Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1096
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (EP) No. 4 of 2024 with
MC (EP) No. 5 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 6 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 8 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 9 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 10 of 2024 in
EL Pet. No. 2 of 2023
Date of Decision: 28.11.2024
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem
… Applicant(s)
Versus
Shri Titosstar Well Chyne
S/o R. Diantonath Khyllep
R/o Khliehshnong, Sohra
Opposite R.K.M. Mission Higher Secondary School,
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793111
… Respondent(s)
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem
Versus
Jiedkupar Kynta
S/o Korbar Sing Lyndem
R/o 323 Sohra,
St. John Bosco Boys, Maraikaphon,
Cherrapunjee, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793108
… Applicant(s)
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem
Versus
Biiosley Malngiang
S/o Biantimai Malngiang
R/o 193, Maraikaphon, Cherrapunjee,
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793108
… Applicant(s)
… Respondent(s)
… Respondent(s)
2024:MLHC:1096
Shri Titosstar Well Chyne
… Applicant(s)
Versus
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem,
S/o Shri Winston Mark Simon Pariat, aged about 31 years,
R/o House No. 171, Umthli Village, Umthli,
S.O. East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793110.
.. Respondent(s)
Shri Jiedkupar Kynta
… Applicant(s)
Versus
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem,
S/o Shri Winston Mark Simon Pariat, aged about 31 years,
R/o House No. 171, Umthli Village, Umthli,
S.O. East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793110.
.. Respondent(s)
Shri Biiosley Malngiang
… Applicant(s)
Versus
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem,
S/o Shri Winston Mark Simon Pariat, aged about 31 years,
R/o House No. 171, Umthli Village, Umthli,
S.O. East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya-793110.
.. Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance: in MC (EP) No. 4 of 2024 with
MC (EP) No. 5 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 6 of 2024
For the Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s): Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv. with
Mr. A.M Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N. Jotendra Singh,Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharshiing, Adv.
_________________________________________________________
2024:MLHC:1096
Appearance: in MC (EP) No. 8 of 2024 with
MC (EP) No. 9 of 2024
MC (EP) No. 10 of 2024
For the Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s): Mr. N. Jotendra Singh,Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharshiing, Adv.
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv. with
Mr. A.M Pala, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This batch of Misc. applications arising out of the main
Election petition being Election Petition No. 2 of 2023, substantially
on the same issue i.e. the questions that have arisen from the evidence
on affidavit filed by the election petitioner and supporting witnesses
are being disposed of by this common order.
2.
This Court in course of the proceedings in the main
election petition by order dated 04.04.2024 after the list of witnesses
had been filed on behalf of the parties had fixed 13.04.2024, for cross
examination of 3 PWs and had directed that the evidence on affidavit
2024:MLHC:1096
be filed before the next date. Thereafter, on the filing of the evidence
on affidavit, the matter was fixed on 18.06.2024, but on that date
before the commencement of the proceedings, the learned counsel on
behalf of the election petitioner submitted that due to inadvertence, a
wrong date had been entered in the evidence on affidavit and a prayer
was made that the petitioner be allowed to file a proper application for
withdrawal of the same and for filing of a correct affidavit. The prayer
of the election petitioner was allowed, and it was provided that
objections, if any were to be filed a week before the next date fixed.
Accordingly, an application seeking leave to replace the statement was
filed by the election petitioner and the same was registered as MC (El.
Pet.) No. 8 of 2024. The other 2 witnesses also filed similar
applications for corrections and the same were numbered as MC (El.
Pet.) No. 9 of 2024 and MC (El. Pet.) No. 10 of 2024, respectively. To
these applications, the respondents had filed objections/replies.
3.
At this juncture, it is necessary to note that prior to the
filing of applications for corrections of the evidence on affidavit by the
petitioner, the respondents had filed an application under Section 379
Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2024 (BNSS) r/w Section 193,
2024:MLHC:1096
Indian Penal Code, 1860 r/w Section 229 Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita,
2023 (BNS) r/w Section 528 Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2024,
with a prayer that criminal proceedings be initiated against the election
petitioner by initiating an inquiry under Section 379 BNSS, 2024. This
application was made for declaration that the election petitioner had
prima facie intentionally given false evidence, for being used in
judicial proceedings before this Court, and for other appropriate
orders. This Misc. Case was registered as MC (El. Pet.) No. 4 of 2024,
and similar applications against the 2 other witnesses were also filed
and were numbered as MC (El. Pet.) No. 5 of 2024 and MC (El. Pet.)
No. 6 of 2024, respectively.
4.
With regard to the Misc. applications filed by the election
petitioner for recall of the statement filed on affidavit, the reasons as
set out have been given Para-3 of the said application, which is
reproduced hereinbelow:-
“3. That due to inadvertent and bona fide mistake, some
errors have occurred in para No. 6 of the Statement
(Examination-in-Chief)
on
affidavit
of
the
Applicant/Petitioner i.e. P.W. No. 1 namely Shri
Titosstar Well Chyne filed on 20/05/2024 while
2024:MLHC:1096
mentioning the date as “12/04/2023” instead of the
correct date “11/04/2023” and one sentence is also
omitted at the end of para No. 8 due to typographical
and cut and copy paste by our typist/Clerk.”
5.
In support of the application, it has been submitted that
the corrections which are sought to be incorporated has been made at
the stage when only the statement (Examination-in-Chief) on affidavit
of the election petitioner (PW No. 1) had been filed and that the same
has not yet been taken up on record, inasmuch as, no exhibit has been
marked so far by the PW No. 1 and that he has not yet appeared for the
purposes of his cross examination. The confirmation or denial it is
contended, of the contents of the affidavit of the election petitioner has
not yet been recorded, which is necessary either to confirm or differ
with the contents thereof, which shall then on being recorded form part
of the evidence of the petitioner.
6.
The learned Senior counsel in support of his submissions
placed reliance on the following cases, wherein a similar situation has
arisen: i)
O.M. Prakash Agarwal vs. Smt. Sudha Agarwal
(Jharkhand High Court) in Testamentary Suit No. 1 of
2017 with I.A. No. 10594 of 2019 decided on 18.01.2020.
2024:MLHC:1096
ii)
7.
Sudir Engineering Company vs. NITCO Roadways Ltd.,
reported in (1995) 34 DRJ 86 (Delhi High Court)
It is submitted that by applying the ratio of the above
judgments, this Court would have to appreciate that the matter is now
at the first stage, inasmuch as, the Examination-in-Chief in the form of
an affidavit by the petitioner and other witnesses, are yet to become
part of the judicial record. As such, he submits the petitioner may be
allowed to replace the statements (Examination-in-Chief) on affidavit
of the election petitioner filed on 20.05.2024, by fresh corrected copies
of statements (Examination-in-Chief) on affidavit, and that the other 2
witnesses be also allowed the same.
8.
In reply to the submissions, Mr. A.S. Pandey, learned
counsel for the respondent has submitted that there exists a prima facie
case that the election petitioner and other witnesses, have given false
evidence before this Court and that in the interest of administration of
justice, they are liable to be prosecuted in accordance with law.
Reverting to the chain of events, the learned counsel submits that the
election petition was signed and the petition along with a verification
2024:MLHC:1096
and affidavit was notarized on 11.04.2023, with the Instrument No.
205 by the Notary. However, he submits the Examination-in-Chief on
affidavit filed on behalf of the election petitioner and 2 other witnesses
states that they had come before the Oath Commissioner on
12.04.2023 and these affidavits, form the basis of the applications with
regard to perjury/false evidence, for which the election petitioner
should be prosecuted. In the affidavit he submits, a reading of the same
would indicate that the election petitioner and the witnesses left Sohra
for Shillong on 12.04.2023, that they had reached the Notary at about
2:00 P.M. where oath was administered and notarization effected, and
that at about 3:00 P.M. of the same day, they entered the High Court
premises for the purposes of presentation. The deposition he contends
shows that all acts were undertaken on 12.04.2023, but however when
the date was fixed for cross-examination, the counsel for the election
petitioner requested that he be allowed to move an application to
correct the false affidavit on the ground that the same was an
inadvertent and bona fide mistake, wherein 12.04.2023 has been
mentioned, instead of the correct date which is 11.04.2023.
2024:MLHC:1096
9.
It is submitted by the learned counsel that prima facie the
ingredients of Section 191 of the IPC are present, inasmuch as, the
witnesses have collectively deposed that the election petition was
sworn and notarized on 12.04.2023, whereas the stamp/seal and noting
made by Notary, clearly reveals that the act of notarization and
preparation of the election petition happened on 11.04.2023. He further
submits that the witnesses by seeking replacement of statements made
in the evidence on affidavit, which is an admission that the entire
exercise of tendering the evidence being a copy paste job, shows that
the evidence given by the other witnesses is not bona fide and have
been made on instructions of the election petitioner. Learned counsel
has then referred to the order dated 31.10.2023 passed by this Court in
MC (EP) No. 19/2023, which required the election petitioner to prove
by way of evidence that the election petition was presented personally
to the Stamp Reporter, and has submitted that instead, the election
petitioner and the other witnesses have admittedly led false evidence in
collusion with each other. The replacement applications, it is
contended, has brought about a new version which is different from the
already filed affidavits, wherein the witnesses have sworn that the
entire events happened in one single day i.e. 12.04.2023, and as such
2024:MLHC:1096
the replacement applications are irreconcilable with the existing
narration of facts as contained in the affidavits already filed. The
learned counsel has then placed Order 18 Rule 4 of the CPC, which
details the procedure with regard to the recording of evidence, and
submits that the Examination-in-Chief, must happen by way of
affidavit and the remaining parts of the evidence i.e. cross-examination
and re-examination must happen in attendance before the Court. As
such, he submits once the Examination-in-Chief is recorded on
affidavit after being sworn before the Oath Commissioner or Notary,
then the same cannot be withdrawn as it becomes part and parcel of the
evidence of that witness. In support of his arguments, the learned
counsel has cited the following decisions: -
10.
i)
Rasiklal Manikchand Dariwal & Anr. vs. M.S.S. Food
Products (2012) 2 SCC 196
ii)
Banganga Coop. Housing Society Ltd. vs. Vasanti Gajanan
Nerurkar, 2015 SCC OnLine Bom 3411
The learned counsel then submits that the above noted
judgments have laid down the law that no evidence on affidavit can be
allowed to be withdrawn, as it is evidence, as soon as it is affirmed. In
2024:MLHC:1096
concluding his submissions, the learned counsel has asserted that the
witnesses have adduced false evidence regarding a material question in
issue, have resorted to collusion to make false statements, offered no
explanation as to the falsehood, but instead have admitted the same
and sought to replace the statements so made. As such, the fact that the
election petitioner has not complied with the provisions of the RP Act,
1951 and the Gauhati High Court Rules in presenting the election
petition being clear, he prays that appropriate action be taken by this
Court in accordance with Section 379 of the BNSS and further pass
orders that the witnesses have prima facie led false evidence in terms
of Section 191 and 193 of the IPC.
11.
On hearing the learned counsel, and on examination of the
materials on record, the issues that arise for consideration before this
Court are :(i)
Whether the election petitioner and the other 2
witnesses are liable to be prosecuted in terms of
Section 379 of the BNSS, 2023 read with Section 193
of the IPC, 1860 read with Section 229 of BNS, 2023
2024:MLHC:1096
(ii)
Whether the affidavit sworn before the Oath
Commissioner/Notary
Public
and
filed
as
Examination-in-Chief can be allowed to be replaced.
Before addressing the first issue as given hereinabove, the
second issue which is of more importance, shall be discussed first. As
the main issue revolves around Order 18 Rule 4 (1) of the CPC, the
same for the sake of convenience is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“4. Recording of evidence.- (1) In every case, the
examination-in-chief of a witness shall be on affidavit
and copies thereof shall be supplied to the opposite party
by the party who calls him for evidence.
Provided that where documents are filed and the
parties rely upon the documents, the proof and
admissibility of such documents which are filed
alongwith the affidavit shall be subject to the orders of
the Court.”
12.
Order 18 Rule 4 stipulates that what is stated in the
affidavit will constitute the Examination-in-Chief, and as such would
normally mean that once an affidavit is affirmed, it requires no further
steps for it to be considered the Examination-in-Chief of the deponent.
However, this will necessarily be subject to the scrutiny of the Court
for it to become evidence and in this regard, cannot override the
2024:MLHC:1096
Evidence Act (BNA). At this juncture therefore, it would be expedient
to examine and discuss the judgments that have been placed by the
parties. In the judgment of O.M. Prakash Agarwal vs. Smt. Sudha
Agarwal (supra) of the Jharkhand High Court which has been cited by
the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner, this judgment had relied
upon a judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of Sri
Mohammed Abdul Ahmad vs. Sri Mohammed Abdul Gafoor @
Ahmed reported in 2013 AIR CC 745 (AP), wherein it was held that an
affidavit is merely an affidavit and if the witness confirmed the
affidavit, the affidavit would then become part of the statement made
by the deponent before the Court. Taking this ratio, it was held that
only when the concerned witness appears before the Court for the
purposes of confirmation of his Evidence-in-Chief, that the same is
said to have been taken on record. In the next judgment i.e. Sudir
Engineering Company vs. NITCO Roadways Ltd., (supra) the same
speaks about three stages with regard to a document filed by either
party before it is held proved or disproved. In the considered view of
this Court the latter judgment, will have no application to the instant
case, inasmuch as, the same relates to proving of documents which
2024:MLHC:1096
have been filed by the parties, whereas in the instant case it is a
question of a statement made on oath.
13.
In the first judgment relied upon by the respondent i.e.
Rasiklal Manikchand Dariwal & Anr. vs. M.S.S. Food Products
(supra) the Supreme Court has outlined the objective of Order 18 Rule
4 of the CPC i.e. the speedy trial of a case to save the precious time of
the Court and at Para-77 thereof, an extract which is quoted
hereinbelow, it has been held as follows:-
“……Where the examination-in-chief of a witness is
produced in the form of an affidavit, such affidavit is
always sworn before the Oath Commissioner or the
notary or judicial officer or any other person competent
to administer oath. The examination-in-chief is, thus,
on oath already.”
The other judgment placed by the learned counsel for the
respondents i.e. Banganga Coop. Housing Society Ltd. vs. Vasanti
Gajanan Nerurkar (supra) which is a judgment of the Bombay High
Court, wherein the decision rendered in Rasiklal Manikchand
Dariwal has also been discussed, apart from other decisions, to the
mind of this Court has great persuasive value. This is because the
2024:MLHC:1096
issues that arise in relation to affidavits in lieu of Examination-in-Chief
has been discussed minutely. In Para-5 of the said judgment these
questions and issues have been given as follows:
“5. In all these matter a common question of law has
arisen. It pertains to Order XVIII Rule 4 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (“CPC”) and some of the issues
that arise in relation to affidavits in lieu of examinationin-chief. Some of these questions and issues are : Is it
permissible for a Court to order the deletion or redaction
of any portion of any such affidavit if that part is found
to be inadmissible as evidence? If so, at what stage of the
proceedings should this be done? Can a party ‘withdraw’
an evidence affidavit without consequence? Can an
evidence affidavit, once filed, ever be ‘returned’? What
are the consequences if an affidavit is filed and then it is
found, perhaps a long time later, that the deponent of
that evidence affidavit is either unavailable or cannot be
tendered for cross-examination? Where documents are
admitted in evidence on the basis of an evidence affidavit
and the witness is then not made available or tendered
for cross-examination, how are those documents to be
treated? These, and other allied questions, all arise with
regularity in suits.”
14.
The same judgment then goes on to discuss the Rasiklal
Manikchand Dariwal case and at Para-10 and 12 has held as follows:“10. In Rasiklal Manikchand Dhariwal v. MSS Food
Products the Supreme Court considered a submission by
the appellants that the evidence led by the plaintiff was
no evidence at all since the deponents of the Evidence
Affidavits had never entered the witness box to confirm
the contents of their Evidence Affidavits. Both FDC Ltd.
and Ameer Trading were cited in support of this
2024:MLHC:1096
submission. The two decisions were considered at length.
The Rasiklal Manikchand court held that Ameer
Trading, in agreeing with FDC Ltd., did not enunciate
an invariable or absolute rule that in every appealable
case, a witness or deponent must necessarily re-affirm
his Evidence Affidavit from the witness box and confirm
its contents and his signature on it. Indeed, where that
statement is on oath or affirmation before a notary,
judicial officer or oath commissioner (or anyone else
empowered to administer oath), the examination-in-chief
is already on affidavit. There is, the Supreme Court said,
no requirement in Order XVIII Rule 5 that even in
appealable cases a witness must enter the witness box for
production of his affidavit and formally prove his
affidavit. The witness is required in the witness box for
cross-examination and re-examination if any; but he or
she is not invariably or always required to step into the
witness box for examination-in-chief.
12. What is not in doubt is that there can never be a
withdrawal of an Evidence Affidavit just as there can
never be a withdrawal of an examination-in-chief
conducted directly in Court. This position, following
Rasiklal Manikchand, raises some subsidiary question:
(1) what are the consequences of a deponent filing an
Evidence Affidavit but not making himself available to a
cross-examination? (2) Is it permissible for a Court to
order the expunging or redaction of any part of an
Evidence Affidavit?”
However, notwithstanding the position as maintained
above, it has been further held in Para-18 by taking recourse to Order
18 Rule 4 as follows:“18. I do not think there is any authority for the proposition
that no objection can be taken to any part of the Evidence
Affidavit, and that the whole of it, irrespective of what it
purports to contain, must be treated as ‘evidence’. Indeed
2024:MLHC:1096
Ameer Trading and FDC Ltd. both suggest the converse is true
and this position at least is undisturbed even in Rasikal
Manikchand. The option available to the Court is to order a
redaction of so much of the affidavit as does not constitute
evidence properly so-called. This is self evident from the
provisions of Order XVIII Rule 4……”
Though the interplay of Order 18 Rule 4 and Section 1 of
the Indian Evidence Act has also been discussed, inasmuch as, Section
1, provides that the Act shall apply to all judicial proceedings as given
therein, ‘but not to affidavits presented to any Court or officer, nor to
proceedings before an Arbitrator’, this judgment has however clarified
in Paras 26 and 27 as follows:“26. Order XVIII Rule 4 requires two things : (1) what
is stated must constitute examination-in-chief; (2) it must
be stated in the form of an affidavit. Order XVIX tells us
what an affidavit cannot contain and to what it must be
restricted; and the Evidence Act tells us what can
constitute examination-in-chief or evidence and what
cannot. Therefore, it any portion of a purported
Evidence Affidavit does not conform to these two
exacting requirements, it is simply not examination-inchief at all and cannot be allowed to pass into the
evidentiary record of the trial. It would, in my view, not
only be incorrect by wholly against legislative intent to
suggest that merely because the material is in the form of
an affidavit that the powers of a court are somehow
denuded and that anything and everything stated in that
affidavit automatically and without checks or balances
passes into the realm of ‘evidence’, jettisoning in its
passage every requirement of the substantive law of the
Evidence Act. That simply cannot be, and this is the
2024:MLHC:1096
foundation of that Mr. Justice Dhanuka’s reasoning in
Khushwaha and Mahabanoo Kotwal and my own earlier
decision in Harish Loyalka.
27. As to what can or cannot be the subject matter of
such an order, I do not think any absolute standard or
rule can be set out. It may, in a given case, be that the
evidence affidavit contains material that is relevant but is
unsupported by pleadings. Cesar Rego Fernandes v.
Angela Ninette Oliveira Fernandes tells us that this is
not the kind of material that can be ordered to be struck
off. But material that is clearly irrelevant, or hearsay, in
the nature of legal submissions, arguments, in the form
of prayers or reliefs, or denials of the kind we find in
pleadings has no place in an evidence affidavit. It may be
possible to illustrate this with an example from
testamentary law. A probate petition, it is well settled,
does not decide questions of title. Therefore, whether or
not the testator had valid title to any given property
mentioned in the will propounded is entirely irrelevant to
that trial. This is the basis of the decision in Khushwaha,
and testimony in that regard was therefore excluded. But
in a given case, a witness may depose that it is to his (the
witness’s knowledge) that the testator was aware at the
time of the making of the will that a certain property was
not his. This may possibly be retained as being relevant
to an issue of unsoundness of mind or undue influence.
The distinction to be drawn, and drawn carefully, is
whether the deponent says this as a matter of conjecture
or personal knowledge. I would suggest that in a matter
where there is the slightest doubt, then the material
should be retained and not deleted or struck off. That
power, while available to a court in its inherent
jurisdiction, must be exercised cautiously and
judiciously, and no cut-and-dried one-size-fits-all
formulaic approach is possible.”
(Emphasis supplied)
And at Para-28, it has concluded as follows:-
2024:MLHC:1096
“28. The result of this discussion is that:
(a) No Evidence Affidavit under Order XVIII
Rule 4 of the CPC can be allowed to be ‘withdrawn’. It is
evidence as soon as it is affirmed.
(b) The Evidence Affidavit cannot contain matter that
is irrelevant, inadmissible or both; or is in the nature of
arguments, submissions or prayers. This is not ‘evidence’
as required by law. Were it to be attempted from the
witness box, it would not be permitted; and hence it
cannot be allowed to creep in merely because it happens
to be placed on affidavit.
(c) It is permissible, and in fact often necessary, for a
Court, with a view to expedition and to avoid a needlessly
protracted cross-examination on irrelevancies and
matter that is not ‘evidence’ to order that any such
material that does not constitute evidence be struck off or
be ordered or directed to be ignored without fear of
adverse consequences.
(d) Where an Evidence Affidavit is filed and the
witness or deponent, though otherwise available, is not
made available for cross-examination, the wellestablished consequences in law will follow. Specifically,
the opposite party will be entitled to submit that an
adverse inference be drawn against such a witness or the
party who fails to produce that witness for crossexamination; and, further, that should that evidence
contain any admissions, these may be used by the other
party; but so much of the evidence as is against the party
entitled to cross-examination but which has gone
untested for want of production of the witness will be
liable to be ignored.”
15.
In the backdrop of this legal position, in considering the
facts of this case, what can clearly be seen is that the redaction or
2024:MLHC:1096
recall of that part of the Evidence on Affidavit which has been sought
for by the election petitioner is with regard to a statement that has been
made on oath as to the date of the presentation of the Election Petition,
which is in variance with the statements made in the body of the
Election Petition. It is not a case where the statement made is of no
relevance, or that the recall sought is of documents that are yet to be
proved, but is a statement which touches the core issue in dispute. The
Courts in such situations can well exercise discretionary powers to
allow redaction or replacement or deletion, if the same in its
considered view is of not much relevance. As all cases stand on their
own peculiar footing or circumstance, a common yardstick in the
exercise of this inherent power, is not available and this power
necessarily will have to be judiciously exercised taking into
consideration all relevant factors. In this particular case, the statement
having been made on oath, in the considered view of this Court, the
same being vital to the proceedings of the application under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC, the prayer of the election petitioner for replacement of
the affidavit cannot be acceded to and is denied.
2024:MLHC:1096
16.
On the other issue i.e. whether the election petitioner and
the other 2 witnesses are liable to be prosecuted in terms of Section
379 of the BNSS, 2023 read with Section 193 of the IPC, 1860 read
with Section 229 of BNS, 2023, in the considered view of this Court
the purported inaccurate statement i.e. the date of presentation will not
amount to a misdemeanour or a transgression that requires inquiry or
any further orders, as the same is a contradiction in facts which the
election petitioner will have to overcome in the course of the
proceedings. As such, the Misc. applications being Misc. Case (EP)
No. 4 of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 5 of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 6
of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 8 of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 9 of
2024, and Misc. Case (EP) No. 10 of 2024 are closed.
17.
Accordingly, as ordered above these Misc. Case (EP) No. 4
of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 5 of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 6 of
2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 8 of 2024, Misc. Case (EP) No. 9 of 2024
and Misc. Case (EP) No. 10 of 2024 are disposed of.
JUDGE
2024:MLHC:1096
Meghalaya
28.11.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.11.28 17:56:46 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review