Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:554-DB
Serial No.05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA. No. 10 of 2025
Date of Decision :09.06.2026
Shri. Bidyut Das,
S/o (L) Rajendra Chandra Das,
And (L) Lakshmi Das,
C/o Smti. Chinky Nongbet,
Quarter No. G 48,
Raj Bhawan Complex,
Shillong-793001
Meghalaya.
…Appellant
-Versus1.
The Union of India
Represented by the Ministry of
Finance Government of India.
2.
The Vijaya Bank,
A body corporate constituted under
Banking Companies (Acquisitions and Transfer
of Undertakings) Act, 1970 (Act V of 1970)
having its Head Office at No. 41/2,
M. G. Road, Bangalore - 560001, Karnataka
now merged with the Bank of Baroda;
Through the Branch Manager, Bank of Baroda,
Shillong Police Bazar Branch,
Shillong-793001, Meghalaya.
3.
The Chief Manager (HRD) Vijaya Bank,
Head Office, No. 41/2 M. G. Road,
Bangalore - 560001.
Through the Branch Manager, Bank of Baroda,
Shillong Police Bazar Branch, Shillong - 793001,
Meghalaya.
2026:MLHC:554-DB
4.
The General Manager Personal, Vijaya Bank,
Head Office, No. 41/2 M. G. Road,
Bangalore - 560001.
Through the Branch Manager, Bank of Baroda,
Shillong Police Bazar Branch, Shillong- 793001,
Meghalaya.
5.
The Deputy General Manager, Vijaya Bank,
Head Office, No. 41/2 M. G. Road,
Bangalore 560001, Through the Branch Manager,
Bank of Baroda, Shillong Police Bazar Branch,
Shillong - 793001, Meghalaya.
6.
The Assistant General Manager, Vijaya Bank,
Head Office, No. 41/2 M. G. Road, Bangalore 560001.
Through the Branch Manager, Bank of Baroda,
Shillong Police Bazar Branch, Shillong - 793001,
Meghalaya.
7.
The Branch Manager, Vijaya Bank,
G. S. Road Branch, Jail Road, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya - 793001.
Through the Branch Manager, Bank of Baroda,
Shillong Police Bazar Branch, Shillong- 793001,
Meghalaya.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B.Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.C.Chakrawarty,Sr. Adv. with
Mr. E.Laloo, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. B.P.Borah, Adv.
Mr. S.Deb, Adv.
:
2026:MLHC:554-DB
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Per. H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The instant writ appeal has been preferred against the judgment and
order dated 01-04-2024, passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C). No.
102 of 2018. The brief facts are that the writ petition was initially filed by
the deceased mother of the writ appellant and on her demise, was
substituted by the writ appellant. The prayer in the writ petition by the
mother of the writ appellant was for granting her claim for ex-gratia
monetary relief, in lieu of compassionate appointment upon the death of
her husband and the father of the writ appellant, one Late Rajendra Chandra
Das, which had been rejected by the respondent No.5 vide letter dated 0803-2013. Prior to this round of litigation, the mother of the writ appellant
had earlier filed a writ petition before the jurisdictional High Court i.e.,
Gauhati High Court, Shillong Bench being WP(C). No. 110 (SH) of 2012,
which was disposed of by directing the respondents to determine afresh the
family income of the mother of the writ appellant by excluding the income
of her non-dependent son.
2026:MLHC:554-DB
2.
The learned Single Judge by the impugned order, had gone into the
details with regard to the issues that had arisen for consideration which
revolves around the determination as to whether the monthly income from
all sources of the writ appellant’s mother (original writ petitioner) would
exceed 60% of the last pay drawn of the deceased employee to render her
ineligible for ex-gratia compensation as per the “Revised Scheme for
Payment of Ex-Gratia Amount in lieu of Appointment on Compassionate
Grounds and Appointment of Dependents of deceased Employees on
Compassionate Grounds”. The said scheme at Chapter II at clause 2.0
reads as follows:
“2.0. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
Dependents whose monthly income from all
sources is less than 60% of the last drawn gross
salary (Net of taxes) of the employee are eligible
to receive ex-gratia amount under the
scheme…”
3.
The learned Single Judge by the impugned order, then came to the
finding that the contention raised by the petitioner that as on the date when
the deceased employee died, the total income of the original petitioner was
below the 60% mark as she was yet to receive the monthly family pension
from the Bank could not be accepted, inasmuch as, the deceased employee
had died in harness and on his death, the original petitioner would be
entitled to such family pension and therefore, the calculation which
2026:MLHC:554-DB
included the monthly pension from the Bank, as well as from the Defence
could not be faulted. It was further held that since the total monthly income
of the original petitioner was ₹ 6371.00 and the gross amount of the last
drawn salary of the deceased employee was ₹ 6661.79 paise, the monthly
income of the petitioner exceeding 60% of the last drawn salary of the
deceased employee, she was not entitled to receive any sum as ex-gratia
payment.
4.
The main ground on which the order of the Single Judge has been
challenged is that he had failed to notice that as on the date of demise of
the deceased employee i.e., 09-12-2001, the writ petitioner was not
drawing any amount as pension from the respondent Bank or from the
Defence Ministry, and as such, had erred in taking into account these
incomes, in coming to a finding that the income of the original writ
petitioner exceeded 60% of the last pay drawn of the deceased employee.
5.
Mr. S.C.Chakrawarty, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. E.Laloo,
learned counsel on behalf of the appellant has submitted that it is amply
clear that the income was to be reckoned as on the date of demise of the
deceased employee which was 09-12-2001, and apart from the date of
demise, no other date has been specified for determining the family income
of the dependents. The additional affidavit filed by the respondent Bank, it
is contended dated 16-11-2021, was not the income of the original writ
2026:MLHC:554-DB
petitioner as on the date of demise of the deceased employee, and as such,
no rejoinder was filed to the averments made therein. The original writ
petitioner, it is further contended, having received the pension w.e.f., 1012-2001, which is after the date of demise of the employee on 09-12-2001,
the learned Single Judge erred in concluding that the writ petitioner would
be entitled to the arrears of family pension for the period prior to 10-122001. Learned Sr. counsel concludes his arguments by praying for
directions that the respondents calculate the monthly income of the writ
petitioner as on 09-12-2001, i.e. the date of demise of the deceased
employee, without including the pensions received from the Bank or from
the Defence authorities, and further, to settle the claim of the writ petitioner
forthwith.
6.
Mr. B.P.Borah, learned counsel for the respondent in reply has
submitted that the basic ground of challenge in the earlier writ petition i.e.
WP(C) No. 110 of 2012, was that the income of non-dependent child
namely, Bidyut Das was also calculated, whereby the total computation
exceeded 60% of the last pay drawn and that it was on this premise that the
High Court by order dated 03-08-2012, directed re-determination of the
income of the family by excluding Bidyut Das, the present writ
petitioner/appellant. It is further submitted that while re-determining the
income of the family from all sources, it was found that the family was in
2026:MLHC:554-DB
receipt of another pension from the Defence which was suppressed by the
petitioner in the earlier application and also in the application for issuance
of Income Certificate. It was on this consideration that the prayer for exgratia payment was rejected primarily on the ground that the income
exceeded 60% of the last pay drawn of the deceased employee vide the
order dated 08-03-2013.
7.
The learned counsel then submits that the order dated 08-03-2013,
was put to challenge only in 2018, after five years where during the
pendency, the original claimant expired. However, he submits, the present
petitioner/appellant who earlier claimed to be a non-dependent substituted
himself and contested the matter whereafter, the writ petition came to be
dismissed by the learned Single Judge by the order dated 01-04-2024. The
learned counsel submits that all questions raised before the learned Single
Judge have been dealt with, especially the computation in calculating 60%
of the total income of the dependent, and therefore, the ground of appeal is
unsustainable in law. It is also submitted that the present writ petition was
based on the ground taken in WP(C) No. 110 of 2012, wherein the writ
appellant herein was considered a non-dependent, which however, is a
situation that does not exist presently, inasmuch as, the present
petitioner/appellant is the same person and cannot claim himself to be a
dependent. He lastly submitted that the objective of the scheme being for
2026:MLHC:554-DB
giving relief to a family to tide over sudden financial crisis on the death of
an employee, the deceased employee in the instant case having died as far
back as on 09-12-2001, the first writ petition being filed in 2012, the
rejection of the claim made on 08-03-2013 and a challenge thereto made
only in 2018, it is clear that there was no urgency or need of ex-gratia
payment. He therefore, prays that the writ appeal be dismissed.
8.
This Court on hearing the parties and on a perusal of the impugned
order passed by the learned Single Judge, firstly notes that the rationale
behind such schemes is to provide prompt financial assistance to help
families of deceased employees who have died in harness, so that they may
not be rendered destitute. In such cases therefore, immediacy of a situation
is the most relevant factor and the longer the delay or the efflux of time,
the same would dilute any claim for compassionate appointment. In the
instant case, as observed and seen above, the deceased employee had
expired as far back as on 09-12-2001, and in the considered view of this
Court, an objective assessment of the income of the dependent (original
writ petitioner) had been conducted whereby it was found that the income
exceeded 60% of the last pay drawn by the deceased employee. The other
point raised in the appeal has failed to convince this Court that the learned
Single Judge had erred in any manner while deciding the writ petition. In
2026:MLHC:554-DB
this context, it would be apposite to reproduce hereinbelow para 21, 23 and
24 of the order dated 01-04-2024.
“21. From the pleadings of the parties, the
fact that the last drawn salary of the deceased
employee (husband of the original petitioner)
was ₹ 6661.79p and also the fact that the
monthly income of the petitioner from all
sources was ₹ 6371.00 has not been disputed by
the petitioner as the above details have been
brought on record by the respondent bank in the
additional affidavit filed on 16.11.2021. A
rejoinder to the same not having been filed by
the petitioner.
23. The contention of the learned Sr. counsel
for the petitioner that as on the date when the
deceased employee died, the total income of the
original petitioner was below the 60% mark as
she has not received any monthly pension from
the bank due to her deceased husband cannot
be accepted as it is evident that since the
deceased employee died in harness, on his
death, his family or rather the original
petitioner would be entitled to such monthly
family pension, even if the same is given at a
later date, she would still be entitled to the
arrears thereof. The calculation which
included the monthly pension from the bank as
well as from the defence services cannot be
faulted.
24. Again, as indicated hereinabove, since
the total monthly income of the original
deceased petitioner was ₹ 6371.00 and the
gross amount of the last drawn salary of the
deceased employee was ₹ 6661.79p, therefore,
the monthly income of the petitioner being
higher than 60% of the last drawn salary of the
deceased employee, she was not eligible to
2026:MLHC:554-DB
receive any sum of money as ex-gratia payment
from the respondent bank.”
9.
A perusal of the above quoted paragraphs would show that there is
no error in the findings, and as such, in these circumstances, the order of
the learned Single Judge is upheld and the writ appeal dismissed.
(B.Bhattacharjee)
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2026.06.10 16:51:52 IST
(H.S.Thangkhiew)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review