Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:JHHC:58]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND, RANCHI
----
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
----
Binod Chandra Jha, aged about 69 years son of late
Ratneshwar Jha, resident of D-2/12, New Officers Flat, New
Nepal House, Doranda, PO and PS Doranda, District Ranchi,
Jharkhand
.... Petitioner
--
Versus
--
The State of Jharkhand, through Anti Corruption Bureau
.... Opposite Party
---CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
--For the Petitioner
:-
Mr. Ajit Kumar, Senior Advocate
Ms. Akriti Shree, Advocate
Mr. Kshitiz Priyanshu, Advocate
For the State (ACB)
:-
Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
----
3/05.01.2026
Heard Mr. Ajit Kumar, the learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner and the learned counsel appearing on
-1-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
behalf of the respondent State (ACB).
2.
This application has been filed for grant of regular bail
to the petitioner in connection with A.C.B. P.S. Case No.09 of 2025,
registered for the offence under sections 409, 467, 469, 471, 420,
120B of Indian Penal Code and section 13(2) read with section
13(1)(c) and (d) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, pending in
court of learned Special Judge (A.C.B.), Hazaribagh.
3.
Mr. Ajit Kumar, the learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner submits that in the F.I.R., the allegation is made of
transferring of Khas Mahal land in favour of 23 persons and the
allegation against the petitioner is that the petitioner was posted as
Khas Mahal Padadhikari, Hazaribagh, and he has initiated the file for
transfer of Khas Mahal land in favour of 23 persons. He next submits
that the petitioner was posted at Hazaribagh as Khas Mahal
Padadhikari with effect from 17.01.2009 and remained in charge up to
31.01.2010. He next submits that the petitioner on 01.02.2010
(afternoon), assumed the charge of Deputy Director GPF Directorate,
Department of Finance, Ranchi and the accused/petitioner has
relinquished his charged as DPRO, Hazaribagh on 08.02.2010.
4.
By way of placing the contents of the F.I.R, Mr. Ajit Kumar, the
learned senior counsel further submits that so far as the renewal of
lease and removal of the word ‘Sewayat’ are concerned, that allegation
is not against the petitioner. He next submits that after receiving of
-2-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
the application for transfer, the petitioner has merely recommended
to the higher authorities for approval. He also submits that these
facts have been admitted by the respondent A.C.B in paragraph
nos.22, 24, 25 and 27 of the counter affidavit filed by the
respondent A.C.B. He draws the attention of the Court to the order
dated 10.08.2009 contained in Annexure-F in the counter affidavit
filed by the respondent A.C.B and submits that by the said order,
the application for transfer of the land has been instituted and the
petitioner has sought the report from the Halka Karamchari and
Kanoongo. By order dated 01.09.2009, the petitioner has forwarded
the recommendation to the Additional Collector for permission. He
next submits that thereafter there is no role of the petitioner and all
the activities have been done by other officers including the Deputy
Commissioner, Hazaribagh. He next submits that final decision of
transfer was taken on 20.8.2010 and at that time, the petitioner
was not posted at Hazaribagh.
He further submits that the
petitioner is in custody since 26.8.2025 and he has retired in the
year 2016 and he is aged about 70 years having several ailments.
He also submits that the petitioner has cooperated in the
investigation and now the charge sheet has already been submitted
against the petitioner. On these grounds, he submits that the
petitioner may kindly be granted regular bail.
5.
Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, the learned counsel appearing on
-3-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
behalf of the respondent A.C.B. has vehemently opposed the prayer
of regular bail of the petitioner and submits that in light of
Annexure-A of the counter affidavit filed by the respondent A.C.B by
way of indenture of deed of lease was given between Ganpat Rai
Sarawgi in favour of the Deity Shri Shri Mahavir Ji in 1941. He next
submits that by way of Annexure-B, in the year 1951, the said deed
was purported to be cancelled by Ganpat Rai Sarawgi which was
issued in favour of the Deity Shri Shri Mahavir Ji. He next submits
that in light of Annexure-C at page 36 of the counter affidavit, the
Sewayats of the said Deity filed another application for renewal of
lease. He next submits that by order dated 12.12.1988, the lease
was again renewed in favour of the Deity Shri Shri Mahavir Ji and
earlier cancellation deed was issued by Ganpat Rai Sarawgi which
was rejected. He next submits that another transfer permission case
was registered which was rejected by the order of Commissioner,
North
Chhotanagpur
Division,
Hazaribagh
vide
order
dated
01.07.2000 which was challenged before the High Court in C.W.J.C
No.4200 of 2000. He then submits that there is clear observation of
the High Court wherein it was held that Hiralal Shetty and Pannalal
Shetty who are the successor-in-interest or any person who took
the charge of the Sevayat had no role to transfer the land in favour
of other persons and the High Court has held that the Commissioner
has rightly refused to grant permission for transfer of lease hold
-4-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
land. He then submits that the High Court order was not respected
by the petitioner and others and in spite of that, the transfer has
been made in favour of 23 persons.
He then submits that the
petitioner has initiated the transfer by order dated 10.8.2009 and
another proposal was also made by the petitioner at page 93 dated
01.09.2009 and that is within the short period of time. On these
grounds, he submits that regular bail of the petitioner may kindly be
rejected.
6.
In view of above submission of the learned counsels
appearing for the parties, the Court has gone through the materials
on ground including the contents of the FIR and finds that the
allegations are made of transferring Khas Mahal lease land in favour
of 23 persons.
From the documents brought on record by way of
filing counter affidavit by the A.C.B., it transpires that in the year
1941 the same was in favour of Ganpat Rai Sarawgi in the year
1951 it was again tried to be cancelled. In the year 1941 itself, the
said land was donated to Shri Shri Mahavir Ji by Ganpat Rai Sarawgi
and again the cancellation was sought to be done by the said
Ganpat Rai Sawargi which was in favour of Shri Shri Mahavir Ji. By
way of Annexure-C at page 36, dated 10.8.1985 the other Sevayats
have again filed the petition for renewal of lease. By Annexure-D at
page 72, dated 12.12.1988 lease was again renewed in favour of
Shri Shri Mahavir Ji. The observation of the High Court is also there
-5-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
in the aforesaid CWJC. The petitioner was posted as Khas Mahal
Officer in Hazaribagh with effect from 17.01.2009 and 31.01.2010.
There are two orders of the petitioner of initiation for transfer of
land and further recommendation to the Additional Collector for
approval of permission which is dated 01.09.2009 and apart from
that, other orders have been passed by others and subsequent
orders have not been passed by the petitioner and the petitioner is
in custody since 26.08.2025 and he has already retired in the year
2016 and it has been pointed out that the petitioner is aged about
70 years and is also having some ailments and charge sheet has
already been submitted against the petitioner and it has been
pointed out that the petitioner has co-operated in the investigation.
In course of argument, Mr. Gadodia, the learned counsel for the
respondent ACB has argued that Sevayats are not coming forward
before the ACB for investigation and for that, the respondent ACB is
competent to find out the Sevayats who are not appearing before
the A.C.B. So far as this petitioner is concerned, he is already in
custody since 26.08.2025 and charge sheet has already been
submitted against the petitioner, and in that view of the matter,
I am inclined to grant regular bail to the petitioner, and accordingly,
the petitioner, above named, shall be released on bail, subject to
the condition that on furnishing bail bond of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees
Twenty Five Thousand), with two sureties of like amount each, to
-6-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
satisfaction of learned Special Judge (A.C.B.), Hazaribagh, in
connection with A.C.B. P.S. Case No.09 of 2025 as well as one of
the bailors will be close relative of the petitioner.
7.
The petitioner shall not leave the State of Jharkhand
without prior permission of the learned trial court and he shall
submit his Passport before the learned trial court. He shall remain
present before the learned trial court on each and every date of
hearing, except, in exceptional circumstances, on a particular date
on permission of the court the petitioner may be exempted from
appearance for that particular date and he shall fully cooperate for
the timely conclusion of the pending proceeding.
( Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
Dated: 05th January, 2026
SI/
-7-
B.A. No.9487 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review