The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. In view of the discussion above, the present appeal is allowed and the impugned judgment dated 2nd April, 2016 passed by the Trial Court is set aside.
25. The matter is remanded back to the Trial Court and the proceedings in the suit shall recommence from the stage of consideration of the amendment application filed on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff. The Trial Court shall give an opportunity to the appellant/defendant to file a response to the said application and the suit shall proceed from there.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 12th January, 2026
%
+
CM APPL. 54284/2025
IN
RFA 760/2016
BRIJ KISHORE PRASAD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Shlok Chandra and Mr. Parikshit
Singh Bhati, Advocates.
versus
KIRAN DEVI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Yashvir Kumar, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
AMIT BANSAL, J. (Oral)
CM APPL. 54284/2025
1.
This application has been filed seeking early hearing of the present
appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the application, the application is allowed.
The appeal is being taken up for hearing today.
RFA 760/2016
3.
The present first appeal has been filed under Section 96 read with
Order XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking setting
aside of the impugned judgment and decree dated 2 nd April, 2016 passed by
the Additional District Judge-01, South West, Dwarka District Courts, Delhi
in Civil Suit No.3027/2014.
4.
By way of the impugned judgment, the aforesaid suit filed on behalf
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
of the respondent/plaintiff has been decreed and a decree of eviction and
possession has been passed in favour of the respondent/plaintiff and against
the appellant/defendant.
5.
On 18th January, 2017, this Court had noted the submission of the
respondent that in the execution proceedings filed by the respondent for
execution of the impugned judgment, she and her family members have
obtained possession of the suit premises and shifted there. A statement was
given on behalf of the respondent that she would maintain status quo with
regard to the title, possession and construction of the suit premises.
6.
Subsequently, an application being CM APPL. 66347/2023 was
moved on behalf of the respondent seeking permission of the Court to carry
out construction on the roof of the property, which was allowed by this
Court vide order dated 10th September, 2024, subject to approval of the
concerned municipal authorities. However, it was made clear that the
property shall remain subject to the directions to be passed in the present
appeal.
7.
Mr. Shlok Chandra, counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has
drawn attention of the Court to the order passed in the suit on 19 th March,
2016. A perusal of the aforesaid order would show that part arguments in the
suit had been heard on the previous date and the case was fixed for
remaining final arguments. A perusal of the appearances given in the said
order would show that the main counsel of the appellant/defendant was not
present on the said date and only a proxy counsel was present on behalf of
the appellant/defendant.
8.
On the same day, an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code
of Civil procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’) was filed on behalf of the
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
respondent/plaintiff seeking amendment in paragraph nos. 3 and 4 of the
plaint.
9.
The Trial Court has noted the ‘no objection’ of the counsel for the
defendant/appellant and allowed the amendment on the same date itself.
Further, the submission of the counsel for the defendant has also been noted
that the defendant does not wish to file written statement to the amended
plaint. The Trial Court went on to hear the remaining final arguments on the
said date and reserved the judgment, which was pronounced on 2nd April,
2016.
10.
At the outset, a reference may be made to paragraph 3 of the original
plaint, which is set out below:
“3. That the plaintiff is the legal heirs of Late Shiv Nath Prasad and
late Phoolmati, who were the joint owners of the property bearing
No.F-67, Gali No.1, Block-F, Sitapuri, New Delhi (hereinafter called
the suit property) and the mother of the plaintiff namely late Poolmati
died on 20.08.2017 and thereafter, the father of the plaintiff was
residing on the abovesaid property, who was also died on 09th March,
2014.”
[Emphasis supplied]
11.
Now a reference may be made to the proposed paragraph 3 as per the
amendment application:
“3. The Plaintiff is the only legal heir of late Shiv Nath Prasad (her
father) and late Phoolmati (her mother). The Plaintiff and her
mother Late Phoolmati were the joint owners of the suit property
bearing No.F-67, Gali No.1, Block-F, Seetapuri, New Delhi and the
mother of the Plaintiff namely late Phoolmati died on 20.08.2007 and
thereafter the father of the Plaintiff was residing in the suit property
and he also died on 09,03.2014.”
[Emphasis supplied]
12.
It is apparent from the above that the respondent/plaintiff had
materially amended the averments made in paragraph 3 of the original
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
plaint. In the original paragraph 3 of the suit, it was stated that the mother
and the father of the plaintiff/respondent were the joint owners of the suit
property whereas, in the amended paragraph 3, a stand has been taken that
the plaintiff/respondent and her mother were the joint owners of the suit
property.
13.
This is a material amendment that has been allowed by the Trial
Court, that too without giving an opportunity to the appellant/defendant to
file a response to the amendment application. Not only that, it has been
recorded that the defendant/appellant does not wish to file an amended
written statement.
14.
In my considered view, the approach of the Trial Court was
completely erroneous. It has been noted in the appearance section of the
order dated 19th March, 2016 that the main counsel of the appellant is not
available on the said date, yet the Trial Court allowed the amendment
application on the very first date and also closed the right of the defendant to
file an amended written statement to the amended plaint.
15.
Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff submits that
this order was passed in the presence of the appellant/defendant, who was
personally present in Court.
16.
This submission is denied by the counsel for the appellant/defendant,
who submits that the appearance of defendant has been noted incorrectly.
17.
Be that as it may, it is nobody’s case that the appellant/defendant was
legally qualified or was representing himself in the case. The fact of the
matter was that the appellant/defendant was represented by a lawyer, who
was conducting the case on his behalf. The appellant/defendant was not
expected to know the implications arising out of the amendment application.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
Therefore, the Trial Court ought to have granted an opportunity to the
appellant/defendant to file a reply to the said amendment application.
Further, even if the amendment was allowed, the Trial Court ought to have
given an opportunity to the appellant/defendant to file an amended written
statement.
18.
Counsel for the respondent/plaintiff further submits that the
appellant/defendant also accepted the cost of Rs.5,000/- that was imposed
for allowing the amendment on the respondent/plaintiff.
19.
Once again, acceptance of cost of Rs.5,000/- would not alter the
position that the amendment should not have been allowed in the absence of
the main counsel of the appellant/defendant and without giving an
opportunity of filing a reply.
20.
Counsel for the appellant/defendant has also drawn my attention to
paragraph 20 of the impugned judgment wherein, while dealing with Issue
No.1, the Trial Court returned the following finding:
“20. …Even though the defendant has taken a defence that the half
portion of the suit property was sold to him by Mr. Shiv Nath
Prasad, father of the plaintiff, but nothing has come on record as to
how it was sold to him and which particular portion was sold to
him. No such details have been placed on record by the
defendant…”
21.
In this regard, counsel for the appellant/defendant has drawn my
attention to paragraph no.4 of the written statement, which is set out below:
“4. … In reply it is submitted that father of the plaintiff sold the
half portion of the property to the defendant No.1 on dated
09.11.2013 and the relevant paper was executed by the father of
the plaintiff in favour of defendant No.1, which has been seized by
the police officials of P.S. Dabri and seizure memo was issued to
the defendant No.1 on 04.08.2014.”
22.
Clearly, the aforesaid finding of the Trial Court is contrary to the
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
stand taken by the appellant/ defendant in the written statement.
23.
In my considered view, the entire approach of the Trial Court was
opposed to the principles of natural justice and erroneous. The
appellant/defendant was not given a proper opportunity to deal with the
amendment application filed on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff as also to
file an amended written statement. The judgment was also reserved in the
absence of main counsel of the appellant/defendant.
24.
In view of the discussion above, the present appeal is allowed and the
impugned judgment dated 2nd April, 2016 passed by the Trial Court is set
aside.
25.
The matter is remanded back to the Trial Court and the proceedings in
the suit shall recommence from the stage of consideration of the amendment
application filed on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff. The Trial Court shall
give an opportunity to the appellant/defendant to file a response to the said
application and the suit shall proceed from there.
26.
The Registry shall send the necessary records of the case back to the
Trial Court. The parties shall appear before the Trial Court on 9th March,
2026.
27.
In terms of the order passed by this Court on 18th January, 2017, no
third party rights shall be created in the suit property till the final disposal of
the suit.
28.
All pending applications stand disposed of.
AMIT BANSAL, J
JANUARY 12, 2026
Vivek/-
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:50:07
RFA 760/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review