Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
[ 3488 ]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 28711 OF 2026
Between:
Bheemanathi Samhitha, D/o V.Vijayalakshmi Aged 17 yea$, Occ. Student
Being minor Rep by her Guardian/mother V. Vijayalakshmi, Aged about 48
years, Occ. Chief Manger, Canara Bank, FUo Flot No.301, Block A, Raaga
central court, Nizampet Road, Kukatpally, Medchal/Malkajgiri District,
Telangana-500072.
AND
...PET!T|ONER
1. The state of Telangana, Rep, by its Principal Secretary, Medical and health
department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad,
2. Kaloji Narayana Rao, University of health sciences Rep by its Registrar,
Nizampura, Warangal, Telangana 506007
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
writ of Mandamus declaring the rule 3(a) of Telangana [\/edical and Dental colleges
admission (admission into MBBS and BDS courses) Rules 2017 as amended vide
G.O.Ms.No.150 Health, Medical and family welfare (Cl ) Department dated 8th
September 2025 excluding the children of employees of Central Government and the
Central Public Sector Undertakings and Central Government Undertakings as being
illegal, unconstitutional, manifestly arbitrary, in violation of Article 14, 19, and 21 of
the Constitution of lndia and consequently direct the respondents to declare the
petitioner as local candidate for all purposes of admission into MBBS/BDS Pursuant
kr NEET (UG) 2026 for MBBS/BDS Admissions under competent Authority Quota2026-2027.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
rr:spondents to treat the Petitioner as local and to admit her into the admission of
[\1BBS course under BC 'B' quota of Telangana local list for the academic year 2026-
27 pending disposal of the main Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI V.R.MACHAVARAM
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FW
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COI'RT FIOR THE STATE OF TEIIINGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH I{I'MAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No.28711 of 2026
[CNR No.HBHC0 Lo s9 46220261
DATE:os.O9,2026
BETWEEN:
Bheemanathi Samhitha
.,..Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Medical and Health Department and
another
..., Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri V.R.Machavaram, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Sri T.Sharath, learned Standing Counsel for Kaloji Narayana Rao
University of Health Sciences appearing for respondent No.2 and
perused the record.
2.
The present writ petition is hled with the following prayer:
". .. ... ro is.sue an appropiate wit, order or direction more
particularlg one in the nature of u.tit of Mandamus declaring the
rule 3(a) of Telangana . Medicol and Dental colleges admission
(admission into MBBS ond BDS courses) Rules 2O17 as omended
uide GOMs No. 150 HeaLth, Medtcal and family uelfare (C1)
Department doted 8t September 2025 excluding the children of
emplogees of Central Gouemment and the Central Public Sector
Undertakings and Central Gouernment Undertakings as being
tLlegal, unconstitutional, maniftstlg arbttrary, in uiolation of
Articte 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution of India and
conseqtently direct tlrc respondents to declare the petitioner as
local candiclate for all purposes of admission ittto MBBS/ BDS
F\).rsuant to NEET (UG) 2026 for MBBS/BDS Admissions under
competent AuthoitA Quota 2026-2027 anci pass such other
ord.ers as this Hon'ble Court deem fit and proper in the
circumstonces of the case "
Factual Matrix
3.
The petitioner, Bheemanathi Samhitha is represented by her
mother, V.Vijayalakshmi, The petitioner's mother is stated to be an
Officer in Canara Bank, whrch, according to the petitioner, is a
Government of India (GOI) undertaking. The petitioner's mother
joined in the employment with the Canara Bank in the year 2001'
The movement of the family bettt'een different places is on account of
the transferable nature of her mother's service.
4,
The particulars of the places petitioner's education are as
follows:
Class
Class I
Class II
Class III and 1\'
Class V to Class IX
Class X, XI arrd XII
School
MNR School of Excellence,
State
Telangana
Faslwadi, Sangareddy,
ODIr Kendriya Vidyalaya, Telangala
Eddumailaram
Kendriya VidyalaYa, AFS Telangana
Begumpet
Andhra Pradesh
Telaagana
5.
The petitioner appeared for NEET (UG)-2O26 and secured an
A1l India Rank of 1,34,196 and a Telangana State Rank of 2,764, and
sought admission to the MBBS/BDS courses for the academic year
2026-27 under the Competent Authority Quota, which is subject to
the local candidature requirements prescribed under the Rule 3(a) of
the Telangana Medical and Dental Colleges Admission (Admission
into MBBS and BDS Courses) Rules,2017, (for short'2017 Rules').
6.
That pursuant to the notihcation issued by the 2"d
respondent-University, petitioner submltted her application and
participated in the online counselling process on 06.O8.2026.
7.
The prospectus issued by the 2"a respondent prescribed, for
candidates claiming local slatus, the requirement of four consecutive
academic years of study in the local area immediately preceding the
relevant qualifying examination, subject to the following exceptions:
(i) Children of employees of the Telangana State Government
who have served or are serving outside Telangana.
(ii) Children of service or retired officers belonging to the
Telangana cadre of A11 India Services (IAS/IFS/IPS) who
have served or are serving outside Telangana.
(iii) Children of defence personnel/ ex-servicemen/ Central
Armed Police Force service.
(ir) Children of employees of a
Corporation I Agency I
Instrumentalit-v under Government of Telangana, liable to
be transferred in India
A provisional merit list was published on 24.O8.2026, wherein the
petitioner states that her name figured at Serial No.410.
8.
Ho"\,ever, upon publication of the Final Merit List dated
28.O8.2026 by !na respondent, the petitioner's name was not
included therein apparently on the ground that the petitioner was
not a local candidate. Aggrieved thereby, the petttioner filed the
present writ pelition.
Submissions on be half of the petitioner
9,
The learned counsel for the petitioner advanced the following
submissions:
i)
That the classification embodied in the proviso to Rule 3(a)(iii)
of 2077 Rules is manifestly arbitrary and bears no rational
nexus with the object sought to be achieved by the Rule.
According to learned counsel, the very purpose of the exception
1s to protect chrldren who are compelled to pursue their
education outsicle Telangana, not by choice, but on account of
the transferable nature of the employment of their parents.
iil That there rs no intelligible differentia between children of
Telangana State Government employees and children of
Central Government employees, including employees of Centra,l
Government Corporations or Undertakings, insofar as the
educational hardship occasioned by transfer is concerned ln
either case, the child is required to relocate outside the State
soiely by reason of the parent's ofhcial posting Learned
counsel would contend that the nature of the employer cannot
constitute a rational basis for conferring the benefit upon one
class while denying it to another similarly situated class.
iii)
That Canara Bank is a GOI undertaking under the control of
the Central Government and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI),
and is accordingly a Central Government Undertaking/ Central
Public Sector Undertaking (PSU) which has been wrongfully
excluded while considering the local residential status of the
petitioner.
irr) Placing reliance upon the order of this Court in W.P.No.23998
of 2026 dated 17.08.2026, it is contended that this Court has
directed that the proviso to Rule 3(al of 2077 Rules be read to
include children of employees o[ the Central Government,
Central Government Corporations, and Central PSU, and that
the petitioner's case is squarely covered by the said direction
inasmuch as her mother is employed as an Officer in Canara
Bank, which is a public sector undertaking and that the
exclusion of the petrtioners in the final merit list apparently on
lhe ground that the petitioner is not covered by the exception,
as interpreted by this Court in W.P.No.23998 of 2026 is il1ega1.
v) That the certificate dated 05.06.2026 issued by the Deputy
General Manager, Human Resources Wing of Canara Bank (for
short'HR Wing'), expressly certifies the Bank to be a PSU, and
being an ofhcial communication issued by a senior functionary
of the Bank's HR Wing, ought to be accepted by this Court as
sufficient proof of the Bank's status for the purpose of
extending rhe benefit of the proviso to Rule 3(a) of 2017 Rules.
vi) That as per the list of central case rs PSUs available on
Wikipedia, Canara Bank is shown as a nationalized bank with
62.93o/o GOI shareholding on account of which the petitioner
stands entitled for the benefit of the exception from the
continuous residence requirement.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
10. 'lhe learned Standing Counsel appearing for 2"d respondent
has advanced the foilowing submissions:
i) That the petitioner cannot claim, as a matter of right,
extension of the benefit of the proviso to Rule 3(a)(iii) of 2017
Rules merely on the ground that her mother is employed in
Canara Bank. It is contended that the exception carved out
under the said Rule is a specific and limited statutory
exception, intended to operate only in respect of the categories
expressly identified therein, and cannot be enlarged by judicial
interpretation so as to cover every employee of an entity which
may, in some manner, be described as a Central Government
undertaking or PSU.
ii) That Canara Bank is a banking institution carrying on
commercial banking activities and its employees cannot be
equated with employees of the Central Government or with
employees of Central Government Corporation/ Central PSU.
The petitioner, therefore, cannot seek parity with the categories
specificaliy enumerated in
the proviso without first
establishing that the institution in which her parent is
employed, fa1ls squarely within the statutory expression
employed in the Rule.
iii)
That the proviso to Rule 3(a)(iii) of 2017 Rules is not a general
exemption available to the children ol all persons employed by
entities having an associaLion with the Centrai Government.
The benefit is conhned to the classes expressly recognized by
the rule-making authority. If the intention of the State were to
extend the exception to employees of public sector banks or
banking institutions, the same could have been expressly
incorporated in the Rule. In the absence of such an express
inclusion, the Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, cannot rewrite or enlarge the
scope of the statutory exception.
irr) That the reliance placed by the petitioner on material sourced
from Wikipedia to establish the constitutional/ administrative
status of Canara Bank is impermissible, on account of the fact
that Wikipedia, being an online, crowd-sourced encyclopedia
that is open to editing by any member ol the public, is not an
authentic or reliable source for adjudication of legal disputes.
v) That the petitioner cannot rely upon the principle of parity
with employees of the State Government merely because both
categories may be liable to rransfers outside the State.
According to the 2nd respondent, transferability by itself cannot
constitute the sole basis for claiming an exception to the localcandidate requirement, since the eligibility <:onditions under
Rule 3(a)(iii) of 2077 Rules are framed by the competent rule-
making authority having regard to the State's policy
concerning admissions under the Competent Authorify euota.
vi) That the certificate dated 05.06.2026 issued by the Deputy
General Manager, Human Resources Wing of Canara Bank, is
an internal communication of the Bank concerning its own
general description, issued by an official who has no authority,
competence or occasion to pronounce upon the Bank,s
classification for the purposes of an executive/ statutory
scheme framed by the State Government of Telangana.
11. We have taken note of the respective submissions urged and
perused the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
12. The challenge in the instant writ petition is to Rule 3 ol 2Ol7
Rules, as amended uide G.O.Ms.No.150 Health, Medical & Family
Welfare (C 1) Department dated 08.09.2025, as being illegal on
account of excluding the children of Central Government employees
or Central PSUs. Perusai of the Rules would show that the
Government, has carved out exceptions for certain category of
candidates. Rule 3, as far as it is relevant, is extracted hereunder for
ready reference:
(a) A candidote for admission into undergraduate courses
under Competent AuthoitA Quota' in Telangana should be
Indtan Notional/ Person of Indtan Ortgin (PIO)/ Ouerseos
Citi-z,ens of India (OCI) card holder and shall fulfil the
fotlowing prouisions:
i) If the candtdate hos studted in educational Institutions tn
suclt LocoL area for o penod of not less than four
consecutiue academic years ending tutth the academic gear
in whiclt le appeared or as the case may be first appeared
in the reteuant qualifuing examination.
(or)
ii) W\rcre during the whole or anA part of the four
consecutiue academic gears endtng with the academic year
in whicLt he appeared, or as tlle cose maA be, first
appeored for the releuant qualifAing examination, he has
not studied in ang educationdl institutions, if he ha-s
resided tn that local area for a peiod of not [ess than four
years immediatelg preceding the date of commencement of
tlrc releuant quaLifuing examination whtch he oppeared or
as the case may be f.rst appeared.
/t
iii) Local area heretn means the State of TeLangana.
Further. tn case th,e candrdate has not studied in ang
educationaL instiution and has resided in the local area as
stated at lir) aboue, to be eligible for admission into
undergraduate coarses under 'Competent AuthoitA Quota',
the candidate shouLd haue appeared for the releuant
quaLifging examina.tion in the State of Telanqana:
I . Proutd.ed that a. candidate who studies outside
TelangantL for ang penod duing the requisite four
conserutiue acodemic gears ending uith the academic gear
in which b'e appeared, or as the case may be, ftrst
appeared in the releuant quahfuing examination tuill be
eligible to be considered if theg fatl under ang of the betout
categoies:
L Cht[dren of emDlouees of the Tel
ana Stote
Gouemment uho haue serued or are seninq outside
Telan ana cones ndi
to the condidate's ear. SO
studu outside Telan qana
2. Children of serui nq or retired officer's belonqinq to the
Tetaneana cadre of Alt India Seruices (IAS/ IFS/ IPS)
tuho houe serued or ore seruin q out side 'l'elonqana
corcespondin q to the candidate's uear/ s of studu
outside Telanqana
3. Chitclren of de fence personnel/ ex s eruicemen/ Central
Armed Police Force seruice u..tho at the time of ioinino
s erulce
haue declared their hometotun to be in t he
State of Tela nqana and. u.,tho haue secured or are
sen)tnq outstde Telanqana conespondin q to the
candidate s ueal/ s of studu outside Telan qana
4. Children of e mplouees of a Corporatio n/ Aqencu/
InstnLmenta[itL1 under Gouemment of Telanqana,
Liable to be transfened an uwhere in India as per the
terms and conditions of Ltis/ her emploument who
haue serued or are seruinq outside I'elanqana
corespondin q to the candidate's uear/ s of studu
outside Telanqana."
(Dmphasts supplied)
A plain reading of Lhe aforesaid Exception (4) to the proviso to
Rule 3(a) of 2017 Rules, demonstrates that the aforesaid provision
makes it clear that [\4'o cumulalrve conditiolls must be satisfied.
First,
the
emplovee must
be
employed by
a
..1
uCorporation/ Agency/ Instrumentality under
Government of
Telangana"; and, secondly, such employee must, under the terms
and conditions of his or her employment, be liable to be transferred
anywhere in India. These conditions are conjunctive and not
disjunctive. Consequently, the mere fact that an employee is liab1e
to be transferred anynvhere in India, without satisfying the first
condition, would not bring the case within the ambit of Exception (4)'
Any other interpretation would have the effect of extending the
exception to employees of every organisation having an all-lndia
transfer liability, irrespective of whether the employer is a
Corporation, Agency or Instrumentality under the Government of
Telangana or not.
Such an interpretation would render the
qualifying words employed by the Rule-making authority otiose and
would be contrary to the plain scheme and language of the provision.
13. It is pertinent to note that the language of the proviso makes it
clear that liabilily to be transferred anywhere in India does not confer
the benefit of the exception. In the case of Exception (4), such
transfer liability is only one of the requirements. The other and
essential requirement is that the employee must be employed by a
Corporation, Agency or Instrumentality under the Government of
Telangana. However, in the present case, the petitioner's mother is
admittedly an employee of Canara Bank. Merely because her service
is transferable and she may be liable to be posted at different places
T2
in India, her employment cannot be brought within the expression
"Corporation/Agency/lnstrumentality
under Government of
Telangana" occurring in Exception (4). Therefore. the petitioner,s
mother's emplovmenl does not fall within the specific class of
employment contemplated under Exception (4) to the proviso to Rule
3(a) of 20 1 7 Rules.
14. It is a well settled principle of statutory construction that
where a provision creates specihc and enumerated exceptions
subject to express qualifying conditions, those conditions must be
given their due meaning and effect. The deliberate inclusron of
particular qualifl.ing words in one exception, when contrasted with
their absence in another, is a relevant indication of the legislative
intent and cannor be disregarded. The principle embodied in the
maxim expressio unius est exclusio alteius (the express mention of
one thing implies the exclusion of others) therefore assumes
significance in construing the scope of the exceptions contained in
the proviso.
15. It is also pertinent to note that the petitioner,s mother is an
Officer/Chief Manager of Canara Bank, which is a body corporate
constituted under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer
of Undertakings) Act, 797 O (for short ,1 970 ActJ . It is no doubt true
that a Public Sector Bank, being an entity established under a
Central enactment and substantially owned
or controlled bv the
Central Government, may falls within the expression "State" or
"other authority' under Article 12 of the Constitution of India.
However, such characterisation made for the specific constitutional
purpose of determining the amenability of such bodies to the
applicability of Part III of the Constitution or the maintainability of a
writ petitron under Article 226 of the Constitution of India does not,
by itsetf, mean that the employees of such a bank become employees
of the Central Government. Nor does it follow that the bank must be
treated as a "Central Government Corporation" or "Central PSU' for
every statutory or administrative purpose, more particularly in
extending a State Government concession to the wards of the
employees.
16. Further, the distinction assumes significance in the present
case, as the Canara Bank is a separate corporate entity, and the
service relationship of its officers and employees is with the Bank (as
a corporate body), and not with the GOI as such. The fact that the
Bank is a Public Sector Bank and that its employees may be liable to
transfer or posting at different places in India cannot, by itself,
satisfy the specific requirement contained in Exception (4), namely,
that the employer must be a "Corporation/ Agency/ lnstrumentality
under Government of Telangana."
17. At this juncture, it is apposite to reproduce Article 3 1 1 of the
Constitution of India, which reads as under:
t4
3I I. Dismissal, remoual or red.uction ln rank of persons
emploged in ciuil capaclties under the Union or d. Stdte.
(1) No person uho is a member of a ciuil seruice of tlrc Union or an
ct. Indla seruice or a cLuil seruice of a State or holds a ciutl post
u.n.der the Union or o State shall be dismisse:d or remoued bg on
cLuthority subordtnate' to thcLt blJ uthich he tuas appointed.
l2) No such person es aforesaid shall be clismissed or remoued or
reduced in ronk except after an inquiry in u-,hich he hos been
informed of the cltarges against him and giuen a reosonable
opportunitg of being heard in respect of those charges [* * *]:
lProuidecl thcLt tuhere it ts proposed after such inquiry, to impose
upon hint ang such penaltg, such penaltg may be imposed on the
ba.sis of the euidence aclduced durtng such inquiry and it shalL not
be necessory to giue such person onA opportunitA of making
representcttion on the penaltg proposed:
Prouided further that this clause shall not appllt-l
(a) uthere a person is drsmlssed or remoued or reduced in rank
on the ground of conduct uthich hos led to his conuiction on a
cnminal charge: or
(b) uthere the aulhoitg empoutered to dismls-s or remoue a
person or to reduce him in rank is satisJied thctt for some reason, to
be recorded bg tha.l authontg in u,tnting, il is not reasonablg
TtracticabLe to hold such nqulry; or
(c) uhere the Presidenl or the Gouernor, as the case may be, is
satisfied that in the interest of the secuntg d the Stote it is not
, xpedient t6 fi6li 3llcht tnqyiry.
(3) If, in respect of ang such person as aforesaid, a question aises
uhether il is reasonablg practicable to hold such inquiry as is
referred to in clause (2), the decision thereon of tLTe authoitA
empouered lo dlsmlss or remoue such person or to reduce him in
rank shall be final.l
18. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in State Bank oJ lr.did u. S,
Vijaga Kumarr, while considering the status of employees of the
State Bank of India (SBI) in the context of Article 31 1 of the
Constitution, held that employees of the Bank do not fall within any
' ltooo; + scc 481
of the categories specified in Article 311(1). Thus, the fact that an
institution is established or regulated under a Central statute, or
that its employees are governed by statutory service regulations, does
not confer upon such employees the status of holders of civil posts
under the Union or make them Government servants. The relevant
portion of the said decision is extracted hereunder:
24. ...The igllt that an offtcer or emplogee of the *.ate Bank
of Indta cannot be dlsmissed from serwice bg an authoitg
louer than the appotnting autlnritg is a creation of statutory
rules and regu lations. So far os the iaht or orotection
quaranteed under Article 31 1 of the Constitution is
concerned, it app lles to members of the Ciuit Seruice of the
Ilnion or an All India serutce or a Ciuil Seruice of a State or
who holds a ciuil post under the Union or a State. Admittedlu
the emplouees of the State Bank do not fall under anu one of
these cateq ories and theu cannot seek oru.l protegtion undel
Article 31 111) of the Constitution.
(Emphasis supplied)
L9. lt is apposite to note that the Department of Public Enterprises
(DPE) which is the nodal department in relation to Central Public
Sector Enterprises, maintains a separate administrative framework
for Central Public Sector Enterprises. Public Sector Banks, on the
other hand, are dealt with separately by the Department of Financial
Services, Ministry of Finance, under the statutory framework
governing banking institutions. Thus, the administrative treatment of
Public Sector Banks is distinct from that applicable to Central Ftblic
Sector Enterprises falling within the purview of the DPE. This
distinction assumes significance while construing the expression
"Central Government, Central Government Corporations, and
Central PSUs" referred to in the order of this Court in W.P.No.23998
of 2026 dated I 7 .O8 .2026. The said expression cannot, in our vierv,
be enlarged merely on t he ground that a Publi<: Sector Bank is
substantiallv ou ned or r:on trolled by the Union Govornment.
20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bank of Ind.ia u. O.P.
Sutantakor2 highlighting the difference in scrvice conditions
between a government e mployee and the employees of banks, whose
service conditions are governed by standing orders, has held as
under:
48. The emplogee:; of the natrcnalized bank mttg not enjog o
"status '' a.s ls the case of gouemment emploqees or the
statutory authorities tuhose terms and condttions of seruice
are gouemed bU the constitutional prouisions and/ or the
statutes and the statutory rules; but there is no gainsaging
thot the emploqees of the nationalized banks en joA secuitA
of their empLogmenl. So far as the employees of the State
Bank o_f India are concented, their terms and conditrcns of
seruice, as notice'rl hereLnbefore, are gouented bg statutory
rules. Llotueuer, so Jar as the emplogees of the- nationalized
banks are concemed, except for the matter of grant of
pension uthicl't is couered bg the regulations fram.ed in terms
of Section 19 oJ'the 1970 Act, other terms and conditions of
their seruLce are rLot statutory in nature. But the State Bank
of India as nlso the nationalized banks are "Stetes" Luithin
the meantnq o;f Arli:Le 1 2 of the Constitution oJ' India. Thte
seruices of the tuorkmen are also gouerned by seueral
standing orders ancl bipartite setttements which haue the
force of kttu. The banls, therefore, cannot take recourse to
"hire and fire" .for Lhe purpose of terminat[ng the serui.ces of
the emplollees. The banks are required to oct fairlg and
stnctlg tn terms oJ *Le norms laid down thereJor. Their actrcns
in this behatf mu.st satl-s/y the test of Articles 14 and 21 of
the Constitution qf India. Hautng regard to the tntendment of
the Scherne, each and euery emplogee uould not be entitled
1zoos1 z scc 72 1
to the benefi.t of the said. Scheme. Those utho are facing
discipltnary proceedings or working in a particular class of
emploAment are not eligible therefor.
2L, The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Fed.erq.l Bank Ltd.. v. Sagar
Thom,as3, held that the merely because RBI lays the banking policy
in the interest of the banking system or in the interest of monetary
stability or sound economic growth having due regard to the
interests of the depositors etc. as provided under Section 5(c)(a) of
the Banking Reguration Act does not mean that the commercial
activity of banking, discharge any public function or public duty.
22. The reliance placed by the petitioner on the decision of this
Court in W.P.No.23998 ol 2026 dated 17.0g.2026 is misplaced,
as
the petitioner therein was the daughter of an employee of the
Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC), a statutory
Corporation established under the Employees, State Insurance
Act,
1948 and functioning under the administrative control of
the
Ministry of Labour and Employment, GOI, whereas the present
petitioner is the daughter of an officer employed by Canara
Bank, a
nationalised banking institution u,ith a distinct statutory
and
administrative framework. Therefore, the direction issued in
W.P.No.23998 of 2026 which extended the benefit to children
employees of the Central Government,
Central Government
corporations and central pSUs cannot be mechanically extencred
1zooa1 to scc 733
of
to
emplovees of cverv Central Government-conrolled entity, including a
nationalised bank. Thus. the said reliance placed on W.p.No.2399g
of 2026 does not advance the case of [he petrtioner.
23. Further, the decision of this Court in W.p.No.23998 of 2026
dated 17.08.2026 r.r,as based upon the concession of the learned
Advocate Gencral. The said judgment neither interprets nor expands
the scope of the exceptron which is a policy driven concession. The
State ivould be well r,",ithin its right to reserve benefits in the
admission to the Under Graduate-Medical or BDS courses to the
local candidates, Thc cxtension of the concession by judicial
interpretation to the wards of the persons working in the commercial
banking companics may dilute the very purposc of the domicile rule
which is intended to safeguard the admission avenues of the
candidates of the specific state.
24, The State has a lcgitimate interest in providing that its own
domicilecl candidates are given priority. The Hon'blc Supreme Court
has endorsed the residency based reservation in State oJ
Telangana u. Kalluri Naga Narasimha Abhlrama. Every time an
exception lo the domicile rs expanded to a new class of candidates,
the quota available to thc local candidates gets shrunk. In the
present case, the fundamental legal distinction between the
Governmcnt Adm inistrativc Services and Commercial Banking
SLP(c) Nos 21S3(r 21i88 ot.2024 ctated. Ot.O9.2O2S
Employment cannot be lost sight of. The Central Government
employees execute sovereign functions of the State. Public Sector
Banks, even where the centre has major shareholding, operate as
corporate commercial entities, focused on financial services. The
employees of the banking compan ies are distinct from the Civil
Services of the state and the centre.
25. It is well settled that Courts must exercise judicial restraint
and refrain from rewriting the State policy. lf the benefit of the
exception in the rule is extended to the persons employed with
Nationalized Banks, there would be no logical reason to deny it to the
employees of private banks, Multi-National Corporations or the
private sector employees, who also hold transferable jobs, which
would ultimately defeat the very object and purpose of the rule.
26. The formulation of the residency criteria, is a pure policy
decision belonging to the executive or legislature. The Court's role is
lo see if the rule is constitutional, not to expand its scope for
perceived individual hardships. The classification between the
Government employees and the Banking Corporation Employees is
neither arbitrary nor unconstitutional. The Government employees
represent the administrative apparatus of the nation. Banking
institutions, on the other hand are independent corporate bodies
governed by the distinctive statutory bodies and have independent
recruitment and service rules.
27, Hardship alone cannot be a ground for the Courts to strike
down or expanrl a valid State policy. The residenc.y exception was
carved out as a restrictive measure for civil servants. Expanding this
benefit to the commercial banking personnel, would set a dangerous
precedent effectivelv frustrating the original intent oi the provision.
28. Insofar as the certificare datcd 05.06.2026 issued by the
Deputy General Manager, HR Wing, Canara Bank is concerned, it is
an in ternal communication issued by an ofhcer of the Bank,
describing Canara Bank as a "public seclor undertaking". Such a
description, contained in a certificate issued for the petrtioner's
service-related purposes, cannot determine the
legal or
administrative classificatron of the Bank for the purposes of the
Rules framed bv the State Government of 1'elangana. The officer
issuing the certilicate has neither the authority nor the mandate to
determine r','hethcr Can:lra Bank falls wi[hin the expression "Central
PSU" or "Corporation / Agency/ lnstrumentality under Government of
Telangana" occurring in the Rule. Therefore, the certificate cannot
override the statutory language or lhe relevanL adminislrative
classificalion of the Ba r-rk and does not advance the case of the
petit.ioner in establishing her entitlement to rhe benefit of the proviso.
29. Further the reliance placed by the petitioner on material
sourced lrom Wikipectia to establish the constitutional and
administrative statlrs of Canara Bank, cannot be countenanced.
2l
Wikipedia is a crowd-sourced and user-editable online encyclopedia
and cannot be treated as an authoritative source for determining the
Iegal or administrative status of an entity. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Heulett Packard India Sales (P) Ltd. a. Commr. of
Custom-ss, has cautioned against placing reliance upon such
material for adjudicating legal questions, observing that, though
such sources may provide useful information, they cannot be
regarded as completely dependable in matters requiring academic or
legal veracity. The relevant portion of the said judgement is extracted
hereunder:
14. At the outset, ue must note tlnt tle adpdicating
authoities while coming to tlrcir respectiue conclusions,
espectallg the Commissioner of Customs (Appeal) haue
extensiuelg refened to onltne sources such as Wtkipedia to
supp orl their conclusion. While u.te expressl u acknou-tledoe
the utilitu of these pLatforms ulhich orou ide free access lo
knou.tLedqe across the qtobe, but u.)e must aLso sound o note
of caution aqainst usinq such sources for Leqal dispute
resolution. We sau so for the reason that these sources,
despite bei nq a tre asure troue of knowtedqe, are based on a
croud-sqy1rced ond user qeneroted editinq model that is nol
completelu de ndable in terms of acad.emic ueracitu and con
promote mislead inq informa tion os has been noted bu this
coun on preuious occasions also [Commr. of Cusloms u. Acer
India (P) Ltd., (2008) 1 SCC 382, para 14 The courts and
odjudicoting authorities should rather make an endeauour to
persuade the counseL to place reliance on more rellable ond
authentic sources.
(Emphosis supplied)
s
1zozs1 z scc 799
Conclusion
30. For thc f.rcgorng rcasons, this courr is or rhc considcred
view
that the petirioner is not entitled to claim locai candidate
under lhe proviso to Rule 3(a). The petitioner,s mother,s
status
employment
with Car-rara Bank cloes not satisfy any of the l,)xceptrons to
The petition.r cilnnoL dt:ri'c anv benefit fr.m the drrectio,
Rule 3.
issued in
W.P.No.23998 rif 2026 u.hich was rendered in the
factual
background of rhat r,.asc and particularly on the basis ol thc
fair
concession bv tlte lcantr:cl ;\drrocatc Ceneral. This Court linds
no
arbitrariness or vLolation of Article 14 of thc Constitution in the
classilication made under thc said Rule. ConsequcnLl-v, the pctitioner
cannot seek c:onsideration for admissior-r to t hc MRIIs/ BDS Courses
pursuant to NEET iU(il 2026 as a local candiclale under the
Competenr Au thoritl euota.
31.
Accordingll . thc Writ [)ctition rs dismissed
As a sequcl, misct:ilaneous petitions, pcnding if any, stand
closed. No cos ts
SD/. M. OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
,..
L7
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble THE CHTEF JUSTTCE SRt APARESH KUMAR STNGH
(For His Lordships Kind Perusal)
AND
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice G.M. MOHIUDDIN
(For His Lordships Kind perusal)
To
1. 11LR Copies.
,
#: ,r.:i,T_.BJ;jw Unjon of tndia Ministry of Law, Justice and company
' Jffif""rTff; ;Ll::n' "'
Ad vocates Association Library,
Hish court
Ms. Bheemanathi Samhitha, D/o V.Vijayalakshmi Aged 17 years' Occ'
StudentBeingminorRepbyherGuardian/motherV'Viiayalakshmi'Aged
+A yeais, Occ. Chief Manger, Canara Bank,- Fl/o Flot No 301' Block A'
"u"ri
ni"gu ."ntr"t court, Nizampet Road, Kukatpally, Medchal/Malkajgiri District'
Telangana-500072.
5 one Cc to SRI V.R.MACHAVARAM, Advocate [oPUC]
for the state of
6 iwo ccs to Gp FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FW, High court
Telangana, at HYderabad. [OUT]
7 one Cc to sRt i.sHARATH, sc FoR KNRUHS [oPUC]
8 Two CD Copies
PSK.
GJP
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0810912026
ORDER
WP.No.28711 of 2026
o
o
o
1i1E ST4 16-
aD
11 SEP 20?1
t
:: ,l
. -.,^.n.)r/'
:--5zz
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
@
t\
q
il
s(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review