Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 29.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 17222/2025, CM APPL. 70857/2025
BRANCH METRICS INC
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Sachit Jolly, Sr. Adv. with Ms.
Mansha Anand, Mr. Sohum Dua, Mr.
Abhyudaya Bajpyee, Ms. Manvi and
Mr. Ghunain Siddiqui, Advs.
versus
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX
CIRCLE
INTERNATIONAL TAX 1 1 2 NEW DELHI
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Debesh Panda, SSC and Mr.
Vikramaditya Singh, Ms. Zehra Khan,
JSCs
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
By way of the instant writ petition, the petitioner has challenged order
dated 02.05.2025 passed by the office of the Circle Income Tax 1(1)(2)
(hereinafter referred to as ‘competent authority’) deciding petitioner’s
application under Section 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Act of 1961’) and consequential certificate dated
18.06.2025 whereby the respondent has required its counterpart in India to
deduct tax at the rate of 15% on the payments made and credited to the
petitioner.
2.
The petitioner is engaged in the business of providing Software as a
Service ('SaaS') based products/offerings which help its customers in
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
generating links which can be used to share content over social media,
provide links to apps on app-store, links to websites in e-mails, etc. The
customers can also obtain a report (strictly for internal use purpose) in order
to determine the effectiveness of the petitioner’s products. These products
are directly provided to Indian customers under a contract/End User License
Agreement (‘EULA’) and an order form between Indian customers and the
petitioner. The petitioner provides off the shelf SaaS based products to the
customers to install the same in their mobile application/ website.
3.
Assailing the order dated 02.05.2025 and certificate dated 18.06.2025,
Mr. Sachit Jolly, learned senior counsel for the petitioner argued that the
competent authority has passed a mechanical order and has refused to
accede to petitioner’s request for grant of certificate at NIL rate (though the
application mentioned 0.01%).
4.
He submitted that while passing the impugned order, the competent
authority has not at all considered the application that was filed by the
petitioner and the submissions put forward and was merely guided by
revenue’s consideration. Though as per the petitioner, no tax is
applicable/payable by it as the services rendered by the petitioner do not fall
within the ambit for Fees for Included Services (FIS) or Fees for Technical
Services (FTS) as defined in the Act of 1961.
5.
Learned senior counsel submitted that if the treaty between India and
the United States of America (in short ‘US’) is taken into account, more
particularly the protocol thereof, marketing services are out of the ambit of
FIS/FTS and therefore, the order impugned is wholly without application of
mind.
6.
While maintaining that the stance taken by the competent authority is
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
per se erroneous and unsustainable, he argued that the premise on which the
impugned order rests, is the judgment of Authority for Advance Ruling
(AAR) in the case of Shell India Markets (P.) Ltd., In re reported in
[2012] 18 taxmann.com 46 (AAR-New Delhi), completely ignoring the fact
that the same has been overruled by the Bombay High Court in Shell India
Markets Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and Others, [2024] 463 ITR 222
(Bom).
7.
Explaining in detail the nature of transactions, which the petitioner
has undertaken in India, learned Senior counsel submitted that by no stretch
of imagination any tax can be imposed or recovered from the petitioner
which is a company based in USA.
8.
Mr. Debesh Panda, learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent on the other hand submitted that the facts as
portrayed by the petitioner cannot be considered by this Court at this
juncture inasmuch as it is beyond the scope of this Court in its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to record finding about the
nature of transaction as the fact finding exercise is to be done by the
authorities under the Act of 1961.
9.
He further submitted that two assessment orders have been passed by
the Assessing Officer (AO) for Assessment Years (AY) 2021-22 dated
25.10.2023 and AY 2022-23 dated 14.01.2025 and after dealing with the
material on record and taking into consideration the nature of transactions,
the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO) of the petitioner has held its
transactions to be taxable under the Act of 1961 and has levied tax at the rate
of 10%.
10.
He submitted that in the face of the findings as recorded by the AO,
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
order of the competent authority cannot be faulted with, more particularly
when the petitioner-company was paying a 2% levy in the earlier year.
11.
In rejoinder, Mr. Jolly, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the order passed by the AO gives an indication that it follows
the finding of the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), appeal whereagainst is
pending before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to
as ‘Tribunal’) and the judgment has been reserved by the Tribunal.
12.
He submitted that the petitioner is hopeful of succeeding in the appeal
and in any case, the certificate at NIL rate ought to be issued to it, as there is
no possibility that the petitioner would not abide by and deposit any tax
levied under the Act of 1961, subject of course to its right of challenging
such order, if so advised.
13.
As a via-media, it was suggested by Mr. Jolly that for the ensuing
period, including year AY 2026-27, the respondent be directed to issue a
certificate of NIL rate and once the appeal is decided by the Tribunal,
subject of course to rights of either of the parties to challenge the same.
14.
He alternatively submitted that since the petitioner has paid 2%
equalization levy up to 31.03.2025, the respondent be directed to issue a
certificate at the rate of 2% so as to meet the balance of equity.
15.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
16.
Without recording any finding about the taxability of the transactions
or prejudging the issue as to whether the services provided by the petitioner
to the recipient(s) of services situate in India, are exigible to tax under the
Act of 1961 read with the treaty, we are still of the firm view that the order
passed by the competent authority on 02.05.2025 followed by issuance of
certificate dated 18.06.2025 is not in accordance with law.
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
17.
Firstly, because the competent authority has not considered the
application and judgments which the petitioner had cited and has simply
picked up the findings of the AO recorded in the assessment orders for AYs
2021-22 and 2022-23 and secondly, because it has placed strong reliance
upon the judgment rendered by the AAR in the case of Shell India Markets
Private Limited (order dated 12.01.2012 in AAR No. 833 of 2009),
completely ignoring the fact that the same stands overruled by the Bombay
High Court in the appeal filed by said assessee reported in [2024] 463 ITR
222 (Bom).
18.
These two reasons are sufficient to set aside the impugned order
which we hereby do. We are inclined to accept the petitioner’s alternative
plea that a certificate be directed to be issued at 2% rate (equal to the
equalization levy), which a levy or amount the petitioner has been paying up
to 31.03.2025.
19.
The appeal of the petitioner against the order of DRP is pending
before the Tribunal and pronouncement of the order of the Tribunal may
take some more time. In the meanwhile, if at the end of financial year (i.e.
on 31.03.2026), the petitioner’s application for issuance of certificate under
Section 197 of the Act of 1961 shall be rendered redundant. Hence, as a
temporary measure, we direct the competent authority to issue a certificate
under Section 197 of the Act of 1961 at 2% rate. Same shall be issued within
a period of 15 days from today.
20.
The impugned order, purportedly dated as 02.05.2025 and the
certificate dated 18.06.2025 are hereby set aside.
21.
The petition is accordingly partly allowed.
22.
We hereby make it clear that our order shall apply only for the
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
certificate to be issued pursuant to the petitioner’s application for AY 202627 (i.e. FY 2025-26).
23.
For subsequent year(s), the competent authority shall consider the
application in accordance with law subject of course to the order of the
Tribunal. Any of the parties aggrieved with the order of the Tribunal shall
obviously be free to assail the same in accordance with law.
24.
As a parting remark, we would like to highlight that we have often
noticed that the date of the order considering application under Section 197
and the date of issuance of certificate is not same. We are informed that the
order often bears the date on which the application under Section 197 of the
Act of 1961 has been filed. Due to this, an impression is often taken as if the
issuance of the certificate has taken a long time after the application was
processed or decided. The date on the order at multiple occasions bears the
date of application that was filed by the applicant. The responsible
authorities/CBDT are requested to address this issue.
25.
The instant petition along with pending application stands disposed
of.
DINESH MEHTA, J
VINOD KUMAR, J
JANUARY 29, 2026/cd
W.P.(C) 17222/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
11:38:38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review