Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 13th May, 2026
Pronounced on: 26th May, 2026
+
RSA 149/2025 & CM APPL. 60353/2025
BHULLAN SINGH
S/o Tika Ram (since deceased)
And represented by Arun Kumar (his grandson)
R/o Quarter No. 90-91,
Scindia Potteries Labour Quarters Complex
Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Vijay Pal Singh and Mr. Yogesh
Kumar, Advocates.
versus
M/S SCINDIA POTTERIES & SERVICES PVT. LTD.
Add. - Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi.
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Anirban Bhattacharya, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC, has been filed
against the Judgment and Decree dated 05.06.2025 passed in RCA DJ No.
22/2021, whereby the learned District Judge upheld the Judgment and
Decree dated 11.11.2021 passed by the learned JSCC/ASCJ/GJ, decreeing
the Suit for Possession in respect of Quarter No. 90, Scindia Potteries
Labour Quarter Complex, Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi, filed by the
Plaintiff/Respondent.
2.
The Plaintiff had filed a Suit bearing No.6877/16 for Possession in
respect of Quarter No.90, Scindia Potteries, Labour Quarter Complex,
Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi(hereinafter referred to as Suit property).
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
3.
The facts in brief are that the Plaintiff Company claimed itself to be
the owner of a huge property at Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi, by virtue of a
Perpetual Lease Deed dated 18.01.1921. The original Lease Deed dated
18.01.1921 was obtained by Development Corporation of India Ltd. As per
the terms of the Perpetual Lease Deed, the said Development Corporation of
India Ltd. had alienated the property in favour of the predecessor of the
Plaintiff Company, by virtue of an Indenture in 1923.
4.
The Plaintiff Company, which was running its pottery factory in a
portion of the said property, had employed a number of persons, to work in
the factory and had built a large number of quarters adjoining Africa
Avenue, which were allotted to its workers for their residence during the
period of their service/employment, with the Plaintiff Company.
5.
In the year 1969-70, the factory was virtually closed and a substantial
number of workers were retrenched/removed. The Defendant/Appellant
Bhullan Singh was an employee of the Plaintiff Company, who was
retrenched from service in the year 1970. He thereafter, was employed in the
Postal Department, Government of India. During the course of his
employment, he was allotted Quarter No. 91, as an employee.
6.
A Suit bearing No. 339/1973, was filed for possession of Quarter No.
91, which was decreed on 25.01.1974. Inadvertently, the Execution Petition
could not be filed within the statutory period of 12 years and consequently
became barred by limitation, in the year 1986.
7.
It is the case of the Plaintiff that the Defendant, emboldened by the
aforesaid facts, sometime in the year 1990 or thereabout, unauthorizedly and
illegally occupied Quarter No. 90 (adjacent to Quarter No. 91) in the
Scindia Potteries Labour Quarter Complex, though neither he had nor has,
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
any right, title or interest in the said Quarter. It is alleged that since then, he
and his family have been residing in Quarter No. 90 unauthorizedly and are
in illegal and unlawful possession thereof.
8.
The Plaintiff asked the Defendant and his family members, to vacate
the Suit property time and again, but they failed to pay any heed to the
demands of the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff, therefore, filed a Suit for Possession
in respect of the Suit property, against the Defendant.
9.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant, who in his Written
Statement, took a preliminary objection that he had been in possession of
the Suit property since 1976 and had made constructions and renovations
therein at his own cost. The Suit has become barred under Article 65 of the
Limitation Act, 1963, since the Suit had been filed after more than 12 years
of continuous, uninterrupted and undisputed possession of the Defendant.
10.
It was further contended that in a Suit for Possession against a
trespasser, all the persons residing in the Suit property are essential and
necessary parties. Since they had not been impleaded in the present Suit, the
Suit was liable to be dismissed for non-joinder of essential and necessary
parties.
11.
It was further claimed that the market value of the Suit property was
more than Rs. 50 lakhs and that the Suit property had been undervalued.
Consequently, the Court had no pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain the Suit.
12.
It was also contended that the Plaintiff was never the owner of the
Suit property and that no Notice had ever been served upon the Defendant,
claiming title over the Suit property. Furthermore, it is contended that no
authentic Site Plan with measurements had been filed, along with the Plaint.
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
Hence, the Defendant claimed that the Suit was liable to be rejected under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
13.
On merits, it was denied that the Plaintiff was a Company
incorporated under the Indian Companies Act or that it was originally
incorporated as Gwalior Potteries (Delhi) Ltd., which was subsequently
changed to Scindia Potteries (P) Ltd. and finally to Scindia Potteries and
Services Ltd.
14.
It was further denied that the original Lease Deed dated 1921 was
obtained by Development Corporation of India Ltd. and it was also denied
that the Lease Deed conferred rights of alienation upon the then Lessee, who
thereafter, alienated the property in favour of the predecessor of the Plaintiff
Company. It was further denied that the quarters had been constructed by the
Plaintiff Company or that the factory had virtually closed in the year 196970.
15.
The Defendant asserted that he, along with his family members, had
been in peaceful, undisputed and uninterrupted possession of the Suit
property for more than 25 years and had thus, become the owner thereof by
way of adverse possession. The Defendant denied that he had unauthorizedly
occupied the Suit property.
16.
All the averments made in the Plaint were denied and it was claimed
that the Suit was liable to be dismissed.
17.
Upon consideration of the pleadings of the parties, the Issues were
framed on 07.02.2002, as under:
“(1) Whether the suit of the plaintiff is barred by limitation? OPD
(2) Whether suit of the plaintiff is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties? OPD
(3) Whether suit of the plaintiff is correctly valued for the purpose of
court fees and jurisdiction? OPP
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
(4) Whether plaintiff Company is entitled to the decree of possession
as prayed for? OPP
(5) Relief.”
18.
An additional Issue no. 4-A was subsequently framed vide Order
dated 08.01.2004, as under: “Issue no. 4-A: Whether the defendant and/or his family
members have become owners of the suit property by adverse
possession? OPD”
19.
In support of its case, the Plaintiff examined PW-1 Sh. Yogesh
Kumar, UDC from Delhi Archives, who proved the Perpetual Lease Deed
dated 18.01.1921 as Ex. PW-1/1.
20.
PW-2, Sh. M.S. Chawla, an Architect by profession, proved the
Valuation Report dated 25.05.2001 of the Suit property and also the Site
Plan which are Ex. P-1 to P-8.
21.
PW-3, Sh. P.K. Ram, deposed on behalf of the Plaintiff, in regard to
the contents of the Plaint.
22.
It is relevant to note that Sh. Bhullan Singh, i.e. the original
Defendant, died before the Defence evidence could be led.
23.
DW-1, Sh. Ramphal, the son of the original Defendant Sh. Bhullan
Singh was partly cross-examined, as he too died during the pendency of his
cross-examination.
24.
DW-2, Sh. Gur Sahai, Astt. Engineer of CPWD, proved the Identity
Card of the Defendant, Sh. Bhullan Singh, issued by CPWD, as Ex. DW1/B. The Service Master Record of the Defendant is DW1/B and Mark C.
25.
DW-3, Rajesh and DW-4 Sh. Shyam Sunder, the grandsons of the
Defendant Sh. Bhullan Singh, deposed on Affidavit in regard to the defence
as taken in the Written Statement.
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
26.
The learned Civil Judge considered the defence of adverse possession
taken by the Defendant and, on the basis of the evidence led by the Parties,
concluded that the Defendants had failed to prove acquisition of title by
way of adverse possession.
27.
It was further held that the Suit for Possession of immovable property
being based on title, the limitation period of 12 years under Article 65 of the
Limitation Act, 1963, which would commence from the date when the
Defendants’ interest became adverse to the Plaintiff. Accordingly, it was
held that the Suit had been filed within limitation. The Suit of the Plaintiff
for possession of the Suit property was consequently decreed, vide
Judgment dated 11.11.2021.
28.
The first Regular Appeal bearing RCA DJ No. 22/2021 was filed to
challenge the Judgement and Decree dated 11.11.2021. In the course of the
Appeal proceedings, the learned District Judge allowed the Appellant to lead
additional documentary evidence, namely, the Letter dated 30.06.1998
issued by L&DO, the Order dated 25.10.2010 passed in W.P.(C) No.
1295/1998, and the Letter dated 01.08.2013 issued by L&DO, vide which a
demand of Rs. 16,99,62,030/- was raised against the Respondent to be paid
within 60 days for regularisation of the breaches and withdrawal of re-entry
of the premises, in order to show that the lease of the Respondent had been
determined and that the L&DO had re-entered the premises. These
documents were admitted by the Plaintiff.
29.
The Plaintiff was also permitted to lead additional evidence, whereby
it proved the Letter dated 20.05.2024 Ex. RW-2/1, issued by L&DO, as per
which certain payments had been made to L&DO by the Respondent, the
Order of re-entry passed by the L&DO in respect of the Suit premises stood
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
withdrawn, and the rights and title of the Respondent under the Lease Deed,
stood restored.
30.
Upon re-appreciation of the entire evidence, the learned District
Judge upheld the findings of the learned Trial Court and dismissed the
Appeal as devoid of merit, vide the impugned Judgment and Decree dated
05.06.2025.
31.
Being aggrieved thereby, the present Regular Second Appeal has
been preferred by the Legal Heirs of the deceased Defendant, Shri Bhullan
Singh.
32.
The grounds of challenge, are that the Plaintiff had committed fraud
upon the Court by claiming to be a Lessee of the Suit property, without
placing any supporting document on record.
33.
It has further not been appreciated that the Lease was determined vide
Order dated 25.10.2010 passed in W.P.(C) No. 1295/1998 in the matter of
'Scindia Potteries and Services Ltd. & Ors. vs. Deputy Land and
Development Officer and Ors.' It is submitted that this material fact of the
determination of the Lease Deed vide Order dated 01.08.2013, has been
concealed from the Court. Once L&DO/UOI admitted that the Lease in
respect of the Suit property was determined, it is not appreciated as to how
the Respondent could have been held entitled to file the Suit in 2001.
34.
Furthermore, the assets of the Company existing on 01.02.1923, were
transferred in favour of the Company, which came into existence on
20.05.1946 and the said Company was considered as the owner of the Suit
property, without any documentary proof.
35.
It has further been contended that the Orders/judgements passed by
the two Courts below, have failed to appreciate that subsequent Orders
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
passed by any Court, cannot be relied upon to fill the lacunae in the Suit for
Possession, particularly wherein no document of ownership was filed and
the Decree had been obtained by fraud.
36.
It has not been appreciated that the Plaintiff Company cannot be
considered as a successor of Gwalior Potteries Limited, without any
documents. The L&DO never executed the Lease in favour of the
Respondent, after the Lease dated 01.02.1923 in favour of Gwalior Potteries
(Delhi) Ltd. It has not been considered as to how Gwalior Potteries (Delhi)
Ltd. assigned its rights to the Plaintiff and there has been no discussion in
regard to the ownership of the Plaintiff in the Suit property.
37.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court had specifically held that only the person
having a better title than the person in possession of the property, can claim
a right against the person in settled possession thereof. The Supreme Court
has specifically held in a catena of cases that the reliance on a part of the
Judgment, which is obiter dicta and not the ratio of the Judgment, cannot be
relied upon by the Trial Courts to declare the ownership of the Plaintiff
Company. The Supreme Court in AIR 1977 SC 2421, has held that where
the Suit is vexatious, even a Notice of such Suit is not merited.
38.
Hence, it was submitted that the impugned Judgments of the two
Courts be set aside.
39.
The Respondent had appeared on advance Notice and submitted
that no Substantial Question of Law was raised and that the Appeal is liable
to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
40.
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
Essentially, the defence of the Appellant is twofold:
RSA 149/2025
(i)
Whether the respondent was the owner of the suit
property? and
(ii)
Whether
the
Plaintiff/respondent
had
acquired
ownership by adverse Possession?
Whether the Respondent is the Owner of the Suit Property:
41.
The main contention of the Appellant was that the perpetual Lease
Deed was in the name of Gwalior Potteries (Delhi) Ltd. and not in the name
of Respondent Scindia Potteries and Services Ltd. It has been held both by
the learned Civil Judge as well as by the learned District Judge, that though
initially the Company was incorporated as Gwalior Potteries (Delhi)
Limited, its name was subsequently changed and it ultimately came to exist
in the name of Scindia Potteries and Services Limited. Therefore, the
contention of the Appellant that the Respondent was not the person having a
perpetual Lease Deed in their favour was patently incorrect.
42.
The second contention of the Appellant, is that the perpetual Lease
Deed in favour of the Respondent, had been cancelled and the L&DO had
re-entered the premises, consequent to which the Respondent ceased to be
the owner of the suit property. However, the Letter dated 20.05.2024, Ex.
RW-2/1, issued by L&DO clearly recorded that after clearing of the dues,
the Perpetual Lease Deed was restored in favour of the Respondent.
43.
In this regard, it may be pertinent to note that there were multiple
litigations undertaken by the Respondent against various occupants of the
Units in the same Property, all of which had been decreed in favour of the
Respondent by holding the Respondent to be the owner of the Property in
question.
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
44.
This Court in RSA 404/2015 titled Hari Kishan vs. M/s Scindia
Potteries and Services Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine Del 13584, which was a
litigation initiated by the Respondent in respect of Quarter No. 74 in the
Property in question, held the Respondent to be the owner of the Suit
Property. It was observed that the Perpetual Lease Deed was mutated in the
name of the Respondent, thereby establishing the ownership of the
Respondent in the Suit Property.
45.
Similar observations were made in RSA 86/2016 titled Sukhbir Singh
vs. Scindia Potteries and Services Ltd., 2016 SCC OnLine Del 6053, which
had been undertaken by the Respondent in respect of Quarter No. 6, wherein
a similar objection taken by the occupant, was rejected and the Respondent
was held to be the owner.
46.
Also, similar observations were made in RSA 225/2017 titled as
Nathu Ram vs. Scindia Potteries and Services Limited, which pertained to
Quarter No.68.
47.
Therefore, the Learned District Court rightly concluded that the title
of the Plaintiff under the Perpetual Lease Deed from the L&DO in respect of
the entire premises of Scindia Potteries and Services Limited, had been
recognised in various litigations and the title of the Respondent in the
Properties in question, stood established.
48.
It may be observed that these findings are based on facts and do not
raise any substantial question of law.
Whether the appellant has acquired ownership by adverse
possession?
49.
The legal position in regard to the essentials to establish acquisition of
Property or acquisition of Title by adverse possession, has been well settled
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
by a long line of decisions of Supreme Court and High Court; some of
which are S. M. Karim vs. Mst. Bibi Skina, AIR 1964 SC 1254; Annasaheb
Bapusaheb Patil and Others vs. Balwant @ Balasahet Babusaheb Patil
(dead) by LRs & herirs etc., AIR 1995 SC 895; Konda lakshmana Bapuji vs.
Govt. of A.P. and Others; 2002 (3) SCC 258; Karnataka Board of Wakf vs.
Government of India and Others, 2004 (910) SCC 779; and T. Anjanappa
and others vs. Somalingappa and Another, 2006 (7) SCC 750.
50.
Learned District Judge had summed up the principles applicable for
adverse possession, as under:
“(1) Onus to prove the question of title by adverse
possession is on the party who makes such a claim.
(2) Mere long possession of the land is not enough. What is
important is whether the possessor had the animus
possidendi to hod the land adverse to the title of the true
owner.
(3) The period of limitation starts running from the date
both actual possession and assertion of title are shown to
exist.
(4) The assertion of title adverse to the true owner must be
clear and unequivocal, though not necessarily addressed to
the real owner.
(5) The party claiming adverse possession must prove that
his possession is “nec vi, nec clamnec precario”.
(6) The party claiming title by adverse possession must
make clear averments to that effect and explain as to when
he entered into the possession of the property and when the
possession became adverse.”
51.
The learned District Judge had referred to the testimony of DW-3 Sh.
Rajesh and DW-4 Sh. Shyam Sunder who, in their respective cross-
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
examination, had shown complete ignorance of the material facts in regard
to the payment of House Tax and Lease rent and was not aware if the same
were being paid by the Plaintiff Company. He further deposed that his
grand-father had set up a defence of adverse possession against the Plaintiff
Company, but he was not aware of the case till the demise of his grandfather. His entire testimony was stated to be based on hearsay and therefore,
was of no relevance.
52.
It was thus, concluded that the Appellants had failed to prove that
their father had the animus possidendi to hold the suit premises adverse to
the title of the true owner or that their possession was nec vi, nec clam, nec
precario ("without force, without secrecy, and without permission") It was
thus, concluded that the Defendants/Appellants had failed to prove the plea
of adverse possession.
53.
Furthermore, as per Article 65 of the Limitation Act, the limitation for
possession of immovable property or any interest therein based on title,
begins to run from the date when the Defendants’ interest became adverse to
the Plaintiff. Therefore, it was incumbent upon the Defendants to establish
the date from which they started claiming ownership in the suit property.
However, no such date was disclosed by the Defendants.
54.
Moreover, both DW-3 & DW-4 had deposed that their father had
claimed ownership of the Suit Property, but had not purchased it and had
also not claimed any right, title or interest in the Suit Property, as their father
was alive and they were living with him. It was thus, rightly concluded that
the plea of adverse possession could not be established by the Appellants,
either through any documentary or oral evidence. Hence, it was held that
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
the Appellants had not been able to prove that they had acquired title in the
Suit Property by adverse possession.
55.
Learned Trial Court as well as learned District Judge in their
respective Judgments, have rightly concluded that the Plaintiff / Respondent
was entitled to the possession of the Suit Property.
56.
There is no substantial question of law that has been raised in the
present Appeal, which has essentially challenged the findings on facts.
57.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed
along with pending Applications.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MAY 26, 2026/R/va
KUMAR BHATT
16:52:54
RSA 149/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review