Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
FA No. 3 of 2022
Mr. Brijender Singh
Date of Decision: 01.03.2023
Vs.
Ms. Sakshi Pandey
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s):
Ms. S. Singha, Adv. with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. with
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The instant first appeal has been preferred under Section 19
and 10 of the Family Courts Act read with Section 28 of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955 against the order dated 18.07.2022, passed by the
Court of the learned Additional District Judge (East Khasi Hills) in
Misc. Case No. 42 (H) 2021 in MAT Divorce Suit No. 12 (H) 2021,
whereby the appellant was directed to pay maintenance pendente lite,
at the rate of Rs. 65,000/- per month to the respondent herein, from the
date she had filed the application for maintenance before the Learned
Court below.
2.
Before the matter could be taken up on its merits, the
maintainability of the instant appeal, has been put to question on the
main ground that the Family Courts Act, 1984 has not been
implemented in the State of Meghalaya, apart from the other ground
that an appeal under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, does not
provide for an appeal from interim orders granting maintenance. As the
objections raised deserve consideration, this Court will therefore first
examine the maintainability of this appeal.
3.
From the side of the appellant, it has been submitted that in
terms of Section 1 (2) of the Family Courts Act, the Act extends to the
whole of India and as such, there is no question that provisions of the
Act, not being applicable to the State of Meghalaya. It has been further
submitted that Section 2 (a) of the Family Courts Act defines a Judge
and contemplates a Civil Judge, hearing family matters and therefore it
is not mandatory, that a physical Family Court exists as per Section 3
of the Act, for the provisions of Family Courts Act to apply. It has also
been urged, that though the Family Courts Act, only makes it mandatory
for a separate Family Court to be established when an area has a
population of more than 1 million, however, Section 3 (1)(b) does not
make it mandatory otherwise, and as such the Act, also contemplates
the concurrent jurisdiction of a Civil Court acting as a Family Court. In
support of this submission, reliance has been placed in the case of Mary
Thomas vs. Dr. K.E. Thomas, a full bench decision of the Madras High
Court decided on 06.10.1989 in O.S.A. No. 21 of 1989, and also a Suo
Motu reference of the High Court of Kerala reported in 2002 SCC
OnLine Ker 305.
4.
Reference has also been made to the Meghalaya High Court
Rules under the Family Courts Act, known as The Family Courts
(High Court of Meghalaya) Rules 2013, to counter the challenge to
maintainability, as also The Hindu Marriage (High Court of
Meghalaya) Rules 2013, which at Section 3(ii) has provided that, Court
means the District Court as mentioned in Section 3(b) of the Hindu
Marriage Act or the Court created under the Family Courts Act. With
regard to the objection to Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955,
it has been contended that, as the Family Courts Act will be applicable,
in terms of Section 20 of the said Act, an interlocutory order under
Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act is appealable.
5.
On behalf of the respondent, it has been contended that
Section 1(3) of the Act mandates that, the Act will be enforced only
after a Notification of the Central Government in the Official Gazette,
as to the dates so appointed is published, and that, no such Gazette
Notification has been issued enforcing the Act in the State of
Meghalaya. It is also submitted that though Section 3(1)(a) makes it
imperative for the establishment of the Family Court for a city or town
having a population exceeding 1 million, the city of Shillong not having
the required population, no Family Court has been established, nor the
State has invoked the power under Section 3(1)(d) to establish the
Family Court for any area in the State. Other provisions of the Family
Courts Act, such as Section 4 on the appointment of Family Court
Judges, Section 7 and 8 on the jurisdiction, Section 13 on the right to
legal representation and Section 19 dealing with appeal and revision
have also been referred to and addressed by the counsel for the
respondent. On the Rules as framed by the Meghalaya High Court, it
has been contended that though the Rules have been made and notified,
the same were incorporated inadvertently in the High Court of
Meghalaya Rules on being replicated from the Gauhati High Court
Rules, which apply only to the Family Courts established in Assam. It
is submitted that; the rules therefore, will be of no consequence as the
Family Courts are yet to be established in the State of Meghalaya.
6.
Reliance has been placed by the respondent counsel on the
case of S.D. Joshi & Ors. vs. High Court of Judicature at Bombay
reported in (2011) 1 SCC 252, on the distinction between the Family
Courts and the Courts presided by Members of the Higher Judicial
Services. With regard to Section 3(ii) of The Hindu Marriage (High
Court of Meghalaya) Rules 2013, it has been argued that the definition
of District Court given therein, means the Court mentioned in Section
3(b) of the Hindu Marriage Act or Family Courts created under the
Family Courts Act, and as the Family Courts Act are yet to be
established, it would mean that District Courts would exercise
jurisdiction. It has also been submitted that, the Family Courts Act does
not contemplate concurrent jurisdiction of a Civil Court acting as a
Family Court, as the same would run counter to Section 8 of the Family
Courts Act, which provides that on the establishment of Family Courts,
all matters pending before the District or Sub-ordinate Courts over
which the Family Court has jurisdiction shall stand transferred to the
said Family Court. It is emphasized by the counsel for the respondent
that in the instant case, the proceedings are pending before a Civil
Court, that is the Court of the Additional District Judge which has no
authority to exercise its powers and functions as per the Family Court
as provided under the Family Courts Act, 1984.
7.
Having considered the submissions of the learned counsels
for the parties. It would be apposite to first examine the relevant
provisions of the Family Courts Act, on the question as to its
applicability to the State of Meghalaya. Section 1 of the Act, which
provides for the extent and manner of implementation, has provided as
follows:
“1.
Short title, extent and commencement.—(1) This
Act may be called the Family Courts Act, 1984.
(2) It extends to the whole of India [***]
(3) It shall come into force on such date as the Central
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
appoint and different dates may be appointed for
different States”.
Establishment of Family Courts is provided in Section 3
and reads as follows:
“3. Establishment of Family Courts.—(1) For the
purpose of exercising the jurisdiction and powers
conferred on a Family Court by this Act, the State
Government, after consultation with the High Court, and
by notification,—
(a) shall, as soon as may be after the
commencement of this Act, established for every
area in the State comprising city or town whose
population exceeds one million, a Family Court;
(b) may establish Family Courts for such other
areas in the State as it may deem necessary.
(2) The State Government shall, after consultation with
the High Court, specify, by notification, the local limits
of the area to which the jurisdiction of a Family Court
shall extend and may, at any time, increase, reduce or
alter such limits”.
8.
A conjoint reading of the abovementioned sections would
show that, though the Act extends to the whole of India, it shall come
into force on such date which is to be notified by the Central
Government in the Official Gazette. A perusal of the bare Act itself
confirms this requirement of Section 1(3) as different States have
different dates on which the Act has been brought into force by such
notification issued by the Central Government. Meghalaya does not
figure in the said list, nor has any notification been issued in this respect.
Section 3 more particularly Section 3(1)(b) of the Act, speaks of the
establishment of Family Courts for such other areas in the State as may
be deemed necessary. This provision allows the establishment of
Family Courts, even if the requirement of Section 3(1)(a) is not met that
is, a population of over 1 million, in an area comprising a city or town.
The above quoted provisions which are essential for implementation of
the Act, not being present, it therefore cannot be inferred that, the
Family Courts Act has been made applicable. Furthermore, there are no
materials to show that, at any point of time the State Government had
initiated any action towards implementing the Act, or to establish
Family Courts, as per the Act.
9.
The position of law in view of the discussion above, being
clear as to the fact that, the Family Courts Act has till date yet to come
into force in the State of Meghalaya, another aspect as has been urged
by the respondents, that it is not a mandatory requirement for the
establishment of a physical Family Court under Section 3, for the Act
to apply, also cannot be sustained, as this would militate against Section
1(3) which mandates that, the Act will come into force only after it is
duly notified by the Central Government. Therefore, the argument that,
the Act contemplates the concurrent jurisdiction of a Civil Court acting
as Family Court is also misplaced and is disregarded.
10.
It is to be noted that, the maintenance pendente lite granted
by the Learned Court below, was in terms of Section 24 of the Hindu
Marriage Act 1955, against which no appeal is provided, as it is interim
in nature, and not a final order in terms of Section 25, which would be
appealable under Section 28 of this Act. The instant appeal apart from
being preferred under Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, has also
been styled to include Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955, but
however, in view of the express provisions as contained in Section 28,
which is quoted hereinbelow, even under Section 28, the Appeal will
not be maintainable.
“28. Appeals from decrees and orders.—(1) All decrees
made by the court in any proceeding under this Act shall,
subject to the provisions of sub-section (3), be appealable
as decrees of the court made in the exercise of its original
civil jurisdiction, and every such appeal shall lie to the
court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the decisions
of the court given in the exercise of its original civil
jurisdiction.
(2) Orders made by the court in any proceeding under
this Act under section 25 or section 26 shall, subject to
the provisions of sub-section (3), be appealable if they are
not interim orders, and every such appeal shall lie to the
court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the decisions
of the court given in exercise of its original civil
jurisdiction.
(3) There shall be no appeal under this section on the
subject of costs only.
(4) Every appeal under this section shall be preferred
within a [period of ninety days] from the date of the
decree or order”.
11.
A rather interesting feature of this case, notwithstanding
the clear non-applicability of the Family Courts Act, 1984 is the fact
that, the Meghalaya High Court as per Section 21 of the Family Courts
Act, has framed rules as per the stipulation of the said section. These
Rules, have been heavily relied upon by the appellant to buttress their
stand that, the Family Courts Act is applicable. In this context, the only
explanation that is acceptable, as pointed out by the counsel for the
respondent is that, with the establishment of the High Court of
Meghalaya in 2013, the rules of the earlier jurisdictional High Court
that is, the Gauhati High Court were replicated, and by inadvertence the
same were incorporated in the rules for the High Court of Meghalaya.
This in the considered view of this Court, will have no bearing or impact
on the instant Appeal, as with the Act not being enforced, whatever
rules made under the rule making provisions of the Act, will be rendered
otiose.
12.
In view of the discussions and findings rendered above, the
Appeal fails on the ground of non-maintainability itself. The authorities
placed by the appellant being of no assistance to the case are not
referred to or discussed.
13.
The instant Appeal accordingly stands dismissed,
however, with no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
01.03.2023
“D. Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review