoor Steel Works, RZF-1005, Ambedkar Marg,
Raj Nagar Part-II, Palam, New Delhi-110077.
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Puneet Singh Yadav, Mr. Onkar
Roy and Mr. D.C. Kaushik,
Advocates for R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J
U D G M E N
T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
1.
Appeal under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.P.C’), has been filed on behalf of the
Appellant/ BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. against impugned Order dated
18.01.2021 of learned ASJ, Special Electricity Court, Dwarka, Delhi
whereby the Respondent No.1/ Deepak Thakur, has been acquitted
under Section 135 of Electricity Act, 2003 in CC No.423484/2016.
2.
The brief facts, as narrated in the Complaint, are that on 10.07.2008, a
joint inspection team, comprising of Sh. Awadesh Rai (Sr. Manager
Enforcement), Sh. J. Pal, (DET, Enforcement) and Sh. Ashok Kumar, (Field
Executive, Enforcement), on directions of DGM, Enforcement, inspected the
premises i.e. c/o Mazdoor Steel Works, RZF-1005, Ambedkar Marg, Raj
Nagar Part II, Palam, New Delhi (hereinafter referred as ‘the premises’).
3.
At the time of inspection of the premises, Respondent No.1 Deepak
Thakur was found using electricity. He told the Inspection Team that
Accused No.2 Anil Kumar was the owner of the premises in question.
Inspection Team found that no electricity meter was existing at the site and
Respondents were found to be indulging in direct theft of electricity illegally
by directly tapping it from BSES LV Mains with the help of illegal wires,
which was seized by the team vide Seizure Memo dated 10.07.2008
prepared at site. The Inspection Team assessed the total connected load
running on direct theft supply, as 21.803 KW/NX/DT for non Domestic
Purpose; and Load Report was prepared. Visual footage of the inspection
was recorded by the photographer from M/s Arora Photo Studio.
4.
Inspection Report, Meter details and Load Report in the Form of
Assessment of Connected Load, as well as Seizure Memo, were prepared at
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
site. It was stated that the aforesaid illegal act of the Respondents has caused
wrongful loss to the Complainant Company and wrongful gain to the
Respondents and were thus acting dishonestly.
5.
Thus, it was a case of direct theft of electricity and theft Bill for a sum
of Rs.8,12,523/- with due date as 05.08.2008, as per DERC regulations and
Tariff Order, was raised by the Complainant Company. However,
Respondent failed and neglected to make the payment of the theft bill
amount. Hence, the Company filed the Complainant in the Court of learned
ASJ.
6.
Respondent Deepak Thakur appeared in the Court, against whom
Notice under Section 251 Cr.P.C. for offence under Section 135 of
Electricity Act, 2003, was framed.
7.
However, Accused No.2 Anil Kumar failed to appear and was
declared Proclaimed Offender under Sections 82 and 83 Cr.P.C., vide Order
dated 26.04.2011.
8.
The Complainant examined CW1 Pankaj Tandon, Assistant Manager
(Legal), BSES Rajdhani Power Limited, who had deposed that he had filed
the Complaint Ex.CW1/A and it had his signatures at point A.
9.
CW2 Awdhesh Rai, Member of the Team was examined.
10.
Thereafter, on appreciation of the evidence, the Respondent was
acquitted vide Judgment dated 10.07.2017. Thereafter, Review Application
under Section 157 Electricity Act was filed on behalf of the BSES, which
was allowed vide Order dated 19.12.2017 on the ground that there was a
technical difficulty in viewing the content of the CD. Consequently, the
Judgment dated 10.07.2017 was set aside.
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
11.
Prosecution, in support of its case, examined PW-1 Sh. A. D. Rai, Sr.
Manager, BSES RPL Division O & M Janak Puri, New Delhi, who was the
member of Inspection Team and proved the Inspection Report including the
Sketch, Meter Details, Load Report, Seizer Memo, as Ex.CW-2/1 to 4 and
Compact Disc as Ex.CW-2/5.
12.
PW-2 Sh. Jai Prakash, Videographer from M/s Arora Photo Studio,
deposed that he had prepared the video of the premises as well as of the theft
of electricity and thereafter, handed over the camera along with along with
cassette to Vivek Arora of M/s Arora Photo Studio who downloaded the
data in the office computer and prepared the CD, which is Ex.CW-2/5.
13.
PW-3 Sh. Ajeet Chauhan, deposed that Deepak Thakur was his
tenant in the premises in question from 2005-2008 on a rent without
electricity @ Rs.5,000/- per month. He was running welding work in the
name of Mazdoor Steel Works. There was no one by the name of Anil, who
was claimed to be the owner of the premises.
14.
PW-4 HC Rakesh Chand deposed that he had visited the premises to
execute the summons on the accused persons and recorded the statement of
Sh. Ajeet Chauhan PW-3 as Ex.PW-3/A, wherein Ajeet Chauhan stated that
Deepak Thakur was his tenant and running the workshop. PW-4 conducted
the investigations and prepared the Report as Ex.PW-4/A.
15.
PW-5 Sh. Pankaj Tandon, Sr. Manager (Legal), BSES, filed the
Complaint in question Ex.CW-1/A.
16.
Statement of Respondent Deepak Thakur was recorded under Section
313 Cr.P.C., wherein he stated that he never used the premises in question
for fabrication work in the name of M/s Mazdoor Steel Works. He admitted
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
to be on rent in the premises @ Rs.5,000/- per month and paying the same to
Sh. Satish Solanki, the owner of the premises. He stated that there was a
meter in the premises in question and that there was no theft of electricity.
He further stated that he was a running a Tent house in the name of Sai Tent
House.
17.
In his defence, he examined three witnesses, DW-1 Sh. Manish
Sabharwal, Assistant Finance Officer, Division Palam, Dabri More, BSES
RPL, New Delhi, who proved the final Electricity Bill pertaining to CRN
No.2660170616 of Ms. Sushila wife of Sh. Rajesh Kumar of the premises in
question as Ex.DW-1/A. He also brought the consumer details of the CRN
number and proved the same as Ex.DW-1/B and also proved the CRN
Number, disconnection details and payment details and proved the same as
Ex.DW-1/C to E.
18.
DW-2 Sh. Gyan Chand deposed that he was doing the work of light,
sound and DJ and knew Respondent Deepak Thakur for the last 10-12 years,
as he has been working with him as a Contractor. He deposed that Deepak
Thakur runs his business from the premises belongs to one Sh. Satish
Solanki.
19.
DW-3 Sh. Manoj Kumar deposed that he knew Respondent Deepak
Thakur for the last 10-11 years, as he supplied the Stewart/Waiter to him, in
running his business of tent house.
20.
Learned ASJ considered the testimony of all the witnesses and
observed that there was no evidence to connect the Respondents with the
alleged commissions of offence. No public person was joined in the
investigations to prove that the meter was segregated and dishonest
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
abstraction of electricity was not established. It was further concluded that
there was no evidence to show that Respondents were responsible for
committing the direct theft of the electricity. Therefore, benefit was given
to Respondent, who was acquitted vide impugned Order dated
18.01.2021.
21.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Order of acquittal, present Appeal has
been filed, challenging the impugned Order on the ground that it is against
the provisions of law and the Electricity Act and is based on conjectures and
surmises, as there was cogent /material evidence on record, to prove that the
Respondents were indulging in the direct theft of the Electricity, which was
overlooked.
22.
The mode of theft of electricity as well as the connected load showing
the fabrication work being run from the premises in question, display board
of the shop written as Mazdoor Steel Works, Proprietor Deepak Thakur
along with his Mobile Number and all illegal wires going to the roof top of
the premises, were all recorded in the videography contained in the CD,
Ex.CW-2/5, which have all be overlooked.
23.
Respondent /Accused Deepak Thakur, on the one hand stated that he
was not using the premises, but on the other hand, admitted to the extent that
he used to pay the rent @ Rs.5000/- per month for the premises in question.
It is crystal clear that he was using the inspected premises and had given
false statement.
24.
He claimed himself to be the tenant of Sh. Satish Solanki, who was
never examined as witness, in support of the case.
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
25.
Learned Trial Court, therefore, erred in relying on this record. PW-3
Ajeet Chauhan proved that Respondent / Deepak Thakur was tenant running
fabrication / welding work in the name of Mazdoor Steel Works. PW-3 in
his cross-examination stated that the said premises was temporally
constructed and was let-out for godown purposes. There was no electricity
meter installed at the premises.
26.
DW-1 Sh. Manish Sabharwal, Assistant Finance Officer, Division
Palam, Dabri More, BSES RPL, New Delhi, who was summoned by
Respondent, had produced the record and other documents as Ex.DW-1/A to
E, which were in respect of the some other electricity connection of some
other premises. Furthermore, this Connection was obtained on 19.12.2008,
which was after the inspection on 10.07.2008.
27.
It has not been considered by the learned Trial Court that Respondent
No.1 /Accused had produced the documents before this Court, in respect of
a meter bearing CRN No.2660170616, installed at the premises. However,
bare perusal of the documents reflects that the aforesaid meter does not
pertain to the premises in question and is not in the name of Respondent/
Accused Deepak Thakur. No documents have been placed on record to
prove that he was the user of the premises.
28.
PW-1 Sh. A. D. Rai, Sr. Manager, BSES RPL Division O & M Janak
Puri, New Delhi, in his cross-examination has duly proved that the
electricity theft was being committed by Respondent/ Deepak Thakur. His
testimony was consistent and cogent, who proved the direct theft of
electricity being committed by Respondent. This testimony has also been
overlooked and it has not been appreciated that the witnesses examined by
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
the Appellant Company were not able to show any infirmity in the evidence
that was produced by the Appellant.
29.
Reliance is placed upon Raju vs. BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd., 2016
(231) DLT 152]; Punjab State Electricity Board and Ors. vs. Ashwani
Kumar, (2010) 7 SCC 569; Aditi Engineering Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. vs. State &
Ors., 2018 (3) JCC 1448; Sushil Sharma vs. BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. &
Ors., 2011 (1) JCC 665; and Hiten P. Dalal vs. Bratindranath Banerjee,
(2001) 6 SCC 16.
30.
Moreover, Respondent/ Deepak Thakur has not placed on record the
Bills of the last five years, even of one month, to show that the electricity
was being consumed through duly sanctioned meter of the Appellant
Company. Appellant has proved beyond doubt, that direct theft of electricity
was being committed by Respondent No.1. Therefore, impugned Order
dated 18.01.2021 is liable to be set aside.
31.
Respondent/ Deepak Thakur, in his Reply to the Appeal, has taken
preliminary objection that Inspection Team, which carried inspection on
10.07.2008, was under obligations to carry a Written Authority signed by
designated officer of the licensee, as per Regulations 25(i) of Delhi
Electricity Regulatory Commission (Performance Standards-Metering and
Billing) Regulations, 2002, which they failed to do and no such authority
was placed on record.
32.
Respondent/ Deepak Thakur had not been identified by PW-1 Sh. A.
D. Rai, Sr. Manager, BSES RPL Division O & M Janak Puri, New Delhi,
who was Team Leader and only witness examined by the Complainant
Company to prove the inspection. He deposed that the person, whom the
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
Inspection Team met, disclosed his name as Anil and told that the premises
was being used by one Deepak Thakur as a tenant, however, Identity Card of
Anil was not taken, to clarify his identity. PW-1 did not remember, whether
Deepak Thakur was present on the spot or not. He could not tell the number
of workers working in premises.
33.
There being no proper identification of Respondent/ Deepak Thakur
on the site; he cannot be connected with the alleged offence. No public
witness was joined in the inspection.
34.
Furthermore, PW-1 Sh. A. D. Rai, Sr. Manager, BSES, in his cross-
examination, had admitted that Anil (to whom the Inspection Team met)
refused to sign the Reports. Inspection Team failed to comply with the
mandatory regulations during inspection, which goes against the
Complainant Company.
35.
It is further submitted that as per the Complaint, there were five
members of the Complainant Company in the Inspection Team, out of which
only two, i.e. PW-1 Sh. A. D. Rai, Sr. Manager and PW-2 Sh. Jai Prakash,
Videographer from M/s Arora Photo Studio, were examined. Inspection
Report, Meter details and Load Report, etc. were signed by other members
of Inspection Team also. There is no explanation for non-examination of all
the members of the Inspection Team.
36.
Moreover, these Reports / Documents were never pasted at the site of
the premises, as prescribed in the provisions of Regulation 52(ix) of Delhi
Electricity Supply Code and Performance Standards Regulation, 2007.
37.
Learned Trial Court, after close scrutiny of the CD and the testimony
of the witnesses, rightly concluded that offence of direct theft of electricity
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
had not been established. Admissions made by PW-1 Sh. A. D. Rai, Sr.
Manager, BSES, in his
cross-examination, completely exonerated
Respondent/ Deepak Thakur, as he was not able to identify him as the
person, who was present on the spot.
38.
On merits, all the assertions made in the Appeal have been denied. It
is reiterated that Respondent No.1 / Deepak Thakur has been rightly
acquitted by learned ASJ, Special Electricity Court, vide impugned Order
dated 18.01.2021 and present Appeal is without merit.
Submissions heard and record perused.
39.
As per the Complainant, an Inspection was conducted on 10.07.2018
at 12:35 P.M by the Team comprising of PW1 Sh. A.D. Rai, Sr. Manager,
BSES RPL, Sh. Jatinder Pal-DET, Sh. Ashok Kumar-FE, Sh. Vinod Kumar
Lineman and Sh. Jai Prakash Videographer at the Suit premises. During the
Inspection, the premises were found to be used by the Respondents Deepak
Thakur and Anil, for fabrication work in the name of M/s Mazdoor Steel
Works. There was no electricity meter and direct theft was being committed
by tapping it directly from BSES L V Mains with the help of illegal wires.
The total connected load of 21 KW (approx.) was found in the premises.
The entire inspection was video graphed by PW-2 Sh. Jai Prakash
Photographer and the CD so prepared is Ex.Cw2/5. The illegal wires were
seized vide Seizure Memo Ex.CW2/4. The Inspection Report Ex.CW2/1 was
prepared which was duly signed by them, though the person Anil Kumar
who was found available on the spot, refused to sign the Inspection Report.
40.
The factum of Inspection is also proved by PW2 Jai Prakash
Photographer who was part of the Inspection Team and had videographed
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
the entire scene and CD Ex.2/5 was prepared. However, it cannot be
overlooked that such an electronic evidence required a Certificate under
Section 65B Indian Evidence Act to be admissible in evidence, but no
Certificate has been proved. Therefore, this CD evidence has to be
necessarily discarded.
41.
The first thing which emerges from the cross-examination of PW1
A.D. Rai is that they had met Anil Kumar and Deepak Thakur on the spot,
while as per the Complaint the name of the person using the electricity was
disclosed as Deepak Thakur, while the accused Anil was disclosed as the
owner of the premises in question. PW1 Sh. A.D. Rai, however, deposed
vaguely in his examination-in-chief that when they conducted the
Inspection, it was found that the premises were being used by Deepak
Thakur and that fabrication work in the name of M/s Mazdoor Steel Works
was being carried out and the owner of the premises was one Anil S/o
Jagjeet Singh.
42.
PW1 in his cross-examination while reiterated that the welding work
was going on in the premises and they had met one person who had
disclosed his name as Anil, the owner of the property and that premises were
being used by Deepak Thakur, but he admitted that they did not check the
Identity Card of Anil to verify if he was in fact Anil or not. He further
deposed that he cannot recollect whether Deepak Thakur was present there
or not.
43.
From his Complaint and the testimony of PW1, it emerges that at the
time of Inspection, the Inspection Team met one person who disclosed his
name as Anil. There is no cogent evidence that Deepak Thakur was found
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
present at the time of Inspection. Moreover, this Anil subsequently has been
found to be non-existent.
44.
While the Complainant asserted that he disclosed at the time of the
Inspection, that he was the owner of the property, but PW3 Ajeet Chouhan
in his testimony, had deposed that he was the owner of the property in
question. There is no clear identification either of the person who was
present on the spot or that he was indeed the owner of the property in
question.
45.
The alleged premises are sought to be connected with the welding
work, from the testimony of PW3 Ajeet Chouhan who deposed that Deepak
Thakur was his tenant and was running the welding work in the name of M/s
Majdoor Steel Works. Pertinently, in his cross-examination, he clarified that
the Suit premises had been let out for go-down purposes and there was no
electricity meter installed in the premises. An earlier raid was conducted in
his name and he had paid the penalty. He further deposed that the Accused
used to do welding work in the plot opposite to the rented premises and he
had not given any electricity facility to him. He admitted that for the
welding work, electricity was required.
46.
Thus, what emerges from his testimony is only that the premises,
which was a temporary go-down, had been let out to Deepak Thakur, but the
welding work was not being done from the Suit premises. It only establishes
that though Deepak Thakur was doing the welding work, but it was from the
plot opposite the rented premises. There is a huge discrepancy in the
Complaint of the theft being committed by Deepak Thakur.
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
47.
It is also pertinent to observe that according to the Complainant, there
was a Board installed outside the premises having the name Mazdoor Steel
Work with the name of Deepak and his mobile number. However, merely
because the Board was installed outside the rented premises, cannot be a
cogent proof of the premises being used for the welding purpose, especially
in the light of admission made by PW3 Ajeet Chouhan in his crossexamination.
48.
Another aspect of relevance is that the Seizure Memo vide which the
wires etc. which were used for illegal extraction of electricity was seized,
had the signatures of one Vinod Kumar as a witness. However, this witness
who was most material to prove the Inspection and the alleged electricity
theft, had not been examined by the Complainant. In fact, there is no
explanation about who this Vinod Kumar was.
49.
The Appellants have relied upon Mukesh Rastogi vs. North Delhi
Power Limited, MANU/DE/9575/2004 to assert that where the Inspection
was carried out by a designated Officer under the Notification dated
31.03.2004, and the Members of the Inspection Team visited the site and
had found the electricity being stolen, are competent witnesses to depose in
the Court about the manner in which the theft of electricity was being done.
50.
However, this Judgment is of little assistance because it is not the
competence of PW1 A.D. Rai which has been questioned, but it has been
found that his evidence was not sufficient to establish the identity of
Respondent as being the person committing the theft of electricity.
51.
It may thus, be concluded that there is no evidence beyond reasonable
doubt, that the welding work was indeed being done from the tenanted
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
premises. It is also proved that Deepak Thakur, the Respondent was not
present at the time of Inspection when the alleged theft was detected.
52.
The Respondent though had tried to claim that there was an
Electricity Meter installed at the Suit premises, but the Electricity Bill
Ex.DW1/A and Ex.DW1/B show that it is not in the name of Anil Kumar,
but one Sushila, wife of Rajesh Kumar who was having a shop at the Suit
premises. Also, from the perusal of these two documents, it emerges that the
date of connection was 19.11.2018 which is after the date of Inspection i.e.
10.07.2018. Some tenant or the owner may have got the Electricity
connection in respect of one shop of the Suit premises, but it is a Connection
taken after the Inspection and is of no assistance to the Respondent to
support his assertion that there existed an Electricity Meter in the Suit
premises.
53.
However, the question of considering the defence of the Respondent
would have arisen only if the Prosecution/ Complainant was able to prove its
case against the Respondent. As has already been observed above, it has not
been proved beyond reasonable doubt that Respondent Deepak Thakur was
indeed running the business of welding from the Suit premises or it was he
who was committing the theft of electricity. The benefit of doubt has been
rightly extended by the learned ASJ to the Respondent to acquit him.
54.
There is no merit in the Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
55.
The Appeal stands disposed of along with the pending Application(s).
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEB RUARY 09, 2026/R/VA
CRL.A.1662/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:01:13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review