Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:41231
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 16568 of 2026
Decided on: September 25 , 2026
Bihari Lal
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
...Respondents
Coram:
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Surender Sharma, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Neeraj Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents
:
Ms. Seema
General.
Sharma,
Deputy
Advocate
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
This writ petition has been filed for the grant of following
substantive reliefs:“(i)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to grant
an opportunity to the petitioner to exercise the option
for the promotional increment after getting the benefit
of annual increment on and w.e.f. 01.01.2018 instead
of 06.10.2017 and thereafter;
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:41231
-2(ii)
The respondents may kindly be directed to re-fix the
pay of the petitioner and to grant all consequential
benefits upon such revision/refixation;
(iii)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to grant
the arrears on account of refixation of the pay of the
petitioner by changing his date of promotional
increment from 06.10.2017 to 01.01.2018 alongwith
interest @ 9% per annum.”
2.
Grievance of the petitioner was noticed as under in the
order passed in this writ petition on 23.09.2026:“Notice. Mr. Y.P.S.
Advocate
General,
accept
Dhaulta,
learned Additional
notice
on
behalf
of
the
respondents.
Petitioner’s case is that he was not given any
opportunity to exercise his option on promotion; That he was
promoted to the post of Work Inspector in October, 2017;
and that he has not been granted the benefit of
the
additional pay increment to be given on promotion. On the
contrary, his annual increment, which was due in January,
has been shifted to October.
Let learned Additional Advocate General to have
instructions in the matter.
List on 25.09.2026.”
Pursuant to above order, learned Deputy Advocate
General has placed on record office instructions dated 24.09.2026
from
the
Executive
Engineer,
Kumarsain
Division,
Kumarsain, relevant portion of which reads as under:-
HPPWD
2026:HHC:41231
-3“In this behalf, it is respectfully submitted that in
compliance to the directions passed by the Hon’ble Court
dated 23.09.2026, the petitioner has been promoted from
Mate to the post of Work Inspector vide the Engineer-inChief, HP.PWD., Shimla vide his letter No.PWE-133-2(R&P)
ES-III-2017-9863-10069 dated 29.09.2017 and joined his
duty on 06.10.2017 (FN). The petitioner increment was
falling in the month of January prior to his promotion, after
promotion to the post of Work Inspector one additional
increment on his promotion was granted to him w.e.f.
06.10.2017 accordingly, his next date of increment will be
due in the month of October 2018 after completion of twelve
months period. The petitioner has not exercised any option
to secure his annual increment which was falling in the
month of January prior to his promotion and it was not
mentioned in the promotion order. Now he is claiming the
annual increment for the month of January as and when the
petitioner submit the option the increment will be given by
the respondent on that date.”
In view of the issue involved in this writ petition, taking
note of the office
instructions, no separate reply is considered
necessary from the respondents. The matter has accordingly been
heard on the basis of aforesaid office instructions.
2(i)
Petitioner was appointed as daily waged worker in the
respondents-department during the year 1994. His services were
regularized as Mate on 18.01.2007 in the pay scale of Rs. 2520 –
4140/- (with initial start of Rs. 2620/-).
Another office order was
2026:HHC:41231
-4-
issued by the respondents on 23.09.2015 regularizing the services
of the petitioner as Mate retrospectively w.e.f. 01.01.2003.
2(ii)
one
During the year 2017 petitioner got three increments i.e.
annual
increment
on
01.01.2017,
thereafter
financial
upgradation on account of 14 years of Assured Career Progression
increment on 01.01.2017 and subsequently promotional increment
consequent upon his promotion as Work Inspector on 06.10.2017.
After petitioner’s promotion on 06.10.2017 the next date of annual
increment of the petitioner was changed and fixed as 01.10.2018.
Petitioner was promoted as Work Inspector vide office
order dated 29.09.2017 w.e.f. 06.10.2017 i.e. the date of joining as
Work Inspector. Consequent upon petitioner’s promotion as Work
Inspector w.e.f. 06.10.2017 his pay was fixed
initially in the pre-
revised pay scale and subsequently as per Himachal Pradesh Civil
Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2022.
Consequent upon fixation of
pay of petitioner, promotional increment was granted to him. As a
result of grant of promotional increment, revised basic pay of the
petitioner was fixed at Rs. 30,500/- in Cell-15.
Date of annual
increment of the petitioner was 1st of January of every year.
Petitioner earned his annual increment in this manner on 01.01.2017
till his promotion as Work Inspector w.e.f. 06.10.2017. After
petitioner’s promotion to the post of Work Inspector, date of grant of
2026:HHC:41231
-5-
annual increment to him was changed by the respondents from 1st
of January to 1st of October. Consequently, next date of annual
increment of the petitioner was somehow fixed by the respondents
as 01.10.2018. Adverse affects thereof became noticeable with the
enforcement of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Revised Pay)
Rules, 2022 (in short ‘Revised Pay Rules, 2022’) which came into
force w.e.f. 01.01.2016. Rule 8 of the Revised Pay Rules, 2022
reads as under:“8.
Fixation of pay on The fixation of pay in case of promotion from
one Level to another in the revised pay
promotion
structure shall be made in the following
manner, namely:(I) the Government employee shall progress
ahead on the horizontal range in Pay
Matrix on Promotion/ non-functional
financial upgrade;
(II) on promotion from one Level to another,
the Government employee shall have an
option to get his pay fixed in the higher
post either from the date of his
promotion or from the date of his next
increment. The option may be exercised
within a period of one month from the
date of his promotion;
(III) in case, the Government employee opts
to get his pay fixed on the higher post
from the date of his promotion, one
increment shall be given in the Level
from which the Government employee is
promoted and he shall be placed at a
Cell equal to the figure so arrived at in
the Level of the post to which promoted,
and if no such Cell is available, he shall
be placed at the next higher Cell in that
Level. The next increment in the higher
post shall be granted after completion of
qualifying service of twelve months (See
Illustration No. 11);
(IV) in case, the Government employee opts
to get his pay fixed from the date of his
next increment, in the Level of the post
2026:HHC:41231
-6from which Government employee is
promoted, his pay shall be regulated as
under: (a) from the date of promotion till his
date of next increment, the
Government employee shall be
placed at the next higher Cell in the
Level of the post to which he is
promoted;
(b) subsequently, on the date of next
increment, in the Level of the post to
which Government employee is
promoted, his pay shall be re-fixed
and two increments (one accrued on
account of annual increment and the
second accrued on account of
promotion) may be granted in the
Level from which the Government
employee is promoted and he shall
be placed, at a Cell equal to the
figure so arrived, in the Level of the
post to which he is promoted; and if
no such Cell is available in the Level
to which he is promoted, he shall be
placed at the next higher Cell in that
Level (See Illustration No. 12); and
(c) The next increment in the higher post
in this case shall be granted after
completion of qualifying service of
twelve months from the date of refixation; and
(V) In case of a Government employee, who
stand promoted between the period
from 1st day of January, 2016 to the
date of notification of these rules, the
option may be exercised by him within a
period of one month from the date of
such notification along with the option
for pay revision as per rule 6. The option
once exercised shall be final. The pay
structure of promotional post in the level
of Pay Matrix shall be corresponding to
the pay band and grade pay of such
post under the Revised (Pay) Rules,
2009.”
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner laid emphasis
upon Rule 8(II) thereof which provides that on promotion from one
2026:HHC:41231
-7-
Level to another, the Government employee shall have an option to
get his pay fixed in the higher post either
from the date of his
promotion or from the date of his next increment.
Rule 8(IV) deals with a situation where the Government
employee opts to get his
pay fixed from
the date of his next
increment. As per Rule 8(IV)(a) ‘from the date of promotion till his
date of next increment, the Government employee shall be placed
at the next higher Cell in the Level of the post to which he is
promoted’. As per Rule 8(IV)(b) ‘subsequently, on the date of next
increment, in the Level of the post to which Government employee is
promoted, his pay shall be re-fixed and two increments (one accrued
on account of annual increment and the second accrued on account
of promotion) may be granted in the Level from which the
Government employee is promoted’. As per Rule 8(IV)(c) ‘the next
increment in the higher post
in this case shall be granted after
completion of qualifying service of twelve months from the date of refixation’.
Petitioner’s case is that consequent upon revision of pay
scale, his pay was
revised and refixed vide office order dated
21.03.2023. While refixing petitioner’s pay as on 01.01.2016 was
fixed at the level corresponding to Grade Pay of Rs. 1900/-, Level-3.
After granting benefit of annual increment to the petitioner as on
2026:HHC:41231
-8-
01.01.2016 his pay was fixed
in Cell 12 i.e. Rs. 27,900/-.
Subsequently, upon grant of annual increment as on 01.01.2017,
petitioner’s basic pay was fixed in Cell-13. On completion of 14
years regular service at Mate he was also granted ACPS increment
on 01.01.2017. Petitioner’s pay was thus fixed in this manner in
Cell-14 at Rs. 29,600/-. Consequent upon petitioner’s promotion as
Work Inspector w.e.f. 06.10.2017, his pay was fixed at Cell-15 i.e.
Rs. 30,500/- with next date of annual increment as 01.10.2018.
4.
Petitioner’s grievance is that after his promotion on
06.10.2017 next date of his annual increment was changed and
fixed as 01.10.2018. He was promoted as Work Inspector w.e.f.
06.10.2017 i.e. after enforcement of Revised Pay Rules 2022
(enforced retrospectively w.e.f. 01.01.2016) and option in terms of
Rule 8 of said Rules was required to be taken from the petitioner by
the respondents within a period of one month for fixation of his pay.
It is the case of petitioner that
had opportunity
of exercising
requisite option been granted to him at the relevant time he would
have exercised option consequent upon his promotion by opting
fixation of his pay from the date of annual increment i.e. 01.01.2018;
That petitioner’s pay was required to be fixed by the respondents in
consonance with
Rule 8(IV) of the Revised Pay Rules 2022,
however, respondents have shifted and changed the date of annual
2026:HHC:41231
-9-
increment of the petitioner from 1st day of January to 1st day of
October causing him recurring financial loss.
Learned Deputy Advocate General has placed on record
office order dated 29.09.2017 wherein petitioner was promoted as
Work Inspector. Apparently, the aforesaid order promoting the
petitioner as Work Inspector did not provide him option as mandated
under Fundamental Rule (F.R.) 22 for his promotional increment.
This has not been even disputed by the respondents in the office
instructions dated 24.09.2026. It was for the respondents to have
given option to the petitioner
only then petitioner would have
exercised same for securing his annual increment. Rule 8 of the
Revised Pay Rules, 2022 also provide for option to the Government
employee for getting his pay fixed in the higher post either from the
date of his promotion or from the date of his next increment with
different procedures for both the options. Prima facie, there appears
to be substance in petitioner’s grievance that consequent upon his
promotion on 06.10.2017, promotional increment was granted to him
without seeking his option under F.R.22, which otherwise was to be
granted to him after seeking option from him and had such option
been given to him, petitioner might have opted for the promotional
increment from a prospective date i.e. after earning next annual
increment. This would have cascading effect upon his monthly salary
2026:HHC:41231
-10-
while fixing his pay in the Revised Pay Rules, 2022 which came into
force retrospectively w.e.f. 01.01.2016, however, these are facts
which require to be examined threadbare by the respondents.
In view of the above, this writ petition is disposed of with
a direction to respondent No. 2/competent authority to examine the
case of the petitioner vis-à-vis F.R. 22 and Rule 8 of the Revised
Pay Rules, 2022 for providing option to the petitioner for earning his
promotional
increment on account of his promotion as Work
Inspector as also date of annual increment within a period of four
weeks from today. In the said process, an opportunity of hearing be
also provided to the petitioner. In case it is found that option was
required to be given to the petitioner, the said exercise by giving
option & taking consequent action be also carried out within the
aforesaid period.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua,
Judge
September 25 , 2026 (PK)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review