Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3219 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETI ION NO:3
oF 20
Between:
1. Boda Ravi, S/o.Bikkulal, Age 40 years Working as Forest Beat Officer,
[Jimourini aeat, Sarhpalhnagar' Section, WLM Chatakonda Range,
Kinne'rasani Division, Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
2. D.Thulasi Ram, S/o. Nanda, Age 43 years, Working as.Forest Beq! Officer,
Musalimaduqu East Beat Musalimadugu Section, Paloncha Range, Paloncha
Division, Bh;dradri Kothagudem District
3.B.Hathiram,S/o.Chandru,Age4Syears,Workingas-Forest.BeatOfficer,
Kistaram Beat Bodu Section, Tekulapalli Range, Kothagudem ulvlslon,
Bhadradri Kothagudem
Beat
4. Boda Motilal, S/o. Boda Bikkulal' Age 37 years, Wqldry as ForestRange
oiticet, tttoitdgudem Beat Sampathnigar Sebtion, -WLM Chatakonda
WLM kinneralani Division, Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
-5.TatiRani,D/o.Pasaiah,Age3gyears,WorkingasForestBeatOfficer'
irvriOiii"i Betat) paradeli"Sectioh, Yatlandu, Range Yellandu Division,
' Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
46 years, Working as Fores-l Beat
Chandar, S/o. Mangya,
6.
- Lakavath
-Konijeila
-6ebt,Age
section Khammam Range,
oiii",ii- rnrmirapittv south
Khammam Division Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
Beat
7. Paddam Yerraiah, S/o. Late Ramulu, Age 54 years Working as Fores!Range
Buyyaram
East
Seition
ant
Beat
South
offG;, eadmapuram
Manuguru Divisibn, Bhadradri Konthagudem Dist.
8. Lakavath Suresh, S/o. Ram Singh, Age 32 years Workinq- as-. Forest Beat
officer.GuntuoalliGopavaramBeat,Narsimha,PuramsectionMaonlra
nange, Khamniam Dividion Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist'
g.BanothSravanKumar,S/o.Lalu,Age33yearsWorkingas.Fo.restBeat
Officer Penuballi Beat Ramavaram Section, Ramavaram Range Komaguoem
Division, Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist-
lo.K.Krishna,S/o.Manu,Age3Tyears,Working-asForestBeatOfficer,
'- ii;;i#;ni ee;t Mioiiaia;i section, Paloncha-Ran$e Paloncha Division,
Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
ll.Azmeera Baby, S/o. Somla, Age 31 years Working-as FoJ-e?t Bgat^9I]9-ej'
Valasala (W) Beat Valasala Section, Khachanapalli Range Yellandu Ulvrslon,
Bhadradri' Ktithagudem Dist.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Environment, Forests, Science and Technology Department, T. S. Secretariat,
Hyd,:rabad.
2. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (HoFF), Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad,
Hydr:rabad
3. The Conservator of Forests, Khammam Circle, Khammam
4. The Conservator of Forests, Bhadradri Kothagudem Circle, Kothagudem
5. The District Forest Officer, Khammam
6. The District Forest Officer, Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Artide 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstanr:es stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or direction more in the nature of Mandamus
declaring the orders passed by the 2nd respondent in Rc.No.9970/ZO14lEE.2
dt.29.10.2015 and the orders of
the same respondent in Ref.
No.9970/2014lEE.2(ii) d1.28.1.2016 and the posting orders in Rc.61St2O.l4- M2
d|.1O.2.2016 in S.O.No.9/2016-M2 are illegal, arbitrary and violates Article 14, 16
and 21 of lonstitution of lndia and contrary to the States Re-organisation Acl
2014 and contrary to the Division Bench Judgement rendered in
W.P.No.45C 11/2016 dt.27.1.2021 and consequential declare that the petitioners
are entitled to get seniority from the date of their seniority as Forest Beat Officers
ie., from 30.6.2007, 2009, 2010 ie., from the date of their initiat appointment from
Bhadrachalam South Division with all consequential attendant benefits in the
interests of iustice.
!ANo: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section '151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to issue
interim direotion suspending the operation of the orders passed by the 2nd
respondent in Rc.No.997012014lEE.2 dt.29.10.2015 and the orders of the same
respondent in Ref. No.9970/20141EE.2(ii) dt.28.1 .2016 and the posting orders in
Rc.61512014- M2 dt.10.2.2016 in S.O.No.912016-M2 for taking last rank in the
seniority in the category of Forest Beat Officers in the division in erstwhile
Khammam Circle pending disposal of the above W.P.
Counselfor the Petitioner: SRI P. V. RAMANA
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES - I
The Court made the following: ORDER
./:./
,I
,l
('
IN THII, HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
I,:
li
ll
li
ti
li
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTTCE T. MADHAVI DEVI
ir
,i
WRTT PETITTON NO.39289 OF 2022
ii
DATED: 11.02.2026
Behveen:
Boda Ravi and l0 others
... Petitioners
AND
The State cf 'l'elangana and 5 others
... Respondents
ORDER
This \\irit Petition is filed seeking the following reliel:
"...tr. i.ssrte a lVrit, Order or direclion more in the nature of'
Mantlumtrs declaring the orders passecl b), tlte 2nd res|tortdent in
Rc. No. .09 7 0/20 I 4/88.2 dt.29 I 0.20 I 5 ctnd the order.r o/- the sante
resporulcrrt in Ref. No.9970/2014/8E.2(ii) dt.2B.l.20l6 and the
postittg orders in Rc.615/2014- M2 dt.10.2.2016 in
S.O.l/o.9/2016-M2 are illegal, arbitrary and violates Article 14,
l6 arrcl 2l ,t" Con.stttution of India and contrary to the State'.y
Re-orgctnisation .4ct 2014 and contrary to the Division Benclt
Judge,ment rendered in W.P.No.450l l/2016 dt.27.1.202 t and
consequential declare that the petitioners are entitled to get
seniority from the date of their senioriry as Forest Beat Officers
ie., /rcm 30.6.2007. 2009, 2010 ie., from the date of their initial
appointme:nt fi'om Bhadrachalam South Diviston with all
consequential attendant bene/its in the interests ofjustice and to
pass.
t
TMDJ
wp_39289_2022
2.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned
Govemment Pleader for Services-I appearing for the respondents and
perused the entire material on record.
3.
Brief facts leading to the filing of the present writ petition
are that the petitioners are working as Forest Beat Officers, having
been appointed in rhe years 2007 ro 2ol0 in the office of the
Divisional Forest officer, Khammam, South Division, in the then
combined State of Andhra Pradesh. It is stated that pursuant to the
bifurcation of the State of Andhra Pradesh into the States of
Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, seven mandals of Khammam District
were initially transfened to the State of Andhra Pradesh under. the
A.P. Re-organisation Act, 2018 and subsequently, a decision was
taken to merge those mandals back into the State of Telangana. In
view of the same, the petitioners were required to exercise their
options for repatriation to Khammam District. It is further stated that
while repatriating the petitioners, proceedings in
Rc.No.997012014/882, Ref.No.99 70l\0t 4-EE.2(ii)
and
Rc.No.6 l5l20r4-M2 dated 29.10.2015, 28.0 t.20to and t0.02.2016
were issued, placing them at the last rank in the cadre. It is stated that
the u;$ same proceedings were challenged by Forest Section officers
,
il
II
TMDJ
wp_39289_2022
(
in w.P.No.45()l l of 2016, and vide order dated 27.01.2021, the said
writ petition was allowed by this Court. Therealier, the present writ
petition ha,; been filed
4.
Lt:arncd counsel for the petitioners placed reliance upon the
order of this Court in W.P. No. 45011 of 2016 and submitted that the
very same proceedings which were set aside in the aforementioned
rvrit petition arc under challenge before this Court also and, therelbre,
the said der:ision is squarely applicable to the petitioners in the present
case as well.
5.
Learned Governrnent Pleader for Services-I, appearing for
the respon,Jents, relied upon the avennents made in the counter
aflidavit and suburitted that the petitioners have exercised their
options agr,:eing to take the last rank in the cadre and, therefore, they
\,vere placerl accordingly. It is further submitted that the petitioners
were transfbrred from the State of Andhra Pradesh to the State of
I'elangana i.e., interstate transfer on their request and they cannot
claim seniority over the employees of the State of Telangana.
6.
Having regard to the rival submissions and the material on
record, this Court finds that it was the Act of the Government of India
\
\
t
TMDJ
wp_39289 2022
to bifurcate the erstwhile State of Andhra Pradesh into the States of
Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, and in that process seven mandals of
Kharnmam District were initially transferred to Andhra Pradesh State
and subsequently re-transfen'ed to Telangana State. It is in this process
that the impugned proceedings came to be issued. This Court, in w.p.
No.45011 of 20[6, considered the said issue and has observed as
under:
"45. In my opinion, since all this happened pur.urant to the policv
decision taken vide G.o.Ms.No.l30 General Administration (sR1
Departtnent dt.19.03.2015 by the Governtnertt of Telangana to
ensure that people of Telangana nativitlt working in the 7 Mandals
of the Khammam District where the Bhadrachalam (South)
Division was operating continued to,,vork in the State of Telangana
only, and they do not get allotted to the State of Andhra pradesh
because of the merger of the 7 Mandals in the East Godavari and
LIrest Godavari Districts of residuar.y State of Andhra pradesh, it
cannot be satd that this amounts to 'transfer on request, of the
petitioners to which Sub-Rule (b) of Rule t I of the A.p. Forest
subordinate service Rules applies. It has to be construed as a
'transfer on administrative grounds' which woutd
falt in sub-Rure
(a) of Rule I l.
46.
The fact that petitioners gave gtven option
for the State of
Telangana cannot be construed as a 'transfer' sought on request to
the State of Telangana because the process was not one of
'transfer'at all, but is essentially repatriation to the State of
Telangana of persons of relangana nattvitlt who would otherwise
I
TMDJ
wp_39289 2022
Cr
have to work in the State of Andhra Pradesh on the transfer of the
7 M,znduls of Klrummam Distt'ict to the said State under the A.P.
Reot'ganization Act, 20 I 4.
47. I do not accept the plea of respondents that :
(tt) es per Special Service Rules in the Fore.st SubOrclinate Service, Division is the unit for recruitment and
di,scharge of a Forestor,'
(b) there coulcl be more than one Division in a District,'
(c,t and so u concliclute uppointed in a particular unit, i.e.,
Division, will have rights with regard to his service in that
particttlar ttrzit only but not in the entire District; and
(d,t ttnlike other Departntents where recruitment to local
cadre is based treating the entire District as a unit by
ttirtue of Special Service Rules, the position tn the Forest
Deparlnrcttt is difibrent.
48.
Tlte above principles would have no application in the
.facts oncl circurnstances of the case and Rule 33(a) of the A.|'}.
State ard Subot'dinate Service Rules which directs that seniority
of o lterson in a service, class, category or grade, shallunless he
had beert reduced to a lower rank as a puntshment, be
determined by the date oJ'his /irst appointment to such service,
class, category or grade.
49. Consequently, petitioners' seniority has to be fixed with
referctnce to their date offirst appointment, i.e., 03.08.2007 and
il is not permissible for the respondents to compel the petitioners
\
I
TMDJ
wp_39289 2022
(''
to give up the seniority which they have earned
condition that they give up s,uch seniority
the junior-most position in the (Jnit to
and qgree to occupl,
which they have been
repatriated and adjusted in the supernumerary
i
!
the said purpose a.\ was done by the principar
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
by imposing a
posts created for
Chief conservator
of Fore.sts (HoFI), Telangana, Hyderabad in proceedings
R'c'No'9970 / 20 r 4 / EE2 dt.29. t 0.20 r5 and
proceedings
RefNo.9970 / 2014 EE.2(i, dt.28.01.20t6
and by the
conservator of Forests, Khammam circre, Khammant
in
rti.s
Accordingly, the I{rit petition rs ailowed; ancr
the
proceedings No 6l5 / 20H _ M2 dr.10.02.20t6.
rl
i
50'
condition imposed by the principar crtief conservator
(HoFF), Telangana, Hyderabad
of Frsrests
in proceedings R.C.No.gg7T /
2014 / EE2 dt.29.r0.20t5 and proceedings
Ref No ggza
/ 20r4 -
EE.2 (ii) dt-28.0r.20t6 and by the Conservator of Forests,
Khamntarn Circle, Khammam in his proceedings
- M2 dt.10.02.20t6 that petitioners
'hourd
No.6r5
/ 2014
agree to occupy the
juntor-most position in the (Jnit to which
they have been
repatriated and adjusted in the supernumerary posts
createtr lbr
the said purpose, is decrared as viorative of Arttcre
14 of the
Constitution of India and the A.P. Forest Subordinate
Rules, and is set aside. It is declared that petitioners
Service
are entitled
to get seniority from the date of their initiar appointment
Forest section offcers from 03.0g.2007 with alr
consequential
benefits and they shourd be given the said benefits
respondents within six weercs
the order.
respondent.r
as
by the
from the date of receipt of copy of
Consequently, I.A.No.l of 20lB
filed by the
to vacate the order dt.22. I 2.2016 irt
TMDJ
w_39289_2022
W1'>MP.No.55484 of 2016 in the Writ Petttion is dtsmissed, and
the' said order is made absolute. No costs. "
7.
This Court is of the opinion that except for the difference in
cadre, there is no other distinguishing tactor in the present case. The
petitione:s herein are also similarly situated, being the Forest Beat
Officers. 'Iherefore, following the decision of the Coordinate Bench
of this Court in W.P. No. 4501 I of 2016, this Writ Petition is allowed.
The impugned proceedings in
Ref.No.9970,i20l4-88.2 (ii)
Rc.No.9970l20l4lEE2,
and Rc.No.6l5/2014-M2 dated
29.10.20 t5, 28.01.2016 and 10.02.2016 are hereby set aside. It is
declared that the petitioners are entitled to seniority from the date of
their initial appointment as Forest Beat Officers with all consequential
beqefits. The respondents are directed to extend the said benefits
within a period of six (06) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order. No order as to costs.
8.
Ivliscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this writ
petition, shall stand closed
Sd/.C. DEEPIKA
ANT REGISTRAR
/ffRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal Secretary to Government, Envi
t, Forests, Science and
Tecl-nology Department, State of Telangana, T
Hyderabad
2. The rrincipal Chief Conservator of Forests (HoFF), Aranya Bhavan, Saifabad,
Hyderabad
3. The ,lonseryator of Forests, Khammam Circle, Khammam.
,-ii&;rr- -*d
Y
l
4. The Conservator of Forests, Bhadradri.Kothagudem Circle, Kothagudem.
5. The District Forest Officer, Khammam.
6. The District Forest Offlcer, Bhadradri Kothagudem Dist.
7. One CC to SRI P. V. RAMANA, Advocate [OPUC]
8. Two CCs to GP for Services-l, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
\
9. Two CD Copies
MP.
W
/
?
HIGH COURT
DATED:1110212026
t
\
T biE S
I
,i
\\
i
r)
I
l-
I '2fi'Ifr
*
P476'Pc'
*-
ORDER /
I
WP.No.39289 of 2022
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
iA
\
1-\
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review