Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
KABOR Digitally
signed by
AMBA KABORAMB
AM LARSON
M
Date:
LARSO 2023.03.03
13:00:10
+05'30'
N
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
M.A.C. Appeal No.2 of 2021
Ref: M.A.C. Case No.56 of 2017
The Branch Manager New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Chingmeirong,
Imphal West, Manipur.
……. Appellant/s
– Versus –
1. Smt. Sanju Khatiwada aged about 30 years, w/o late Hari Prasad
Khatiwada.
2. Agya Khatiwada aged about 4 years, d/o late Hari Prasad
Khatiwada.
3. Netra Prasd Khatiwada aged about 56 years s/o late Chandra Dutta
Khatiwada.
4. Smt. Shita Devi Khatiwada aged about 53, w/o Netra Prasad
Khatiwada.
All resident of Japhou Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Chandel, District:
Chandel District, Manipur at present Kanglatombi Shantipur
near Durga Mandir, P.O. & P.S. Sekmai, Imphal West,
Manipur.
5. Sukhraj Singh aged about 30 years, s/o Kulwinder Singh of Beltola
Tinali, Dharanpur Path, House No.8 P.O. & P.S. Bashstha
Guwahati, Assam.
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |2
Temporary address at TCP Gate Kohima, Nagaland-797001
(registered owner of the Tata Truck bearing Regn. No. NL01K-0763)
6. Pankaj Sharma aged about 35 years, s/o Juganta Sharma of
Ongurhi P.S. Olani P.O. Koliyabor, District Nagaon, Assam (Driver
of the Tata Truck bearing Regn. No. NL01K07763)
7. The Manager, ICICI Lombard, Lombard House 414 P. Balu Marg,
SVS Road near Siddhivinayak Temple, Prabhadevi, Mumbai,
Maharastra – 400025.
8. Prem Gurung aged about 30 years, s/o Karna Bahadur Gurung of
PR Hill Kohima, Nagaland – 797001.
At present c/o Gopal Gurung AR Colony, Kanglatombi, P.O. &
P.S. Sekmai, Imphal West District, Manipur (registered owner
of the Tata Truck bearing Regd. No.NL01-K4166)
9. Milan Gurung aged about 28 years, s/o Kumar Gurung of Willong
Khullen, P.O. & P.S. Senapati, Senapati District, Manipur. (driver of
the Tata Truck bearing Regn. No. NL01K-4166)
…. Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Appellant
: Mr. A. Denni Sharma, Adv.
For the Respondents
: Mr. H. Dijen Sharma, Adv. for Respondent Nos.1 to 4
Mr. H. Chandrakumar, Adv. for Respondent No.7
Date of Hearing
: 10.02.2023
Date of Judgment &
Order
: 24.02.2023
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |3
JUDGMENT &ORDER
(CAV)
(A. Guneshwar Sharma, J)
This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is
filed against the final judgment and award dated 23.11.2020 passed by the
Ld. Presiding Officer, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Manipur in MAC Case
No.56 of 2017 whereby the Ld. Tribunal directed the appellant herein to pay
a sum of Rs.36,67,500/- (Rupees thirty-six lakhs sixty seven thousand and
five hundred) only to the respondent Nos.1 to 4 for the death of Hari Prasad
Khatiwada who succumbed to his injuries in a road accident that occurred on
06.06.2017 within 60 days from the date of passing of the award along with
interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of filing of the claim case, i.e., from
08.11.2017 till the date of realization.
[2]
The brief fact of the case is that on 06.06.2017, while deceased
Hari Prasad
Khatiwada was returning by riding his TVS Jupiter
Discle(scooter) from Imphal towards his resident at Kanglatombi, he was
knocked down by one Tata Truck bearing Regd. No.NLO1K-0763 which was
also coming from the same direction. At the time of the accident, another
vehicle Tata Truck bearing Regd. No.NLO1K-4166 was also involved. Shri
Hari Prasad Khatiwada got serious injury and later on, succumbed to his
injuries. The present respondent Nos.1 to 4 filed a claim in MAC Case No.56
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |4
of 2017 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Manipur for payment of
compensation for a sum of Rs.45,00,000/- (Rupees forty five lakhs) only for
the death of Shri Hari Prasad Khatiwada. The appellant filed written
statement denying any liability of compensation as the accident happened in
rash and negligent driving of the deceased himself who was driving 2
wheelers at the same time. The learned Tribunal framed 5(five) issues as
given below:
1.
Whether Hari Prasad Khatiwada riding his TVS Jupiter
bearing Regd. No.MN-01AC-7041, registered in his name was
returning back to his residence from his office on 06.06.2017 at
about 5.25 pm and on reaching Sekmai Koujengleima, along NH
2, one Tata Truck bearing Regd. No.NL01K-0763, coming from
the same direction knocked down his vehicle, as a result he
sustained injuries and succumbed to his injuries at the spot, due
to the rash and negligent driving on part of the driver of the said
Tata Truck or was there contributory negligence on part of the
deceased?
2.
Whether the respondents are jointly and severally liable to
pay compensation to the claimants for causing death of the
deceased in the said road traffic accident or not?
3.
Whether Hari Prasad Khatiwada was serving as a Cashier
cum accountant or not?
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |5
4.
What would be the appropriate amount of compensation
liable to be paid to the claimants, who are the dependents of the
deceased?
5.
Reliefs?
Vide impugned judgment and award dated 23.11.2022, the
learned MACT, Manipur directed the appellant to pay a sum of
Rs.36,67,500/- (Rupees thirty six lakhs sixty seven thousand and five
hundred) only to the claimant as compensation along with an interest @ 6%
per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition, i.e., on 08.11.2017.
The details of the compensation is reproduced below:
Sl. No.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
Heads
Salary
50% of (i) to be added as
future prospect
¼th of (ii) to be deducted as
personal expenses of the
deceased
Compensation after
applying age multiplier of 17
Loss of consortium
Loss of care and guidance
for minor children
Funeral expenses
Total
(i+ii+iii+iv+v+vi+vii+viii)
Calculations
Rs.15,000/- per month
Rs.15,000/- + Rs.7500/- = Rs.25,000/Rs.22,500/- - Rs.5625/- = Rs.16,875/16,875/- X 12 X 17 = 34,42,500/Rs.1,00,000/Rs.1,00,000/Rs.25,000/Rs.36,67,500/-
Being aggrieved by the final judgment and award passed by the
MACT, Manipur, the appellant herein filed the present appeal amongst on
the following grounds:
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |6
1. The multiplier in case of a person of 35 years should be 16 and not
17 as calculated and as applied in the impugned judgment.
2. The Ld. Tribunal has strongly deducted ¼th only for personal
expenses which should be 1/3rd as the claimants have failed to prove
that the father of the deceased is depending on him, as father will
not be dependent for calculation of compensation unless proof in
contrary.
3. The learned Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees
one lakh) only for the loss of consortium in violation of the direction
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Pranay Sethi’s Case
which clearly fix at the sum of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand)
only.
4. The Ld. Tribunal has awarded another sum of Rs.1,00,000/(Rupees one lakh) only under the loss of care and guidance of
minor children and Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five) only as funeral
charges in place of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only.
5. The learned Tribunal has failed to give any finding regarding the
negligence of the deceased in the accident and to ascertain the
amount to be deducted for his own fault.
6. The accident happened due to involvement of 2(two) vehicles and
any liability has to be shared between the 2(two) vehicles.
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |7
7. The learned Tribunal has directed the appellant to pay interest @
6% from the date of filing of the case, i.e., on 08.11.2017 whereas
the present case has been long pending due to negligence of the
claimants in producing their witness in time.
[3]
The claimants produced 5(five) PWs including the claimant No.1
and exhibited as many as 17 documents in support of their claim case.
[4]
After hearing the parties and perusing the materials and
documents, the learned Tribunal held that Shri Hari Prasad Khatiwada, aged
about 35 years was knocked down by one Tata Truck bearing Regd. No. NL01K-0763 registered in the name of respondent No.5 and driven by
respondent No.6 which is insured with the appellant due to rash and
negligent driving on the part of the respondent No.6. It is observed that at
the time of the accident, respondent No.6 was having a valid license and the
offending Tata Truck was under the validity of the insurance and respondent
No.3 being insurer of the offending vehicle was held to pay the
compensation amount to the claimants (Respondent Nos.1 to 4).
Accordingly, it was to pay a sum of Rs.36,67,500/- (Rupees thirty six lakhs
sixty seven thousand and five hundred) only.
[5]
Vide order dated 21.10.2021, this Court issued notice to
respondent Nos.1 to 4 appearing on Caveat through Mr. H. Dijen Singh,
learned counsel and it was directed to take steps for respondent Nos.5 to 9
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |8
by speed post. On 04.03.2022, Vakalatnama was filed on behalf of
respondent Nos.5 and 6 and Mr. Th. Jugindro, learned counsel appeared on
behalf of respondent Nos.5 and 6. On 06.04.2022, this Court admitted the
appeal for hearing and the question of maintainability of the appeal to be
considered at the time of hearing and called for the records from MACT,
Manipur. Paper book was ready and the matter was set for hearing.
[6]
Before going to the merit of the case, it will be pertinent to
consider
the
question
of
admissibility
of
the
present
appeal
as
claimant/respondent Nos.1 to 4 have raised the question of maintainability of
the appeal in view of Section 170 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
[7]
Heard Mr. A. Deni Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant,
Mr. H. Dijen Singh, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 4 and Mr. H.
Chandrakumar, learned counsel for respondent No.7.
[8]
Mr. H. Dijen Singh, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 4
submits that in the proceeding before the MACT, Manipur, the appellant has
not taken leave of the Tribunal to defend the case as provided under Section
170 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. It cannot prefer an appeal under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 except for limited grounds and
he prays that the appeal may be dismissed as not maintainable on this
ground alone.
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Page |9
[9]
Mr. A. Deni Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant/insurer
submits that that when the claimants themselves have impleaded the insurer
as a party respondent in the claim case before the learned Tribunal, it can
prefer an appeal without the leave of the Court under Section 170 of the MV
Act. He has differentiated the difference between the insurer who has been
impleaded as party respondent in the claim case before the Tribunal and an
insurer who has been only a noticee. In this regard, he relies on the
judgment of 3(three) Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Shila Datta, (2011)10 SCC 509. He
submits that the present appeal filed under Section 173 of the MV Act
preferred by the insurer is maintainable in the present form, as the insurer
was impleaded as a party-respondent by the claimants themselves before
the Tribunal.
For clear understanding, the relevant Para of Shilla Dutta case
(supra) are reproduced herein below:
“Re : Point (i) : The position in cases where the claimants implead
the insurer as a respondent in the claim petition
13. The scheme of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as contained in Chapters
XI (Insurance of Motor Vehicles against Third-party Risks) and XII (Claims
Tribunals) proceeds on the basis that an insurer need not be impleaded as
a party to the claim proceedings and it should only be issued a statutory
notice under Section 149(2) of the Act so that it can be made liable to pay
the compensation awarded by the Tribunal and also resist the claim on any
one of the grounds mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (2) of
Section 149. Sub-sections (1), (2) and (7) of Section 149 clearly refer to the
insurer being merely a noticee and not a party. Similarly, Sections 158(6),
166(4), 168(1) and 170 clearly provide for and contemplate the insurer
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 10
being merely a noticee for the purposes mentioned in the Act and not being
a party-respondent. Section 170 specifically refers to impleading of insurer
as a party to the claim proceedings.
14. When an insurer is impleaded as a party-respondent to the claim
petition, as contrasted from merely being a noticee under Section 149(2) of
the Act, its rights are significantly different. If the insurer is only a noticee,
it can only raise such of those grounds as are permissible in law under
Section 149(2). But if he is a party-respondent, it can raise, not only those
grounds which are available under Section 149(2), but also all other
grounds that are available to a person against whom a claim is made. It,
therefore, follows that if a claimant impleads the insurer as a partyrespondent, for whatever reason, then as such respondent, the insurer will
be entitled to urge all contentions and grounds which may be available to it.
15. The Act does not require the claimants to implead the insurer as a
party-respondent. But if the claimants choose to implead the insurer as a
party, not being a noticee under Section 149(2), the insurer can urge all
grounds and not necessarily the limited grounds mentioned in Section
149(2) of the Act. If the insurer is already a respondent (having been
impleaded as a party-respondent), it need not seek the permission of the
Tribunal under Section 170 of the Act to raise grounds other than those
mentioned in Section 149(2) of the Act.
16. The entire scheme and structure of Chapters XI and XII is that the
claimant files a claim petition only against the owner and driver and the
Tribunal issues notice to the insurer under Section 149(2) so that it can be
made liable to pay the amount awarded against the insurer and if
necessary, deny liability under the policy of insurance, on any of the
grounds mentioned in Section 149(2). If an insurer is only a noticee and not
a party-respondent, having regard to the decision in Nicolletta Rohtagi 1a, it
can defend the claim only on the grounds mentioned in Section 149(2) and
not any of the other grounds relating to merits available to the insured
respondent. This is the position even where the claim proceedings are
initiated suo motu under Sections 149(7) [sic Section 166(4)] and 158(6) of
the Act, without any formal application by the claimants, as the insurer is
only a noticee under Section 149(2) of the Act.
17. Section 170 of the Act does not contemplate an insurer making an
application for impleadment. Nor does it contemplate the insurer, if he is
already impleaded as a party-respondent by the claimants, making any
application seeking permission to contest the matter on merits. Section 170
proceeds on the assumption that a claim petition is filed by the claimants,
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 11
or is registered suo motu by the Tribunal, with only the owner and driver of
the vehicle as the respondents. It also proceeds on the basis that in such a
proceeding, a statutory notice would have been issued by the Tribunal to
the insurer so that the insurer may know about its future liability in the
claim petition and also resist the claim, on any of the grounds mentioned in
Section 149(2).
18. Section 170 of the Act also assumes that the Tribunal will hold an
inquiry into the claim, where only the claimants and the owner and driver
will be the parties. Section 170 provides that if during the course of such
inquiry, the Tribunal finds and satisfies itself that there is any collusion
between the claimant and the owner/driver or where the owner/driver has
failed to contest the claim, the Tribunal may suo motu, for reasons to be
recorded in writing, direct that the insurer who may be liable in respect of
the claim, who was till then only a noticee, shall be treated as a party to
the proceedings. The insurer so impleaded, without prejudice to the
provisions of Section 149(2), will have the right to contest the claim on all
or any of the grounds that are available to the driver/owner.
19. Therefore, where the insurer is a party-respondent, either on account of
being impleaded as a party by the Tribunal under Section 170 or being
impleaded as a party-respondent by the claimants in the claim petition
voluntarily, it will be entitled to contest the matter by raising all grounds,
without being restricted to the grounds available under Section 149(2) of
the Act. The claim petition is maintainable against the owner and driver
without impleading the insurer as a party.
20. When a statutory notice is issued under Section 149(2) by the Tribunal,
it is clear that such notice is issued not to implead the insurer as a partyrespondent but merely to put it on notice that a claim has been made in
regard to a policy issued by it and that it will have to bear the liability as
and when an award is made in regard to such claim. Therefore, it cannot,
as of right, require that it should be impleaded as a party-respondent. But it
can, however, be made a party-respondent either by the claimants
voluntarily in the claim petition or by the direction of the Tribunal under
Section 170 of the Act. Whatever be the reason or ground for the insurer
being impleaded as a party, once it is a party-respondent, it can raise all
contentions that are available to resist the claim.”
[10]
In the present case, on bare perusal of the impugned judgment
and award passed by the learned MACT, Manipur, it is seen that the
appellant has been impleaded as respondent No.3 in the claim case filed by
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 12
the respondent Nos.1 to 4 herein. As per the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Shila Datta (supra), an insurer who has been impleaded
as a party respondent by the claimants themselves, can prefer an appeal
without taking leave under Section 170 of the Act.
Accordingly, this Court is of the view that the present appeal filed by the
appellant/insurer on merit is maintainable in the present form as it has been
impleaded as a party respondent by the claimants themselves in the
proceeding before the MACT, Manipur. Hence, preliminary issue is decided in
favour of the appellant/insurer.
[11]
Mr A. Deni Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant pointed out
that as per the judgment of Sarla Verma vs. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has recalculated the multiplier applicable according to
the age of the deceased or injured in para 42 as below:
“42. We therefore hold that the multiplier to be used should be as
mentioned in Column (4) of the table above (prepared by applying
Susamma Thomas3, Trilok Chandra4 and Charlie9), which starts
with an operative multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of 15 to 20
and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for every five years, that
is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for 31 to 35 years, M-15 for 36 to
40 years, M-14 for 41 to 45 years, and M-13 for 46 to 50 years,
then reduced by two units for every five years, that is, M-11 for 51
to 55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for 61 to 65 years and M-5
for 66 to 70 years.”
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 13
[12]
The main ground of appeal is that the learned Tribunal has
wrongly applied the appropriate multiplier in respect of a deceased person
aged 35 years. He points out that the appropriate multiplier for 35 years of
age is 16 as given in Para No.42 of the judgment in Sarla Verma v. DTC,
(2009) 6 SCC 121. He points out that in the impugned order of the MACT,
Manipur, multiplier 17 is used for calculating the compensation as such this
multiplier in calculation of total income has to be corrected by this Court.
The next ground of challenge is that loss consortium is
calculated as a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only in the award.
Mr. A. Deni Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant points out to the
judgment of 5(five) Judge Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi (2017)16 SCC 680. The
multiplier calculated at Para 42 of the Sarla Verma (supra) has been
confirmed by the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in Para 59.6 and 59.7 of the judgment in Pranay Sethi (supra). He submits
that appropriate multiplier is 16 not as 17 used by the Ld. Tribunal in the
impugned award.
The next ground of challenge is that the Tribunal had given an
excessive amount towards loss of consortium as Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one
lakh) only. He relies upon the judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra) where in
Para 59.8, it was held that
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 14
“59.8. Reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely, loss
of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be
Rs.15,000. Rs.40,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively. The
aforesaid amounts should be enhanced at the rate of 10% in
every three years.”
[13]
Mr. A. Deni, learned counsel for the appellant points out that only
a sum of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only has been earmarked as
compensation towards loss of consortium and he insists that only this amount
has to be awarded by the Ld. Tribunal. Another ground of challenge is the
compensation towards loss of care and guidance for minor children as
1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only. Mr. A. Deni, learned counsel for the
insurer points out that this head is not mentioned in the schedule appended to
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 nor in the Sarla Verma (supra) nor in the Pranay
Sethi (supra) and this amount have to be deleted while calculating the total
amount of compensation.
[14]
Mr. A. Deni, Ld. Counsel for the appellant further points out that
an excessive amount of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only is
awarded towards funeral expenses. He refers to Para 59.8 of Pranay Sethi
(supra) judgment where an amount of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand)
only is provided towards funeral expenses and he prays that this
compensation for funeral expenses to be reduced.
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 15
However, during the course of hearing, Mr. A. Deni, learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
has
not
addressed
the
question
of
composite/contributory negligence on the part of the deceased. Even though,
it was one of the grounds of appeal, Mr. A. Deni, learned counsel for the
appellant has not addressed the question of negligence on the part of the
deceased. This Court is bound to consider this issue as it is one of the
grounds of appeal. Whenever more than one vehicles are involved in an
accident, the share of respective contributory negligence of all the vehicles
are to be ascertained and the claim amount has to be proportionately
distributed accordingly. In the present case, whole responsibility fixed on Tata
Truck insurer (with the appellant) only.
[15]
This Court has gone through the deposition of PW 2,
Jhomakanta Khatiwada who was eye-witness of the incident. PW 2 states that
when he was standing on the roadside, he saw the deceased Hari Prasad
Khatiwada driving from Imphal side to Kanglatombi at a moderate speed by
his 2(two) wheeler, TVS Jupiter (scooter) and another Tata Truck bearing
Redg. No.NL01K-4166 was also driving at the back of the offending Tata
Truck. At that time, the offending Tata Truck bearing Regd. No.NL-01K-0763
coming from the same direction suddenly knocked down the TVS Jupiter
(scooter) Regd. No.MN01AC 7041 in front of him. Relevant portion of his
deposition is reproduced below:
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 16
“2. That, on 06-06-2017 at about 5.25 p.m. I awaited by standing
road side at the point of opposite of the waiting shed of Sekmai
Koujengleima to come any passenger vehicle for returning my
resident at Kanglatongbi Shantipur after meeting one of my
friend of Sekmai New Market, while I see the deceased Hari
Prasad Khatiwada driven his TVS Jupiter Scooter (Pink in
colour) bearing regd. No. MNO1AC 7041 from Imphal side to
Kanglatongbi side at his moderate speed just passed over from
me the above said Tata Truck (ten wheeler) also driving from
Imphal side towards Dimapur side (same direction) and one
another Tata Truck bearing Regd. No. NLO1K 4166 also driving
at same direction as a back moving vehicle of the aforesaid
involved Tata Truck (ten wheeler). This is true to the best of my
knowledge.
3.
That, suddenly knock down the above said TVS Jupiter
Scooter by the Tata Truck (ten wheeler) bearing Regd. No.
NLO1K 0763 it was occurred in front of me about 60/70 feet as |
immediately ran to the spot of the accident. I found and seen on
the spot the said deceased Hart Prasad Khatiwada felt down on
the road side with unconscious situation and he was very
seriously injured on his person. At that time 7/8 persons of the
locality also arrived on the spot and stopped to drive the said
involved Tata Truck. And the above said one another Tata Truck
bearing Regd. No. NLO1K 4166 which is driving very near as a
back moving vehicle of the said involved Tata Truck (Ten
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 17
wheeler) also stopped to drive. This is true to the best of my
knowledge.”
In the cross-examination by the learned counsel for the
appellant, deposition in examination-in-chief could not be shaken.
[16]
PW 4, I/O of the case also stated in examination-in-chief that the
driver of the Tata Truck bearing registration No.NL-01K-0763 knocked down
the TVS Jupiter 2(two) wheeler. He also stated that in the Mechanical
Inspection Report, the brake pipe was found leakaged and the victim was
wearing his helmet at the time of accident and the accident was due to rash
and negligent driving on the part of the driver of the Truck bearing Regd.
No.NL-01K-0763 and the other Tata Truck bearing Regd. No. NLO1K 4166
was not found negligent and not involved in the accident. During the
investigation, from analysis of the deposition of PW 2 and PW 4, it is seen that
the deceased was driving his 2(two) wheeler TVS Jupiter at a moderate
speed and the offending Truck bearing Regd. No.NL-01K-0763 knocked down
him from behind due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver
also. Accordingly, this Court does not find any infirmities in the finding of the
Ld. MACT, Manipur for the accident which was occurred due to negligent
driving on the part of the driver of the offending Truck bearing Regd. No.NL01K-0763 alone.
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 18
[17]
Shri H. Dijen, learned counsel for the claimant/respondent Nos.1
to 4 fairly admits that the appropriate multiplier would be 16, not 17 as
recorded in the impugned award.
[18]
Regarding the amount awarded as compensation, towards loss
of consortium, Mr. H. Dijen, learned counsel for the respondents/claimants
relies upon the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Param Pal
Sharda and others v. Dhani Ram and others, AIR 2022 SC 4620 in Para 10
wherein the amount of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only was
awarded to each of the claimants.
[19]
Mr. A. Deni, learned counsel for the appellant also submits that
one forth deduction regarding the item at serial No.(iii) of the award should be
one third. He submits that the Ld. Tribunal has wrongly calculated the
standard deduction of one forth towards personal expenses of the deceased.
It is submitted that in absence of any evidence to the effect that father of the
deceased was depending upon the deceased, the father will not be
considered as a dependent of the deceased. He refers to Para Nos.30 and 31
of the judgement in Sarla Verma (supra) in Para 30 and 31 which is
reproduced as under:
“30. Though in some cases the deduction to be made towards
personal and living expenses is calculated on the basis of units
indicated in Trilok Chandra4, the general practice is to apply
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 19
standardised deductions. Having considered several subsequent
decisions of this Court, we are of the view that where the deceased
was married, the deduction towards personal and living expenses
of the deceased, should be one-third (1/3rd) where the number of
dependent family members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4th) where the
number of dependent family members is 4 to 6, and one-fifth (1/5th)
where the number of dependent family members exceeds six.
31. Where the deceased was a bachelor and the claimants are the
parents, the deduction follows a different principle. In regard to
bachelors, normally, 50% is deducted as personal and living
expenses, because it is assumed that a bachelor would tend to
spend more on himself. Even otherwise, there is also the possibility
of his getting married in a short time, in which event the contribution
to the parent(s) and siblings is likely to be cut drastically. Further,
subject to evidence to the contrary, the father is likely to have his
own income and will not be considered as a dependant and the
mother alone will be considered as a dependant. In the absence of
evidence to the contrary, brothers and sisters will not be considered
as dependants, because they will either be independent and
earning, or married, or be dependent on the father.”
He submits that there are 4(four) dependants as per the claim petition
including the father of the deceased. In absence of any evidence regarding
the dependants of the father who is claimant No.3, he will not be considered
as a dependent of the deceased. Hence, there are only 3(three) dependants
of the deceased and 2 to 3 persons as per Para 30 of the Sarla Verma’s
Case (supra), one-third has to be deducted towards personal and living
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 20
expenses. He submits that the item No.(iii) in the award have to be modified
accordingly.
[20]
Mr. H. Dijen, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 4 also
refers to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Raj Bala and
others v. Rakeja Begam and others, AIR 2022 SC 5145. In this case, he
points out relying upon the case of Pranay Sethi (supra), loss of consortium
at the rate of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only was granted to the
spouse and Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only each to the minor
children of the deceased and he prays that items at serial Nos.(v) and (vi) for
loss of consortium and loss of care and guidance for minor children, be
modified.
[21]
Mr. H. Chandrakumar, who appears on behalf of respondent
No.7 has not made any submission as no liability is fixed on respondent No.7.
[22]
Mr. H. Dijen, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 4 has fairly
admitted that the appropriate multiplier for the age of 35 years should be 16
inspite of 17 as applied by the Ld. Tribunal in the award.
[23]
In view of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
cases of Sarla Verma (supra) and Pranay Sethi (supra), it is held that
appropriate multiplier for deceased, aged 35 years should be 16 in place of
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 21
17. Accordingly, item at Sl. No. (iv) head of award the appropriate of multiplier
should be “16”.
[24]
Admittedly, there are 4 (four) claimants in the claim petition
including the wife of the deceased, minor daughter, father of the deceased
and mother of the deceased. On perusal of the materials on record including
the deposition of the claimants specially claimant No.1, there is no
document/statement to the effect that the father of the deceased was
dependent on him. In view of the decision in the case of Sarla Verma (supra)
in Para 30 and 31, claimant No.3/respondent No.3 herein is not a dependant
on the deceased and he will not be entitled to any claim/compensation.
Accordingly, there would be only 3(three) dependants of the deceased. As per
Para 30 of the Sarla Verma Case (supra), 1/3rd (one third) has to be
deducted as personal expenses from the income of the deceased in place of
1/4th (one forth) as applied in Sl.No.(iii) of the Sub Head of the award passed
by the Ld. Tribunal. With respect to loss of consortium given as Rs.1,00,000/(Rupees one lakh) only at Sl.No.(v), it is held that it should be Rs.40,000/(Rupees forty thousand) only as held in the judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)
and this excessive amount of Rs.60,000/- (Rupees sixty thousand) only have
to be deducted. Regarding the award of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only
towards loss of care and guidance for the minor children at Sl.No.(vi) of the
award, it is held that minor children will be entitled to Rs.40,000/- (Rupees
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
P a g e | 22
forty thousand) only each as held in Raj Bala and others v. Rakeja Begam
and others, AIR 2022 SC 5145 in Para 21. In the present case, there is only
one minor children of the deceased as such, she would be entitled to a sum of
Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only towards loss of care and guidance
for minor children. So, excessive amount of 60,000/- (Rupees sixty thousand)
only has to be deducted. Regarding the funeral expenses, a sum of
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only is given at Sl.No.(vii) in the
award. As per the judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra) in Para 59.8, the amount
of funeral expenses is Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only.
Accordingly, this excessive amount of Rs.10,000/- have to be deducted
towards funeral expenses.
[25]
In view of the above findings, the award is re-calculated as
below:
Sl. No.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
Heads
Salary
50% of (i) to be added as
future prospect
1 rd
/3 of (ii) to be deducted as
personal expenses of the
deceased
Compensation after applying
age multiplier of 16
Loss of consortium
Loss of care and guidance
for minor children
Funeral expenses
Total (i+ii+iii+iv+v+vi+vii+viii)
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
Calculations
Rs.15,000/- per month
Rs.15,000/- + Rs.7500/- = Rs.22,500/Rs.22,500/- - Rs.7500/- = Rs.15,000/15,000/- X 12 X 16 = 28,80,000/Rs.40,000/Rs.40,000/Rs.15,000/Rs.29,75,000/-
P a g e | 23
[26]
Accordingly, the appellant is directed to pay a sum of
Rs.29,75,000/- (Rupees twenty nine lakhs and seventy five thousand) only to
respondent Nos.1, 2 and 4 along with interest @ 6% from the date of filing the
claim case. Since the appellant/the insurer has failed to prove the negligence
on the part of the claimants/respondents 1, 2 and 4 in pursuing their case
before the Ld. Tribunal, the date of effecting interests is not altered.
Respondent Nos.1, 2 & 4 are entitled to the amount of award of
Rs.29,75,000/- in equal shares. The share of the minor respondent No.2 shall
be kept as fixed deposit in a scheduled bank till she attains the age of
minority. No withdrawal shall be made from the fixed deposit amount made in
favour of the minor respondent No.2 without leave of the Ld. Tribunal.
[27]
The appeal is partly allowed and disposed of in terms of the
above findings. The parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
-Larson
MAC Appeal No.2 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review