Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
BRAJENDRA SINGH MANN
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Swastik Singh and Mr. Manish
B., Advocates.
versus
DY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Tushar Sannu, Ms. Palak Gupta
and Mr. F. Rehman, Advocates for
GNCTD.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
22.01.2026
%
THE FACTS:
1.
The Petitioner claims that he purchased a plot falling in Khasra No.
25 (4-16), Village Neb Sarai, New Delhi, from one Vidyawati Gusain on
21st June, 1989. The asserted title is founded on documents which includes a
Special Power of Attorney, General Power of Attorney and a Will. The
Petitioner also claims to have been placed in possession pursuant thereto.
2.
The Petitioner’s grievance arose on 26th June, 2008, when officials of
Respondent No. 1 allegedly visited the site and informed him that the land in
question had been notified as part of the ridge area for creation of reserved
forest vide notification No. F.1(29)/PA/DC/95 dated 2nd April, 1996. The
officials indicated that they would take over possession of Plot No. D194(A), which the Petitioner asserts forms part of the said Khasra.
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
3.
The Petitioner asserts that the said Khasra has been extensively built
upon and that a substantial portion of persons (more than 80% of plotholders) have raised residential constructions long ago. He further claims to
have informed the officials that the plot falls within a colony described as
“Freedom Fighters Enclave”, which was under consideration for
regularisation. However, owing to resistance from neighbouring occupants
and local protest, the officials did not take possession at that stage.
4.
The Petitioner further states that he subsequently became aware of a
notification issued under Section 154 of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954, 1
whereby uncultivated land of the Gaon Sabha falling in the Southern Ridge,
including Village Neb Sarai, measuring 466 bighas 10 biswas, was notified
for ridge purposes, and that the land comprised in Khasra No. 25 (4-16) was
covered by that notification.
5.
On approaching the revenue authorities, the Petitioner discovered that
proceedings under Section 81 of DLR Act had been instituted against Tara
Chand, shown as the recorded bhumidar in the revenue record, in respect of
Khasra No. 25 (4-16) in the revenue estate of Village Neb Sarai. It is stated
that by order dated 24th May, 1994 passed by the Revenue Assistant (South)
in Case No. 184/RA/88 titled Gaon Sabha Neb Sarai v. Tara Chand, the
recorded bhumidar was directed to reconvert the land to agricultural use
within three months, failing which the land was to vest in the Gaon Sabha. It
is further stated that upon non-compliance, the land stood vested in the Gaon
Sabha with effect from 24th August, 1994.
6.
The Petitioner contends that neither he, nor any other occupants of
plots carved out of the said Khasra number, were ever issued any notice or
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
intimation at any stage. Despite his possession over the plot, the land was
notified for creation of reserved forest without affording the Petitioner any
opportunity of hearing.
7.
In that backdrop, on 1st July, 2008 the Petitioner moved an application
before the Forest Settlement Officer/ADM (South) appointed under
Notification No. F.10(42)-I/PA/DCF/93/II dated Nil May, 2006 issued by
the Secretary (Environment, Forest and Wild Life), Government of NCT of
Delhi, to inquire into and determine the existence, nature and extent of
alleged rights in respect of land notified for creation of reserved forest.
8.
The Petitioner’s application was rejected by order dated 2 nd
December, 2009. He thereafter preferred an appeal under Section 17 of the
Indian Forest Act, 1927 before the Divisional Commissioner, and then a
further appeal under Section 18 before the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi,
which was rejected by order dated 2nd March, 2016.
9.
In these circumstances, the present writ petition has been instituted.
PETITIONER’S CONTENTIONS:
10.
Counsel for the Petitioner advances several submissions which are
summarised as follows:
10.1. The impugned orders passed by the Forest Settlement Officer, the
Divisional Commissioner and the Lieutenant Governor are illegal, arbitrary
and contrary to settled principles of law. The rejection proceeds on a narrow
view of jurisdiction and an undue refusal to examine the substance of the
asserted rights.
10.2. The land in question forms part of “Freedom Fighters Enclave”, an
unauthorised colony under consideration for regularisation, and the
“DLR Act”
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
Petitioner has remained in continuous possession of the plot since its
purchase in 1989.
10.3. The land is private and the authorities have erred in treating the same
as Gaon Sabha land. The inclusion in the ridge/forest is, therefore, unlawful.
10.4. The impugned proceedings were conducted in violation of principles
natural justice. In the Section 81 proceedings culminating in vesting, neither
the Petitioner, nor other occupants were heard, despite alleged occupation
and development. Further, the ridge/forest notification proceeded without
any meaningful notice or opportunity to affected occupants.
10.5. The Forest Settlement Officer could not have declined to entertain the
Petitioner’s claim on the ground of jurisdiction, particularly when the officer
was appointed precisely to inquire into claims in respect of land notified for
creation of reserved forest.
10.6. The action of the authorities is discriminatory and violative of Article
14 of the Constitution. Similarly situated persons in cases such as T.C. v.
DCF (South), Shankar Sahni v. DCF (South) and Azad Kaur v. DCF
(South), arising out of the same ridge notification dated 2 nd April, 1996,
have been granted relief by the Forest Settlement Officer, whereas the
Petitioner’s application was rejected without adjudication on merits.
10.7. The Petitioner also relies upon the notification dated 12 th December,
2007 issued by the Government of NCT of Delhi, to contend that where land
is vested in the Gaon Sabha under Section 81 of the DLR Act, but
possession has not been taken, shall be treated as private land. The subject
plot ought not to be treated as Gaon Sabha/forest land when possession
remained with occupants.
10.8. Reliance is placed on the Supreme Court’s environmental
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
jurisprudence in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India2 to submit that the scheme
was directed at protecting the ridge, yet it did not authorise a mechanical
sweep that converts an already built-up colony into “forest land” without
examining whether it is truly “uncultivated surplus Gaon Sabha land” of the
kind contemplated in the directions and the consequent notification.
Respondents’ Contentions:
11.
Per contra, counsel for the Respondents opposes the petition on the
following grounds:
11.1. The Petitioner lacks locus standi, as the documents relied upon by
him, including GPA/SPA/Will, do not confer legal title or ownership rights
in the subject land. At the highest, they create an asserted arrangement or a
claim of possession that cannot displace statutory vesting and forest
notifications.
11.2. Proceedings under Section 81 of the DLR Act were initiated in 1988
against the recorded bhumidar, who duly participated therein. These
proceedings culminated in an order directing reconversion of the land to
agricultural use, failing which the land stood vested in the Gaon Sabha. The
vesting order cannot be collaterally questioned in these proceedings.
11.3. The alleged transfer in favour of the Petitioner took place during
pendency of the aforesaid proceedings and, in any event, transfer of rights in
such land is restricted under the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954.
11.4. Pursuant to directions of the Supreme Court in M.C. Mehta v. Union
of India, uncultivated surplus Gaon Sabha land falling in the ridge area was
notified vide notification dated 2nd April, 1996, including the present Khasra
number, and the land was placed at the disposal of the Forest Department for
Writ Petition (C) 4677 of 85
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
purposes of creation of reserved forest/ridge forest.
11.5. Once a notification is issued under the Indian Forest Act, 1927,
Section 5 operates as a bar against acquisition of fresh rights in respect of
such land, and the Petitioner has no lawful claim over the notified forest
land.
11.6. Khasra No. 25 of Village Neb Sarai is a notified forest land and was
handed over to the Forest Department by the Gaon Sabha. Any construction
or development claimed by the Petitioner is unauthorised and contrary to the
provisions of the Indian Forest Act, 1927.
11.7. The impugned orders are reasoned and call for no interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution.
ANALYSIS:
12.
The controversy, at its core, turns on whether the Petitioner
demonstrates a legally cognisable right in the land which could survive the
consequences of vesting under the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 and
could, thereafter, sustain a claim before the forest settlement authorities
against the ridge/forest notification regime.
13.
The record reveals that proceedings under Section 81 of the DLR
Act, were initiated in the year 1988 against the recorded bhumidar Tara
Chand, in Case No. 184/RA/88 titled Gaon Sabha Neb Sarai v. Tara
Chand and culminated in an order dated 24th May, 1994, holding as
follows:
“O R D E R
This order shall dispose of the proceedings u/s 81 of DLR Act.
The case was instituted on the basis of the patwari report dated 6.4.88
stating
that
the
land
bearing
khasra
No.:
(4-
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx situated in the revenue estate of Village
Neb Sarai has been used for non agricultural purposes. Notices were
issued to both the parties. Counsel for respondent filed his reply on
13.6.88.
On 24.5.94 the undersigned alongwith the area Patwari and other
revenue staffs inspected the land bearing khasra number mentioned
above situated in the village Neb Sarai and it was revealed that
construction is going on and construction materials are lying in the suit
land and as such the land is used for non agricultural purposes.
Accordingly I, Namita Datta, SDM/RA (South) hereby through
this order direct the abovementioned Respondents to reconvert back the
above suit land to agricultural use within a period of three months from
the date of this order failing which the said land shall stand vested in
Gaon Sabha and the Respondent liable to be ejected therefrom. Ordered
accordingly. Tehsildar (Mehrauli) to act accordingly. A copy of this
order be also sent to Director (P) for information.
Announced in the open court and given under my hand and seal of
this court on this 24th day of May 1994.”
14.
The order extracted above records that notices were issued, a site
inspection was conducted, and the Revenue Assistant found that the land
was being used for non-agricultural purposes with construction activity. The
Revenue Assistant directed reconversion of the land to agricultural use
within three months, failing which vesting in the Gaon Sabha would follow.
15.
The Petitioner’s documents are dated 21st June, 1989. On his showing,
therefore, his alleged acquisition is during the pendency of the Section 81
proceedings. A transferee pendente lite cannot, in a collateral proceeding,
reopen the foundational consequences of a proceeding to which the recorded
tenure holder was party, without first impeaching that foundation in
accordance with law. The forest settlement process is not a forum to set at
naught the consequences of a subsisting revenue adjudication under the
DLR Act. The Petitioner’s grievance regarding non-disclosure of pending
proceedings by the transferor, even if assumed, does not translate into an
enforceable public law right to compel de-notification of forest/ridge land.
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
16.
The Petitioner’s emphasis on lack of notice must be examined in this
context. The Section 81 proceedings were instituted against the recorded
bhumidar. That is the person whom the statute recognises for notice and
participation. The Petitioner’s claimed entry into the land is derivative and is
asserted to have occurred during pendency of those proceedings. In that
setting, the argument that the entire vesting consequence must be ignored
because the Petitioner did not receive personal notice cannot be accepted,
particularly where the vesting order itself remains unchallenged.
17.
Once the land is treated as Gaon Sabha land pursuant to a subsisting
vesting order, the impugned notification operates on that legal status. The
Lieutenant Governor, in the appellate order dated 2 nd March, 2016, accepted
the position that the Delhi Land Reforms Act does not carve out a distinction
between “original” Gaon Sabha land and “vested” Gaon Sabha land, and
held that, unless the vesting is set aside, the land continues to bear that
character, thereby attracting the ridge/forest notification consequences. That
approach does not disclose an error of law. The relevant portion of the order
reads as under:
“Order dated 02.03.2016.
(Najeeb Jung, L.G.)
This is an appeal under section 18 of the Indian Forest Act (in
short called the Forest Act) against the impugned order dated
03.09.2015, passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Govt. of NCT of
Delhi, thereby dismissing the appellant's application for de-notification
of Khasra No. 25(4-16) of village Neb Sarai.
Matter came up for hearing on 03.02.2016. On behalf of the
appellant, Counsel stated that one Shri Tara Chand S/o Shri Kacheru R/o
Village Neb Sarai, Delhi had been the recorded bhumidar of the land
bearing khasra no. 25(4-16) in the revenue estate of village Neb Sarai.
He stated that in the year 1985-86 a registered society namely
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
Freedom Fighters Cultural Centre purchased large agricultural land in
the said village including the land comprising in khasra no. 25(4-16). He
stated that the said society carved out plots on the land and a plot
bearing no. D-194 (A) measuring 200 sq. yards had been allotted to one
of the members of the society namely Smt. Vidyawati Gusain on
21.12.1986, which was purchased by the appellant on 21.06.1989.
Counsel stated that the actual physical possession of the plot had been
handed by the allottee to the appellant on the spot and the appellant after
raising some temporary structure on the plot had been in continuous
possession since then.
Counsel for the appellant stated that on 26.06.2008 the officials of
the Forest department came to the appellant's plot and informed that they
had come to take possession as the land had been notified in ridge area
for creation of reserve forest vide notification dated 02.04.1996. He
stated that thereafter on enquiry from the revenue department the
appellant came to know that the land bearing khasra no. 25 (4-16) had
been vested in Gaon Sabha under section 81 of the Delhi Land Reforms
Act vide order dated 24.08.1994 passed by the Revenue Assistant (South).
Counsel stated that no notice had ever been issued to the appellant or
any other occupant of the plot at any point of time and the land had been
notified as reserve forest without providing any opportunity of hearing to
the appellant. He stated that the appellant approached the ADM
(South)/Forest Settlement Officer with an application for de-notification
of khasra no. 25(4-16) but the same had been rejected by the ADM vide
order dated 02.12.2009 on the ground that he has no jurisdiction to
adjudicate the same, He stated that against the said order the appellant
filed an appeal before the Divisional Commissioner which was also
dismissed vide impugned order dated 03.09.2015.
He stated that the notification dated 02.04.1996 stipulates that
uncultivated surplus land of Gaon Sabha falling in ridge may be excluded
from vesting in Gaon Sabba and made available for the purpose of
reserve forest. He stated that the land in question was not an uncultivated
surplus land of the Gaon Sabha, instead the same was a part of an
unauthorized colony, which is pending consideration for regularization
before the Government. Counsel further stated that notification dated
12.12.2007 issued by the Govt. of NCT of Delhi defines that the land
vested in Gaon Sabha under section 81 of the DLR Act and whose
possession has not been taken over by the Gaon Sabha would be treated
as a private land. He stated that the land in question had been vested in
Gaon Sabha without any notice and the possession had also not been
taken. He stated that the appellant is in possession of the land and
therefore it may be construed to be a private land. It was, therefore,
prayed that the impugned order may be set-aside and land bearing
khasra no. 25(4-16) situated in the revenue estate of village Neb Sarai,
Delhi may be de- notified.
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
On behalf of the respondent no. 1/ Forest Department, Counsel
stated that the land falling under khasra no. 25 of village Neb Sarai
belonging to Gaon Sabha had been notified as Reserve Forest vide
notification dated 02.04.1996. She stated that the said land had been
handed over to the Forest Department after demarcation by the Revenue
Department on 26.09.1996. She stated that the department of Forest &
Wild Life has always been in possession of the khasra no. 25 and the fact
that some portion of the said khasra no, occupied by some encroachers
does not merit the claim for its de-notification. She stated that the
demolition is a continuous process and remaining portion of the said
khasra no. and other encroached areas will be retrieved.
On behalf of the respondent no. 3/ Gaon Sabha, Counsel stated
that the land in question had been vested in the Gaon Sabha in 1984 and
the vesting order had not been challenged by the recorded owner or the
appellant till date.
He stated that the Government had declared the land in question
as Forest Land belonging to the Gaon Sabha as per the revenue records.
He stated that the possession of the land in question had been handed
over by the Gaon Sabha to the Forest Department.
I have considered the submissions made by both the sides and
have also gone through the case file. I am constrained to observe that the
Forest Department has not been making sufficient efforts to safe guards
its lands which had been notified vide notification dated 02.04.1996. The
Forest Department shall endeavour to see that its lands are not
encroached and if the same has been encroached, then the Department
shall get it removed after following the due procedure of Law. I am in
agreement with the observations of the Divisional Commissioner that the
Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 does not make any distinction between the
original Gaon Sabha land or the vested Gaon Sabha land. Until and
unless the vesting had been challenged and set aside, the land will
remain as a part of the Gaon Sabha land. As the Gaon Sabha lands
located in the Ridge were notified as forest land, the appellant in the
instant matter has no case as the basic order vesting the land into Gaon
Sabha has not been challenged in any Court. The impugned order passed
by the Divisional Commissioner is a speaking and reasoned order. I
therefore find no ground to interfere with the same. Accordingly the
present appeal is rejected.
Announced.
File be consigned to record.”
18.
The Court also finds no merit in the submission that construction,
colonisation, or pendency of regularisation proposals can dilute the statutory
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
character of notified ridge/forest land. This Court has repeatedly rejected
challenges mounted by occupants of unauthorised colonies in ridge areas,
holding that colonisation or construction cannot defeat the statutory
protection extended to ridge/forest land, and that regularisation schemes
exclude areas falling within notified forest.
19.
In Freedom Fighters Social Welfare Association v. Union of India,3
the Court, having regard to the object of preservation of the ridge area, held
that it is immaterial whether the encroachment was prior to or after issuance
of the notification; further it was noted that the Regulations dated 24th
March, 2008 for regularisation of unauthorised colonies exclude areas
falling under notified/reserved forest. The Division Bench in Shree Hazur
Baba Sadhu Singh Ji Maharaj Trust v. Union of India,4 further clarified
that “uncultivated Gaon Sabha land” cannot be read as “vacant land”, and
that the label of an unauthorised colony cannot, by itself, undo the legal
character of land notified under the ridge/forest regime.
20.
In light of the above, neither the existence of construction nor the plea
that the area forms part of an unauthorised colony pending regularisation can
be a basis to seek de-notification of land covered under the notification
dated 2nd April, 1996.
21.
The Petitioner’s reliance on certain orders where relief is stated to
have been granted by the Forest Settlement Officer does not advance the
case. Equality under Article 14 operates on established similarity of material
facts and legal status. The Petitioner has not placed the record of those
matters to demonstrate parity on essentials such as the revenue status of
2011 SCC OnLine Del 1318
2011 SCC OnLine Del 4710
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
land, existence or absence of a vesting order, the nature of claim proved, and
the evidentiary foundation accepted in those cases. In any event, an
erroneous benefit, if shown, does not create an enforceable right to demand
repetition.
22.
The notification dated 12th December, 2007, relied upon by the
Petitioner, is pleaded as an administrative measure to treat certain vested
lands as private where possession has not been taken. Even assuming such
an instruction exists in the form asserted, it cannot be used to override a
subsisting vesting order under the DLR Act, or to compel de-notification of
land that stands brought under the ridge/forest notification regime.
23.
The Petitioner has not shown an enforceable legal right which
survives the subsisting revenue vesting consequences and the ridge/forest
notification regime, so as to warrant interference under Article 226.
24.
The writ petition is dismissed, along with pending applications, if any.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JANUARY 22, 2026
as
W.P.(C) 5434/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 28/01/2026 at 12:47:20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review