Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
****
WRIT PETITION NO.30763 OF 2025
Between:
Bhavani Industrial Engineering Services
… Petitioner(s)
Versus
Rashtriya Isapt Nigam Limited and others
...Respondents
*****
DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED :
16.02.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgment/Order?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copy of Order may be
marked to Law Reporters/Journals?
Yes/No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to see the
fair copy of the Judgment/Order?
Yes/No
JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
* HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
+ WRIT PETITION NO.30763 OF 2025
% 16.02.2026
# Between:
Bhavani Industrial Engineering Services
… Petitioner(s)
Versus
Rashtriya Isapt Nigam Limited and others
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
:
Sri V.Sudhakar
^ Counsel for the Respondents
:
1. Sri Kiran Kumar Vadlamudi
!
2. Sri V.Subramanyam
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
1.
Writ Petition No.22780 of 2021, dated 13.07.2022
on the file of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at
Amaravati.
This Court made the following:
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
APHC010591542025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3327]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION NO: 30763/2025
Between:
1. BHAVANI INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING SERVICES,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER SRI.
DUNNA SADANANDA S/O APPANNA, AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS,
D.NO.14-8-27,
B.C.ROAD,
GAJUWAKA,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. RASHTRIYA ISAPT NIGAM LIMITED, REPRESENTED BY
ITS
CHAIRMAN
CUM
MANAGING
DIRECTOR,
ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING, VISAKHAPATNAM STEEL
PLANT, VISAKHAPATNAM - 530031
2. THE GENERAL MANAGER MSAND CONVENER,
STANDING BANNING COMMITTEE, MANAGEMENT
SERVICES DEPARTMENT, RASHTRIYA ISPAT NIGAM
LIMITED,
VISAKHAPATNAM
STEEL
PLANT,
VISAKHAPATNAM – 530031
3. THE GENERAL MANAGER WC, WORKS CONTRACTS
DEPARTMENT, RASHTRIYA ISPAT NIGAM LIMITED,
VISAKHAPATNAM STEEL PLANT, VISAKHAPATNAM –
530031
4. THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR WORKS, RASHTRIYA ISPAT
NIGAM LIMITED,
VISAKHAPATNAM STEEL PLANT,
VISAKHAPATNAM -530031
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the
High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction,
more particularly one in the nature of a writ of mandamus
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
declaring the action of the 2nd respondent in issuing the
Impugned Banning order vide Reference N0.25/MS/SBC dated
07.05.2025 banning the petitioner for a period of 3 years with
effect from 07.05.2025 and de-registering from the list of
ancillaries/Vendors/Contractors of RINL from the date of issuance
of banning order is illegal, arbitrary, violative of principles of
natural justice, apart from violation of the rights of the petitioners
under Art. 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India and
consequently set aside the banning order dated 07.05.2025 and
pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to suspend the Impugned Banning
order issued by the 2nd respondent vide Reference
No.25/MS/SBC dated 07.05.2025 by permitting the petitioner to
participate in future tenders pending disposal of the Writ Petition
and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. Y SUDHAKAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. KIRAN KUMAR VADLAMUDI
2. V SUBRAMANYAM
The Court made the following:
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
ORDER
Heard Sri Y.Sudhakar Rao, learned counsel for the Writ
Petitioner and Sri Kiran Kumar Vadlamudi, learned counsel for the
respondent Nos.1 to 4.
2.
This Writ Petition was filed seeking the following
relief:
“…to issue a Writ or Order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of 2nd respondent
in issuing the impugned Order vide Reference No.25/MS/SBC dated
07.05.2025 banning the petitioner for a period of 3 years with effect
from 07.05.2025 and deregistering from the list of Ancillaries/Vendors/
Contractors of RINL from the date of issuance of Banning Order, as
illegal, arbitrary, violative of principles of natural justice, apart from
violation of the rights of Writ Petitioner under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of
the Constitution of India and consequently, set-aside the Banning
Order dated 07.05.2025 and pass such other order or orders …”
3.
Contents of the affidavit filed by the Managing Partner
of Writ Petitioner Company, in brief, are that the Writ Petitioner is
a Partnership Firm registered with the Registrar of Firms,
Visakhapatnam on 23.09.2015. The main object of the Writ
Petitioner firm is to undertake and execute mechanical, structural,
civil,
electrical
equipment
erection
and
commissioning,
technological assistance etc., and other contract business. The
Writ Petitioner firm is also registered with the Ministry of Micro,
Small and Medium Enterprises, Government of India as a Micro
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
Enterprise. The Writ Petitioner firm is also a Registered Contractor
of RINL-VSP, vide Registration No.VSP/WC/REGN-P/2023-134,
dated 07.10.2023.
(b)
On 07.05.2024, 1st respondent called for Tenders for
Cleaning Works including Cooling System and PCI of BF-1 and
BF-2 vide Notice Inviting Tender No.260000885 with an estimated
value of Rs.4,25,62,634.40 paise and the contract period is 24
months. The Writ Petitioner firm participated in the bid and quoted
price of Rs.59,58,727.60 paise via RFx No.2600008855. While
entering the bid figures, it erroneously entered the digits and
quoted the bid price as Rs.59,58,727.60 paise, which is 86%
below the estimated amount. Realizing the error, the Writ
Petitioner firm immediately made a communication dated
15.06.2024 to 3rd respondent, notifying the above typographical
error and stating that it would be impossible for the Writ Petitioner
firm to execute the works on the quoted price and apologized for
the mistake.
(c)
On 25.06.2024, 3rd respondent straightaway issued
Suspension Order in respect of business dealings of the Writ
Petitioner firm, stating that it was suspended for a period of Six
(06) months for backing out from the subject work with effect from
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
25.06.2024. Respondent No.3, instead of lifting the suspension
order after lapse of Three (03) months, vide Order dated
23.01.2025 extended the said suspension for a further period of
Three (03) months with effect from 25.12.2024. Respondent No.2,
without prior notice or hearing, vide Reference No.25/MS/SBC,
dated 07.05.2025 issued order, banning the business dealings
with Writ Petitioner firm for a period of Three (03) years with effect
from 07.05.2025 and deregistered the firm from the list of
Contractors of RINL. After receipt of orders, the Writ Petitioner
addressed
letters
on
13.06.2025
and
15.07.2025
to
2nd
respondent requesting the authority to consider the issue
amicably, but there was no response whatsoever from 2nd
respondent authority. The Writ Petitioner made a representation/
Appeal on 16.08.2025 to 3rd and 4th respondents for withdrawal of
banning orders and the same is pending till date. Hence, the Writ
Petition.
4.
Respondent Nos.1 to 4 filed counter-affidavit denying
the contents of the affidavit accompanying Writ Petition,
contending inter alia that the Writ Petitioner firm submitted their
quotation electronically on 30.05.2024 at 10:51:19, and the
communication stating the error, was made on 15.06.2024.
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
Immediately upon submission of quotation, on 30.05.2025, the
system generated quotation response document that contain
explicit,
multi-layered
warnings
regarding
the
abnormal
discrepancy. The Writ Petitioner firm RFx response explicitly
pointed out 86% deviation and confirmed the tender and despite
these definitive electronic warnings, the Writ Petitioner firm took
no action to withdraw or rectify the bid prior to the tender opening.
The Writ Petitioner firm notified the RINL error on 15.06.2024 after
generating the comparative statement dated 14.06.2024. The
Tender was floated to execute job in Blast Furnace 1 and 2, which
are most critical units of RINL, operates 24x7 and any delay in
tendering process would hamper the production and cost huge
financial loss to RINL and in such scenario, the Writ Petitioner
firm’s conduct resembles a buyer’s remorse scenario, as it chose
to ignore clear system warnings well in advance. Respondent
No.3 vide e-Mail dated 17.06.2024 in reply to the Letter dated
15.06.2024 of the Writ Petitioner firm, informed the agency that
appropriate action would be taken as per Clause 27 of the Special
Conditions of Contract (for brevity ‘SCC’).
(b)
The Writ Petitioner firm on the same day i.e.
17.06.2024 replied that it cannot accept the quoted rate and to
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
proceed as per its its process, hence, the Writ Petitioner firm was
aware of the Clause 27 and the consequences that follow and 3rd
respondent was constrained to take action as per procedure. The
Writ Petitioner firm vide Letters dated 15.07.2025 and 16.08.2025
requested to review the banning order, but as per the impugned
Order dated 07.05.2025, it was made clear that appeal if any, may
be filed within 30 days before the Appellate Authority and the Writ
Petitioner firm preferred the appeal after two months well after the
deadline exhausting the remedy provided to them, which shows its
casual and litigant nature.
(c)
Further, the agency in its bid security declaration had
given an undertaking that in case of failure or refusal to execute
contract, it shall be debarred automatically for a period of Three
(03) years and it was agreed by the Writ Petitioner firm. The Writ
Petitioner’s
withdrawal/backing
out
of
the
Tender
(RFx
No.2600008855) after achieving Lowest Bidder (L-1) status,
severely prejudiced the operations of RINL, and it necessitated for
re-tendering and caused heavy financial loss to RINL. The
requirement of a personal hearing is not absolute or mandatory in
every instance and the Committee is empowered to dispense with
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
such hearing, where the merits of the case do not justify. Hence, it
is prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition.
5.
Learned counsel for the Writ Petitioner would contend
that no written notice or reasonable opportunity of hearing was
provided to the Writ Petitioner before passing the impugned Order
vide
Reference
No.25/MC/SBC
dated
07.05.2025
by
2nd
respondent and it is in clear violation of principles of natural
justice. Learned counsel would further contend that quoting less
price in the subject Tender occurred erroneously due to oversight,
but instead of considering the same as a human error, impugned
Order was issued straightaway for a period of Three (03) years.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1 to 4 would
contend that after generating the comparative statement on
14.06.2024, the Writ Petitioner firm notified the RINL error on
15.06.2024. The act of Writ Petitioner, ignoring clear system
warnings well in advance, hampered the production and huge
financial loss to RINL. Learned counsel would further contend that
the Writ Petitioner is provided the remedy to prefer appeal within
30 days before the Appellate Authority, but the same was
preferred after two months after exhausting the deadline, which
shows its casual and litigant nature.
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
7.
Perused the entire material available on record.
8.
The Writ Petitioner firm is a Micro Enterprise,
registered with the Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises, Government of India vide Udyam Registration
No.UDYAM-AP-10-0012927, dated 28.08.2015, and its object is to
undertake and execute manufacturing works pertaining to
mechanical, structural, civil, electrical equipment erection. The
Writ
Petitioner
firm,
vide
Registration
No.VSP/WC/REGN-
P/2023/134, dated 07.10.2023 entered into a Partnership Contract
with respondent No.1 viz. RASHTRIYA ISPAT NIGAM LIMITED,
Visakhapatnam Steel Plant and the said registration is valid up to
31.08.2026. However, in the Registration Certificate, entered
between the Writ Petitioner and 1st respondent, it was mentioned
that the registration does not guarantee tender enquiry and award
of contract works.
9.
A perusal of the material on record goes to show that
respondent No.1 issued a Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) vide
No.260000885, dated 07.05.2024 calling for tenders in respect of
the work for ‘Cleaning works including Cooling System and PCI of
BF-1 and BF-2’ and last date and time for submission of tenders
was 30.05.2024 at 15.00 hours. A perusal of the NIT further goes
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
to show that the value for the aforesaid work estimation is
Rs.4,25,62,634.40 paise. As per the NIT issued by 1st respondent,
the Pre-Qualification Criteria (PQC) for consideration of tender is
that the tenderer should have experience in executing at least one
single similar work of the aforesaid nature of value not less than
Rs.1,06,40,658.60 paise during last 7 (Seven) years ending last
day of previous month of the NIT date and further, the tenderer
should
have
an
average
annual
financial
turnover
of
Rs.63,84,395.16 paise during last 3 (Three) Financial Years (i.e.
from 2022 to 2024).
10.
A perusal of Udyam Registration No.UDYAM-AP-10-
0012927, dated 28.08.2015 registered with the Ministry of Micro,
Small and Medium Enterprises, Government of India goes to show
that the Writ Petitioner firm was incorporated on 28.08.2015 and
during the Financial Year, its total turnover is Rs.2,11,17,427/-.
There is a condition put-forth by 1st respondent that for renewal of
registration, the agency must have successfully executed one
similar job in VSP in each category registered during the last three
years or must have participated in at least one tender enquiry in
each
category
during
last
three
years
served
by
VSP.
Indisputably, the Registration Certificate vide No.VSP/WC/REGN-
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
P/2023/134, dated 07.10.2023 entered between the Writ Petitioner
and 1st respondent, the Writ Petitioner firm was registered as a
Contractor of RINL-VSP for fresh class of jobs/works i.e. ‘5.27 C,
5.11 E and 5.07 C’ besides renewing the Class of Jobs/Works for
‘5.17C’. Therefore, it can be assumed that the Writ Petitioner
being an agency, fulfilled the conditions of 1st respondent and as
such, the Registration Certificate was renewed with certain class
of jobs besides assigning fresh class of jobs to the Writ Petitioner
firm.
11.
Indisputably, pursuant to the Notice Inviting Tender
dated 07.05.2024, the Writ Petitioner submitted its quote by
mentioning the Unit Price at Rs.59,58,727.60 paise. The
Estimated Value of the Tender is Rs.4,25,62,634.40 paise.
Therefore, the Writ Petitioner quoted its Unit price 86% below the
estimated cost.
12.
Learned counsel for the Writ Petitioner would contend
that while making entry of the bid figures, a mistake occurred, due
to which, a sum of Rs.59,58,727.60 paise was quoted, and it is
86% below the estimated cost and it is highly impossible for the
Writ Petitioner to execute the works on the quoted price and it
would sustain loss and the mistake was duly informed to 1st
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
respondent, but the respondent No.1 without seeking any
explanation from the Writ Petitioner, straightaway suspended the
business dealings with Writ Petitioner for a period of Six (06)
months and later, issued the impugned Order dated 07.05.2025.
13.
Learned counsel for the respondents would contend
that due to the act of Writ Petitioner, RINL sustained huge
financial loss. Further, in view of the inability to execute the work
after being the lowest bidder, and backing out from the tender,
failure or refusal to execute the contract, the tenderer shall be
barred automatically for a period of Three (03) years. Similarly, the
Writ Petitioner being the tenderer, expressed its inability to
execute the works and as such, the impugned Banned Order was
issued, banning the business dealings with Writ Petitioner.
14.
A perusal of the correspondence made by the Writ
Petitioner with 1st respondent goes to show that the intention of
Writ Petitioner was to propose a price that aligns with industry
standards, which it estimated to be approximately higher than the
amount it quoted currently due to the scope and requirements of
the project, but, it is due to a typographical error, the Writ
Petitioner wrongly quoted their amount at 86% below the
estimated cost and therefore, it expressed their inability that it
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
could not execute the work at the quoted price. Pursuant to the
said letter, vide Ref.No.VSP/WC/BF/2600008855/24/WCC/ 388,
dated 25.06.2024 since the Writ Petitioner was backing out from
the subject Tender, 1st respondent suspended the business
dealings with Writ Petitioner firm for a period of Six (06) months
with effect from 25.06.2024 and the same was extended for a
further period of Three (03) months.
15.
Vide impugned Order Reference No.25/MS/SCB/
dated 07.05.2025, 1st respondent banned the business dealings
with Writ Petitioner firm for a period of Three (03) years with effect
from 07.05.2025 and deregistered the firm from the list of
ancillaries/vendors/contractors of RINL. The impugned Order,
dated 07.05.2025 would go to show that under Clause 27 of
Tender Enquiry-Default by Tenderers – the successful tenderer
may be debarred at the discretion of the company, from issue of
further tender documents, work orders etc., for a specific period to
be decided by the employer in case of: „undue delay in starting
and execution of work awarded, poor performance, backing out
from the tender, non-accepting Work Order/LOA during the validity
of tender or non-observance of company‟s materials/property,
non-payment of due wages to labour or such similar defaults‟. The
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
Writ Petitioner vide Letters dated 13.06.2025, 15.07.2025 and
16.08.2025 to 1st respondent expressed their grievance that no
one could complete the subject works for the price quoted by the
Writ Petitioner and it is due to human error, the amount was
wrongly quoted and being deprived of the impugned order,
requested to withdraw the said order.
16.
A perusal of the record goes to show that the Writ
Petitioner having quoted the amount, expressed its inability to
execute the works as per the Tender, for the reason that it quoted
the amount at 86% below the estimated cost, which is on account
of a typographical error, and it is highly impossible for them to
execute the said work as per the quoted unit price. It is further
stated by the Writ Petitioner that if it executes the work, it would
sustain huge financial loss. The Writ Petitioner firm is a micro
enterprise.
The
estimated
value
of
the
Tender
is
Rs.4,25,62,634.40 paise. As per the Writ Petitioner, it wrongly
quoted the price at Rs.59,58,727.60 paise. When the estimation
value is Rs.4,25,62,634.40 paise and quoted price is 86% below
the estimation value, even though a tenderer like the Writ
Petitioner, who is a micro enterprise, successfully gets the bid, it
could not execute the work for such a lesser price.
17.
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
Learned counsel for the Writ Petitioner contends that
there is no provision under which 1st respondent could have
passed the impugned order, banning the business dealings with
the Writ Petitioner, and the Writ Petitioner cannot be prohibited
from participating in any tenders called by 1st respondent unless
such a prohibition is supported by law and for specific reasons
held against the Writ Petitioner. He placed strong reliance on the
proposition of law laid down by this Court in Virothi Ramulu v.
Visakhapatnam Port Trust1, wherein this Court at paragraph
Nos.8 and 9 held as under:
“8.
…it must be held that there is no provision for
banning a contractor, for any period of time, by the 1st
respondent, under the special conditions of contract. The
impugned proceedings of the 2nd respondent are stating that the
petitioner has been banned from doing business with the 1st
respondent. Such a ban is not provided for in any of the terms
of the contract or the special conditions of contract being
applied by the 1st respondent.
9.
In such circumstances, it must be held that the
impugned proceedings are clearly not supported by any
provision of law or by any agreement between the parties.”
18.
Under Clause No.27 of Special Conditions of
Contract, which deals with Default by Tenderers, if there is undue
Writ Petition No.22780 of 2021, dated 13.07.2022 on the file of the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati.
delay in
starting
and execution of
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
work awarded,
poor
performance, backing out from the tender etc., at the discretion of
the Company, the successful tenderer may be debarred from
issue of further tender documents, work orders etc., for a specific
period to be decided by the employer. No doubt, on account of
inability expressed by the Writ Petitioner to execute the subject
works on the ground of quoting of aforesaid price, 1st respondent
was necessitated for retendering. At the same time, the
respondents ought to have examined the fact as to whether the
Writ Petitioner was able to execute the subject work at the price
quoted, which is 86% below the estimation price. Further,
pursuant to the Letter dated 15.06.2024 addressed by the Writ
Petitioner bringing it to the notice of 1st respondent that because of
the typographical error, it wrongly quoted substantially lesser
price, 1st respondent did not issue any notice to the Writ Petitioner.
The said fact is also concurred by the learned counsel for the
respondents that they did not issue any notice to the Writ
Petitioner before passing the impugned order. The action of 2nd
respondent in passing the impugned Ban Order, which is not
preceded by any prior notice, is in violation of the principles of
natural justice, specifically audi alteram partem, as the Writ
SRK, J
W.P.No.30763 of 2025
Petitioner being the affected party, lost a reasonable opportunity
to put-forth its defence before suffering the consequences. In view
of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the impugned Order,
dated 07.05.2025 deserves to be set-aside.
19.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed, setting-aside
the impugned Order vide Reference No.25/MS/SBC dated
07.05.2025. There shall be no order as to costs of the Writ
Petition.
As a sequel thereto, the miscellaneous applications, if any,
pending in this Writ Petition shall stand closed.
16th February, 2026.
Note:
LR Copy to be marked.
B/o.
DNB
________________________
JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review