Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Judgment reserved on: 01.07.2026
Judgment delivered on: 07.07.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Single No.1347 of 2015
Bhopal Chandra Pancholi
--Petitioner
Versus
State Election Commission, through its Deputy Secretary & Ors.
--Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. Aditya Singh, learned counsel for petitioner.
None present for respondent Nos.1 and 2.
Mr. Anil Kumar Bisht, learned counsel for respondent No.3.
Mr. Bhupendra Singh Koranga, learned Brief Holder for the State of
Uttarakhand/respondent No.4.
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J. (Oral)
By means of present writ petition, petitioner has
sought the following reliefs:i) Issue a writ, order or direction, in the nature of
certiorari quashing the impugned Government order
no.770/XVII (7)/ (40)/2011 dated 6.11.2013 issue by
the State Government being violative of Article 134,
39(1) (d) & 311-2 of the Constitution of India annexed
as Annexure No.8 to the writ petition.
ii) Issue a writ, order or direction, in the nature of
certiorari quashing the impugned orders dated
13.5.2014 & 19.3.2015 issued by the respondents
annexed as Annexure Nos.18 & 20 to the writ petition.
iii) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus commanding the respondent to resettle the
grant of III A.C.P. after taking into consideration the
services rendered by the petitioner w.e.f. 1.4.1985 in
Municipal Board, Pithoragarh prior to his retrenchment
as surplus employee of Optroy Department and to pay
all the arrears to which the petitioner is entitled.
2.
The facts of the case are that petitioner was initially
appointed as a Peon in Nagar Palika Parishad, Pithoragarh on
01.04.1985 and his services were regularized with effect from
02.04.1986. Thereafter, pursuant to an order dated 19.10.1996,
he was appointed as a Class-IV employee in the State Election
Commission and joined the office of District Election Officer
(Panch Sthaniya), Pithoragarh on 07.11.1996, after being
relieved from Nagar Palika Parishad, Pithoragarh. Petitioner
claims that while computing the qualifying service for grant of
third Assured Career Progression (A.C.P.), respondents failed to
take into consideration the period of service rendered by him in
Nagar
Palika
Parishad
from
01.04.1985
to
07.11.1996.
According to him, the benefit of third A.C.P. was initially
extended by order dated 10.03.2014 after counting the said
period of service. However, the said benefit was subsequently
withdrawn by order dated 13.05.2014 in view of Government
Orders
dated
08.03.2011,
01.07.2013
and
06.11.2013,
whereby, earlier service rendered in the local body was excluded
for the purpose of computing qualifying service for grant of
A.C.P. Aggrieved thereby, petitioner has preferred the present
writ petition seeking quashing of the Government Orders dated
06.11.2013 and the consequential order dated 13.05.2014,
besides praying for a direction to the respondents to consider
the service rendered by him in Nagar Palika Parishad for the
purpose of grant of third A.C.P. along with all consequential
benefits.
3.
Learned
counsel
for
petitioner
submits
that
petitioner was initially appointed as a Peon in Nagar Palika
Parishad, Pithoragarh on 01.04.1985 and was regularized on
02.04.1986. Thereafter, pursuant to an order dated 19.10.1996,
he joined the services of the State Election Commission on
07.11.1996. It is contended that respondents have illegally
ignored the period of service rendered by petitioner in Nagar
Palika Parishad while determining his eligibility for the grant of
third
Assured
Career
Progression
(A.C.P.).
According
to
petitioner, previous service rendered in a statutory local body
cannot
be
treated
subsequently
joined
as
non-existent
another
merely
Government
because
he
establishment,
particularly when such service had been duly recognized for the
purpose of pay protection at the time of his appointment in the
State Election Commission.
4.
He further submits that petitioner had rightly been
granted the benefit of third A.C.P. vide order dated 10.03.2014
after taking into consideration his entire qualifying service.
However,
the
said
benefit
was
arbitrarily
withdrawn
by
impugned order dated 13.05.2014 solely on the basis of
Government
Orders
dated
08.03.2011,
06.11.2013,
which,
according
to
01.07.2013
petitioner,
have
and
been
misconstrued
by
respondents.
He
contends
that
the
Government Orders do not contemplate exclusion of the service
rendered by an employee in a statutory local body while
computing qualifying service for the grant of A.C.P. and that
respondents
have
adopted
an
erroneous
interpretation,
defeating the very object of the A.C.P. Scheme meant to remove
stagnation in service.
5.
It is also argued by the learned counsel for petitioner
that the withdrawal of benefit already granted is arbitrary,
retrospective in operation and violative of the principles of
natural justice, as no opportunity of hearing was afforded to
petitioner before passing the impugned order. It is further
argued by him that respondents failed to consider the various
recommendations and communications issued by the competent
authorities, including Deputy Secretary, Housing Department,
Executive Officer, Nagar Palika Parishad and other departmental
authorities, recommending that petitioner's past service be
counted for the purpose of third A.C.P. It is contended by him
that petitioner's repeated representations were not decided in
accordance with law and respondents mechanically relied upon
departmental communications to deprive him of his legitimate
service benefits.
6.
Learned counsel for petitioner contends that the
impugned Government Order dated 06.11.2013, insofar as it
excludes the service rendered in a previous Government or
statutory organization for the purpose of grant of third A.C.P., is
arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India. He further contends that once
petitioner's previous service has been acknowledged for pay
protection and continuity of service, there exists no rational
basis to disregard the same for the purpose of extending the
benefit of A.C.P. Scheme.
7.
Counter affidavit has been filed by respondent- State
Election Commission, the main contesting party, as well as by
the other respondents. In the counter affidavit respondent-State
Election Commission stated that writ petition is misconceived
and devoid of merit. It is further stated that petitioner was
initially appointed as a Peon in Nagar Palika Parishad,
Pithoragarh and thereafter, joined the services of State Election
Commission pursuant to a fresh appointment with effect from
07.11.1996. It is also stated that petitioner cannot claim the
benefit of continuity of service for the purpose of grant of third
Assured Career Progression (A.C.P.), as the services rendered in
the Nagar Palika Parishad, being a local body, cannot be
equated with service rendered under the State Government. It is
further contends that petitioner has failed to point out any
statutory provision or executive instruction entitling him to
reckon the service rendered in the local body for the purposes of
A.C.P. Scheme.
8.
It is further contended in counter affidavit of
respondent-State Election Commission that grant of A.C.P. is
regulated by Government Orders dated 08.03.2011, 01.07.2013
and 06.11.2013, which specifically govern the eligibility criteria
for grant of financial upgradation. It is contended that in view of
the clarification issued by Finance Department vide Government
Order dated 06.11.2013, only the regular service rendered
under the State Government is liable to be counted for the
purpose of A.C.P., whereas, the service rendered in local bodies,
autonomous
institutions
and
other
organizations
stands
excluded. According to respondent-State Election Commission,
the benefit of third A.C.P. was initially granted to petitioner due
to an inadvertent error in calculating the qualifying service and,
upon detection of the mistake, same was rightly withdrawn by
the impugned order dated 13.05.2014. It is submitted that no
vested or accrued right can arise from an order passed contrary
to the applicable Government Orders.
9.
It is further submitted by the respondent-State
Election Commission that the petitioner's reliance upon the
benefit of pay protection and the recommendations made by
various
departmental
authorities
is
wholly
misconceived.
According to respondent-State Election Commission, principles
governing pay protection and those regulating eligibility for
A.C.P. operate in distinct fields and are governed by different
executive instructions. It is also submitted that because
petitioner's previous service was taken into consideration for
pay fixation does not confer any right to count such service for
the purpose of grant of A.C.P. It is also submitted that the
recommendations or communications issued by the Housing
Department, Election Department or other authorities do not
create any enforceable right in favour of the petitioner, as the
Finance Department alone is competent to prescribe the policy
governing the A.C.P. Scheme, which is binding upon all
departments.
10.
Respondent-State Election Commission submitted
that, pursuant to the directions of this Court, respondents have
also
placed
on
record
petitioner's
appointment
order,
regularization order and other service records by way of
supplementary counter affidavit, which establish that petitioner
initially served under the Nagar Palika Parishad before joining
the State Election Commission. It is also submitted that the
Urban Development Department has merely clarified the factual
position and has supported the stand of Finance Department
regarding the applicability of Government Orders. The impugned
action is stated to have been taken strictly in accordance with
the applicable Government Orders and uniformly applied to all
similarly situated employees. It is, therefore, submitted that
there is no violation of Articles 14 or 16 of the Constitution of
India or of the principles of natural justice, and the writ petition,
being devoid of merit, deserves to be dismissed.
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
having perused the material available on record, this Court finds
that the principal issue arising for consideration is whether the
service rendered by petitioner in Nagar Palika Parishad,
Pithoragarh, prior to his appointment in the State Election
Commission can be reckoned as qualifying service for the
purpose of grant of third Assured Career Progression (A.C.P.).
The claim of petitioner is founded on the premise that his
previous service in the Nagar Palika Parishad ought to be
counted towards qualifying service for the grant of A.C.P.
However, the grant of A.C.P. is governed by the Government
Orders issued by Finance Department, namely Government
Orders dated 08.03.2011, 01.07.2013 and 06.11.2013, which
regulate
the
eligibility
criteria
for
financial
upgradation.
Petitioner has failed to point out any statutory provision or
executive instruction entitling him to count the service rendered
in the Nagar Palika Parishad for the purpose of grant of A.C.P.
after his appointment in the State Election Commission. The
contention that previous service was taken into consideration
for pay protection also does not advance petitioner's case. Pay
protection and financial upgradation under the A.C.P. Scheme
operate in distinct fields and are governed by different
provisions.
Merely
because
petitioner's
past
service
was
recognized for pay fixation cannot, by itself, confer a right to
claim the benefit of A.C.P. by considering the said service.
Likewise, initial grant of the third A.C.P., if made contrary to the
applicable Government Orders, did not create any vested right
in favour of petitioner, and the competent authority was justified
in rectifying the error by passing the impugned order.
12.
This Court also finds no merit in the challenge to the
Government Order dated 06.11.2013, as no material has been
placed on record to demonstrate that the same is arbitrary,
discriminatory or violative of any statutory or constitutional
provision. The impugned order dated 13.05.2014 has been
passed in consonance with the applicable Government Orders
governing the A.C.P. Scheme and, therefore, warrants no
interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction.
13.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
14.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
07.07.2026
PN
PREETI
NEGI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=63c75a8c4765581180a58d7478fadbe38331bac55c78b5f9f0276c16432f6aab,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=2BA53171893B3C3CB3CCCAE81FAE064498483A83D84BDB0F9229D5BF
08D959AC, cn=PREETI NEGI
Date: 2026.07.07 17:08:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review