The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 12.2013, petitioners have become the absolute owners of premises no. 10/10 by virtue of inheritance. The learned trial judge recorded a prima facie finding that the opposite party-club was registered only on May 14, 2007 and obtained permission/provisional permission latter from various authorities for holding Durga Puja, Laxmi Puja and Kali Puja festival at premises No. 10/9, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026. The learned trial judge also recorded a prima facie finding that the defendants/petitioners are the absolute owners and are in possession in respect of premises No. 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026. The learned trial judge further recorded a prima facie finding that the plaintiff/opposite party has not obtained any permission to organize Durga Puja over premises No. premises No. 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026. The learned trial judge further observed that the plaintiff failed to produce any document relating to Durga Bedi or mandap at premises no. 10/9. After the Miscellaneous Appeal No.196 of 2026 was transferred to the court of the learned Additional District Judge, 12th Court at Alipore, this Court finds that September 2, 2026 was fixed for further hearing and orders in respect of an interim order. On September 2, 2026, the learned judge of the appellate court fixed September 3, 2026 for further hearing. However, this Court…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
D/L- 27
14/09/2026
Ct. No.- 6
Aritra
C.O. 3141 of 2026
Bishwanath Bhattacharyya & Ors.
Vs.
Kalighat Nepal Bhattacharjee Street Club, rept.
by its Secretary Mr. Avijit Bose
Mr. Pradyuman Sinha, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Sannidhya Datta
….for the petitioners
Mr. Uday Sankar Bhattacharyya
Ms. Sudeshna Basu Thakur
Mr. Mritunjoy Halder
….for opposite party
This application under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India is at the instance of the defendants and is directed
against an order being No.7 dated September 3, 2026
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, 12th
Court at Alipore in Miscellaneous Appeal No.196 of 2026.
By the order impugned the learned judge of the
appellate court allowed the opposite party-club to perform
celebration of the Puja in the suit property without
causing any inconvenience to the neighbours and local
inhabitants and public in general.
The opposite party-club filed a suit for declaration
that the club has a legal right to peacefully possess and
occupy the schedule mentioned suit property without any
interference
of
the
defendants
and
for
permanent
injunction restraining the defendants and their men and
agents not to create any illegal acts over the schedule
mentioned suit property and/or not to demolish or
obstruct the schedule mentioned suit property and also
restrain the plaintiff and its men and agents from free
ingress and egress of the schedule mentioned suit property
in any manner whatsoever.
In connection with the said
suit the opposite party-club filed an application under
Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
praying
for
a
temporary
injunction
restraining
the
plaintiffs and their men and agents not to create any
illegal acts over the schedule mentioned suit property
and/or not to disturb or obstruct the schedule mentioned
suit property and also not to restrain the plaintiff and its
men and agents from free ingress and egress of the
schedule
mentioned
whatsoever.
suit
property
in
any
manner
An ad interim order of injunction was also
sought for by filing the said application.
The learned trial judge upon a contested hearing
rejected the application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2
of the Code of Civil Procedure by an order dated July 15,
2026.
Being aggrieved by the said order, the opposite partyclub preferred a miscellaneous appeal being No.196 of
2026 and the learned Additional District Judge, 12th Court
at Alipore, by the order impugned, granted permission in
favour of the opposite party-club to perform celebration of
Puja in the schedule mentioned suit property.
The learned advocate appearing for the petitioners
submits that the learned judge of the appellate court
without considering the fact that the learned trial judge by
a reasoned order rejected application for temporary
injunction passed an interim order granting permission to
the opposite party-club to perform Durga Puja by fixing a
date of hearing of the miscellaneous appeal on October 14,
2026.
He further submits that the learned judge of the
appellate court granted the ultimate relief to the opposite
party-club by keeping the miscellaneous appeal pending.
Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned advocate appearing for
the opposite party-club submits that considering the
urgency involved in the instant matter and also the fact
that the opposite party-club is performing Durga Puja for
the last 46 years the learned Judge of the appellate court
have only allowed the club to perform Durga Puja subject
to obtaining necessary permission and order from the
competent authorities. He submits that since the club is
performing the Durga Puja for a pretty long time, the order
impugned should not be interfered with by this Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Heard the learned advocates for the parties and
perused the materials placed.
The suit property as described in the schedule of the
plaint suggests that it is a piece and parcel of Durga Bedi
measuring about 195 sq.ft. more or less situated at
ground floor of premises No.10/9, Nepal Bhattacharjee
Street and 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street. The suit
property is butted and bounded on the southern side by
premises No. 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street and in the
schedule it has been described as the (defendants portion).
In paragraph 20 of the plaint it is the case made out
by the club that they requested the defendants/petitioners
on several occasions verbally to make amicably settlement
amongst themselves by metes and bounds but the
petitioners did not agree for the amicable settlement of the
suit property which is making it very much inconvenient
for the plaintiff-club to enjoy and possess the suit
property.
The
petitioners
have
claimed
that
one
Santi
Bhattacharyya purchased the land measuring about 4
cottahs 4 chittaks 13 square feet of premises no. 10/10 by
virtue of two registered deeds of conveyance dated
17.01.1976 and 24.01.1980 and after her demise on
10.12.2013, petitioners have become the absolute owners
of premises no. 10/10 by virtue of inheritance.
The learned trial judge recorded a prima facie finding
that the opposite party-club was registered only on May
14, 2007 and obtained permission/provisional permission
latter from various authorities for holding Durga Puja,
Laxmi Puja and Kali Puja festival at premises No. 10/9,
Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026. The learned
trial judge also recorded a prima facie finding that the
defendants/petitioners are the absolute owners and are in
possession in respect of premises No. 10/10, Nepal
Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026.
The learned trial
judge further recorded a prima facie finding that the
plaintiff/opposite party has not obtained any permission
to organize Durga Puja over premises No. premises No.
10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, Kolkata-700026.
The learned trial judge further observed that the
plaintiff failed to produce any document relating to Durga
Bedi or mandap at premises no. 10/9.
After the Miscellaneous Appeal No.196 of 2026 was
transferred to the court of the learned Additional District
Judge, 12th Court at Alipore, this Court finds that
September 2, 2026 was fixed for further hearing and
orders in respect of an interim order.
On September 2, 2026, the learned judge of the
appellate court fixed September 3, 2026 for further
hearing. However, this Court finds that the learned judge
of the appellate court by an order dated September 3,
2026 granted permission in favour of the opposite partyclub to perform celebration of Puja in the schedule
mentioned suit property as per the schedule of the
injunction application without causing any convenience to
the neighbours and local inhabitants and public in
general.
As pointed out hereinbefore that the plaintiff/opposite
party-club
while
describing
the
suit
property
has
specifically admitted that the premises No. 10/10, Nepal
Bhattacharjee Street is the defendants’ portion.
The
learned
the
trial
judge
recorded
prima
facie
that
defendants/petitioners are the owners and in possession
over
premises
No.
Bhattacharjee Street.
premises
No.
10/10,
Nepal
By the order impugned the learned judge of the
appellate court allowed the opposite party-club to perform
Durga Puja in the suit property meaning thereby in a
portion of premises No. 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street
which is admittedly the property of the petitioners as
indicated in the schedule of the plaint.
When the learned trial judge after considering the
materials produced by the respective parties rejected the
prayer for injunction in respect of premises No. 10/10,
Nepal Bhattacharjee Street, this Court is of the considered
view that the learned judge of the appellate court without
assigning any reasons could not have allowed the opposite
party-club to organize and perform Puja on premises No.
premises No. 10/10, Nepal Bhattacharjee Street.
The
effect of the order impugned amounts to reversing and/or
modifying the order passed by the learned judge of the
appellate court and granting the final relief at the interim
stage without assigning reason which is impermissible.
It is well-settled that in order to modify or reverse the
findings of the court of first instance, the appellate court
ought to have considered the reasons assigned by the
learned trial judge and then assign its reasons for coming
to a different conclusion while reversing and/or modifying
the order of the trial judge.
When the plaintiff/opposite party club failed to satisfy
even prima facie that they have any right over premises
no. 10/10, the learned Judge of the Appellate Court could
not have permitted the opposite party club to perform
Durga Puja celebration on premises no. 10/10.
The learned Judge of the Appellate Court failed to
perform its duty of an appellate court. The order impugned
in bereft of any reasons. For all the reasons as aforesaid,
this Court is inclined to interfere with the impugned order.
Accordingly the order dated 03.09.2026 passed by the
learned Additional District Judge 12th Court at Alipore is
set aside.
The learned Additional District Judge, 12th Court at
Alipore is requested to take up the hearing of the
Miscellaneous Appeal No.196 of 2026 and dispose of the
same by passing a reasoned order as expeditiously as
possible without granting any unnecessary adjournments
to either of the parties. Needless to mention that if any
interlocutory application is pending or may be filed by any
of the party, the same shall also be disposed of as
expeditiously as possible and in accordance with law.
It is clarified that the observations made hereinabove
are only for the purpose of supporting the ultimate
conclusion arrived at by this Court in this order. The
learned judge of the appellate court while deciding the
miscellaneous
connection
appeal
thereto
or
shall
any
application
decide
the
filed
same
in
being
uninfluenced by any observations made hereinbefore and
in accordance with law.
Accordingly, CO 3141 of 2026 stands disposed of.
There will be no order as to costs.
All parties shall act on the server copy of this order
duly downloaded from the official website of this Court.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review