Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Jay Sengupta
WPA 24912 of 2024
Bhavini Sinha
Vs
St. Xavier’s University and others.
For the petitioner
: Mr. Nilotpal Chatterjee
Mr. Satyaki Banerjee
.....Advocates
For the respondent
nos. 1 to 6
:
Mr. Partha Sarathi Sengupta, ld. Sr. Adv..
Dr. R. N. Jhunjhunwala
Mr. Ramesh Kumar Patodia
Ms. Megha Agarwal
Mr. Mohit Gupta
Mr. Milind Mohul Ghosh
.....Advocates
Heard lastly on
:
07.07.2026
Judgment on
:
29.09.2026
Jay Sengupta, J:
1.
This is an application praying, inter alia, for direction upon the
respondent University not to withhold the candidate/the petitioner from
moving to the next semester and from taking all examinations on the ground
of alleged lack of attendance. Several other similar matters were taken up
for hearing together, but one after the other. Common points were
canvassed. Therefore, this Court would be taking into consideration all the
contentions raised by the concerned parties while deciding this petition.
2.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has submitted
and has relied on the written notes as follows. The writ petitioner was
pursuing her 6 semester B.A LLB Hons course from the St. Xavier's
University; ii) The petitioner had approached this Hon'ble Court on a
previous occasion by filing a writ petition being WPA No 18899 of 2024
alleging failure of the University in condonation of her absence due (a)
Illness and (b) Participation in Xuvkala as a Core member. By solemn order
dated August 9, 2024 the writ petition was disposed of directing inter alia
"this writ petition is disposed of by granting liberty to the petitioner to make
a comprehensive representation before the Vice-Chancellor of the University,
who shall consider the same expeditiously and in accordance with law and
keeping in mind the decision of this Court in WPA 18202 of 2004. A copy of
the said order passed in WPA 18899 of 2024 is annexed to the writ petition.
In terms of the solemn order passed by this Hon'ble Court a detailed
representation was made to the University on 16.08.2024 specifically
pleading that (a) Illness and (b) Participation in cultural events as a Core
committee member of Xavier's University Cultural & Arts Society necessary
documents including medical certificate by the treating doctor were also
annexed to the representation; iv) On 14.09.2024 a purported order was
passed by the University, the reasoned is self contradictory in paragraph 5
of the said reasoned order it is mentioned that since the attendance was
55.76% which was below the minimum attendance of 65% to be eligible for
condonation on the grounds of illness and or involvement in extra-curricular
activities however in the same breath in paragraph 5.1 the University claims
to have adjusted 15 classes for participation in XUCUS as P.R head. The
word “Adjustment” does not find place in the Rules of the University and is
indeed adjustment or compromise with the rules by the University at its
whims and fancies, by whatever name called the same results in
condonation as it is adding 15 classes to arrive at the aggregate attendance,
on one hand the university is not considering condonation for illness as the
attendance is below 65% on the other hand condonation of 15 classes are
done participation in XUCUS as P.R head. Sport, events & off campus
placement is mentioned in clause 3.4.2" (b)" while clause 3.4.2 "(a)" provides
grounds for condonation for illness, the rules of the University doesn't
permit any distinction between the two. The reasoned order is not in
accordance with law as in spite of specific direction by this Hon'ble Court of
considering the petitioner's representation keeping in mind the decision
passed in WPA 18202 of 2024 Souparna Dey vs State of West Bengal, in
passing the reasoned order dated 14.09.2024 the University did not take
into consideration the order passed by this Hon'ble Court in WPA 18202 of
2024. There is no appeal to the solemn order dated 05.08.2024 passed in
WPA 18202 of 2024 and the observation and directions passed therein are
binding on the parties; v) The petitioner was advised 2 weeks home rest by
her treating doctor because of illness on and from 15.01.2024 (medical
certificate pg29 of the writ petition) and due to such reason around 35
classes were missed by the petitioner. University in its opposition has
admitted that during this period she had missed 27 classes
none of the
classes were condoned allegedly for not submitting the medical certificate in
terms of regulation 3.4.2a; vi) Paragraph 9 pg 11 of the affidavit in
opposition the University percentage of attendance of 19 out of 24 students
are although less than the required 65% (after condonation of their period of
absence) but more than the percentage of attendance of the petitioner, goes
to show that others were allowed condonation but in petitioner's case the
same was not allowed on the pretext of below 65%; vii) The petitioner was
requested by the authorized representative of Xavier's University Cultural
and Art Society (XUCUS) to function as the Core member in Xavrang and
Xavkala events conducted by Xavier's University Cultural and Art Society
(XUCUS) (pg 31of WP, brochure records Bavini Sinha -Core member), for
such reason the petitioner had missed around 40 classes over a period of 2
weeks during 2nd week of February, 2024 till 1 week of March, 2024 due to
participation in the Xavrang and Xavkala events organized by XUCAS. In
terms of regulation 3.4.2 b, the entire missed classes were to be condoned.
In opposition (pg 14 para 16 of AO) the University had admitted that the
petitioner was appointed P.R Head of XUCUS, however the University had
submitted that the missed classes were duly adjusted. In paragraph 17 of
opposition the University has averred that during the period of 2 weeks i.e.,
from 08.02.2024 to 26.02.2024 a total number of 55 classes were delivered
by the University out of which petitioner had attended 29 classes and
missed 26 classes out of which a total number of 15 classes were condoned
for her participation XUCAS. It is but obvious that if the petitioner was
participating as P.R. Head of XUCUS with necessary approval from
University authority the all the 26 classes missed during such period ought
to be condoned but instead only 15 were. The University in its affidavit in
opposition (pg. 15 Para 17) and in the reasoned order annexed in the writ
petition (Pg. 56 Para 5.1) had admitted that the petitioner attended 29
classes out of 55 classes during the Xavkala event and out of which 15
classes were condoned and adjusted leaving balance 11 classes where she
was marked absent. If 15 classes can be condoned and adjusted then 11
remaining classes missed during such period ought to be condoned and
adjusted when the aggregate percentage of attendance is below 65%; viii) It
is a fact that the classes missed by the petitioner during January due to
illness were not at all considered by the University, University in its
opposition has admitted that during this period she had missed 27 classes
(para 15 pg 13 of AO) none of the classes were condoned allegedly for not
submitting the medical certificate in terms of regulation 3.4.2a. if such
absent classes for illness (27 classes) and (11 classes) (as demonstrated in
para vii herein above) were condoned by the university the percentage of
attendance would have reached above 65% and like all students petitioner
could have participated in the 6º semester examination; ix) The University
did not publish any debarment list nor was any communication made to the
petitioner regarding rejection of her prayer and on and from 15.05.2024
examination of 6 Semester commenced and petitioner was not allowed to
participate therein; x) The last date of admission to semester 7 was
15.07.2024 as the petitioner's father was hospitalized for "Acute febrile
illness left sided pneumonitis." On 22.07.2024 petitioner had made a
detailed representation to the University authorities to allow her admission
to 7th semester (pg 42/43/44 of wp), the previous round of writ petition
WPA No 18899 of 2024 was filed and the same was disposed of on
09.08.2024. In terms of the solemn order petitioner had made a
comprehensive representation on 16.08.2024 but the University delayed in
passing the reasoned order till 14.09.2024 which resulted in missing of
classes in the 7th semester as well. University Regulations:- 1. Clause 3.4.2
A student who has between 60% (65% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) and 74%
attendance in a semester will have to seek approval from the Dean of the
concerned faculty/Vice-Chancellor on grounds of illness or involvement in
extra-curricular activities approved by the University; a) In case of illness,
leave application must reach the office of the Dean of Faculty within three
days of the student's absence. A medical certificate is also to be submitted
within 15 days of joining. Mere submission of leave application in itself will
not ensure condonation; b) In case of extra-curricular activities, a student
must obtain prior written confirmation of his/her participation from the
concerned authorities: Head of Department/Profs.-in-Charge of University
Societies/Sports Officer/Programme Coordinator of Social Work, which will
be countersigned by the Dean of the concerned faculty. When calculating
the attendance percentage of the students representing the University in
extra-curricular
activities
in
Inter-University
competitions,
due
consideration will be given to the days when they so represented the
University. Condonation in such cases must be in explicit written form,
authorized by the Dean of the concerned faculty; c) For a student, absence
from the classes for the aforementioned reasons may be condoned up to
15% (10% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) of the total classes delivered
However, in all such cases, lower limit for condonation will remain as 60%
(65% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) A student who is condoned will have to
pay a condonation fee within the notified period of time."; 2. Clause 3.4.3 " A
student will be debarred from appearing for the semester examination if i)
he/she has less than the required attendance without condonation." Thus,
the prescription in terms of this clause is first condonation is to be done to
arrive at the average attendance, if even after condonation if the attendance
is below the required percentage the student will be debarred; 3. Clause
3.6.1 A student must have at least 75% aggregate attendance in a semester.
Condonation may be granted (refer section 3.4.2) in exceptional cases; 4.
Clause 3.6.2 if a student does not fulfil the attendance requirement, as
mentioned in Section 3.4.3, he/she will be debarred from appearing for the
semester examinations. Thus, in terms of 3.4.3 first condonation is to be
done to arrive at the aggregate attendance and then if the student doesn't
fulfil the required attendance then the student can be debarred. 5. Clause
4.8 Arrear Papers - 4.8.1 An arrear paper is one in which a student fails to
secure the minimum pass marks. 4.8.2 Arrear paper may arise either
through failure or absence This will be indicated in the semester mark
sheet. A student will be permitted to appear for an arrear paper in the next
appropriate semester. A copy of the relevant rules is annexed herewith
marked with letter R1. Consistent stand of the University that the students
are well aware of their attendance as the same is available at the student's
portal in the form of Student's Attendance view, the foot note of the same
reads as Aggregate Attendance is calculated after the adjustment of classes
for sports, events & off campus Placement. ". Thus, it is apparent that the
Aggregate attendance is arrived at after adjustments/condonation. The
University has allowed every student who has secured 65% of aggregate
attendance in terms of the students’ attendance view, the touchstone was
65% and not 75%. a) University has specifically submitted that the students
were aware of their attendance status from the attendance view as the
attendance view was live i.e., after adjustment/condonation. Thus, all
students who had 65% of attendance and allowed actually had below 65% of
attendance before adjustment/condonation but condonation was allowed to
them, this vitiates the stand of the University that below 65% attendance is
not condonable. It is submitted that the University had failed in
implementation of its own Regulation as no list prior to condonation and
after condonation was prepared at the end of the semester before the
examination and unless the condonation is done at the end of the semester
i.e., just before the examination the implementation of rule i.e., no
condonation below 65% was not possible, University's stand that the
condonation
was
live
/spontaneous
thus
throughout
the
semester
condonation was made whenever the students have applied throughout the
semester, thus it can be safely concluded that if someone's aggregate
attendance was 65% at the end of the semester as per Attendance view it
might well include numerous condoned classes, thus students with below
65% was actually allowed condonation in violation of clause 3.4.2 c) Unless
the condonation was done/calculated at the end of the semester it's
implementation of clause 3.4.2 c) remains a fallacy; b) Clause 3.4.3" A
student will be debarred from appearing for the semester examination if i)
he/she has less than the required attendance without condonation. Thus,
the prescription in terms of this clause is first condonation is to be done to
arrive at the aggregate attendance, if even after condonation if the
attendance is below the required percentage the student will be debarred; c)
For all students who had secured attendance between 65 to 74% attendance
the University is not insisting for adherence to clause 3.4.2 i.e., leave
application & medical certificate must reach the office of the dean of faculty
within 3 and 15 days respectively. However in case of the petitioner the
condonation is not allowed allegedly on the pretext of the non submission of
medical certificate within time specified in 3.4.2 and the same amounts to
violation of Article 14 of the Constitution; d) The attendance view of
petitioner (pg 28 of wp) demonstrates that total number of classes
delivered(D) were 284 and the Attended classes (A) is added comes to 150,
the aggregate would (150/284 x 100 = )52.81 for reasons unknown the
Aggregate Attendance according to attendance view is 55.76%, 55.76% of
284 comes to 158.3 thus there is difference 8.3 classes The alleged
adjustment of 15 classes are yet again not explainable, rules does not
provide for adjustment and provides for condonation and if condonation
below 65% was permissible for participation in extra-curricular activity in
terms of clause 3.4.2.b, illness in terms of clause 3.4.2a could not have been
denied on the pretext of below 65%. The rules do not provide for a
distinction between clause 3.4.2a and 3.4.2.b, both are grounds for
condonation and stand on equal footing. In case of another semester 6
student, Himadri Poddar the attendance view reveals that she has attended
173 out of 287 delivered classes) average attendance should be 60.27%
however the attendance view reflects 61.57% thus 3.7 classes have been
added to arrive at the aggregate attendance though the University contends
that she was not entitled to condonation. A copy of attendance view of
Himadri Poddar is annexed as R2. Thus there is no sanctity to the
procedure of arriving at the aggregate attendance; e) Everyone between 65 to
74% attendance is allowed with a mere payment of condonation fees without
even a medical certificate; f) The University cannot act arbitrarily and make
a discrimination in adherence to clause 3.4.2 a) in case of students below
65% and not insisting on the same in students who had secured attendance
between 65 to 74% attendance; g) Regulation 3.4.2.c) For a student, absence
from the classes for the aforementioned reasons may be condoned up to
15% (10% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) of the total classes delivered it is
submitted that students cannot evaluate the status of their attendance as
the total number classes to be delivered were never disclosed by the
University before the examination. In the present case the attendance view
shows that the petitioner had attended 150 classes out of 287 (total
delivered classes). a) Advised 2 weeks of rest by the treating doctor on and
from 15.01.2024 ( para 4 & pg29 of writ); b) The University in its affidavit in
opposition (Pg 13 para 15) had admitted she had missed 27 classes during
said period, none of the missed classes during this period were condoned as
the medical certificate was not submitted within the timeframe ie in terms
Clause 3.4.2 a); c) The University in its affidavit in opposition (pg. 15 Para
17) and in the reasoned order annexed in the writ petition (Pg. 56 Para 5.1)
had admitted that the petitioner attended 29 classes out of 55 classes
during the Xavkala event and out of which 15 classes were condoned and
adjusted leaving balance 11 classes where she was marked absent. If 15
classes can be condoned and adjusted then 11 remaining classes missed
during such period ought to be condoned and adjusted when the aggregate
percentage of attendance is below 65%. The classes missed for petitioner's
participation in Xuvkala as a core committee member (para 6 pg 32 of wp
)were also not condoned, the allegations are dealt with in paragraph 17 pf
15 of opposition, unfortunately the University has disowned its liability; d)
Though a prayer for condonation was made to the university on
09/05/2024, 10/05/2024 and on 13/05/2024 (pg 33,34,35 of writ )the
same was not considered. Total number of classes attended as per
attendance view is 150 and the aggregate attendance is 55.76% as per the
attendance view, total classes delivered were 284 condoning 27 classes
missed for illness(pg 29 of wp) would have made and 11 for participation as
PR head of XUCAS as also classed missed for functioning as core committee
member of Xavkala in her aggregate attendance more than 65% and like
every other student between 65 to 74% of attendance petitioner would have
participated in her 6h semester examination. The stand of the University
that attendance below 65% is not condonable is misconceived as in terms of
3.4.3 first condonation is to be done to arrive at the aggregate attendance
and if after condonation the aggregate attendance is less than 65% the same
is not condonable. Clause 3.6.1 "A student must have at least 75% of
aggregate attendance in a semester. Condonation may be granted (refer to
Section 3.2.1) in exceptional cases. It is unfortunate that the University did
not even consider the prayer for condonation. It was obligatory for the
University to consider if the case of the petitioner falls under exceptional
cases in terms of clause 3.6.1. A conjoint reading of clause 3.4.2 c), clause
3.4.3 and clause 3.6.1 and more fully the conduct of University in
condoning attendance of other students including Bhavini Sinha and
Himadri Poddar (as described hereinabove written in clause 7.d) would show
that it was permissible to condone the absence of the petitioner and the
University had condoned classes even below 65%. The petitioner had duly
attended the classes of semester 7, 8 and 9 has secured the required
attendance also duly participated in the 7, 8 and 9 semester examination
though there might be some shortage of attendance in 7th semester as well
as the petitioner was not allowed to take admission or attend classes unless
directed by this Hon'ble Court, however the University has not regularized
the admission to 7, 8 and 9 semester neither evaluated the answer scripts of
7,8 and 9 semester. The University has never adhered to the its regulation
regarding
the
required
attendance
(clause
3.4.2)
on
previous
semester/semesters in the present semester no word of caution to the
students, unless the total number of classes are declared a students cannot
ascertain his actual status of attendance before the end semester, the
University could have taken extra classes in the interest of the students but
it didn't. Judgements relied upon by the petitioner :- a) Sri Bamang Nabam
vs North Eastern Hill University, wherein the Hon'ble Division Bench of High
Court at Meghalaya has held that "rule could cover a situation where in
normal circumstances a student is absent and his attendance falls below
70% But this rule certainly does not cover extraordinary circumstances like
illness or bereavement in a student's family, natural disaster, riot strike,
political upheavals other act of God and so on which prevents a student or
students from attending classes. In such case, this rule would not apply.
The Administrators of the college are to consider each case on its own
merit." A copy of said Judgement is annexed herewith marked with letter
Annexure R3. b) WPA 14385 of 2024 Aditya Chatterjee Vs St Xavier's
University and others wherein the student had 63.22% attendance and the
Hon'ble Single Judge was pleased to allow the writ petition. The University
might submit that they have preferred an appeal against order dt
20.05.2024, fact remains inspite of no stay order rather no interference as
on date the University has evaluated the answer script of the subsequent
semesters of the said students and the petitioner herein is discriminated. A
copy of said Judgement is annexed herewith marked with letter Annexure
R4. Direction for production of Records by the University in the instant
proceedings:- The petitioner in the instant writ petition had alleged nepotism
(para 29 pg 13), on 11.07.2024 in WPA 17553 of 2024 Himadri Poddar the
Hon'ble Court was pleased to observe "One needs to know whether such
condonation as claimed had actually been done in favour of anyone and if
so, what was the basis for the same. The University needs to produce the
records to show whether they have condoned such shortage in attendance in
other cases. Let the University file an opposition within four weeks from this
date. Reply, if any, be filed within two weeks therefrom. List this matter for
hearing after six weeks. On the next date, the University shall produce the
records of students' attendance view for the last semester in respect of all its
students of LLB. On 03.01.2025, 14.01.2025 and 20.01.2025 the court has
insisted on production of records in terms of previous direction dated
11.07.2024. On 28.01.2026 the Hon'ble Court was further pleased to direct
production of records regarding condonation of absence from classes for
whatever reasons in relation to the petitioner's sixth semester for the year
2023-2024. On 13.02.2026, further direction for production of records
regarding condonation of absence of all students from classes for the course
and batch for whatever reasons. On 20.02.2026 the University failed to
provide record in relation to all students to whom condonation was granted
on medical grounds, allegedly 18 students were granted condonation on
medical ground but records of only 5 students could not be traced out. The
record of condonation granted on participation in extra curricular activities
does not confirm to compliance of clause 3.4.2 b), no written confirmation
from the head/prof in charge/sports officer/ programme coordinator could
be placed before the Court, no explicit written form authorized by the Dean
of faculty could be placed before the Court. Submission in this regard: When
the petitioners have specifically averted discrimination and or nepotism,
specially when the Hon'ble Court is adjudicating the lis, it was the obligation
of the University to preserve and produce the record, failure of the
University to do so confirms to the averments/allegations being true.
Petitioner prays for :- a) Treating the examination of semester 6 as Arrear
papers and in terms of clause 4.8. and 4.8.2 participation in the all the
papers of 6th semester as Arrear papers of semester 6th at the next
appropriate semester and take the 6th semester examination at the end of
the course i.e., after 10th semester if required the petitioner can undergo
remedial classes; b) Evaluate the answer scripts of 7th 8th and 9th
semesters and declare the results wherein the petitioner has duly
participated.
3.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents has
submitted and has relied on the written notes as follows. Before adverting to
the facts of the case and the written notes of the petitioner, the respondents
humbly point out that:- i. The Rules and Regulations of the Respondent
University (hereinafter referred to as the University Regulations which are
statutory in nature and in fact has been so held in recent judgment of St.
Xaviers University Kolkata and Ors. vs. Yash Shroff, being MAT No. 1324 of
2024 [Cal. HC]) have not been challenged in the Writ Petition; ii. Whether a
case should be considered sufficient for the purpose of condonation is a
question of fact and it has been repeatedly held by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court that the error of fact however grave cannot be entertained in a Writ
Jurisdiction (reference: AIR 1964 SC, PR 477, 5 judges Bench); iii. The
Hon'ble High Court having directed Respondent No. 1 to consider the
representation of the Writ Petitioner, and the same having been considered
in the light of statutory Rules and Regulations and on the basis of facts on
record this Hon'ble Court cannot reassess the correctness of the said
decision of Respondent No. 1 and no case has been made out for
interference by this Hon'ble High Court; iv. If the view taken by the authority
is a possible view of the matter, then this Hon'ble High Court cannot
substitute the said view with its own; v. The petitioner having knowledge
that a minimum percentage is to be maintained for appearing in the
examination and twenty-five percent (25%) of the absence standing already
condoned by virtue of the rules one cannot act in contravention of the said
Rules and more so when undertaking was given by the petitioner and his
guardian with regard to maintenance of the percentage, not once but twice;
vi. Even after joining, after the alleged medical cause the petitioner didn't
care to be present in all subsequent classes which itself shows the negligent
attitude on the part of the petitioner and next if any lenient view is taken of
the rule, that will destroy the basic purpose of the introduction of the five
year law course as without attending the classes as prescribed one cannot
get adequate knowledge of the subject so as to be able to render the services
to the clients and society at large; vii. That an Article 226 Writ Petition
cannot be filed to do a roving and fishing enquiry against the Respondents.
A Petition can succeed only if a Petition makes out a case and not to give a
chance to establish the claim. [A Hamsaveni v State of TN (1994) 6 SCC 98 ].
It is not for the High Court to, at the instance of unsuccessful candidates,
place itself into a position of fact-finding commission and to commence a
roving enquiry (Sadananda Halo v Momtaz Ali Sheikh (2008) 4 SCC 619). As
per the said University Regulations, a law student must have 75% of the
attendance to be eligible to be promoted to the next Semester. However, the
Petitioner's attendance in the 6th Semester was 55.76% only, as a result of
which she was debarred from promotion to the 5th semester. As such, on or
about 27 September 2024, the student Bhavini Sinha filed the instant Writ
Petition seeking reliefs as prayed for in the Petition. The petitioner, Bhavini
Sinha, is a student of B.A.LLB (Hons.) course, having Registration No.
XK01-2112-0938-21 with CIN 21-001-06-31-0105. The duration of the
course is five years spread across ten (10) semesters. At the time of
admission, the petitioner and her guardian/parent signed a Declaration
Form on August 06, 2021, to maintain a minimum of 75% attendance (in
aggregate) in order to be eligible to appear in the semester examinations as
per Regulation 3.4.1 of the University Regulations as framed by the
Executive Council of the University pursuant to the powers contained in
Section 31(XVI) of the St. Xavier's University, Kolkata Act, 2016. The said
Regulations in Regulation 3.4 deals with Student's Attendance and
Regulation 3.4.1, 3.4.2 and 3.4.3 of the said Regulations are quoted as
under: "3.4.1-A student must maintain a minimum of 75% aggregate
attendance in a semester. 3.4.2-A student who has between 60% (65% for
B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) and 74% attendance in a semester will have to seek
approval from the Dean of the concerned faculty/Vice-Chancellor on
grounds of illness or involvement in extra-curricular activities approved by
the University. a) In case of illness, leave application must reach the office of
the Dean of Faculty within three days of the student's absence. A medical
certificate is also to be submitted within 15 days of joining. Mere submission
of leave application in itself will not ensure condonation; b) In case of extracurricular activities, a student must obtain prior written confirmation of
her/her
participation
from
Department/Profs.-in-Charge
the
concerned
University
authorities:
Head
of
Societies/Sports
Officer/Programme coordinator of Social Work, which will be countersigned
by of the Dean of the concerned faculty. When calculating the attendance
percentage of the students representing the University in extra-curricular
activities in Inter-University competitions, due consideration will be given to
the days when they so represented the University. Condonation in such
cases must be in explicit written form, authorized by the Dean of the
concerned faculty; c) For a student, absence from the classes for the
aforementioned reasons may be condoned up to 15% (10% for B.A.-LLB &
B.COM-LLB) of the total classes delivered. However, in all such cases, lower
limit for condonation will remain as 60% (65% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB).
A student who is condoned will have to pay a condonation fee within the
notified period of time. 3.4.3 A student will be debarred from appearing for
the Semester Examination if (i) he/she has less than the required
attendance without condonation; (ii) if the student has not paid the semester
fees by the notified last date. A student so debarred will not be eligible for
promotion to the next semester. Such student will be required to repeat the
Semester in the next academic session. If, in the meantime, there has been
a change in the syllabus, the student will have to appear for the CIA and the
Semester Examinations in the revised syllabus." That after admission, the
petitioner was given a link through email dated 20.08.2021 so as to enable
the petitioner to register himself on the University Student Portal
'www.sxuk.edu.in' and upon such registration, the petitioner had access to
all academic information, including his attendance from the Student Portal.
The classes of the sixth semester of the University began on 15.01.2024,
with the last class scheduled to be held on 06.05.2024. On 04.04.2024, St
Xavier's University, Kolkata, announced the dates for the sixth-semester
exam of the BA LLB (H) course, which was to commence on 11.05.2024. The
same was displayed on the University's website. The same was displayed on
the digital notice boards on all the ground floors of the academic blocks.
After the last class of the Semester was held on 06.05.2024, the petitioner
secured 55.76% attendance as she attended 150 out of 284 classes. The
same was lower than the minimum 75% attendance required to be eligible to
sit for the examinations. The same is also lower than the minimum 65%
required for condonation to be granted for health grounds. On 06.05.2024,
the petitioner submitted a medical certificate dated 15.01.2024 to the Xavier
Law School. The procedure for submitting the application was in violation of
Regulation 3.4.2(a) of the University regulations, which mandates that such
a leave application be submitted within three days of taking the leave.
Further, medical certificates as per regulations should be submitted within
15 days of rejoining classes, which was not done. On 09.05.2024, the
petitioner, vide an email to the Dean of Xavier Law School, intimated
respondent No. 5 that she had not received the condonation link, as a result
of which she was unable to access the download link for the admit card for
the end-of-semester examination. The Petitioner, in the email, also informed
the Respondent that she would be applying for a transfer after this
Semester, as it was becoming challenging for her father to look after her
younger brother. She also requested that the dean allow her to sit for the
exam so that her transfer post the Semester examination can be carried out.
It is submitted that in the particular cycle of examinations, 81 students of
different disciplines in different semesters had been debarred from
participating in the intermediate semester examination of 2023-24 due to a
shortage of attendance. Out of these 81 students, 24 students were
debarred from the LLB 5-year Integrated Course. The percentage of
attendance of 19 out of the said 24 candidates were although less than the
required 65% (after adjustment of their period of absence), but was more
than the percentage of attendance of the petitioner. The University rejected
the petitioner's request for condonation as her attendance was 55.76%,
which is below the minimum 65% attendance required for Condonation
request to be considered as stipulated in the University Regulations.
Further, the Petitioner did not submit the leave application within 3 days of
the leave taken and did not submit the medical certificates within 15 days of
the resumption of classes. A perusal of the records shows that during the
two-week period commencing 15.01.2024, 31 classes were delivered, of
which the petitioner attended 4 and missed 27. Further, the event Xavrang
2024 was held on 22nd and 23rd January 2024, during the period when the
petitioner claimed she was advised by her doctor to rest. Therefore, the
claims that she had missed classes due to being unwell and that she had
also missed classes due to taking part in extracurricular activities were
contradictory. Further, no classes were held on those days. Therefore, there
was no requirement for condonation of classes on those days. The Xavkala
2024 event was held on 02.03.2024, at which the petitioner participated as
the PR head of Xavier's University Cultural and Arts Society (XUCAS), along
with another student. Her responsibilities were primarily to draft event
brochures. In the run-up to the 2 weeks commencing from 08.02.2024, and
ending on 26.02.2024, a total number of 55 classes were delivered by the
University, out of which the petitioner attended 29 classes and missed 26
classes, out of which a total of 15 classes were adjusted for her participation
in Xavkala 2024, whose event was held on 02.03.2024. The preparation for
the event was done in the month of February 2024, where the petitioner's
responsibilities centred around drafting event brochures and reaching out to
sponsors. Most of these activities were event based and did not require
missing classes. The examinations for the 6th Semester Examination
thereafter took place between 11.05.2024 and 24.05.2024. The schedule of
the examinations was as hereunder: On 11.05.2024 – Law of Transfer of
Property and Easement; On 15.05.2024 – Corporate Laws II; On 17.05.2024
–Drafting, Pleading & Conveyancing; ON 21.05.2024 – Introduction to Crime
and Criminology; On 24.05.2024 – Political Science – IV. On 23.07.2024,
more than a month after the Semester examinations were concluded, the
Petitioner filed the Writ Petition 18899 of 2024. On 09.08.2024, the bench of
Hon'ble Justice Jay Sengupta was pleased to pass an order of which the
operative part is quoted as follows: “This Writ Petition is disposed of by
granting liberty to the petitioner to make a comprehensive representation
before the Vice Chancellor of the University, who is requested to consider
the same expeditiously and in accordance with law and keeping in mind the
decision of this Court in WPA 18202 of 2024”. The Petitioner made a
representation on 16.08.2024, and the respondent no. 2 constituted a
committee on 21.08.2024 and requested the said Committee to submit its
report by 29.08.2024. Due to intervening holidays, the respondents could
not respond to the representation made on 14.09.2024 in accordance with
the direction of the Hon'ble Court in WPA No 18899 of 2024. The Vice
Chancellor made a reasoned order based on the recommendations of the
committee as follows: a. For a one-day event, 55 classes could not have been
missed, and the Petitioner was just the PR Head of XUCAS, and all other
Core Committee Members involved in the said event have done well to
maintain their attendance; b. This was an intra college event, and the
petitioner was just a PR Head. Some classes were missed due to meetings
and other preparations, and thus the petitioner could have easily attended
the remaining classes in the day; c. The condonation of absence on account
of illness is to be taken into consideration only if the student is within the
zone of condonation, i.e., the attendance of the student is between 65
percent and 74 percent and the student has made an application as per the
rules and regulations of the university, which is not the case of the
petitioner; d. The rules and regulations of the university have been rightly
interpreted, and the petitioner was not eligible for condonation of her
attendance on medical grounds, and the petitioner was already given an
adjustment of 15 classes on account of her participation in the XAVKALA
event organised by XUCAS; e. The due process of calculating aggregate
attendance has been duly followed in the case of the petitioner; f. The
university has followed its regulations in entirety and has never chose to
follow a part of the rule and discard the other part. In the month of
September, more than 2 months after the exams for the 6th Semester were
concluded, the Petitioner filed the instant Writ Petition. The same was
moved before this Bench when the Learned Judge was pleased to pass an
interim order. The relevant part of the operative portion is quoted
hereunder: “There is no harm in granting time for exchange of affidavits.
However, no fruitful purpose would be served in making the Petitioner sit at
home without attending classes. This would complicate the situation further
in respect of the issue of attendance in future, especially in the event the
petitioner succeeds in this application. In view of the above, let Opposition
be filed within two weeks after the ensuing Puja Vacation. Reply, if any, be
filed within two weeks thereafter. List this matter for hearing under the
heading "Motion" four weeks after the Puja Vacation. In the meantime, the
University shall permit the petitioner to attend the classes for the VII
Semester without promoting her to the VII Semester or creating any equity
in her favour. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
given to the parties on completion of usual formalities.” The instant writ
petition was again moved on 18.11.2024, before this Bench, after the same
was mentioned for inclusion in the list by the Advocate appearing for the
petitioner on 18.11.2024, itself, on which date the Learned Judge was
pleased to pass an interim order. The relevant part of the operative portion
is quoted hereunder: “List this matter for hearing under the same heading
on 05.12.2024 at 2 PM. In the meantime, the University authorities shall
permit the petitioner, as in other cases, to sit for the 7th semester
examinations. However, the same shall not create any equity in favour of the
petitioner. In fact, the University need not even correct the answer papers
and keep them in a sealed cover. The fate of those answer sheets would be
governed by the final result of the writ petition. Parties shall act on a copy of
communication made by the learned advocate on record of the petitioner.”
At the outset, before dealing with the petitioner's submissions as contained
in the aforesaid written notes, I would like to state that the Respondent
University is a Juristic Person having limited powers as defined under the
Statute and being a creature of the Statute, it cannot transgress the barriers
of the statutory provisions and have to travel within the circumference
thereof. The Respondent University got the autonomous status by virtue of
the St. Xavier's University, Kolkata Act, 2016, which was duly notified in the
Official Gazette on January 16, 2017 and in pursuance of the powers
contained Section 31(XVI) of the said Act, the Executive Council of the
University has framed the Rules and Regulations as referred to hereinbefore,
which the University is bound to adhere to and cannot exercise any powers
de hors the said Regulations as such an act would be regarded as arbitrary
and in excess of powers conferred. Your Respondents are presenting these
Written Notes of Arguments to present before the Hon'ble Court the true
facts to show that the Petitioner has no ground for sitting for the sixth
semester examination. Granting relief to such a Petitioner would amount to
a grave injustice for the Respondents, as it would create a Precedent for
students to break the rules of attendance, which the University Grants
Commission mandates. It would make the University, which is considered
one of India's most premier universities, impossible to function. It would
also amount to a grave injustice for other students of the University who
have diligently followed the rules and attended classes. It will also be a grave
injustice to those students who did not have the required attendance and
had to repeat the Semester following the relevant rules. The Petitioner
Bhavini Sinha primarily contends that she should be allowed to sit for the
sixth semester examination without repeating the sixth semester based on
the following contentions. i. That she took part in the fest Xavrang and
Xavkala events as a core committee member, and therefore she should have
been given attendance for the same. She claims that she missed 40 classes,
over a period of 2 weeks, from the second week of February to the first week
of March; ii. That for a purported illness where she was allegedly advised by
her doctor to take 2 weeks of rest; iii. That the College had allegedly
previously allowed those with less than 65% of attendance to sit for the
examinations; iv. That Regulation 3.4.2 of the 5-year law course at Xavier's
University is arbitrary and discriminatory as it discriminates against those
studying in the three-year law program; v. That the Petitioner should be
allowed to sit for the arrear papers of the 6th Semester and clear them in
the 7th Semester. Your Respondents in these written submissions will deal
with every contention of the Petitioner to bring to light the true facts of this
case. The contention that the University did not grant her an adequate
amount of attendance for the event Xavrang and Xavkala is completely false,
as is stated below: i. Xavrang was held on the 22nd and 23rd January 2024.
As per her own petition, she was medically unwell on those particular days.
The Petitioner is trying to claim double condonation first by saying she was
attending a University event on those particular days and claiming
adjustment for extracurricular attendance, then also claiming condonation
by submitting medical leaves; ii. The Petitioner also misled the Hon'ble
Court by saying that attendance needed to be adjusted for those 2 days.
However, it is a fact that no classes took place on 22nd and 23rd January
2024. Therefore, there was no question of attendance adjustment for those
particular days; iii. What the Petitioner is surreptitiously claiming is that
she should be granted 40 attendance classes on purported preparation for
the cultural fest event Xavkala, which took place on. The Respondents
submit that no such provision exists which allows students to claim leave
for preparation of cultural fests without taking prior permission from the
University Administration. Any condonation for extracurricular activities
must be taken before the event and be approved by the faculty in charge of
the activity and countersigned by the Dean of the concerned Faculty. This is
as per Regulation 3.4.2(b) of the University; iv. The Respondents submit that
if students are allowed to claim an attendance adjustment for so-called
preparation for events without taking any permission for the same, it will
lead to students simply registering for any extracurricular activity and then
miss classes, saying they are preparing for it. This will make the University
impossible to function and lead to a complete breakdown of the academic
environment; v. For the event of Xavkala which took place for one day on
02.03.2024, the Petitioner had taken part in the preparation and applied for
adjustment of attendance. Based on the valid rules, 15 classes of the
petitioner were adjusted. However, Petitioner cannot claim as many classes
as they wish, which had no relation to the event and for which prior
permission as per the rules were not taken; vi. It is submitted that many
other students had taken part in the Xavkala event, which was just a oneday intra-college event. All these other students received the same treatment
as to the adjustment of attendance and met the attendance requirements of
the University. The contention that Petitioner should have had her
attendance condoned for the purpose of illness is completely false because of
the following reasons: a. Firstly, the Respondents would like to explain to
the court that leave due to medical reasons cannot be a substitute for
attending classes. Leave due to medical reasons becomes relevant only when
the attendance is less than 75% but more than 65% as per UGC and BCI
rules. In such a situation, any medical situation becomes relevant for the
purpose of condonation of classes. However, the statutory regulations are
clear that even if there are valid medical reasons, but the attendance is
below 65%, no Condonation can take place. In this case, the Petitioner's
attendance is 55.76% so the question of her medical fitness is not relevant;
b. The regulations as decided by the UGC, BCI and St. Xavier's University
are well thought out because otherwise any student would stop attending
classes and at the end of the semester, furnish medical certificates to sit for
the exam. This would break down the academic atmosphere and discipline
in all Universities. Further, it is for the well-being of the students that these
rules have been made, as attending a minimum number of classes is
essential for them to derive knowledge from the faculty to become better
lawyers. Otherwise, Universities will become mere exam-taking facilities; c.
Your Respondents state that, in addition to the above points made, the
Petitioners assertions in the Petition about health leave were false and
misleading before the court. Under regulation 3.4.2. (a) the Petitioner had to
file for medical leave within three days of the leave taken and provide
medical certificates within 15 days of joining the classes. Neither of these
regulations was followed, as an application for medical leave was filed only
on May 6, whereas the certificate was for 15.01.2024; d. However, it would
not have mattered as condonation for leave can be granted for medical
reasons only when the applicant is within the zone of consideration, i.e.,
between 65% 75% attendance. Since the petitioner's attendance is below
65% the Condonation for medical grounds cannot take place as per
Regulation 3.4.2 of the University. It is submitted that the allegation that
the University has allowed those with less than 65% attendance in the past
to sit for the University exam is absolutely false. The allegation was made
without any proof attached to the Petition and Affidavit in Reply. The
Petitioners submit that the intention of the Respondents submit was to use
an Article 226 Writ Petition to do a roving and fishing enquiry against the
Respondents. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the Division Bench of
Hon'ble Calcutta High Court and various other High Courts have held that
an Article 226 Petition cannot be used to do a roving and fishing enquiry.
The Respondents submit the following judgments for consideration before
the bench. i. A Petition can succeed only if a Petition makes out a case and
not to give a chance to establish the claim. A Hamsaveni v State of TN (1994)
6 SCC 98; ii. It is not for the High Court to, at the instance of unsuccessful
candidates, place itself into a position of fact-finding commission and to
commence a roving enquiry. [Sadananda Halo v Momtaz Ali Sheikh (2008) 4
SCC 619; iii. A writ is issued in favour of a person who has some right and
not for the sake of roving enquiry having scope for manoeuvring; further
held that where neither steps to enforce claims are taken except sending
vague representations nor any material produced before the Court, it would
be too dangerous to accept a plea, as here, to call upon the respondents to
produce their records. | Ratan Chandra Samanta v UOI 1993 Supp (4) SCC
67; iv. A Court is not expected to indulge in roving enquiry to rule out all
possible explanations and alternative scenarios justifying such irregularities.
[West Bengal Board of Primary Education and Anr v Priyanka Naskar and
Ors. 2025 SCC OnLine Cal 9448]; v. Allegations of Mala Fide are serious in
nature and they essentially raise a question of fact. It is, therefore,
necessary for the person making such allegations to supply full particulars
in the petition. If sufficient averments and requisite materials are not on
record, the court would not make "fishing" or roving enquiry. Mere assertion,
vague averment or bald statement is not enough to hold the action to be
mala fide. It must be demonstrated by facts. Moreover, the burden of
proving mala fide is on the person levelling such allegations and the burden
is "very heavy". [Dhampur Sugar v State of Uttarakhand (2007) 8 SCC 448];
vi. The defendants' request really amounted to the Court's collecting
documentary evidence which the defendants considered to be in their favour
at that point of time. It is no business of the Court to collect evidence for a
party or even to protect the rival party from the evil consequences of making
forged entries in those account books. (Padam Sen and Anr v State of Uttar
Pradesh 1960 SCC OnLine SC 77]; vii. The court cannot be used as a tool to
create evidence [Tejo Ratna Kongara v National Housing Bank and Ors.).
Therefore, the Petitioners' contention that the Respondents were allowing
students with less than 65% attendance to sit for examinations is to be
dismissed as they have not provided any evidence in their Petitions or in
their subsequent affidavits. The Petitioners' sole objective in making such
false and baseless allegations was to try to use the Court to enter into a
roving and fishing enquiry in a bid to create evidence and prolong the matter
as long as possible. The Respondents further submit that pursuant to the
order of the Hon'ble High Court dated 13.02.2026 the Petitioners submitted
documents available in the office of the Dean, Xaviers Law School, relating
to condonation and attendance adjustment records of the concerned
batches, namely: BALLB (Hons) Semester VI Even Semester AY 2023-24;
B.Com LLB (Hons) Semester VI Even Semester AY 2023-24; B.Com LLB
(Hons) Semester IV Even Semester AY 2023-24. In compliance with the
requisition, the following documents were submitted before the court. i.
Original letter of condonation prayer/recommendation submitted to the Vice
Chancellor in May 2024; ii. Original medical applications/documents
submitted by the students, as available in the records of the Dean's office;
iii. A detailed statement indicating the availability and non availability of
original medical documents/applications in respect of the concerned
students. It was further submitted before the court that, as reflected in the
enclosed statement, certain original medical documents/applications could
not be traced in spite of the best possible efforts of 13 students (non
petitioners), This was because the current Dean of St. Xavier's Law School
took charge on 01.07.2024 and was not handed over the papers from the
previous Dean. A perusal of the records submitted by the Respondents will
show the Hon'ble Court that the condonation was granted only to students
who had more than 65% attendance. No student who had less than 65%
attendance were granted condonation of attendance on health grounds.
Therefore there was no arbitrariness or prejudice in the decisions taken by
the Respondents. The Respondents further submit that the Petitioner is
trying to mislead the court while suggesting that she is allowed to sit for the
examinations as arrear examinations while going to the next trimester. It is
submitted that the rules are very clear that arrear papers can be given in
the next Semester only when a student has appeared and been unable to
clear the paper. However, the rules are clear that in case a student misses a
semester paper due to attendance shortfall, the person cannot be allowed to
sit for the exams and move on to the next Semester. This is to maintain
academic discipline in the University, otherwise students will keep missing
classes and keep moving to Semester after Semester keeping papers as
arrears and clearing them as per their own pleasure. It is further submitted
that similar guidelines are present in other top National Law Universities
and many other Law Universities. In the affidavit of Reply, the contention
being made by the Petitioner is that because she received an adjustment of
attendance for her participation in extracurricular activities, she is liable for
condonation even though she has less than 65% attendance. It is submitted
that such a claim is misconceived as the Respondent University adjusts
attendance for participation of students for participating in extra curricular
activities pre-approved by the University. This is done for every student of
the University. This does not mean that Condonation, which is a reprieve
granted for students who have less than 75% attendance, but more than
65% attendance should now be infructuous. The Respondents submit that
The Hon'ble Calcutta High Court had dismissed the Petition of student in
IIM Calcutta who had claimed relaxation of attendance requirement and
passage to the next Semester on sympathetic grounds of health. The Court
held that "The Petitioner being awarded degree in such circumstances,
would send a bad message to the student community at large and in such
cases, sympathy and compassion should have no role to play, and in the
event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the institution rather than the
student (Shubham Pal and Ors. vs Staff Selection Commission and Anr.
(Civil Appeal No(s). of 2026 (arising out of SLP (c) No(s). 21999/2024)) as
such indigence will not create difficulties for the institution but also for the
students." (Harish v Union of India and Ors WPA 24155 of 2025, para 32].
Thus, the petition filed by the petitioner is devoid of any merit and deserves
to be dismissed with costs. Decisions relied upon by the respondents: a. By
virtue of the powers conferred in the parent Act, the Executive Council
framed the Rules and Regulations for Under-Graduate Degree Courses
containing
the
exhaustive
provisions
relating
to
conducting
the
examinations, the attendance percentage, the medium, the discipline and so
on so forth. The regulation is exhaustive and imbibes within itself the
minimum attendance to be adhered by the student in order to qualify in the
examination conducted for a particular Semester. Rule 3.4.2 of the said
Rules and Regulations are quoted as under: "3.4.2 A student who has
between 60% (65% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) and 74% attendance in a
semester will have to seek approval from the Dean of the concerned
faculty/Vice-Chancellor
on
grounds
of
illness
or
involvement
in
extracurricular activities approved by the University. a) In case of illness,
leave application must reach the office of the Deana of Faculty within three
days of the student’s absence. A medical certificate is also to be submitted
within 15 days of joining. Mere submission of leave application in itself will
not ensure condonation; b) In case of extra-curricular activities, a student
must obtain prior written confirmation of his/her participation from the
concerned authorities: Head of Department/Profs.-in-Charge of University
Societies/Sports Officer/Programme coordinator of Social Work, which will
be countersigned by the Dean of the concerned faculty. When calculating
the attendance percentage of the students representing the University in
extra-curricular
activities
in
Inter-University
competitions,
due
consideration will be given to the days when they so represented the
University. Condonation in such cases must be in explicit written form,
authorized by the Dean of the concerned faculty; c) For a student, absence
from the classes for the aforementioned reasons may be condoned up to up
to 15% (10% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) of the total classes delivered.
However, in all such 4 cases, lower limit for condonation will remain as
60%(65% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB). A student who is condoned will have
to pay a condonation fee within the notified period of time." It is manifest
from the above quoted provision that the minimum percentage of attendance
in each Semester shall be 75 percent. However, the students having
attendance percentage ranging between 60 to 74 percent may be permitted
to seek approval from the Dean of Faculty/Vice Chancellor on the ground
enumerated therein and it is no gain saying that the University is conferred
with the power to condone or relax the percentage of attendance in a
particular Semester below 75 percent with a minimum cap of 60 percent.
The authority, therefore, cannot act beyond the statutory provisions and the
moment the outer cap for exercise of discretion or the power to relax is fixed,
it becomes inflexible and the University cannot exercise the power de hors
the same. In the event if it is so, it would be regarded as an arbitrary and in
excess of the power so conferred. The Court shall not direct the authority to
act in defiance of the law or to act contrary to law. The authority being the
creature of the statute cannot transgress the barriers of the statutory
provisions and have to travel within the circumference thereof. The said
Clause 3.4.2 does not confer upon the appellant, the power to condone the
shortfall below 60 percent of the attendance and, therefore, the direction of
the Single Bench to condone the same despite the attendance being short of
60 percent is contrary to the aforesaid statutory provisions and, therefore,
cannot be sustained. a. St. Xaviers University Kolkata and Ors. vs. Yash
Shroff, being MAT No. 1324 of 2024 (Cal. HC), para 2 on page 4; i. In
instances of occasional aberrations, whereby ineligible students are
permitted under court orders to undertake university examinations, such
orders should not be treated as precedents and unless the High Court can
justify its decision on principle and precept, it should better desist from
passing such orders, for it puts the "Rule of Law to a mockery and promotes
rather the "Rule of Man". a. Central Board of Secondary Education vs. Nikhil
Gulati and Anr.. reported in (1998) 3 SCC 5. para 1; ii. When an order states
that it is not to be treated as a precedent, it should not be followed by the
High Courts and the courts below. Also, the Rules laid down cannot be
made redundant. a. Maharshi Dayanand University vs. Dr. Anto Joseph and
Ors... reported in (1998) 6 SCC 215, para 7; iii. This five years law course is
being sought to be frustrated by permitting this kind of indulgence to the
students that they may not attend 65% of the lectures and they may be
permitted to appear in examination on grounds like medical and other
grounds then the whole purpose of improving the standard of legal
education will be frustrated. The relaxation should be granted only in
exceptional cases and not in mass scale as has been granted; a. University
of Calcutta & Ors. vs. Amit Jalan & Ors.. reported in 1999 SCC Online Cal
152, para 12, 13, 16 and 19; iv. The directions to the appellants to disobey
the law is subversive of the rule of law, a breeding ground for corruption and
feeding source for indiscipline. The High Court, therefore, committed
manifest error in law, in exercising its prerogative power conferred under
Article 226 of the Constitution, directing the appellants to permit the
students to appear for the examination etc.; a. State of Maharashtra vs.
Vikas Sahebrao Roundale and Ors., reported in (1992) 4 SCC 435, para 12;
v. It is a settled legal proposition that Article 14 of the Constitution is not
meant to perpetuate illegality or fraud, even by extending the wrong
decisions made in other cases. The said provision does not envisage negative
equality but has only a positive aspect; a. Tarun Kundu and Ors. vs. State of
West Bengal & Ors., reported in 2000 SCC Online Cal 649, para 7; b.
Jyostnamayee Mishra vs. The State of Odisha and Ors., in SLP (C) No.
13984 of 2023, para 31; c. U.P. State Sugar Corpn. Ltd. and Anr. vs. Sant
Raj Singh and Ors.. reported in (2006) 9 SCC 82. рага 26; d. ViceChancellor. M.D. University vs. Jahan Singh, reported in (2007) 5 SCC 77,
рага 28; vi. It is a trite law that the Court, while adopting an interpretative
tool in ascertaining the meaning, object, and the language of a statutory
provision, should firstly take endeavour to make the provisions workable
rather to render it otiose or redundant. Mere one word or an expression
should not be viewed jealously so as to render the entire provisions
unworkable. Since the writ petitioner/appellant did not challenge the vires
of the said provision on the test of a reasonability, we do not delve to go into
the aforesaid aspect as an appellate court, more particularly, in absence of
any pleading having made in the writ petition filed before the Trial Court; a.
Tanusree Mazumdar vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors. in MAT No. 156 of
2024, para 10, 12; vii. If a law student does not attend lectures or obtain the
requisite percentage of attendance, he cannot think of taking a leap to
another year of study. Mercy does not come to her aid as law requires a
student to digest her experience and gradually discover her own ignorance
and put a progressive step thereafter; a. Chaudhary Ali Zia Kabir vs. GGSIP
University & Ors., reported in 2011 SCC Online Del 1356, para 13, 14; viii.
When there is a conflict between law and equity, it is the law which has to
prevail, in accordance with the Latin maxim 'dura lex sed lex' which means
'the law is hard, but it is the law'. Equity can only supplement the law, but
it cannot supplant or override it; a. State of Uttarakhand and Anr. vs.
Archana Shukla and Ors... reported in (2011) 15 SCC 194. рага 6; ix. on
Learned Single Judge held to have committed a serious error in making an
order based compassionate endowment directing the appellant-corporation
'as a special case' to reappoint an employee whose date of birth was
erroneous in the records; a. General Manager (Marketing) Hindustan
Fertilizer Corporation of India Ltd. and Ors. vs. Subodh Chandra Das and
Ors.. reported in (1988) 1 SCC 594, para 2; x. While construing a statute,
'sympathy' has no role to play. Sympathy or sentiment by itself cannot be a
ground for passing an order in relation whereto the appellants miserably fail
to establish a legal right. It is further trite that despite an extraordinary
constitutional jurisdiction contained in Article 142 of the Constitution of
India, this Court ordinarily would not pass an order which would be in
contravention of a statutory provision; a. State of Bihar and Ors. vs.
Amrendra Kumar Mishra, reported in (2006) 12 SCC 561, para 15; b. Maruti
Udyog Ltd. vs. Ram Lal and Ors., reported in (2005) 2 SCC 638, para 44; c.
Guru Nanak Dev University vs. Parminder Kr. Bansal and Ors.. reported in
(1993) 4 SCC 401, para 7; xi. This court in several cases deprecated the
practise of allowing students to appear provisionally in the examinations of
the Board or the University and then ultimately regularising the same by
taking a sympathetic view of the matter. The Court cannot by its fiat direct
the University to disobey the Statute to which it owes its existence and the
Regulations made by the University itself as that would be destructive of the
rule of law; a. C.B.S.E. and Anr. vs. P. Sunil Kumar and Ors., reported in
(1998) 5 SCC 377, para 3; xii. It would not be correct to say that this Court
in
B.C.
Chaturvedi
case
has
accepted
the
view
that
the
High
Courts/Tribunals possess the same power which this Court has under
Article 142 of the Constitution for doing complete justice, even in the
absence of such a provision; a. Sanchalakshri and Anr. vs. Vijayakumar
Raghuvirprasad Mehta and Anr., reported in (1998) 8 SCC 245, para 8. The
petitioner has not relied upon and referred to any judicial decisions in
support of her claim. In view of the background facts and circumstances of
the case and for the reasons as stated herein above, the writ petition is not
maintainable in law and in the facts of the case and hence should be
dismissed with cost, being wholly misconceived.
4.
I heard the learned counsels for the parties, perused the writ petition,
the affidavits and the written notes of submissions.
5.
First, the respondent University was requested to produce the relevant
records, especially as some of the petitioners expressed doubts about proper
maintenance of the same. The records were produced in respect of the two
courses of LL B and BMS. On 20.02.2026, it was submitted on behalf of the
University that out of 18 students who had sought condonation of absence /
leave on medical ground, records were available only for 5 students. It was
also submitted that as regards the attendance record for programme /
events, the documents were themselves forwarded by the Dean, but there
was no prior approval given by the Dean to each of the students, separately.
However, it appears from the Form itself that there is a clause no 2 which
stated that copy of prior approval letter from the Dean of the respective
Faculty was to be attached. Although the records were not complete and it
was argued on behalf of the University that they did not contain details of all
students and that some parts may be missing, it appears that records have
been maintained in respect of certain number of students who had prayed
for leave and the like. Therefore, there is a substantial compliance regarding
maintenance of records by the University. Although there was an allusion
made on behalf of some of the students that some other students might have
been unduly favoured in this regard, there is no specific allegation leveled
and / or example given in this regard nor were such candidates made parties
herein. Therefore, it will be futile to go into this aspect. As found earlier, the
University has been able to show maintenance of records as regards grant of
leave to students.
6.
As rightly contended by the respondent University, both the University
and the reputed College in Kolkata have maintained high standards in
education and have contributed greatly to the society. According to them,
discipline is a thing which came in handy in achieving such goals. Perhaps,
no one can dispute this. However, no one is infallible. Therefore, if there is an
erroneous handling of matters regarding dealing with lack of attendance of
students by the University or any of their staff, this Court would be duty
bound to look into it if the student’s rights were prejudiced by the same.
7.
Withholding of students from the next semester for lack of attendance
cannot be a means to punish students, far less an end by itself. However,
there are certain rules in life that all have to adhere to. A curriculum in a
study course is prepared carefully by keeping in mind its requirements
including as regards attendance of classes. Law has traditionally been a
mature subject studied after an under graduate course. But, now it is taught
even after Class 12 as an integrated 5 years course. Thus, the requirement of
attending classes in order to have a proper feel of the subject from an early
stage is perhaps more pronounced now than ever before. Just as we expect
doctors coming out of medical institutes to be of a particular standard, we
cannot expect any less of lawyers. This is what our society requires.
Incidentally, unlike certain other professions, the avocation of an Advocate is
not covered by the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act. So, there is a
greater need to train our would-be legal professionals well and as per the
curriculum formulated. In University of Calcutta & Ors. vs Amit Jalan
(supra), a Division of this Court had been very categorical in holding legal
education as a thing to be taken seriously and if a student is supposed to
attend certain minimum number of classes, then the same has to be
scrupulously followed. A similar view had been taken by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in a catena of decisions as regards maintenance of such discipline in
an educational course.
8.
In this regard, it would not be out of context to say that we who have
been able to complete our education to some extent and the students who
are in the process of completing their education are a privileged lot. In our
country, there are several persons who do not get the opportunity to start,
far less complete their education. Due to financial strain or otherwise,
students drop out even from schools. To them, College education is a distant
dream. Moreover, the students of Colleges and Universities are young, but
adults. They are not juveniles. They should be aware of their rights and
responsibilities as well. One wonders whether if a young man of the same age
as a student of the College who works in a farm or in a factory infringes the
rules
of
engagement
in
an
organization,
he
would be
spared
the
consequences only because of his or her age. Therefore, a student cannot
claim a similar advantage, as of right, for non-adherence to the rules of
engagement in a College.
9.
That apart, it is the case of the University that not only were the
students made aware of the strict rules regarding attendance. In some cases,
either the students or their parents had to sign undertakings that they would
be abiding by such conditions.
10.
The other impediment in showing undue leniency as regards
attendance of classes is the supposed wrong that would be perpetrated on
the numerous others who had, despite all odds, scrupulously attended the
classes as required. They might then very well object claiming that they
could have honed their skills in some sports or tried their luck in some other
avocation if they had known that absence from classes would be condoned
anyway.
11.
However, all these do not mean that if there is an overall violation of
natural justice or if the University had contributed to or had acquiesced to
the leave or absence of a candidate or that the student had been able to
prima facie show that he or she had good grounds to claim exemption, the
candidate would not be able to get necessary benefit.
12.
A question of law has been raised by the petitioners that the rules
framed by the University regarding attendance were defective. According to
them, the students need to attend minimum number of classes. Certain
absence would be excused upon strict compliance of the provisions.
However, according to this petitioner, there have been occasions where the
rules were not scrupulously followed. More importantly, the calculation was
to be done by deducting the excusable absence from the total number of days
attended. But, in some cases, like in the case of the petitioner Bhavini Sinha,
the same was not done. There even before the total calculation could be
done, certain days were excused. In fact, as per the petitioners, permissions
required were not given in time and it was assured verbally that such strict
compliance would not be required.
13.
For the sake of clarity, the relevant provisions of the rules as framed by
the University regarding attendance may be set out as under:
“3.4 Student' Attendance
3.4.1 A student must maintain a minimum of 75%
aggregate attendance in a semester.
3.4.2 A student who has between 60% (65% for B.A.-LLB
& B.COM-LLB) and 74% attendance in a semester will
have to seek approval from the Dear of the concerned
faculty/Vice-Chancellor on grounds of illness or
involvement in extra-curricular activities approved by the
University.
a) In case of illness, leave application must reach the
office of the Dean of Faculty within three days of the
student's absence. A medical certificate is also to be
submitted within 15 days of joining. Mere submission of
leave application in itself will not ensure condonation.
b) In case of extra-curricular activities, a student must
obtain prior written confirmation of his / her participation
from the concerned authorities: Head of Department /
Profs.-in-Charge of University Societies / Sports Officer/
Programme Coordinator of Social Work, which will be
countersigned by the Dean of the concerned faculty.
When calculating the attendance percentage of the
students representing the University in extra-curricular
activities
in
Inter-University
competitions,
due
consideration will be given to the days when they so
represented the University. Condonation in such cases
must be in explicit written form, authorized by the Dean
of the concerned faculty.
c) For a student, absence from the classes for the
aforementioned reasons may be condoned up to 15%
(10% for B.A.-LLB & B.COM-LLB) of the total classes
delivered. However, in all such cases, lower limit for
condonation will remain as 60% (65% for B.A.-LLB &
B.COM-LLB).”
14.
It is true that in the case of the petitioner Bhavini Sinha, it appeared
from the reasoned order passed by the Vice Chancellor that certain days
were exempted from the total number of attendance although the total
attendance was below 65%. This was indeed a one-off case and the matter
was being taken up for decision by the Vice Chancellor pursuant to a
direction passed by this Court. Any action taken therein and the manner of
calculation adopted therein, thus, cannot be used against the University.
15.
Otherwise, it does not appear that the rules framed by the University
in this regard were inherently defective. However, the University is requested
to scrupulously follow what they laid down regarding grant of permission to
students for engaging in extra-curricular activities and the like. They should
also maintain their records better and in a complete manner and preserve
the records for a term not less than 7 years.
16.
Now, let us come to the particular facts of the present case. The
petitioner’s main grievances with the University are that illness requiring two
weeks’ home rest from 15 January 2024 was not adjusted; as regards her
participation as a Core Committee Member i.e., Public Relations Head of
XUCAS in Xavrang and Xavkala, only 15 classes were adjusted, while the
petitioner claimed that additional missed classes ought to have been
condoned. The petitioner is, thus, aggrieved with the debarment from
appearing in the Sixth Semester examination; the refusal to condone the
petitioner’s shortage of attendance allegedly despite her medical absence and
participation in extra-curricular activities as PR Head of XUCAS and Core
Committee Member of Xavkala; the alleged arbitrary and inconsistent
treatment inasmuch as 15 classes during the Xavkala period were
condoned/adjusted, while the remaining 11 classes missed during the same
period were not considered for condonation; the non-regularisation and
failure to declaration of results of her subsequent semesters despite her
having attended the same and appeared in the examinations.
17.
According to the University, the petitioner’s 6th Semester attendance
was 55.76%, below the 65% threshold prescribed under Regulation 3.4.2 for
consideration of condonation. The medical certificate dated 15th January
2024, along with the application for condonation, was submitted only on 6th
May 2024, without a leave application within three days of the absence or
the medical certificate within 15 days of joining classes, as required under
Regulation 3.4.2(a). The University further stated that the petitioner had
already been given adjustment of 15 classes for her participation in
XAVKALA 2024 and that her remaining absence was not liable to be further
condoned or adjusted, particularly as her responsibilities as PR Head
primarily involved drafting event brochures and reaching out to sponsors.
The University also disputed her claim regarding participation in XAVRANG,
stating that no classes were held on 22nd and 23rd January 2024 and that
she was not a Core Committee member of the Student’s Board which
organised the event.
18.
Therefore, the prime thrust of the petitioner’s claim is that she
participated in certain programmes and / or extra-curricular activities,
mostly on behalf of the University, but was not granted exemption for the
same. The University, on the other hand, contended that some exemption
was granted that were just. Claims of the petitioner as regards illness appear
to be secondary.
19.
Here, a practical distinction is required to be made in respect of extra-
curricular activities and illness. Perhaps, there is more force in the
University’s stipulation in Clause 3.4.2 b) that in case of extra-curricular
activities, a student must obtain prior written confirmation of his / her
participation from the concerned authorities, than in Clause 3.4.2 a) that in
case of illness, leave application must reach the office of the Dean of Faculty
within three days of the student's absence and a medical certificate was also
to be submitted within 15 days of joining. The reason is quite elementary.
While the issue of prior permission to be given in case of extra-curricular
activity by an instrumentality of the University itself may be subjected to
greater scrutiny and distrust by an affected party, thereby requiring stricter
compliance, the existence of a medical certificate issued by an independent
medical professional / concern would be more sacrosanct in the present
facts unless it is found patently erroneous or irreconcilable. Hence, a delay
on the part of a student afflicted by illness in either making a leave
application or providing a medical certificate beyond time cannot be treated
as fatal. The furnishing of the medical certificate itself should be sufficient
compliance of the requirement stipulated. Incidentally, the records do not
show recording of prior according of sanction in case of leave for extracurricular activities. But, this also has been accepted as sufficient
compliance of the Rules by the University in view of their contention that in
cases where such permission was granted, the papers were forwarded for
necessary action.
20.
As stated earlier, here the petitioner’s prime contentions are that she
was not granted exemption for participating in some programmes and /or
extra-curricular activities. A few days were exempted by the University on
this score, but not all. In his reasoned order the Vice-Chancellor had clarified
that the adjustment of 15 classes was done on the basis of attendance
adjustment form duly signed by the Professor-in-Charge of XUCAS and
counter-signed by the Dean as in other similar cases. The petitioner had to
ensure that either she complied with the attendance requirement for the
University course or she took steps to obtain prior permission of the
concerned authorities in participating in such activities. The petitioner,
however, has not been able to show that she obtained prior permission as
required for participating in all the extra-curricular activities for which she
had claimed exemption.
21.
As regards the medical prescription dated 15.01.2024 furnished by the
petitioner, there is no diagnosis whatsoever mentioned therein. Among other
things, an anti-biotic, an anti-histamine, vitamin C and paracetamol were
prescribed for five days, but rest was suggested for two weeks. This does not
appear to be such an exceptional case as to warrant an intervention by this
Court, at least on this score.
22.
That apart, not much importance can be attached to the apparent
discrepancy between the purported live attendance view and the final
counting of attendance. The former gives a cursory glance of attendance so
as to keep the student aware of the overall situation. However, the latter has
to get precedence in view of its compliance with the Rules in question.
23.
Ultimately, the University records show the petitioner’s attendance to
be a dismal 55.76% while the required minimum attendance is 75%. Even for
consideration of such condonation, the minimum attendance had to be 65%.
24.
In view of the above, this Court is not inclined to allow the petitioner’s
application. However, in view of the fact that during the pendency of the
application, without prejudice and without creating any equity in favour of
the petitioner, she had been allowed to sit in examinations and move to the
subsequent semester / s, the present application is disposed of with the
following directions (i) The petitioner shall again attend the classes for the semester
for which she had inadequate attendance and fulfil the
attendance requirement;
(ii) Immediately thereafter, all her examination results for the
said and / or the following semesters, which had been kept
unpublished, shall be published;
(iii) For such purpose, if the examination papers have not been
evaluated till now, shall be kept evaluated in the meantime;
(iv) No stigma shall be attached or further prejudice shall be
caused to the student for having to participate in the said
semester classes afresh;
(v) At the completion of the course as contemplated above, the
petitioner shall receive all certificate / s, mark sheets /s and other
relevant documents, if any, without further delay.
25.
Urgent certified copy of the order shall be provided to the parties upon
compliance of usual formalities.
(Jay Sengupta, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review