The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
67. Reliance placed on Deepali Gundu Surwase by the petitioners is inapposite. It was a case of wrongful termination and entitled the petitioner therein relief of back wages. The respondents have instead relied upon the exposition in P. Karupaiah (Dead) through Legal Representatives v. General Manager, Thruuvalluvar Transport Corporation Limited and J.K. Synthetics Ltd. which has restated the legal position regarding back wages. It has been held that it is not automatic or natural consequence of reinstatement. Suffice it to mention that for reasons already recorded hitherto including that the limited direction given by the High Court and not disturbed by this Court was to permit the petitioners to work on the concerned posts and to pay them regular salary as and when the same accrues to them, the plea under consideration needs to be recorded only to be rejected.
68. Be that as it may, keeping in mind the settled legal position, we have no hesitation in concluding that the case at hand does not qualify the test of contumacious, much less wilful disobedience of the order of the Court by the officers of the respondents as such. In other words, the basis on which the (2018) 12 SCC 663 (paragraph 10) contempt action against the respondents in reference to order dated 4.12.2018 issued by the respondents, has been initiated is tenuous. Hence, the same is rejected.” The order dated 12.08.2025 does not record definitive direction/finding as to whether the petitioner was working against the post of Sanitary Supervisor or he was entitled to the salary of Sanitary Supervisor. The direction issued in the order is that if the petitioner was working against the post of Sanitary Supervisor, he would not be removed, but would be allowed to continue against the post in question. Keeping in view the stand of the respondent that the promotion of the petitioner to the post of Sanitary Supervisor stood withdrawn from him under office order dated 12.01.2024 and in view of this office order, which has not been stayed, the petitioner was entitled only to the salary of Peon, in my considered view, no contempt-wilful disobedience of the order, can be said to have been committed by the respondents. The factual matrix of the case, is an aspect which is yet to be deter…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
COPC No.1247 of 2025
Decided on: 10.08.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Bhawani
…..Petitioner
Versus
Aditya Chauhan
.....Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Vivek Singh Thakur, Advocate.
For the Respondent: Mr. Rajiv Rai, Advocate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner has instituted this Contempt Petition
alleging breach of directions issued in the order dated
12.08.2025 passed in CWP No. 1885 of 2024 (Bhawani Vs.
State of H.P. and Ors).
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the case file.
3.
Vide order dated 13.03.2024 passed in CMP No.
2675 of 2024 in CWP No. 1885 of 2024, the respondents
were directed to maintain status quo qua the functioning of
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
the petitioner as it existed on that date.
Subsequently,
following order was passed in the matter on 12.08.2025:“CMP No. 19162 of 2025
By way of instant application, prayer has been
made on behalf of the applicant/petitioner to stay
order dated 19.06.2025 (Annexure AP-1) (available at
page 96 of the paper book), whereby one Mr. Tajinder
Kumar has been ordered to be posted as Sanitary
Supervisor at Nagar Panchayat Chowari.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioner, as has
been highlighted in the petition and further canvassed
by
Mr.
Vivek
Singh
Thakur,
learned
counsel
representing the petitioner, is that since vide order
dated
13.03.2024,
respondents
to
this
Court
maintain
had
status
directed
quo
qua
the
the
functioning of the petitioner, there was no occasion, if
any, for the respondents to appoint above named Mr.
Tajinder
Kumar
against
the
post
of
Sanitary
Supervisor at Nagar Panchayat Chowari.
From the averments contained in the application
as well as writ petition, this Court finds that petitioner
herein, who was working as Peon, was claiming
promotion to the post of Sanitary Supervisor, but since
such
claim
of
him
was
not
accepted
by
the
respondents, he approached this Court by way of
present petition.
Vide order dated 13.03.2024, this Court, having
taken note of the fact that petitioner is working as
Sanitary Supervisor, directed parties to maintain
status-quo qua functioning of the petitioner. During the
pendency
of
petition,
as
detailed
hereinabove,
respondents have proceeded to appoint Mr. Tajinder
Kumar, as Sanitary Supervisor at Nagar Panchayat
Chowari, as a result thereof, petitioner, who at present
is
working
against
the
post
in
question,
has
approached this Court in the instant application for
staying order dated 19.06.2025 issued by the Director
Urban Development, thereby deploying number of
persons as Sanitary Supervisors and Accountant on
outsource basis at various Nagar Panchayats.
Mr. B.C.Verma, learned Additional Advocate
General for the respondents-State and Mr. Rajinder
Singh Thakur, Advocate, for respondent No. 3, while
making this Court peruse order, sought to be stayed,
vehemently argued that present application is not
maintainable because it is none of the case of the
applicant/petitioner
that
person
namely
Tajinder
Kumar has been posted in place of applicant/
petitioner or pursuant to afore order, petitioner, who
claims to have been working against the post of
Sanitary
Supervisor
removed.
Learned
respondents
further
on
13.03.2024,
counsel
state
has
been
representing
the
otherwise
also,
that
appropriate remedy, if any, for violation of order dated
13.03.2024 is contempt proceedings, but till date no
such circumstance exists, as such present application
is not maintainable and same is required to be
dismissed at the threshold.
Having
carefully
perused
order
dated
13.03.2024, though this Court is persuaded to agree
with afore submissions made by learned counsel
representing the respondents, but having taken note of
the fact that at the time of passing of order dated
13.03.2024, factum with regard to working of the
petitioner against the post of Sanitary Supervisor was
brought to the notice of this Court and taking note of
such fact, this Court directed the respondents to
maintain status quo qua functioning of the petitioner,
this Court deems it fit to dispose of the present
application with liberty to the respondents to appoint
persons on outsource basis against the post of
Sanitary Supervisor, but if the petitioner is working
against the post of Sanitary Supervisor, he shall not be
removed, rather shall be allowed to continue against
the
post
in
question,
pursuant
to
order
dated
13.03.2024.”
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that in the operative portion of the above order, it was
clearly held out in case the petitioner was working against
the post of Sanitary Supervisor, he then shall not be
removed, rather shall be allowed to continue against the
post in question pursuant to the order dated 13.03.2024.
Learned counsel further submitted that petitioner had been
working against the post of Sanitary Supervisor, therefore,
he
could not be removed from the post of Sanitary
Supervisor. The
respondents have paid the salary to the
petitioner as Sanitary Supervisor till August 2025; That it
was only in September 2025, the respondents reflected the
petitioner as Peon and paid him salary accordingly. The
actions of the respondents according to the petitioner are
contemptuous.
Learned counsel for the respondent submits
that under office order dated 12.01.2024,
petitioner's
promotion to the post of Sanitary Supervisor had been
cancelled with immediate effect. This was pursuant to the
directions
received
from
the
Directorate
of
Urban
Development, Himachal Pradesh; In terms of the office
order dated 12.01.2024, petitioner was to continue to serve
against the post of Peon; Somehow, despite the order dated
12.01.2024 the petitioner continued to draw his salary as
Sanitary
Supervisor;
This
fact
was
noticed
by
the
respondent, who assumed the charge of Senior Executive
Officer, Nagar Panchayat Chowari under office order dated
03.06.2025; Immediately thereafter, office order was issued
on 30.09.2025 to the effect that petitioner serving as Peon,
had been wrongly drawing his salary attached to the post of
Sanitary Supervisor. Accordingly, his salary was fixed in the
corresponding pay scale of the Peon as per HP Civil Services
Pay Rules 2022 and excess payment of his salary was
ordered to be recovered in accordance with law.
Sudhir
Vasudeva
Ravishekeran2, Hon’ble
Apex Court
In
Vs.
George
observed that a
Court exercising jurisdiction under the Contempt of Courts
Act, 1971 must not travel beyond the four corners of the
(2014) 3 SCC 373
orders in relation to which contempt has been alleged. That
the Court hearing a contempt petition ought to restrict the
scope of its enquiry to such directions which are explicit in
the judgment or orders of which contempt has been alleged.
Abhishek Kumar Singh Vs. G. Pattanaik and
Others3 holds that benefit of
possibility of another view
(interpretation) of the order should be given to the
respondents:“64. Arguendo, the interpretation as propagated by the
petitioners of the stated orders dated 28.11.2017
passed by the High Court and 16.3.2018 of this Court,
is a possible view. Being another possible view, the
benefit must then be given to the respondents. For, it
would certainly not be a case of wilful disobedience as
enunciated by this Court in Sushila Raje Holkar v. Anil
Kak (Retired) which follows the dictum of this Court in
State of Bihar v. Rani Sonabati Kumari, Purnendu
(2008) 14 SCC 392 AIR 1961 SC 221 Mukhopadhyay
and Maruti Udyog Limited v. Mahinder C. Mehta.
65. It is well settled that contempt action ought to proceed
only in respect of established wilful disobedience of
the order of the Court. This Court in paragraph 12 of
the decision in Ram Kishan observed thus:
“12. Thus, in order to punish a contemnor, it has to be
established that disobedience of the order is
“wilful”. The word “wilful” introduces a mental
element and hence, requires looking into the mind
of a person/contemnor by gauging his actions,
which is an indication of one's state of mind.
“Wilful” means knowingly intentional, conscious,
calculated and deliberate with full knowledge of
(2021)7 SCC 613
consequences flowing therefrom. It excludes
casual, accidental, bona fide or unintentional acts
or genuine inability. Wilful acts does not
encompass involuntarily or negligent actions. The
act has to be done with a “bad purpose or without
justifiable excuse or stubbornly, obstinately or
perversely”. Wilful act is to be distinguished from
an act done carelessly, thoughtlessly, heedlessly or
in¬ advertently. It does not include any act done
negligently or involuntarily. The deliberate conduct
of a person means that he knows what he is doing
and intends to do the same. Therefore, there has to
be a calculated action with evil motive on his part.
Even if there is a disobedience of an order, but
such disobedience is the result of some compelling
circumstances under which it was not possible for
the contemnor to comply with the order, the
contemnor cannot be punished. “Committal or
sequestration will not be ordered unless contempt
involves a degree of default or misconduct.”
(emphasis supplied)
66. It is useful to recall the exposition in Director of
Education, Uttaranchal and also in K.G. Derasari &
Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.; wherein this Court
observed that in exercising contempt jurisdiction, the
primary
concern
commission
or
must
be
omission
whether
the
acts
of
can
said
to
be
be
contumacious conduct of the party who is alleged to
have
committed
default
in
complying
with
the
directions given in the judgment and order of the
Court. Further, the Court ought not to take upon itself
power to decide the original proceedings in a manner
not dealt with by the Court passing the judgment and
order. It is also not open to go into the correctness or
otherwise of the order or give additional directions or
delete any direction, which course could be adopted
only
in
review
jurisdiction
and
not
contempt
proceedings.
67. Reliance placed on Deepali Gundu Surwase by the
petitioners is inapposite. It was a case of wrongful
termination and entitled the petitioner therein relief of
back wages. The respondents have instead relied
upon the exposition in P. Karupaiah (Dead) through
Legal
Representatives
v.
General
Manager,
Thruuvalluvar Transport Corporation Limited and J.K.
Synthetics Ltd. which has restated the legal position
regarding back wages. It has been held that it is not
automatic or natural consequence of reinstatement.
Suffice it to mention that for reasons already recorded
hitherto including that the limited direction given by
the High Court and not disturbed by this Court was to
permit the petitioners to work on the concerned posts
and to pay them regular salary as and when the same
accrues to them, the plea under consideration needs to
be recorded only to be rejected.
68. Be that as it may, keeping in mind the settled legal
position, we have no hesitation in concluding that the
case at hand does not qualify the test of contumacious,
much less wilful disobedience of the order of the Court
by the officers of the respondents as such. In other
words, the basis on which the (2018) 12 SCC 663
(paragraph
10)
contempt
action
against
the
respondents in reference to order dated 4.12.2018
issued by the respondents, has been initiated is
tenuous. Hence, the same is rejected.”
The order dated 12.08.2025 does not record
definitive direction/finding as to whether the petitioner was
working against the post of Sanitary Supervisor or he was
entitled to the salary of Sanitary Supervisor. The direction
issued in the order is that
if the petitioner was working
against the post of Sanitary Supervisor, he would not be
removed, but would be allowed to continue against the post
in question. Keeping in view the stand of the respondent
that the promotion of the petitioner to the post of Sanitary
Supervisor stood withdrawn from him under office order
dated 12.01.2024 and in view of this office order,
which
has not been stayed, the petitioner was entitled only to the
salary of Peon, in my considered view, no contempt-wilful
disobedience of the order, can be said to have been
committed by the respondents. The factual matrix of the
case, is an aspect which is yet to be determined in the Civil
Writ petition.
Accordingly, These contempt proceedings are
closed, notice is discharged. It is, however, clarified that the
observations made above are only for the adjudication of
this contempt petition and shall not be construed as an
opinion on the merits of the matter.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
also to stand disposed of.
August 10, 2026
R.Atal
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review