Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 02nd December, 2025
Pronounced on: 23rd February, 2026
%
+
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018, CRL.M.A. 8898/2018 & 3527/2019
MAHENDER SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Jaswainder Singh and Monu
Kumar Advocates.
versus
STATE (GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI) & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP with SI Vivek.
Ms. Sima Gulati with Ms. Diksha
Narula, Advocates for R-2.
+
CRL.M.C. 2500/2018, CRL.M.A. 8905/2018
CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Jaswainder Singh and Monu
Kumar Advocates.
versus
STATE (GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI) & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP with SI Vivek.
Ms. Sima Gulati with Ms. Diksha
Narula, Advocates for R-2.
+
CRL.M.C. 2728/2018, CRL.M.A. 9705/2018 & 3518/2019
BNS RATNAKAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Jaswainder Singh and Monu
Kumar Advocates.
versus
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
STATE (GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI) & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP with SI Vivek.
Ms. Sima Gulati with Ms. Diksha
Narula, Advocates for R-2.
+
CRL.M.C. 2738/2018, CRL.M.A. 9763/2018 & 3515/2019
MOHAN TANKSALE
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Jaswainder Singh and Monu
Kumar Advocates.
versus
STATE & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Utkarsh, APP with SI Vivek.
Ms. Sima Gulati with Ms. Diksha
Narula, Advocates for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Petition filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C”) on behalf of the Petitioners
seeking quashing of CC No. 28797/2016, P.S. Barakhamba Road, under
Sections 420/406/120B/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
referred to as “IPC”) pending before Ld. MM, Patiala House Court, New
Delhi.
2.
The aforesaid four Petitions have been filed by the Bank and its
Officials, namely, Mahinder Singh (Crl. MC 2499/2018), AGM of the
Asset Recovery Branch of the Central Bank of India, Accused No. 5;
Central Bank of India (Crl. MC 2500/2018), Accused No.1 Bank; BNS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
Ratnakar (Crl. MC 2728/2018), AGM of the Asset Recovery Branch of the
Central Bank of India, Accused No. 3; Mohan Tanksale (Crl. MC
2738/2018), GM of the Central Office Mumbai, Central Bank of India,
Accused No. 2, for the quashing of the Complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C.
filed under Sections 406/409/420/120B/34 IPC by the Complainant and the
Summoning Order dated 28.06.2017.
Facts as per the Complainant Respondent No.2, Sh. Suresh Goel:
3.
A Complaint under Section 190 Cr.P.C read with Section 200 Cr.P.C
was filed under Sections 406/409/420/120B/34 IPC by the Complainant.
4.
It is stated that the Complainant, Sh. Suresh Goel, is the Authorized
Representative/Managing Director of M/s Cosco Sales & Services Pvt. Ltd.
and M/s Cosco Blossoms Pvt. Ltd. The said two Companies had availed
overdraft facilities from Central Bank of India, Janpath, New Delhi. Due to
financial constraints, repayment could not be made by the Complainant and
the accounts were declared NPA in 1999-2000.
5.
The Bank filed OAs No. 159/2002 and 160/2002 before DRT, New
Delhi. On 17.8.2012, Certificates of recovery for Rs 2,57,62,026/- plus
interest @ 16% p.a. with cost of Rs.1,18,96,158/- and for Rs. 2,18,96,158/plus interest @ 16% p.a. with cost were issued. (As on 31.3.2013 the
amount in both the Certificates, came to Rs.13 crores approximately).
6.
According to the Complainant, the Accused No.2 to 5, namely, Shri
M.V. Tanksale, Shri B.N.S. Ratnakar, Shri B. Mondal, Shri Mahender Singh,
approached the Complainant in January, 2013 to settle the Account, by way
of One Time Settlement (“OTS). The Complainant had already deposited
Rs. 10 lakhs in a ‘No-Lien’ account.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
7.
Thereafter, the Complainant and his son, met Accused No.2 to 5 on
08.02.2013 and they were informed in the Meeting that Bank can settle with
the Complainant, provided he gave some proposal in writing. Relying on
their assurances, the Complainant deposited an additional Rs.48 lakhs on
08.02.2013 and submitted an OTS proposal.
8.
On
receipt
of
this
offer,
the
Accused
issued
terms
of
Settlement/Compromise vide Sanction Letter dated 27.02.2013. As per
this Letter, the Bank agreed to compromise for Rs.6 Crores towards full and
final settlement of its dues. Rs.58 lakhs was deposited in ‘No Lien’ Account
was agreed to be adjusted, on conveying the Sanction. Balance of Rs.542
lakhs was to be paid before 31.03.2013 with interest, at the base rate plus
2% Simple Interest on reducing balance.
9.
It was agreed that in case of default, the compromise would stand
cancelled and the decree would remain executable. The Complainant
Company was required to submit PDCs for the amount, at the time of
conveying Sanction and in default of payment the Compromise was to be
treated as cancelled. In case of default of payment by the Complainant, all
concessions were to be treated as withdrawn as if no Settlement has taken
place. The Complainant accepted the terms.
10.
As the full settlement amount could not be paid and only Rs.58 lakhs
stood deposited, the OTS stood automatically cancelled and concessions
withdrawn. The Complainant accepted the terms of OTS. However, the
Complainant was unable to abide by the terms of OTS, and the amount of
Rs.58 lakhs remained deposited with the Bank. As the compromise stood
cancelled, all the concessions that were given were also withdrawn.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
11.
The Complainant wrote a Letter dated 26.04.2013 requesting the
Accused Bank to comply with the Bank’s Sanction Letter dated 27.02.2013
and to return the amount of Rs.58 lakhs, which was deposited with the Bank
for the purpose of Settlement.
12.
Instead, the Bank issued a Letter dated 20.04.2013 (received on
27.04.2013) stating that the debt had been assigned to UVARCL through an
Assignment Agreement dated 20.04.2013.
13.
The Complainant alleged that Bank had misappropriate the amount of
Rs.58 lakhs paid it. It was further claimed that the officials of the Bank
assigned the debt to UVARCL in conspiracy, with the sole intention to usurp
and grab the properties. The Assignment Agreement that was executed was
to be effective from 20.04.2013, whereas the Stamp Paper and the Court
duty was paid on 30.07.2013. The documents were registered on
12.08.2013.
14.
It was further stated that the Accused No.7 to 9, namely, Ms. Shilpi
Sharma, Mr. Pramod Sharma, Mr. Ashwani Kumar Chadha, officials of
UVARCL approached the Complainant in January, 2013, which was much
prior to the execution of the Assignment Agreement with the Bank, and
informed that they were sent by Central Bank of India to negotiate the
Settlement with him.
It was further alleged that despite Recovery
Certificates of about Rs. 13 crores, bank officials conspired to assign the
debts to UVARCL at a much lower consideration, allegedly in collusion and
with dishonest intent.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
15.
It is further submitted that, much prior to the execution of the
Assignment Agreement with the Bank, certain officials of UVARCL had
approached the complainant in January 2013.
16.
Specifically, Accused No. 8/Mr. Pramod Sharma (Key Personnel),
and Accused No. 9/Mr. Ashwani Kumar Chadha (Deputy Chief Executive
of Accused No. 6), acting under the instructions of their Promoter-Director,
Accused No. 7/Ms. Shilpi Sharma, visited the Complainant at his residence
on 12.01.2013. They represented that they had been sent by the officials of
the Central Bank of India and attempted to negotiate a settlement with the
complainant on behalf of the Bank, while allegedly demanding a
commission for the said purpose.
17.
It was alleged that this Agreement was fabricated and antedated to
misappropriate the Complainant’s money. It is evident that the said
Assignment Agreement was fabricated, for the purposes of cheating the
Complainant by the above sale accused persons and the sole game plan since
inception, of the above said accused persons was to snatch the properties and
earn wrongful personal gain, under the shadow of said Assignment
Agreement.
18.
The Complainant alleged that the Accused persons acted in collusion,
to execute the Assignment Agreement and misappropriate Rs.58 lakhs, and a
wrongful loss of Rs.58 lakhs was caused to him, which was a wrongful gain
to the Bank. Moreover, the Assignment Agreement consideration was much
lower than the recovery amount and the deposited Rs. 58 lakhs, was not
reflected in the Agreement. The Complainant alleges that the document is
forged and created to cause wrongful loss to him and wrongful gain to the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
accused. The Complainant claimed that the Bank officials in conspiracy with
each other, cheated and committed the breach of trust, constituting offences
under Sections 409/420/120B/34 IPC, and related violations under IPC and
banking laws.
19.
The Complaints were made to SHO, P.S. Barakhamba Road on
16.10.2013 and 20.11.2013, but no action was taken. Reminders were sent to
DCP Parliament Street on 06.02.2014 and 13.03.2014, but no action
followed.
20.
The Complainant thus, filed a Complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C
for the offence under Section 406/409/420/120B/34 IPC.
21.
In pre-summoning evidence, the Complainant examined himself as
CW1 and reiterated the facts contained in the Complaint and exhibited the
documents.
22.
Ld. MM summoned Accused No.1 to 5 for commission of offences
under Section 420/409/120B IPC vide Order dated 28.06.2017.
23.
The Accused persons have challenged the Summoning Order by way
of the Writ Petition.
Grounds taken by the Petitioners:
24.
The Petitioners have challenged the impugned Order on the ground
that the Ld. MM has wrongly summoned the petitioners, without
considering
whether
the
averments
made
in
Complaint
prima
facie constitute any offence. There is nothing in the Complaint that
substantiates the commission of an offence of Cheating under Section 420
IPC or Criminal Breach of Trust under Section 405 IPC.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
25.
It is submitted that Respondent No. 2 had received and accepted the
Letter dated 28.02.2013 conveying the sanction, thereby establishing that
there was no objection to adjustment of the said amount pending completion
of other stipulations in the said letter. Subsequently, Respondent No. 2 failed
to make the balance payment and the compromise lapsed. However, this did
not mean that the sum of Rs. 58 lakhs already deposited by Respondent No.
2, upon which the „No Lien‟ status ceased to apply, was liable to be
refunded.
26.
Ld. MM failed to appreciate that the deposit of Rs. 58 lakhs made by
Respondent No. 2 in a ‘No Lien’ account, was liable to be adjusted in terms
of the Sanction Letter. Respondent No. 2 had accepted the terms of the
sanction. Accordingly, there was no ‘entrustment’ after 28.02.2013, and the
Bank was well within its rights to adjust the amount in terms of the
Agreement. Consequently, no case of „entrustment‟ or alleged criminal
breach of trust is made out.
27.
Ld. MM failed to appreciate that even on a complete reading of the
allegations made in the Complaint, pre-summoning evidence, and the
documents placed on record, no offence whatsoever is made out; much less
the offences of cheating or criminal breach of trust.
28.
It is submitted that the Central Bank of India and its officers were
acting in exercise of statutory powers conferred under the SARFAESI Act,
2002 while assigning the debt, after Respondent No. 2 failed to honour the
compromise.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
29.
Even on merits, Respondent No. 2 was not entitled to refund of the
sum of Rs. 58 lakhs. Accordingly, the Complaint was misconceived and
ought not to have been entertained.
30.
It is submitted that the offence of cheating is not even remotely made
out from a reading of the Complaint, as the said offence presupposes
fraudulent misrepresentation and dishonest intention at the inception of the
transaction. In the present case, there was no misrepresentation as all terms
were conveyed clearly and categorically.
31.
Ld. MM failed to appreciate that the other accused persons working in
UVARCIL, were dropped from the array of parties’ consequent upon
settlement with Respondent No. 2 during the pendency of the Complaint,
despite allegations of criminal conspiracy with officials of the Bank. This
itself demonstrates that Respondent No. 2 has falsely implicated the
Petitioners and other accused persons for extraneous considerations, and that
the allegations lack substance.
32.
Moreover, the Civil Suit filed by Respondent No. 2 is pending which
indicates that the dispute is essentially civil in nature and is being
deliberately given a criminal colour. In the Summary Suit filed by
Respondent No. 2, the Leave to Defend applications are still pending
adjudication.
33.
Furthermore, there is no specific averment against the Petitioners in
the entire body of the Complaint and that the petitioners have been wrongly
arrayed as an accused. It is settled law, as laid down by Apex Court in SMS
Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Neeta Bhalla & Ors., dated 20.02.2007, that
liability arises on account of specific conduct, act, or omission on the part of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
a person, and not merely by virtue of holding an office or position in a
company. The Complaint must disclose necessary and specific allegations
against such person.
34.
Hence, a prayer is made to quash the CC. No. 28797/2016, P.S.
Barakhamba Road, under Sections 420/406/120B/34 IPC.
35.
A Counter-Affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Respondent
No.2/ Complainant Sh. Suresh Goel. He took the preliminary objections
that the present Petition for quashing of the proceedings in the Criminal
Complaint Case, has been filed after a period of 10 months for which there
is no explanation. The Petition is not maintainable as the Summoning order
dated 28.06.2017 is a revisable Order and the Revision Petition under
Section 397/399/401 Cr.P.C. was the appropriate alternate remedy available
to the Petitioners.
36.
The Petitioners have invoked this extra-ordinary and inherent powers
of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C even though there is an alternate
remedy under Cr.P.C. It is claimed that this Petition has been filed to
circumvent the due process and to avoid the legal objections relating to
period of limitation, as applicable for filing the Revision Petition. This is an
abuse of process of law and on this ground itself, the Petition should be
dismissed.
37.
It is further contended that the Petition does not disclose any ground
for quashing of the proceedings of the Criminal Complaint and is otherwise
based upon the probable defence of the Accused, which by itself is full of
infirmities and is prima facie unbelievable; it is required to be proved by
way of evidence during the trial. It is further contended that the Petitioners
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
have deliberately concealed material facts and documents and have
attempted to mislead this Court.
38.
The facts have been distorted and misrepresented. It has been falsely
claimed that Rs.58 lakhs were credited to the Account of the Respondent. It
is further wrongly claimed that the alleged Assignment Deed was dated
20.04.2013; as per its own relied documents of Assignment Deed show that
the Stamp duty for the document was purchased only on 30.07.2013 and was
registered on 12.08.2013. In any event, the veracity of this document is
shrouded in mystery and truth can be unravelled only during the trial.
39.
The Petitioner asserts that the alleged Assignment Deed that the
Assignment of Debt to Assignee M/s UVARCL was of the entire Decretal
amount along with interest calculated up to the said date, as has been clearly
stated in Schedule 1 of the Assignment Deed, which further establishes that
the amount paid by the Complainant was never credited to the Account of
the Companies of the Complainant.
40.
Furthermore, it was stated in the Sanction Letter dated 27.02.2013
that the amount was paid and was deposited in the ‘No Lien Account’.
Therefore, the amount was liable to be returned/refunded to the Complainant
in the event of failure of OTS, as was proposed and was under process. As a
matter of fact, the amount of Rs.10 lakhs were already lying in the ‘No Lien
Account’, which amount was included in the total of Rs.58 lakhs. This
amount was never credited to the Account of the Complainant. Prima facie,
offence under Section 420/409/1230B IPC was established.
Hence, the
Summoning Order, is not liable to be recalled.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
41.
Furthermore, it has been stated in the Complaint that there was some
involvement of M/s UVARCL even in January, 2013 and the accused
persons arraigned in the Complaint, had acted in tandem and deliberately
mislead and induced the Complainant, by concealing the true facts relating
to the involvement of M/s UVARCL. Thereby, the Complainant was
induced to pay such a huge amount which they never intended to be credited
to the account of the Complainant or to his Companies. The assignment of
entire decretal amount and payable interest, has been done dishonestly with
criminal design to assign to M/s UVARCL, which amounts to a case of
Cheating and Criminal Breach of Trust.
42.
It was further stated that the Accused Bank and the Accused persons
had created back dated documents of Assignment to cull out a false, flimsy
and frivolous of Assignment, after receipt of Letter dated 26.04.2013 from
the Complainant demanding back the sum of Rs.58 lakhs, since the OTS had
failed and the position was to revert to status quo ante as there was no
Settlement.
43.
The Complainant has relied on State of Haryana vs. Bhajan Lal, 1992
AIR 604; R.P. Kapur vs. The State of Punjab, (1960) 3 SCR 388 to state that
the Petition of the Petitioners is not liable to be quashed.
44.
On merits, all the averments made in the Petition have been denied.
45.
The Status Report has been filed on behalf of the State, wherein all
the facts as stated herein have been detailed. After receipt of Complaint,
enquiry was conducted and it was found that no cognizable offence was
made out.
The Complainant had filed a Complaint under Section 200
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
Cr.P.C along with an Application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. The Status
Report had also been duly filed before the Ld. M.M.
46.
The Petitioners in their Written Submissions has reiterated his
assertions as made in the Petition. The Respondent No.2 in the Written
Submissions, has made submissions on similar lines as the CounterAffidavit.
Submissions heard and record perused.
47.
The facts as narrated by the Complainant in his Complaint are that Sh.
Suresh Goel, who was Authorised Representative of M/s Cosco Sales &
Services Pvt. Ltd. and M/s Cosco Blossoms Pvt. Ltd., was running the
business smoothly and had Overdraft facilities from Central Bank of India,
New Delhi. However, they were declared NPA in the year 1999-2000. Two
OAs were filed before DRT, in which, Recovery Certificates were issued for
Rs.2,67,62,026/- and Rs.1,18,96,158/- along with interest @ 16% per
annum, totalling to Rs.13 crore approximately.
48.
The Complainant has asserted that Petitioners, who were Senior
business officer of Central Bank of India, approached him in the year 2013
for a One Time Settlement (“OTS”), which was finally settled and OTS was
entered into between the parties. Accordingly, Sanction Letter dated
27.02.2013 was issued.
49.
As per the terms of this OTS, it was agreed that total amount of Rs.6
crore only was payable towards full and final settlement of Bank dues of
Rs.58,00,000/-, out of which Rs.10,00,000/- were lying in ‘No Lien’
Account and Rs.48,00,000/-, which were additionally transferred to this
account,
shall
be
adjusted
in
the
Settlement
amount.
Balance
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
Rs.5,42,00,000/- would be paid before 31.03.2013, along with interest at the
base rate plus 02% Simple Interest on reducing balance. In case of default in
payment, as per the terms of sanction, the compromise was to be
automatically treated as cancelled and all concessions shall be treated as
withdrawn, as if there were no compromise ever between the parties and in
that event the decree shall be executed.
50.
The Complainant himself stated that the terms of the Sanction Letter,
could not be adhered to and the balance payment of Rs.5,42,00,000/- could
not be paid, as agreed upto 31.03.2013. Once the OTS fails, as per the
averments of the Complainant, the liability of the two Companies, who were
being represented by the Complainant, got revived under the Recovery
Certificates.
51.
The Complainant has sought to invoke the offence of cheating and
criminal breach of trust on the ground that the Complaint, vide his request
Letter dated 26.04.2013, had requested the Bank to return the amount of
Rs.58 Lacs, as had been entrusted by the Complainant to the Bank, solely
for the purpose of settlement. Since this money was retained and not
adjusted in his outstanding liability, there was cheating and breach of trust
committed by the Bank.
52.
The gravamen of the Complaint is that the Bank failed to refund the
sum of Rs.58 lakhs deposited in the „No Lien‟ Account and thereby,
committed offences under Sections 406/409/420 IPC.
53.
First and foremost, admittedly, OTS failed on account of non-
adherence of the terms by the Complainant. Secondly, though this amount of
Rs.58 lakhs was lying in ‘No lien’ account, the Bank, in case of default, was
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
well within its right to adjust the said amount towards outstanding amount. It
cannot be held to be a case of criminal breach of trust or of cheating.
54.
It was contended on behalf of the Bank that due adjustment of this
amount has been done in the loan account of the Complainant. Even if it is
not correct, it is merely a case of recovery of Rs.58 lakhs, to which the
Complainant is making a claim, which is purely a civil dispute, for which he
has already invoked civil remedy by filing a Civil Suit, which is pending
trial.
55.
At best, the dispute relates to adjustment or refund of money arising
out of contractual terms. There is no material to indicate any fraudulent or
dishonest intention at the inception of the transaction, a sine qua non for
constituting the offence of cheating under Section 420 IPC. Thus, it does not
disclose any criminal offence, as is sought to be made out by the
Complainant.
56.
The second averment made by the Complainant is that after receiving
the Request Letter dated 26.04.2013 of the Complainant demanding return
of Rs.58 lakhs, the Bank and its officials, in order to cheat him, fabricated
the ante-dated document dated 20.04.2013, informing the Complainant that
the Bank has absolutely assigned the debts of the Complainant, in favour of
UV Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. (“UVARCL”) vide Assessment
Agreement dated 20.04.2013.
57.
The Complainant has asserted that this Letter had been prepared to
misappropriate the amount of Rs.58 lakhs paid by the Complainant to the
Accused Bank. There is illegal nexus between the officials of the Central
Bank of India and officials of UVARCL in entering into the Assessment
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
Agreement dated 20.04.2013, which was solely prepared in connivance of
the officials of the Central Bank of India and officials of UVARCL, with the
sole motive and intention to grab the valuable properties of the innocent
persons.
58.
Moreover, while the Assignment Agreement is dated 20.04.2013, the
Stamp Paper of this Assessment Agreement was paid on 30.07.2013 and the
documents were registered on 12.08.2013, which again reflects the
fabrication for the purpose of cheating the Complainant.
59.
The contention of the Petitioners is that Assessment Agreement dated
20.04.2013 is a fabricated document. But the Bank was well within its right
to assign its debts to the Company. This was an Agreement entered into by
the Bank with UVARCL in its business wisdom and there is nothing to
show that it was intended to cheat the Complainant of his Rs.58 lakhs. Even
if the account got assigned along with other NPA Accounts, it is merely a
business venture in which no element of cheating can even prima facie
presumed. The Bank and Petitioner have stated that this amount has been
given due adjustment in the Assessment Deed.
60.
In any case, if there is any challenge of the Complainant to his
entitlement to Rs.58lakhs, he has his own civil remedy. No offence of
cheating or criminal breach of trust has made out, merely because the
Petitioners and Central Bank of India entered into Assessment Agreement
with UVARCL, which was formalised on 20.04.2013. Parties may have
chosen to purchase the Stamp Paper in July, 2013 and may have got it
registered on 12.08.2013, but it was only a legal formality that got
completed subsequently.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
61.
There is not a whisper of any fact which can give any presumption of
there being any mala fides between the Central Bank of India and
UVARCL. Neither of the party has challenged that they had not entered into
the Assessment Agreement on 20.04.2013 or that the formality of
registration was undertaken in July, 2013. Again, there is no specific
allegation demonstrating that the Assignment Agreement was executed with
a pre-existing conspiracy, to cheat the Complainant.
62.
The third contention raised by the Complainant is that officials of
UVARCL had approached in January, 2013 and claimed that they had been
sent by the officials of Central Bank of India and they tried to negotiate the
settlement on behalf of Central Bank of India. The officials of UVARCL
may have approached the Complainant in January, 2013, but the
Complainant himself has stated that they had approached him for and on
behalf of Central Bank of India.
63.
This clearly reflects that the officials of UVARCL had not approached
in their own right, simply because the Assessment Agreement was not
executed till then. Such negotiations, even if assumed to be true, do not
disclose ingredients of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B IPC in the
absence of material indicating an Agreement to commit an illegal act. No
connivance or conspiracy can be even prima facie presumed, from these
assertions made by the Complainant.
64.
If the entire content of the Complaint is admitted to be correct and
true in toto, even then, it does not disclose any criminal offence of cheating
or of criminal breach of trust or any other criminal offence.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
Conclusion:
65.
In these circumstances, the Complaint under Section 200 of Cr.P.C.
along with the Summoning Order date 28.06.2017 and all proceedings
emanating therefrom, is quashed.
66.
Petition along with pending Applications is disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 23, 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:38:31
CRL.M.C. 2499/2018 and Ors.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review