Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 30th April, 2026
Pronounced on: 6th July, 2026
+
RC.REV. 235/2024 & CM APPL. 64052/2024
SH. BRIJ MOHAN BATTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Himanshu Lilani and Mr.
Siddharth Singh, Advocates.
versus
SH. TARA CHAND GARG & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: None (proceeded ex-parte).
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT SHARMA
JUDGMENT
AMIT SHARMA, J.
1.
The present petition filed under Section 25B (8) of the Delhi Rent
Control Act, 19581, seeks the following prayers: “In light of the facts and circumstances of the case, the Petitioner most
respectfully and humbly prays that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to:a) Set aside the Impugned Judgment / Order dated 08.07.2024passed by
Ms. Tapasya Agarwal, Ld. ACJ/CCJ/ARC District (West), Tis Hazari
Courts InRC/ARC No. 16 of 2013 25664/2016 titled as “Shri Brij Mohan
Batta Vs. Shri Tara Chand Garg &Ors.”.
b) Grant the relief of eviction of the demised premises as prayed for in
the Petition by the Petitioner;
For short, ‘DRCA’
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
Pass such further orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper
in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
2.
By way of the present petition, the petitioner is seeking setting aside of
impugned judgment dated 08.07.2024 passed by learned Additional Rent
Controller, West, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, in RC ARC 16/2013 (25664/16),
titled as, ‘Brij Mohan Batta v. Tara Chand & Sons & Ors.’, whereby, the
eviction petition filed on behalf of the petitioner was dismissed.
3.
At the very outset, it is pertinent to note that during the pendency of
present petition, the petitioner has passed away on 10.01.2026. An
application, CM APPL.11513/2026, under Order XXII Rule 3 read with
Section 151 of the CPC was filed on behalf of the legal representatives of the
deceased petitioner, i.e., his wife, two sons, and one daughter/applicants, and
the same was allowed by learned Joint Registrar (Judicial) vide order dated
20.04.2026 as the deceased petitioner was not survived by any other class-I
legal heirs except the applicants, and right to sue survived in their favour.
4.
It is further pertinent to note that notice was issued to the respondents
in the present petition on 23.09.2024. Subsequently, an application, CM
APPL.64052/2024, under Section 151 of the CPC was filed on behalf of the
petitioner for issuance of notice only against Legal Representative No.1ESunil Garg of the respondent No.1-Tara Chand Garg. Vide order dated
10.02.2025, learned Joint Registrar (Judicial) observed that service is
complete as respondent No.1(A to F) are served and respondent No.2 is
represented through legal representative. However, before Court, none
appeared on behalf of the respondents, on 10.03.2025 and 07.08.2025, despite
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
service. On 13.11.2025, learned Predecessor Bench noted that there was no
appearance on behalf of the respondents despite being duly served, and in
view of the same, they were proceeded ex-parte, and their right to file the
reply was closed.
BRIEF BACKGROUND
5.
The original petitioner-Brij Mohan Batta had filed the subject eviction
petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRCA against the respondent Nos.1, 2,
and 3, who were Late Tara Chand Garg, Late Deep Chand Mittal (in their
capacity as a partners of M/s Tara Chand & Sons), and M/s Tara Chand &
Sons (through its partners respondent Nos.1 and 2). It was stated in the
petition that original petitioner is the owner/landlord of demised premises,
i.e., Shop bearing No.3/14-A, measuring 22’ x 10’, Kirti Nagar, Industrial
Area, New Delhi, as shown in red colour in the site plan attached with the
petition. It was further stated that the property was owned by Late Shri Hari
Chand and the petitioner is the legal heir of Shri Hari Chand. The demised
premises were given on rent on 04.02.1970 to respondent Nos.1 and 2.
6.
It was further stated that the adjoining shop is with the petitioner from
where he is running a catering business. The petitioner had two sons, namely
Nitin Batta, 25 year old, and Ankush Batta, 24 year old. His both sons are
unemployed and the petitioner is unable to manage his food catering business,
due to the fact that he is all alone and requires additional accommodation, i.e.,
demised premises, so that his both sons could sit and run the business. It was
further stated that there is no other suitable accommodation available with the
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
petitioner except demised premises. It was further stated that the petitioner
required the demised premises for his bonafide requirement for the purpose of
settlement of business of his sons, who are unemployed and willing to run
their own businesses from the demised premises.
7.
In leave to defend application filed on behalf of respondent Nos.1 and
3, it was pointed out that respondent No.2-Deep Chand Mittal had died long
back, and if the petitioner wanted to file any petition against said respondent,
then the same should have been filed in the name of his legal
heirs/representatives. During the proceedings before learned ARC, the subject
petition was withdrawn by the petitioner vide statement dated 18.09.2013.
Respondent No.2 was deleted from array of parties by learned ARC vide
order dated 18.01.2016.
8.
Respondent Nos.1 and 3, in their leave to defend application, had stated
that the petitioner had wrongly alleged that he is carrying his catering
business from the adjoining shop. It was pointed out that sad business requires
license from MCD, TIN verification number from VAT Office, service tax
number etc. It was stated that the petitioner is carrying the business of running
Punjabi Rasoi, where food articles are being sold at fixed rates mentioned on
the door. It was stated that the subject property is situated in industrial area.
The petitioner is in possession of one shop situated on the ground floor of the
property, and the construction of entire first and second floor. The entire
construction and shop on ground floor is in possession of the petitioner. It was
the stated that the said construction is lying locked without any use for last
several years and if the petitioner was in necessity of getting any business
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
started for his sons then, the same would have been utilised by him for
running the business for his sons. It was the case of these respondents that the
petitioner had not started any business in the name of his son and same shows
that he has no bonafide requirement.
9.
It was further stated that the petitioner had kept the portion of the
property vacant as his sons are carrying business under the name and style of
‘Om Vanesosa Creations’, dealing in gift items and theme packaging from the
ground floor of property bearing No.41/7. East Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi-26.
It was further state that the sons of the petitioner are carrying on business and
have established the same. Even otherwise, the petitioner is two shops lying
vacant in premises being bearing No.41/7. East Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi-26,
and said shops are lying vacant for last several years without any use and
therefore the petitioner do not require any shop for the business or for his sons
who are gainfully employed in the business run from the shop situated on the
ground floor of the property as noted hereinbefore. It was further stated that
even the mobile number of the son of the petitioner was mentioned. The
petitioner is having sufficient alternate accommodation available at his
disposal, and it has been falsely averred that he has no other reasonable
suitable accommodation except the demised premises. It was further stated
that the petitioner himself is also gainfully employed and do not require any
additional accommodation. Based on these averments in the application
seeking leave to defend application filed by respondent Nos.1 and 3, leave to
defend was granted to the said respondents by learned ARC vide order dated
12.12.2013. Written statement was filed on behalf of these respondents on
10.01.2014. During the pendency of proceedings before learned ARC,
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
respondent No.1-Tara Chand Garg passed away and on an application filed on
behalf of the petitioner under Order XXII Rule 4 read with Section 151 of the
CPC his legal representatives were impleaded on 30.10.2017. Further, vide
order dated 04.12.2017, on account of non-appearance on behalf of legal
representatives of respondent No.1 except for Rewati Garg (1A), and Sunil
Garg (1E), other legal representatives were proceeded ex-parte by learned
ARC.
10.
Learned ARC, after conducting trial and appreciating the material
placed on record, dismissed the eviction petition filed on behalf of the
petitioner vide judgment dated 08.07.2024. Hence, the present petition has
been filed assailing the same.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has made the following submissions
of the latter’s case: i)
It is submitted that learned ARC had dismissed the eviction
petition solely on the premise that the respondent had filed photographs
alleging that a shop was being run under the name and style of ‘Om
Vaneesa Creations’ and the banner in the photograph contained the
mobile number of the son of the petitioner, and it was admitted by the
petitioner only to the extent that the phone number is of one of his sons,
and therefore, there is no bonafide requirement of the demised premises
by the petitioner.
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
ii)
It is submitted that the aforesaid defence taken by original
respondent No.1 was refuted by the petitioner in reply filed to the
written statement filed on behalf of respondent Nos.1 and 3. It is case
of the petitioner that reliance placed on said banner by respondent No.1
is misplaced as the said banner was hung on a closed shop, and said
shop does not belong to the petitioner. It is further submitted that the
shop on which said banner has been put is a part of the property of
petitioner’s brother, and the petitioner does not have any right, title, and
interest in the said property. It is further the case of the petitioner that
the contention with respect to availability of first and second floor of
the petitioner for satisfying the alleged bonafide requirement is bereft
of merit inasmuch as said floors are not conducive for running a
restaurant since customers do not walk upto stairs, and only prefer
gently walking in and out from the shop for their meals.
iii)
It is further the case of the petitioner that respondent No.1 is not
using the demised premises, and the entire shop remains closed on most
of the days, and only a chair and table is placed inside the shop and no
business is being carried out from the demised premises by respondent
No.1.
iv)
It is further submitted that during the course of proceedings,
respondent No.1- Tara Chand Garg had passed away on 11.12.2014,
and despite service, his LRs did not appear before learned ARC, and
were proceeded ex-parte.
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
v)
It has been argued that one of the sons of the petitioner is
working at a restaurant, and another is unemployed. His sons are or not
running any business under the name and style of ‘Om Vaneesa
Creations’ from property bearing No.41/7, East Punjabi Bagh, New
Delhi, however, the said property belongs to petitioner and his brother.
The banner exhibited as Ex. PW1/D2 does not belong to the petitioner
as also his sons and his family. It is further submitted that in the said
property situated at East Punjabi Bagh, only four shops belong to the
petitioner. Out of said four shops, three have been rented by the
petitioner and only one shop is in his possession. It is further submitted
that the photographs placed on record by respondent No.1 of the said
property do not show that sons of petitioner are working in the said
shop. Even LRs of respondent No.1 had not placed on any material to
show that son of petitioner are presently working or not.
vi)
It is further submitted that respondent No.1 had failed to adduce
any document to establish the fact that the demised premises are in
active usage and are not lying vacant. It is pointed out that, LR of
respondent No.1-Sunil Garg (respondent No.1E) in his crossexamination admitted that photographs in respect of the alleged banner
placed on record do not depict that shop in Punjabi Bagh premises is
vacant or not. It is also pointed out that Sunil Garg was also not aware
as to whether business of ‘Om Vaneesa Creations’ is being run by the
sons of the petitioner or not.
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
vii)
It is further the case of the petitioner that mere admission of the
petitioner that mobile No.9212241784 on the banner of ‘Om Vaneesa
Creations’ was of one of his sons does not mean that sons of petitioner
are running business, and neither can it be presumed that property of
petitioner’s brother would be available for satisfying the bonafide
requirement of the petitioner over which he does not have any right title
or interest. It is submitted that learned ARC had failed to appreciate
these facts, and had passed the impugned judgment on the basis of
incorrect appreciation of evidence which has come on record during the
course of trial, and therefore, liable to be set aside.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
12.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the records.
13.
Learned ARC, in the impugned judgment dated 08.07.2024, with
respect to the alternate suitable accommodation available with the petitioner
as well as the bonafide requirement of the petitioner for himself or for any
member of his family dependent upon him, had observed as under: “ 14.
Whether suitable alternate accommodation is available with
the petitioner?
14.1 In his written statement, the respondents have submitted that
the petitioner is in possession of suitable alternate accommodation.
The petitioner is in possession of one shop situated on the ground
floor of property in dispute and the entire first and second floor of
the said property which is lying locked for the last several years.
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
They have further stated that the petitioner also has two vacant
shops at property bearing no.41/7, East Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi.
14.2 It is the case of the petitioner in his replication that his sons
want to open a restaurant from the tenanted premises. He has also
stated that the first floor of the property in dispute is being used as
godown purpose for storing unused articles from his previous
businesses whereas the second floor was rented out to K.C.
Engineering by his father.
14.3 Further, this Court is in agreement with the submission of the
petitioner that the first and second floor may not be conducive for
opening a restaurant since customers do not want to walk up a
flight of stairs and gently preferred quickly walking in and out from
the shop for their meals. Even otherwise, it is settled law that court
cannot dictate which floor should be used by the landlord for his
purpose. Thus, there is no merit in the submission of the respondent
that the first and second floor of the property in question is
available to the petitioner as alternate accommodation.
14.4 As regards the shops at East Punjabi Bagh, the petitioner has
admitted in his cross-examination that out of the 07 shops, 04
belong to him. Out of the 04 shops, 03 are under the occupation of
tenants. No further questions have been put to PW1 regarding the
feasibility of shops at East Punjabi Bagh for his requirement. Thus,
the respondent is unable to prove any suitable alternate
accommodation available with the petitioner.
15.
Petitioner bonafidely requires the tenanted premises for
himself or for any member of his family dependent upon him.
15.1 In order to discuss the bonafide requirement of the petitioner,
it is first relevant to discuss the law as laid down in judgment
passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India titled as Sarla Ahuja v.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 1999 SUPREME COURT
100 wherein it was held that:“.....The crux of the ground envisaged in clause (e) of
Section 14(1) of the Act is that the requirement of the
landlord for occupation of the tenanted premises must be
bona fide. When a landlord asserts that he requires his
building for his own occupation the Rent Controller shall
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
not proceed on the presumption that the requirement is not
bona fide. When other conditions of the clause are satisfied
and when the landlord shows a prima facie case it is open to
the Rent Controller to draw a presumption that the
requirement of the landlord is bona fide. It is often said by
Courts that it is not for the tenant to dictate terms to the
landlord as to how else he can adjust himself without getting
possession of the tenanted premises. While deciding the
question of bonafides of the requirement of the landlord it is
quite unnecessary to make an endeavour as to how else the
landlord could have adjusted himself....”.
15.2 Thus, it is now well settled law that once the landlord shows a
prima facie case, a presumption that his need is bonafide, may be
drawn in his favour. The onus shifts upon the tenant to displace this
presumption.
16. In the facts of the present case, as per the petition filed by the
petitioner, he requires the tenanted premises as both of his sons are
unemployed. The petitioner is running a catering business from the
adjoining shop, but since he is all alone, he is unable to manage the
same and requires additional accommodation so that both his sons
can sit and run the business. What business is sought to be run by
the sons of the petitioner, has not been specified in his petition,
however, there are many judgments of Superior Courts which states
that the petitioner is not required to specifically plead the nature of
business to be run from the tenanted premises.
17. Admittedly, in replication filed by the petitioner to the written
statement of the respondent, the petitioner in Para 18 (a)(iii) stated
that he has closed down the dhaba and started using the adjoining
shop for running denting and painting of car business. Then, in Para
18(a)(vi) of his replication, he has stated that the tenanted premises
is required as the sons of the petitioner intend to run a restaurant
from the tenanted premises. He has further elaborated to say that
the tenanted premises shall be used a kitchen and the other shop
shall be used as sitting area.
18. During his cross-examination, the petitioner stated that he
closed the business of denting and painting of cars in 2018 and
started a partnership of job work from the adjoining shop which
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
stood dissolved due to demise of his partner. Further, in his crossexamination, he also stated that one of his sons is working in a
restaurant while the other is unemployed.
19. Thus, originally, the requirement of the petitioner that he
wants the sons to run the business of catering became infructuous
as admittedly, the petitioner has shifted businesses multiple times
after the filing of the petition. However, this fact alone cannot be
read against the petitioner as the case of the petitioner was
instituted in the year 2012 and he cannot be expected to run any
loss making business for the purposes of petition.
20. From the beginning, the stand taken by the tenant, has been
that the bonafide need of the petitioner is forged and fabricated as
the sons of the petitioner are running a business in the name and
style of Om Vaneesa Creation dealing with gifting and theme
packaging. When confronted with the photographs Ex.PW1/D2
being the photograph of the banner of Om Vaneesa Creation hung
outside a shop, the petitioner first denied that the phone numbers on
the same did not belong to his sons, but he later, admitted that
mobile no.9212241784 belongs to one of his sons. He also admitted
that the shop on which the banner of Om Vaneesa Creation was put,
belong to his brother. I am unable to agree with the petitioner that
the business of Om Vaneesa Creation does not belong to his sons as
the mobile number on the banner is admitted and it is also admitted
that the shop on which the banner is hung, belongs to the brother of
the petitioner.
21. The petitioner has not lodged any complaint with regard to
misuse of his sons’ phone number neither has he produced his
brother as a witness to show that his sons were not running the
business of Om Vaneesa Cration from the shop of petitioner’s
brother.
22. It is not the case of the petitioner that his sons want to wind
up the said business and start a restaurant neither has he pleaded
that his sons want to simply open another business of a restaurant
from the tenanted premises. In his cross, it was stated by RW-1 that
the photograph Ex.PW1/D2 were taken 11 years old. However,
since the very beginning i.e. from reply to respondent’s leave to
defend, the petitioner has categorically denied that his sons are
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
running any other business. Thus, it appears that the petitioner has
not come to the court with free hands.
23. In view of the discussion above, I have no hesitation in
holding that the need of the petitioner appears to be concocted and
fabricated to evict the respondent from the tenanted premises.
24. As the petitioner has not been able to establish his bonafide
need, the petition stands dismissed.
14.
Thus, the learned ARC has dismissed the eviction petition of the
petitioner on the ground that he could not establish the bonafide requirement
of the demised premises. Admittedly, in the eviction petition, the petitioner
had shown his bonafide requirement that the demised premises are required
for both of his sons who are unemployed and the petitioner who is running the
business of Food Catering, is now unable to manage the same due to the fact
that he is all alone, and requires the additional accommodation, i.e., demised
premises, so that both his sons sit and run the business from the said premises.
It is pertinent to note that respondents had, from the very beginning, in their
application for leave to defend had specifically taken the ground that the sons
of the petitioner are carrying business under the name and style of 'Om
Vaneesa Creations' from property bearing No.41/7, East Punjabi Bagh, New
Delhi-26. In support of the application for leave to defend, they had also
placed on record the photographs showing the banner of the said enterprise
bearing the phone and mobile numbers of one of the sons of the petitioner. It
is noted that the respondent's application seeking leave to defend was allowed
vide order dated 12.12.2013 by learned ARC by observing as under: "11 SECOND DEFENCE: -Sons of petitioner already in
business.
11.1 It has been stated by the respondent no.1 and 3 in their
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
application under consideration that the sons of the petitioner are
carrying business under the name and style of Om Vaneesa
Creations and are dealing gift items and theme packaging and
running the said business from the ground floor property bearing
no. 41-7, East Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi.
11.2 The said defence has not been specifically denied by
petitioner in the counter affidavit as he has not specifically denied
in Para 5 of the counter affidavit that his sons are already in the
business in the name and style of 'Om Vaneesa Creations'. On the
other hand the respondent has filed photographs of the said shop in
order to show that the sons of the petitioner are already in business
and in order to raise a triable issue.
11.3 During the course of the arguments it was argued by the ld.
counsel for petitioner that the photographs filed by the respondent
are manipulated and have been taken after installing banner in the
name and style of 'Om Vaneesa Creations' on closed shops.
However, the same is matter of trial and and as such the court
cannot decide merely on the basis of affidavit or counter affidavit
as to whether the photographs are manipulated or not.
11.4 Thus, a triable issue as regards bonafide requirement has been
raised by the respondent."
15.
It is, thus, clear that the aforesaid stand and photographs placed on
record by the respondents were well within the knowledge of the petitioner.
After grant of leave to defend, even in the written statement, the stand of the
respondents was consistent. The relevant averments made in the written
statement filed by respondent Nos.1 and 3 read as under: "18(a)(i) ..........
****
****
****
(VI) .....
****
****
****
The petitioner has kept the portion of the property in dispute
vacant because the sons of the petitioner are carrying business
under the name and style of Om Vaneesa Creation and dealing in
gift items and Theme Packaging which business is being run from
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
the ground floor of the property bearing No.41/7, East Punjabi
Bagh, New Delhi- 26. The said sons of the petitioner are carrying
on the said business and are established in the said business. The
petitioner has kept the portion of the premises in dispute vacant
because sons of the petitioner are gainfully employed in the said
business of Om Vaneesa creation. Even otherwise, the petitioner
has got two shops lying vacant in premises bearing no.41/7, East
Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi and the said shops are lying vacant for
the last several years without any use and the petitioner do not
require any shop for the business shop and the sons of the /
petitioner because sons of the petitioner are gainfully employed in
the business being run from the shop situated on the ground floor of
the said property at East Punjabi Bagh. Even the mobile number of
the sons of the petitioner was mentioned. The petitioner as such is
having sufficient accommodation and the sons of the petitioner are
gainfully employed and as such, the petitioner do not requires any
accommodation for the sons of the petitioner. It has been falsely
alleged that the petitioner has no other reasonably suitable
accommodation available to the petitioner except the present one.
As already submitted the petitioner has got reasonable suitable
alternative commercial accommodation where the petitioner's sons
can carry business activities though, sons of the petitioner are
already gainfully employed in the business of Om Vaneesa
Creation. The petitioner himself is also gainfully employed and the
business of the petitioner is such, which do not require any
additional accommodation. Initially the petitioner was carrying the
business of running the dhabha but now the petitioner has closed
down the said business and started the business of denting and
painting of vehicles. The photographs of location of the property in
dispute and also of the East Punjabi Bagh property have already
been filed on court record."
16.
In these circumstances, it was incumbent upon the petitioner to
establish by way of documents or otherwise to show that the banner shown in
the photographs) exhibited as Ex.PW-1/D2 did not belong to his sons. It is
aptly observed by learned ARC that the petitioner did not even examine his
brother, who, as per the petitioner, was owner of the shop on which the
banner was hung nor did he produce any documents in this regard.
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
17.
Further, learned ARC has rightly observed that it was not the case of
the petitioner that his sons wanted to wind up the said business, and start a
restaurant nor has he pleaded that his sons wanted to open another business of
the restaurant from the demised premises. It is further pertinent to note that
apart from the banner, the respondent had also placed on record a visiting
card, again reflecting the contact number of the petitioner's son which was
exhibited as Ex.RW-1/1 having the same number as reflected in the banner in
the aforesaid photographs (Ex.PW-1/D-2). Thus, the contention of learned
counsel for the petitioner that the learned ARC did not take into account the
statement given by way of evidence to the effect that his sons were not
running the aforesaid 'Om Vanesosa Creations' is not tenable.
18.
The powers of this Court under Section 25B (8) of the DRCA are not as
wide as those of Appellate Court, and in case, it is found that the impugned
orders are according to law and do not suffer from any jurisdictional error,
this Court must refrain from interfering with the same. The power under this
provision is limited and supervisory in nature. Only when, it is evident that
the Rent Controller has committed grave illegality or came to a conclusion
which was not possible, based on the material produced, should this Court
interfere in the order passed by the Rent Controller. In Sarla Ahuja v. United
India Insurance Co. Ltd.2, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had observed and
held as under: "8. …..The satisfaction of the High Court when perusing the
records of the case must be confined to the limited sphere that the
order of the Rent Controller is "according to the law." In other
(1998) 8 SCC 119: AIR 1999 SC 100
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
works, the High Court shall scrutinize the records to ascertain
whether any illegality has been committed by the Rent Controller in
passing the order under Section 25B. It is not permissible for the
High Court in that exercise to come to a different fact finding
unless the finding arrived at by the Rent Controller on the facts is
so unreasonable that no Rent Controller should have reached such a
finding on the materials available."
19.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Abid-Ul-Islam v. Inder Sain Dua3,
with respect to scope of revision under DRA, had observed and held as under:
"Scope of revision
22. We are, in fact, more concerned with the scope and ambit of
the proviso to Section 25-B(8). The proviso creates a distinct and
unequivocal embargo by not providing an appeal against the order
passed by the learned Rent Controller over an application filed
under sub-section (5). The intendment of the legislature is very
clear, which is to remove the appellate remedy and thereafter, a
further second appeal. It is a clear omission that is done by the
legislature consciously through a covenant removing the right of
two stages of appeals.
23. The proviso to Section 25-B(8) gives the High Court
exclusive power of revision against an order of the learned Rent
Controller, being in the nature of superintendence over an inferior
court on the decision-making process, inclusive of procedural
compliance. Thus, the High Court is not expected to substitute and
supplant its views with that of the trial court by exercising the
appellate jurisdiction. Its role is to satisfy itself on the process
adopted. The scope of interference by the High Court is very
restrictive and except in cases where there is an error apparent on
the face of the record, which would only mean that in the absence
of any adjudication per se, the High Court should not venture to
disturb such a decision. There is no need for holding a roving
inquiry in such matters which would otherwise amount to
converting the power of superintendence into that of a regular first
appeal, an act, totally forbidden by the legislature."
(2022) 6 SCC 30: (2022) 3 SCC (Civ) 287: 2022 SCC OnLine SC 419
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
20.
The jurisdiction of the present petition is confined to examining
whether the impugned order suffers from any error apparent on the face of the
record. The Revisional Court cannot reappreciate evidence or substitute its
own view, unless the impugned order is shown to be arbitrary, perverse, or
vitiated by material impropriety. In the absence of such infirmities, there
remains narrow scope for interference with the impugned order.
21.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the present case, no
grounds for interference with the impugned judgment dated 08.07.2024
passed by learned Additional Rent Controller, West, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi,
in RC ARC 16/2013 (25664/16), titled as, ‘Brij Mohan Batta v. Tara Chand
& Sons & Ors.', whereby, the eviction petition filed on behalf of the petitioner
was dismissed, are made out, and the same is, accordingly, upheld.
22.
The present petition is dismissed and disposed of.
23.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of accordingly.
24.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court, forthwith.
AMIT SHARMA
(JUDGE)
JULY 06, 2026/bsr/ns
Digitally Signed
RC.REV. 235/2024
By:SHIWANI NEGI
19:06:51
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review