Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~43 & 44
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW
DELHI
Date of decision: 30th September 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010473362026
+
C.R.P. 299/2026 & CM APPL. 68148-68149/2026
BALJEET KAUR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Ms. Priya Kumar, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Shreyansh Singhvi, Ms. Archita
Yadav,
Ms.
Ekaa
Sharma,
Advocates.
versus
AJIT PAL SINGH BINDRA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Abhishek Singh, Mr. J. Amal
Anand, Mr. Elvin Joshy, Mr. K. V.
Vibu Prasad, Mr. Joel David, Mr.
Vedant Upadhyay, Advocates.
(44)
#
CNR No. DLHC010473382026
+
C.R.P. 300/2026 & CM APPL. 68153-68154/2026
BHUPINDER SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Shreyansh Singhvi, Ms. Archita
Yadav, Advocates.
versus
AJIT PAL SINGH BINDRA & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Singh, Mr. J. Amal
Anand, Mr. Elvin Joshy, Mr. K. V.
Vibu Prasad, Mr. Joel David, Mr.
Vedant Upadhyay, Advocates.
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These petitions have been filed for setting aside orders dated 13th
August 2026 passed by the District Judge, West District, Tis Hazari Courts,
Delhi in Civil DJ No. 782/2022 titled as, “Ajit Pal Singh Bindra v. Baljeet
Kaur” which is the subject matter of C.R.P. 299/2026 and in Civil DJ
No.512/2022 titled as, “Ajit Pal Singh Bindra v. Bhupinder Singh & Anr.”
which is the subject matter of C.R.P. 300/2026. Both the impugned orders
have been passed by the same Court in respect of similar set of facts and
circumstances.
2.
Plaintiff (Ajit Pal Singh Bindra) entered into an Agreement to Sell
(‘ATS’) dated 22nd October 2011 for the purchase of undivided share of
each of the petitioners/defendants herein, in freehold property admeasuring
216 square yards bearing No.D-24, Bhagwan Dass Nagar Colony, New
Delhi-110026 (hereinafter, ‘subject property’). The property was originally
owned by Sh. Rakha Singh, father of Sh. Bhupinder Singh and father-in-law
of Smt. Baljeet Kaur, which was acquired by him by virtue of Conveyance
Deed dated 23rd January 1965. Sh. Rakha Singh constructed a residential
building comprising of ground floor, first floor and barsati on the subject
property. He passed away on 05th January 1991 leaving behind his wife,
four sons and five daughters. His wife and three sons eventually passed
away.
3.
Baljeet Kaur, along with her children on one hand, and Bhupinder
Singh on the other, had agreed to transfer the undivided shares, being, 1/9th
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
and 1/3rd respectively. As a result, respondent/plaintiff entered into
agreements to sell, with Baljeet Kaur and Bhupinder Singh, as well as, the
other co-owners for the purposes of acquiring the subject property
completely. The agreements to sell mentioned details of these shares and
provided that, after the payment of earnest money, balance amount would
be paid at the time of execution and registration of the sale deed along with
handing over vacant and peaceful possession of the subject property, within
two weeks after purchasing the share of all co-owners. This has been noted
in Clause 3 of the ATS with Baljeet Kaur.
4.
After the death of various family members, as per the plaint in Civil
DJ No. 782/2022, the legal heirs inherited various shares in the property
and the respective shares were realigned, which are tabulated as under:
Serial
No.
Name
Bhupender Singh
Gurcharan Singh
Mrs. Sukhvender Kaur
Mrs. Palvinder Kaur
Mrs. Rajender Kaur
Mrs. Parmjeet Kaur
Mrs. Surender Kaur
Legal Heirs of Sh. Ranjeet Singh:
(a) Smt. Sukhjinder Kaur w/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh
(b) Sh. Inderdeep Singh s/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh
(c) Sh. Sukhdeep Singh s/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh
(d) Smt. Rajdeep Kaur d/o Late Sh. Ranjeet Singh
Legal Heirs of Sh. Harjeet Singh:
(a) Smt. Baljeet Kaur d/o Late Sh. Harjeet Singh
(b) Smt. Gurdeep Kaur d/o Late Sh. Harjeet Singh
(c) Smt. Hardeep Kaur d/o Late Sh. Harjeet Singh
(d) Smt. Navdeep Kaur d/o Late Sh. Harjeet Singh
(e) Sh. Sahildeep Singh s/o Late Sh. Harjeet Singh
Relation
Son
Son
Daughter
Daughter
Daughter
Daughter
Daughter
% of
Shares
1/9th
1/9th
1/9th
1/9th
1/9th
1/9th
1/9th
Son
1/9th
Son
1/9th
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
5.
As regards the transaction with Baljeet Kaur, the total sale
consideration was Rs.22,22,222/- and respondent/plaintiff made part
payment of Rs.2,00,000/- on 22nd October 2021 and thereafter, over a
period of time, made further payments totalling up to Rs.21,75,000/-, by
way of different cheques. Thereafter, another additional amount of
Rs.4,50,000/- was also paid till about 18th January 2022.
6.
This was made on the basis of an assurance that petitioner/defendant
(Baljeet Kaur) shall honour their part of the obligation and execute a valid
registered sale deed. However, for some reason or the other,
petitioner/defendant was seen to be wriggling out of the ATS and attempted
to sell her share of the subject property to tenants/occupants without
disclosing the execution of the respondent/plaintiff’s agreement to sell.
Therefore, the suit for specific performance seeking execution of the prior
ATS, and for permanent injunction from alienating the undivided share of
petitioner/defendant, was filed.
7.
As regards the transaction with Bhupinder Singh for a consideration
of Rs.25,00,000/- for his undivided share, an amount of Rs.2,00,000/- was
paid at the time of signing of the ATS and out of the remaining sale, further
amounts were given from time to time. Finally, a total amount of
Rs.33,00,000/- had been paid, out of which an amount of Rs.26,37,360/had been deposited to the account of petitioner/defendant and a sum of
Rs.6,62,640/- had been deducted against tax deducted at source (‘TDS’).
8.
Defendant no. 2 in the suit, who was the power of attorney (‘POA’)
of Bhupinder Singh (who was a resident of Canada) had in fact gone with
respondent/plaintiff to register the sale deed, where, respondent/plaintiff
had paid the stamp duty of Rs.3,96,000/-, as well as, registry fee of
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
Rs.66,000/-. After the signed and executed sale deed was submitted to the
Sub-Registrar, respondent/plaintiff was subsequently informed that
petitioner/defendant no.1 through another attorney S. Kuljeet Singh had
already submitted a sale deed for registration with regard to his shares in
the subject property and executed them in favour of Smt. Sarabjeet Kaur.
Therefore, the registration of respondent/plaintiff’s sale deed was put on
hold.
9.
As a result, thereof, the present suit has been filed seeking specific
performance for execution of the sale deed and an injunction for alienation
of the undivided share of petitioner/defendant no.1 (Bhupinder Singh).
10.
Respondent/plaintiff, in both these suits, has categorically averred
that he had entered into ATS with other co-owners of undivided shares in
the property and since there was failure to execute sale deeds in favour of
respondent/plaintiff, suits for specific performance had been filed, which
are as under:
i.
Civil Suit bearing Civ DJ 611469/2016 titled as “Ajit Pal
Bindra v. Gurcharan Singh & Anr.” pending before ADJ-05
(West).
ii.
Civil Suit bearing Civ DJ 612593/2016 titled as “Ajit Pal
Bindra v. Surinder Kaur” pending before ADJ-04 (West).
iii.
Civil Suit bearing Civ DJ 512/2022 titled as “Ajit Pal Singh
Bindra v. Bhupinder Singh & Anr.” pending before ADJ-04
(West).
11.
It has also been stated that the Trial Court had passed ad interim
orders in favour of respondent/plaintiff in the following matters:
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
i.
Order dated 19th March 2016 passed by ADJ-05 (West) in
Civil Suit bearing, Civ DJ 611469/2016 titled as “Ajit Pal
Bindra v. Gurcharan Singh & Anr.”.
ii.
Order dated 2nd March 2016 passed by ADJ-04 (West) in Civil
Suit bearing, Civ DJ 612593/2016 titled as “Ajit Pal Bindra v.
Surinder Kaur”.
iii.
Order dated 2nd June 2022 passed by ADJ-04 (West) in Civil
Suit bearing, Civ DJ 512/2022 titled as “Ajit Pal Singh Bindra
v. Bhupinder Singh & Anr.”.
12.
Applications under Order VII Rule 11 of Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (‘CPC’) were filed by petitioners/defendants, contending: firstly, that
the ATS is an unregistered document and cannot be specifically performed;
and secondly, that it is barred by law under Section 14(b) of Specific Relief
Act, 1963 (‘SRA’). Surprisingly, the application under Order VII Rule 11
of CPC is particularly sparse in its content, though the submissions made
by Ms. Priya Kumar, Senior Counsel for Baljeet Kaur, were very
extensive.
13.
Ms. Priya Kumar, Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Baljeet
Kaur, contended that: firstly, cause of action did not arise since the suit had
been filed prematurely and respondent/plaintiff had not been able to acquire
the shares of co-owners, therefore, the suit as per Clause 3 of the ATS of
Baljeet Kaur was premature; secondly, it was argued that since the ATS
was unregistered, specific performance could not be sought; thirdly, no
consequential relief of possession had been sought and no declaration had
been sought either in that regard.
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
14.
Mr. Shreyansh Singhvi, counsel for Bhupinder Singh, additionally
pressed that the suit was barred under Section 14(b) of SRA, since it
required performance of a continuous duty and since vacant and peaceful
possession of the premises would depend on the acquisition of the share of
co-owners.
15.
Scope of a Revision Petition under Section 115 of CPC is quite
circumscribed and limited. The Court has to see if there is a material
irregularity in the manner in which the jurisdiction has been exercised by
the Trial Court and it does not involve imposing an alternative view in the
matter. Court having assessed the impugned order notes that all these
arguments have been carefully considered and there is no reason to displace
the reasoning of impugned order on any of these aspects, which have been
raised by counsels for petitioners/defendants, since there is no material
irregularity.
16.
As regards the scope of Revisional Court, reliance may be placed
upon the decision of Supreme Court in Ambadas Khanduji Shinde v.
Ashok Sadashiv Mamurkar, (2017) 14 SCC 132, where the Supreme
Court held that revisional jurisdiction of the High Court is restricted to
cases of illegal or irregular exercise of jurisdiction by the subordinate
courts. Under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’), it
would not be open to the High Court to correct errors of facts or law, unless
they go to root of the issue of jurisdiction.
17.
Reliance may also be placed upon the decision of this Court in
Rajeev v. Hariom Kumar, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 5027, where it was held
that scope of revision includes issues related to jurisdiction alone and not
errors of fact or law. It cannot interfere with trial court decisions simply
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
because they may be erroneous, and the High Court under Section 115 of
CPC cannot assess the merits of the case, at this stage.
18.
In any event, in dealing with the issues specifically raised, the Court
first notes that, this is a transaction where the respondent/plaintiff sought to
acquire undivided shares of each of the co-owners in order to acquire the
complete subject property. Having paid almost the entire consideration in
respect of these two agreements to sell and still not having a sale deed
executed, led to the filing of the suit for specific performance, which in
itself is a legitimate cause of action. The plea that the suit is conditional on
whether respondent/plaintiff is successful in securing the shares of other
co-owners or not, may be not relevant for pursuing his rights with respect
to a particular seller/co-owner.
19.
The argument put forth by Ms. Priya Kumar, Senior Counsel for
Baljeet Kaur, that there was a conditionality in Clause 3 of the ATS that
the execution of sale deed and grant of possession would be done within
two weeks after purchasing the share of all the co-owners is an
unreasonable and irrational reading of Clause 3.
20.
The argument put forth by counsel for respondents, in this regard, is
correct, in that, Clause 3 states that balance amount has to be paid after
purchasing the share of all co-owners, which is followed by the execution
of sale deed and possession.
21.
Counsel for respondents relied upon the decision of Supreme Court
in Manickam alias Thandapani & Anr. v. Vasantha 2022 SCC OnLine
SC 2096, where the Supreme Court has stated that relief of possession is
ancillary to the decree of specific performance and need not be specifically
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
claimed. This was stated in reference to Section 22 of SRA and the relief of
possession is further saved by the proviso to Section 22(2) of SRA.
Supreme Court had stated that Section 22 of SRA was meant to avoid the
multiplicity of proceedings and the proviso to Section 22(2) takes out the
mandatory nature.
22.
In this case, respondent/plaintiff has already averred that complete
consideration has been paid and, therefore, in any case, even if this
conditionality is to be considered, it would not be relevant in the facts and
circumstances. Moreover, the Court is constrained to note that after having
accepted consideration, as per the respondent/plaintiff, the natural
consequence would be the execution of sale deed.
23.
In fact, in Bhupinder Singh’s case, the sale deed had indeed been
executed before the Sub-Registrar, but was put on hold since there was an
objection raised on account of a separate sale deed which had been moved
for registration and ordered in a court case.
24.
There is no way that respondent/plaintiff can be expected to move all
the transactions with various members of the family in a coordinated and
synchronized manner, failing which, he ought to be non-suited (as per the
petitioners) for seeking execution of sale deeds with respect to each of
these agreements to sell. Plea of the petitioners/defendants in this regard is,
therefore, unmerited.
25.
On the second issue of an unregistered agreement to sell being
sought to be the basis for seeking specific performance, the Trial Court has
rightly adverted to the decision of Supreme Court in Ameer Minhaj v.
Dierdre Elizabeth (Wright) Issar (2018) 7 SCC 639 and R. Hemalatha v.
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
Kashthuri 2023 INSC 381, where Supreme Court categorically placed
reliance upon the proviso to Section 49 of Registration Act, 1908, which
states that an unregistered document with respect to immovable property
can still be admitted as evidence of a contract in a suit for specific
performance. Therefore, any argument, in this regard, is untenable, as the
law applicable and provisions of the Registration Act, 1908, are very clear.
26.
Thirdly, whether the suit would be barred since no consequential
relief has been sought under Section 34 of SRA, it has to be noted that the
suit is for specific performance and no declaration has been sought with
respect to the suit property and, therefore, the proviso to Section 34 of
SRA, which demands further relief beyond the declaration of title for a suit
to succeed, is not applicable in the facts of this case.
27.
Fourthly, the argument that the suit will be barred by Section 14(b)
of SRA, reliance placed on the decision of House of Lords in Co-operative
Insurance Society Limited v. Argyll Stores [1997] 3 All ER 297 and Prem
Kumar Bansal v. Ambrish Garg 2016 SCC OnLine Del 2549 by the
counsel for petitioner/defendant would not apply, since the issue in Prem
Lata Bansal (supra) was an ATS which was conditional upon demolition
of the property and reconstruction and then separate shares were to go to
plaintiff and the defendant. Defendant having not complied, the suit for
specific performance was filed. The said judgment had been passed in a
Regular First Appeal (RFA), in a decided suit, where evidence was taken
into account and the Court held that the aspect for reconstruction would
require continuous enforcement and, therefore, would require oversight on
a series of court orders rendering it incapable of enforcement.
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
28.
However, in the matter at hand, respondent/plaintiff is simply
seeking execution of a sale deed in respect of an undivided share, to be sold
to them which is already determined and does not require any further
condition to be satisfied or any continuous duty to be supervised.
29.
In light of above, the pleas of petitioners/defendants are completely
unmerited and, therefore, the petitions are dismissed.
30.
Pending applications are rendered infructuous.
31.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 30, 2026/ak/sp
C.R.P. 299/2026 & C.R.P. 300/2026
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:47:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review