Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010462422026
+
W.P.(C) 14232/2026 & CM APPL. 66589/2026 and CM APPL.
66590/2026
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashok Kumar Poddar and
Ms. Sneha Poddar, Advs.
versus
SUNIL KUMAR GUPTA
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Saaket Jain, Ms. Shivangi
Anand and Mr. Ankur Singhal, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
25.09.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This writ petition assails order dated 22 April 2026 passed by
the Central Administrative Tribunal1 whereby OA 3667/2025, filed by
the respondent, challenging his transfer from the Corporate Office of
the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd at Delhi to the Gujarat Circle has been
allowed.
2.
The Tribunal has, in passing the said order, placed reliance on
1 “the Tribunal” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
Rule 10(A)(4) of the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (Recognition of
Executive Association) Rules 20142, which reads as under:
“10(A)
Facilities to be extended to the Support
Association: The following facilities will be extended to the
Support Association during the period of recognition:(4)
The concession of immunity from transfer from the
CHQ/Circle/SSA is applicable to the General Secretary,
Assistant General Secretary and Financial Secretary (or
Treasurer) upto the recognition period of the concerned
Association as Support Association, irrespective of the post
held or the cadre to which he/she belongs. The facility
enjoyed once at any level, viz. CHQ/Circle/SSA, will not
be available for the second time at the same level either in
the same Association or in any other Association, in case
the incumbent so joins another Association.”
3.
Solely on the basis that the respondent, having been elected as
the Assistant General Secretary of the BSNL Executive Association3,
the Tribunal has proceeded on the premise that the respondent had an
absolute immunity from transfer during the currency of his
membership of the Association.
4.
On this sole ground, the order transferring the respondent from
Delhi to Gujarat has been set aside.
5.
We may note, here, that the respondent has been serving at
Delhi for almost 25 years before the impugned transfer order was
passed.
6.
Another factor which is required to be noted is that, against the
2 “the Rules” hereinafter
“the Association” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
transfer order, the respondent had earlier approached the Tribunal by
way of OA 2449/2025, which was disposed of, by the Tribunal, with a
direction to the BSNL to decide the representation preferred by the
respondent by a reasoned and speaking order. In compliance with the
said direction, the BSNL passed a speaking order on 15 September
2025, rejecting the respondent’s representation. Para 12 of the said
order read thus:
“12. With regards to his claim the executive has joined the
association w.e.f 22.04.2025 i.e. just before the issuance of the
annual order dated 02.05.2025. The process of transfer and posting
was initiated in the month of March 2025. As per past practice
during 2023 & 2024 the long stayee executives were considered for
transfer to balance the manpower across various circles on PAN
India basis. Following this practice, the process of transfer and
posting was initiated in the month of March 2025 & Sh. Sunil
Kumar Gupta was aware about his transfer being among the long
stayee in BSNL CO. It is obvious that to avoid his transfer he got
elected in the association on 22.04.2025 i.e. just before the issue of
transfer order dated 02.05.2025. In the said order BSNL has issued
annual transfer and posting across PAN India basis.”
7.
Additionally, in the said order, it has been stated that the
respondent’s transfer was one of many routine transfers effected by a
common order in administrative exigencies.
8.
Aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal to set aside the
respondent's transfer, the petitioner has approached this Court by
means of the present writ petition.
9.
We have hard Mr. Ashok Kumar Poddar, learned Counsel for
the petitioner and Mr. Saaket Jain, learned Counsel for the respondent
at length.
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
10.
Mr. Poddar has drawn our attention to “Consolidated
instructions on the facility of immunity from transfer extended to
recognized representative associations and support associations”
issued by the BSNL on 11 September 2020. Para 2.5 thereof reads as
under:
“2.5 The concessions are not guaranteed and cannot be claimed
as a matter of right. They are always subject to administrative
exigencies.”
11.
Thus, submits Mr. Poddar, the immunity from transfer to the
members of the Association was not absolute but was subject to
administrative exigencies. Inasmuch as the transfer of the respondent
to Gujarat was to cater to administrative exigencies, Mr. Poddar
submits that the Tribunal was in error in setting it aside. He draws
attention to the fact that there is no reference, in the impugned order of
the Tribunal, to para 2.5 of the instructions dated 11 September 2020.
12.
Mr. Poddar has, fairly, also drawn our attention to a subsequent
Circular dated 24 December 2020 issued by the BSNL, clarifying the
afore-extracted para 2.5. The concluding paragraph of the said
Circular dated 24 December 2020 reads thus:
“It is further clarified that the said provision contemplates a
situation which may arise, when Management may not be in a
position to extend the facility to any office bearer due to
administrative exigencies. However, the decision of not extending
the immunity to any eligible office bearer should be resorted to
only in an exceptional situation and after placing such proposals
with full justification for prior information to CGM concerned in
Circles and Director (HR) in Corporate office.”
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
13.
To a query from the Court as to the authority for issuing such
instructions in the face of Rule 10(A)(4) of the Rules, Mr. Poddar has
placed reliance on Rule 16 of the Rules which reads as under:
“16. Relaxation: The BSNL management may dispense with or
relax the requirements of any of these rules, in consultation with
the recognised representative association, to such extent and
subject to such conditions as it may deem fit in regard to any
Service Association.”
14.
In exercise of the powers conferred by Rule 16, it is Mr.
Poddar’s submission that the BSNL was empowered to relax the
rigour of any of the rules. The subjection of the immunity from
transfer,
following
membership
of
the
Association,
to
the
consideration of administrative exigencies, he submits, amounts to a
relaxation of the rigour of Rule 10(A)(4) and is, therefore, traceable to
Rule 16 of the Rules.
15.
Mr. Jain disputes the submission of Mr. Poddar that the
administrative instructions have been issued in exercise of the powers
conferred by Rule 16 of the Rules. He further submits that even if the
transfer is to be justified as being in administrative exigencies, it has
to be after prior intimation to the CGM concerned and Director (HR)
with the Corporate Office.
16.
We are prima facie not in agreement with the Tribunal that
there is an absolute immunity to the General Secretary, Assistant
General Secretary and Financial Secretary of the Association from
transfer, following their election to the said offices. The immunity is
subject to administrative exigencies.
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
17.
The Tribunal has not adverted to Rule 16 or to the instructions
dated 11 September 2020, particularly to Clause 2.5 thereof.
18.
There is also no finding, by the Tribunal that the plea of
administrative exigencies raised by the BSNL was insubstantial or
unjustified.
19.
Accordingly, we, therefore, put it to Mr. Saaket Jain, learned
Counsel for the respondent, as to whether his client was agreeable to
setting aside the impugned order passed by the Tribunal and a remand
of the matter to the Tribunal for consideration de novo, keeping in
mind these factors and other relevant factors to which the Tribunal’s
may be drawn.
20.
On instructions from his client, who is present in Court, Mr.
Jain is agreeable to the said suggestion.
21.
Accordingly, with consent of learned Counsel the impugned
order dated 22 April 2026 passed by the Tribunal in OA 3667/2025 is
quashed and set aside.
22.
OA 3667/2025 is remanded to the Tribunal for consideration de
novo keeping in mind all the aforesaid facts as noted by us or any
other factors to which learned Counsel may draw the attention of the
Tribunal.
23.
We may it clear that, apart from our finding that Rule 10(A)(4)
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
does not operate as an absolute immunity from transfer but is subject
to administrative exigencies, none of the findings contained in the
order passed today would influence the decision of the Tribunal when
it deals with the merit of the matters.
24.
To that extent, all questions of fact and law are left open to be
urged before the Tribunal.
25.
As this is a transfer matter, it is of some urgency. Accordingly,
we direct learned Counsel for the parties to appear before the
concerned Bench of the Tribunal on 6 October 2026.
26.
We request the Tribunal to take up the matter for hearing on the
said date. Neither side would be entitled to seek any adjournment. In
order to facilitate hearing, both sides are directed to place on record,
before the Tribunal, at least 48 hours in advance of the date fixed by
us, written submissions not exceeding 4 pages each along with duly
indexed compilations of any judicial authorities on which they may
seek to place reliance, after exchanging copies with each other, on the
record of the Tribunal.
27.
Needless to say, should either side be aggrieved by the decision
of the Tribunal, the remedies in law as available would remain
reserved.
28.
This writ petition is allowed to the aforesaid extent, with no
orders as to costs.
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
29.
Dasti to parties or their learned Counsel.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
SEPTEMBER 25, 2026/dsn
W.P.(C) 14232/2026
KUMAR
17:39:59
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review