Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION (FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL) NO. 25356
of 2025
In F/CRIMINAL APPEAL/38972/2025
With
F/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 38972 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
BHASHKAR BHIKHABHIA MANGANBHAI
Versus
JITENDRABHAI BHIKHABHAI PARMAR & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. DEVENDRA G RANA(6997) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR ROHAN RAVAL, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 4
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 30/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
By way of this application, original complainant seeks to grant
leave to appeal and further prayed to admit the acquittal appeal.
2.
Here is the Appeal by the original complainant against the
judgment and order of acquittal.
3.
Being dissatisfied by the judgment and order passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Amreli, passed in Sessions Case No.38 of 2017, dated
16.05.2025, acquitting the accused respondents for the offences
punishable under Sections 302, 201 read with Section 34, 120(B) of IPC,
the original complainant –father of the deceased Naresh has preferred
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
leave to appeal and acquittal appeal.
4.
We have heard Mr.D.G. Rana, learned advocate and Mr.Rohan
Raval, learned APP for the respective parties.
5.
The factual matrix of the case is as under:
5.1
Deceased Naresh was resident of Village Batva Devdi, Tal.:
Vadiya, Dist.: Amreli. He was married person living in a joint family
consisting of parents and brothers and their family. According to the
prosecution case, the accused viz. Jitendra Bhikhabhai Parmar (A1),
Kalpesh @ Kapil Bhikhabhai Parmar (A2), and Lalji Valji Bhaskar (A3)
entered into criminal conspiracy, harboring grievance and suspicion
regarding an illicit relationship between deceased Naresh and wife of A2,
acting in furtherance of their common intention, on 22.07.2017, at about
09:30 p.m., the accused called the deceased Naresh and was taken on
Barvada Road, where the accused indiscriminately assaulted the deceased
Naresh with the deadly weapon like knife, sword and axe, whereby the
accused caused his death and threw his dead body into nearby water
body. The A1 was with knife, A2 was having in his hand a sword and A3
used a weapon axe.
5.2
According to the prosecution case, the applicant-appellant father
and the wife of the deceased was in search of deceased and after
extensive search in the vicinity area of the village, they could not find any
clue about the whereabouts of the deceased.
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
5.3
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
In the morning, the friends of the deceased found the dead body of
the deceased in the water body situated at Barvada Road of the Village.
The appellant father and others went to the place of the occurrence. The
Village Sarpanch was informed by the appellant. He arrived at the place
and after consultation with him, the appellant father lodged an FIR before
Vadiya Police, inter alia stating that some unknown persons have
eliminated his son. It was disclosed that the deceased was having no
enmity with village person.
6.
In such circumstances, the offence being C.R.No.20/2017 being
registered for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201, 34 and
120(B) of the IPC against the unknown persons. PW:31, I.O. N.G. Gosai
was entrusted with the investigation of the case. During the investigation,
the dead body of the deceased was sent for postmortem with Vadiya
CHC, the panchnama of the place of occurrence being drawn in the
presence of panchas, the statements of witnesses were being recorded.
The I.O., during the investigation, recorded the statement of one Vinubhai
Bhaskar PW:19, who in turn had disclosed in his police statement that, he
saw the deceased Naresh and accused Jitendra A1 together at about 09:15
p.m. near the milk diary of the village and they were going on Barvada
Road. Based on this evidence of last scene together, the I.O. enquired
about the whereabouts of the accused. The accused were not found at
their home. In such circumstances, the accused respondents were arrested
in the alleged crime and the motive behind the murder was illicit relation
of the deceased with the wife of A1. The I.O., during the investigation,
arrested the accused, and seized and recovered the weapons knife, sword,
and axe and clothes from the house of the accused allegedly presented by
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
the wife, mother and father of the respective accused. The I.O., during the
investigation, collected the blood samples of the deceased from the P.M.
doctor. He sent the seized articles to the FSL for forensic analysis
purpose. After receiving the FSL report, and upon conclusion of the
investigation, the chargesheet for the offences, as referred above, came to
be filed before the Magistratial Court and the case was committed to the
Court of Sessions at Amreli.
7.
The learned Sessions Judge framed charge to which the accused
pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
8.
In order to prove the charge, the prosecution has examined as many
as 31 witnesses and relied upon 24 exhibited documents.
9.
On conclusion of oral evidence, the Trial Court recorded further
statements of the accused as provided under Section 313 of the Code,
wherein, they claimed their innocence and stated that they have been
falsely implicated in the offence.
10.
The learned Sessions Judge, after appreciating and examining the
oral as well as documentary evidence, acquitted the accused herein for the
offences with which they were charged. The Trial Court while acquitting
the accused, has observed that the prosecution story based on suspicion as
there is no direct evidence found against the accused. The prosecution
case entirely based on circumstantial evidence. The circumstances relied
upon by the prosecution like; last seen theory, motive, conduct of the
accused, recovery and discovery of the weapons used in the crime,
forensic evidence, having not been proved by way of reliable clinching
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
evidence and various link as referred in the chain of circumstances are
inconclusive and does not cogently and firmly establish to draw a
conclusion that within all human probabilities, the crime in question
being committed by the accused and non-else
11.
In such circumstances, the Trial Court while acquitting the
accused, held and observed that the prosecution has not been able to
prove the charge against the accused by reliable and cogent evidence
beyond reasonable doubt.
12.
Mr.D.G. Rana, learned counsel appearing for the applicant -
appellant original complainant, while assailing the impugned judgment
and order of acquittal, made the following submissions:
(A)
That the findings of acquittal are contrary to law and
evidence on record and the findings recorded are palpably
erroneous and based on the irrelevant material;
(B)
That the Trial Court failed to appreciate that the witnesses
have categorically stated that before the incident, the deceased and
A1 have had altercation on account of the relation with the
deceased and wife of the accused. Thus, the motive for the offence
is clearly established, however, the Trial Court has ignored the
material circumstance.
(C)
That the evidence of last seen together erroneously discarded
by the Trial Court. The witness Vinubhai Bhaskar PW:19 has
deposed that on 23.07.2017, at about 09:15 p.m., when he was out
from his house for urination, he saw the deceased Naresh A1
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
talking each other near milk dairy of the villager and they had
proceeded towards Barvada Road. The evidence of PW:19 was
natural and he has no any enmity or reason to falsely depose
against the accused, for which, the accused did not have offered
any explanation that under which circumstances, the death of the
deceased occurred. Thus, the Trial Court on flimsy grounds,
observed that the witness is got up witness and cannot be relied
upon to prove the circumstance of last seen together and therefore,
the findings in this regard is contrary to the evidence, and settled
principles of law.
(D)
That the Trial Court committed a grave error by rejecting
crucial recovery panchnama (Exh.54, 77 and 79), concerning
weapons and bloodstained clothes seized from the accused and the
reasons assigned for rejection of the evidence that the panchnamas
having not been drawn in terms of Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
(E)
That the Trial Court failed to appreciate the forensic
evidence in its true perspective mainly on the ground that there was
a delay in sending the samples for FSL testing. The blood group of
the deceased matched with the blood group on clothes recovered
from the accused’s house. Thus, the important link pointing
towards the involvement of the accused having been ignored and
discarded.
13.
In such circumstances, Mr.Rana, learned counsel submitted that the
prosecution succeeded in proving the charge against the accused beyond
reasonable doubt and chain of incriminating circumstances required to
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
bring home the guilt of the accused is complete in all aspects, and
therefore, when the complete chain of events leading to the involvement
of the crime in question is proved and established, the Trial Court, in that
view of the matter, while acquitting the accused committed a serious error
in appreciating the evidence. Therefore, the findings of acquittal are not
based on the evidence, suffers from legal infirmity, perverse and
fundamentally erroneous and thus, it is prayed that the impugned
judgment is not sustainable in law.
14.
In the present case the issue falls for our consideration as to
whether the trial Court was justified in acquitting the accused?
15.
We have carefully examined the oral as well as documentary
evidence and perused the findings of acquittal rendered by the Trial
Court.
16.
Before proceeding to address the rival submissions, we would like
to place on record the scope of interference in an appeal against the
acquittal and when the same is justified. In exceptional cases, where there
are compelling circumstances and the judgment under appeal is found to
be perverse, the appellate court can interfere with the judgment of
acquittal. The Appellate Court should bear in mind the presence of
innocence of the accused and further that, the trial Court’s acquittal
bolsters the presumption of his innocence. Interference in a routine
manner, where the other view of possible should be avoided, unless there
are reasons for interference.
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
17.
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
Undoubtedly, the prosecution case rests on the circumstantial
evidence. The law with regard to the conviction on the basis of
circumstantial evidence has been laid down in the judgment of Sharad
Bardhichand Sharda Vs. State of Maharashtra (1984 (4) SCC 116).
Paras-152 and 153 of the judgment reads as under:
“152. Before discussing the cases relied upon by the High Court we
would like to cite a few decisions on the nature, character and
essential proof required in a criminal case which rests on
circumstantial evidence alone. The most fundamental and basic
decision of this Court is Hanumant v. State of Madhya Pradesh [AIR
1952 SC 343 : 1952 SCR 1091 : 1953 Cri. LJ 129]. This case has
been uniformly followed and applied by this Court in a large number
of later decisions up-to-date, for instance, the cases of Tufail (Alias)
Simmi v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(1969) 3 SCC 198: 1970 SCC (Cri.)
55] and Ramgopal v. State of Maharashtra [(1972) 4 SCC 625 : AIR
1972 SC 656]. It may be useful to extract what Mahajan, J. has laid
down in Hanumant case [AIR 1952 SC 343 : 1952 SCR 1091 : 1953
Cri. LJ 129]:
It is well to remember that in cases where the evidence is of a
circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which the conclusion
of guilt is to be drawn should in the first instance be fully established
and all the facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. Again, the circumstances
should be of a conclusive nature and tendency and they should be
such as to exclude every hypothesis but the one proposed to be
proved. In other words, there must be a chain of evidence so far
complete as not to leave any reasonable ground far a conclusion
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
consistent with the innocence of the accused and it must be such as to
show that within all human probability the act must have been done
by the accused.
153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the following
conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be
said to be fully established:
(1)
the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be
drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances
concerned 'must or should' and not 'may be' established. There is not
only a grammatical but a legal distinction between 'may be proved'
and 'must be or should be proved' as was held by this Court in Shivaji
SahabraoBobade & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC
793 : 1973 SCC (Cri.) 1033 : 1973 Cri. LJ 1783] where the following
observations were made: [SCC para 19, p. 807 : SCC (Cri. p. 1047)
Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not
merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental
distance between 'may be' and 'must be' is long and divides vague
conjectures from sure conclusions.
(2)
the facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say. they should not
be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is
guilty,
(3)
the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency.
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
(4)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to
be proved, and
(5)
there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave
any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the
innocence of the accused and must show that in all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
18.
The circumstances on which the prosecution relies are as follows:
(i)
The last seen theory, as on 23.07.2017, the witness PW:19
saw the deceased Naresh and accused Kalpesh together at about
09:15 near the milk diary of village, going towards Barvada Road.
(ii)
The motive - it was suspected by the A1 that the deceased
was having relationship with his wife and on this issue, before the
incident, the altercation took place between them.
(iii)
Soon after the incident, the accused did not find at their
house in the village.
(iv)
The weapon allegedly used in the crime recovered and
seized from the house of the accused.
(v)
Forensic science evidence pointing out towards the guilt of
the accused as the bloodstained found on the clothes of the accused
having been matched with the blood group of the deceased.
19.
Having regard to the evidence on record, the issue falls for our
consideration as to whether the circumstances as referred above forms
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
chain of events pointing only to the guilt of the accused and non-else.
20.
It is not in dispute that the death of the deceased is homicidal in
nature and therefore, there is no need to further discussion on this issue.
21.
Now let us examine the circumstances relied upon by the
prosecution.
(1)
The last seen theory:
In the facts of the present case, in order to prove the circumstance
of last seen together, the prosecution has heavily relied upon the
evidence of PW:19 Vinubhai Bhaskar. The witness has stated that
on 22.07.2017 at about 09:15 p.m., for the purpose of urination, he
came out from his house and at that time, he saw the accused
Jitendra sitting on the bench opposite his house and after
urination, he saw the deceased Naresh in the company of accused
Jitendra talking each other going towards Barvada Road. The
witness has further stated that thereafter, he went to his house. The
witness has further stated that in the morning, he came to know
about the incident and death of the deceased Naresh. The witness
has further stated that he had told the father of the deceased that
the deceased was lastly in the company of accused Jitendra. In the
cross examination, witness has admitted that before lodging of the
complaint, he had told the complainant about the theory of last
seen. In such circumstances, the Trial Court in Para-55 of its
judgment, assigned reasons for not believing the witness PW:19.
We have carefully examined PW:19. The witness is the cousin
brother of the deceased. The complainant – appellant in his FIR
did not have referred the conversation made with the witness on
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
the aspect of last seen theory. Even in the complaint, it was
disclosed by the appellant that he does not have any suspicion on
any person. Thus, in our opinion, the witness PW:19 is got up
witness. The witness was silent till lodging of the FIR. The
appellant was unaware about who had killed his son. If the
appellant would have informed then he certainly could have
disclosed the theory of last seen together because according to the
say of the witness, he had already conveyed to the appellant. Thus,
the witness being a relative of the deceased’s family is not stating
true facts. Therefore, the evidence of last seen together cannot be
accepted and the prosecution failed to prove that the deceased was
lastly in the company of the accused Jitendra.
(2)
Motive:
It is the case of the prosecution that the motive behind the murder
was illicit relationship of deceased wife of the accused no.1. In
case of circumstance evidence, motive for the offence is required to
be proved by the prosecution. In the present case, none of the
witnesses have stated that the deceased was having relation with
the wife of A1. The appellant father was also unaware about the
relationship. If he would have knowledge about the relation, then
there is no reason for him not to disclose the said aspect in his FIR.
On the contrary, he had disclosed in the FIR that his son deceased
had no any enmity with anyone. Admittedly, the statement of the
wife of A1 having not been recorded by the police nor she has been
cited as witness. Therefore, the evidence on record does not prove
the existing of necessary motive required to commit a crime by the
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
accused.
(3)
Conduct of the accused:
It is alleged that after incident, the accused fled away from the
village. The Trial Court in Para-53 of the judgment did not have
accepted the said circumstance to prove the abnormal conduct of
the accused. Admittedly, incident occurred on 22.07.2017, and the
same came to be registered on 23.07.2017 about 14:30 p.m. The
accused A1 arrested on 23.07.2017 at about 18:45 p.m. and his
presence was very much there in village itself, so far as accused
nos.2 and 3 are concerned, nothing on record to suggest that they
were not present in their house and hiding themselves. In such
circumstances, the conduct of the accused after the incident, does
not raise any suspicion.
(4)
Seizure and Recovery of the weapons and bloodstained
clothes:
In the facts of the present case, the weapon knife, sword and axe
along with clothes of the respective accused i.e. A1 to A3 being
seized and recovered by the I.O. PW:31. The panchnama of the
recoveries being produced at Exh.54, 66 and 69. Admittedly, the
weapons and clothes being presented by the family members of the
accused. In other words, the knife and clothes of A1 being seized
from the house at the instance of wife of the accused Shilpa,
whereas the sword and axe were being seized and recovered at the
instance of mother and father of respective accused i.e. A2 and A3.
The panchas of respective panchnamas have supported the half
heartedly as the contents of the respective panchnamas having not
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
been fully disclosed and deposed before the Trial Court by the
panch-witnesses. I.O. PW:31, mechanically and causally, referred
the panchnama of recovery. Admittedly, no any weapon or clothes
being seized and recovered at the instance of any of the accused.
Therefore, there is no disclosure statement of the accused in terms
of Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Thus, the evidence of recovery
of the weapons and clothes cannot be in any manner pointing
towards the guilt of the accused. The forensic evidence to this
effect cannot be accepted as substantial evidence because this
evidence at the best can be used as a corroborative piece of
evidence.
22.
For the reasons recorded, we are of the considered opinion that the
prosecution failed to prove all incriminating necessary circumstances by
reliable and clinching evidence which would constitute a complete chain
without any gap, pointing to the guilt of the accused. We are conscious
about the seriousness of the offence but the circumstances howsoever
strong cannot take place of proof and conviction is not permissible on the
basis of suspicion. It is in this context, we may profitably refer the
observations made by the Supreme Court in the case of Surendra Koli
Vs. State of U.P. (2025 LawSuit S.C. 1479), wherein while acquitting
the accused, it was observed that when the proof fails, the only lawful
outcome is to set aside the conviction even in a case of involving horrific
crime.
23.
In light of what has been noted above, the view taken by the Trial
Court for acquitting the accused is plausible view and the findings of the
acquittal being considered after proper appreciation of the evidence and
R/CR.MA/25356/2025
(GJHC240690102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
thus, we do not find any perversity in the findings so as to interfere. Thus,
in our considered opinion, the Trial Court was justified in acquitting the
accused and we are in complete agreement with the findings, ultimate
conclusion and resultant order of acquittal recorded before the Court
below and therefore, we do not find any grounds to grant leave to appeal
as prayed herein. Accordingly, the application as well as the appeal
stands dismissed.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
Rakesh
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review