The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. For the foregoing facts and circumstances, there being no infirmity in the selection process, this writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
18. No order as to costs.” Before us, the learned advocate representing the appellant (being the writ petitioner) essentially reiterated the submissions made before the learned Single Judge. He also took us through the relevant documents including the letter of the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) dated 12th January, 2017, addressed to the appellant/writ petitioner and her reply dated 21st January, 2017. On the other hand, the learned advocate representing HPCL has also taken us through various documents including HPCL‟s letter dated 29th March, 2017, whereby, the appellant/writ petitioner was categorically informed regarding her letter dated 21st January, 2017, wherein she had mentioned that the plot offered by her had a frontage of 125 meters, which was not matching with the frontage of the plot as given in her original application, sketch map as well as the lease deed. In the said letter dated 29th March, 2017, the HPCL has further specifically stated as follows:“In this regard please note that no change in offered land dimension is allowed.” Learned advocate representing HPCL has also taken us to the format of Land Evaluation conducted by a Land Evaluation Committee (LEC), which had found the land to be not suitable. Learned advocate representing the HPCL has also referred to the typed copy of the original application provides for the layout sketch of the land off…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.08
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.11/2021
Date of Order: 01.10.2021
Biolin Kurbah
Vs.
Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. & anr
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. K. Khan, Sr.Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr.Adv with
Ms. P. Biswakarma, Adv for R/1
Mr. L. Lyngdoh, Adv for R/2
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The instant writ appeal arises in respect of a judgment and order dated
9th December, 2019, passed by a learned Single Judge in WP (C) No.466 of
2018 (Smti. Biolin Kurbah v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited &
anr). By the impugned judgment and order, the learned Single Judge proceeded
to dismiss the writ petition.
The appellant before us is the writ petitioner.
The brief facts of the case are as follows:The respondent No.1 (Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited) on
5th November, 2014, had put up an advertisement in the Local Dailies
for appointment of Regular/Rural Retail Outlet Dealerships, in East
Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya. The writ petitioner, accordingly, had
applied for the same and submitted the particulars, which the
respondents however found wanting and by letter dated 24 th October,
2016, the writ petitioner was requested to make some corrections in
the documents which had been submitted earlier. The pleaded case of
the writ petitioner is that even after submission of the corrected
documents, the respondent, vide letter dated 12th January, 2017,
rejected the application of the writ petitioner on the ground that the
writ petitioner‟s candidature was not found to be eligible for allotment
of the Dealership as the land offered did not meet the National
Highway norms. The writ petitioner, thereafter, against the said
rejection had filed a representation on 21st January, 2017, before the
respondent No. 1, but the same was also rejected for reasons stated
therein. Being aggrieved, the writ petitioner assailed the impugned
decision of the respondent No. 1 by filing a writ petition.
A plain reading of the impugned judgment and order reveals that the
learned Single Judge heard out the matter extensively after exchange of
affidavits. After considering all aspects of the matter, the learned Single
Judge came to the following conclusion:“13. From the materials it is seen that the petitioner had preferred an
appeal before the respondent No. 1 on 21.01.2017 and at Para-2, 3
and 4 of the said appeal, submitted that the plot had a frontage of 125
meter and distance of 17 meters from the 3.5 meters road from the
edge of the frontage, and projected therein that with the new
permutation and combination of the measurements of the same
location, the same would come within the norms as stipulated by the
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. It is to be noted that this
redefinition was not as per the submitted application wherein it was
clearly stated that the frontage was 100 meters. The respondent No. 1
by letter dated 29.3.2017 rejected the said appeal for reconsideration
citing the non-compliance of Dealers Selection Guidelines, 2014.
14. Another pertinent fact which is noted by this Court is the letter in
which the petitioner has taken to be the foundation for her case, which
had allowed her to correct and file additional documents is dated
24.10.2016. The Land Evaluation Committee report dated 27.12.2016
which is subsequent to the said letter (annexed to show cause of the
respondent No. 1 filed on 11.10.2019) was based on an evaluation
which was conducted in the presence of the petitioner and duly signed
on that day itself by her, which showed the frontage and size of land
the same as had been submitted earlier in the application. The said
report also indicated that the land was unsuitable as it did not meet the
NHAI norms. The shifting stand of the petitioner therefore does not
convince this Court as to the genuineness of her claim or that the
respondent No. 1 arbitrarily rejected her application even after
rectification.
15. As aforementioned the allotment of Retail Outlets is to be as per
the stated guidelines coupled with the prescribed norms of NHAI. In
the instant case, firstly the contention of the petitioner that she had
been allowed to submit additional documents with regard to the
offered plot does not seem to be a valid ground, inasmuch as, the
submission as far as it concerned the location was only limited to „the
location name mentioned in the advocate‟s letter‟. The guidelines as
given in Note „d‟ to Clause „L‟ has specifically stipulated that
rectified or additional documents would be accepted only if they are
pertaining to the information provided in the application form. The
petitioner by her representation seeking to redefine the dimensions,
will not come within the meaning of the permitted rectification or an
additional document. Further, the petitioner having participated in the
Evaluation conducted by the LEC and not having raised any
objections as to the findings, that too the same which was conducted
on 27.12.2016 much after the letter dated 24.10.2016 had been
communicated to the petitioner, it cannot be held that the respondent
No. 1 had acted unreasonably or arbitrarily in rejecting the
petitioner‟s application.
16. The judgment so placed by learned counsel for the respondent No.
2, though more of persuasive value is relevant as the judgment was
rendered in more or less similar facts in which the Bombay High
Court had also taken into consideration the prescribed guidelines for
allotment of Retail Outlets.
17. For the foregoing facts and circumstances, there being no
infirmity in the selection process, this writ petition is accordingly
dismissed.
18. No order as to costs.”
Before us, the learned advocate representing the appellant (being the
writ petitioner) essentially reiterated the submissions made before the
learned Single Judge. He also took us through the relevant documents
including the letter of the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
(HPCL) dated 12th January, 2017, addressed to the appellant/writ petitioner
and her reply dated 21st January, 2017. On the other hand, the learned
advocate representing HPCL has also taken us through various documents
including HPCL‟s letter dated 29th March, 2017, whereby, the appellant/writ
petitioner was categorically informed regarding her letter dated 21st January,
2017, wherein she had mentioned that the plot offered by her had a frontage
of 125 meters, which was not matching with the frontage of the plot as given
in her original application, sketch map as well as the lease deed. In the said
letter dated 29th March, 2017, the HPCL has further specifically stated as
follows:“In this regard please note that no change in offered land dimension is
allowed.”
Learned advocate representing HPCL has also taken us to the format
of Land Evaluation conducted by a Land Evaluation Committee (LEC),
which had found the land to be not suitable. Learned advocate representing
the HPCL has also referred to the typed copy of the original application
signed by the appellant/writ petitioner on 27th December, 2016, which
provides for the layout sketch of the land offered by her with the following
declaration:“I hereby confirm that the above mentioned details of the plot offered
by me are correct and site has been inspected by the Company
Officials as mentioned below I also understand that in case any of the
details mentioned above are found incorrect or the site is found
unsuitable by the Corporation for any reason whatsoever then I would
have no claim on the dealership of this location.”
According to the learned advocate representing HPCL, the letter
written by the appellant/writ petitioner dated 21st January, 2017, (which
contains a revised sketch map), tantamounts to effecting a change in the land
dimension originally offered, which is not permissible.
After considering the respective submissions made by the learned
advocates for the parties and upon perusing the impugned judgment and
order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 9th December, 2019, we are
of the view that all the points which have been raised before us have been
meticulously considered by the learned Single Judge and have been
extensively dealt with in the impugned judgment and order. In an IntraCourt Mandamus appeal, interference is usually warranted only when
palpable infirmities or perversities are noticed. On a plain reading of the
impugned judgment and order, we do not notice any such infirmity or
perversity. Rather, we find that the judgment and order is supported with
cogent and justifiable reasons. There is no doubt – in the fact of the instant
case – that the appellant/writ petitioner, by her representation dated 21st
January, 2017, was essentially seeking to redefine the original land
dimensions and the same cannot come within the meaning of permitted
rectification or an additional document. The learned Single Judge has even
taken note of this fact, as also the fact that the appellant/writ petitioner,
having participated in the evaluation conducted by a Land Evaluation
Committee (LEC), had not raised any objection to its finding and as such it
cannot be held that the concerned authority had acted unreasonably or
arbitrarily in rejecting the application of the appellant/writ petitioner.
For reason stated above, we do not find any merit in the instant IntraCourt Mandamus appeal, which is liable to be dismissed and stands
accordingly dismissed along with MC (WA) No.59 of 2021.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
01.10.2021
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review